What’s really special is that this performance was before Wish You Were Here was released, so probably nobody in the audience had ever heard this song before. And they absolutely went nuts for it, as they should; it’s a fundamentally incredible work of art.
I was at one these Concerts at the " Wembley Empire Pool " as it was called back then, and they were stunning. The first half of the show started with this early version of " Shine On ", plus " You gotta be Crazy " and " Raving and Drooling " which we all now know as " Dogs" and " Sheep ".....Second half of the show was an updated " Dark Side of the Moon " complete with the now famous large circular back screen showing various clips throughout the performance. So glad to hear tracks like this from SO long ago in 1974. Still got my Programme and Tickets from the Concerts, and will stay with me forever, methinks......Shine On Indeed.....
The studio version (released in 1975 in two halves [Pts I-V and Pts VI-IX] on the album Wish You Were Here) is 26 minutes in total and several of the In The Flesh tour (1977) performances stretched as long as 35 minutes.
I feel you man, Pink Floyd has probably saved my life a few times with their music. Listening to them makes me feel like I'm not alone in my struggles in this world.
They wouldn't know where to begin, real musicians each putting their best effort to creating a unique sound, thank God for these recordings we can still remember what real talent sounded like
I raced to the record store..sorry kids no internet then..on the day this was released and I’m still listening to it 47 years later..still a masterpiece…love these guys…without Gilmour and Wright it ain’t Floyd.
Remember when you were young, you shone like the sun. Shine on you crazy diamond. Now there's a look in your eyes, like black holes in the sky. Shine on you crazy diamond. You were caught on the crossfire of childhood and stardom, Blown on the steel breeze. Come on you target for faraway laughter, Come on you stranger, you legend, you martyr, and shine! You reached for the secret too soon, you cried for the moon. Shine on you crazy diamond. Threatened by shadows at night, and exposed in the light. Shine on you crazy diamond. Well you wore out your welcome with random precision, Rode on the steel breeze. Come on you raver, you seer of visions, Come on you painter, you piper, you prisoner, and shine!
I was lucky enough to see them on this tour at The Usher Hall in Edinburgh. Apart from tracks from Wish You Were Here they did the whole of Dark Side of The Moon and Echoes as an encore. It was an unforgettable experience one I will never forget.
I don't know what is gonna be of me when years go through. Probably life will give me surprises, happiness, hard times, but something I really know is that, despite all time could pass, this song will still being listening by me. I think there's no a song similar to this. Shine on you crazy diamond has something speciall, it's a melody that can not be replaced by another one, it shows me calm and patience. Just a masterpiece.
I discovered this gem in my local library. I like this live version of “Shine on You Crazy Diamond” even more than the album cut. It’s dreamy to hear the song done in one piece. Richard Wright takes it to a whole new level. This song was the first song in a live concert Pink Floyd did in 1974. Other songs include early versions from Animals, “Raving and Drooling” and “You Got to be Crazy”. The 2nd half of the concert includes “DSOTM”, and an awesome live version of “Echoes”. If you are a lifelong fan of Pink Floyd like me, then you will want to kick back and listen to the whole concert. This is Pink Floyd in their prime. I say that as an old man who had the good fortune of seeing Pink Floyd live seven times, four times with Roger Waters.
I first head Shine On the day Wish You Were Here was released in 1975. I had been eagerly anticipating it because DSOTM had been release more than 2 years earlier. As I listened to this in my college dorm room, I remember thinking..... "This is a psychedelic blues album."
This was the 1st opening song at the wembley 74 winter tour gigs. Still being formulated prior to recording ( as they did back then!) I was in row B in front of DG and 2 backing singers. I’m still stunned!!
Fully agree. Especially from 17.11 to the end of the song. Absolutely brilliant drumming ,
2 роки тому+6
Nick Mason is a lot like Ringo Starr. He was never flashy or wild on the kit, but he was always able to deliver the perfect groove the song demanded. A lot of people don't realize that being a decent drummer is the hardest part of playing the drums.
