Fully 3D Printed NAS Case... toolless and without need for metal screws!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 87

  • @jaxspider
    @jaxspider 8 місяців тому +11

    Talk about a great first video. Bravo.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому +1

      Thank you! Means a lot.

  • @chrismay2298
    @chrismay2298 5 місяців тому +4

    Very nice work! Been printing some caddies and trays to do two 3 disk arrays and now I'm going to shift my deltas over to print this case. Subbed.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  5 місяців тому +1

      awesome! would love to see your end result or if you have any questions, shoot me a message on discord "andrewe1". Cheers!

  • @Haki1112
    @Haki1112 5 місяців тому +3

    Will be building this in the next few days. This design is amazing. Edit: Just realized I had a mATX board and can't use the design ={

  • @outrageousotis454
    @outrageousotis454 Місяць тому

    I got this cabinet now and it was so much fun to build in. Only real "issue" was the area for GPU was too small. My Sparkle Intel Arc 310 Elf should fit, but had to take off the fan shroud. Because of this, i would recommend the low-profile version with the high-profile bracket, A310 ECO or A380 Genie. But it's all good. Running TrueNAS, disks are very well cooled, 30-32c. I use cpu cooler NH-U9S and it was too tall, so had to clip out a hole for it through the grill. The case is very well designed, and well worth the $10 for the design.

  • @RafaelSoaresP
    @RafaelSoaresP 8 місяців тому +8

    This is AMAZING! Kudos for the design.

  • @leemyers8407
    @leemyers8407 8 місяців тому +8

    If hadn't already built an NAS, it would be tempting.

  • @patrickfutato6555
    @patrickfutato6555 6 місяців тому +1

    This is one of the coolest 3D prints I’ve seen. Great design!

  • @AlphaConde-qy7vi
    @AlphaConde-qy7vi 2 місяці тому

    Woah, now that's an outlier of a NAS case ! Unconventional shape, but certainly seems to work. Great job 💪

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  2 місяці тому +1

      thank you for your comment! I agree the shape is unconventional, but you have to understand that this was designed from the inside out, since you have to work within the limitations of what a 3d printer can do...I basically solved for the important stuff which was holding everything together and being easy to assemble, and then building a shell around it...all without exceeding a small print area of around 22x25 centimeters and not abuse the amount of material used.

  • @stevobox8726
    @stevobox8726 7 місяців тому +1

    Please make more things! I just love the industrial design of this

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому

      Thank you so much for your comment

  • @matjam421
    @matjam421 7 місяців тому +3

    This is a very good and well thought out design. Very clever. Great job! I really need to get a 3D printer lol

  • @TRiToNDREyJA
    @TRiToNDREyJA 6 місяців тому

    This case is awesome! Wow!
    Very inspired now to make the 6 or 8 bay version of my own case now.
    It currently is a full ATX 16-bay case with toolless drive caddies and removable fan wall modules, but id like to eliminate the need for superglue altogether. I have designed locking pins that handle this for the chassis, but the drive bays at the front still need glue.
    After seeing what youve done here, im excited to see what i can come up with when i do a compact design from scratch, where i can better integrate slots for my snap-latch caddies 🙂

  • @robbertbletterman
    @robbertbletterman 2 місяці тому

    Very nice to print and built this, i have running xpenology on this nas.

  • @mitchitv
    @mitchitv 6 місяців тому +1

    Looks awesome. I hope you can design an MATX NAS case next.

  • @adamturtle69
    @adamturtle69 2 місяці тому

    Awesome!!!😍

  • @J0ermungand
    @J0ermungand 7 місяців тому

    *subscribed* this is an amazing design in terms of utility, ease of use and toughness. I am hoping you'll make more videos about future projects.

  • @DaliborKezele
    @DaliborKezele 27 днів тому

    Amazing work, best one I've seen so far
    However, I'm all into smaller builds, and would gladly buy a version with sfx psu and low profile brackets on motherboard side (enough for something like LSI9211) if you ever decide to make it.

  • @ewhac
    @ewhac 2 місяці тому +1

    Only addition I would make is a place to put drive activity LEDs.

