Ms Russell is clearly not someone who has an interest in solutions to problems. The manner of questioning and the repetition was just rude with no interest in hearing any answers. Most Kiwis are over this kind of churlish time-wasting.
Absolutely agree we are desperate to get things moving and if Labour and others think they are being clever trying to create "gotcha answer me" moments and time waste to slow things down they will gain no friends, even among their own kind who are also desperate to see the country move again...
Trying to educate Chloe must be tiring 😫 3 woman questioning who have NO idea.... they think they are clever. Jacinda was the queen of not answering a question and these clowns are childish witches 😊
The Hon. Nicola Willis wonderfully kept her cool and at one time couldn't stop herself laughing at the loud gaggle of Geese confronting her! The Hon. Dr. Deborah Russell was demanding, rude and aggressive. Where was the Chairman? Keep on track, Nicola!
She was exactly the same towards women submitting against the sex self ID bill. Becoming blonde hasn't changed anything she's just a nasty piece of work
Absolutely, the witches of Eastwick were out of control, because the chairman wasn't in control. Nicola was as professional as those three cows were unprofessional
What a garbled babble from Russell all puffed up with an ego larger than her brain - the only thing larger than her ego was her mouth - it never stopped ... rude. obnoxious and full of self importance.. showing her extreme ignorance and proving she does not belong on such a panel. She simply never shut her loud mouth constantly talking over the answers to the questions she had rudely demanded answers to... There are often no Yes or No straight answers when talking about planning and forecasting around finance - many factors have to be taken into account ... anyone with knowledge knows this. Thank you Nicola Wills for being so professional I found what you had to say very clear, heartening and I feel a lot more confident for the future with you at the helm. As for Russell try getting a job in the local fish market... your loud shouting mouth would be acceptable there!
It's ridiculous not eveen childish just plain silly n unintelligent overplayed and overrated ppl who run this country got no ideas and all the admiring try hards who pretend to be the voice of the people with their imposing make me sick ...
I wouldn't call Deborah Russell as Hon Dr Deborah Russell, she was a disgrace, rude, and showed she's not fit to be on this committee, have to admit Chloe handled her behavior rather well and looked embarrassed on how Deborah Russell was behaving.
Where are the pragmatic males? The Government must untangle the Maori Racist Legal Web that has Government Departments confused with budgets. The previous NZ Labour Party tied spending onto a race-based legislation.
well done Nicola, a politician talking facts, not just economics Nicola, the ongoing exodus is understandable , why would the average kiwi want to strive for success, in a country that looks like it may snach failure from the jaws of success with race based racist crap, and not sorting the treaty issue , and this is best done through education ,
I for one would like to see an amendment to MMP voting. Add a third vote to let the people decide who can never stand for parliament again, in any capacity.
The Dr Russell "Look at me, Look at me. I'm not bound by the Chairpersons Rules and I don't care if I'm an embarrassment to this discussion or you peasants" Bully, Can't handle criticism, weak..
Being a Kindergarten Teacher is exhausting for this poor man. The adult in the room handled the kids very well I thought. It was way over the kids head and they didn't like it so they start behaving like the little children they REALLY ARE!!
Very disappointing behaviour from our elected representatives. There is a lesson for the questioner to, at some point, stop talking so they may hear, and learn, from an answer - don't you think?
Well if the Maoris didn't get given $800 million of taxpayers money last year. New zealand wouldn't be in so much shit like it is now. All these special benefits for Maoris has to stop to get nz moving forward not backwards all the time. Labour greens govt has alot to answer to. The govt has to get taxes down fuel down and cost of living down and stop special benefits to Maoris. To get people to start to think about staying in nz
@Longtack55 Did you also learn that not everyone speaks English as their first language? Do you know what a typo is? Do you know that a UA-cam is a comments section and not a legal document and it doesn't matter?
Poor Nicola,trying bloody hard to answer the questions,whilst putting up with the usual left wing woke ridiculousness🥴...give the girl a break🤔🥺...not all questions require just a Yes or No❗
Deborah Russell is the very example of an academic Labourite who actually was a part of the the previous government’s failure into reigning back the ridiculous waste of tax payer dollars & left NZ broke. What a legacy from a qualified accountant. Rest my case.
