EMIYA Alter's Backstory Just Keeps Getting Worse
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 січ 2024
- kiara y u do dis
Channel Merch: teespring.com/stores/iv-12
Subscribe for more content: goo.gl/wvduQG
Follow me on Twitter - / tsiahiv
Support the channel - / tsiahiv
#FateGrandOrder #FGO #FateGO
Join the discord - / discord - Розваги
![The EMIYA Alter Origin Crack Theory [FGO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sC1rYjoM1Uo/mqdefault.jpg)
Emiya Alter went full Guts when he recognized Kiara.
You never wanna go full Guts.
Guts: GRIFFIN!!
Emiya Alter: KIARA!!
Cuts to Griffin & Kiara standing there menacingly. With Casca in Griffin arms. Meanwhile Kiara is holding on to Sakura, Rin & Artoria.
You do if they have invincibility pierce because there's no way you're surviving an NP otherwise.
.
.
.
Man, I gotta lay off the challenge quests.
That is the primal chad fury no one wants to be on the receiving end of.
@@Rogue-a-Pogue if only he had solemn defence from castoria
Someone had to.
Fate was literally built on Emiya suffering
Yea, an emiya has to suffer for fate to keep going
@@somepvpguy69It's literally his Fate to suffer countless lives...
@@infinitykiyen6270 my*
I mean…when you put it like that. You kind of right. I say the only one storyline this may NOT apply to is Anything Apocrypha related but the rest. Yeah you’re not wrong.
@@sleepylmguy9968 but in apocrypha is the suffer of an shirou face
How can Emiya’s backstory get even WORSE?? 😭 give that man a break god damn!
They did give him a (mind)break though
He is Spiderman No break
The Fate series is all about Shirou having a Shit life
When we thought that we already had hit the rock bottom of Emiya Alter’s backstory, only to discover we’re still falling at full speed.
Bro hit the bottom and then asked for a shovel
It’s like Lie Like Vortigern. There’s no bottom, just an endless hole.
He hit bedrock alright, but underneath, there's still hell waiting.
@@_arkalis_5573he was handed a drill rig instead of a shovel saying let's keep going as deep as possible 😂
There is no end to EMIYA suffering. That spreads to his family and all his variants sadly. And people STILL think he's a bad protagonist.
That's the twist them thinking hes a bad protag is part of the suffering
Suffering doesn't immediately make a good protag though.
FGO players: 'Ritsuka suffers so much through the Lost Belts, he has to make so many horrible choices for the sake of humanity!'
Emiya Shirou: 'I literally ripped limbs off people when I was still alive for the sake of an idea of "good" that destroyed me and doomed my eternal soul.'
I mean. Both can be true. Shirou did it all as an extremely unhealthy coping mechanism for his intense survivors guilt, trying to find validation and worth in saving others until it ripped himself apart. Ritsuka meanwhile got shoved into a position as a normal guy/girl and *has* to keep going, else all of humanity and their own lives will be lost, but also carrying the weight of so many lost lives on their shoulders, the sins of destroying lost belts.
Both are terrible tragedies, one due to personal choices from compounding grief and trauma, and one due to circumstance way, way beyond their control that they still have to face, because there's no one else who can.
What an honour. What an injustice.
@@amidabibjo1869 i am not even sure about that last part, guy got trained as an assassin as a kid, sometime almost got near-death fighting and training, then he really did died that one time Touko pulls a Gojo on him
It doesn't really matter who suffers more. It's who's do you care about more. Personally, I care more about Shirou as a character and find Ritsuka frustrating. So seeing Shirou suffer hits harder for me.
@@gerardomunoz6725 i can respect that, in the end of the day, suffering isn't a dick measuring contest
@@amidabibjo1869 to be fair though, they both have body counts you would not bother to count, Ritsuka killing at least a couple hundred thousand to potentially billions per lostbelt (with some exceptions), since by technicality its an alternate Earth, only that we can only interact with a certain portion of it since the rest is not willed to reality yet, while Emiya is killing endlessly as long as Alaya sees a problem which needs to be solved. Both of them would rather not kill if they can help it, but they have to keep moving forward.
EMIYA's backstory already makes me sad, but EMIYA Alter's backstory, this part in particular, had me bawling like a newborn baby Q~Q
How is he not a Berserker after all that is beyond me
His heart is made of glass but his mind is made of wrought-steel.
Well he is qualified for the berserker class, Emiya alter could probably be summoned as a berserker as you know with Vlad where he was summoned as a berserker even though he was a lancer in Apocrypha
I'm surprised his Alter didn't manifest as an Assassin since he was basically a hitman in life.
