I'm an American revert. The last shred of following morality has been lost now. I'm speaking about the Gaza war. No matter what country you live in, I think some values will overlap with Islam, even if only by accident. But it's all gone now in my opinion. I'm in my late 70s and have seen a lot of change here. Freedom, justice, and the American way are just total bunk. If I were young, I would leave. My hope for America started to crack when Guantanamo was created, but it's in shambles now. I could put up with the sexual immorality because I hoped people would get tired of it and see it's emptiness and search for something else - Islam. But, this Gaza war is the ultimate betrayal of the values we used to idealize. We are no different than the China America used to complain about. Disgusting.
May Allah help you settle in a country suitable for you and your family's Islamic as well as worldly needs. I'm trying to move to a better country myself for a more sharia compliant lifestyle, even if all it offers is just a bit stricter of a law on promiscuity and indecent exposures.
@@realitybeckons4120 Some few of their values are the same as God's commands. And they are encoded in international law. They should at least abide by those. There is no excuse.
@@HitherandYarn It breaks me to know that the majority of Christians support the tragedy that's taking place. Of all people, I thought of them as brethren. I thought they were closest In love and affection. Breaks your heart. I'm so fearful for my children and their future. May Allah swt bless you and keep you safe
After looking at Syria, Tunisia, Libya my eyes have opened. Sheikh's answer is right. Rulers are only a reflection of the society. Unless and until majority of the Muslims learn and follow Islam the correct way (the way of Prophet S. A. W and Sahaba) by avoiding shirk and bidah, it's hard that we'll go back to glory. Muslims need to learn Islam and the etiquettes of justice before dreaming about glory. May Allah forgive our sins and shortcomings and grant us understanding of His deen. Ameen
Spot on, at the end of the day, a ruler may open as many bars and night clubs as they want, however, as long as the populous remain steadfast on their religion then no one will visit these evil venues
I don't understand the itching urge some get go label others as disbelievers or judge them, a soul is not accountable for what another did, we should look at ourselves and our actions first and foremost
@@dontBeAParrot that's not how it always works, surely the level of faith is only decreasing as we heading towards the last hour. and surely you didnt read Quran nor have even basic knowledge of it and thus you think it is alright when a ruler goes against Quran and sunnah and find it okay to corrupt others. next are you gonna say, it is okay that since now a bar is opened, some Muslims can go and start drinking alcohol right? I mean just admit we are coward that we fear the rulers because of their punishment more than we have fear of Allah. May Allah help us and definitely you are not helping others in your misguding thoughts
if ur father is a smoker, do u address him in a huge family gathering and tell him to fear Allah etc? if u say yes then u need to learn about the etqiutes to forbiding evil, follow the scholars not your own logic@@freaky425
@@freaky425 friend, did Allah mention a person's iman will decrease due to the deeds of his ruler? Are we not all under the protection of Allah? The youth of the cave lived under a pagan king, yet their faith in Allah was so strong that they exclude themselves from society entirely to seek Allah's pleasure. They did not start protests or start wars. They sought after Allah's mercy. And Allah rewarded them and chose them as a sign for all humanity. @dontBeAParrot is closer to the Quran than the venom that comes out of your mouth.
This was a great question. I’ve been wondering the same and we all know which country he’s referring to. May Allah SWT keep us all firm on our deen. Ameen
If the ruler is stopping you from salah, then you gotta migrate to the place where you can preform salah. Or you can protest and go to jail if you like that. See the practical options. I doubt any Muslim nation has rules forbidding Muslims to practice religion. The mistake these rulers are doing is allowing bad things.
@@Soldier-Of-Mahdi But all muslim countries allow you to follow the basics of Islam. It's just that they also permit haram for kafirs to enjoy which is not a halal reason to retaliate, we just make dua and InshaAllah it will be answered either now or in the hereafter.
And now people will bring up their own interpretations of Hadiths and cry about Sheikh being this and that May Allah swt bless our ummah with critical thinking and to make decisions with sound judgement and to act with plans that are not just to carry out certain things but to have plans that are long and far sighted. Ameen
May Allah bless you and your family. May Allah accept all your good deeds. May Allah protect you and your family from all kind of evils and calamities. May Allah grant you Janattul Firdowes. JazakumAllahu Khayran
Ya sheikh hope this our ummah understood the way of prophet's (mpuh) and companions struggle. He was away from mecca for nine years. Made our religion strong gave education strengthened the army and took back mecca.
he r.a succeded, u think we will succed with Mo's (shortening their name from muhammad) trying to figure out his gender and probably doesnt know the meanign shahadah?
