to me one of the best movies ever PERIOD. the level of empathy it has for all of its characters is so beautiful. i'm an artist and have struggled with deep depression, and saw myself (from the past thankfully) so deeply in colm that the first time i watched it i almost couldn't finish it. i think it tells a very dark truth about despair and mental illness that can get glossed over in art, which is how it can ruin the way you experience other people and their average everyday niceness and companionship
This movie did not resonate with me, personally, but I am glad you were able to find something in it that spoke to you. Reading your take helped me see how that is possible. (I had a similar experience with Everything Everywhere All At Once. Some people dismissed the film as trash, but man did I identify on a deep level with the characters/messages.) All our past experiences shape how we view and experience everything after, film included. When we see something of ourselves or something we “know” in someone else’s art… it’s a powerful, affirming thing. Great that you found that in Banshees! Thanks for sharing your perspective!
@@chrissiereacts after your reactions to this and In Bruges, I feel compelled to recommend Grand Budapest Hotel for a future reaction. It’s not really related, but I think based on your appreciation for these movies you will love it.
This is an allegory of the Irish Civil War (which is taking place in the background). I'd recommend watching some interviews with Martin McDonagh in which he talks a lot about the film.
I'd also recommend a video by you tuber Jake Bishop explaining the parallels with the war along with documentary footage and clips from the films Michael Collins and The Wind that shakes the Barley.
@@stefanforrer2573I’ve read that early to mid 20th century western Ireland was thought to have the highest rate of schizophrenia in the world. More studies revealed it was a combination of bachelordom, loneliness & alcoholism.
Watching someone else's reaction to this film was great, as I was utterly devastated after seeing it! I found it so painful and I haven't been so affected by a film in a long time. I have since watched and listened to countless analysis of this film. It's utterly brilliant and the connection to the Irish civil war just makes it so much more powerful.
I’ve disconnected with some friends cold heartedly but felt the pain deep down. This film was a huge awakening for me to prep for those toughest moments down the road.
The old woman was a banshee "banshee, supernatural being in Irish and other Celtic folklore. At night was believed to foretell the death of a member of the family of the person who heard the spirit."
Most of McDonaghs films dont end with a clear resolution, but the final scene i think means colm and padraig are now enemies. The end is the beginning of a true feud
This movie was made in amazing fashion. Any movie with these 2 leads is a must watch. I see you watched In Bruges. Ill check that next. This is a great film with a phenomenal backstory.
Barry Keoghan got beat up on a night out while filming the movie, they had to change the script so his dad beat him in the movie because they couldn't cover his injuries and only had so many days to film.
Great film. Doesn't have to fit into any categories for me. I laughed and despaired both. As you've watched this and In Bruges, try the director's 3 Billboards.
I've been waiting for a long time for someone to post a reaction to "Banshee")) A masterpiece, this film continues to remain in my memory for a year now and constantly touches me. No one is right or wrong, it’s difficult to “give roles” to the characters, it’s painfully reminiscent of real life cases (except for the fingers ;) ) It’s interesting - as Podrick’s “fall” progresses, animals increasingly enter his house. At first his sister doesn’t let them in, and when she leaves, the cow is already lying inside the house with him. In theory, this symbolizes hell - living alone among animals. Are cut off fingers a human sacrifice to become immortal in art? Pain that is necessary for creativity? Was it worth it in the end? Or is this a metaphor for the fact that without simple connections between people (without fingers) there is no art? God knows, this movie doesn't care)) The character of Barry Keoghan is most touching - when he says - well, this dream is gone, and then he declares that he still has things to do somewhere out there: only after watching you understand what kind of things - to drown himself, because there is more hope it was gone, the last one collapsed. It's harsh.
I'm glad I was able to deliver 😄 Do you think him cutting off his fingers also meant he could no longer hide behind the idea that it was Padraic that was holding him back? He talks about being one of the greats and how he wants to be remembered for his music. Instead of an ear he chose his fingers.