  • @YeahNoTellTheTruth
    @YeahNoTellTheTruth 16 днів тому

    Fantastic

  • @johngelnaw1243
    @johngelnaw1243 8 місяців тому +2

    Very nice! If I hadn't already built my NAS in an 8 bay case, I'd be downloading this as I type this.
    Regardless, that's a very well thought out case.

  • @ashman2023
    @ashman2023 4 місяці тому

    Sick but I can't afford the $10. Someday maybe :) Great video!

  • @YannMetalhead
    @YannMetalhead 6 місяців тому +1

    Great project!

  • @TheKd4lyfe
    @TheKd4lyfe 3 місяці тому

    Ok I know what I’m doing for a NAS now!

  • @FrodeBergetonNilsen
    @FrodeBergetonNilsen 18 днів тому

    Not bad. This was a ton of work.
    Never seen anyone using this size screw of printed nuts and bolt before. Is that M18 or M20? How did you deal with the tolerances?
    How did you go from Fusion assembly to this video?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  18 днів тому

      Thanks for your comment, screw size is arbitrary... I started experimenting with printed bolts and screws a few years ago and this size felt really solid so I've reused it on a lot of my designs. Tolerances are dealt with the same way as everybody that designs 3d printed parts that assemble with each other does, just account for +-.10-.15mm on everything. Tolerances are usually not a problem unless you have a badly calibrated printer.
      Not sure I understand your last question, but to try to answer it, with lot's of prototyping and tweaking. I started with the core of the case and checking fit of the components and then worked my way out. I 3d scanned some parts like the motherboard as I couldn't easily find accurate CAD models.

    • @FrodeBergetonNilsen
      @FrodeBergetonNilsen 18 днів тому

      @@replicrafts I use regular M screws. I just scale down the threads in width to 98%. That requires tapping of the female. If you use 97%, there is hardly any need for tapping, you may print a tapper and use it if needed. But it is a hazzle. Line height is a nightmare for a 0.6 nozzle, and no matter what I do, for PETG the speed needs to be slooooow.
      As for the other part, from the other video, you do design i Fusion. But this video uses illustrations of them CAD parts, as they are assembled. I haven't looked into that yet myself, and was wondering how you got the modeled parts animated in the video. That is a more a video tech question, not so much printing. It is the animation itself, of the CAD model I find nice, just wondering what the workflow was, to make it.
      Also, mesh is best printed as infill. It is seriously hard to master, but once you realize how hard infill actually is to print, you simply learn to dial the speed way down. That is when the party begins. It is insanely easier to model for.
      For visualization in cad, that may be done too, but modeling mesh is a complete nightmare. I have this one assembly of mine, that uses more than 120GB of RAM. I actually ran out of RAM, even with 128GB installed. It just runs super slow, as Fusion only uses two treads. Just make sure to use wide enough line width, and slow enough speed. Also, bed adhesion is kind of a different universe with this method, as is ABL, which really needs to be disabled for the type of parts you print.
      Anyway, your style of design, is not really that different than mine. Depending on if you are able to get up to speed, you probably will find that you fit right in with the work that I have done. Which is a ton.
      You probably know how much work goes into this by know, so hopefully you get how much I have put into mine, once you see it.
      I really don't know much about you, but nobody seem to really design for print. Not with the intention to learn to exploit this production method. It is kind of up for grabs. To be honest, it is really refreshing seeing somebody putting in an effort like you have here, and in particular, actually use plastic screws and plastic nuts. That is a first, beyond my own work.
      So if you get up to speed, we really should see how we could help each other out. You will get what I mean, when my work finally gets out.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  18 днів тому

      @ Ah you meant the video rendering. That was done in 3ds Max, which lets you import fusion parts natively.
      You touch on a lot of points, I have gotten a ton of feedback from people that have printed theirs, there have been barely, if any, comments regarding the actual print and assembly process of the case. Most of the feedback or critique comes down to design choices, some of them having to be made due to print volume limitations.
      In the end, I designed this case for me since I couldn’t find one that fit my needs. I just decided to publish it after sharing some photos on reddit and have people comment on it.
      To be honest, the manual and documentation took me longer to do than the actual case, but thats because I find that last process boring and tedious…

    • @FrodeBergetonNilsen
      @FrodeBergetonNilsen 17 днів тому

      @@replicrafts Thanks. If you decide to dig into this, you will probably do well. But I am to go pro on this, releasing commercial products that are printed. There is a market that is up for grabs.