Bro government members should be on a performance based pay system. Not to mention fingers in private enterprise. If you're growing wealth whilst working for the people........ That is fraudulent you should be subject to the proceeds of crime act!
I would be quite happy with her and Brook Van Velden as PM and Deputy PM (in either order). Not only do I think they are the best qualified for the job, it should go a long way to reminding people that women who earn their places on merit make excellent leaders.
It never ceases to amaze me that people in parliament think money grows on trees and you never have to pay back debt just keep on spending . Chloe is a prime example of this stupidity.
I'm not a national supporter, but this really reminded me of the level headedness we've seen out of David Seymor during the introduction of the TPB to parliament. Champion level of patience and adequate composure from Nicola Willis is on display here.
I have to give my grudging respect to Crazy Chlöe. She called for the ten minutes, let Dozy Deborah embarrass herself and non verbally turned her back on DD, admitted she agreed with the minister just disputed the way it was dealt with (if she could loose the hard left stance there is some potential for an adequate politician). If she keeps this up I may have to start calling her Crafty Chlöe.
I wish well, but I doubt she can grow the economy significantly without removing the key impediment: Heavy handed central and local bureaucracy. We need to reduce the bureaucratic burden and the bureaucrats that impose it.
30 million for teachers that can't be trained to be retrained is by way a waste of $$$ Nicola is ensuring tax payers are scamed yet again. Im not left nor right but great with figures & geopolitics. Any silly spending gets a 👎
You can see that if that Russell individual's party was in power now that this country would be by now Broke & the danger of all out Civil Disobedience would be about occur. Incredible to be able to see just how unhinged & without any sign of being a professional in the role she has she's completely lost. Quite something to witness indeed.
Nicola is one VERY smart cookine!! Chloe seems to be slowly, oh so VERY slowly learning from her. Probably unwillingly, but she is getting better. Give her 15 more years or so.
Yep, the decision regarding the ferries was a master stroke that has saved the country billions. Possibly more. They need to treat all the other portfolios and decisions the same. Imagine how much they could save if they cut health and education entirely.
If the cost of fuel was cheaper there would be a knockon affect of cheaper product, marsdon point oil refinery which was shut down by labour kept our gas prices down, labour has a habbit of doing dumb stuff. Look at uk and Canada.
The people on the ground have the solutions so put into them biz analyst roles that actually know what needs to proceed for best outcomes don't need a Phd or MBA or a degree to understand unless you have been served on a golden plate all your life
Cant watch this rubbish, Nicola did an amazing. Self important people who have on idea how to listen to answers which is not constructive, only verbal abuse.
I agree... LABOUR wasted millions of taxpayer dollars on signing a deal on ferries that were too big for the ports.Now the coalition are being painted as bad guys for cancelling a deal that was STUPID to start with!?Typical Labour Govt-Big on promises and low on achievement.Ardern & Robertson both scuttled away before the full effects of their fiscal incompetence came to light.... into well paid alternative employment.
I think Willis is dangerous to New Zealand. While health, police, environmental protection, and military expenditures should not be cut, the rest of the government civil service is way too bloated. We also need less expenditure on vanity projects like Roads of "Significance".
Ms Russell is clearly not someone who has an interest in solutions to problems. The manner of questioning and the repetition was just rude with no interest in hearing any answers. Most Kiwis are over this kind of churlish time-wasting.
100% agree
Absolutely agree we are desperate to get things moving and if Labour and others think they are being clever trying to create "gotcha answer me" moments and time waste to slow things down they will gain no friends, even among their own kind who are also desperate to see the country move again...
totally.. She should be on charges for arrogance.
Trying to educate Chloe must be tiring 😫
3 woman questioning who have NO idea.... they think they are clever.
Jacinda was the queen of not answering a question and these clowns are childish witches 😊
Trust a Labour MP to screech about needing a yes/no answer distilled from a comprehensive response
Especially when labour could never give a straight yes or no answer. Pot calling kettle black
yes /no is the maxed out level of her intellect
Rude woman sounds just like the rude moari party 😢😢😢
Sounds a bit like the defeated Demoncrats 😅
The Hon. Nicola Willis wonderfully kept her cool and at one time couldn't stop herself laughing at the loud gaggle of Geese confronting her!
