Bushido - Samurai Code of Honour - Myth and Reality of Shogun TV Show
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2024
- Kings and Generals animated historical documentary series on the history of Japan continues with a video in which we talk about the bushido - Samurai code of honour, the way of the warrior and ask if the Japanese nobility actually adhered to it, bringing up examples from the Shogunate and Imperial era, as well as discussing the most famous incident that became almost synonymous with the concept of bushido took place - the 47 Ronin.
🎥 Russo-Japanese and Pacific War on UA-cam: / @kingsandgenerals or Patreon: / kingsandgenerals
Other videos on Japan and Shogunate:
William Adams - English Samurai: • The Real Story Behind ...
Japan and the West: First Contact: • Japanese Armies of the...
Japanese Armies of the Shogunate Era: • Japanese Armies of the...
Structure of Medieval Japan: • What Was the Structure...
Yasuke - African Samurai: • Yasuke: Story of the A...
Samurai: Outsiders to Legends: • History of the Samurai...
Russo-Japanese War Begins: • Russo-Japanese War #1 ...
How did Japan become Buddhist?: • How did Japan become B...
Imjin War: • Imjin War - Japanese I...
Wakō - History of Piracy in Japan: • Wakō - History of Pira...
Shimabara Rebellion: The Christian Revolt in Japan • Shimabara Rebellion: T...
Ainu - History of the Indigenous people of Japan: • Ainu - History of the ...
Real Ghost of Tsushima - Mongol Invasion of Japan: • Real Ghost of Tsushima...
Mongols: Invasions of Japan 1274 and 1281: • Mongols: Invasions of ...
Sohei: Buddhist Warrior Monks: • Sohei: Buddhist Warrio...
Script: Dimitris Koutsoumis
Animation: Michael Merc / @mercenarycamp , Kate Korolko
Artwork: Vadym Berkutenko (j_blackwood.artstation.com/)
Narration: Officially Devin ( / @offydgg & / @gameworldnarratives )
Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1I...
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/stores/kingsand...
✔ Podcast ► www.kingsandgenerals.net/podcast/
✔ Twitter ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Facebook ► / kingsgenerals
✔ Instagram ► / kings_generals
Production Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
#Documentary #Japan #Shogun
🎥 Russo-Japanese and Pacific War on UA-cam: ua-cam.com/channels/MmaBzfCCwZ2KqaBJjkj0fw.htmljoin or Patreon: www.patreon.com/kingsandgenerals
Azai Nagamasa chose which side to back according to the ancient moral principle of Bros Before Hoes, following a Warrior Code far more ancient than Bushido: The Bro Code
Broshido as they call it in Japan
😂😅
“They’re more like guidelines” 😂
thats bull
And there are others who are like "it's a checklist"
Technically, it is not a "rule"
- A Samurai, doing air quotes.
Ha! U sound like Barbossa!
Bloody pirates
"civilization means not only comfort in daily necessities but also the refining of knowledge and the cultivation of virtue so as to elevate human life to a higher plane" - Fukuzawa Yukichi
In theory, lol.
@@asiblingproductionWhy??
@@asiblingproduction virtue is a theory
Having done extensive research on the subject I was worried when I saw the title of this video, thinking you would disappoint. Silly of me. Once again you show that you are a reliable source of information and can still remain entertaining. Thank you for setting the story straight for those that haven’t looked into the subject.
Lol. Funny, considering that their Japanese history videos routinely get ripped apart for being full of myth and misinformation. Their Sengoku Period one is particularly infamous for this. Really, you can find actual historians picking apart their videos all the time when they cover anything before the modern era.
@@Nyx_2142 nothing funny about it. Archeologists and historians are constantly ripping each other apart. As it should be. We keep each other in check. If one is wrong you can always reply and respond. Or correct what you said. But this is how we get to the truth. I don’t know which video you are referring to but this one is accurate. Having studied the subject for some time, stereotype of the “honorable” samurai always annoyed me.
@@Nyx_2142 Except their modern era is much worse than this could ever be. I find their videos to be best when they talked about Medieval Balkans or Feudal Europe for instance.