  • @Cary_mac
    @Cary_mac 4 місяці тому

    What I can say is this. I do enjoy this design for the interior aspects. Everything for quick assembly, adequate space and 6+2 design? Fantastic. What I can say is some of the exterior is just hideous. I get that it’s functional but looking at certain sides? Woof.

  • @peteratkin3788
    @peteratkin3788 7 місяців тому

    Love it, well done.

  • @redsword98
    @redsword98 8 місяців тому +3

    Very nice job, liked commented, shared and subscribed

  • @salehabualasal
    @salehabualasal 5 місяців тому

    Cool design .. do the HDDs get enough air flow? .. what is the max temp?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  5 місяців тому

      Yeah, there are 2 fans dedicated to blowing air through them. Average temps are 35-40 C... In the hottest days of summer, a stubborn 8 year old WD RED 8TB reached 45C... that drive likes to run hotter than my newer RED 16TB's. Thx for your comment!

  • @danthompsett2894
    @danthompsett2894 7 місяців тому +1

    what a lovely design, could it be done in aluminium and what about standard ATX, E-ATX and Server Sized Motherboard versions?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +2

      Thanks for your comment… Aluminum with that level of complexity is not something an individual can do so at that point a commercial solution is a better option.

  • @Alen.88
    @Alen.88 7 місяців тому +1

    Amazing. Do you plan to build something similar for mATX motherboard? To be able to accomodate GPU, HBA and network card? Thank you.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +1

      So I've gotten this question quite a few times... To be honest, it would be too resource intensive to make a 3d printed case that fits mATX when the common print area is just around 250x250 mm. So current 3d printing limitations would make something niche even more niche and it's hard to dedicate time to that...but never say never.
      This case already has support for a dual-slot PCIe expansion card btw. Won't fit a full-size video card but there are many smaller solutions that will.
      Thx for your comment

  • @CampRusso
    @CampRusso 7 місяців тому

    This is awesome! Wish I had a 3D printer. Do you think any parts might sag from any heat sources? 🤔

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +2

      Warping/sagging is not an issue if you use petg!

    • @CampRusso
      @CampRusso 7 місяців тому

      @@replicrafts Ah, did not know that. #3dprintnoob 😁👍

  • @anthonyjobson
    @anthonyjobson 5 місяців тому

    Amazing case.
    Is it possible to print multiples of the centre HDD piece so you can have two or more rows of HDD for larger capacity NAS cases?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  5 місяців тому +1

      an extended caddie was planned for 2 extra hdd’s, however time constraints have not allowed me to design it. The files include the fusion 360 files though so anyone can try and add stuff to fit their needs. Thx for the comment!

  • @cynikalX
    @cynikalX 2 місяці тому

    Wow i have to say, this is quite incredible!! Alas i'm no longer using 3.5" drives, instead i have 2(boot)+10(data) = 12x drives (all 2.5" SSD's, about 7mm high), and i just ordered a pair of enclosures (IcyDock MB608SP) that hold 6-drives each, in a 5.25" form-factor. Do you provide the design files i could modify for redesigning the center portion that is expecting 3.5" drives? I also don't need the fan part underneath, as each enclosure has its own fan. What did you use to design this, something like Fusion or Solidworks? Assuming it's a parametric modeler, i should be able to just adjust the dimensions that are inputs to the design, right?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  2 місяці тому

      @@cynikalX fusion360 files are included in the download, see my other video. cheers!

  • @Castor586
    @Castor586 5 місяців тому

    Which motherboard would you recommend using?

  • @ewasteredux
    @ewasteredux 10 днів тому

    I like this design but I want to put a gtx1660 GPU in the unit. Will it fit?

  • @seethruhead7119
    @seethruhead7119 8 місяців тому +1

    feel like this could take some cues from the silverstone ds380 which packs in 8 drives in a smaller space

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому +4

      More drives meant sacrificing full-atx psu like the ds380 does, which is something I didnt want to do. This was never meant to compete with a commercial product though, I wanted a toolless nas case that would make swapping components as easy as possible and there werent any solutions for my particular needs, and decided to share the design for anybody that wanted to try something different…

  • @creepy_utka
    @creepy_utka 7 місяців тому +1

    Отличный получился корпус.
    Сколько времени прошло с момента как ты продумывал это в голове до реализации?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +1

      Thanks, around 6 months from idea to final implementation I would think. Having a single 3d printer didn’t help with the times though.