@ right! Idk what ppl want. Is he supposed to try to overpower David's solos and just clash with the sound? He seems chill playing later on but on the original Pompeii recording, you see Mason get after it and can appreciate his talent
Nick Mason is actually such a good drummer that nobody knows how good of a drummer he is. Minimalist and egoless not because he can't not be, but because that's what the situation calls for. Dude could probably beat the shit out of his drums with 32nd note hits but he's wise enough not to. The warrior who keeps his weapons sheathed.
So this performance is from a concert 6 months *prior* to them recording the track for the Wish You Were Here album?? It's fascinating to hear the track in its development stage, albeit an advanced one here. All the tempo and time signature changes (the basic rhythm track) of the album version are present here. What's still to be developed further is the fabulous album version of Part 8, where Rick Wright runs riot on the synths and clavinet - duelling and trading riffs with a frienzied Gilmour. Here, part 8 is a more laid-back jam with sustained Hammond organ parts and subdued licks from Gilmour. There are some comments below about the vocals - I think they are great in this performance. Raw and heartfelt!
@@mattgilbert7347 I agree. Some of the other ones I've heard from this time had him sounding a bit cringeworthy. This sounds the best with respect to the album version.
@tina the punk rocker Yeah, i can relate to that. When you play on a recording for some reason you feel the pressure that everything has to be perfect, and you play in some sort of a robotic way. But when you play live, you can feel the whole energy flowing and your creativity just explodes.
I think without David's playing and singing we all never would have been so turned on by Pink Floyd. I love all aspects so don't get me wrong but he's too brilliant to deny.
That Uni Vibe effect on those opening Arpeggios in Shine On was a studio mistake that Waters insisted that Gilmour kept in and didn’t change or correct. Pink Floyd were a remarkable band. I seen them in 88,89, 90 and 94. But alas without Waters. But I’m glad to say that they were my first live experience.
@@erikarabie They definitely have similiar tonal characteristics on slower settings that can hard to distinguish. On faster settings, the Uni-Vibe sweep tends to be a little more pronounced. Best examples I can think of: Uni-Vibe Jimi Hendrix - Machine Gun Robin Trower - Bridge Of Sighs Phaser - Rush - The Necromancer Van Halen - Eruption ( slower setting )
Same omg, went up to Joshua tree with my girl and some friends. Brought out my boom box, gave them some shrooms and told them to hang on for the ride. Best ever man, listening to this song and welcome to the machine together felt like an everlasting trip
A masterpiece of crativity😍complete pré version of Shine on you crazy diamond unrealesed and not even totally completed at the time🤗great live 4 man ONLY played loosing nothing to the later versions Played with more musicians... The ONLY time i Hear the band play the tune complete live this is a precious gem,💎... This all set of new tunes were they played raving and drooling(pré version of Sheep) and you got to be crazy(pré version of dogs as followers... Só we got a set of 3 new tunes at the time wich lasted almost 1 hour😳 what a show this must have been💥
1 man, 1 vision. Conjured up the name, created their sound, walked away into obscurity and still influenced their musical journey. Syd was the catalyst and major reason why The Pink Floyd Sound manifested into existence. 4 men paying homage to their lost brother, sad. If Syd kept it together we would lose out on future masterpieces. Unfortunately, he went off the rails, payed his price and the other 4 created this as a memorial to our fallen genius. Syd is still inspiring, check out Dave's new single. Coincidence? Think not. Hopefully the dolly rocker concurs in the cosmos. Totally appreciate their craft. They have inspired millions for decades. 5 unique talents, who complety made true art, not just music. Great recording btw. Glad I saw them during The Division Bell tour, amazing. Sorry Rog, they were still a force of nature without your presence & blessing. Not the same but damn, still better than 99% of music out there. Rog had the grandiose, universal lyrics but lacked the musical chops. Dave, Nick and Rick pulled off 2 (3, if you count The Endless River) amazing albums. Amused to Death was a great premise and had some killer songs. Also remember, Radio Chaos and The Pros and Cons of Hitching. Also had good themes and some great songs. He could never capture or encapsulate the magic of all 4 together. Damn shame. Live 8 was a great reunion but knew in my heart they all couldn't bury the hatchet. Not bitching at all. Grateful for all they produced together and their solo works. Dave's new single is tight and another nod to Syd. Jolly good.