The Hon. Dr. Deborah Russell was demanding, rude and aggressive.
Where was the Chairman?
Keep on track, Nicola!
She was exactly the same towards women submitting against the sex self ID bill. Becoming blonde hasn't changed anything she's just a nasty piece of work
Absolutely, the witches of Eastwick were out of control, because the chairman wasn't in control.
Nicola was as professional as those three cows were unprofessional
Wished they’d drop the Honourable BS , I don’t see must Honour going on in this place. Thank you Nicola
Russell has a serious arrogance issue .
What a garbled babble from Russell all puffed up with an ego larger than her brain - the only thing larger than her ego was her mouth - it never stopped ... rude. obnoxious and full of self importance.. showing her extreme ignorance and proving she does not belong on such a panel. She simply never shut her loud mouth constantly talking over the answers to the questions she had rudely demanded answers to... There are often no Yes or No straight answers when talking about planning and forecasting around finance - many factors have to be taken into account ... anyone with knowledge knows this. Thank you Nicola Wills for being so professional I found what you had to say very clear, heartening and I feel a lot more confident for the future with you at the helm. As for Russell try getting a job in the local fish market... your loud shouting mouth would be acceptable there!
Yeah what a contrast. Woke ppl are nothing more than bored ppl wanting something to do .
I thought I had poor social skills. Listening to these MPs who are supposedly the best representatives of the people, I feel embarrassed for them.
It's ridiculous not eveen childish just plain silly n unintelligent overplayed and overrated ppl who run this country got no ideas and all the admiring try hards who pretend to be the voice of the people with their imposing make me sick ...
I wouldn't call Deborah Russell as Hon Dr Deborah Russell, she was a disgrace, rude, and showed she's not fit to be on this committee, have to admit Chloe handled her behavior rather well and looked embarrassed on how Deborah Russell was behaving.
I wouldn't trust anything said by Deborah Russell or Chloe Swarbrick.
Poor chairing. Edmonds was mulish, Russell clearly thinks she's the star of the show. Probably why she was only a minister for 10 months.
If you are going to ask a question shut up and let them tell you how it is, stop demanding yes or know answers and talking at them 🤔
Where are the pragmatic males? The Government must untangle the Maori Racist Legal Web that has Government Departments confused with budgets. The previous NZ Labour Party tied spending onto a race-based legislation.
100%
How did Nicola keep her cool? Those banshees should be ashamed
They don't have shame
You describe them well... that's exactly what they are - banshees!
@@valeriehughes1008 Nicola is a failure she has tanked our economy.
The deficit given by a LABOUR GOV should not have happened in the first place! people asking the Questions are totally INCOMPETENT !
Sometimes you just cannot give a yes/no answer. An example, "Megan Woods, do you still eat six pies a day, yes or no?"
At what price did the pies cost the taxpayer , were they inflationary
This is not factual. Megan rarely ate more than 5 pies , but did like to chase it down with three donuts and a litre of coke
She does.
well done Nicola, a politician talking facts, not just economics Nicola, the ongoing exodus is understandable , why would the average kiwi want to strive for success, in a country that looks like it may snach failure from the jaws of success with race based racist crap, and not sorting the treaty issue , and this is best done through education ,
I for one would like to see an amendment to MMP voting. Add a third vote to let the people decide who can never stand for parliament again, in any capacity.
Some people just argue for the sake of arguing.
The Dr Russell "Look at me, Look at me. I'm not bound by the Chairpersons Rules and I don't care if I'm an embarrassment to this discussion or you peasants" Bully, Can't handle criticism, weak..
Re: Russell, I recall her performance on the Firearms submissions. I do struggle to understand why she is still wasting that chair space.
Well done Nicola. They failed miserably over the last six years, and they still do not get it.
Dur Russel is lying.
I wish they'd just not assert bs as part of their "question".
Swarbrick and her cronies listen with their mouths.
The chair is as bloody weak as Brownlee, and can't control the room. And I'm amazed that Chloe almost sounds normal
Maori are scrambling to maintain their beast
Being a Kindergarten Teacher is exhausting for this poor man. The adult in the room handled the kids very well I thought. It was way over the kids head and they didn't like it so they start behaving like the little children they REALLY ARE!!
