I've never understood why players and managers cannot argue balls and strikes. Umpires get to blow a call, then throw out the person fans paid to see for complaining. Nobody ever went to a game to see an umpire.
There needs to be a new rule. Managers cannot be ejected from game. They can be fined by the league for arguing balls/strikes, disputed plays, but cannot be ejected. Three to five times in a season a manager can eject for cause an umpire. The umpire misses the rest of that game. Additionally the entire crew misses the next game. Cooler heads need to prevail. Robo balls & strikes are past due. Definition accuracy is irrelevant. Consistency, which is easily determinable before the season starts, is entirely achievable.
I get the feeling that if managers get to eject an umpire, Angel Hernandez is gonna get dinged a lot. But until managers and players all have perfect games, they need to sit down, and shut up. None of them are perfect, umpires are flawed humans just like them, they will make bad plays. Some of the managers and players are acting like spoiled little children when arguing a bad call, and that needs to stop. That's why none of what you said would be implemented.
@@PapaVanTwee5 How can you know whether a player can play, or a manager manage, a perfect game without a perfect call. You've got it exactly backwards. Without perfect adjudication, you a priori take away the possibility of a player executing perfectly in each presented situation. Such a thing is possible, but it is the essence of baseball to make the other player "make the play." If you can't be sure it will be adjudicated accurately then your separation of the two realities is curious if not silly.
It happened on July 23, 1917, and the player was Babe Ruth who was pitching for the Red Sox. After getting thrown out for arguing after walking the first batter, Ruth punched out the ump. The runner got thrown out trying to steal. Then Ernie Shore, the pitcher who relieved Ruth proceeded to retire the next 26 batters. ua-cam.com/video/PpfrFPfsuIg/v-deo.html
The base line is defined by the path taken by the runner at the time of the actual play being made, not some chalkline on the diamond. If the runner had take a wid circular path around third then coming in at as much as a 20º angle is entirely possible.
@@jamesoliver6625 Not base line, base path.and he was still out of that (3 foot outside line between himself and home when fielder starts motion with ball to tag.)
@@PapaVanTwee5 the chalked line has nothiing in particular to do with "base path". Base bath is defined as a straight line from where the runner is and the base at the moment the actual ply is commenced, usually the moment the fielder receives the ball priot to th tag play. Given that, he was within his base path.
I've never understood why players and managers cannot argue balls and strikes. Umpires get to blow a call, then throw out the person fans paid to see for complaining. Nobody ever went to a game to see an umpire.
Blue has really gotten soft.
They get there panties in a bunch really fast
Oli and Nado's ejections were ridiculous
In the game between the Nationals and the Mariners it was the right call by the home plate umpire
What’s with the editing?
There needs to be a way to remove an umpire. Or they'll be out of a job to AI.
36th
There needs to be a new rule. Managers cannot be ejected from game. They can be fined by the league for arguing balls/strikes, disputed plays, but cannot be ejected. Three to five times in a season a manager can eject for cause an umpire. The umpire misses the rest of that game. Additionally the entire crew misses the next game. Cooler heads need to prevail. Robo balls & strikes are past due. Definition accuracy is irrelevant. Consistency, which is easily determinable before the season starts, is entirely achievable.
I get the feeling that if managers get to eject an umpire, Angel Hernandez is gonna get dinged a lot.
But until managers and players all have perfect games, they need to sit down, and shut up. None of them are perfect, umpires are flawed humans just like them, they will make bad plays. Some of the managers and players are acting like spoiled little children when arguing a bad call, and that needs to stop. That's why none of what you said would be implemented.
@@PapaVanTwee5 How can you know whether a player can play, or a manager manage, a perfect game without a perfect call. You've got it exactly backwards. Without perfect adjudication, you a priori take away the possibility of a player executing perfectly in each presented situation. Such a thing is possible, but it is the essence of baseball to make the other player "make the play." If you can't be sure it will be adjudicated accurately then your separation of the two realities is curious if not silly.
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
goofy ah
Poorly put together video
stop hating
I want someone to just lay out an umpire one day. Wait for en egrigious call and just punch one of them in the mouth.
It happened on July 23, 1917, and the player was Babe Ruth who was pitching for the Red Sox. After getting thrown out for arguing after walking the first batter, Ruth punched out the ump. The runner got thrown out trying to steal. Then Ernie Shore, the pitcher who relieved Ruth proceeded to retire the next 26 batters. ua-cam.com/video/PpfrFPfsuIg/v-deo.html
Look at 1:26 -- the runner's in the grass.
The base line is defined by the path taken by the runner at the time of the actual play being made, not some chalkline on the diamond. If the runner had take a wid circular path around third then coming in at as much as a 20º angle is entirely possible.
@@jamesoliver6625 Not base line, base path.and he was still out of that (3 foot outside line between himself and home when fielder starts motion with ball to tag.)
@@PapaVanTwee5 the chalked line has nothiing in particular to do with "base path". Base bath is defined as a straight line from where the runner is and the base at the moment the actual ply is commenced, usually the moment the fielder receives the ball priot to th tag play. Given that, he was within his base path.
Your gone
Good calls to me
There were some questionable strike/ball calls, but it's mostly children throwing tantrums and getting thrown out for no reason.