Mateusz Leśniak .is this really wembley 74. The song was not still complete in this form at that year. You can hear live recording from 73 on dark side of the moon experience version edition . It must be from in the flesh tour 77. They were perfectionists at that time and roger sang very emotional.
What’s really special is that this performance was before Wish You Were Here was released, so probably nobody in the audience had ever heard this song before. And they absolutely went nuts for it, as they should; it’s a fundamentally incredible work of art.
I absolutely heard this when it came out my friend ❤ love Pink Floyd ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
greatest song ever written
Have I gone deaf,or did Dave sing lead here?
@@josiplilic3384 they both do
@@AdamSandaver Thanks, never have heard this version & Dave's voice sounds waaaaay powerful!
Man can not live on bread alone he needs this type of music to feed his soul
LOVE this comment!!
Peace from Detroit city!! ✌
our priest told that this morning in church.
True that. A rock masterpiece.
Истину глаголиш , человек существо не только материальное , но и духовное - одновременно.
It's like David is summoning the Devil during his Slide work..
I was at one these Concerts at the " Wembley Empire Pool " as it was called back then, and they were stunning. The first half of the show started with this early version of " Shine On ", plus " You gotta be Crazy " and " Raving and Drooling " which we all now know as " Dogs" and " Sheep ".....Second half of the show was an updated " Dark Side of the Moon " complete with the now famous large circular back screen showing various clips throughout the performance. So glad to hear tracks like this from SO long ago in 1974. Still got my Programme and Tickets from the Concerts, and will stay with me forever, methinks......Shine On Indeed.....
I need you to tell more about those times
This is music for the soul. The soul needs music like this
indeed. there is no therapy quite like it
I recently made an album called music for the soul xx haha bizarre coincidence that 😅 I can safely say pink Floyd are better at it than me xxx
That intro by Richard Wright is so surreal; really hypnotizing.
IKR !!!!
Felipe Miranda such a shame he died a few years back 😔
He's so awesome on Hammond...
the final idem
@@justbecause968 34 years years after this
Only Pink Floyd can "drag" a song out for 20+ minutes and leave you sad it's over and wanting more :)
The 3 minute radio limit steals souls
The studio version (released in 1975 in two halves [Pts I-V and Pts VI-IX] on the album Wish You Were Here) is 26 minutes in total and several of the In The Flesh tour (1977) performances stretched as long as 35 minutes.
Coriolis's Dante did it for me
@@gmxkey lol
@@21centuryhippie61 Oakland 77 man ^^
I have been having major personal issues, thank god for Pink Floyd,their music has been my solace . And thank you Pink Floyd Remastered Songs ~
You are not alone there. I mean Floyd's music bringing solace.
I feel you man, Pink Floyd has probably saved my life a few times with their music. Listening to them makes me feel like I'm not alone in my struggles in this world.
Two years on, I hope you are doing better these days.
I took a long drive for work
Popped on both versions the long drive.
The ending was pretty sad but upbeat
R.I.P Richard Wright, your soul will live on through music and memory
Shine on you crazy diamond R.I.P😢😭
Amazing audio quality...and from 1974, they were definitely at the top of their tradecraft
12:30 Dave's slide guitar is so chilling. Much more than on the album. The rawness of being one of the first times playing this live.
1974 damn nobody can touch this in 2020
Agreed man!
