This is a late comment but I have watched this video a few times. The difference in the first(yellow card) and second(red card) is that the first one wasn’t intentional while the second was
Great, great observations, Rob, especially given your experience as a football referee. There is a ‘black’ card also in Gaelic football which is given if someone prevents a definite scoring chance by committing a foul. Keep up the work! 😉💚☘️
The black card is in theory a bit nuanced. It is for the "cynical" dragging of an attacker to the ground. Before the Black card was introduced, there was a kind of tactical foul where a midfielder would drag down an opponent in midfield or just barely into the defenders half in order to stop the breakaway attack and give defenders time to get reorganised. The foul was very mild, too mild for a yellow, but the free kick was far enough out that a point might not be scored and with the defense back in place a goal was unlikely. If a player gets a black card, they are sent off the pitch, but can be replaced. I think it was designed as a bit of a crutch for referees, as it was thought referees were reluctant to punish a team in big games with a red card for a string of mild fouls. Not sure that the black card actually works as intended, but it is nice to see a player go off the pitch for being so sly sometimes.
I know im very late but at 10:40 the reason he got a yellow is because slide tackling in gaa is really frowned upon and really bad injuries can occur thats why theres such a reaction from his teammates.
@@RobReacts1 If you have played golf you should find striking the ball in the air easy enough. Practise against a wall. A lot of kids over here practise in Handball alleys (very similar to the court for Squash)
pretty good, but what you need to know is that careless and all that stuff is different in hurling and gaelic than football, other than that you did a great observation
That Keeper's red card was a pretty intentional. I remember at that match where the Red and Green 3 got sent off, that card basically cost Mayo(R+G) the match....breaking my heart once again..
Hi Rob, it's probably been pointed out to you already in the comments (please forgive me if it has) but in Cork (and most likely the rest of the country) we play games with the sliotar but it's considered more practical to use tennis balls when practicing- good look with it (:
To edit my last comment- I'm not sure if this tennis ball thing applies to club practice as I was never good enough to play there lol, but for ordinary banging the ball off your garage wall-,or out in a field with a friend- swinging long shots forward and back then the tennis ball is fine
Your detailed observations were very interesting, Rob. The red card, yellow card - and now black card, were adopted from soccer. I don’t altogether approve of them. Before they were introduced, you could only be sent off for two reasons; striking and persistent fouling. As far as I remember, you were allowed four fouls before being warned. On the fifth foul you were sent off. I only remember it being implemented once. Strangely enough, there didn’t seem to be any head-high tackles in those days; it was mostly jersey-pulling and holding. One of the rules which leads to much rough play - especially in hurling - is the Advantage Rule. Players can be mauled and even struck as they try to work their way through and all they get at the end of it, if they lose the ball, is a free. In my opinion, the present situation is a result of the undue pressure on referees by a certain county manager who encouraged his players is the use of a quick hand pull to cause an opponent to lose possession and then complained loudly that referees were slowing down the game by giving too many frees. “Let the game flow” was a favourite mantra of his.
Speaking of Gaelic. If you haven't yet, you should check out something on International Rules Australia vs Ireland. It's essentially AFL Vs Gaelic Football since both codes are similar. Used to be a massive event back in the day. Now not so sure now since I barely hear from it. Lol
When you said intended punch will get you a red. It's the same for the NRL. An attempted punch will get you binned and if you make contact then that is a bin plus are suspension for one match
Cork are a mess in Gaelic football in a 2nd division relegation battle. In Hurling Cork were in the All-Ireland Hurling Final were Kilkenny well beating us they won the mach in the first half Kilkenny is the best Hurling team I have even seen
@@RobReacts1 that’s good I’d love to watch the watch along but I managed to get a ticket for the match but I’ll definitely watch it when I get home. Enjoy the match! Hopefully it will be less one sided than last year🤞🏻
Great observations but you don't get it. In Ireland there is 2 national sports. Hurling and Irish football so the rules are different. We learn both sports from an early age. I learned rugby at 4 years of age by 10 I was playing galic football by 12 I was hurling, and I became very good at that. What you don't realize is it's pride of your town then county and there is massive rivalry between clubs county's and that's what makes hurling so great.
Hi Rob the correct way to pronounced the Irish word for the hurling ball is not slee a tard nope the best way is slit-er give yourself a bit of practice for Sunday the the 17th of July 2022 the all Ireland hurling final 3pm limerick v kilkenny the first time since the pandemic over 82000 instead of last years 40000 Then two weeks later the all Ireland football ⚽️ final 3pm so excited even though we are not in either final this year I hope you do the 2 finals this year
I'm proud to say that I have never received any colour card...I did accidentally hit a guy in the head during a hockey game...but that was more his fault than mine...Just how much do you enjoy waving those cards, Rob?
