Dr. Saheb spoke very well by pointing out the coercive policy measures to extort tax contrary to anything which could be said as agreeable to both the stakeholders which are the State and taxpayers. The taxation policy lacks to factor in all or most obvious facets of exempt income such as pension, remittances etc. I will request Dr Saheb to address in some detail the myth that Pakistani people do not pay taxes whereas despite the repressive WTH regime in force which extracts tax regardless of the status of the money being exempt as per law. Also requested to shed light on WTH regime as a whole . Thanks
Sir, Government ne 1947 k baad se IMF aur World Bank se aaj tak jo loans liye hain development k naam se aur wo kabhi ada nahi kiye na to koi development ki, wo aaj "TAX" ki surat mein awan ki pockets se nikalna chahtey hain, is per per abhi logo ki awareness k liye aik program kijye aur bataye k agar sara loan wapas bhi kar dein to kya IMF aur WORLD BANK ka karza utar jaye ga.
Dr Iqbal is stalwart of FBR.He .must be included somewhere as think tank .He can introduce easiest ways of taxation .Easiest method should be introduce to avoid fake & flying invoices.A general amnesty is need of the day for sales tax payers whose cases are strucked up in tribunal or apex courts. Minimum Dr Sahib should be placed as Federal Ombudsman. He can bring radical changes in system & save taxpayers from the clutches of revenue.
while I agree with what Dr. Iqbal is saying, please check how he used to operate in his days as Member FBR and what policies he used to devise and follow
بھائ جب کوئی Law abiding شہر ی نہیں ہے تو پھر اسٹیٹ کو ڈنڈا تو اٹھانا پڑے گا ۔ مجھے اقبال صاحب کی بات ہضم نہیں ہوئ۔ پھر یرا خیال ہےتمام تھانے کچہریاں بند کر دینی چاہئیں ۔ ان تھانوں کچہریوں میں جانے والے بھی اسی سوشل کنٹریکٹ میی شامل ہیں۔ ان کے ساتھ سراسر ذیادتی ہے۔
He served about 30 to 35 years being bureaucrate & MBBS Doctor.His experience is worth praise.in his all replies he shown misiries of tax payers & unjustified behaviour of revenue.Fbr has quasi-judicial powers.Income tax is a tax on income rather a municipal tax on any facility.No govt can be run without taxation but in Pakistan indirectly each Pakistani is paying I tax & Sales Tax which is quite unjustified & he has no reward.
بھائ پہلے یہ وضاحت فرمائیں کہ یہ اقبال صاحب کون سے ڈاکٹر ہیں اگر پی ایچ ڈی معاشیات وغیرہ میں ہیں تو ان کی بات میں وزن ہوگا ورنہ ایسا ہی ہے جیسے میں MBBS ڈاکٹر کے نسخے پر تبصرہ کروں۔ تو چلیے سنتے پیں۔
Bohut Khoob- a right example of sincerity of professionalism, Mehtab sb.
Great
An excellent program. 👌
Sir your channel is superb. Your content is useful in real sense. Keep it up.
Nice discussion.
Documentation of economy is foremost important
Dr. Saheb spoke very well by pointing out the coercive policy measures to extort tax contrary to anything which could be said as agreeable to both the stakeholders which are the State and taxpayers. The taxation policy lacks to factor in all or most obvious facets of exempt income such as pension, remittances etc. I will request Dr Saheb to address in some detail the myth that Pakistani people do not pay taxes whereas despite the repressive WTH regime in force which extracts tax regardless of the status of the money being exempt as per law. Also requested to shed light on WTH regime as a whole . Thanks
Dear Sirs,
Don't waste your time & energy
Debacle, eventually perish our destiny
By choice
Coercive taxation vs Contractual taxation
جو ٹیکس عوام ادا کر رہی ہے، کیا آئین کے مطابق اسکا صحیح استعمال ہو رہا ہے؟
Sir, Government ne 1947 k baad se IMF aur World Bank se aaj tak jo loans liye hain development k naam se aur wo kabhi ada nahi kiye na to koi development ki, wo aaj "TAX" ki surat mein awan ki pockets se nikalna chahtey hain, is per per abhi logo ki awareness k liye aik program kijye aur bataye k agar sara loan wapas bhi kar dein to kya IMF aur WORLD BANK ka karza utar jaye ga.
Dr Iqbal is stalwart of FBR.He .must be included somewhere as think tank .He can introduce easiest ways of taxation .Easiest method should be introduce to avoid fake & flying invoices.A general amnesty is need of the day for sales tax payers whose cases are strucked up in tribunal or apex courts.
Minimum Dr Sahib should be placed as Federal Ombudsman. He can bring radical changes in system & save taxpayers from the clutches of revenue.
Maximum tax, maximum threat and no facility to tax payer and no reasonable effort to bring high earning non filer in tax system.
while I agree with what Dr. Iqbal is saying, please check how he used to operate in his days as Member FBR and what policies he used to devise and follow
بھائ جان اسکریپ امپورٹ ہوتا ہے۔
Totally non sense.
بھائ جب کوئی Law abiding شہر ی نہیں ہے تو پھر اسٹیٹ کو ڈنڈا تو اٹھانا پڑے گا ۔ مجھے اقبال صاحب کی بات ہضم نہیں ہوئ۔ پھر
یرا خیال ہےتمام تھانے کچہریاں بند کر دینی چاہئیں ۔ ان تھانوں کچہریوں میں جانے والے بھی اسی سوشل کنٹریکٹ میی شامل ہیں۔ ان کے ساتھ سراسر ذیادتی ہے۔
State itself is not law abiding .....
He served about 30 to 35 years being bureaucrate & MBBS Doctor.His experience is worth praise.in his all replies he shown misiries of tax payers & unjustified behaviour of revenue.Fbr has quasi-judicial powers.Income tax is a tax on income rather a municipal tax on any facility.No govt can be run without taxation but in Pakistan indirectly each Pakistani is paying I tax & Sales Tax which is quite unjustified & he has no reward.
بھائ پہلے یہ وضاحت فرمائیں کہ یہ اقبال صاحب کون سے ڈاکٹر ہیں اگر پی ایچ ڈی معاشیات وغیرہ میں ہیں تو ان کی بات میں وزن ہوگا ورنہ ایسا ہی ہے جیسے میں MBBS ڈاکٹر کے نسخے پر تبصرہ کروں۔ تو چلیے سنتے پیں۔
Mbbs کو تو یہاں لاکر بٹھانا نہیں تھا بے وقوف