fantastic illustration of ways i hadn't formally recognized ... i've recently realized that great art has all the characteristics of great cinema; story, symbolism, tone, and enigmas that bind us to the works and require diligent use of our powers of observation and imagination
I do not wish to overstep my bounds at all, but your videos are so very helpful that I would humbly ask a favour: Please consider making another video like this one that discusses the differences between Neoclassical and Baroque art forms. Thank you.
I kneel down and absolutely adore your work and channel. You are a blessing in this world. People like you that so masterfully share the beauty of art and history diserve the highest of all respects.
The discrepancy between Italian and Flemish painting in the baroque period makes some art historians question if we could actually talk about a baroque genre in Flemish art (except in the most notorious cases of Rubens or Rembrandt who clearly incorporated an italian influence), because we can't forget that, in the end, the Baroque was a concept emerged in Italy, and most countries have a specific environment of cultural and artistic confluences, which, in the case of Flemish art, are particularly notorious, contradicting even many formal aspects of the Italian baroque canon. Svetlana Alpers in her "Art of Describing" has defended this point, not seeing Vermeer as a baroque painter, and much more as an artist surged in the naturalist and pormenorized tradition of Flemish art, and as we see, his paintings seem much more fitting in the context of the cerebral and quiet vein of a Van Eyck painting than of a Caravaggio one. Saying that, i think this was a very clear and thematically incisive video, and maybe what i'm talking about is a large enough topic for not being included in such a directly explanatory video, but i think it should be questioned more often until what point can we actually frame the 17th century dutch painting in the baroque context.
The problem may be the result of art historians for so long seeing primarily through the lens of Italy (but that is a bigger problem). It should also be noted that that any stylistic rubric such as Baroque (a term that was not used in the same manner when the work was new), will fall apart under careful examination-even within Italy. Such terms remain useful only for introductory investigation.
I just discovered this channel and I LOVE IT! Amazing content and so much insight. You've gained a new subscriber. It drives me bananas how so few people go into detail explaining what's going on in a work of art. Everyone in this channel makes it clear and answers all of my questions before I ask them.
I've never seen this side of David and I like it, lol. Both versions, Michelangelo and Bernini are absolutely stunning, but I am so moved by the latter. I love the intensity and power. From what I can tell so far, I'm a fan of the Baroque art style. It did get more challenging to identify the later examples as Baroque (e.g. the Vermeer), but as I'm exposed to more, it'll get easier. :)
This is awesome. I’m studying for my state teaching exams and we have to know the history of art for multiple subject certification. I got bored of my textbook and turned to UA-cam and I’m glad I did! Very interesting and gave me so much appreciation for baroque art!
I feel that God is speaking to us through art like this. Just as.the gospels were inspired into the hearts of the prophets, images of life were also divinely inspired into the hearts and hands of the artists. In this stunning rendering in stone, God is communicating the fragility and challenges of life juxtaposed against the strength and fortitude of the individual. Prophets and artists are chosen vessels of divine communication.
What a great video! Especially with northern art of the time it can be difficult to note the baroque charactersitics. Thanks for spending time on that too and for showing a lot of examples! Very pedagogic and very useful!
Baroque depicts action and motion, while renaissance depicts intention, planning and spirituality. The comparision between the two Davids explains this difference with huge force. Michelangelo shows us the crucial seconds right before the action, those when the action has been planned. In my opinion that's a lot more powerful than the action itself, because this involves the most human attitude: the thinking, the planning. In the renaissance they intended the human being as center of decision, while in baroque it was considered more important to act. (under someone else directives: god, lord, king, pope...)
This video and all the others that you've made have been encouraging me to learn and search more abou Art. So thank you for your disposal and incredible work! :)
Just Subscribed! One of my new favorite channels! I find these videos of course educational, but also deeply relaxing and consoling! Feels Wonderfully soothing to listen to these conversations on art! Very hard to find/create them in my day to day! Thank You! If you're open to suggestions I would love a video on the rivalry between Romantic and Classical styles, particularly examining the works and relationship between Delacroix and Ingres! Comparing their style/works would be wonderful to watch! Also I would love to know more about Symbolism! A "How to recognize Symbolist art" video would be Amazing! Again Thank You for the work you've put into these videos, completely joyful to watch/listen too. More Please!
I've always been fascinated by Baroque art the most out of all the art movements, especially the work of the Dutch masters but I never really understood why until I watched this video.
I especially like how didactic and educational it was! Thanks, very useful video! I absolutely love that it highlights the overarching general characteristics of the style, giving us an overview. Hope to see this kind of video from other styles and geographic locations too!