Said currently it's just league games on so it would be better to wait for championship for a good televised game. Then recommended you check out Jeff and kammy's Road to croker which gives good insight of the sports from club level to county. with a link to the first video. 🤷♂️😅
@@robmorgan1989 would second Jeff and Kammy's road to Croker - is a good watch - comment possibly removed by UA-cam for the link but the videos are still on there
Nice to see some GAA back on the channel
been a while! A lot of stuff is seasonal. I watched the hurling final last year but it's only really just starting again.
This is a late comment but I have watched this video a few times. The difference in the first(yellow card) and second(red card) is that the first one wasn’t intentional while the second was
There was a crazy game where Armagh vs Tyrone there were 5 red cards 1 Armagh player and 4 Tyrone players sent off
Yea just like the all Irelands 🤣 Hon Tyrone!
Armagh didn’t deserve a red
A double yellow to a red is a lesser offence than a straight red, for player suspensions after the ref's report goes in.
Great, great observations, Rob, especially given your experience as a football referee.
There is a ‘black’ card also in Gaelic football which is given if someone prevents a definite scoring chance by committing a foul. Keep up the work! 😉💚☘️
Cheers Jim. So a DOGSO in football which is a red card :)
The black card is in theory a bit nuanced. It is for the "cynical" dragging of an attacker to the ground. Before the Black card was introduced, there was a kind of tactical foul where a midfielder would drag down an opponent in midfield or just barely into the defenders half in order to stop the breakaway attack and give defenders time to get reorganised. The foul was very mild, too mild for a yellow, but the free kick was far enough out that a point might not be scored and with the defense back in place a goal was unlikely. If a player gets a black card, they are sent off the pitch, but can be replaced. I think it was designed as a bit of a crutch for referees, as it was thought referees were reluctant to punish a team in big games with a red card for a string of mild fouls. Not sure that the black card actually works as intended, but it is nice to see a player go off the pitch for being so sly sometimes.
I know im very late but at 10:40 the reason he got a yellow is because slide tackling in gaa is really frowned upon and really bad injuries can occur thats why theres such a reaction from his teammates.
Where did you get the Hurley Rob. I laughed when you reached behind and produced it. Greetings from Dublin.
I bought it. But I'm rubbish and havnt got round to using it yet.
@@RobReacts1 If you have played golf you should find striking the ball in the air easy enough. Practise against a wall. A lot of kids over here practise in Handball alleys (very similar to the court for Squash)
So nice to hear you call it a hurley. 👍👍 Great video
pretty good, but what you need to know is that careless and all that stuff is different in hurling and gaelic than football, other than that you did a great observation
Enjoyed this , well done mate👍
That Keeper's red card was a pretty intentional.
I remember at that match where the Red and Green 3 got sent off, that card basically cost Mayo(R+G) the match....breaking my heart once again..
Hi Rob, it's probably been pointed out to you already in the comments (please forgive me if it has) but in Cork (and most likely the rest of the country) we play games with the sliotar but it's considered more practical to use tennis balls when practicing- good look with it (:
4:30 the guy talking is the same guy who got sent off in the first one. He has many records and is often considered the greatest modern player.
Cork vs clare 2013 all Ireland final replay would be a good one to watch.
1:45 waterford must have been playing filthy to have 2 players sent off
One thing the world has no shortage of is one-eyed commentators.
To edit my last comment- I'm not sure if this tennis ball thing applies to club practice as I was never good enough to play there lol, but for ordinary banging the ball off your garage wall-,or out in a field with a friend- swinging long shots forward and back then the tennis ball is fine
Your detailed observations were very interesting, Rob. The red card, yellow card - and now black card, were adopted from soccer. I don’t altogether approve of them. Before they were introduced, you could only be sent off for two reasons; striking and persistent fouling. As far as I remember, you were allowed four fouls before being warned. On the fifth foul you were sent off. I only remember it being implemented once. Strangely enough, there didn’t seem to be any head-high tackles in those days; it was mostly jersey-pulling and holding.
One of the rules which leads to much rough play - especially in hurling - is the Advantage Rule. Players can be mauled and even struck as they try to work their way through and all they get at the end of it, if they lose the ball, is a free.
In my opinion, the present situation is a result of the undue pressure on referees by a certain county manager who encouraged his players is the use of a quick hand pull to cause an opponent to lose possession and then complained loudly that referees were slowing down the game by giving too many frees. “Let the game flow” was a favourite mantra of his.