He is talking about Saudi, and the Sheikh is right because the Ummah is not united.......so yeah just shut up and continue praying and ask Allah for help.....
@@shadowstorm5261 is asking question also wrong now? And side note no salafi i met in real life dared to bring the matter of khurooj Before me cause they knew they wont be able to answer.
you dont even question the sheikh ? are you his slave ? he is human he can have his opinions and they can be wrong, he didnt say the Quran and sunnah says not to do this or that, he didnt bring up any surah or ayah, dont listen to 100% of what he says, who do you expect to free Palestine if you're that docile ? if you cant even protest you own country and help maintain islamic values and stop puppet leaders selling it and westernizing it, such a shame, your kind wont get stronger or braver by the way they'll keep being cowards till the day of judgment, you're waiting for prophet aisa a.s to lead you ? or you'll die before and still a coward ? if they opened up Palestine for muslims to go fight will you sit back ? show me you care, instead you ask the guy " what do you suggest " as if you're disagreeing with him and blindly following your masters the sheikhs who tell you stay still, while they sell fatwas and support the crown prick who westernizing Saudi and party in yachts and assassinates his oppositions and jails good sheikhs and his relatives. @@maazmustafa2322
Asalaam alaikum A large group of the ummah will not agree with Sheikh on this opinion. But what is the other option? Our ummah doesn’t unite and without a well thought out plan just go forth and protest. Look at Syria, Libya and Yemen and how our ummah has been displaced. Were they better off under dictatorship or are they better off right now? Weren’t the rebels in favor of toppling the dictatorships? Most definitely dictatorships aren’t great but it also stems down to the corruption among the govt employees, general public like yourself and me don’t engage with the leaders but with the govt officials. These so called rebels have achieved what other than bloodshed of innocent Muslims, disillusion of the youth into going and highlighting our deen in the wrong manner.
@@ibnadam5789 Do u have evidence that this thing is justified? Evem Imam Ahmad never protested against Al MUtazili khalifa like Al Mamun and Mutasim Billah. there are a lot of hadeeths condemning such acts. Go to Syria , Yemen , Libya, what do u think ? theses are protests that turned them like this. Have faith IN Allah , fear Allah , have tawakkul, Read how the salfs have dealt in such situations , do not follow desires , we completely submit to Allahs command. Did MBS stopped muslims from praying? he allowed everything except for some additionals haramas he added. May Allah help us in these situations and guide Muluks of our times. do not speak of desires and rational thinking , for we aint even ulama to begin with. even they are very concise with what they say
@@Trollfacevidz what ahle madina did after karbala ???ok leave now tell me where this came that u cant even crticize ruler in public ...no need to explain bcx i know where frm this all comes ...before labelling me as rafidi or kharijjjji ..let me clarify ..im not😊
Assalamualaikum. Recently, I feel a bit of wet drop on my private part and plants ( very small drop) during a certain time, everyday around 4 pm. I don't know what is it. as I am a 17 year old Muslim virgin.( man) I can't really distinguish the difference between Mathi and Mani. but I know some key difference, the drop I get is transparent and I have no feeling while it comes out. this may mean it's Mathi. What it might be? and do I need to wash that part of my clothes which has this liquid and do wudu again?( As its very small drop, and i don't know why it is happening to me during this certain time everyday)
Assalamu Alaikum, The hadith on Nasai 4209 is: It was narrated from Tariq bin Shihab that: a man asked the Prophet, when he had put his leg in the stirrup: "Which kind of Jihad is best?'" He said: " a word of truth spoken before an unjust rulers." The hadith doesn’t mention speaking the truth in front of the public & provoking them. The salaf's way of doing it is to speak the truth in private. And to me this is the best approach. Because by nature if you do an evil act & someone gives dawa/ advice infront of people, most probably you'll not listen to that. But if anyone gives you dawa privately, most probably you're gonna take heed. If anyone doesn’t change after giving dawah privately with love, I don’t think he's gonna change if you say it in front of the public. Allahu a'lam. Just shared my layman thoughts.