@@chrissiereacts Perhaps, partly. He blames Padraic for this, but it is not he who is holding him back, but something inside Colm himself. Where else could the idea of self-harm come from? I also think that the cut off fingers give significance to his intention to devote himself to music, such a psychological mechanism. Most likely, he realizes that he will no longer become the second Mozart. Maybe that’s why at the end he cuts off all the remaining 4 - after that you won’t be able to play: that’s it, now Padraic is definitely to blame, but for himself Colm can say - I did everything possible, even went to extreme measures, but they literally didn’t let me . Subconsciously, at least. - Maybe Colm will even find peace after the finale. Without fingers, without a friend, accidentally killing a donkey (being stubborn like a donkey, huh). But Siobhán escaped from this madness, but she, too, was wondering whether to drown herself. Well, damn sad for Padraic. - Of course, if you look at it from the point of view of psychiatry, then this is a direct diagnosis ;) But I would like to perceive this more theatrically, otherwise it turns out too dark. It will be great if you see the rest of both McDonagh brothers ;)
I think the symbolism behind the cutting of the fingers is how we self mutilated our selves and ideals during the civil war in Ireland during the early 20th century. I love how you are able to further explore it as a symbol for the human condition. Nice interpretations. I love it
I’ve read that in the early to mid 20th century, the west of Ireland was thought to have the greatest rate of schizophrenia in the world. Later studies revealed it was a combination of high rates of bachelordom, loneliness & alcoholism.
It was a very good film discussing depression and how it can destroy lives with something simple as friendship. It is described as dark comedy but it had very few funny moments. It was brilliantly acted, and beautifully filmed. I really liked it but it was a darn serious film. Now the other Gleeson/Farrell film-in Bruges was very, very funny
The whole movie is an allegory for the irish civil war (which you can seee transpiring on the mainland in background scenes) and how people who would've normally been best mates would've been fighting against each other regarding us not getting the 6 counties in the north
The Banshees of Inisheherin really reminds me of times n people past , of drinking pochine and the love between two friends, we're smalltalk is what really holds people to feckin gether and if this doesn't win Awards by the bucketload then there's no point or place in films no longer, By the way wouldn't every boy love a woman like Siobhan to consider falling in love with ...
I hope to see a first time reaction to Jaws (1975) and Alligator (1980) and Tremors (1990) the greatest creature feature movies ever created and The Thing (1982) and Alien (1979) and The Shining (1980) the greatest horror movies ever created and Aliens (1986) the greatest sci-fi action and horror movie as well:).
Colm hates himself. Past his fifties. He knows he will never be remembered as a musician. He has too much pride. He was looking for an excuse and it's Padraic. He punishes himself for his inadequacy of being top tier musician. He cuts his fingers off because he thinks therye useless anyways.
This is an amazingly accurate depiction of the human condition : your friends betray you , your family deserts you and the few that actually truly love you die - and , in the end , you are left all alone Yeah , that's what you have to look forward to
Perhaps you'd like to react to an Australian crime movie called Two Hands. It's violent and full of dark humour and stars Bryan Brown and the very young Heath Ledger and Rose Byrne. I've never heard anyone not from Oz react to movies like this, so another pair of eyes might be good.
Chrissie, g’day from Australia! I’m an expat Scottish bloke and I really enjoy watching all your reactions to some really fantastic films! I see you tend towards the “gritty” genres, I suggest you jump into Candy (Heath), The Castle (Eric) and Romper Stomper (Russell) Good luck with your programming! I love your empathetic vibe and how often the questions you pose are answered almost immediately in the video (hope that is real not post edit 😊)
Just came across your channel. Thank you. Such an amazing script and story, so many ways to look at it. When I watched it I felt the same kind of confusion. What I think having rewatched your reaction is that Paidric was innocent and naive and Colm was intelligent and depressed, that they were dealing with the black dog in their own ways and eventually learned the place in the middle. Dominic had both of them, the innocence with being simple and neurodivergent and the complexity of his dad beating him. It’s so sad what happened to him but thank you for sharing it again
i wish more movies were made like this. to make us feel... you don t need cgi for a masterpiece, unfortunately cinema is dead. 1 - 2 great movies per year at best
This is definitely one of those films where I can appreciate aspects (the allegory, the performances, the gorgeous setting) and still not like it as a whole. I don’t mind darkness, drama, or difficult topics. I don’t even need a happy ending. This film, though, to me, is all trauma and suffering and cruelty, and I just can’t enjoy it. In your outro, you wondered if Padraic has finally come to terms with things. The actors themselves have debated the ending. For me, by the end of the film, their relationship was beyond toxic and I think Padraic was able to recognize that. He said he’d watch the dog “any time” but I feel that was more for the pup’s sake than for Colm’s. Shows that, despite the change in him, Padraic still has his core caring and decency. Just my take from a single viewing. I think some people see hope of reconciliation in that line. Different perspectives abound!
