The manager who kept the sugababes name from MKS for years after has a lot to answer for. I think they were all victims but I struggle with how Keisha was treated. This line up just felt soulless, the magic was gone.
@@iKETOURAGE I watching it and thinking how did people legitimately watch this at the time and not laugh. Never liked Amelle, always thought she was a bit shifty and this just confirms it now
I bet Amelle would do anything she could to reunite with this lineup, the thing is Heidi loves being a mom and wife and it seem to me Jade wants to forget this chapter in her life, so... I can't see that ever happening.
I strongly doubt it. They didn't survive with the name Sugababes despite making so much noise and getting publicity due to the last replacement, let alone with a new unknown name. Nevertheless they should have changed the name (and sung new songs exclusively) regardless just to avoid ruining the group's legacy and essence.
@@xxxTIN0xxx I do wonder had Heidi and Amelle had started a new band with Jade with a new name if they'd have more of a chance, as I feel like by this point they were just tarred with the line up changes.
This line up was doomed to fail, Amelle seemed dark she wanted to be the one without the voice, u can see Jade was brought in as the powerhse, glad originals bk to2getha! Love Keisha!
Part of me wished, that when Keisha left that Heidi, Amelle and Jade decided to form a new version of Sugababes, use a new name and reform themselves for a new sound..... I did like this line up, but they were not as superior to the original. It was doomed from here in.
From this it seems Amelle was likely the ringleader in looking to call a quits, no idea how Heidi thought she could make it with her. Heidi was just in the right place at the right time. I think equal success could have been achieved if it was Liz McLarnon singing with Keisha and Mutya. They changed their music style and moved labels when Heidi came on board, so success wasn’t dependent on her. These 3 have zero charisma or chemistry….MKS / 2023 Sugababes are much stronger vocally and actually have that ‘edge’ this lineup lacked. Keisha recently has said she would never perform any songs from this lineups ‘Sweet 7’ album as she doesn’t connect with any of the songs.
i could never quite place heidi with the other two originals and didn't really warm up to amelle (though i loved the group through all the lineups), but i think jade was always quite talented, pretty and versatile (minus the times when she sang too loudly instead of harmonizing with the others). i think she was perfect for this group, but it's just sad she was there to "replace" keisha which i think is my favorite sugababe out of the 6 (with jade a close second). i just think jade got too much hate when she's done nothing wrong. she took an opportunity and gave it a great contribution. i would like to see all 6 form a supergroup. or at least a jade+keisha collaboration
Jade always belonged solo in my eyes, she should have continued finishing her album after “My Man” was released. Who knows what hits it could have produced? ”My Man” was praised by critics. The critics weren’t kind to Sugababes 4.0
Wish everyone would stop hating this line up. It’s not these girls fault other members 2 of the original members left. Heidi is as much as sugababe as Keisha
I even cringe at the thumbnail - the moment Keisha was ousted the legitimacy of Heidi being a true Sugababe diminished, and Amelle and Jade were never real Sugababes.
I don't get why sugababes have changed so many times as in the girls in the band they have changed like mutya and Keisha am I thinking of someone else or is it the same group?
Crown Management and their record label - the joining of Heidi was reasonable and she was a good replacement for Siobhan. Heidi and Keisha should have stayed a duo until Mutya had recovered of her depression.
Take over?!? What substance are u taking it? Siobhan left by itself at the early stage, Mutya also. And Keisha always looked a bit problematic and self-centred! Mann this is showbiz you need to take sacrifice for staying on the job not crying when things become tough . I have a slightly feeling that again new comeback will not remain for a long time. They're simply not serious enough
@lastavica1396 MKS now The Sugababes having reclaim the name they gave themselves have been together for more than 10 years even though they haven't done a lot of recording until recently. Which shows their commitment towards each other. They get to tour which they obviously enjoy as they've done this all over the country and in other countries. Even with the stuff about Keisha's suppose attitude, there was no issues of her getting into fights in clubs with other people which there was with Amelle so she isn't the innocent unproblematic person she is making herself out to be. Regardless of Siobhan only being there for one album, she was there for the very start of the creation of the group and did solid work in building the group in achieving getting a record deal at such a young age with Muyta and Keisha which if it didn't happen would have meant Heidi wouldn't have had a group to join despite what she brought to the group.