@@hey.maaahir So many people misinterpret this hadith. I get it their emotional and their blood is boiling, perhaps that's why they can't think rationally when it comes to basic comprehension. The hadith is clear, speak a word in front of an unjust ruler. This means say it in his presence. Then there are other hadith to speak to him in private. Any1 interested in following the sunnah should understand this. But logic goes out the window when emotions come in
he is changing, for fear of people thinking he's bad, thats why protests work, as we see now people around the world take Palestine's side because the public had enough, you're not a scholar, now we follow salafs way, we follow the sunnah of our beloved prophet pbuh, you're not qualified to explain what a hadith means and give your opinions about it, our prophet pbuh says in this hadith " a word of truth spoken before an unjust rulers ", so what we go privately to our rulers in his palace made from our taxes and country's wealth and have a speech with thrm like kids ?? is this what your interpretation is ?? its " before an unjust ruler " not behind or privately, but before him, meaning infront of him, and we're all people who dont like him cause he's unjust, and we cant go privately to him, so whats the next best thing ? let him know, by going on a free space and SPEAKING to him through cameras and media who'll film it, this is only based on the hadith you quoted in English as in Arabic it may sound different, and what is said at least makes better sense than what you interpreted, and im not interpreting it im just debunking what you said it might means.@@hey.maaahir
@@FlareVolt0Asalaam alaikum Brother you need to relax. This sort of emotional argument is what tumbles any sense of discussion. What do you think got the people to protest? It was widespread media showcasing of the plight of our brothers and sisters in Gaza which got people to come out and ask their leaders to ask for a ceasefire. To your point of refuting/debunking what the other brothers said, and who/what gives you the right to refute and debunk or interpret what RasoolAllah saw said in the Hadith? Our brothers and sisters in Gaza and West Bank couldn’t be united and could not form a govt, couldn’t be united among themselves, there was no proper representation from their side just factions that wanted to drive the idea in their favor, PLO wants something, h@m@$ wants something else and Allah swt forbid whatever our leaders in Saudi and the Arab world are doing behind the scenes. There are so many factors, so many issues. We Muslim ummah aren’t united in our own backyard and want to help our ummah in lands outside of ours and are united only in distress. What a joke of a ummah we have become and emotional fools like yourself don’t help the cause either because whenever there is one front trying or even attempting people like you behave like frogs in a well, stir the pot and absolute destroy any ideology.
@@FlareVolt0bro you didn't debunk a thing lol. Don't try to be smart here and go against the hadith thinking you're doing something beneficial. If you can't reach the rulers then don't bother. It's not upto you to give advice to authorities anyways. You lack the wisdom clearly when you're using such a logic of going against the hadith, surely you won't have the wisdom on how to advise him. Saying in public will do nothing, ur words won't even reach him. Plus if they do he already knows religious muslims are against his policies, against his changes and the fate of them, we're all aware what it is... Leave it to knowledgeable people to advise and perhaps they do. They don't have to mention about their discussions to the public. See musnad ahmad 21784
Then what happened with Hassan ra? Or both of the sides actually. Do you wanna repeat the cycle? Why didn't the prophet Muhammad saw fought against the meccans when they almost beat Abu Bakr ra to death, or when they tortured sumaya ra. Or countless other examples. We need to have Sabr. Islam will prevail we know. But hastiness is never good. And Allah SWT knows the best.
@@heaven.3031with all do respect this is stupid. no doubt Hussain RA will be granted the highest level in jannah for his sacrifice. what we should just not do or say anything and leave everything to allah? no that’s dumb. first we need to show allah that we are atleast trying On the authority of Abu Sa`eed al-Khudree (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say, “Whosoever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart - and that is the weakest of faith.” [Muslim] (hadith 34, 40 hadith an nawawi)
@@ibrahim_-_-_ the hadith you narrated literally favours my point. And no one said anything about the reward of family of our beloved prophet saw or any companion for that matter. What you gonna do? Jihad? Protest? Yeah they definitely work don't they. This is clearly not the time to act. Impulsiveness is not a quality of a good Muslim rather patience is. Make your family follow Deen properly, let them marry righteous individuals, instead of just following the material possessions. Which, everyone is guilty of, whether they accept it or not. Only if we do that, can there be Baraka in their marriages and the birth of righteous people. Making the nation right again. We love to call others munafiq and such directly or indirectly. Without looking at what's happening in our households or surroundings. I ask you how many times have you knocked on your neighbours at night time just to ask them if they're fine, it's even gonna sound bizarre to us. Nations gets destroyed just as much from down to up than it gets from up to down. May Allah SWT grant us deeper understanding and increase our imaan, Ameen.