@@its_dey_mate I cannot speak to those as I mainly stay in the ancient to medieval timelines. Based off what you’re saying I may explore their more modern stuff. I can tell you from experience that their WWII Marine Raider video was excellent. Wish they had done that for other early SOF units.
47 Ronin needs to be done completely. The full story would be done justice here. 👍
European medieval knights also were supposed to have "codes of conduct"... and they respected them as much as the samurai, ie: when it suited them, And, as in the codified bushido, much of these "codes" were actually revived and rewriten in the 19th century victorian era...
Not really, it was more the really late 1600's for bushido, but the point stands.
Europ knights is just robber.
@@justinstrong9595 part of the bushido revival, and the responsable for much of the utter fanaticism and outright brutality of japanese troops in WWII, was carried out post WWI by ultra nationalists, who took it to it's most extreme manias.
The Knight’s Code of Chivalry. It differs between knight sects, but generally contain the same elements. The Code of Chivalry is still modified and adopted by warriors today. My last battalion has a code of chivalry that all NCOs and officers were required to swear to. I still live my life by said code despite being retired for ten years. The code of chivalry gave us a great advantage when we were fighting an insurgency. The code we swore to was a mix of old knights’ codes and tactics in counterinsurgency.
European Knights were literally thieves and brigands. That's literally why they started the crusades, in order to steal and rob the Arabs of the resources they had. European sense of "honor" will never be on the same level of Japanese honor.
"If you find yourself in a fair fight, you messed up."
I've always found Chivalry and Bushido to have a fascinating historical parallel: both developed when their respective warrior classes were in decline and needed something to bolster their prestige. Chivalry went from simply describing skill at fighting from horseback to emphasizing moral and ethical excellence in the later Middle Ages, after mounted knights had lost their unquestioned battlefield dominance over common-born infantrymen. In their turn, the samurai only developed an obsession with bushido after they became a legally-privileged yet increasingly impoverished warrior caste in a country at peace.
I don’t think knights ever lost their status of unquestioned dominance on the battlefield tbh, not until firearms became widespread and advanced enough to reliably pierce through plate armour.
Kings & Generals channel, you always catch me on the next one and I love yall for it
Bushido were created by rulers out of necessity. And the popular cultures that criticized and mocked them since Edo era are still undervalued
When times are harsh, warriors become more pragmatic. When times turn pacific, warriors come back to honor codes.
What if times turn Atlantic? 🤔
Even during the times of peace, some samurai would still kill civilians despite being innocent. Look it up.
"Tsujigiri", where samurai would commit murder to unarmed civillian just to test their new katana
@@hanshen3588pretty sure this was uncommon or rare and they actually used bodies of dead convicts. Farmers just don't grow out of trees
@@hanshen3588 that's rare and is considered a crime, no Daimyo would want their Samurai to go around killing all the taxpayers.
The animations and story telling are always top notch. A true inspiration to small history youtubers like myself
Great channel, bro, you gained 1 subscriber just noe
@@neversarium much appreciated:)
Amazing video. It's good that the Bushido code is getting some attention because reality is not black and white nor were the samurai in any era. Amazing art and animation. Thank you very much.
Much love for the hard work always.
in the end samurai is warrior that want to win. they will take AR-15 with holographic sight and red dot pointer if it available in 16th century instead of using sword or pike.
Of course, as they did with Tanegashima!
They even had hand-held cannons called Odzutsu and created modifications/enhancements to perfect the matchlock design
Oh, and in the 1800s gatling guns existed in Japan.. so....
Fictionalized Samurai: Nooo! Only fight with sword, its the only thing that's honorable!
Historical accurate Samurai: Haha matchlock go boom
Much like european knights. Actual warrior cultures tended to unsurprisingly use whatever they felt was best at battle at the time.
lol nearly all cultures embraced the way of the gun. Even the native americans used them when the colonizers arrived and the main reason they won Little Bighorn was because they bought new guns that Custer's army didn't have yet
Techno Samurai.