  • @kabalu
    @kabalu Місяць тому

    this just with 14 2.5" ssds would be nice

  • @SirLANsalot
    @SirLANsalot 7 місяців тому

    For something like this I would highly suggest the use of ASA for the better heat resistance, epically if you put in a higher end GPU that is going to get hot.
    PLA's glass transition point is only about 70c before it starts to get soft, so I would not suggest using PLA for a computer case.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +1

      I agree PLA is not a good idea, that's why I recommended PETG which is what I've been using and is more than enough for this application.

    • @SirLANsalot
      @SirLANsalot 7 місяців тому

      @@replicrafts I generally just skip PETG and go to ASA, if its not going to work in PLA, I just go to ASA even if its slightly overkill. Its not like PETG isn't good, and a new one on the market called PCTG is almost the best of everything. Almost a perfect filament (check out Zack Freidmans videos about filament, his ranking one talks about PCTG).

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому

      @@SirLANsalot Thanks for the tip, PETG has been so easy to use for me that I've not looked into other filaments. Will look into ASA.

  • @AnupamVipul
    @AnupamVipul 2 місяці тому

    how the heck u made a better system the 45Drives HL8 I they had money and metal and COST . All they built it hyper small box with tiny fans and FLEX ATX powersupply & tiny fans

  • @hatoffnickel
    @hatoffnickel 6 місяців тому

    That's sweet

  • @crissnickers_frog6689
    @crissnickers_frog6689 4 місяці тому

    best ever, handles?

  • @crabbypaddy5549
    @crabbypaddy5549 Місяць тому

    my ender 3 has 310 x 320 mm print area. I think it would work?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  Місяць тому

      It won't, i'm sorry... working on a version that will...no ETA though, those missing millimeters really complicate things.

  • @testheyaccount4910
    @testheyaccount4910 8 днів тому

  • @dktol56
    @dktol56 8 місяців тому +2

    Have you considered the following variation on your design? Instead of individual 3.5" drive bays, each holding a drive in a caddy, provide space to slide in one of the existing commercial 4 or 5 drive bay enclosures that has a SATA/SAS hotswap backplane - these usually are designed for adjacent 3x 5.25" optical bays in conventional older PC tower cases (like Antec). This removes the mess of SATA power and data cables running to the individual drives. Instead the power and data are routed to the backplane from the rear of the enclosure, which typically has its own cooling fan. The main downside is that you lose 1 or 2 drives over your existing design. I purchased a 4 bay Athena Power enclosure (on sale from newegg) that has toolless drive bays, 2 SATA power connectors and a MiniSAS SFF-8643 data connector on the back side. Very cool, and the MiniSAS connector supports 12Gbps SAS 3 if I use an HBA that supports it. I envision one of these sliding "toaster style" into a modified version of your case. What do you think?

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому +2

      Thanks so much for your comment.
      So one of the challenges I wanted to do was to have something that worked and was fully 3d printed. The minute you start adding off-the-shelf parts then the design becomes a little more complicated since those parts might be hard to get, discontinued, or have variations.
      Don’t get me wrong though… suggestions like yours would certainly make the design better in some ways as 3d printing quality is just not able to compete with mass-produced products. I certainly would like to have variations to the case with suggestions like yours but at the moment I cannot afford to invest more time in something that is very niche.
      I want to get some other ideas out before going back to this case… I am working on releasing the CAD files though, that way people can take the design and make it theirs or adjust it to their needs.
      There are many ways to improve the design, I just wanted to set the baseline for something that was completely different to other 3d printed offerings, as I have never seen another 3d printed case that’s held together by 3d printed parts.
      Cheers!