Maybe when all the mosques in the world are full for fajar salah outside Ramadan on a regular basis then inshallah we will be strong enough to defeat these enemies but now unfortunately it’s all talk and no action
@@Ibnsvn how can i go Against the words of allah(quran) and his rasulullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam (sahih Hadith)?[nowhere did i make that remark] And did u Just say that the Ottomans were kafirs? Can u take responsibility for that during the day of Hashr?
Although right about the Arab Spring he is totally wrong on this issue today and shouldn’t be asked about politics in future. He is correct that you can’t impose religion but when the sun was on their side of the hedge many scholars were happy to provide a veneer of religiosity to despicable rulers who misused religious edicts to justify their tyranny and false claims of royalty. The Sheikh with no disrespect intended should stick to what he knows religion etc. and leave the rest to the practical people of the world. Though it may appear that another scholar had sold out or shown his true colours in difficult circumstances it may not be like that. Like all humans they simply appreciate the patronage of their hosts and the good life. Like us all they will be judged by what they could do at the time. People may say history will judge them but ultimately it’s Allah’s judgement that counts and we should look to ourselves first in all such cases. If you want wholesome changes in the world don’t look to rulers or scholars work with practical people of all faith or none to get things done. Historically it what people have always done especially when our societies were flourishing and at their most powerful.
Do not listen to what you hear from Daniel H, Mohammed Hijab or Ali Dawah. Sahih Muslim 1847b The scholars advise the rulers In private and yet us laymen want to rebel.
@@rehanriaz620 since you don’t know anything and should not judge, it seems YOU are behaving like a kuffar. What business is it of yours? Shameful comment.
I'm an American revert. The last shred of following morality has been lost now. I'm speaking about the Gaza war. No matter what country you live in, I think some values will overlap with Islam, even if only by accident. But it's all gone now in my opinion. I'm in my late 70s and have seen a lot of change here. Freedom, justice, and the American way are just total bunk. If I were young, I would leave. My hope for America started to crack when Guantanamo was created, but it's in shambles now. I could put up with the sexual immorality because I hoped people would get tired of it and see it's emptiness and search for something else - Islam. But, this Gaza war is the ultimate betrayal of the values we used to idealize. We are no different than the China America used to complain about. Disgusting.
May Allah help you settle in a country suitable for you and your family's Islamic as well as worldly needs. I'm trying to move to a better country myself for a more sharia compliant lifestyle, even if all it offers is just a bit stricter of a law on promiscuity and indecent exposures.
Thats a very nice comment / confession. I appreciate it
People have strayed away from God's commands . How can you expect people to abide by man-made laws and regulations? They never work
@@realitybeckons4120 Some few of their values are the same as God's commands. And they are encoded in international law. They should at least abide by those. There is no excuse.
@@HitherandYarn It breaks me to know that the majority of Christians support the tragedy that's taking place. Of all people, I thought of them as brethren. I thought they were closest In love and affection. Breaks your heart. I'm so fearful for my children and their future.