This is a comment to support this channel
Very interesting , especially the summary 14:35s onward ...it would be nice to see comperasion of bushido and medival European knights code . I was hoping to see it , similarities and differences
This is something that happens in all cultures, religions, and regions. There guidelines, books, and laws. The ideals and principles are there to follow it’s up to the people to make it a priority. Samurai & Knights had a code and some followed it and lived it others didn’t.
We need a Total War: Shogun 3!!!!!
We don't really
Why, so modern CA can ruin it with incredibly watered down mechanics and sell us more overpriced DLCs with a fraction of the content in them compared to older games (and attempt to threaten the players into buying them when they successfully boycott)?
Thank you as always for the video. I think every culture of warriors has a code of their own in some way or another ⚔️👊🏻
Openning video in Shogun 2 Total War depicts samurai perfectly.
Really interesting and well described really interesting story.
Thanks for this video Kings and GeneralsThe Samurai are so of the most feared warriors in history. Can you do a documentary about the WWI German stormtrooper.
Well syncronized, with last episod of Shogun... 😉
Amazing video!!!!!!!!!!!!! I agree almost 100%
Very interesting 👏👏👏👏
really nice documentary.
I just saw the shogun finale and no comment.........
私は日本人だが、戦国時代については小学生のころから遊んだゲームで学んだ。それから数十年経ったが、今でもやっぱりこの時代は面白い。この時代が好きすぎて、日本国内の城巡りも未だにやっている。私をこう言う人間に育てたゲームは光栄テクモの信長の野望シリーズ。今でも新しいシリーズが出れば遊ぶ。私はこの会社の関係者でもなんでもないが日本の戦国時代に興味があるのであればぜひプレイして当時の大名を体験して欲しい。この時代の沢山の武将にめぐりあえる。
Nah you are american weeb
素晴らしいアドバイスをありがとうございました
@@fincorrigan7139 このゲームのタイトルにもなっている織田信長の生涯は波乱に満ちていて本当に興味深い。その中でも特に｢桶狭間の戦い｣は凄い！世間では馬鹿息子として扱われていた小さな大名の若い信長でしたが、当時もっとも勢力の大きかった今川軍2万5000が攻めてきたときに信長はわずか3000の兵。誰もが勝てるわけが無いと思う戦い。ところが地形や気象、運までも味方しこの大軍の本陣を奇襲作戦で撃破する。この物語は日本では何度も戦国ドラマとして制作されています。
This video made me appreciate the work done by the writers of the 'Legend of the 5 Rings' RPG even more. There are many facets to a code of honor and that book greatly manages to show them to us.
The Bushido code was one of the elements which general Millán-Astray used to create a code for the Spanish "Legión", which he founded in 1920. This Army Corps is still part of the Spanish Army today.
Nice. 🎉
The Sengoku Jidai era was full of betrayal and that is a reason why I am very sceptical about Bushido. Oda Nobunaga dismantled the Ashikaga shogunate by usurping power in 1573. Nobunaga himself was forced to commit suicide when his general Akechi Mitsuhide betrayed him in 1582. Toyotomi Hideyoshi usurped the power of the Oda family after the death of Oda Nobunaga and unified the country. Tokugawa Ieyasu probably won the battle of Sekigahara in 1600 because many enemy generals like Kobayakawa Hideaki defected his side and betrayed Ishida Mitsunari. Ieyasu himself betrayed his oath to the Toyotomi family and usurped the power becoming the shogun.
What program did you use to make the animated map? Please help me
After Effects
Always love it when you cover A history of japan and its culture, but what happened with the Yakuza video that you promise many year ago? Did some Yakuza member threaten you to not make a video?
lmao
Very nice topic about the Samurai!
I'm looking at you, Yabushige
New Shogun tonight!
There seem to be a lot of parallels between Japanese Bushido and Medieval European codes of chivalry. Both were respected, but not always followed, and both were greatly exaggerated by later generations.