That is interesting because in my mind it was the comfort of knowing that if Colm was to give into the despair completely, he knew his dog would be cared for; Padraic saying 'any time' could be interpreted as - whenever you decide you're ready to go, I'll be here for him. So it was more dark in my mind than hopeful. But I also questioned that train of thought and I could be way off... I love all the possible outlooks and perspectives this film offers!
@@chrissiereacts I honestly don’t think there is a right or wrong answer. The filmmakers may have had their own ideas in mind, but if they wanted to push one specific message, they would have made it less ambiguous. People come at life with all sorts of different experiences that color how they look at and interpret the world (and art). I love hearing other perspectives. It’s fascinating how people can have such different ways of seeing the same things! (And it's fun to watch artists take advantage of that, then debate what it all means!)
I wasn't a huge fan of this one. I get the symbolism, but some of the characters interactions are just too unbelievable. When it came out it was presented as a comedy and that didn't help one bit. It clearly isn't, and no matter how good a movie it is, how beautiful the locations are, or how great the acting is, it's hard to focus on those when you were going in expecting something completely different. When I watched it I was definitely not in the mood for drama, so the movie was very unpleasant to watch. I did find the AI generated reviews pretty hilarious though.
Personally I wasn't a fan of this film. I didn't find it funny. Just incredibly sad and miserable and depressing. Didn't understand the rave reviews it wasn't dark comedy it was just dark.
I loved "In Bruges" but this gets a big thumbs down (no pun intended) from me. It's dark but not a comedy. It's gritty but not realistic. It's just an indulgence masquerading as 'art' IMO, and nobody I know who likes cinema liked it either.
"Nobody I know who likes cinema likes it either"... this film has gotten high praise the world over including a 13 minute standing ovation at the Cannes film festival.
@@Jim-fd9jz If it won 12 Oscars, was blessed by the Pope and won the Nobel Peace Prize it still wouldn't alter the fact that I didn't like it and neither did anyone I know who have seen it.
@@thewildgoose7467 That's cool, I was simply replying to the part that you and your friends didn't like it even though they like cinema, as if that's some sort of gauge on whether films are good or not.
to me one of the best movies ever PERIOD. the level of empathy it has for all of its characters is so beautiful. i'm an artist and have struggled with deep depression, and saw myself (from the past thankfully) so deeply in colm that the first time i watched it i almost couldn't finish it. i think it tells a very dark truth about despair and mental illness that can get glossed over in art, which is how it can ruin the way you experience other people and their average everyday niceness and companionship
This movie did not resonate with me, personally, but I am glad you were able to find something in it that spoke to you. Reading your take helped me see how that is possible. (I had a similar experience with Everything Everywhere All At Once. Some people dismissed the film as trash, but man did I identify on a deep level with the characters/messages.)
All our past experiences shape how we view and experience everything after, film included. When we see something of ourselves or something we “know” in someone else’s art… it’s a powerful, affirming thing. Great that you found that in Banshees! Thanks for sharing your perspective!
I love this movie so much, oh my god. Colin Farrell’s performance is one of the greatest things I’ve ever seen
I'm so happy I've finally come around to watching his films. He's so talented.
@@chrissiereacts after your reactions to this and In Bruges, I feel compelled to recommend Grand Budapest Hotel for a future reaction. It’s not really related, but I think based on your appreciation for these movies you will love it.
I absolutely agree. My goodness he deserved every major award for his performance!
This is an allegory of the Irish Civil War (which is taking place in the background). I'd recommend watching some interviews with Martin McDonagh in which he talks a lot about the film.
I'd also recommend a video by you tuber Jake Bishop explaining the parallels with the war along with documentary footage and clips from the films Michael Collins and The Wind that shakes the Barley.
and besides the war allegory, it's also a pretty powerful parabola of what depression and isolation does to people
@@stefanforrer2573I’ve read that early to mid 20th century western Ireland was thought to have the highest rate of schizophrenia in the world. More studies revealed it was a combination of bachelordom, loneliness & alcoholism.