    • @dktol56
      @dktol56 8 місяців тому +1

      @@replicrafts Thanks for the quick reply! I appreciate your goal in this NAS case, and the results are excellent. You clearly spent a LOT of time refining the design and it shows. Definitely worth the $10 for the print files. I especially appreciate your detailed documentation. I've seen some other cool printed NAS cases on youtube and printables, but the instructions and pictures are somewhat lacking. Maybe not a problem for those experienced in 3D printing, but I have 0 experience and no printer - the learning curve looks steep, and I have some other priorities at this time. Maybe later.
      As far as these 4 or 5 drive bay enclosures with hotswap backplanes, they are quite common (on Amazon and Newegg) and have standard dimensions defined by 3 x 5.25" (legacy) optical drive bays. Strictly speaking, two of the dimensions are restrained by the PC case standards, but the depth can vary somewhat depending on the size of the cooling fan in the back. For many people building their own NAS, a hotswap backplane with easy drive access has become a common requirement, so this seemed like a straightforward way to incorporate this feature into your design.
      I look forward to your future case modifications. You might check out the NASCompares youtube channel for some ideas. Cheers!

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому

      @@dktol56 Appreciate the compliments on the manual, believe it or not the model was ready since summer of last year, I had just put off the release because I wanted to do a proper manual and since it's not exactly a fun task, I kept putting it off lol.
      Thanks for your comment and hopefully the design will be of use to you in the future.

  • @nielsvanosch3924
    @nielsvanosch3924 8 місяців тому

    Are there any plans for a 4 bay one? It costs me 280$ to only order the parts that dont fit on my own printer :(, I don't know anything about splitting the parts..

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому

      Sorry but no plans of a smaller yet… I’m soon releasing the cad files so people mod as they please tho.

  • @unabatedshagie
    @unabatedshagie 8 місяців тому +2

    If only I had a 3D printer....

    • @playeronthebeat
      @playeronthebeat 8 місяців тому

      Bought mine last year. One of the best and coolest purchases I made the entire last year!

  • @johnboling
    @johnboling 8 місяців тому

    This is super dope!

  • @vlottech
    @vlottech 8 місяців тому

    *cries in ender 3 v3 ke*
    it is 240mm vertical though. maybe it could work. think ill give it a try or maybe you could make a ender 3 friendly version

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  8 місяців тому

      parts are designed to be printed in a specific orientation, you would be better off splicing the parts but like I said, its untested and not recommended. Making it fit the ender 3 would mean sacrificing two drives, which was not the design goal.

  • @teaspoon966
    @teaspoon966 8 місяців тому

    Pretty cool.

  • @an0n0mus0ne
    @an0n0mus0ne 8 місяців тому

    Impressive

  • @BoraHorzaGobuchul
    @BoraHorzaGobuchul 7 місяців тому

    Good design, hdds separate from the board and well cooled. Still, limited to mitx... Unless you're space constrained, see no real need to do that. Much more hassle to build and cable manage, much less capable boards, few bays.

    • @replicrafts
      @replicrafts  7 місяців тому +2

      I wanted something compact that wasn't a pain to disassemble (had a fractal 304), and that was completely toolless to make component swap as fast as possible as uptime was the priority... I couldn't find any commercial options that fit my needs so I tried to make it myself. So far it has met all my expectations and of some people close to me, hope it does the same for anybody else that thinks it could be useful to them.
      In the end, it's just another option for anybody that is interested in a home server/NAS.
      thx for the comment

    • @BoraHorzaGobuchul
      @BoraHorzaGobuchul 7 місяців тому

      @@replicrafts I have had a node 304 and I feel you :)
      For me, anything smaller than an eatx tower is too small to bother building in. Don't appreciate working in tight spaces.

  • @Pancho4217
    @Pancho4217 8 місяців тому +1

    Having trouble finding mini itx supporting 6 SATA most under $100 are 2 ,or 4 but at SATA 2 speeds.If I spend $200+ for mobo i might as well build full size PC fro ML/AI.

    • @johngelnaw1243
      @johngelnaw1243 8 місяців тому +2

      Or you could buy an HBA card. I'm running an LSI 9300-8i in my NAS ($80).

    • @maTTkogusgus
      @maTTkogusgus 7 місяців тому

      If you will do not use m.2 slot for nvme search google for asmedia asm1166 m.2

    • @HksF16
      @HksF16 6 місяців тому

      @@johngelnaw1243 who is ripping you off? i found it for $38 including sas cables

  • @TheRoholm
    @TheRoholm Місяць тому

    *Sad Ender 3 noises*

  • @weasel101
    @weasel101 6 місяців тому

    Nice! But why are we 3d printing to slap HDDs into? SSDs or bust. Shave weight, heat, etc