I think a big difference between the two is the outlook on death
Most chivalry codes outlined that it was better to live to fight another day, whereas Bushido code emphasized that only victory or death were acceptable.
3:07 yo history aside, did anybody feel this episode's artworks particular are insanely good?
Thanks!
An emblematic point about Bushido the book, was that it was originally published in English, in America, and then after gaining popularity did it get translated into Japanese. It was more about appealing to Western sensitivities, and portraying "Bushido" as a proto Christianity, which would lay a foundation for the morals of "western civilization" to enlighten Japan. Once it reached Japan, the Japanese were like, holy, those feudal lords who stole from and killed us and are emblematic of the government we overthrew are actually pretty cool, we should be more like them.
make a shogun playlist
Prior to viewing this video, the only version of Bushido I am familiar with is the WWII version where its considered dishonorable to surrender.
Great information, in depth exploration of the culture, myths, and facts. High quality content.
With respect, the blinding bright light as a transition makes the video painful to watch (ex. at 0:48). Too bright, hurts my eyes.
Everything else is awesome :)
If only they had anything resembling this "care for detail" in their other garbage videos on Japan that are more myth than fact (but still presented to you as fact).
"good, bad, I'm the guy with the gun." -- a samurai...probably.
Life in every breath
thanks for Viet-subs !
I hope im not the only one who read Bushito and thought of rap (therese a famous German rapper called Bushido)
Me Too
Sabaton . Bushido Dignified! Fiction's the Last Stand of the Samurai. Was the 1st thing to cross my mind
The show is so freaking good though
Next video korean kingdom Silla Hwarang warriors conquest of Japan.
So Nobutatsu's betrayal of Toranaga is accurate. Cool.
Samurai code is a lot like lane markers on a Thai expressway...suggestions.
there two types of warrior those who are willing to win even marked as a monster those retain virtues and moral in the face of death
Boom stick go boom, boom stick blow away dishonor :v
I would like an episode about the Hwarang warriors of Korea.
I think it’s worth mentioning this is the same code that led Japan to militarize and eventually engage in genocide across Asia
And eventually get their asses kicked by the Americans, British, and Soviets at the end of WWII.
@@malgusvitiate7002 Japan was literally fighting the entire alliance by themselves at that point, they also lack natural resources and manpower due to having small population and live on an island, so them losing is to be expected. On equal resource american ain't gonna win.
@@DccAnh
Bold statement.
It could easily go either way. Japanese had a tendency to severely underestimate US troops in the battles of the pacific and as a result were often slaughtered by disciplined opposition.
So Edo era Bushido ideals were just a call back to the ideals of the early Kamakura era, but on steroids? That's basically how I'm understanding it.
Plz make video on pashtunwali the code of honour ❤
Playing total war shogun 2 in the warring states period, and having your prince betray you when invested enormously into him😢
Oda Nabonaga broke that shit..and Oda surpass the unexpected success
I cannot dishonor my famari
Current day Yakuza culture is probably more similar to samurai.
Like
If their depiction in popular culture is anything to go by, than probably not. In the movie Harakiri there were even Ronins who showed up at the doors of clans asking to commit ritual suicide, but in reality they were hoping to be turned away with money.
Bushido Dignified! Fiction's the Last Stand of the Samurai
Why was no.47 pardoned?
Nice bedtime story
What's the difference between Bushido and chivalry?
Might makes right.
In the Shogun TV show, the seppuku (and attempted seppuku) to sword fight ratio is just about 1:1. Was seppuku really that common? The number of times people committed suicide, or were about to, seemed awfully high, like they just didn't care that much about the value of life.
I think it was often the way to allow your children to keep your lands/title. Alternative was the entire family executed/banished.
[Oleg Benesch intensifies]
In the name of the God-Empe-oops wrong channel
not really even if it is war hammer. the Japanese from 1868 until 1945 -1947 worshiped the Emperor as a living god. while the shoguns ruled Japan from 1185 to 1868. the Emperors were still seen as the son of heaven. the Emperors appointed or approved New shoguns but were figureheads both the Imperial court, the Samurai and Shoguns revered the Emperor though he had no real power but ceremony was important was the Emperor became head of the Shinto religion even likely before the Edo period.