Just watched , very interesting. Thanks for the recommendation.@@gavinwock6133
Watching someone else's reaction to this film was great, as I was utterly devastated after seeing it! I found it so painful and I haven't been so affected by a film in a long time. I have since watched and listened to countless analysis of this film. It's utterly brilliant and the connection to the Irish civil war just makes it so much more powerful.
I’ve disconnected with some friends cold heartedly but felt the pain deep down. This film was a huge awakening for me to prep for those toughest moments down the road.
The old woman was a banshee "banshee, supernatural being in Irish and other Celtic folklore. At night was believed to foretell the death of a member of the family of the person who heard the spirit."
When colm thank him for takeing care of his dog . Its the first time in the movie colm starts a conversation with him
Oh wow! Good detail.
You've got to see Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri now. Also Calvary, by the directors older brother
Most of McDonaghs films dont end with a clear resolution, but the final scene i think means colm and padraig are now enemies. The end is the beginning of a true feud
This movie was made in amazing fashion. Any movie with these 2 leads is a must watch. I see you watched In Bruges. Ill check that next. This is a great film with a phenomenal backstory.
I don´t think Dominic is quite as stupid as people think. Beautiful film and tragic performance by Barry Keoghan
Barry Keoghan got beat up on a night out while filming the movie, they had to change the script so his dad beat him in the movie because they couldn't cover his injuries and only had so many days to film.
really enjoying your channel and all your new reactions, glad i found you :)
Thank you!! 😊
Great film. Doesn't have to fit into any categories for me. I laughed and despaired both. As you've watched this and In Bruges, try the director's 3 Billboards.
First time I’ve ever watched a reaction to a film…first time seeing the film myself 😆…loved it Chrissie.
Ps…you’re very sweet.
Haha I'm honoured! 🍒 😉
I've been waiting for a long time for someone to post a reaction to "Banshee")) A masterpiece, this film continues to remain in my memory for a year now and constantly touches me. No one is right or wrong, it’s difficult to “give roles” to the characters, it’s painfully reminiscent of real life cases (except for the fingers ;) )
It’s interesting - as Podrick’s “fall” progresses, animals increasingly enter his house. At first his sister doesn’t let them in, and when she leaves, the cow is already lying inside the house with him. In theory, this symbolizes hell - living alone among animals.
Are cut off fingers a human sacrifice to become immortal in art? Pain that is necessary for creativity? Was it worth it in the end? Or is this a metaphor for the fact that without simple connections between people (without fingers) there is no art? God knows, this movie doesn't care))
The character of Barry Keoghan is most touching - when he says - well, this dream is gone, and then he declares that he still has things to do somewhere out there: only after watching you understand what kind of things - to drown himself, because there is more hope it was gone, the last one collapsed. It's harsh.
I'm glad I was able to deliver 😄
Do you think him cutting off his fingers also meant he could no longer hide behind the idea that it was Padraic that was holding him back? He talks about being one of the greats and how he wants to be remembered for his music. Instead of an ear he chose his fingers.
@@chrissiereacts Perhaps, partly. He blames Padraic for this, but it is not he who is holding him back, but something inside Colm himself. Where else could the idea of self-harm come from?
I also think that the cut off fingers give significance to his intention to devote himself to music, such a psychological mechanism. Most likely, he realizes that he will no longer become the second Mozart. Maybe that’s why at the end he cuts off all the remaining 4 - after that you won’t be able to play: that’s it, now Padraic is definitely to blame, but for himself Colm can say - I did everything possible, even went to extreme measures, but they literally didn’t let me . Subconsciously, at least.
-
Maybe Colm will even find peace after the finale. Without fingers, without a friend, accidentally killing a donkey (being stubborn like a donkey, huh). But Siobhán escaped from this madness, but she, too, was wondering whether to drown herself. Well, damn sad for Padraic.