May Allah swt bless you and keep you safe
After looking at Syria, Tunisia, Libya my eyes have opened. Sheikh's answer is right. Rulers are only a reflection of the society. Unless and until majority of the Muslims learn and follow Islam the correct way (the way of Prophet S. A. W and Sahaba) by avoiding shirk and bidah, it's hard that we'll go back to glory. Muslims need to learn Islam and the etiquettes of justice before dreaming about glory. May Allah forgive our sins and shortcomings and grant us understanding of His deen. Ameen
Spot on, at the end of the day, a ruler may open as many bars and night clubs as they want, however, as long as the populous remain steadfast on their religion then no one will visit these evil venues
I don't understand the itching urge some get go label others as disbelievers or judge them, a soul is not accountable for what another did, we should look at ourselves and our actions first and foremost
@@dontBeAParrot that's not how it always works, surely the level of faith is only decreasing as we heading towards the last hour. and surely you didnt read Quran nor have even basic knowledge of it and thus you think it is alright when a ruler goes against Quran and sunnah and find it okay to corrupt others. next are you gonna say, it is okay that since now a bar is opened, some Muslims can go and start drinking alcohol right? I mean just admit we are coward that we fear the rulers because of their punishment more than we have fear of Allah. May Allah help us and definitely you are not helping others in your misguding thoughts
if ur father is a smoker, do u address him in a huge family gathering and tell him to fear Allah etc? if u say yes then u need to learn about the etqiutes to forbiding evil, follow the scholars not your own logic@@freaky425
@@freaky425 friend, did Allah mention a person's iman will decrease due to the deeds of his ruler? Are we not all under the protection of Allah? The youth of the cave lived under a pagan king, yet their faith in Allah was so strong that they exclude themselves from society entirely to seek Allah's pleasure. They did not start protests or start wars. They sought after Allah's mercy. And Allah rewarded them and chose them as a sign for all humanity. @dontBeAParrot is closer to the Quran than the venom that comes out of your mouth.
This was a great question. I’ve been wondering the same and we all know which country he’s referring to. May Allah SWT keep us all firm on our deen. Ameen
What country might this be?
@@HaramainExperience It's where the place in your profile picture is located (as of 27/3/24).
@@theavglifter alright akhi jazakallah khair
If your blood boils, put it in the fridge.
--Sheikh Assim, Ramadan 2024
@Soldier-Of-Mahdi Nice. In the end times seek refuge. Stay home and hold your tongue until death comes to you. - I feel this way
@@westlisbon6307 no, shiekh was sarcastic(we all know)
We can retaliate if the ruler is not allowing to follow even basics of islam.
Islam allows it.
If the ruler is stopping you from salah, then you gotta migrate to the place where you can preform salah.
Or you can protest and go to jail if you like that.
See the practical options. I doubt any Muslim nation has rules forbidding Muslims to practice religion. The mistake these rulers are doing is allowing bad things.
@@Soldier-Of-Mahdi But all muslim countries allow you to follow the basics of Islam. It's just that they also permit haram for kafirs to enjoy which is not a halal reason to retaliate, we just make dua and InshaAllah it will be answered either now or in the hereafter.
And now people will bring up their own interpretations of Hadiths and cry about Sheikh being this and that
May Allah swt bless our ummah with critical thinking and to make decisions with sound judgement and to act with plans that are not just to carry out certain things but to have plans that are long and far sighted. Ameen
May Allah bless you and your family. May Allah accept all your good deeds. May Allah protect you and your family from all kind of evils and calamities. May Allah grant you Janattul Firdowes. JazakumAllahu Khayran
Ameen
This is the only way forward. May Allah protect us and increase our patience until the promised day.
SubhanAllah.
Thank You Ya shaikh, the ummah stands united in cowardice and laziness.
Ya sheikh hope this our ummah understood the way of prophet's (mpuh) and companions struggle. He was away from mecca for nine years. Made our religion strong gave education strengthened the army and took back mecca.
Respected Sheikh ! Why then did Imam Muhammad bin Abdul Wahab fight all of the neighbouring tribes and conquer what’s now known as KSA ?
he r.a succeded, u think we will succed with Mo's (shortening their name from muhammad) trying to figure out his gender and probably doesnt know the meanign shahadah?
they weren't rulers. they were tribes
@@shadowstorm5261 so does make their blood Halal ?
What if anybody doesn’t recognise the legitimacy of a ruler ?
Ofcourse he will say don't protest and that kind of stuff. He lives in saudi arabia and we know all to well the evil things they do there.
What about the good things? People are eager to mention bad things
He is talking about Saudi, and the Sheikh is right because the Ummah is not united.......so yeah just shut up and continue praying and ask Allah for help.....
Just one question then why did the arabs rebelled Against the Ottomans then in 1914. if its haram?
@@katwithanC why are you asking some guy on UA-cam for your answer? go ask them instead
@@shadowstorm5261 is asking question also wrong now?
And side note no salafi i met in real life dared to bring the matter of khurooj Before me cause they knew they wont be able to answer.