Very interesting, but I have been a little surprised. I saw Vermeer as sort of a classical painter because his work is so intimate, so far from the violence of baroque.
@@taterazay2302 LOL sorry, forgot I even posted anything like this. I graduated with a straight A. I even picked Baroque painting as a topic of discussion out of all the things!! Time flies, I'm now in my final year of University, studying graphic design. Again, I will be graduating from history of art in a month. So I'll definitely visit this video many times again! :D
Thank you so very much for this knowledge, this channel, the involvement and yet subtleness with which you explain everything. So blessed to have found such valuable content to invest time in and learn from . Merci beaucoup P.S : love the jazz music too :D
thank you very much for this, i am sure that if i get on my bachelor arthistory examination a question about baroque, i will have no problems describing it anymore :) . I would love to see this kind of video comparing baroqe and manierism or baroqe and clasicissm , or also about architecture :) I hope that you will find the time to make these amazing videos. :)
I started loving the Renaissance but now I’m shifting towards Baroque....I really like(d) the strong pieces but the delicate pieces are getting my attention now..
What an amazing video that I found quite helpful to understand Baroque style. I was also expecting Baroque architecture which unfortunately was not covered in this video but good work though.
Would Renaissance sculpture be more like the Classical Period of Greek Art, while the Baroque period is more like the Hellenistic Period? The difference between Bernini and Michelangelo's Davids reminds me of the difference between something like Doryphoros and Laocoön and His Sons.
Thank you for your comment, it is much appreciated. We've been busy fundraising and recording the audio and taking the photos we need to create new content. Stay tuned, we should have some great new additions soon.
Wow-! I gave up nine minutes and I got back a lifetime of baroque art appreciation. Thank you!
David wasn't naked, what scam
how have I lived só far without knowing this Channel?
fantastic illustration of ways i hadn't formally recognized ... i've recently realized that great art has all the characteristics of great cinema; story, symbolism, tone, and enigmas that bind us to the works and require diligent use of our powers of observation and imagination
I do not wish to overstep my bounds at all, but your videos are so very helpful that I would humbly ask a favour: Please consider making another video like this one that discusses the differences between Neoclassical and Baroque art forms. Thank you.
We love suggestions! Thank you for being in touch.
Smarthistory. art, history, conversation. yes please!!
ajmittendorf this is the most polite UA-cam comment I've ever seen!
ajmittendorf - woah.. between neoclassical & baroque are forms? You’ve WAY overstepped your bounds buddy
@@delusionsofgrandeur1330😂
I love your channel because its visible that the people, which talk really are fascinated by the topics. this somehow makes me more interested.
a super clear and concise explanation of Baroque sculpture and paintings. Thank you so much.
The narrator's commentary is very warm and inclusive. I enjoy learning from this wonderful channel.
Fantastic, those first two minutes were the most clear expression of the baroque one could ask for
I kneel down and absolutely adore your work and channel. You are a blessing in this world. People like you that so masterfully share the beauty of art and history diserve the highest of all respects.
The Baroque period is one of my favorites. Love listening to you guys explain the elements of it
Ugh, you guys are simply the best! Thank you so much for this excellent program. Love it.
This channel is so brilliant. You're giving people an education. Bravo.
The discrepancy between Italian and Flemish painting in the baroque period makes some art historians question if we could actually talk about a baroque genre in Flemish art (except in the most notorious cases of Rubens or Rembrandt who clearly incorporated an italian influence), because we can't forget that, in the end, the Baroque was a concept emerged in Italy, and most countries have a specific environment of cultural and artistic confluences, which, in the case of Flemish art, are particularly notorious, contradicting even many formal aspects of the Italian baroque canon.
Svetlana Alpers in her "Art of Describing" has defended this point, not seeing Vermeer as a baroque painter, and much more as an artist surged in the naturalist and pormenorized tradition of Flemish art, and as we see, his paintings seem much more fitting in the context of the cerebral and quiet vein of a Van Eyck painting than of a Caravaggio one.
Saying that, i think this was a very clear and thematically incisive video, and maybe what i'm talking about is a large enough topic for not being included in such a directly explanatory video, but i think it should be questioned more often until what point can we actually frame the 17th century dutch painting in the baroque context.
The problem may be the result of art historians for so long seeing primarily through the lens of Italy (but that is a bigger problem). It should also be noted that that any stylistic rubric such as Baroque (a term that was not used in the same manner when the work was new), will fall apart under careful examination-even within Italy. Such terms remain useful only for introductory investigation.
Ooooooooooooo nice comment and reply! More to look for, read, and think about. Love challenging information!