Who are these girls? To be honest - they were like puppets from their label. I think they all felt it that's not thing they want and music they released is so plastic and not surprised why original members left group.
Duplicated and imitated but never ever an Original I never liked this lineup the sugababes achievements are not theirs to be introduced with it , the original Sugababes got the last word as they deserve
Thank God Mutya, Keisha and Siobhan are back!
It would have been nice if Heidi, Amelle and Jade were there too so all 6 would have reunited and the Sugababes were now a group of 6.
The most boring and dull line up. Heidi should be there
@@zkou-oc9sm Heidi is there !
@@zkou-oc9sm that's if u were referring to the video !
@@cleodickens7184I was calling the mks line up boring 😴
Love the sugababes.. All versions
The manager who kept the sugababes name from MKS for years after has a lot to answer for. I think they were all victims but I struggle with how Keisha was treated. This line up just felt soulless, the magic was gone.
Watching this back is wild. That they legitimately thought they had a chance of surviving.
Right,dead serious too.
@@iKETOURAGE I watching it and thinking how did people legitimately watch this at the time and not laugh. Never liked Amelle, always thought she was a bit shifty and this just confirms it now
So what if they did, they are nice girls, clearly you wanted them to fail . Happy now??
@@AndreyaWryght very
@@noeldaniel 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Honestly...ive loved every version of the Sugababes. =)
"They've sold over 7 million albums" lol no they didn't. Mutya and Keisha did.
And Heidi
Lol actually they took off once Heidi joined.. check the charts
I bet Amelle would do anything she could to reunite with this lineup, the thing is Heidi loves being a mom and wife and it seem to me Jade wants to forget this chapter in her life, so... I can't see that ever happening.
lol sucks to suck
Mum.
i think they would have survived if they changed their band name.
hmmmmmm, i doubt that..
I strongly doubt it. They didn't survive with the name Sugababes despite making so much noise and getting publicity due to the last replacement, let alone with a new unknown name. Nevertheless they should have changed the name (and sung new songs exclusively) regardless just to avoid ruining the group's legacy and essence.
@@xxxTIN0xxx I do wonder had Heidi and Amelle had started a new band with Jade with a new name if they'd have more of a chance, as I feel like by this point they were just tarred with the line up changes.
These three have absolutely nothing to do with the original band. Safe to say they’ve all been ousted with the real sugababes back in control
Heidi is just as good as an OG member. She's worked her ass off in that group. Put some respect on her name
Heidi basically was in all the sugababes song. Also amelle is in the best selling sugababes song ever. There biggest hit.
4:00 the story with the manager shouting through the letterbox at 5am should have been a huge red flag
LOL. "Get the fuck out of bed, we need another Sugababes lineup."
This line up was doomed to fail, Amelle seemed dark she wanted to be the one without the voice, u can see Jade was brought in as the powerhse, glad originals bk to2getha! Love Keisha!
Amelle should have left
Why?
I'm glad she didn't because now the originals are back together.
Part of me wished, that when Keisha left that Heidi, Amelle and Jade decided to form a new version of Sugababes, use a new name and reform themselves for a new sound..... I did like this line up, but they were not as superior to the original. It was doomed from here in.
Jade knows. You can see it in her eyes.
Sugababes tribute band not the OG real sugababes
From this it seems Amelle was likely the ringleader in looking to call a quits, no idea how Heidi thought she could make it with her. Heidi was just in the right place at the right time. I think equal success could have been achieved if it was Liz McLarnon singing with Keisha and Mutya. They changed their music style and moved labels when Heidi came on board, so success wasn’t dependent on her.
These 3 have zero charisma or chemistry….MKS / 2023 Sugababes are much stronger vocally and actually have that ‘edge’ this lineup lacked.
Keisha recently has said she would never perform any songs from this lineups ‘Sweet 7’ album as she doesn’t connect with any of the songs.
They have no chemistry at all, like 3 strangers trying to work together closely, the girl Jade seems so unhappy
Snakes.
Totally agree 💯
The SugaSnakes
YES and LIARS
@@TheRedgoldenchild Sugafakes.
These are not the sugababes ! Completely different sound to the originals 😢 sorry gals . Get your own name .
every lineup had great songs. I loved all 4 lineups. I'm glad the original lineup is back but it does seem kinda unfair to this final lineup.
What do u think was unfair???