@@venayakgupta2879 ^
You said it
or 2024
They wouldn't know where to begin, real musicians each putting their best effort to creating a unique sound, thank God for these recordings we can still remember what real talent sounded like
The Syd era medley at the end is so great... Rick is a beautiful soul
October 2024. Who is with me ?😊
I am
Here with you mate
Presente... 🙋
Saludos del sur del mundo....🇨🇱.. 🙌
Greatest Band of All time
In 60ist the beatles..in 70ist pink floyd
What about WHAM!??? Ha ha just kidding.
pink floyd is definitely one band of all time
fk yes
In my humble opinion the Beatles hold nothing to zeppelin or floyd but I understand that many will feel differently
Its so cool to hear these early versions where they were experimenting with the song, some different parts here and there
Rick Wrights solo around 12 minutes predates Blade Runner by some years, too. Utterly fantastic.
it's about a decade ahead of it s time at least..how cool..Richard was the heart and soul
what do the two have to do with each other, if I may ask?
how can we make this world better? by listening to songs like this more often.
I can really appreciate how these artists constantly strove to perfect their craft. Excellent creativity & performances.
best live of shine on you crazy diamond.
It`s awesome, but I love the guitar in the later versions
I raced to the record store..sorry kids no internet then..on the day this was released and I’m still listening to it 47 years later..still a masterpiece…love these guys…without Gilmour and Wright it ain’t Floyd.
me 2😊
Just heard this version for the first time (3/23), I’m in awe.
Now this is music. What a wonderful masterpiece.
50 years ago! WOW!😮
00:11 Part I
1:38 Part II
4:48 Part III
6:56 Part IV
9:19 Part V
10:47 Part VI
14:59 Part VII
16:23 Part VIII
18:42 Part IX
The greatest musical heritage I received from my father! Today, I pass it on to my children.
Remember when you were young, you shone like the sun. Shine on you crazy diamond. Now there's a look in your eyes, like black holes in the sky. Shine on you crazy diamond. You were caught on the crossfire of childhood and stardom, Blown on the steel breeze. Come on you target for faraway laughter, Come on you stranger, you legend, you martyr, and shine! You reached for the secret too soon, you cried for the moon. Shine on you crazy diamond. Threatened by shadows at night, and exposed in the light. Shine on you crazy diamond. Well you wore out your welcome with random precision, Rode on the steel breeze. Come on you raver, you seer of visions, Come on you painter, you piper, you prisoner, and shine!
That is hands down the ULTIMATE recording of Shine On I have ever heard. Way better than the album version in my honest opinion!!!
♒🕉☮☯️👽🎸🎶🎵🌌🍄🧠
studio album was over produced imho. this is raw and essential
I agree! Can't believe I never came across this recording before. Richard Wright's organ/synthesizer is particularly haunting in this rendition.
It’s just like a demo but one of the best ones it was just need more time for it because the second part but it’s so good 🫡
I was lucky enough to see them on this tour at The Usher Hall in Edinburgh. Apart from tracks from Wish You Were Here they did the whole of Dark Side of The Moon and Echoes as an encore. It was an unforgettable experience one I will never forget.
Wow. I would have fainted from happiness
The envy of me
I was at this show Wembley (front row) and Manchester Palace (at the back) same winter tout 1974.
The solo from 12:00 to 15:10 is out of this world can’t get tired of listening to it you can feel the rawness of the performance beautiful ✨
Roger - bass, lead vocal
Dave - lead guitar, harmony vocal
Rick - organ, synth, harmony vocal
Nick - drums
Pink Floyd takes you into another dimension...........there will never be another band like them..................................ever.
Absolutely
Right into my Pink Floyd playlist :-) The sound quality is great with my HD headphones :-) ROCK ON!!!!!!!
Awesome version, and excellent images. I like how they are conveniently placed to when each member becomes more prominent in the song.
I don't know what is gonna be of me when years go through. Probably life will give me surprises, happiness, hard times, but something I really know is that, despite all time could pass, this song will still being listening by me. I think there's no a song similar to this. Shine on you crazy diamond has something speciall, it's a melody that can not be replaced by another one, it shows me calm and patience. Just a masterpiece.
They were still working it all out. And it’s one of the greatest live performances of all time.
That slide solo is just wicked. Unreal tones there...
50 лет уже этой композиции! До сих пор слушаю её и плачу, эмоции переполняют😭😭😭😭😭
Four geniuses fully embracing the technological evolution in the music industry.