I just discovered this channel and I LOVE IT! Amazing content and so much insight. You've gained a new subscriber.
It drives me bananas how so few people go into detail explaining what's going on in a work of art. Everyone in this channel makes it clear and answers all of my questions before I ask them.
Amazing video , finally somebody explained how to recognize the difference )) Please make more similar videos , love it !!!
I've never seen this side of David and I like it, lol. Both versions, Michelangelo and Bernini are absolutely stunning, but I am so moved by the latter. I love the intensity and power. From what I can tell so far, I'm a fan of the Baroque art style. It did get more challenging to identify the later examples as Baroque (e.g. the Vermeer), but as I'm exposed to more, it'll get easier. :)
This is brilliant! Would love more like this. Thanks so much :)
This is awesome. I’m studying for my state teaching exams and we have to know the history of art for multiple subject certification. I got bored of my textbook and turned to UA-cam and I’m glad I did! Very interesting and gave me so much appreciation for baroque art!
So glad our work was useful. Good luck on your certification.
I feel that God is speaking to us through art like this. Just as.the gospels were inspired into the hearts of the prophets, images of life were also divinely inspired into the hearts and hands of the artists. In this stunning rendering in stone, God is communicating the fragility and challenges of life juxtaposed against the strength and fortitude of the individual. Prophets and artists are chosen vessels of divine communication.
My hometown
What a great video!
Especially with northern art of the time it can be difficult to note the baroque charactersitics. Thanks for spending time on that too and for showing a lot of examples! Very pedagogic and very useful!
Very concise analysis , baroque tenebrous and chiaroscuros treatment of creating drama and gestures discuss quite fairly.
Wow what a video. Love the fast editing of dialogue. Great breakdown and re-itrrated points well
Awesome video. Can you do more videos for different styles?
+Sam Barkley That's our plan and thanks for your kind words-we appreciate the encouragement!
Great video! However could you do a video about the Pantheon?
We have one: smarthistory.org/the-pantheon/
Stephen Blackwell: You shouldn't take the "damned soul" image as your avatar.
Beautiful analysis, across European artists! You can are great guys, pleas keep doin this, it's food for the soul! Love this!
Baroque depicts action and motion, while renaissance depicts intention, planning and spirituality. The comparision between the two Davids explains this difference with huge force. Michelangelo shows us the crucial seconds right before the action, those when the action has been planned.
In my opinion that's a lot more powerful than the action itself, because this involves the most human attitude: the thinking, the planning.
In the renaissance they intended the human being as center of decision, while in baroque it was considered more important to act. (under someone else directives: god, lord, king, pope...)
The Baroque was a very interesting time in art, such great drama and intensity!
Love conciseness and brief videos. They’re short and very Baroque
This video just reinvigorated my love for art. Baroque is by far my favorite. 😍
Great stuff!! Love the conversational style! Thanks!!
I already know a lot about art - but this summarized it all brilliantly. Kudos...
Amazing, this channel should have millions of subscribers!!!
I really enjoyed this and found it helpful. thankyou
Its very indo-european
VERY
a wild survive the jive
Hail Thomas 😊
This video and all the others that you've made have been encouraging me to learn and search more abou Art. So thank you for your disposal and incredible work! :)
YIKES .. so so love this Bernini .. the figurefocus, Expressiveness, the eloquently articulated tightwound Energy !
This helped me alot to understand the differances between styles in art. Thanks for this!
Just Subscribed! One of my new favorite channels! I find these videos of course educational, but also deeply relaxing and consoling! Feels Wonderfully soothing to listen to these conversations on art! Very hard to find/create them in my day to day! Thank You!
If you're open to suggestions I would love a video on the rivalry between Romantic and Classical styles, particularly examining the works and relationship between Delacroix and Ingres! Comparing their style/works would be wonderful to watch!
Also I would love to know more about Symbolism! A "How to recognize Symbolist art" video would be Amazing!
Again Thank You for the work you've put into these videos, completely joyful to watch/listen too.
More Please!
This is like ASMR
Yeah, both voices sound so pleasant.
Yes indeed
Incredibly helpful video that presents the key ideas from the period, presented in a visually pleasing way with illustrative examples.
I've always been fascinated by Baroque art the most out of all the art movements, especially the work of the Dutch masters but I never really understood why until I watched this video.
Brilliant video, gonna watch it several more times.
Why did I find your channel only now? You are amazing!
this explanation is Oscar worthy ..
Very professionally executed and high quality content, thank you .
Perfectly explained the perfect work of art.
Thank you so much. This was very informative and I liked the comparison you made. Hope you will continue making such educational videos.