I don't feel I'm convinced by his answer. May Allah forgive us all.
What do you suggest is correct?
you dont even question the sheikh ? are you his slave ? he is human he can have his opinions and they can be wrong, he didnt say the Quran and sunnah says not to do this or that, he didnt bring up any surah or ayah, dont listen to 100% of what he says, who do you expect to free Palestine if you're that docile ? if you cant even protest you own country and help maintain islamic values and stop puppet leaders selling it and westernizing it, such a shame, your kind wont get stronger or braver by the way they'll keep being cowards till the day of judgment, you're waiting for prophet aisa a.s to lead you ? or you'll die before and still a coward ? if they opened up Palestine for muslims to go fight will you sit back ? show me you care, instead you ask the guy " what do you suggest " as if you're disagreeing with him and blindly following your masters the sheikhs who tell you stay still, while they sell fatwas and support the crown prick who westernizing Saudi and party in yachts and assassinates his oppositions and jails good sheikhs and his relatives. @@maazmustafa2322
same here brother, 2 billion+ muslim and we still have to fear, this answer totally contradicts Quran and Sunnah.
Asalaam alaikum
A large group of the ummah will not agree with Sheikh on this opinion. But what is the other option?
Our ummah doesn’t unite and without a well thought out plan just go forth and protest. Look at Syria, Libya and Yemen and how our ummah has been displaced. Were they better off under dictatorship or are they better off right now? Weren’t the rebels in favor of toppling the dictatorships? Most definitely dictatorships aren’t great but it also stems down to the corruption among the govt employees, general public like yourself and me don’t engage with the leaders but with the govt officials. These so called rebels have achieved what other than bloodshed of innocent Muslims, disillusion of the youth into going and highlighting our deen in the wrong manner.
@@ibnadam5789 Do u have evidence that this thing is justified? Evem Imam Ahmad never protested against Al MUtazili khalifa like Al Mamun and Mutasim Billah. there are a lot of hadeeths condemning such acts. Go to Syria , Yemen , Libya, what do u think ? theses are protests that turned them like this. Have faith IN Allah , fear Allah , have tawakkul, Read how the salfs have dealt in such situations , do not follow desires , we completely submit to Allahs command. Did MBS stopped muslims from praying? he allowed everything except for some additionals haramas he added. May Allah help us in these situations and guide Muluks of our times. do not speak of desires and rational thinking , for we aint even ulama to begin with. even they are very concise with what they say
I think the caller is referring to KSA.
Do not publicly condemn? Sure
If ruler is doing wrong ...condemn it in ur mind😂
how do u confront them physically ? whilst u know they will do harm that are greater. Even Imam Ahmad stayed qquiet during mutazili period for decade
@@Trollfacevidz what ahle madina did after karbala ???ok leave now tell me where this came that u cant even crticize ruler in public ...no need to explain bcx i know where frm this all comes ...before labelling me as rafidi or kharijjjji ..let me clarify ..im not😊
@@shiningalpha_ bro i have no intent on calling u such names audhubillah. Enlighten me with what knowledge has come to you which i am missing.
@@shiningalpha_ sahih Muslim 1847b , search and read it my brother. It describes exactly the situation we are in and the question asked :)
Assalamualaikum.
Recently, I feel a bit of wet drop on my private part and plants ( very small drop) during a certain time, everyday around 4 pm. I don't know what is it. as I am a 17 year old Muslim virgin.( man)
I can't really distinguish the difference between Mathi and Mani. but I know some key difference, the drop I get is transparent and I have no feeling while it comes out. this may mean it's Mathi.
What it might be? and do I need to wash that part of my clothes which has this liquid and do wudu again?( As its very small drop, and i don't know why it is happening to me during this certain time everyday)
The sheik has talked about it in a video, check that out and may it help you insha'allah
Did you ever talk to a urologist, and did you ever do ruqyah?
Asalaam alaikum
As mentioned by the previous reply there is a video by sheikh Assim
And it’s been answered on islamq&a
Check the response in Islamqa website run by Sheikh Salih al munajjad
Please explain this Hadith Sunan al-Nasā’ī 4209
Assalamu Alaikum,
The hadith on Nasai 4209 is:
It was narrated from Tariq bin Shihab that:
a man asked the Prophet, when he had put his leg in the stirrup: "Which kind of Jihad is best?'" He said: " a word of truth spoken before an unjust rulers."