@@raymondyongho5757 he is also qualified for assassin but that is for regular EMIYA, although his alter should have the same qualifying classes Archer, Caster, Assassin, Berserker
@@bluedefalt4097and technically Saber since he can still make the normal variations of his swords. He’s classified for all main classes really
Love how Emiya was listening to him and was just like "oh nah, you're COOKED!"
Can we just speak on the art of this manga for a moment? It feels so raw and gritty, a powerful tool to aid in the telling of EMIYA Alter
Emiya in black with the red scarf is reminiscent of Walter B. Gibson's The Shadow.
Deep cut.
Just when you think Emiya Shirou can't suffer anymore, there is a universe where his life is worse. I agree with you, this is a Mind of Steel continuation. He isn't even bothering to be a Superhero here. I also think it's interesting that the government saved him from death to be their perfect agent. He did actually defeat a major threat to them. It's just too bad it cost him his soul.
Also, I really wonder what Kotomine would have thought about Kiara, and if he would have stood against her and what she represented -- especially if he could have trained Shirou to kill everyone he loves. I think, in this scenario, the priest would be laughing from beyond the grave at Alter's fate.
Kotomine would probably join the cult to see Emiya Alters suffering first hand. And would also probably backstab Kiara
@@justsomeguyonhisphone709 That would be both horrible, and hilarious.
Going by what Rasputin says about her, even he thinks she is too much.
Kirei would eliminate Kiara without a second thought. Without even a first thought. Kiara would be just another loser that made it big by playing a conman. As far as Kirei's concerned, she isn't even a lowly life-form; merely another politician draped in someone else's clothing trying to make a bigger deal of herself than she was. Those are the kind of people that Kirei has no qualms eliminating. Zouken was a little better than Kiara in terms of purpose; Kiara is not even worth a worm to Kirei. She'd be dead and buried in an unmarked grave.
“Why are we here? Just to suffer?” Is literally the very definition of Demiya.
26:38 THANK YOU: if this was one of Emiya Alter's ascensions, or even a skin, type moon would jave raked in so much cash 💰
They had my man become a government spook just taking people out with a suit and everything. I can't help but think of Kiritsugu and Kirei as they both took out magi/monsters but found no real salvation or satisfaction just doing it until they were at the end of their rope or literally couldn't anymore.
His NP make way more sence now essentially shooting his ideals into a something and those ideals tear them apart from the inside as swords. I don't think we've ever seen it depicted being used on anything but I imagine it looks like they got hit with an Origin Bullet only messier being turned into a porcupine with swords sticking out.
Justice for emiya we need it
"Justice" is probably the last thing he wants.
Tell that to Shirou....
Give him a route where he and Artoria are together and they are not only in a relationship but have a family.
So in short we have more or less the following endings or definitions of some versions of shirou emiya:
Shirou emiya (fate route): he had gone to avalon post-true ending of the fate route, true ending of fate route is on the fate/stay night last episode, his ideals stayed the same but he is more insightful of others (this is what i understood about Fate route shirou since his story is pretty simple)
Shirou emiya (no route aka common facts only): disappeared in some time after (i think it was on 2008, 2009'ish or around the 2010's), this version is still in lack of information so i will say nothing
Shirou emiya UBW: gone to the clock tower with rin early and learned some things that he would learn later in the war early such as creating copied NPs that are not techniques or divine constructs and unlocking his Reality marble early, maked sure he doesn't end up as EMIYA (archer).
Shirou emiya HF: turned into an doll, btw it was the best scenario for him in the HF route from which i nicknamed the HF route as 'there is no holy grail war and yes only destruction' route, abandoned his ideals to only protect his close ones
Shirou emiya miyuverse: gone to the imaginary number space, abandoned his ideals to save his sister
EMIYA (Archer): executed in public because of his ideals, Fate route shirou except he did'nt save Saber and also he turned into an counter guardian by forming an contract with the world
Nameless (archer): same as EMIYA (Archer) except he was betrayed by his friends since they already knewed the path he was going, almost the same as Emiya (Archer) except he maked peace with his ideals, gone for an mercenary job and maked an contract with moon cell
Since we got the backstory then; EMIYA Alter: was going to be executed but he had being turned into an governament dog aka an public hero, lost all of his remaining of being Shirou emiya in the Kiara sessyoin's cult fight and inspired by mind of steel ending of FSN the only difference is that he stills care for taiga (even though he killed her), just like his FGO profile screen says he is an merciless executor.
