Rafisaab is the apple of my right eye and Kishore da is the apple of my left eye and they are both great legends on their own I can never compare them with each other or with any other singers (Period)
70s tak koi compare hi nhi Tha baad me young generation ko doom dharaka chahiye Tha Jo ki Kishore Kumar gaate the over all versatile me rafi ,Lata se kisi ka koi compresion nhi hai classical singer ke samne yeh log kuch nhi hai
K.L Sehgal was benchmark for all Legendary Singers. All Legendary Singers like Mukesh,hemant kumar, Kishore Kumar, Lata Mangeshkar,Asha Bhosle & Rafi used To copy him.
@@rishabhadarsh5227 yes you're right but it should be corrected latter never copied K.L. Sehgal instead Mukesh's "Dil jalta hai toh Jalne de aasoo na baha fariyaad na kar" was alike copied!
@@NINJAGMR124 initially he used to copy k.l.sehgal so are other lengends like kishore, hemant,Mukesh,lata & asha. Because that tym Sehgal style of singing was in trend & producer used to force singers to sing like him
no, not both. kishore is far far superior than rafi undoubtedly and unarguably. kishore jsise naa koi huwa naa hoga. rafi is ok but kishore on the top of music world always.
Even Kishore Da was a fan of Rafi sb, Rafi sb's range and the Sweetness and Uniqueness of voice style generated by himself.... Makes him the most versatile singer, and greatest of all the time. 🙏😊
Raffi sahab was also fan of Kishore da ..He used to tell sher to Kishore da..Mera sher aayega to sab ke awaz dab jayegi...Both has respect for each other.
Rafi saab was a great fan of k.l.saigal saab and he even begged naushad saab to give him the opportunity to sing a line with saigal saab but still i will not say that saigal saab is a greater singer than rafi saab, only people with a particular mindset always try to say that rafi saab was greater than kishore saab, saigal saab, mukesh ji etc.
@@soorshehzadah6604 When Raffi jee entered in Bollywood sahagal was on the top and in a party Sahgal had to perform but he was absent then Raffi jee sang in his absence and people admired...Lata jee fan of Sahgal and Kishore da regard Guru to Sahgal but sahgal died only age 0f 40..In early days Kishore da used to sing in sahgal style..Sahgal was a great singer and he had good command over raags but those days raag based song was used and his carrier was very short ...
Rafi ruled the era of 1950 60 70 but due too Hajj Rafi sahab stop singing.. thats why kishore became popular.. otherwise rafi sang more songs than kishore mukesh manna day etc.. Even till th death he use to sing
@shahidImran-mn5nx aap jarur shabbir, munn aziz ke fan lagte ho. wo bhi rafi jsisehi gaate the. kishord ki baat hi alag hai. kishore is kishore none else.
Basically Rafi Sahab is a classical singer .Kishore kumar is a non- classical singer. Rafi Sahab is a God- gifted singer.He is unique and unparalleled in the history of Indian cinematic songs.He is trained specially in gazals,Bhajans,Rag sangits e.t.c. His contribution as a singer particularly in Hindi movies is highly impressive. His songs are ever melodious,memorable,unforgettable and obviously heart touching. On the other hand Kishore kumar is also a legendary figure in Hindi cinema.His achievement in singing style with tone of voice relating to the volume of expression in the varieties is ever considered .He can never be compared about his competency and potentiality with the other great singers.He is very much confident while he sings a songs by his own modulations consisting of any type. His songs are outstanding and ever lasting at the heart of the Indian people.His songs present us an essence of beauty. Both are great respectively in their own fields. We alaways hatts off to this two beloved and respected figures in regard to the Indian cinematic songs.
Both are great in their own respects.Both are peerless.Kishoreda's most favourite artist was Md Rafi&Rafi sahab respected Kishoreda for his versatility
Rafi Sahi ka tareeqa bemisal that jo variations wo late they apni awaz main amwo Kishore lagi nahi sakenge the ya koi singer isliye Kishoe ke ganon ko zyada log asani se galette hain aj tak Rafi sahib k naaz mushkil hai aksar ek hi angrezi main bhi wo variations late dijye hain.
You all say anything about Mohammed Rafi and all other Singers. They all are/were only Singers. But Kishorekumar was Allrounder and he was One in All. Kishorekumar was Multitalented artist in Hindil and All Regional Languages Therefore I always feel and consider that Kishorekumar is Unbeatable in Whole Indian Films Industries. Kishorekumar was not only Singer, but he was actor, dancer, stage performer alone and with others too. He acted with Top Heroines of his time like Vyjayantimala, Madhubala, Nutan, Shyama and many more Heroines of his time. He was producer, director and music director of his own film firm.Look at Kishorekumar's acting in Padosan and Chalti ka Naam Gaadi where Kishorekumar's acting was much much better than all other Main Actors in the films. Whatever you all say but I always feel and consider that Kishorekumar is Top Artist amongst all Indian Film Artists. He acted in many films. His dances, songs and acting was very good in Asha and so many other Films too.
@ganeshpujari1346 you are right sirji. talat was having soft, smooth, makhmai voice, king of filmi gazal. one of my favorite singers. thnx, Goodluck sir.
Manadey Mukish, Mehender Kapaoor and all music directors were firmly believed that Rafi Sahib is number one. and Kishore is very good. I believe that Rafi 1 and Kishore 2
@zubairkhan2622 rafi was totally hopeless singers for duets, funny, romantic, uchhalkud, songs. kishore is most all rounder in all rypes of songs. kishore is exceptional unmatched and incomparable in all aspects of music.
