Schwinn IC4 vs Echelon EX4s from COSTCO - $1,000 Peloton Alternative Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 лип 2024
- Schwinn IC4: amzn.to/3kEhoI1
Buy from Schwinn directly: bit.ly/schwinnIC4 (IN STOCK)
Echelon EX-3 amzn.to/3n9T7M7 (similar w/out screen)
The Schwinn IC4 and the echelon ex4s from costco are two good indoor cycling bike peloton alternatives both prices right around $1000. In this video I compare the Schwinn IC4 vs echelon ex-4s costco indoor cycling bike and give you my opinion on the drive train feel, max resistance, and several other important similarities and differences between the schwinn and the echelon bike.
chapters:
0:00 intro
1:15 similarities and differences
3:33 resistance knobs
4:10 echelon LAG
5:25 adjustability
6:04 seats
6:35 handlebars
8:17 ic4 first impressions
9:56 echelon first impressions
11:35 comfort observations
12:20 drive train comments
13:00 ex4s max resistance
13:40 schwinn ic4 resistance quickness
14:30 schwinn ic4 max resistance
15:27 size observations
16:00 more max resistance compare
16:40 echelon drive train comments
17:35 schwinn ic4 drive train comments
18:24 summary
Check my channel for more indoor cycling videos and reviews. I have a full echelon ex4s review as well as a in depth concise Schwinn IC4 review with tailhappy score.
the Schwinn IC4 has a heavier flywheel at a weight of 40lbs, the echelon ex4s has a flywheel weight of 13kg which comes out to about 28.66 lbs. both of the drive trains feel nice. The echelon ex4s has a higher max resistance than the Schwinn IC4, but the ic4 will wear you out too.
The maximum user weight of the Schwinn IC4 is 330 lbs while the echelon ex4s max weight is only 300lbs.
chapters listed, please click LIKE :)
0:00 intro
1:15 similarities and differences
3:33 resistance knobs
4:10 echelon LAG
5:25 adjustability
6:04 seats
6:35 handlebars
8:17 ic4 first impressions
9:56 echelon first impressions
11:35 comfort observations
12:20 drive train comments
13:00 ex4s max resistance
13:40 schwinn ic4 resistance quickness
14:30 schwinn ic4 max resistance
15:27 size observations
16:00 more max resistance compare
16:40 echelon drive train comments
17:35 schwinn ic4 drive train comments
18:24 summary
Just bought the Schwinn iC4 today via the link! Can't wait for it to get here! Thank you so much for all of your video reviews!
Great review! You did an amazing job of describing the Pros and Cons of each bike!
Your channel and content is great. You deserve way more views and subs. Even after having bought a bike and being content with it, I still enjoy your videos. Thanks for all you do. I did return my Sunny bike and am waiting on the replacement which should be delivered Sunday. I hope to not have any issues with the new bike. If I do, I think I will try the Echelon Sport or EX3. Happy spinning and keep up the great content.
Thanks for all your super informative videos! I was comparing these 2 and decided to go with Schwinn and made sure to use your link ;)
I don’t understand how monetary system works with UA-cam but I hope you are making a good living doing these videos. You are awesome and your vids are great.
its my dream, need more views!
@@TailHappyTV I'm doing my best to share these videos with some FB groups I'm in! Your videos are indeed awesome--hope your channel continues to grow.
I keep watching his videos even though I already bought the schwinn 🤣
Thanks for the thoughtful review! I bought the IC4 a couple weeks ago based on your review and love it. I was a little afraid you would say the Echelon was way better, so I’m happy to hear they are very comparable. Your videos are great!
Lol sorry for causing you worry Michael, thank you for your compliment!
Thanks for your insights. I went with the IC4 and bought through your link. I wanted the Echelon, but it doesn't have a tablet holder, so that really is a deal breaker. I am most concerned about the non auto adjust resistance.
I was unlucky ordering the IC4 from Amazon. It showed up in a damaged box, and when I opened it, it was clearly used. Zip ties were cut, and the bike was dirty on the bottom like it had been on a dirty floor. I also didn’t see any HR monitor in the box. At least the return to Amazon was easy, other than UPS wouldn’t give a specific time for the pick-up. Anyway, just be aware that this is a possibility if you order from Amazon.