The hadith doesn’t mention speaking the truth in front of the public & provoking them.
The salaf's way of doing it is to speak the truth in private.
And to me this is the best approach. Because by nature if you do an evil act & someone gives dawa/ advice infront of people, most probably you'll not listen to that.
But if anyone gives you dawa privately, most probably you're gonna take heed.
If anyone doesn’t change after giving dawah privately with love, I don’t think he's gonna change if you say it in front of the public.
Allahu a'lam.
Just shared my layman thoughts.
@@hey.maaahir So many people misinterpret this hadith. I get it their emotional and their blood is boiling, perhaps that's why they can't think rationally when it comes to basic comprehension. The hadith is clear, speak a word in front of an unjust ruler. This means say it in his presence. Then there are other hadith to speak to him in private. Any1 interested in following the sunnah should understand this. But logic goes out the window when emotions come in
he is changing, for fear of people thinking he's bad, thats why protests work, as we see now people around the world take Palestine's side because the public had enough, you're not a scholar, now we follow salafs way, we follow the sunnah of our beloved prophet pbuh, you're not qualified to explain what a hadith means and give your opinions about it, our prophet pbuh says in this hadith " a word of truth spoken before an unjust rulers ", so what we go privately to our rulers in his palace made from our taxes and country's wealth and have a speech with thrm like kids ?? is this what your interpretation is ?? its " before an unjust ruler " not behind or privately, but before him, meaning infront of him, and we're all people who dont like him cause he's unjust, and we cant go privately to him, so whats the next best thing ? let him know, by going on a free space and SPEAKING to him through cameras and media who'll film it, this is only based on the hadith you quoted in English as in Arabic it may sound different, and what is said at least makes better sense than what you interpreted, and im not interpreting it im just debunking what you said it might means.@@hey.maaahir
@@FlareVolt0Asalaam alaikum
Brother you need to relax. This sort of emotional argument is what tumbles any sense of discussion. What do you think got the people to protest?
It was widespread media showcasing of the plight of our brothers and sisters in Gaza which got people to come out and ask their leaders to ask for a ceasefire. To your point of refuting/debunking what the other brothers said, and who/what gives you the right to refute and debunk or interpret what RasoolAllah saw said in the Hadith?
Our brothers and sisters in Gaza and West Bank couldn’t be united and could not form a govt, couldn’t be united among themselves, there was no proper representation from their side just factions that wanted to drive the idea in their favor, PLO wants something, h@m@$ wants something else and Allah swt forbid whatever our leaders in Saudi and the Arab world are doing behind the scenes. There are so many factors, so many issues. We Muslim ummah aren’t united in our own backyard and want to help our ummah in lands outside of ours and are united only in distress. What a joke of a ummah we have become and emotional fools like yourself don’t help the cause either because whenever there is one front trying or even attempting people like you behave like frogs in a well, stir the pot and absolute destroy any ideology.
@@FlareVolt0bro you didn't debunk a thing lol. Don't try to be smart here and go against the hadith thinking you're doing something beneficial. If you can't reach the rulers then don't bother. It's not upto you to give advice to authorities anyways. You lack the wisdom clearly when you're using such a logic of going against the hadith, surely you won't have the wisdom on how to advise him. Saying in public will do nothing, ur words won't even reach him. Plus if they do he already knows religious muslims are against his policies, against his changes and the fate of them, we're all aware what it is...
Leave it to knowledgeable people to advise and perhaps they do. They don't have to mention about their discussions to the public. See musnad ahmad 21784
Then why did Hassan (R. A.) fought against muawiya? U sure about doing nothing and let them do everything evil.
Did Muawiyah (R. A) do evil?
Then what happened with Hassan ra? Or both of the sides actually. Do you wanna repeat the cycle? Why didn't the prophet Muhammad saw fought against the meccans when they almost beat Abu Bakr ra to death, or when they tortured sumaya ra. Or countless other examples. We need to have Sabr. Islam will prevail we know. But hastiness is never good. And Allah SWT knows the best.
Did Muawiyah (R. A) do evil?
