She had such a great personality it is so evident throughout this whole video, even when some of the people were being rude she still kept it together and continued to be positive. I wish i had met her 😢 I pray that Allah Grants her the highest paradise and May Allah make it easy for her to answer the questions in the grave and open for her the windows where she can see and smell the paradise. Alahumma Ameeeeen !!!
What a beautiful human being inside and out. She was our harriet tubman, Rosa park, and Oprah Winfrey all in one. May Allah have mercy on her Beautiful soul. 😢
Somali Review, how do you know all these people you named are good people?, you forget the ones Allah promised paradise don’t let Hollywood fool you🤝🤝🤝
Hodan I wish I was there, I would've shown you around the whole store lol. Sorry some people were rude to you, come back to MN soon please! We love you!
Naimo A so sad abayo you’re good person I wish I was there too sister our poeple are rude Walaahi i feel bad when she said nobody wants to talk to you may Allah give the highest of janatul fardowsa aclaa yaa rabii at least they don’t know sida dadka loo qanciyo subxaana lah dadkeena they need abdication
If the woman leading this film only spoke English, despite this being in Minnesota, she would never have been able to find the hair salon ! She had enormous difficulty getting the directions as it was, having to resort to a Somalian language almost every time she needed direction. This is a place where the people truly don't seem to want to learn the language of their host country.
Anna D, "host country." Get the f out of here!! The USA murdered over 10,000 Somali civilians, we have a right to be here. Also, I was born on American soil. I'm just as American as you are. I can tell you're a subconscious white supremacist just by the phrase "host country." Read a book and educate yourself, please.
I'm sorry that you experienced those mean people. Usually folks at Karmel are nice. That dude telling you not to record was so unnecessary. But you of course handled it like a professional. Good job Hodan! Please come back to Minneapolis we already miss you!
0:02 A shopping mall for Somalis? Minneapolis is still in the United States of America, right? Would a blond woman without a hijab be safe in this shopping mall? This UA-cam channel is called "INTEGRATIONTV." There is no integration going on in this video.
firecloud77, once, I saw a redhead family of 11, and they were fine... TF kind of question is that, anyways. Also, don't be so ignorant; most of us arrived in the 90s, although I was born here in the 2000s.
I'm all for diversity... but where is the assimilation into American culture? It's painfully obvious that the Somali's of Minneapolis don't want to blend in with the rest of the people, they want exactly what they had back in Somali, here in America. That should be very troublesome for everyone else.
Chris James you're expecting them to forget their culture. That's not right.....you say you're all for diversity but then seeing diversity bothers you 🤔 what fun would it be if we were all the same?
You clearly don't understand the economic and social dynamics of new immigrants. They normally gather in on place to create enough of a number to act as customers and suppliers as they learn the language and ways of integrating themselves. In the process some of them slowly gather enough money and resources to catapult them into mainstream America. Those successful ones branch out and their children are fully Americanized and the process is repeated. For instance the overwhelming majority of those who started the mall are no longer there! They set up businesses in other parts of the city and even relocated their families to better and more prosperous neighborhoods. This process is the same for all other communities.
Ahmed Sanyare absolutely they’re rude our poeple I don’t know why xitaa qof ka si dagan ula hadlaan ma yaqaanaan aqlaaq especially dumarka somaliyeed they don’t like camera but dadka in ay xantaan wey jecel yihiin uff I don’t like the way ay gabadha ula hadleyn ilaahay ha u naxariisto my lovely sister aqoon uma lihi wlhi but qof aan jeclaa ayay aheyd oo media ku bartay jeclaa inaan daawado janada mida ugu sareyso ilaahay guri ha ugu dhiso yaa rabii
Somali’s don’t like dogs because in Islam if you get licked by one you have to shower 7 times. And I guess they were avoiding the camera because people don’t like being recorded, and people don’t know what platform the recording will go on
Waaaaaaaaw maashaa allaah. Lots have chaged. Carmel had no more than 5 to 7 small shops 11 years ago, sorry to say this but every one at the time of my visit, looked like reerbaadiye that has never been to a magaalo.!!!! Somali Canadians aa aad u ilbaxsanaayeen when i visited Toronto in 2008 wich made go back to Toronto three more times. Glad to see my somalian brothers and sisters creating this shopping centre for their community.