@@Araju-q7n tumhari khud ki pasand kishor Kumar hai isliye Aisa kah rahe ho warna kya tumhe nahi pata ki jo tum category Gina rahe ho aise gane sirf 70 me hi bane hai ya tumne pahli baar sirf kishor Kumar ko hi gate suna hai 70 se pahle bhi bahut se gane romantic uchal kood wale funny song bante rahe hai lakin tumne sune nahi honge Rafi sahab ki awaaz me dileep kumaar rajendra kumar jitendra Dharmendra viswjeet Sammi kapoor Sashi kapoor Sanjay khan Mahmood jony baker jo is johar joy Mukherji sabpe uchal kood wale gane hai Rafi sahab se jyada depth wale gane bhi nahi hai kisi ke
@@Araju-q7n duit me bhi Rafi sahab ki awaz sabse jyada clear hai koi kitna bhi gane bhagne ki koshish kare jaldi jaldi gaye lakin Rafi sahab ki awaaz alag hi sunayi padti hai
@zubairkhan2622 lata asha ke jitne bhi duet rafi ne gaaye, sabhi gane me rafi pura fikka, artificial feel, overfeel aur fake expression me gaata hai. kihore duets me lata asha ke takkar wala lagta hai. aise sekdo gaane hai jisme rafi ne asha ko copy karte karte feel ki maa bahan kee chhote 2/3 example yaar chulbula hai, achha ji mai chalo maan jao. hum kisise title qwali rafi ko sikhanaa hoga asha se kaisi qwali gayi jaati hai ... film Upasana, aao tume pyar sikhadoo. gori ke haath me film Mela aise unginat gaane hai bhaisahab jisme rafi ne overfeel, artificial expressions se pura irritate kiya. bhaisahab ye gaane jara sun lo properly. pataa chalega rafi kaise gaata tha. rafi gazal, sad type theek gaata tha mgar aise gaano me bilkul hopeless. kishore ka koi bhi gaana suno greatest singer all-rounder, exceptional feel expressions. sorry bhaisahab. khush raho.
Thanks for balancing and evaluating both both the legends. Both personalities are standing pilllers of hindi movie music Kishoredada and Rafisab are super
As a singer and getting trained , I would say that Rafi saheb is incomparable. There is no one currently who can meet the technicality and perfection which Rafi Saheb has contributed
Both are greats... I am personally a bigger fan of Kishore Da. But some of my favourites are Md Rafi songs. Don't be toxic fans of any of them and enjoy irreplaceable work of these legends.
Kishore da all in one the,singer,comedian director,producer,musician Lekin Rafi sahab sirf singer the aur sarvashreshtha the,wahan tak pahuchna mushkil hai.
kishore jab full time singer banke aaye 67/68 ke baad rafi ki chhuti ho gayi. rafi haaj faaj kidhar bhag gaya, barfi ka karobar chalu kiya. sabhi jagah kishore hi kidhore. kishore ka koi jod nahi tod nahi. kishore greatest singer aur farishta insaan. kishore jaisa na koi huwa naa hoga.
@shakilahmad2046 bhaisahab, rafi paida hoke bhi fayda nahi just see the history... 67/68 rafi almost disappeared from industry till death, kishore was totally captured everywhere. after 80s Similar kishore voice and style Kumar sanu ruled the music industry for around 18 years. that means 68 to 2000 kishore style singers only like some more Shaan, Babul, Abhjeet nd all dominated Bollywood. be practical and try to accept facts. Bhaisahab you like rafi, no issue, your choice but "comparison with better singer" no way bhaisahab. no personal bhaisahab. khush raho.
@@Araju-q7n Md Rafi singer hi nahi Bharat ki pahchan hain,koi aas paas bhi nahi.you forget when he bounced back and gave immortal songs in 75 to 80.It is not easy to become Rafi.Rafi has sung for kishore da also.
@@sjcwin79when we talking about versatile singer that's mean versatile singer no actor no writer no director Only about versatile singer If kishor da was then why after so many times he try to sing nafrat ki duniya ko chhod kar bur he failed Then he chose one name for this song And you know who was I think you know much better
@SAYEDSHAKEELANWARALI infact aisa koi gaana nahi jo kishore nhi gaa sakta. rafi ek hi type gata tha. kishore ka koi bhi gana ulimate hota hai. rafi ko 67/68 ke baad kaam nahi tha, kishore ne aise bahotse gaane music director kobolke rafi ko taras khake gaane ko diya. nafrat ki duniya ko usime ek hai bhaisahab. kishore no1 farishta tha. singer to kishore jaisa huwa naa hoga. no personal bhaisahab. khush raho.
Short neat well presented video and some very melodiously sung lines ……always a pleasure to meet and hear fellow music lovers of the legendary Kishoreda and Rafi saab……🙏🙏🙏
You are a true music lover and have aptly analysed singing style of these two most versatile playback singers. There have been other great male playback singer but not complete as these TWO.
When I was young I felt the songs of Kishore kumar like magnetic in the year 1972 it was lot attracting me I was ten years old I used to sing Kishore kumars song Film Tapasya it was wonderful ❤
Bhai bohot achi baat h me bhi Kishore da ke gaane sunta hu bohot acha gaate the... magar jo Rafi sahab ka level he usko ajtak koi touch bhi nahi kar paya aur nahi kar payega kyoki sadiyon tak ab koi Rafi sahab nahi ayenge ye god gifted the...
Mai dono singer ke geet Harmonium par riyaz karta dono singer apne field me master hai you are right..Raffi sahab is perfect singer and Kishore da is magician.
rafi ki awaz pichkoo. kishore ek hero ki awz ek mard ki awaz. kishore feel expressions ultimate. rafi just nothing in front of kishore undoubtedly and unarguably.
