Leo tolstoy ki kahani ko anudit kr ke sunane ke liye apko bahut bahut dhanyawad. Lekin bas ek kami khalti hai ki tolstoy ki kahani ke asli naam ka zikra bhi nahi kiya jata,to relate karne me mushkil hoti hai.kripya asli shirshak ke sath story narrate karen
Vese leo Tolstoy ki story me rajput aur marathe kese aaye Anuvad to dhang se karte Marathon ne humesha sb ki sahayata ki hai Baki sb ne to ghutne tek k dushmnoko apni hi betiya biha di
@pallavishirke4572 tum kaale 2 feet ke bone marathe ho, tumhara bas 100 saal ki history hai, sarm karo 100 saal mein lapet ke fek diya tumhe , aur ham rajput 712 ad se leke 1918 battle of haifa tak 1200+ years ki history hai, jaane kitne kingdoms ko haraya hai alchon huns, sakas, tughlaq dynasty, khilji dynasty, malwa sultanate, afghans aur mughals ko bhi weak hamne he kiya tha aurangzeb ke time, voh toh rajputo ki mahanata thi ki unhone expansionist policy nhi lagayi rajput veer the aur hai, aur bhulo mat panipat ke yuddh mein tumhare choti height ke kaale bone marathe kaise bhaag gaye the panipat ke yuddh mein apni marathi aurato ko afghans ke haatho mein choddke, breast faad diye gaye afghans ne , aurato ko gulam bana ke le gaye, haare hue maratha sainiko ko gulam banake bechne le gaye afghans aut tumhare maratha soldiers tab bhag bhaag ke chale gaye, aur history utha ke dekh ke rajputs ne tumhari gaand faadi hai puraane weapons hone ke bavjood bhi , kabhi jadunath sarkar ki books ya maratha commander pohlmen aur james skinner ki battles mein kya hua tha dekh, maratha bhaag gaye field se rajputo ne kaat ke rakh diya saare bhagte hue maratha soldiers ko (iss battle mein haare the kyuki hamare pass advanced weapons nhi the aur tumhare pass modern british and portuguese french ke weapons the ..
Bohot saari cheeze hai, Pahla to ye ki tolstoy ki har kahani ki tarah isme bhi ye hai ki paristhitiya kaisi bhi ho, prayatnshil raha jaaye. Haar nahi maane, dusra ye ki yuddh me apne saathi ka saath hamesha do.
Yeh Premchand ki badmashi hai ke marathe aur Rajput ki kahani banayi warna likhne wale ne toh apane yaha ke koi samai ki kahani likhi hogi...marathi ko aise hi badnaam kiya hai jaichand ne
ये सत्य इतिहास है. पहले बाजीराव पेशवाके बाद शिंदे, होळकर, गायकवाड जैसे सरदार उत्तर भारतमे बस गये. बड़ी फौज रखनी पड़ती थी. मुगलोंके अस्तके बाद मुस्लिम नबाब और सरदार खुदमे छोटे छोटे राजा बने थे. वो प्रस्थापित थे. मराठा सैनिकोंके वेतनके लिये पैसा नहीं जुटता था. हिंदु राजा पहले मुगलोंको सालाना टॅक्स कलेक्शन का चौथा हिस्सा देते थे लेकिन मराठोंको नहीं देते थे. सब कंगाल हो गये थे. ... ऐसे पिड़ीत राजाओने बादमे अब्दालीको बुलाया और पानिपतका संग्राम हुआ..... ये इतिहास है.
Samir Goswami Ji aap ye batane ki kripa karenge ki Tolstoy russian tha rajput character indian hota hai to ye kahani jhooti hai ya aap murkh banane ka thika le rakha hai jahan tak mujhe ghamand hai Tolstoy ko jitna mai padha hun utna aap nahi
Jiwan Ji, Deepa Jha Ji ne aapka answer kar diya hai, Aap itne gyani aur jankar hain ki us par aapko ghamand hai isliye asha karta hoon rupaantar kya hota hai ye aap samajhte hain, Maine opening aur closing mein bola bhi hai ki Premchand Ji ne is kahani ka hindi Rupantar kiya hai. Baki rahi murkh banane ki baat to aap itne gyani hain ki aap kisi ko bhi murkh kah sakte hain. Aapka dhanyawad.
@@KahaniSuno mujhe pahle aapko batana chahunga ki rupantar kya roop badlana hota hai ya translate agar translate hai to character wahi hota hai language badlta hai jaise Tolstoy ki hi war and peace hindi me yudh aur shanti hai jab rupantar yani roop badlana to wo nakalchi hua to wo Tolstoy ki nahi premchand ki hui Tolstoy ke naam par thagna mera vichar jaisa lage lekin gyan aapka jarur badhega
@@KahaniSuno aapki kahaniya pichhle ek saal se roj sun rahi hu aur bahut achi lagti hain...aapka bahut dhanyawad itni achi kahaniya is andaz me hamare paas lane ke liye..