Daariq Ahmed hey now don’t be swearing you’re a Muslim .... you gotta show good for Islam don’t be like the rest.... you need to show how peaceful Islam is
I HAD A DREAM LAST NIGHT. A YOUNG MAN COME TO ME AND HODAN NAALEEYE WAS BEHIND HIM. SHE WAS HAPPY. THE YOUNG MAN INSTANTLY SAID TO ME HODAN IS NOT DEAD SO TELL THE PEOPLE. So I’m telling you the people Hodan is not dead.
Karmel Square is awesome...the hot Chai with milk and Sambusas or cake...damn delicious. And the their sandwiches and spaghettisides with a banana...i love it.
I don't want people to think I'm a hater but I did not see any integration in this video though the young lady seemed very articulate and well-adjusted to Western culture.
Walcolm Trollinski Islam is not what you see on the television or what Muslims do ! .. Islam is a way of life . Islam is perfect Muslims are Not . So please don’t judge religion on its followers . I can do same for the crusaders but I know it’s stupid so anyway be wise don’t be brainwashed by the media
lol my people are so rude, we are just 0.2% of the entire world and Hodan is trying to show positive image of us out here so you better take advantage.
Do you notice all the deplorables spewing their hate. The history of America is one which always depict a group of people as "others " and today Somalis are the others until another group comes along. Stop it once and for all.
rashid hand its not that most of us hate Somalis. Its that most of us hate their ideology, Islam. When mislims are in the minority like they are now, it doesn't seem so bad, but when they become the majority over time, the land they dominate submits to Sharia Law. There are no minority rights. That's what concerns people. Race has nothing to do with this.
Boring. Sad and I have to say I grew up with music, haven't listened much in the past 10yrs, but when I do I ALWAYS feel my emotions strongly. Any culture that doesn't have music, isn't a culture! I think it's fair to say almost ALL world cultures have music of some type.
The presenter looks amazing in the traditional gear, dress ... but, I think she's on a different page from everybody else, in the somali shopping center.
War dadkan Camera ka baqaaya Waaa maxay bisinka LKn masha'allaah DJ illaah aya ka madowbeyey Heesaha teyda gabartan video duubeysa nice girl Waye oo Happy iska ah
She went to Somalia and planned to live there permanently to show the good side of it and then one afternoon she was in a hotel and it got blown up by al shabaab, she died. May she rip
I love this sister! Mansha'Allah! We need more people like her in our communities. Keep up the good job Hodan! Spread peace & love and kill them with kindness soomaaha haha!
Tad dia waa Inaad xurmeyso bilaa xurmo, waxaad dhahaysaa laguma duubayo waana aragnaa Inaad duubtey marbeenleey baatagay we dadka we aanrabin wejiyadooda in la duubo xitaa camerada hadaydaftey, Inaad anaga naga qariso waaye bilaa professional
Permissibility of Music The question of permissibility of music in Islamic jurisprudence is historically disputed. Imam al-Ghazzali, one of the most famous Muslim scholars, writing almost a thousand years ago, reported several hadith and came to the conclusion that music is permitted, saying: “All these Ahadith are reported by al-Bukhari and singing and playing are not haram.” Despite this, some Salafist groups interpret the chapters of Luqman and Al-Isra in the Quran as evidence that music is haram, although this is disputed by others who disagree. Those who do not allow music believe that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) censured the use of musical instruments when he said: "There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible adultery, silk, alcohol and musical instruments". Islamic scholars of the past who agreed upon this include Abu Hanifa, Al-Shafi'i, Malik, Ahmad bin Hanbal, Al-Tabari, Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Al-Bukhari, Al-Tirmidhi, Al-Nawawi, Al-Bayhaqi, Al-Tahawi, and Al-Qurtubi.[citation needed] However, those who argue that music is halal (permitted) state that this hadith relates to usage-at the time the polytheists used music and musical instruments as part of their worship- and does not apply to all music. They also point out that in the Holy Quran, it is stated that Prophet David (pbuh) was given the Psalms. (an-Nisa, 4/163; al-Isra, 17/55). In other Islamic resources, it is stated that the Psalms given to Prophet David (pbuh) were sent down in the month of Ramadan, that it contained sermons and words of wisdom and that Prophet David (pbuh) usually recited it accompanied by a melody and a musical instrument; therefore music is permitted. Supporters of this view also point out that in classical Islamic jurisprudence and Sharia, the Holy Quran is the higher authority on correct Islamic practice; the hadith, while important, are secondary to the Holy Quran. Those who saw the permissibility of music include some of the most famous Muslim scholars, jurists, philosophers and Sufi poets of the Muslim world, including Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi, Ibn al-Qaisarani, Ibn Sina, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Rumi, Ibn Rushd, and Ibn Hazm. Al-Ghazali also reports a narration from al-Khidr, where he expressed a favourable opinion of music, provided it be within the usage limitation of virtuous areas. Al-Ghazali has been referred to by some historians as the single most influential Muslim after the Islamic prophet Muhammad (pbuh). According to some authorities Islam does allow singing without musical accompaniment within prescribed circumstances-namely that the performer be of the same gender as the audience, although this contradicts a well-known hadith in which two girls sang a song to the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and he instructed Abu Bakr (RA) to let them, stating, "Leave them Abu Bakr (RA), for every nation has an 'Id (i.e. festival) and this day is our 'Id.". Others hold that music is permitted in Islam provided that the lyrics are not obscene or vulgar. There is no direct verse in the Holy Quran which discusses or even prohibits the listening or practice of music.