-
Of course, if you look at it from the point of view of psychiatry, then this is a direct diagnosis ;) But I would like to perceive this more theatrically, otherwise it turns out too dark. It will be great if you see the rest of both McDonagh brothers ;)
I think the symbolism behind the cutting of the fingers is how we self mutilated our selves and ideals during the civil war in Ireland during the early 20th century. I love how you are able to further explore it as a symbol for the human condition. Nice interpretations. I love it
Siobhan is the only sane person on Inisherin.
I love this film.
She nearly kills herself but still she is the most sane
I’ve read that in the early to mid 20th century, the west of Ireland was thought to have the greatest rate of schizophrenia in the world. Later studies revealed it was a combination of high rates of bachelordom, loneliness & alcoholism.
You should check out the films The Wind That Shakes The Barley or Michael Collins if you want a good representation of Irish history
Should have cleaned up at the Oscars!!
Great to see someone reacting to different kinds of films like this.
😊
All the acting in this film is superb, but Kerry Condon really makes an impression. What a great film.
Really adore this film
Great movie,
Me second favourite of 2022
It was a very good film discussing depression and how it can destroy lives with something simple as friendship. It is described as dark comedy but it had very few funny moments. It was brilliantly acted, and beautifully filmed. I really liked it but it was a darn serious film. Now the other Gleeson/Farrell film-in Bruges was very, very funny
The whole movie is an allegory for the irish civil war (which you can seee transpiring on the mainland in background scenes) and how people who would've normally been best mates would've been fighting against each other regarding us not getting the 6 counties in the north
If you like films set in Ireland, try Calm With Horses.
🍺 🍻 good Las 👍
There goes that dream 😢😢😢
If you haven't already, check out In Bruges and Seven Psychopaths. Similar, and equally as great
In Bruges is already on my channel and Seven Psychopaths is on my Patreon :)
loved the sister who’s she ?
The Banshees of Inisheherin really reminds me of times n people past , of drinking pochine and the love between two friends, we're smalltalk is what really holds people to feckin gether and if this doesn't win Awards by the bucketload then there's no point or place in films no longer, By the way wouldn't every boy love a woman like Siobhan to consider falling in love with ...
you must must must watch Three Billboardds outside Ebbing Missouri, i think its probably the directors best (and widely regarded as such)
I've heard great things!
The funny because it’s considered his lowest film
Love ya reviews this off the hook dark shit spot on Irish
after living in Ireland for a stint, i learnt quick that secrets dont stay secret there lol
they're all natural gossipers haha
As people have pointed out...yhe irosh civil war where families would jist immediately stop talking to each other depending on their allegiance.
the donkey rocked me
I hope to see a first time reaction to Jaws (1975) and Alligator (1980) and Tremors (1990) the greatest creature feature movies ever created and The Thing (1982) and Alien (1979) and The Shining (1980) the greatest horror movies ever created and Aliens (1986) the greatest sci-fi action and horror movie as well:).
I saw my first Carpenter film recently so I'm down to watch The Thing :) I also want to start the Alien series soon!
Colm hates himself. Past his fifties. He knows he will never be remembered as a musician. He has too much pride. He was looking for an excuse and it's Padraic. He punishes himself for his inadequacy of being top tier musician. He cuts his fingers off because he thinks therye useless anyways.
This is an amazingly accurate depiction of the human condition : your friends betray you , your family deserts you and the few that actually truly love you die - and , in the end , you are left all alone
Yeah , that's what you have to look forward to
That intro was embarrassing for me as someone who is Irish and does not consume alcohol 🤣 I also grew up on Inis Mór where a lot of this is filmed.
it’s right what you say but lyric can also deal with it his way, not happy but good
Though they are few and far between, this is another reminder that great films are still being made. Keep em coming young lady!
Perhaps you'd like to react to an Australian crime movie called Two Hands. It's violent and full of dark humour and stars Bryan Brown and the very young Heath Ledger and Rose Byrne. I've never heard anyone not from Oz react to movies like this, so another pair of eyes might be good.
I'm intrigued! Thanks for the rec :)
Chrissie, g’day from Australia! I’m an expat Scottish bloke and I really enjoy watching all your reactions to some really fantastic films! I see you tend towards the “gritty” genres, I suggest you jump into Candy (Heath), The Castle (Eric) and Romper Stomper (Russell)
Good luck with your programming! I love your empathetic vibe and how often the questions you pose are answered almost immediately in the video (hope that is real not post edit 😊)
I give it a four out of four fingers rating.