@@jiwanpathak4209 Ji Pahle aap rupaantar ko samjhen, kisi kahani ya upanyas ka roop isliye badla jata hai taki any parivesh ke padhne wale us se jud sake aur samajh sake jaise aaj gaon ke logon ko ho sakta hai mall, multiplex, food court samajh mein naa aaye isliye agar wo kahani shikshaprad hai to gaon ke parivesh ke hisab se uska roopantar karke pesh ki jayegi taki gaon wala us kahani se milne wali shiksha le sake. Premchand Ji ne koi chori nahin ki unhone lekhak mein Tolstoy ka naam hi diya hai, Baki aap premchand ji ko nakalchi kah sakte hain aapki marzi hain aur swatantrata hai, iske alawa saahitya ka gyan aapko premchand ji se zyada hoga. Agar aapko rupantar samajh aa gaya to theek anyatha ab mere paas itna time nahin hai ki aapse zyada charcha kar sakoon. Shukriya
आपका बहुत धन्यवाद । कि आपने ये कहानी सुनायी ।काफी अच्छी थी
आपकी आवाज़ और बोलने का तरीका बहुत ही अच्छा हैँ 👍👌👌
प्रभावशाली वाचन।टॉल्स्टॉय ने किसी शीर्षक से कहानी लिखी है यह भी बताया जाय।
कहानीका मूल नाम बताया कीजिये, अच्छा लगेगा!
लाजवाब 👌👌👌👌👍👍
Bahut hi sumadhur saleekedar voice
Proud to be rajput
Leo tolstoy ki kahani ko anudit kr ke sunane ke liye apko bahut bahut dhanyawad. Lekin bas ek kami khalti hai ki tolstoy ki kahani ke asli naam ka zikra bhi nahi kiya jata,to relate karne me mushkil hoti hai.kripya asli shirshak ke sath story narrate karen
अनुवाद और रूपांतर दोनों अलग अलग हैं प्रेमचंद जी ने रूपांतर किया है।
Thanks
Bhut khoob
Thank you sir
लाल दाढ़ी वाले मुस्लिम लुटेरे हो सकते है मराठे नही।
Saalo yha bhi hindu Muslim krlo ... Yeh kahani Tolstoy ki story ka translation hai... Russia me kha se muslim n marathe aa gye ...😂😂
वहीं मे सोच रहा था. और गुलामो की संस्कृति हमारी नहीं विदेशी संस्कृति हे.....
Vese leo Tolstoy ki story me rajput aur marathe kese aaye
Anuvad to dhang se karte
Marathon ne humesha sb ki sahayata ki hai
Baki sb ne to ghutne tek k dushmnoko apni hi betiya biha di
@pallavishirke4572 tum kaale 2 feet ke bone marathe ho, tumhara bas 100 saal ki history hai, sarm karo 100 saal mein lapet ke fek diya tumhe , aur ham rajput 712 ad se leke 1918 battle of haifa tak 1200+ years ki history hai, jaane kitne kingdoms ko haraya hai alchon huns, sakas, tughlaq dynasty, khilji dynasty, malwa sultanate, afghans aur mughals ko bhi weak hamne he kiya tha aurangzeb ke time, voh toh rajputo ki mahanata thi ki unhone expansionist policy nhi lagayi rajput veer the aur hai, aur bhulo mat panipat ke yuddh mein tumhare choti height ke kaale bone marathe kaise bhaag gaye the panipat ke yuddh mein apni marathi aurato ko afghans ke haatho mein choddke, breast faad diye gaye afghans ne , aurato ko gulam bana ke le gaye, haare hue maratha sainiko ko gulam banake bechne le gaye afghans aut tumhare maratha soldiers tab bhag bhaag ke chale gaye, aur history utha ke dekh ke rajputs ne tumhari gaand faadi hai puraane weapons hone ke bavjood bhi , kabhi jadunath sarkar ki books ya maratha commander pohlmen aur james skinner ki battles mein kya hua tha dekh, maratha bhaag gaye field se rajputo ne kaat ke rakh diya saare bhagte hue maratha soldiers ko (iss battle mein haare the kyuki hamare pass advanced weapons nhi the aur tumhare pass modern british and portuguese french ke weapons the ..
thanks sir
Super👌👍🙏🌹
Thank you
धन्यवाद् सर
🙏
Sweet voice
Sweet to nhi h😂
Bahut hi sundar ❤️
Bhai kitnay ads laga rakhe hain.