@@heaven.3031with all do respect this is stupid. no doubt Hussain RA will be granted the highest level in jannah for his sacrifice.
what we should just not do or say anything and leave everything to allah? no that’s dumb. first we need to show allah that we are atleast trying
On the authority of Abu Sa`eed al-Khudree (may Allah be pleased with him) who said:
I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say, “Whosoever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart - and that is the weakest of faith.”
[Muslim]
(hadith 34, 40 hadith an nawawi)
@@ibrahim_-_-_ the hadith you narrated literally favours my point. And no one said anything about the reward of family of our beloved prophet saw or any companion for that matter.
What you gonna do? Jihad? Protest? Yeah they definitely work don't they. This is clearly not the time to act. Impulsiveness is not a quality of a good Muslim rather patience is. Make your family follow Deen properly, let them marry righteous individuals, instead of just following the material possessions. Which, everyone is guilty of, whether they accept it or not. Only if we do that, can there be Baraka in their marriages and the birth of righteous people. Making the nation right again. We love to call others munafiq and such directly or indirectly. Without looking at what's happening in our households or surroundings. I ask you how many times have you knocked on your neighbours at night time just to ask them if they're fine, it's even gonna sound bizarre to us. Nations gets destroyed just as much from down to up than it gets from up to down. May Allah SWT grant us deeper understanding and increase our imaan, Ameen.
Maybe when all the mosques in the world are full for fajar salah outside Ramadan on a regular basis then inshallah we will be strong enough to defeat these enemies but now unfortunately it’s all talk and no action
idk everyone wants to fight the muluk, Ya Akhi, Defeat your nafs first. and guide peole around you , insha Allah we will get back to what we were
Ameen
@@TrollfacevidzAmeen
He literally said dont protest... Wow just wow
Prophet sallallahu alyhiwassallam prohibited protests . there is a lot of Hadeeths even one goes to Hasan ibn Ali Radiallahuanhuma
@@Trollfacevidz i am intrigued. Please share the reference?
@@mzorkeaSahih Muslim 1847b
@@IbnsvnJust one question then why did the arabs rebelled Against the Ottoman then? Or were this Hadith discover after that?
@@Ibnsvn how can i go Against the words of allah(quran) and his rasulullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam (sahih Hadith)?[nowhere did i make that remark] And did u Just say that the Ottomans were kafirs? Can u take responsibility for that during the day of Hashr?
Although right about the Arab Spring he is totally wrong on this issue today and shouldn’t be asked about politics in future. He is correct that you can’t impose religion but when the sun was on their side of the hedge many scholars were happy to provide a veneer of religiosity to despicable rulers who misused religious edicts to justify their tyranny and false claims of royalty. The Sheikh with no disrespect intended should stick to what he knows religion etc. and leave the rest to the practical people of the world. Though it may appear that another scholar had sold out or shown his true colours in difficult circumstances it may not be like that. Like all humans they simply appreciate the patronage of their hosts and the good life. Like us all they will be judged by what they could do at the time. People may say history will judge them but ultimately it’s Allah’s judgement that counts and we should look to ourselves first in all such cases. If you want wholesome changes in the world don’t look to rulers or scholars work with practical people of all faith or none to get things done. Historically it what people have always done especially when our societies were flourishing and at their most powerful.
If you are true Muslim you will know islam has its place in every part of life whether it be how to run a country all the way to how to drink water.
Getting serious madkhali vibes from this video.... Also why did they cut his question short while he was speaking 😂 thats just crazy
Do not listen to what you hear from Daniel H, Mohammed Hijab or Ali Dawah.
Sahih Muslim 1847b
The scholars advise the rulers In private and yet us laymen want to rebel.
@@Ibnsvn ok but do you really think you'll be given the opportunity by the ruler to advise him in private?
@@mzorkea what do you suggest is the best option and did you see the hadith?
@@Ibnsvn where exactly does this hadith mentions protests and demonstrations are not allowed?
@@mzorkea the hadith did not mention protests or demonstrations. I do not the Prophet ﷺ or any of the Salaf
The questioner lives with the kuffar!!! Why is he living there?? Is that a country abiding by the sharia???
@@rehanriaz620 since you don’t know anything and should not judge, it seems YOU are behaving like a kuffar. What business is it of yours? Shameful comment.