Paved by another 4 piece that heralded the 60's. Sixties and seventies created some of the most memorable and everlasting groups and sounds ever
This is amazing. They really were a fucking brilliant live band.
I discovered this gem in my local library. I like this live version of “Shine on You Crazy Diamond” even more than the album cut. It’s dreamy to hear the song done in one piece. Richard Wright takes it to a whole new level. This song was the first song in a live concert Pink Floyd did in 1974. Other songs include early versions from Animals, “Raving and Drooling” and “You Got to be Crazy”. The 2nd half of the concert includes “DSOTM”, and an awesome live version of “Echoes”. If you are a lifelong fan of Pink Floyd like me, then you will want to kick back and listen to the whole concert. This is Pink Floyd in their prime. I say that as an old man who had the good fortune of seeing Pink Floyd live seven times, four times with Roger Waters.
Greatest band of all time. Nobody else sniffs it.
We sure miss ya, Rick. See you on the other side. I'll look you up, because I have a lot of questions. RIP ❤
I first head Shine On the day Wish You Were Here was released in 1975. I had been eagerly anticipating it because DSOTM had been release more than 2 years earlier. As I listened to this in my college dorm room, I remember thinking..... "This is a psychedelic blues album."
Dixon Diaz me too. One of my favorites
I felt the same the first time I listened to that fabulous album!
This was the 1st opening song at the wembley 74 winter tour gigs. Still being formulated prior to recording ( as they did back then!)
I was in row B in front of DG and 2 backing singers. I’m still stunned!!
I was too young to get to ever see them. another Regret .life goes on.
Same here. SAD
Go see Roger Waters when he resumes his tour which was postponed for 2020, I can guarantee you its the next best thing and will be utterly amazing!!
Many many people consider Nick Mason a 'meh' drummer. Reason? There aren't enough recordings from their mid to late 70s. I love this recording.
Fully agree. Especially from 17.11 to the end of the song. Absolutely brilliant drumming ,
Nick Mason is a lot like Ringo Starr. He was never flashy or wild on the kit, but he was always able to deliver the perfect groove the song demanded. A lot of people don't realize that being a decent drummer is the hardest part of playing the drums.
@ right! Idk what ppl want. Is he supposed to try to overpower David's solos and just clash with the sound? He seems chill playing later on but on the original Pompeii recording, you see Mason get after it and can appreciate his talent
Nick Mason is actually such a good drummer that nobody knows how good of a drummer he is. Minimalist and egoless not because he can't not be, but because that's what the situation calls for. Dude could probably beat the shit out of his drums with 32nd note hits but he's wise enough not to. The warrior who keeps his weapons sheathed.
So this performance is from a concert 6 months *prior* to them recording the track for the Wish You Were Here album??
It's fascinating to hear the track in its development stage, albeit an advanced one here. All the tempo and time signature changes (the basic rhythm track) of the album version are present here. What's still to be developed further is the fabulous album version of Part 8, where Rick Wright runs riot on the synths and clavinet - duelling and trading riffs with a frienzied Gilmour. Here, part 8 is a more laid-back jam with sustained Hammond organ parts and subdued licks from Gilmour.
There are some comments below about the vocals - I think they are great in this performance. Raw and heartfelt!
Imo Water's live voice never sounded as good as what I'm hearing here. He was in tune and giving it all the welly he could muster.
Full marks.
@@mattgilbert7347 I agree. Some of the other ones I've heard from this time had him sounding a bit cringeworthy. This sounds the best with respect to the album version.
...and played in total. Parts 1-10 without a break either. My 1st PF gig. Right at the front. It was a magical psychadelic hippy jam.
Oh man, the bassline in this one is way better than the album version!!
Definitely true!!
@tina the punk rocker Yeah, i can relate to that. When you play on a recording for some reason you feel the pressure that everything has to be perfect, and you play in some sort of a robotic way. But when you play live, you can feel the whole energy flowing and your creativity just explodes.
yeah you can tell hes doing a lot of improv here
I know, actually that’s why I love part 6-9 because the bass and the synth :)
I think without David's playing and singing we all never would have been so turned on by Pink Floyd. I love all aspects so don't get me wrong but he's too brilliant to deny.