Kismat k rang bahut azib hi
Nice story 👍
टॉलस्टॉय की अमिट छाप थी प्रेमचन्द जी पर.. उन्ही की प्रेरणा ने उन्हे उपन्यास सम्राट बना डाला था... 😊💐
बहुत सुंदर
Suraj Rajpoot
munshi premchand ne tolstoy ki kahani ka anuvaad nahin satyanaash kar diya hai. tolstoy ko badnaam karne ka haq kisi munshi ko kisne diya
Aap nadani me ye baat bol rahe ho, Munshi Premchand ji ek behtareen kahanikar rahe he
Add jyada aate h
Story se kya sikh Mili ye to batao
Bohot saari cheeze hai,
Pahla to ye ki tolstoy ki har kahani ki tarah isme bhi ye hai ki paristhitiya kaisi bhi ho, prayatnshil raha jaaye. Haar nahi maane, dusra ye ki yuddh me apne saathi ka saath hamesha do.
Is kahani me koi seekh nahi he
Your story Hindi translation is not good as leo wrote...
Durdarshan ki tarh antotight mat dalo babu
Advertisment ke dukaan.
Yeh Premchand ki badmashi hai ke marathe aur Rajput ki kahani banayi warna likhne wale ne toh apane yaha ke koi samai ki kahani likhi hogi...marathi ko aise hi badnaam kiya hai jaichand ne
ये सत्य इतिहास है. पहले बाजीराव पेशवाके बाद शिंदे, होळकर, गायकवाड जैसे सरदार उत्तर भारतमे बस गये. बड़ी फौज रखनी पड़ती थी. मुगलोंके अस्तके बाद मुस्लिम नबाब और सरदार खुदमे छोटे छोटे राजा बने थे. वो प्रस्थापित थे. मराठा सैनिकोंके वेतनके लिये पैसा नहीं जुटता था. हिंदु राजा पहले मुगलोंको सालाना टॅक्स कलेक्शन का चौथा हिस्सा देते थे लेकिन मराठोंको नहीं देते थे. सब कंगाल हो गये थे. ... ऐसे पिड़ीत राजाओने बादमे अब्दालीको बुलाया और पानिपतका संग्राम हुआ..... ये इतिहास है.
@@vaibhav14476 😂😂sahi se history nhi padhi h aapne
Kisi ki kukrtayo ko kab tak chupaoge
Bhai ye ai voice se mat banao please
Esme marathao ko galt tarike se portray kiya
Actually this story is Russians vs Tatars...
Fictional hai tension mat lo
नहीं मराठो का अच्छा चरित्र है| उन्होंने राजपूतों को यातना नहीं दी. सुशीला कितनी दयालु थी. पैसे लेकर चरण सिंह को छोंड दिया, वादाखिलाफी नहीं की.
@@MrShukra2000 reality hai fictional nhi
Bakwas
Samir Goswami Ji aap ye batane ki kripa karenge ki Tolstoy russian tha rajput character indian hota hai to ye kahani jhooti hai ya aap murkh banane ka thika le rakha hai jahan tak mujhe ghamand hai Tolstoy ko jitna mai padha hun utna aap nahi
Ye rupaantar hai premchand dwara
Jiwan Ji, Deepa Jha Ji ne aapka answer kar diya hai, Aap itne gyani aur jankar hain ki us par aapko ghamand hai isliye asha karta hoon rupaantar kya hota hai ye aap samajhte hain, Maine opening aur closing mein bola bhi hai ki Premchand Ji ne is kahani ka hindi Rupantar kiya hai. Baki rahi murkh banane ki baat to aap itne gyani hain ki aap kisi ko bhi murkh kah sakte hain. Aapka dhanyawad.
@@KahaniSuno mujhe pahle aapko batana chahunga ki rupantar kya roop badlana hota hai ya translate agar translate hai to character wahi hota hai language badlta hai jaise Tolstoy ki hi war and peace hindi me yudh aur shanti hai jab rupantar yani roop badlana to wo nakalchi hua to wo Tolstoy ki nahi premchand ki hui Tolstoy ke naam par thagna mera vichar jaisa lage lekin gyan aapka jarur badhega
@@KahaniSuno aapki kahaniya pichhle ek saal se roj sun rahi hu aur bahut achi lagti hain...aapka bahut dhanyawad itni achi kahaniya is andaz me hamare paas lane ke liye..
@@jiwanpathak4209 Ji Pahle aap rupaantar ko samjhen, kisi kahani ya upanyas ka roop isliye badla jata hai taki any parivesh ke padhne wale us se jud sake aur samajh sake jaise aaj gaon ke logon ko ho sakta hai mall, multiplex, food court samajh mein naa aaye isliye agar wo kahani shikshaprad hai to gaon ke parivesh ke hisab se uska roopantar karke pesh ki jayegi taki gaon wala us kahani se milne wali shiksha le sake. Premchand Ji ne koi chori nahin ki unhone lekhak mein Tolstoy ka naam hi diya hai, Baki aap premchand ji ko nakalchi kah sakte hain aapki marzi hain aur swatantrata hai, iske alawa saahitya ka gyan aapko premchand ji se zyada hoga. Agar aapko rupantar samajh aa gaya to theek anyatha ab mere paas itna time nahin hai ki aapse zyada charcha kar sakoon. Shukriya
🙏
Thanks