Cody?
Jaysus I love this sport I was only sent off 1 time in my time.of playing..but had so many fights it's very passionate
Speaking of Gaelic. If you haven't yet, you should check out something on International Rules Australia vs Ireland. It's essentially AFL Vs Gaelic Football since both codes are similar. Used to be a massive event back in the day. Now not so sure now since I barely hear from it. Lol
I did actually do a video on that! 🙂 ua-cam.com/video/j-cb3bgBliQ/v-deo.html
You don't hear about it as it hasn't been on for about 8 years.
When you said intended punch will get you a red. It's the same for the NRL. An attempted punch will get you binned and if you make contact then that is a bin plus are suspension for one match
Yep! Intention is as bad as making contact in football.
In the gaelic football it first was a shoulder to the chest which is a yellow
I play both soccer and football, and I try to avoid physical contact as much as possible
Cork are a mess in Gaelic football in a 2nd division relegation battle. In Hurling Cork were in the All-Ireland Hurling Final were Kilkenny well beating us they won the mach in the first half Kilkenny is the best Hurling team I have even seen
Limerick aren’t the best team in recent history. Kilkenny are
@@donnachadoyle6629 I put limerick instead of Kilkenny my bad ty for the correction
The one with the blue Jersey in the gaelic football he got a Second yellow
The current system, as I understand it:
Red = OFF
Black = Off, but a substitute is allowed
Yellow = Caution, name taken
Two yellows = Red
Played hurling without a helmet after moving from London to Ireland at 12
Wasn’t compulsory then. Only got hit a few times in the head lol
Only! haha
Just to let you know the all Ireland hurling final is on next Sunday the 17th of July and the football final is on the following Sunday.
I'm planning on doing a watch along!! I can't wait
@@RobReacts1 that’s good I’d love to watch the watch along but I managed to get a ticket for the match but I’ll definitely watch it when I get home. Enjoy the match! Hopefully it will be less one sided than last year🤞🏻
It's been a long time since I've seen any Gaelic football or hurling
It's been a while! A lot of stuff is seasonal. I watched the hurling final last year but it's only really just starting again.
Im almost sure your ok up to the shoulder . Neck is high . Your able to hook the hurl . You might think thats a foul but its a legit tackle
Great observations but you don't get it. In Ireland there is 2 national sports. Hurling and Irish football so the rules are different. We learn both sports from an early age. I learned rugby at 4 years of age by 10 I was playing galic football by 12 I was hurling, and I became very good at that. What you don't realize is it's pride of your town then county and there is massive rivalry between clubs county's and that's what makes hurling so great.
Denying and obvious goal scoring opportunity is not a red card. Just a free
The old days you had to pull a weapon
Coming from a referee any strike to the head is a red card my team is the player at 4:57 in the black and amber and I think 100% it was a red card
and then there's the Black Cards!! That's a little different from soccer! :)
Dublin a stither galway a shlitter 🤣
Hi Rob the correct way to pronounced the Irish word for the hurling ball is not slee a tard nope the best way is slit-er give yourself a bit of practice for Sunday the the 17th of July 2022 the all Ireland hurling final 3pm limerick v kilkenny the first time since the pandemic over 82000 instead of last years 40000
Then two weeks later the all Ireland football ⚽️ final 3pm so excited even though we are not in either final this year I hope you do the 2 finals this year
I'm proud to say that I have never received any colour card...I did accidentally hit a guy in the head during a hockey game...but that was more his fault than mine...Just how much do you enjoy waving those cards, Rob?
Haha I only enjoy giving cards when a player has been annoying me all game and then gives me enough of a reason to card him!
His beard is about as even as uniteds chances of winning the league
Slit-tar 😂😂😂😂
I assume I pronounced it wrong 😂 I will have to just call it the ball haha
That shea ryan one was a black card
I dont even know what a black card is!
@@RobReacts1 a deliberate pull down or a trip has to be deliberate and it’s a permanent forced substitution
Now it’s a ten minute sin bin tho
Comment removed?? 😅
Not by me it wasn't. What did you say?
Said currently it's just league games on so it would be better to wait for championship for a good televised game. Then recommended you check out Jeff and kammy's Road to croker which gives good insight of the sports from club level to county. with a link to the first video. 🤷♂️😅
@@robmorgan1989 would second Jeff and Kammy's road to Croker - is a good watch - comment possibly removed by UA-cam for the link but the videos are still on there
Number 3 is my cousin 😒
No, we like the violence, men play it voluntarily, stop watering down good sports.