This is Waters singing here. Pink Floyd would be nothing without Waters' compositions.
@@stickman1742 True and True. And I wish they both would realize that
@@stickman1742 who sings this song in the album version?
@@leomiller2291waters
This Is Waters singing
Ląduje w innym wymiarze słuchając, a to wyjątkowo trwa 20 minut. Uzbierało się już tych wersji. ♥️♥️♥️🇵🇱
Amazing show I'll never forget. I was 1
Best I've heard Waters singing this live
agreed, was just thinking that😊
IMO he got even better after this & peaked from the late 70s up until his first solo record/tour in 84.
Pink Floyds live music is riveting.
I’m so sad when this song ends so I play it again :)
There wont be another band like them for a long time
Ever
Never has been.
Already is, it’s called Tool
@@FortuneFinders hahahahaha, i needed a chuckle today, thanks.
@@tombradley4844
He is kind of right though
What a perfect version.blew my mind!
Mason's drum a killer!
Thank God and the Universe for Pink Floyd, for mother Gaia, for health, for life and death
That Uni Vibe effect on those opening Arpeggios in Shine On was a studio mistake that Waters insisted that Gilmour kept in and didn’t change or correct. Pink Floyd were a remarkable band. I seen them in 88,89, 90 and 94. But alas without Waters. But I’m glad to say that they were my first live experience.
I can never tell the difference between Uni-vibe and phase shifter
@@erikarabie
They definitely have similiar tonal characteristics on slower settings that can hard to distinguish.
On faster settings, the Uni-Vibe sweep tends to be a little more pronounced.
Best examples I can think of:
Uni-Vibe
Jimi Hendrix - Machine Gun
Robin Trower - Bridge Of Sighs
Phaser -
Rush - The Necromancer
Van Halen - Eruption ( slower setting )
right at 2:58 when Rick's MiniMoog line rises in your right ear,,,wooww, chills & goosebumps every time
Wouldn't it be great to have a DVD of these early shows? How did they not film every one of them.
...and no soundboard recordings either...WTF??!!
They did filmed those, they are keeping them in a huge archive to make millions in the future...
@@JorgeVargas-po6ls so why hasn't it been released? do you think they need the money?
@@AdamSandaver record companies always want more
@@OfSoundNFury the band still call the shots
as if the stars were falling from the sky and feeding my soul with their magical energy......
best version that I have heard of this song....
16:00 Waters vocals in this part are awesome
i know man its so good
"Awesome" is not word one would normally associate with Rogers' voice.
@@blahdeblah6207 but bro its so good at that spot in the video
@UpAndDown whatever
I was pleasantly surprised knowing what he could sound like LOL!
That see emily play at the end sounds so beautiful here wow just wow
Daniela Waters can you share the time stamp? I’ve never known which part that was
@@MajesticWaffle 18:59 :)
this is absolutely brilliant. floyd in their element
Jak slucham Pink Floyd to czuje ze człowiek przekracza wszelkie granice a muzyka jest tylko jedna z możliwości.
Best version of the best song ever I have to crank it to flat out stuff falling off the shelves everywhere
brilliance that will NEVER be topped!
Live is much better then recording a fresh breath of air wonderful artists
Pink Floyd just pulls you into an alternate audio reality. Totally lost in their music, I am not worthy! 🎵
Anyone cry at the end? RIP Rick
THE song of my first shrooms trip 💓🌙💜🌈
Andres Navas same here man! Great choice
Same omg, went up to Joshua tree with my girl and some friends. Brought out my boom box, gave them some shrooms and told them to hang on for the ride. Best ever man, listening to this song and welcome to the machine together felt like an everlasting trip
Took some syd once and couldn't get to the TV turn off the pulse......it was so intense I couldn't breathe.
Awesome. Same, but LSD
good taste of music, i've just finded. On weed is amazing too
This live are fucking awesome!!!!!!