So true
Very disappointing behaviour from our elected representatives. There is a lesson for the questioner to, at some point, stop talking so they may hear, and learn, from an answer - don't you think?
Well if the Maoris didn't get given $800 million of taxpayers money last year.
New zealand wouldn't be in so much shit like it is now.
All these special benefits for Maoris has to stop to get nz moving forward not backwards all the time.
Labour greens govt has alot to answer to.
The govt has to get taxes down fuel down and cost of living down and stop special benefits to Maoris.
To get people to start to think about staying in nz
Who is that woke women with white Hair? And who is voting her in?
She needs professional help
@ probably shoplifting to suppress her white guilt
Shes a maui activist cant remember her name, taniwha comes to mind
"Women" is plural - or so I learned as a seven year old.
@Longtack55 Did you also learn that not everyone speaks English as their first language? Do you know what a typo is? Do you know that a UA-cam is a comments section and not a legal document and it doesn't matter?
Yes no answers never come from labour or the greens they waffle on
Poor Nicola,trying bloody hard to answer the questions,whilst putting up with the usual left wing woke ridiculousness🥴...give the girl a break🤔🥺...not all questions require just a Yes or No❗
Deborah Russell is the very example of an academic Labourite who actually was a part of the the previous government’s failure into reigning back the ridiculous waste of tax payer dollars & left NZ broke. What a legacy from a qualified accountant. Rest my case.
This is an embarrassment if you’re in the opposition parties.
The Three Witches of Endor - and Nicola came out unscathed. Well done Nicola - You're exceptional. To the three on the other side, you're foul.
That's a great discription
How thick are the Labour and Green MP,s
listen to them arguing amongst themselves 🙄
They need to go back to primary school, be quiet when master is talking! All money wasters!
😂🎉
The Chair needs to keep order
How much Gov't spending could be saved by NOT allowing immigrants to access Benefits, free housing for at least 5 years
Well explained to us kiwis…thank you Nicola. You’re doing a great job..
Bro government members should be on a performance based pay system. Not to mention fingers in private enterprise. If you're growing wealth whilst working for the people........ That is fraudulent you should be subject to the proceeds of crime act!
omg they cant stop arguing
Good to see a massive increase in the quality of the cabinet ministers versus the last government 👍
where do you get these horror films from
The Right Horrible Dr. Deborah Russell Dr. meaning Disgustingly rude.
It’s time Chloe learnt to speak more succinctly. Her questions are so muddled with new words she wants to try out..
she is going to be a great Prime Minister
I would be quite happy with her and Brook Van Velden as PM and Deputy PM (in either order). Not only do I think they are the best qualified for the job, it should go a long way to reminding people that women who earn their places on merit make excellent leaders.
It never ceases to amaze me that people in parliament think money grows on trees and you never have to pay back debt just keep on spending . Chloe is a prime example of this stupidity.
I'm not a national supporter, but this really reminded me of the level headedness we've seen out of David Seymor during the introduction of the TPB to parliament.
Champion level of patience and adequate composure from Nicola Willis is on display here.
HAHAHA...women.
the public are forbidden to extend their time.
Russell is a rude lunatic. It would be like dealing with a drunk.
A drunk makes more sense than Dr Russell...
😂😂😂 the difference between Senator Hawley in US politics and our scone lady grilling the MoF ...embarrassing...
Nicola Willis for pm
What a mess that would be.
Still waiting to hear her genius solution regarding the ferries.
She passed that buck as soon as she could......
I have to give my grudging respect to Crazy Chlöe. She called for the ten minutes, let Dozy Deborah embarrass herself and non verbally turned her back on DD, admitted she agreed with the minister just disputed the way it was dealt with (if she could loose the hard left stance there is some potential for an adequate politician). If she keeps this up I may have to start calling her Crafty Chlöe.
Thank you Nicola. Along with the other Elite Maori - Seymour, Peters, Jones, etc - the takeover is complete.
Waste of tax payers money most of these clowns. Can’t even listen when someone talks! A joke
Tbf Swarbrick looks embarrassed and frustrated by her allies behaviour.