Do u have ur Tickets???
i could never quite place heidi with the other two originals and didn't really warm up to amelle (though i loved the group through all the lineups), but i think jade was always quite talented, pretty and versatile (minus the times when she sang too loudly instead of harmonizing with the others). i think she was perfect for this group, but it's just sad she was there to "replace" keisha which i think is my favorite sugababe out of the 6 (with jade a close second). i just think jade got too much hate when she's done nothing wrong. she took an opportunity and gave it a great contribution. i would like to see all 6 form a supergroup. or at least a jade+keisha collaboration
Jade always belonged solo in my eyes, she should have continued finishing her album after “My Man” was released. Who knows what hits it could have produced? ”My Man” was praised by critics. The critics weren’t kind to Sugababes 4.0
@@nameisamine i know. i still listen to my man, it's sad we didn't get an album
sugababes are so amazing
Wish everyone would stop hating this line up. It’s not these girls fault other members 2 of the original members left. Heidi is as much as sugababe as Keisha
@Daniel S I never said she was original, but she stayed in the group longer than the rest of them
@@TVStudio4 But the 3 OG's came up with the name together when they were teens, the rest of them were products of a label.
Keisha didn't leave she was kicked out.
I even cringe at the thumbnail - the moment Keisha was ousted the legitimacy of Heidi being a true Sugababe diminished, and Amelle and Jade were never real Sugababes.
I don't know them
@@michaelvasek3974 They don't even go here.
@@K_F_P i don't like this replacement of Sugababes
@@michaelvasek3974 Canderelbabes.
Agreed.
I don't get why sugababes have changed so many times as in the girls in the band they have changed like mutya and Keisha am I thinking of someone else or is it the same group?
Crown Management and their record label - the joining of Heidi was reasonable and she was a good replacement for Siobhan. Heidi and Keisha should have stayed a duo until Mutya had recovered of her depression.
I'm glad to say that none of these three are the Sugababes anymore. Mutya, Keisha and Siobhan are back with new material on the way 👌
@@MrDfix1988 Unfortunately labels aren't like that.
Love these three, the sugababes name has so much negativity to it so they should have started fresh with a new name.
Pior fase .. meu Deus ..
If amelle left it would have been more iconic, she should have just gone solo!!
She is the only sugababes member to have e a UK number 1. Hardly a fail. She didn't even release a album.
Hoping this lineup would reunite
What name? 😂
@@eleeveeayees3425 J.H.A.
@@eleeveeayees3425 The Undignifieds
Heidi, Amelle and Jade.
yes they done well 🤣😂🤣
Heidi I love you so much!
these girls really had not shame in talking shit about a fellow colleage, at least if not a friend
I love Heidi !!!!!!!!!! ;-)
Not the sugababes you can feel how fake it feels !
Lord, this lineup (Heidi excepted) makes me cringe.
amelle is so attractive.
Who? 💀
who the f is this, this lot never sold 7mil albums
How cheeky they thought they had the band to take over etc 😂😂😂😂😂😂👀👀👀
Take over?!? What substance are u taking it? Siobhan left by itself at the early stage, Mutya also. And Keisha always looked a bit problematic and self-centred! Mann this is showbiz you need to take sacrifice for staying on the job not crying when things become tough . I have a slightly feeling that again new comeback will not remain for a long time. They're simply not serious enough
@lastavica1396 MKS now The Sugababes having reclaim the name they gave themselves have been together for more than 10 years even though they haven't done a lot of recording until recently. Which shows their commitment towards each other.
They get to tour which they obviously enjoy as they've done this all over the country and in other countries.
Even with the stuff about Keisha's suppose attitude, there was no issues of her getting into fights in clubs with other people which there was with Amelle so she isn't the innocent unproblematic person she is making herself out to be.
Regardless of Siobhan only being there for one album, she was there for the very start of the creation of the group and did solid work in building the group in achieving getting a record deal at such a young age with Muyta and Keisha which if it didn't happen would have meant Heidi wouldn't have had a group to join despite what she brought to the group.
Who are these girls? To be honest - they were like puppets from their label. I think they all felt it that's not thing they want and music they released is so plastic and not surprised why original members left group.
Duplicated and imitated but never ever an Original I never liked this lineup the sugababes achievements are not theirs to be introduced with it , the original Sugababes got the last word as they deserve
Love this version of sugababes
Same
Oh? This is Sugababes?
who is the lead singer now?