SOOOOOOO ABSOLUTELY LOVE THE GUITAR in this song.❤😎😁
Fax
A masterpiece of crativity😍complete pré version of Shine on you crazy diamond unrealesed and not even totally completed at the time🤗great live 4 man ONLY played loosing nothing to the later versions Played with more musicians... The ONLY time i Hear the band play the tune complete live this is a precious gem,💎... This all set of new tunes were they played raving and drooling(pré version of Sheep) and you got to be crazy(pré version of dogs as followers... Só we got a set of 3 new tunes at the time wich lasted almost 1 hour😳 what a show this must have been💥
EL MEJOR TEMA DE PINK FLOYD
LEJOS LO MEJOR EXELENTE SIN LIMITES
sometimes hearing shine i think what a shame i already know how the rest of the music is, and i'm not hearing shine for the first time
1 man, 1 vision. Conjured up the name, created their sound, walked away into obscurity and still influenced their musical journey. Syd was the catalyst and major reason why The Pink Floyd Sound manifested into existence. 4 men paying homage to their lost brother, sad. If Syd kept it together we would lose out on future masterpieces. Unfortunately, he went off the rails, payed his price and the other 4 created this as a memorial to our fallen genius. Syd is still inspiring, check out Dave's new single. Coincidence? Think not. Hopefully the dolly rocker concurs in the cosmos. Totally appreciate their craft. They have inspired millions for decades. 5 unique talents, who complety made true art, not just music. Great recording btw. Glad I saw them during The Division Bell tour, amazing. Sorry Rog, they were still a force of nature without your presence & blessing. Not the same but damn, still better than 99% of music out there. Rog had the grandiose, universal lyrics but lacked the musical chops. Dave, Nick and Rick pulled off 2 (3, if you count The Endless River) amazing albums. Amused to Death was a great premise and had some killer songs. Also remember, Radio Chaos and The Pros and Cons of Hitching. Also had good themes and some great songs. He could never capture or encapsulate the magic of all 4 together. Damn shame. Live 8 was a great reunion but knew in my heart they all couldn't bury the hatchet. Not bitching at all. Grateful for all they produced together and their solo works. Dave's new single is tight and another nod to Syd. Jolly good.
Realmente alucinante, se disfruta cada segundo de tremenda melodía, pink floyd ayuda mucho a expandir la mente...
Me encantan los vocales, en especial los de Gilmour cuando canta la parte que dice "Shine on you crazy diamond"
This Is Roger singing
live performances really drive you out of this world!!! its absolutely amazing!
I was 12 years old my brother 10. And still we crying
An hour with Pink Floyd: This; You've Gotta be Crazy; Echoes.
This is amazing. Thanks for sharing😊!
Beautiful video
Mateusz Leśniak .is this really wembley 74. The song was not still complete in this form at that year. You can hear live recording from 73 on dark side of the moon experience version edition . It must be from in the flesh tour 77. They were perfectionists at that time and roger sang very emotional.
I saw them in SF when they did this tour. Spekfreakintacular.
Roger singing here is great
Shine On You Crazy Diamond and Soon (Yes) two amazing songs.
You are the master of the industrial business of the Rock progressive 👏🙌😀👍😄..the best or nothinggggg...Master..pink floyd...floyd and floyd..
Epochal! Timeless great music...
Absolutely incredible
The end is EPIC
This feels much more like Dark Side Of The Moon style compared to album version...awesome version too
Só tenho uma coisa a dizer, isso é maravilhoso!!!!
É impressionante a capacidade sonora desses caras. Surreal!
Love the trippy video. Gerald Scarfe is a fucking genius.
WooOoo it's Epic !! Amazing Band ¥ Infinite sounds ¥☆☆☆☆☆~
Best version ever
Magical when they all played together.
This is why roger's voice is better, he sang with emotion and he tryied to express feelings using it, unlike david
Beacause he wrote it
@@blackandgoldmusica Yeah exactly
I would argue david has the better voice, but you're spot on about roger singing with more emotion