@@njscan007 sach kadwa hota hai dost, sunkar mirch kyo lagi. burnol lagaa le. ek kam karo dost tu jaha apne dimag ka ilaaj kiya us doctor ka pataa de mere bhai. rafi ko chutya bola to mai mareej kishore ko accha bola to mi zaeen ye kaunsa arithmetic hai bhai? jo sach hai woh sach hai, sari dunya jaanti hai, ab jaan le bhai too bhi. apni apni choice bhai.
Yes, you correctly pointed out that there can't be any comparison...infact, there's no need to compare at all.... both of them, along with Mukesh, Hemant Kumar, Talat Mahmood, Lata ji and Asha Ji....are all legends.... I'm saying 'are' because they continue to live through their immortal songs! ❤
Kishore Kumar had great blessing of god that during his survival he had known that he was compared with the voice which could not be surmounted by any one, the god gifted voice of Rafi Sahab
Im a senior citizen, who heard to both Rafis and Kishores songs in 1960s & 70s, when they were released. Was a big fan of Kishores songs when young. Now a days, old Hindi songs imply Rafi and only Rafi. Been humming Guides song TERE MERE SAPNE, for the last week and half.
किशोर दा , एक ऐसे महान फनकार , जिन्होंने कभी भी किसी से सिंगिंग की ट्रेनिंग नही ली थी , इसके बावजूद भी वो अपने दौर में हमेशा टॉप पे रहे ,, सबसे ज्यादा 8 बार बेस्ट प्लेबैक सिंगर का अवार्ड , सबसे ज्यादा 28 नॉमिनेटेड , सबसे ज्यादा हिट परसेंटेज सॉन्ग्स ,, दादा जैसा फनकार इस धरती पे दोबारा पैदा होना मुश्किल ही नहीं नामुमकिन है , अब कहने को चाहे कोई कुछ भी कहता रहे ,, मिस यू दादा 😢😢😢😢
किशोर ने एक भी क्लासिक कल गाने नहीं गाए और रफी साहब ने जितने भी गाने गाये है तो ऐसा लगता है जैसे वही हीरो गा रहा है वह बात किशोर में नहीं थी सो किंग आंफ दा रफी साहब।
गायकी के हिसाब से रफी साहब किशोर कुमार से बढ़कर थे। संगीत कोमल व मधुर हो तो ही वह श्रेष्ठ है जिससे मनुष्य भाव विभोर होकर आन्तरिक शान्ति पाता है। मधुरता व कोमलता स्वरों के साथ आवाज में भी हो तो गीत मन की गहराईयो को छू लेता है। इस मामले मे रफी साहब का पलडा भारी पडता है।
This is a question that I'm facing for years from Srilanka. I think Rafi is the best. But, Kishore too is very close. But, Rafi is far ahead. Tribute to both. My best songs, Baharo pool barsa( Rafi) , Pal Pal Dil ( Kishore)❤❤
@srijibmondal4045 , kya bolta hain aap, mujhe ko hindi aur urdu ata hain, aap to hindi bolta hain lagta hain kie tum ghane nahin samajta ho gha, jane kie sabhie ghane eek Hindi aur Urdu kie mizaal hain...
Even KK was a big fan of Rafi saab. He admired Rafi ji forever. Only fools do comparisons. I think both are goat singers. Rafi Saab is the Sun & Kishore da is the Moon. Both have their own charm, grace & versatility. I love both ❤️
Nd rafi was trained but kishore sang in the modern music rafi song more in old music which was little boring but kishore sing modern entertaining songs with rd burman and laxmi kant pyarelal
@Tarun Kumar log dash ho Gaye the aur dash hote Jaa rahe hai. Ye duniya apne patan ki aur Jaa rahi hai. isiliye logo ko new-new voice chahiye tha jisse unko entertainment mile that's why Kishore Kumar emerged as an eminent personality since the Great Mohammad Rafi Sahab stopped giving his voice due to the rules of the Islamic faiths. And one can easily see that people of now are nowhere closer to the people of 50's,60's,70's. Not today's music is of that level nor the singers are of that level.
@@vedantyadav00 but i feel kishore was has vibration no doubt rafi is massive singer but till 60s music was not so good after 60s rafi songs were good but in 1969 kishore kumar came and dominated were people already know who is mohammad rafi i like mohammad rafi songs after 70s which was top hit but kishore is legend he didn't learn music from anybody u can see the video of lata mangeskar no singer can do yoodling how kishore kumar do and how kishore sang aaankhein seedi lagi dil pe ooo sawariyaaa song in two voices he has unique talent which makes him different singer ek chatur naar karke singaar these are the songs which are very difficult only kishore kumar and manna dey sang this that is the reason kishore is legend
Rafi sang every kind of song. The nuances Rafi brought in his voice were matchless. The range Rafi displayed was unique. Rafi is certainly the better of the two. We also love many Kishore numbers. But we know that Rafi was hundred out of hundred.
Both were Diamonds of same qeeraat ,if one is purplish plnk the other was pinkish purple so no comparison could be done.both were legends RIP.❤️ from🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Rafisaab is the apple of my right eye and Kishore da is the apple of my left eye and they are both great legends on their own I can never compare them with each other or with any other singers (Period)
Yessssssss 👌👍
I'm proud of you 🙏🙏🙏
Amazing explanation ali sahib 🙏🙏🙏
This is a strawmen argument to hide flaws of kishore
70s tak koi compare hi nhi Tha baad me young generation ko doom dharaka chahiye Tha Jo ki Kishore Kumar gaate the over all versatile me rafi ,Lata se kisi ka koi compresion nhi hai classical singer ke samne yeh log kuch nhi hai
रफी साहेब और किशोर दा एक दुसरी करिबी दोस्त थे और एक दुसररे कि बहोत izzat किया करते थे 👍🙏🏻
दोनो भी ग्रेट सिंगर थे 👍
Of course Mohammad Rafi Sahab 🙏🌺 as per voice & classical understanding
Both are good but RAFI SAHEB TAKES AN EDGE OVER .