Just came across your channel. Thank you. Such an amazing script and story, so many ways to look at it. When I watched it I felt the same kind of confusion. What I think having rewatched your reaction is that Paidric was innocent and naive and Colm was intelligent and depressed, that they were dealing with the black dog in their own ways and eventually learned the place in the middle. Dominic had both of them, the innocence with being simple and neurodivergent and the complexity of his dad beating him. It’s so sad what happened to him but thank you for sharing it again
first time watcher of your channel
first of all, you've got The Kiss at the background?! gurl you got taste, luv that
i wish more movies were made like this. to make us feel... you don t need cgi for a masterpiece, unfortunately cinema is dead. 1 - 2 great movies per year at best
This is definitely one of those films where I can appreciate aspects (the allegory, the performances, the gorgeous setting) and still not like it as a whole. I don’t mind darkness, drama, or difficult topics. I don’t even need a happy ending. This film, though, to me, is all trauma and suffering and cruelty, and I just can’t enjoy it.
In your outro, you wondered if Padraic has finally come to terms with things. The actors themselves have debated the ending. For me, by the end of the film, their relationship was beyond toxic and I think Padraic was able to recognize that. He said he’d watch the dog “any time” but I feel that was more for the pup’s sake than for Colm’s. Shows that, despite the change in him, Padraic still has his core caring and decency. Just my take from a single viewing. I think some people see hope of reconciliation in that line. Different perspectives abound!
That is interesting because in my mind it was the comfort of knowing that if Colm was to give into the despair completely, he knew his dog would be cared for; Padraic saying 'any time' could be interpreted as - whenever you decide you're ready to go, I'll be here for him. So it was more dark in my mind than hopeful. But I also questioned that train of thought and I could be way off...
I love all the possible outlooks and perspectives this film offers!
@@chrissiereacts I honestly don’t think there is a right or wrong answer. The filmmakers may have had their own ideas in mind, but if they wanted to push one specific message, they would have made it less ambiguous. People come at life with all sorts of different experiences that color how they look at and interpret the world (and art). I love hearing other perspectives. It’s fascinating how people can have such different ways of seeing the same things! (And it's fun to watch artists take advantage of that, then debate what it all means!)
This started out great & then got dark & then even darker. I thought In Bruge was sad until I saw this.
I wasn't a huge fan of this one. I get the symbolism, but some of the characters interactions are just too unbelievable.
When it came out it was presented as a comedy and that didn't help one bit. It clearly isn't, and no matter how good a movie it is, how beautiful the locations are, or how great the acting is, it's hard to focus on those when you were going in expecting something completely different.
When I watched it I was definitely not in the mood for drama, so the movie was very unpleasant to watch.
I did find the AI generated reviews pretty hilarious though.
It's a shame it was presented as a comedy because I totally get it - being in the right mindset for a film like this is kinda crucial.
Personally I wasn't a fan of this film. I didn't find it funny. Just incredibly sad and miserable and depressing. Didn't understand the rave reviews it wasn't dark comedy it was just dark.
Definitely not a comedy.
@@chrissiereacts I know right. It's considered black comedy but I don't get how it can be considered that
From a British perspective, it's hilarious. Our humour is usually darker than yours, or if you are a Brit my humour is darker than yours.
I loved "In Bruges" but this gets a big thumbs down (no pun intended) from me.
It's dark but not a comedy. It's gritty but not realistic.
It's just an indulgence masquerading as 'art' IMO, and nobody I know who likes cinema liked it either.
"Nobody I know who likes cinema likes it either"... this film has gotten high praise the world over including a 13 minute standing ovation at the Cannes film festival.
@@Jim-fd9jz If it won 12 Oscars, was blessed by the Pope and won the Nobel Peace Prize it still wouldn't alter the fact that I didn't like it and neither did anyone I know who have seen it.
@@thewildgoose7467 That's cool, I was simply replying to the part that you and your friends didn't like it even though they like cinema, as if that's some sort of gauge on whether films are good or not.
Agree 💯!
Its not meant to be realistic, its a fairytale. It sits at 96% on Rotten Tomatoes so Id say many people who like cinema liked it.
0:46 Padraic , on the last happy day of his life