We’ve been getting a lot of EMIYA backstories but never Shirou post-fsn stories. It’s like Shirou’s character development throughout the routes and appearances (minus Emiya) are non-existent. I don’t even think anyone cares about Shirou anymore.
@@subcommanderxelios800 Not gonna lie, I always wanted to know what happend in archers grail war and how he proceeds afterwards till his death and also post ubw and fate route.
Emiya alter is interesting and all but I wish I could finally get answers on the where fate and ubw shirou succeed where archer failed.
Ubw shirou especially because he saw archers life so he can go right where archer went left but nasu probs don't care. I also say this because sbaer got garden of avalon (though it was too short for my liking) but archer doesn't get that kind of expansion.
@@thirdplanet4471 I think Archer’s backstory doesn’t need any more content. We know he’s a Shirou Emiya that lived a life similar to the fate route just minus the love for Saber. I am more interested in the OG Shirou since he’s always been getting shitted on by the fandom, neglected by nasu, and replaced by muramasa. Mabye one day we may get a different class of EMIYA that directly references OG Shirou Emiya’s appearance in every fate series. Maybe like a ruler or saber class Emiya because of the Avalon ending. Him making it to Avalon is no small feat.
in the Type-Moon I care about EMIYA and NANAYA the most So every EMIYA video is a win for me.
I read this yesterday and damn it hurts a lot.
This is the closest we'll get to a possible background for EMIYA Assassin (Kerry/Kiritsugu) as well since it sounds similar to how his life ended up as. It would've been worse had the ones who spared him from execution were from the Mages Association
Deym Emiya alter suffered a lot, I do wonder in his current state of mind what would he wish if he was given the grail(aside from killing shirou).
A question for anyone willing to answer: Why did Natsu and a good portion of Type Moon, write Angra Mainyu as weak in terms of being a servant?
We’re all aware of the build up he was given from Zero, slight mentions from the Fate and UBW Routes, good portion of the story in the Heaven’s Feel Route to even being given a small event in FGO to shine. Yet that one seemed to be more focused on introducing Kiritsugu as a Counter Guardian.
You’d think for someone given this amount of build up, has one of the most tragic backstories, literally forced against his will to embody everything scummy about Humanity to even being given the monicker of ‘All The Worlds Evil’ would be a pretty powerful threat in terms of being a servant or character, right?
This isn’t me doing this for the sake of complaining and I do like a good portion of his character. This is just me being curious on why he was written to be weak in terms of being a servant.
Another thing I’d like to know if what would he look like if he was summoned in a different class? How would a Angra Mainyu look like as a Berserker? How would that work with his character and would that make him able to be equal with other servants or no?
It really is fucked up because he did infact save humanity but at the cost of killing his own humanity.
Seriously who gave that man that clean ass cut tho
damn, Alter Shirou really did off his whole family.
alright hear me out; If the running theory is that this mind of steel Shirou, he's gone hardcore into adopting the Kiritsugu method, but to an alternative extreme; as Kiritsug's method is as little collateral as possible, Alter Shirou's would be as much collateral as possible to bury it from people's consciousness.
And as a staunch anti-magus and any presentation of magecraft advocate, disconnected or alienating from any connection with the larger mage community.
in effect, probably the only surviving bonds Shirou had to the outside world was with Taiga. (I'm also more inclined to believe that Taiga's son is also his in a roundabout way, as the only anchor to his sanity)
Shirou's knee jerk reaction is to cut it at the source (preventing another Sakura route Heaven's-Feel-like scenario, were his actions may've been aimed at saving Sakura but the cost in lives is unacceptable, and if made to repeat HF Alter Shirou's solution maybe to simply destroy the grail war from advancing beyond the initial summoning phase, kill all participant masters and -their extended families-, hunt surviving participants from previous grail wars (if he discovers them), and maybe tear apart the church and mage's association to reach Zelretch, after destroying all related information about the ritual).
like asking about the grail and people's only recollection would be Jesus's cup from the last supper.
(forget mind wiping, he's going scorched earth doctrine).
this sounds like a whole mini singularity/lostbelt where shirou thinks that doing this would be for the best of humanity in general but if he succeeds he would do it and finish it would have horrible affects on humanity or something
The price he paid just to become a hero....
Thats a Berserker face that would scare a Foreigner
Kiritsugu would be rolling around in his grave if he were to look at the type of man his son grew up to become and saw his reflection.