Both are great, lekin rafi sb's voice innocence is unmatchable
Kishore da is god of singing ❤
😂😂😂😂
Rqfi shaab ka pehar bhi nhi he
Rafi saheb is the benchmark for playback singing..Pure and divine passing through the mind and staying in heart...
K.L Sehgal was benchmark for all Legendary Singers.
All Legendary Singers like Mukesh,hemant kumar, Kishore Kumar, Lata Mangeshkar,Asha Bhosle & Rafi used To copy him.
@@rishabhadarsh5227 yes you're right but it should be corrected latter never copied K.L. Sehgal instead Mukesh's "Dil jalta hai toh Jalne de aasoo na baha fariyaad na kar" was alike copied!
@@rishabhadarsh5227no bro md Rafi never copied anyone he is the best in every category of singing
@@NINJAGMR124 initially he used to copy k.l.sehgal so are other lengends like kishore, hemant,Mukesh,lata & asha.
Because that tym Sehgal style of singing was in trend & producer used to force singers to sing like him
@@rishabhadarsh5227 there is difference between copying and getting inspired bro
Both are excellent
Both are incomparable
We love both
no, not both.
kishore is far far superior than rafi undoubtedly and unarguably.
kishore jsise naa koi huwa naa hoga.
rafi is ok but kishore on the top of music world always.
@@Araju-q7n tu jyada janta hai bey! Rafi Saab ko Ok singer bata rha h..!
@@Kkp-tl1nq accha accha to too rafi ke baareme kya jaanta hai?
@@Kkp-tl1nq rafi acchha hai magar kishore ke samne ok ok.
Even Kishore Da was a fan of Rafi sb, Rafi sb's range and the Sweetness and Uniqueness of voice style generated by himself.... Makes him the most versatile singer, and greatest of all the time. 🙏😊
Raffi sahab was also fan of Kishore da ..He used to tell sher to Kishore da..Mera sher aayega to sab ke awaz dab jayegi...Both has respect for each other.
Rafi saab was a great fan of k.l.saigal saab and he even begged naushad saab to give him the opportunity to sing a line with saigal saab but still i will not say that saigal saab is a greater singer than rafi saab, only people with a particular mindset always try to say that rafi saab was greater than kishore saab, saigal saab, mukesh ji etc.
@@soorshehzadah6604 When Raffi jee entered in Bollywood sahagal was on the top and in a party Sahgal had to perform but he was absent then Raffi jee sang in his absence and people admired...Lata jee fan of Sahgal and Kishore da regard Guru to Sahgal but sahgal died only age 0f 40..In early days Kishore da used to sing in sahgal style..Sahgal was a great singer and he had good command over raags but those days raag based song was used and his carrier was very short ...
The expressions of Rafi Sahab voice are unmatched even today. Rightly said, he was the most versatile and complete singer till date. Jai Rafi Sahab
Rafi ruled the era of 1950 60 70 but due too Hajj Rafi sahab stop singing.. thats why kishore became popular.. otherwise rafi sang more songs than kishore mukesh manna day etc.. Even till th death he use to sing
Only and one
Great Rafi Sahab❤
Kishore Kumar zindabad
By every conceivable yardstick, Rafi Sahab is light years ahead of all his contemporaries..
I FULLY AGREE ... !
There is no comparison with Rafi Sahab whatsoever.. full stop!! Kishor Kumar is great singer in his own way..
Rafi sahab ki awaaz to farishte ki awaz hai , baaki saare to insaano jaisi hi hai.
Absolutely , Kishore was limited singer. Not only Rafi but Talat , Mana dey were also better than Kishore.
@@russelindia THAT'S GENIOUS OF YE TO'VE REMARKED LIKE THAT ... !
Who are we to compare between the legends when Kishore Kumar was the greatest fan of Md Rafi?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Rafi was also greatest fan of Universe singer Kishore Da.
Bilkul. We are just fans and can only have our personal liking. Nobody here is qualified enough to decide who was better.
@@Kishore_108😂😂 aap zaroor honey Singh ke fan ho
@shahidImran-mn5nx aap jarur shabbir, munn aziz ke fan lagte ho. wo bhi rafi jsisehi gaate the.
kishord ki baat hi alag hai.
kishore is
kishore none else.
No comparison, Rafis voice is something absolutely pure and unbelievable. Who doesn't how to enjoy music is doing this comparison,
I love Kishor songs picturised on Dev Anand the most. Golden Songs
Basically Rafi Sahab is a classical singer .Kishore kumar is a non- classical singer.
Rafi Sahab is a God- gifted singer.He is unique and unparalleled in the history of Indian cinematic songs.He is trained specially in gazals,Bhajans,Rag sangits e.t.c. His contribution as a singer particularly in Hindi movies is highly impressive. His songs are ever melodious,memorable,unforgettable and obviously heart touching.
On the other hand Kishore kumar is also a legendary figure in Hindi cinema.His achievement in singing style with tone of voice relating to the volume of expression in the varieties is ever considered .He can never be compared about his competency and potentiality with the other great singers.He is very much confident while he sings a songs by his own modulations consisting of any type.
His songs are outstanding and ever lasting at the heart of the Indian people.His songs present us an essence of beauty.
Both are great respectively in their own fields.
We alaways hatts off to this two beloved and respected figures in regard to the Indian cinematic songs.
Rafi is not much trained singer but he has got amazing voice. no comparison required!!