Very interesting, very informative. thank you
I especially like how didactic and educational it was! Thanks, very useful video! I absolutely love that it highlights the overarching general characteristics of the style, giving us an overview.
Hope to see this kind of video from other styles and geographic locations too!
Very interesting, but I have been a little surprised. I saw Vermeer as sort of a classical painter because his work is so intimate, so far from the violence of baroque.
thank you for your very informative video (as usual).
You guys probably helped me graduate High School.. Will know the results in 3 days lol. Thank you so much! Very informative and easy to understand.
And?
Still waiting
@@taterazay2302 LOL sorry, forgot I even posted anything like this. I graduated with a straight A. I even picked Baroque painting as a topic of discussion out of all the things!! Time flies, I'm now in my final year of University, studying graphic design. Again, I will be graduating from history of art in a month. So I'll definitely visit this video many times again! :D
@@gman248 that's sweet, good luck !!
@@taterazay2302 So I successfully passed my University art finals with a score of B!
Thank you so very much for this knowledge, this channel, the involvement and yet subtleness with which you explain everything. So blessed to have found such valuable content to invest time in and learn from . Merci beaucoup
P.S : love the jazz music too :D
Nice documentary of art . Thanks.
Thank you so much. I like the way you talk. I got help of subtitle a little bit but still easy to understand. And the passion about the pictures!
And so my ignorance of art shrinks a hair. Thanks!
Excellent analysis and visual comparison with the David by Michelangelo.
I always see your videos when I have history exam. They are a great help. I dont even need to open the book. Thanks :)
I love this channel! Beautifully explained! (:
This is incredible. You guys helped me a lot with my studies!!!
Excellent video. Such clear explainations!!!!!
Wonderful art description
Absolutely loved this video. Thank you so much.
Greatest narrators ever!
thank you for the clear explanation, it really helps
This video makes me want to come to the art museum.
Great, thank you so much! An ideal, bite-sized teaching aid for my course!
Glad it's useful, we have 1100 other videos and even more short essays designed for classroom use. Explore smarthistory.org
Excellent explanation.
I have learnt so much from you, thank you so very much !
Thank you, this was extremely helpful ! You guys are great !
Renaissance is so more relaxed, calm, captures humbleness , centered on character, 😁, it all moves me,
thank you very much for this, i am sure that if i get on my bachelor arthistory examination a question about baroque, i will have no problems describing it anymore :) . I would love to see this kind of video comparing baroqe and manierism or baroqe and clasicissm , or also about architecture :) I hope that you will find the time to make these amazing videos. :)
I started loving the Renaissance but now I’m shifting towards Baroque....I really like(d) the strong pieces but the delicate pieces are getting my attention now..
awesome!, more please 🙏🏻
Very good explanation.
really enjoyed your videos. Could make more of this? Like how to recognize Romanticism, Neo-Classical, Mannerism, Rococo art?
Wow. Beautiful. Thanks you✨
What an amazing video that I found quite helpful to understand Baroque style. I was also expecting Baroque architecture which unfortunately was not covered in this video but good work though.
Great video! Used it for my class. Thanks!
You all explained this a whole lot better than my textbook
this channel is amazing!
Good video, very informative, and very descriptive.
You guys are awesome. I really enjoyed it!
this video helped me a lot in my study, and i found them very relaxing as well, in the good way
Wonderful work!
Excellent analysis, absorbing. (UK)
Gosh this was terrific!
My favourite period
Who are the artists who made this masterpieces?
Amazing 😊
Such a wonderful explanation for an absolute dummy like me. Thanks a lot!
Would Renaissance sculpture be more like the Classical Period of Greek Art, while the Baroque period is more like the Hellenistic Period? The difference between Bernini and Michelangelo's Davids reminds me of the difference between something like Doryphoros and Laocoön and His Sons.
The parallel isn't perfect but many people have recognized this relationship. In fact the Hellenistic was once called the Hellenistic Baroque.
我非常感谢这里的中文翻译字幕施工者，让我的学习体验好了不止一倍，阿里嘎多）））
Excellent video!
Splendid!
Very informative, thank you very much
Missing your excellent videos :(
Thank you for your comment, it is much appreciated. We've been busy fundraising and recording the audio and taking the photos we need to create new content. Stay tuned, we should have some great new additions soon.
Smarthistory. art, history, conversation. That's great! Thanks for the update, I'm looking forward to seeing the new content.
what are differences and similarities of Italian and Dutch Baroque Art?
Great piece guy's .. Bernini .. WOW
Great video, I enjoyed it very much!
How many masterpieces are named in the video?