OMG I wish I was there that day in karmel I will show you all around the mall 😍 and meet nice people I can't believe some people are stupids that they never seen a camera recording before how rebadiye especially the naag with the nin in the store😖😖😬😬😬karmel there are a lot of rude people but 24 mall has the nicest people 💕💕I wish you were in 24 mall next time when you visit Minneapolis go to 24 mall hodan❤️❤️💕💕
halimo abdi, people have the right to refuse just like she has the right to record that’s a God given right, you no better if you are using bad language🤝🤝🤝
Hodan sis I like your show, but damn girl don't you think its rude to bring the camera in front of people's face and telling them that your not recording, but actually your recording them hammm.
So here we have a "very plain girl" from Toronto. This plain girl speaks to men she meets in the street. Then we have the hip conversation because Islam is cool with lots of cool people doing cool things like listening to music back in Toronto. I have a problem with all this staged hoo haa. Islam does not allow Muslims to listen to popular music, let alone actually play it. Islam does not allow members of the female gender to walk around town and talk with strangers, let alone male strangers. So the message being conveyed here is false. I also am not impressed with this shopping centre made to look like somewhere in down town Somalia. Sorry this does not appear to be integration to me. But then I might be a racist, fascist, proto fascist, islamophobe (what ever that is) or even, a bigot.
Who is cutting onions. My phone is full of tears 😭 Rest In Peace hodan
Sorry sweetheart 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭but Allah will never forgive thim
Hani kushkush, never said never Allah forgives whoever he wants
@@fadumonor868 she means the ones who kill her
She had such a great personality it is so evident throughout this whole video, even when some of the people were being rude she still kept it together and continued to be positive. I wish i had met her 😢
I pray that Allah Grants her the highest paradise and May Allah make it easy for her to answer the questions in the grave and open for her the windows where she can see and smell the paradise. Alahumma Ameeeeen !!!
said aden, amiin amiin!!!
She was a fantastic young beautifull lady we really going to miss her
How she die?
@@ภัทราภรณ์วาปี-ธ8ฌ kill by fellow Somali
Everytime I seen her hodan tears fall my eyes. May Allah grant her janatul fardows...Amiin
Wlh gabadhaan waa iska jaclahay dar alla cidii ila jacel like ii saara
What a beautiful human being inside and out. She was our harriet tubman, Rosa park, and Oprah Winfrey all in one. May Allah have mercy on her Beautiful soul. 😢
Somali Review, how do you know all these people you named are good people?, you forget the ones Allah promised paradise don’t let Hollywood fool you🤝🤝🤝
wlhi can't stop laughing why most of Somali think like Recording is kind of Dangerous 😂😂😂😂
Hodan I wish I was there, I would've shown you around the whole store lol. Sorry some people were rude to you, come back to MN soon please! We love you!
Naimo A so sad abayo you’re good person I wish I was there too sister our poeple are rude Walaahi i feel bad when she said nobody wants to talk to you may Allah give the highest of janatul fardowsa aclaa yaa rabii at least they don’t know sida dadka loo qanciyo subxaana lah dadkeena they need abdication
True Somali to the core and loved her people.
Send these people back to your islamic shithole Somalia, please.