Rafi sahab jaisa koi na to aaya hai aur na hi kabhi aayega ❤❤❤@@shancg1
rufi chicha takla useless
@@vilasshriram9851 ghanta Baja ja mandir ka😂
Kishore कडक मर्दाना अावाज तिखी🎻और रफी soft नवजवॉ आवाज जज्बाती🎻
Both no 1
Both are great in their own respects.Both are peerless.Kishoreda's most favourite artist was Md Rafi&Rafi sahab respected Kishoreda for his versatility
Dard e dil dard e jigar mein bohat kadak aawaz m gaya hai Rafi sahab ne
Shahenshah-e-tarannum Best singer of millennium "Md Rafi" sahab...
Absolutely 💯💯💯
Not only him even Kishor da is good
Kishore Da the Kinggggg
तुम भी लानती हि हो
Rafi Sahi ka tareeqa bemisal that jo variations wo late they apni awaz main amwo Kishore lagi nahi sakenge the ya koi singer isliye Kishoe ke ganon ko zyada log asani se galette hain aj tak Rafi sahib k naaz mushkil hai aksar ek hi angrezi main bhi wo variations late dijye hain.
You all say anything about Mohammed Rafi and all other Singers. They all are/were only Singers. But Kishorekumar was Allrounder and he was One in All. Kishorekumar was Multitalented artist in Hindil and All Regional Languages
Therefore I always feel and consider that Kishorekumar is Unbeatable in Whole Indian Films Industries.
Kishorekumar was not only Singer, but he was actor, dancer, stage performer alone and with others too. He acted with Top Heroines of his time like Vyjayantimala, Madhubala, Nutan, Shyama and many more Heroines of his time.
He was producer, director and music director of his own film firm.Look at Kishorekumar's acting in Padosan and Chalti ka Naam Gaadi where Kishorekumar's acting was much much better than all other Main Actors in the films. Whatever you all say but I always feel and consider that Kishorekumar is Top Artist amongst all Indian Film Artists.
He acted in many films. His dances, songs and acting was very good in Asha and so many other Films too.
Kishore da ka jaisa itna sara hit gaana koi singer nahi diya
You are wrong
4000 filmi hindi songs
Just 150 good songs
@@tariqsiddiqi7964 galat baat,saare gaane hit hai kishore da ke,konse gaane uske hit nahi hai batao to aapko maan jaau.
Tujhe pata bhi hai bas muslim hai tu to Rafi ko support kar raha hai 😅 pagal Rafi ji aas pass bhi nahi the Kishore Kumar ke @@tariqsiddiqi7964
@@tariqsiddiqi7964 means 4000 me se 150 song hit ,to 3850 flop song konse hai bata zara,
Tum jo mil gaye ho
Is one of the masterpieces by Rafi sir 🎉🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yes, excellent song.
@@manoj_agr Thanks for the video sir 🙏🙏🙏
Baitho na dur hamse dekho khafa na ho, kismat se mil gye ho milke juda na ho.....
Dekha ek khwaab toh ye silsiley hue
Kishore da
Md rafi sb. Ki makhmali awaz ki tulna kisi se nahi ho sakti rafi sb god gift they
makhmali awaz to ladkiyoki hoti hai bhaisahab. rafi makhmali??
kishore ek mard ki awaz ek hero ki awaz,
voice kishore jaisi ho.
Makmali aawaj ke maalik to
Talat Mahmood sahab te
@ganeshpujari1346 you are right sirji. talat was having soft, smooth, makhmai voice, king of filmi gazal. one of my favorite singers.
thnx, Goodluck sir.
makmal se farsh saf karte 😅😅😅. taklu chichaa gata Kam rota Jada tha
They are two of my fav singers … both were amazing in their own way. 🙏❤️
Manadey Mukish, Mehender Kapaoor and all music directors were firmly believed that Rafi Sahib is number one. and Kishore is very good. I believe that Rafi 1 and Kishore 2
Mohammed Rafi sahab very nice super
Rafi saab could sing classical songs effortlessly. Greatest singer of all times.
Classical ke alawa dusre style ke gane bahut badi tadat me bade bade actors ke liye gaya hai iske alawa har artist ko apni awaz di jab tak hayat rahe
@zubairkhan2622 rafi was totally hopeless singers for duets, funny, romantic, uchhalkud, songs.
kishore is most all rounder in all rypes of songs.
kishore is exceptional unmatched and incomparable in all aspects of music.
@@Araju-q7n tumhari khud ki pasand kishor Kumar hai isliye Aisa kah rahe ho warna kya tumhe nahi pata ki jo tum category Gina rahe ho aise gane sirf 70 me hi bane hai ya tumne pahli baar sirf kishor Kumar ko hi gate suna hai 70 se pahle bhi bahut se gane romantic uchal kood wale funny song bante rahe hai lakin tumne sune nahi honge Rafi sahab ki awaaz me dileep kumaar rajendra kumar jitendra Dharmendra viswjeet Sammi kapoor Sashi kapoor Sanjay khan Mahmood jony baker jo is johar joy Mukherji sabpe uchal kood wale gane hai Rafi sahab se jyada depth wale gane bhi nahi hai kisi ke
@@Araju-q7n duit me bhi Rafi sahab ki awaz sabse jyada clear hai koi kitna bhi gane bhagne ki koshish kare jaldi jaldi gaye lakin Rafi sahab ki awaaz alag hi sunayi padti hai
@zubairkhan2622 lata asha ke jitne bhi duet rafi ne gaaye, sabhi gane me rafi pura fikka, artificial feel, overfeel aur fake expression me gaata hai.
kihore duets me lata asha ke takkar wala lagta hai.
aise sekdo gaane hai jisme rafi ne asha ko copy karte karte feel ki maa bahan kee chhote 2/3 example yaar chulbula hai,
achha ji mai chalo maan jao.
hum kisise title qwali rafi ko sikhanaa hoga asha se kaisi qwali gayi jaati hai ...
film Upasana, aao tume pyar sikhadoo.
gori ke haath me film Mela
aise unginat gaane hai bhaisahab jisme rafi ne overfeel, artificial expressions se pura irritate kiya.
bhaisahab ye gaane jara sun lo properly.
pataa chalega rafi kaise gaata tha.
rafi gazal, sad type theek gaata tha mgar aise gaano me bilkul hopeless.
kishore ka koi bhi gaana suno greatest singer all-rounder, exceptional feel expressions.
sorry bhaisahab.
khush raho.