Don’t give any money to the greens. They don’t have any clues
Nicola pure class under pressure 👏
What a circus. Have any of these people asking questions had s proper job ? They are behaving like kids.
How does Ms Swarbrick think government emplyment saves taxpayer's extra contribution????
The standard of chairing in Wellington seems to be very poor. From the example the speaker sets down I can't believe how weak they are.
Wow, the blonde lady in green is very patronizing!
wow i mistakenly thought the ad was about the Beast of Belsen Irma Grese. My mistake
Chloe sounded much better than the labour trio.
I wish well, but I doubt she can grow the economy significantly without removing the key impediment: Heavy handed central and local bureaucracy.
We need to reduce the bureaucratic burden and the bureaucrats that impose it.
I now know we have a straight thinking minister of finance ….at last
Just words without actions.
Need to spend money to fix the
Country.
Just another bloody CICUS
Once again Chloe Swarbrick using a reductive binary to form her argument... I wonder where I got the phrase "reductive binary" from?
We pay tax for people to behave like this.
Well said nick good work
30 million for teachers that can't be trained to be retrained is by way a waste of $$$ Nicola is ensuring tax payers are scamed yet again. Im not left nor right but great with figures & geopolitics. Any silly spending gets a 👎
In fairness to Chloe the questions the video shows her asking were well considered and in good faith
I wish she could've "superbly" handled the ferries issue as she does these so called unruly MPs...
I know...I'm asking for far too much...
That was an absolute Muppet of a decision. Possibly the worst financial decision made for nz in my lifetime. Guess we'll find out.
You can see that if that Russell individual's party was in power now that this country would be by now Broke & the danger of all out Civil Disobedience would be about occur. Incredible to be able to see just how unhinged & without any sign of being a professional in the role she has she's completely lost. Quite something to witness indeed.
Chloe is doing a Hilary
Where are the jobs gone last 10 years bn heaps work now its turned2 mud
Sounds like in parliament, childish!
Nicola is one VERY smart cookine!! Chloe seems to be slowly, oh so VERY slowly learning from her. Probably unwillingly, but she is getting better. Give her 15 more years or so.
Yep, the decision regarding the ferries was a master stroke that has saved the country billions. Possibly more. They need to treat all the other portfolios and decisions the same. Imagine how much they could save if they cut health and education entirely.
If the cost of fuel was cheaper there would be a knockon affect of cheaper product, marsdon point oil refinery which was shut down by labour kept our gas prices down, labour has a habbit of doing dumb stuff. Look at uk and Canada.
Did it?
Sound More Like a Chicken Fight
The people on the ground have the solutions so put into them biz analyst roles that actually know what needs to proceed for best outcomes don't need a Phd or MBA or a degree to understand unless you have been served on a golden plate all your life
Disgusting insulting white hair woman. ABUSIVE
Whos the bully wanting yes or no answer.
Cant watch this rubbish, Nicola did an amazing. Self important people who have on idea how to listen to answers which is not constructive, only verbal abuse.
No boats is simply dribbling crap ; no idea about economic policy ; simply plucking ideas out of the air !!!
Yes or no ?
willis is a joke, BS her way as finance minister with a trash degree in English😂
The reshuffle. I have seen a smarter cabinet in Ikea
Get that Red 💄 On Nicci Baby 🎉
She’s so full of bull shit lol
Maximum impact like throwing away millions on the ferry deal,no credibility whatsoever
I agree... LABOUR wasted millions of taxpayer dollars on signing a deal on ferries that were too big for the ports.Now the coalition are being painted as bad guys for cancelling a deal that was STUPID to start with!?Typical Labour Govt-Big on promises and low on achievement.Ardern & Robertson both scuttled away before the full effects of their fiscal incompetence came to light.... into well paid alternative employment.
I think Willis is dangerous to New Zealand. While health, police, environmental protection, and military expenditures should not be cut, the rest of the government civil service is way too bloated. We also need less expenditure on vanity projects like Roads of "Significance".
Stepping down Nicola Willis 😂 or demoted from the portfolio. Demoted..Luxon has no faith in ya! National are down in the polls. One term government 😂
We should never borrow from anyone. Its why we fail our infrastructure
Shrews.
Around Around and around sounds just like Seymour Nicky's mouse. Where's Donald duck 😅😅