May allah have mercy on Hodan Nahaley and forgive her her sins, and bless and reward the security guard give like and amin everybody
Always smile Mashallah she was the best person
Wat happen to her?
Send these people back to your islamic shithole Somalia, please.
If the woman leading this film only spoke English, despite this being in Minnesota, she would never have been able to find the hair salon ! She had enormous difficulty getting the directions as it was, having to resort to a Somalian language almost every time she needed direction. This is a place where the people truly don't seem to want to learn the language of their host country.
Anna D, "host country." Get the f out of here!! The USA murdered over 10,000 Somali civilians, we have a right to be here. Also, I was born on American soil. I'm just as American as you are. I can tell you're a subconscious white supremacist just by the phrase "host country." Read a book and educate yourself, please.
I'm sorry that you experienced those mean people. Usually folks at Karmel are nice. That dude telling you not to record was so unnecessary. But you of course handled it like a professional. Good job Hodan! Please come back to Minneapolis we already miss you!
aww nice advice from the security guard brother
The women cover their heads for modesty and YET they cake on the make-up and wear false eyelashes...hypocrites!!!!!!!
B Dominguez, I have to agree.
Your Waifu
Sister can I get your email address. I wanna share something with you
Alle yaa Raxma Raaximmin Hodden Naalleye 😭
Amiin amiin iyda ii odeygeda jano ku kulansii yarbi yarbi yarbi insha allh
It's amazing how u said nobody wants to talk to you when u have camera 😂😂! !
0:02 A shopping mall for Somalis? Minneapolis is still in the United States of America, right? Would a blond woman without a hijab be safe in this shopping mall?
This UA-cam channel is called "INTEGRATIONTV." There is no integration going on in this video.
firecloud77, once, I saw a redhead family of 11, and they were fine... TF kind of question is that, anyways. Also, don't be so ignorant; most of us arrived in the 90s, although I was born here in the 2000s.
Get educated dude.
There's cops everywhere there.
if that picture is you u ugly fat ass
😂😂 they are americans too bitch go get your own shit
hahaha! what amazing things are Somalis doing for this country?? don't we have enough ghettos? why are we shipping people here to create more ghettos?
These mall looks like third world built!
Well yes it’s a Muslim mall what is you’re point
abman136 it does not look 3rd world built; don’t lie to your self to degrade others hard work
That security guard is cool...ive chatted with him over the years. He's been working there for years...a real nice gentleman.
Is he still there
I'm all for diversity... but where is the assimilation into American culture? It's painfully obvious that the Somali's of Minneapolis don't want to blend in with the rest of the people, they want exactly what they had back in Somali, here in America. That should be very troublesome for everyone else.
Chris James you're expecting them to forget their culture. That's not right.....you say you're all for diversity but then seeing diversity bothers you 🤔 what fun would it be if we were all the same?
That's not diversity at all lol... That is ALL people of Somalia... Where do you see the diversity?!
this show should be called spot the american
DAM STRAIT
You clearly don't understand the economic and social dynamics of new immigrants. They normally gather in on place to create enough of a number to act as customers and suppliers as they learn the language and ways of integrating themselves. In the process some of them slowly gather enough money and resources to catapult them into mainstream America. Those successful ones branch out and their children are fully Americanized and the process is repeated. For instance the overwhelming majority of those who started the mall are no longer there! They set up businesses in other parts of the city and even relocated their families to better and more prosperous neighborhoods. This process is the same for all other communities.
Omg. So many somali peaple haha but they're rude and afraid Of camera
+Ahmed Sanyare i'd be the same
Ahmed Sanyare They irritated me. lol
Ahmed Sanyare absolutely they’re rude our poeple I don’t know why xitaa qof ka si dagan ula hadlaan ma yaqaanaan aqlaaq especially dumarka somaliyeed they don’t like camera but dadka in ay xantaan wey jecel yihiin uff I don’t like the way ay gabadha ula hadleyn ilaahay ha u naxariisto my lovely sister aqoon uma lihi wlhi but qof aan jeclaa ayay aheyd oo media ku bartay jeclaa inaan daawado janada mida ugu sareyso ilaahay guri ha ugu dhiso yaa rabii
@@shukrihussein1043 Aamiin yaa Rabbi💔💖
4:44 she is so kind but yet that somali habayaar is so rude
abdirahim mohammed they all rude our people especiall dumarkeena
Shukri Hussein, she was not being rude is her choice to refuse just like is her right to record herself
@@fadumonor868 ok but she could have said it in a nice way can she not
Lol I like how majority of the people kept saying ha'idoobin ani lol majority of them are on the run for no reason what so ever.