Mohd.Rafi is the great in the world.
Thanks for balancing and evaluating both both the legends. Both personalities are standing pilllers of hindi movie music Kishoredada and Rafisab are super
Sabhi ki apni apni khasiyat hain,koi kisi SE kam nahi. Sabhi great singers hain.so no comparison pl🙏
As a singer and getting trained , I would say that Rafi saheb is incomparable. There is no one currently who can meet the technicality and perfection which Rafi Saheb has contributed
Both are greats...
I am personally a bigger fan of Kishore Da.
But some of my favourites are Md Rafi songs.
Don't be toxic fans of any of them and enjoy irreplaceable work of these legends.
Fans like you are rare to find. I am a Rafi who has immense love and respect for Kishore.
*The great personality of Mohammad Rafi is above Bollywood and also above Dada Saheb Palke Award.*
*The voice of Mohammad Rafi is A School of Acting.*
Faltu bakwaz mat kar. Writing in bold fonts do not make something more meaningful. Clown
Both are greatest and incomparable...they have generated different taste of music
I’m totally agree with you sir🙏🙏🙏
Thank you sir for this video. I revisited all the songs you mentioned. It was the best of both worlds ❤
Both are amazing 🎉Their way of singing is totally different but equally impressive 🙏
Chingari koi bhadke is my fav Kishore song
Kishore da all in one the,singer,comedian director,producer,musician Lekin Rafi sahab sirf singer the aur sarvashreshtha the,wahan tak pahuchna mushkil hai.
kishore jab full time singer banke aaye 67/68 ke baad rafi ki chhuti ho gayi. rafi haaj faaj kidhar bhag gaya, barfi ka karobar chalu kiya. sabhi jagah kishore hi kidhore.
kishore ka koi jod nahi tod nahi.
kishore greatest singer aur farishta insaan.
kishore jaisa na koi huwa naa hoga.
@@Araju-q7n Bhasha theek karo,maine kishore da ki tareef hi ki hai,Lekin Rafi koi paida nahi hoga.
@@shakilahmad2046 bhasha aisihi hai, aap samz rahe ho mai kya likh raha hun, itna kaafi hai bhaisahab
@shakilahmad2046 bhaisahab, rafi paida hoke bhi fayda nahi just see the history...
67/68 rafi almost disappeared from industry till death, kishore was totally captured everywhere.
after 80s Similar kishore voice and style Kumar sanu
ruled the music industry for around 18 years.
that means 68 to 2000 kishore style singers only like some more Shaan, Babul, Abhjeet nd all dominated Bollywood.
be practical and try to accept facts.
Bhaisahab you like rafi, no issue, your choice but "comparison with better singer" no way bhaisahab.
no personal bhaisahab.
khush raho.
@@Araju-q7n Md Rafi singer hi nahi Bharat ki pahchan hain,koi aas paas bhi nahi.you forget when he bounced back and gave immortal songs in 75 to 80.It is not easy to become Rafi.Rafi has sung for kishore da also.
Rafi shab and kishor da both
Great singer
There are 2 types of singers, one is Kishore Kumar n 2 is others
Both greats but if there is an award then it would go to Rafi
Very nice unbiased Analysis of two legends
Rafi.sahab had some beautiful traditional Geets and Gazals to his credit ,u missed to mention this talent in Rafi sahab's singing.
You don't know what is called 'Versatile' , Versatile means they have many talents in many fields not only own fields, Kishore Kumar was that person
@@sjcwin79when we talking about versatile singer that's mean versatile singer no actor no writer no director
Only about versatile singer
If kishor da was then why after so many times he try to sing nafrat ki duniya ko chhod kar bur he failed
Then he chose one name for this song
And you know who was
I think you know much better
@@SAYEDSHAKEELANWARALI सारंगा तेरी याद में रफ़ी नहीं गा पाये थे तब मुकेश ने गाया।
@SAYEDSHAKEELANWARALI infact aisa koi gaana nahi jo kishore nhi gaa sakta. rafi ek hi type gata tha.
kishore ka koi bhi gana ulimate hota hai.
rafi ko 67/68 ke baad kaam nahi tha, kishore ne aise bahotse gaane music director kobolke rafi ko taras khake gaane ko diya.
nafrat ki duniya ko usime ek hai bhaisahab.
kishore no1 farishta tha.
singer to kishore jaisa huwa naa hoga.
no personal bhaisahab.
khush raho.
Mohammad Rafi had the Most Perfect and the best male Playback Singer voice. Itni clear And perfect voice aaj tak nahi aayi na Kabhi aayegi
Short neat well presented video and some very melodiously sung lines ……always a pleasure to meet and hear fellow music lovers of the legendary Kishoreda and Rafi saab……🙏🙏🙏
Rafi saab sang for Kishore da
There is no match for rafi sb. His voice is voice of God. His voice was soulful
❤️🙏
Rafisahab ke flim biju bawara ke sare geet, flim dosti ke sare geet, jis ki koi misal nahi.