The Youshido code implies that I leave this comment, in support of the channel.. (bow)
47 ronin wiped out the retinue and took no casualties during the attack?
We need a full Sengoku Jidai period documentary
I recommend the Shogunate´s long (more than 60 parts) documentary for you then.
@@FinnishDragon Is that a K&Gs vid?
@@justryan6480 Nope. That is the name of another UA-camr who is specialized in Sengoku Jidai history.
@@FinnishDragon Just found him, haha. Thank you so much. Although i must say i like K&Gs vids better, i like the battle map and the fact they use footage from Total War. But im watching The Shogunates vids either way. Thanks again :D
@@FinnishDragon The Shogunate's videos are full of bad history and his primary source for most videos is from a work infamous for its plagiarism and misinformation, and no, he isn't "specialized" in it, he just desperately wants to be seen that way. Stop expecting UA-cam to tell you history because you are too fucking lazy to read the proper material yourself.
Anyone else booting up shogun 2 total war after watching Shogun?
Me
I'm very curious, where is the Shinobis at this Medieval Japan Period 😂😂????
Myth.
Always in the shadows.
Ninja clans usually had worked for daimyos as staffing agencies
Samurai honor..... Daimyos took hostages when forming alliance because they didn't trust their ally to uphold their ends of the agreement.... The guise of honor imo is due to Seppuku..... but even that is so that the family of the samurai doesn't share in their "dishonor" whatever that may be which would leave them ostracized or even killed... There's no "honor" it's all opportunism and lacking of choice........ I'm certain if they had the choice to live and keep their honor after failure, they'd take it.......
1:00 "He (Asai Nagamasa) prayed to the gods that this was the right decision". Spoilers: It was not.
If you cant' beat 'em, join 'em...until you can beat them.
ほこりを噛む「KILLER QUEEN - Yoshinaka Kira
Do a rajput code of honour.
Honestly the impression I got from reading and watching all relevant material is a resounding no.
ok
When the Imperial government perverted bushido to discourage surrender in WWII, it was a great tragedy.
They were nuanced like everyone else. Some behaved exactly like that and others didn't. It would be wrong to say it was one or the other
🗡🗡🗡🧙🏻♂
What particular warrior code would lead the japanes soldier to do such atrocities?! If they would have been honorable to their enemies instead of treating them like shit they might have better chance of winning.
Poor chain of command. Unironically, there were some IJA generals that were executed after WW2 even though they didn't support the war crimes only because they failed to stop them. After the fall of Bataan, the Japanese actually treated the American prisoners fairly. The fact the IJA high command were so pathetic in restoring order only snowballed into more soldiers committing war crimes. Pre-WW2 treatment of Japanese soldiers to enemies were actually quite nice and they cooperated with the Red Cross. Such a shame nationalism and chauvinism destroyed their legacy.
Isn't dethroning the Emperor an act of treachery?
No, if the emperor wronged the lord of the dethroner
✌️
Ninjutcu do.
They were overly romanticized
i dont think the SAmurai follow Bushido especially since the rise of tension with Arafat Abou Chaker
Aywa Berliiiin was geht?😂😂😂😂 Hab nur darauf gewartet aus der Deutschen Community ❤️❤️❤️
wat lmao japan was isolated til the middleages
@@liukang3545 ?
There was never a true Standard Bushido
First!!!!
Japanese and Arabs were too badass before age of modernization
Honestly the arabb were dope fighters until they started hiring turks..then everything sort if went downhill for them image wise as lest
@@kakun723 Same with Japanese before they got humbled by US
Can you make videos about sui tang vs Goguryeo.
How millions of Chinese failed invasions of Korea.
Make a video explaining how Korea’s been nothing but a vassal state for its entire existence.
No, they weren't!... nor did the knights followed any ''code''... a prick with a stick is a prick with a stick!...
Bullshitdo
don’t think this video was needed as they chop off a guys head just for praying in the first episode