LMAOOO horta why do Somalis avoid cameras? I thought the only fear they had was that of dogs
Somali’s don’t like dogs because in Islam if you get licked by one you have to shower 7 times. And I guess they were avoiding the camera because people don’t like being recorded, and people don’t know what platform the recording will go on
Waaaaaaaaw maashaa allaah. Lots have chaged. Carmel had no more than 5 to 7 small shops 11 years ago, sorry to say this but every one at the time of my visit, looked like reerbaadiye that has never been to a magaalo.!!!!
Somali Canadians aa aad u ilbaxsanaayeen when i visited Toronto in 2008 wich made go back to Toronto three more times.
Glad to see my somalian brothers and sisters creating this shopping centre for their community.
Rest in peace hodan 😔😰
Still watching 2021
MORE FAMOUS THEN SHE WAS REALITY THE WORLD MISS HER
it looks exactly like the middle east.Americans, what happened to you're great nation?
@@daariqahmed8297 it is true what they say about you stupid leeches!
Daariq Ahmed hey now don’t be swearing you’re a Muslim .... you gotta show good for Islam don’t be like the rest.... you need to show how peaceful Islam is
Michael Workman I don’t get it why are you even watching this if you don’t like Muslim.... watch something else ... you’re just a troll who hates
Gustaaf Argoan wow do you even know what a Muslim means ....you’re more stupid than them trolls on here
Amanda Souhi not even close... pure evil!
I HAD A DREAM LAST NIGHT. A YOUNG MAN COME TO ME AND HODAN NAALEEYE WAS BEHIND HIM. SHE WAS HAPPY. THE YOUNG MAN INSTANTLY SAID TO ME HODAN IS NOT DEAD SO TELL THE PEOPLE.
So I’m telling you the people Hodan is not dead.
It’s possible I can imagine to believe that bro
RIP HODAN, VERY SAD TO HEAR SHE IS GONE TODAY.
Allah u Naxariisto Walasheyda Hodan iyo inti ku dhimatay Qaraxii kismayo 🤲
Am crying 😭
May the Almighty reward you the highest rank of JANNAH
this is not right.
monjiaitaly , selfish what ? 😂
Karmel Square is awesome...the hot Chai with milk and Sambusas or cake...damn delicious. And the their sandwiches and spaghettisides with a banana...i love it.
I had she passed away .I cant believ it.am a big fun of hers
May Allah bless her soul with jannah
Ameen .she deserves it
Lebanon was a secular multi- religous country as we're many
I don't want people to think I'm a hater but I did not see any integration in this video though the young lady seemed very articulate and well-adjusted to Western culture.
They have the right to refuse to be filmed
Its public
You don't need a hair salon you don't even uncover your head so it makes no sense
Randy Salinas so White American chicks don’t shave their vaginas according to that logic lol
May her soul Rest In Peace .
Protest by walking through the mall with a ham sandwich!!!
Big Papi
Why would you wanna do that ?! Or are you just being stupid
Walcolm Trollinski
Islam is not what you see on the television or what Muslims do ! ..
Islam is a way of life . Islam is perfect Muslims are Not . So please don’t judge religion on its followers . I can do same for the crusaders but I know it’s stupid so anyway be wise don’t be brainwashed by the media
Wow is this is the USA??? what a shame!
usa is finish
usa 2050 more muslims than christians in usa
Your badnes is shame
Shut the fuck up dum ass bitch
What the heck? Good God what has happened to us?
Terpag1
NOO she not here no more 😭 I would love to meet her . RIP
never trust a skinny
Is this the US?
lol my people are so rude, we are just 0.2% of the entire world and Hodan is trying to show positive image of us out here so you better take advantage.
Do you notice all the deplorables spewing their hate. The history of America is one which always depict a group of people as "others " and today Somalis are the others until another group comes along. Stop it once and for all.
rashid hand its not that most of us hate Somalis. Its that most of us hate their ideology, Islam. When mislims are in the minority like they are now, it doesn't seem so bad, but when they become the majority over time, the land they dominate submits to Sharia Law. There are no minority rights. That's what concerns people. Race has nothing to do with this.