Ji bilkul. Film guide, ram aur Shyam, bambai ka babu, teesri manzil... anginat anmol geet. And my most favorite "yeh ishq ishq hai" qawwali.
Well explained, Sir🙏🏼❤️. God bless you 🙌. I'll continue listening to both until the end of my time. Stay positive and golden doston 💛.
With due respect to Kishore Da, Rafi saab is incomparable
Same can be said otherwise. That's the beauty of this discussion.
@@asyouwish9641 your Kishore da is nowhere near Rafi saab
You are a true music lover and have aptly analysed singing style of these two most versatile playback singers. There have been other great male playback singer but not complete as these TWO.
East or west Rafi sahab is the world's best👍
There is no comparison with RAFI SAAB nobody even MALE and female singers OF all time till today and after till this industry remains
There is only singer who is worshipped in UK and US...Lata Mangeskar
Don't mention female singer ok..
Kishor da was genius, he sang too greatly. Where as Rafi Saheb's voice is God's own voice, both are unmatched.
Mohammed RAFI SAHAB and Mokesh sahab all the time the best ever. 🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹💐🌹
Great mukesh
When I was young I felt the songs of Kishore kumar like magnetic in the year 1972 it was lot attracting me I was ten years old I used to sing Kishore kumars song Film Tapasya it was wonderful ❤
Rafi sahab is divine ❤️
Absolutely.
One and only one Rafi sahab no one can take place of Rafi sahab
Sir you explained very well ❤...
Thanks for this beautiful explanation.
I loved your singing.
❤🙏🙏
Thank you 😊
Kishore Kumar is god of Singing. ❤
Rafi saheb voice of God
@@SandeepBhattacharyyarafi voice female like
@@asyouwish9641go back to womb, your birth is a mistake
Rafi sahab acche singer the, but kishore da is my dearest singer❤
Bhai bohot achi baat h me bhi Kishore da ke gaane sunta hu bohot acha gaate the... magar jo Rafi sahab ka level he usko ajtak koi touch bhi nahi kar paya aur nahi kar payega kyoki sadiyon tak ab koi Rafi sahab nahi ayenge ye god gifted the...
Mai dono singer ke geet Harmonium par riyaz karta dono singer apne field me master hai you are right..Raffi sahab is perfect singer and Kishore da is magician.
Ek gana hai,
Tum bin jaau kaha....
Iske 4 version hai aur chaaro version bahut behtreen hai. Zaroor sune.
Ji haan bilkul. Bahut achcha example hai Kishore da aur Rafi sahab ki approach samajhne ke liye. 👍
Rafi sahab ❤
Kishore Kumar's quality is popularity and Mohammad Rafi's quality is his perfect performance!
But Before 1969 😂😅
Rafi sab ki bht alag hai na rafi sab jesa awaz ta na hai or na kabi hoga ❤❤❤Rafi sab ❤❤❤
Rafi sab ki bht alag hai na rafi sab jesa awaz ta na hai na rahiga ❤❤❤
Only Rafi
rafi ki awaz pichkoo. kishore ek hero ki awz ek mard ki awaz.
kishore feel expressions ultimate.
rafi just nothing in front of kishore undoubtedly and unarguably.
@@Araju-q7n: tera dimaag check kar jaake. Tu zehni mareez hai.
@@njscan007 sach kadwa hota hai dost, sunkar mirch kyo lagi.
burnol lagaa le.
ek kam karo dost tu jaha apne dimag ka ilaaj kiya us doctor ka pataa de mere bhai.
rafi ko chutya bola to mai mareej kishore ko accha bola to mi zaeen ye kaunsa arithmetic hai bhai? jo sach hai woh sach hai, sari dunya jaanti hai, ab jaan le bhai too bhi. apni apni choice bhai.
@@Araju-q7n : Rafi Sahab ki popularity sab se upar hai. Tu poora Burnol ka can istemaal kar le. Haqeeqat badalne wali nahi hai.
No Singer Can Ever Touch The Dust Of Great Rafi Sahib Foot
Yes, you correctly pointed out that there can't be any comparison...infact, there's no need to compare at all.... both of them, along with Mukesh, Hemant Kumar, Talat Mahmood, Lata ji and Asha Ji....are all legends.... I'm saying 'are' because they continue to live through their immortal songs! ❤
My favourite Kishore Kumar
What a lovely post. I quite agree. And you sang so well. Thank you.
We should be proud of having these two Great voices to cherish and their songs to remember them by.
No one can touch Md Rafi in singing
Both were the priceless pearls ❤❤❤
Kishore Kumar had great blessing of god that during his survival he had known that he was compared with the voice which could not be surmounted by any one, the god gifted voice of Rafi Sahab
Very well said.. Both are All-time Greatest.. Both Rafi sahib and Kishore da are close to my heart. Amazing singers❤❤
Kishore Kumar legend❤❤❤❤
Duniya ke rakh wale
Sirf aur sirf rafi sahab gay sake the
Bilkul!
@@manoj_agr Thanks for reply
Im a senior citizen, who heard to both Rafis and Kishores songs in 1960s & 70s, when they were released. Was a big fan of Kishores songs when young. Now a days, old Hindi songs imply Rafi and only Rafi. Been humming Guides song TERE MERE SAPNE, for the last week and half.
Mukesh is the greatest❤
Best analysis up to now. Great job sir ❤🌹🙏
Thank you 😊
Rafi sahab is the best singer in the world..
How do you know ? Do you have slightest knowledge about music and musicians of whole world ?