I appreciate you! Thank you so much!!!
Thanks Russell, I appreciate hearing your feedback!
Which might be better for me @ 5’1”? While Schwinn has greater variety in adjustments, cld Echelon possibly fit better given how the handle and seat get closer the lower they are? Does the Echelon manual list min height? Thanks for the great video!
Thanks for you amazing review! From the video the echelon looks like more of a sturdy bike, especially the seat pillar. Is that right? I hear echelon is more of a studio standard bike while IC4 is a home standard bike. So struggling between those two because now costco has it for 799 which is the same price as IC4 now.
Hi, great video again. As a complete novice to the indoor biking world, these videos are greatly helping me narrow my choice down. Have a quick question on the Ex-3 vs Ex-4, as we only have the Ex-3 available in the UK. Is there much difference in performance or resistance vs the Ex-4? Or is it simply just missing out on the screen? Keep up the great work!
i think its basically the same without the screen which may not be a bad thing if you dont want to use echelon services
@@TailHappyTV Yea, that is pretty much what I was thinking. Ideally would get a Peleton, but there is currently a 2-3 month lead time in the UK.
Thanks for the review on the Schwinn IC4. Do you a have a link to purchase a Schwinn IC8 ?
So if you take the 4s subscription cost out of the comparison is this bike worth $999, or does it rank with a lower cost bike like Sunny?
What is the bottom bracket like on the IC4? Is the spindle held in place by a spring C clip or is it screwed on like the Echelon?
Have you reviewed (or thinking about reviewing ) the bow flex velocore bike?
Things to mention. EX4s is pretty limited without a subscription. It can be bypassed to use peleton and other apps too but the tablet is of course low quality so it remains to be seen how it performs.
At $500 which is the current sale price these are literal bargains compared peleton. The bowflex ic7 went for $280 which is insane
I would love to see a comparison of magnetic resistance s friction resistance
noted. thanks for the idea, keep forgetting to do this!
Is there a place to put your own tablet/ laptop on the Echelon v. Schwinn?
Recommendation for 5’- 5’1” female for a spin bike
Its super helpful when you give equivalent resistances compared with the Peloton. Max resistance is most important for me and anyone serious about fitness.
I can't really afford the Keiser M3i which seems to be king, with Peloron second. I am tying to decide between a Peloton original or Echelon.
What resistance on the Keiser M3i would you say is equivalent to the max resistance on the Echelelon 4S, or 5S?
When the IC4 is connected to an app does the same lag exist as you found on the ex4s? I have a lag on my elliptical cadence and it’s bothersome to me. Thank you.
Does the Echelon from Costco come with a warranty or service from Echelon? If it breaks will someone from Echelon come out and fix it?
Your reviews are so helpful - thank you! I’m looking to buy a bike and I’m just so lost on what I want 😂 Would you say the Echelon EX-4S would work well for Peloton classes with some work arounds? And I know this is a big difference, do you have any experience with the higher-end Sunny bikes on Amazon (especially in comparison to the Echelon)? I like the idea of buying from Costco because of their customer service and warranties.
Def will work, need a second screen and peloton digital though. I am planning on buying more sunny bikes, the 1805 and synergy pro are on my list, I like sunny
@@TailHappyTV thank you!! I’m stuck between the Echelon EX-4S now and the Sunny 1805. I think the Echelon would just be more convenient in the end, but there’s a big price difference lol.
@@kristinaj.5836 Hi Kristina..... I have an Echelon Connect Sport.... It's less expensive at $500 (and comes w/ 6 months of the echelon subscription if you buy thru Walmart).... I wanted a bike I could connect the Peloton app to... the Echelon's with the monitors force you into using the Echelon app. Just my 2 cents. Good luck to you!
@@ZsashaD i so appreciate the feedback! I’ll have to look into that one. Thank you! ☺️
@@kristinaj.5836 TailHappy has many videos on the Connect Sport.