HAHA why is everyone so camera shy'?😂😂
I prefer Ethiopian Christians over Somali Muslims. Just sayin.
May Allah take her to jannah ameen ❤
Boring. Sad and I have to say I grew up with music, haven't listened much in the past 10yrs, but when I do I ALWAYS feel my emotions strongly. Any culture that doesn't have music, isn't a culture! I think it's fair to say almost ALL world cultures have music of some type.
damn a lot of somali people at Minnesota
Hello
Yeap
Ilahow u naxariiso
UA-cam hadeeruu muuqaladeeda recomend noogu samaynayaa😥😥😥
The presenter looks amazing in the traditional gear, dress ... but, I think she's on a different page from everybody else, in the somali shopping center.
lmaoo somalis n their unfriendly camera thing. lord have mercy
Why are they hating the camera?
Jazaka kheir Naleye
I really enjoyed it. :)
I miss her God blees you syster
why is drinking tea in the hallway something different 😬
War dadkan Camera ka baqaaya Waaa maxay bisinka LKn masha'allaah DJ illaah aya ka madowbeyey Heesaha teyda gabartan video duubeysa nice girl Waye oo Happy iska ah
The sun will rise from West.
What a neat look into MN Somalian culture.
Send these people back to your islamic shithole Somalia, please.
Allah Ha Naxiisto Hodan Naleye Iyo Kuwa Ladhintay Samir Iyo Iimaan All Kuwa Jecel Somalimada
Aamiin
Can someone tell me, how did she die? I am so saddened. R.I.P.😭😭😭
She went to Somalia and planned to live there permanently to show the good side of it and then one afternoon she was in a hotel and it got blown up by al shabaab, she died. May she rip
you're very charismatic interviewer.
RIP 😰
I love this sister! Mansha'Allah! We need more people like her in our communities.
Keep up the good job Hodan!
Spread peace & love and kill them with kindness soomaaha haha!
البقاء لله كل نفس ذائقة الموت 😢😢😢allow ku naxariisto rabiyow fadliga &awoodada janada ku abal mari hodan naaleeye gbr wngsn ayey aheed🤲🤲🤲
Amiiin thuma Amiin Ya Allah
What happened to her?!
what are the great things these people have done?
Burn it down
WTFCUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
BRAINWASHED obviously ur name says everything
@@naimanura lol
Alle ha kuu naxariisto Edo 💗💔 One Luv
😭😭😭
a mall?????? it's a dump
Sean Dorsey your Just mad 🤦🏾♀️
Sean dorkey whateva ur name why have so much uncle sam hasn't dropped yr state cheque yet
So much bile from a bum
Shut the fuck up dum ass Bitch
It looks like a "Flea Market" out in the western states... That is not a American Mall at all... Again , Why are they here..?
This is actually a somali mall
Somalis are Somalis and will remain Somalis....Hodan Naleye do it....
She is halima right?
Omg may Allah Grant her perfect peace she's beautiful can someone explain what happened to her?
Felicia Johnson she die in kismaayo in Somalia.
🙌
yooo she went through A & J chicken in southside reppin southside minneapolis dawg
My comments never appeared
what the hell is wrong with these people why they didn't direct you? they are Camara shy community.
... The thin edge of "The Wedge", *DUH.*
Tad dia waa Inaad xurmeyso bilaa xurmo, waxaad dhahaysaa laguma duubayo waana aragnaa Inaad duubtey marbeenleey baatagay we dadka we aanrabin wejiyadooda in la duubo xitaa camerada hadaydaftey, Inaad anaga naga qariso waaye bilaa professional
Permissibility of Music
The question of permissibility of music in Islamic jurisprudence is historically disputed. Imam al-Ghazzali, one of the most famous Muslim scholars, writing almost a thousand years ago, reported several hadith and came to the conclusion that music is permitted, saying: “All these Ahadith are reported by al-Bukhari and singing and playing are not haram.” Despite this, some Salafist groups interpret the chapters of Luqman and Al-Isra in the Quran as evidence that music is haram, although this is disputed by others who disagree.