किशोर दा , एक ऐसे महान फनकार , जिन्होंने कभी भी किसी से सिंगिंग की ट्रेनिंग नही ली थी , इसके बावजूद भी वो अपने दौर में हमेशा टॉप पे रहे ,, सबसे ज्यादा 8 बार बेस्ट प्लेबैक सिंगर का अवार्ड , सबसे ज्यादा 28 नॉमिनेटेड , सबसे ज्यादा हिट परसेंटेज सॉन्ग्स ,, दादा जैसा फनकार इस धरती पे दोबारा पैदा होना मुश्किल ही नहीं नामुमकिन है , अब कहने को चाहे कोई कुछ भी कहता रहे ,, मिस यू दादा 😢😢😢😢
किशोर ने एक भी क्लासिक कल गाने नहीं गाए और रफी साहब ने जितने भी गाने गाये है तो ऐसा लगता है जैसे वही हीरो गा रहा है वह बात किशोर में नहीं थी सो किंग आंफ दा रफी साहब।
@@sarfukhan1441I can understand your pain just by reading your name
गायकी के हिसाब से रफी साहब किशोर कुमार से बढ़कर थे। संगीत कोमल व मधुर हो तो ही वह श्रेष्ठ है जिससे मनुष्य भाव विभोर होकर आन्तरिक शान्ति पाता है। मधुरता व कोमलता स्वरों के साथ आवाज में भी हो तो गीत मन की गहराईयो को छू लेता है। इस मामले मे रफी साहब का पलडा भारी पडता है।
क्या रफ़ी ने ही कोमल वा मधुर गीत गए हैं किशोर दा से इतनी नफ़रत वो भी बिना रिसर्च किये। 😂😂
Komal aur madhur ke sath agar awaaz mein mardanagi ho to wo singer ka koi mukabla nahi,bhari awaaz mein Sur mein rehna bahot mushkil hai.
Very nice explanation sir ,your voice is very good also
Thank you 😊
I dont know how to describe how much I'm in love with Rafi sahab and kishore sahab voices and songs
This is a question that I'm facing for years from Srilanka. I think Rafi is the best. But, Kishore too is very close. But, Rafi is far ahead. Tribute to both. My best songs, Baharo pool barsa( Rafi) , Pal Pal Dil ( Kishore)❤❤
Aap ko hindi aate hain?? Do u understand hindi?
@@srijibmondal4045 little bit. But i enjoy the music
@@ssdissanayaka8049 sinhala hindi language is very close relative each other both of them are origins from sanskrit but tamil is quite different
@srijibmondal4045 , kya bolta hain aap, mujhe ko hindi aur urdu ata hain, aap to hindi bolta hain lagta hain kie tum ghane nahin samajta ho gha, jane kie sabhie ghane eek Hindi aur Urdu kie mizaal hain...
Every singer has his/her own good style no need to compare one with others. Just enjoy listening to them.
Best comments, I agree with you, respect and love from Kishor da fan, from Karachi, Pakistan
We can't compare Rafi sahab with any other singer. He was a legends legend. He was Masters Master.
बहुत बढ़िया विशलेषण,धन्यवाद।
Very sweet voice hai aapki, songs per aapki itni knowledge dekh Kar Khushi Hui,
Even KK was a big fan of Rafi saab. He admired Rafi ji forever. Only fools do comparisons. I think both are goat singers. Rafi Saab is the Sun & Kishore da is the Moon. Both have their own charm, grace & versatility. I love both ❤️
WTF ?? KISHORE ADMIRED SEHGAL
BHAI DIL PE HATH RAKH KE KAHO ❤❤❤ RAFI SAAB SE BADA KOI NAHI ❤❤❤❤❤ LATA KISHORE MUKESH MANADE ETC ETC
Dono hi Greatest Singers hai 👌👌
God of singing Rafi sahab❤
Bohat badhia vishleshn ❤
Rafi sahab was a legend and the greatest.Manna dey said in an interview that “ jo rafi sahab kar sakte hain wo hum bhi nahi kar sakte”
Nd rafi was trained but kishore sang in the modern music rafi song more in old music which was little boring but kishore sing modern entertaining songs with rd burman and laxmi kant pyarelal
@@TarunKumar-hl3fzhahaha kn log ho tum
@Tarun Kumar log dash ho Gaye the aur dash hote Jaa rahe hai. Ye duniya apne patan ki aur Jaa rahi hai. isiliye logo ko new-new voice chahiye tha jisse unko entertainment mile that's why Kishore Kumar emerged as an eminent personality since the Great Mohammad Rafi Sahab stopped giving his voice due to the rules of the Islamic faiths. And one can easily see that people of now are nowhere closer to the people of 50's,60's,70's. Not today's music is of that level nor the singers are of that level.
@@vedantyadav00 but i feel kishore was has vibration no doubt rafi is massive singer but till 60s music was not so good after 60s rafi songs were good but in 1969 kishore kumar came and dominated were people already know who is mohammad rafi i like mohammad rafi songs after 70s which was top hit but kishore is legend he didn't learn music from anybody u can see the video of lata mangeskar no singer can do yoodling how kishore kumar do and how kishore sang aaankhein seedi lagi dil pe ooo sawariyaaa song in two voices he has unique talent which makes him different singer ek chatur naar karke singaar these are the songs which are very difficult only kishore kumar and manna dey sang this that is the reason kishore is legend
KING SINGER MUHAMMAD RAFI AND QUEEN SINGER LATA JI.
Rafi sang every kind of song. The nuances Rafi brought in his voice were matchless. The range Rafi displayed was unique. Rafi is certainly the better of the two.
We also love many Kishore numbers. But we know that Rafi was hundred out of hundred.
Both were Diamonds of same qeeraat ,if one is purplish plnk the other was pinkish purple so no comparison could be done.both were legends RIP.❤️ from🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