Now I am so torn. I picked up the IC4 for $799 on the Best Buy flash sale day and it’s in the garage boxed for Christmas. That said the EX4s looks to me to essentially be the same specs as the 5s with two exceptions, handle bar adjustment and the screen size. My main concern is cadence. Help!!! If you don’t know how you’ll like echelon vs peloton what do you do??
If you live near a peloton store you can test it at there store
If I don't use the screen on the EX-4 will it connect to an IPAD like the other Echelon bikes?
Hace you tries the Asuna bike?
After the year subscription on the echelon exe 4 if you decide not to renew it , you can't use that screen to use other apps or UA-cam videos?
Nope
I heard that you can side load apps but I don't know how.
The cadence display delay... I wonder if it matters. He went from stationary to moving so there's a lot of relative accelleration and any reading taken during that time would be meaningless as there's no consistent cadence - it's 0, then 10, then 20... not useful info. Cadence is most accutately measured based on sample size >1. What would be more interesting/valid was how long it takes to respond to a CHANGE in cadence, not from a cold start. Even then though, I'm not sure 5 seconds delay matters too much. n.b. I just bought the EX4s+ from Costco for $499+TAX including 1 year's membership so if I make good use of the classes, the bike is effectively free :-) Seemed like an amazong bargain - the + has a 15" screen !
My ex4s seems to not have the right time zone. How do I change it. When I go to live workout it shows everything 1 day ahead
Does your bike have the same lag issue?
You helped me buy the echelon off Walmart that was your first video I had seen with the gooseneck iPad and other things ... thanks for putting it together . Got my bike in 10 days and before delivery date was due. Can you do a video on your exercise regime and your diet?
I've been thinking about that, thanks for asking I will consider it for a future video, although I have to admit I haven't been on top of it as much as I was pre pandemic
His exercise regimen involves testing bikes
@@mrwilson6108 lol that's basically about right lately, building and filming the build is surprisingly exhausting. Ps nordictrack is built
@@TailHappyTV I can imagine. You’re working your tail off, hopefully it pays off for you
Just bought the schwinn ic4 yesterday for $999 and waiting for it to be delivered. Walked into costco today and saw the echelon ex4s on sale for $799. Now I'm wondering if I made the right choice.
You did. Echelon works with electricity whereas IC 4 doesn't
Hi. Great reviews. Appreciate the perspective. Quick question: How would you rank the EX-4S, the IC4, and the Bowflex C6 against each other? Seem pretty similar and I’m looking to get one of them. Thank you.
Thanks. From my understanding the c6 is the same as the ic4 just different color scheme. Hope this helps.
Yes, think that is right. Both are made by Nautilus. One of those or the ex-4s?
Please review PooBoo. I have my eye on one but would love your opinion. Thanks!
noted
What, if anything, would I lose out on not having a plug-in bike and going with the Tour De France.
IC4 cadence max of 124?
What about the echelon ex3?
Can you use peloton app with exs3?
Yes
I seen in a video that the Schwinn max resistance is pretty lame
Schwinn is $699 at Amazon now.
The Schwinn bike now includes a one year JRNY membership free but the bike price has increased $100, from $899 to $999 and the membership is valued at $149. So this additional package deal is worth $49. The Echelon EX-4S now costs $1099.99, no additional features just increased price...probably due to supply/demand. Annoying!
Will the x4s run if the screen is damaged or unpluged?
Not sure
They dIdn't fix the lag in 4s+ unfortunately.
I tried out the ic4 and the echelon in the stores. The ic4 seat bar and handle bars rattles slightly when riding. I've seen that on some other reviews. That would get annoying. Edge to echelon. Plus I think I'm too tall for the Schwinn
So thisbike (the 4s) was priced at $999 in December 2020? Well, that is now gone. Today's special discount price (through 1-31-2021) is ONLY $1,499 at costco. Is there something I am missing here?
is that the ex5s maybe?
@@TailHappyTV My Bad You're correct. I don't think they're selling the ex4s anymore.
Sorry
@@tberru only in stores, can call and ask
It is now 799. I believe sale ends 2/14
@@killerapl Thanks Eddie. I purchased one from Schwinn Dealer 2 weeks ago. Should have it delivered in 10 days.