Those who do not allow music believe that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) censured the use of musical instruments when he said: "There will be among my Ummah people who will regard as permissible adultery, silk, alcohol and musical instruments". Islamic scholars of the past who agreed upon this include Abu Hanifa, Al-Shafi'i, Malik, Ahmad bin Hanbal, Al-Tabari, Al-Hasan Al-Basri, Al-Bukhari, Al-Tirmidhi, Al-Nawawi, Al-Bayhaqi, Al-Tahawi, and Al-Qurtubi.[citation needed] However, those who argue that music is halal (permitted) state that this hadith relates to usage-at the time the polytheists used music and musical instruments as part of their worship- and does not apply to all music. They also point out that in the Holy Quran, it is stated that Prophet David (pbuh) was given the Psalms. (an-Nisa, 4/163; al-Isra, 17/55). In other Islamic resources, it is stated that the Psalms given to Prophet David (pbuh) were sent down in the month of Ramadan, that it contained sermons and words of wisdom and that Prophet David (pbuh) usually recited it accompanied by a melody and a musical instrument; therefore music is permitted. Supporters of this view also point out that in classical Islamic jurisprudence and Sharia, the Holy Quran is the higher authority on correct Islamic practice; the hadith, while important, are secondary to the Holy Quran.
Those who saw the permissibility of music include some of the most famous Muslim scholars, jurists, philosophers and Sufi poets of the Muslim world, including Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi, Ibn al-Qaisarani, Ibn Sina, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Rumi, Ibn Rushd, and Ibn Hazm. Al-Ghazali also reports a narration from al-Khidr, where he expressed a favourable opinion of music, provided it be within the usage limitation of virtuous areas. Al-Ghazali has been referred to by some historians as the single most influential Muslim after the Islamic prophet Muhammad (pbuh).
According to some authorities Islam does allow singing without musical accompaniment within prescribed circumstances-namely that the performer be of the same gender as the audience, although this contradicts a well-known hadith in which two girls sang a song to the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and he instructed Abu Bakr (RA) to let them, stating, "Leave them Abu Bakr (RA), for every nation has an 'Id (i.e. festival) and this day is our 'Id.". Others hold that music is permitted in Islam provided that the lyrics are not obscene or vulgar.
There is no direct verse in the Holy Quran which discusses or even prohibits the listening or practice of music.
i hate those kind of people if u don't have something nice to say be quite
islam = false religion!
Jessie Nicholas= ignorant
Betty Taylor, I feel bad for you how can you hate something you know nothing about? don’t be a sheep 🐑 do some research on your own
Betty Taylor, your county? if we are going back you are coming to bro!! 💼 bag your bags
OMG I wish I was there that day in karmel I will show you all around the mall 😍 and meet nice people I can't believe some people are stupids that they never seen a camera recording before how rebadiye especially the naag with the nin in the store😖😖😬😬😬karmel there are a lot of rude people but 24 mall has the nicest people 💕💕I wish you were in 24 mall next time when you visit Minneapolis go to 24 mall hodan❤️❤️💕💕
Hey, give me your snap or facebook.
Hello
halimo abdi, people have the right to refuse just like she has the right to record that’s a God given right, you no better if you are using bad language🤝🤝🤝
PRESIDENT TRUMP!!!!!!
Haha why many folk hate when you're making vudeo camera? It's oky,what's wrong with the ppl?
4:50😂😂😂😂😂😂
Minnesota needs to turn in its MAN CARD! .
Ilaahy how naxariisto #HodanNaalaye Walashen halyeyadeeniiii
Hodan sis I like your show, but damn girl don't you think its rude to bring the camera in front of people's face and telling them that your not recording, but actually your recording them hammm.
+Omarr Omar so true
Any anti Islam comments disappear
Maxaa ka qaldan dadkaan ka cararaya camerada. Hodan i love your channel keep it up abaayo.
So here we have a "very plain girl" from Toronto. This plain girl speaks to men she meets in the street. Then we have the hip conversation because Islam is cool with lots of cool people doing cool things like listening to music back in Toronto. I have a problem with all this staged hoo haa. Islam does not allow Muslims to listen to popular music, let alone actually play it. Islam does not allow members of the female gender to walk around town and talk with strangers, let alone male strangers. So the message being conveyed here is false. I also am not impressed with this shopping centre made to look like somewhere in down town Somalia. Sorry this does not appear to be integration to me. But then I might be a racist, fascist, proto fascist, islamophobe (what ever that is) or even, a bigot.