On another note; since Kiara was Emiya Alter's enemy in life, would the Counter Force summon him to deal with her whenever she becomes a threat rather than a Grand?
almost any route kiritsugu would be haunted with the type of person shirou became
Sigh things just keep getting worse he officially become known as worse Case scenario emiya of course until another emiya gets even worse fate and knowing netso there definitely will be someone even worse
Emiya alter should be an Avenger at this point
Nah man he'd be a Grand avenger
Angry Mango aka Angra Mainyu: Oh I see how it is. I just don’t exist to all y’all now huh?
Amor(Caren): Dude they didn’t mean it.
Angra Mainyu: Nah Ruler I know exactly what they meant! They’re better get their cancel culture ready for what I am about to say. You bunch of rotten-(a storm of curses 🤬 and slurs)!
Thank you for covering this, I didn't know it was already translated.
I mean he refused a co-operation from Ishtar and was like ' am gonna investigate this my way, no help needed'. Being with ritsuka with all the nice attitude pissed him it's not a surprise he betrayed them.
This manga has been so fantastic. I mean some elements are horrific like with Emiya Alter. But still it’s a great manga with amazing moments. Loving the fights especially.
EMIYA seems to never catch a break bro just be taking L after L
The art is goated ngl. The paneling, the composition, the linework, everything is just so perfect especially for Emiya's story
Tsiah in the beginning is a whole mood
27:03 I'm in those comments actually. Hell, I saw where someone edited this and made a final ascension picture like it was a costume, and yeah I'd pull for this and throw whatever materials or prisms at this skin if it was made.
I'd pay top dollar for this skin 26:54
Thanks!
Quick questions: what limits the servant that you can summon if you don’t have a catalyst( by that I mean a physical object connected to the person, outside of your own physical body like francesca) to use, but a good mana pool? Can someone who has ties to death summon death of the four horseman, like a church executioner?
Why do servants that clearly has no desire to get the grail get summon? Prime example being Gilgamesh. Can the servant not refuse the summon because of the summoner possessing a catalyst?
Gilgamesh does desire the grail. He’s explained that his natural assumption is that it belongs to him and he wants it back since he assumes anything valuable must be something he forgot he had.
@@Khajitxi i really meant the wish, but wanting to get the physical grail I guess is fiend. I know he had in his gate of Babylon before it disappeared, so wouldn’t it just do that again? I guess he could wish it to forever remain in his possession.
Damn fate really loves giving emiya that Peter Parker treatment " is that happiness im seeing overthere immma need you to get rid of all that ".
Shirongoing alter turns him into a Fed, checks out
Lime to see a video on how well Prisma Illya would do in FGO
imma say its ya fault it got translated LMAOO bro puttin the fate community on his back
Do you think that illya can fuse with a card in her Zwei form when she has the 2 khaleido sticks fused together and if she how powerful would her being fused with the Saber card be or even better the berserker card to use Hercules I think that would be something great to see in the show or a moving as a last stitch move
8:57 he looks like Columbus
I'm going to start using emiya alter more.
Shirou is the only character Type Moon can consistently that makes us feel things
Crazy thing is Angra Mainyu is an Emiya and his suffering began at the start of humanity 😭
Hey Tsiah, where do you read your Emiya Alter manga on? I wanna start reading some also.
Emiya Alter: Life update, it got worse
We need an anime
They love and they hate EMIYA
Dont let em bring down the Goatmiya grind 🗣️
Spiderman: why i have a feeling that someone is staring my ass
fate is my one comfort topic that i cant talk to any of my friends about
so real
I think the point where he disappears the contract
I really wish we grt this as a costume and they put at the same time put more thought into the alter skin in na. Not about anything but color theory for me since the cracks blend into the skin. I wanna use third ascension badly but it look so bad to me as an artist
0,12 no way these man packs look like bazonkahonkas in this illustration😂.
Attempt 99 of asking you to do a video on white wolf's world of darkness.
hey can you do a how to watch fate especially the singularities and the lostbelts
The Counter Force needed someone like Emiya. Not Shirou.
Apocrypha is another timeline where Shirou is doing okay along with Rin, Sakura, and even Luvia.
So Emiya got turned into a glowie asset? Wow...
sometimes i do wonder that why didnt emiya just made a wish to the grail to remove his existence
Maybe the grail isn't powerful enough. Also, my opinion but perhaps he doesn't want to cease existing and prefers to keep going.
I'd join Kiara's cult in a second
Its surprising to see that all this originated from a Eroge.
hey does anyone know what that thing was if it wasn't primate M at the end of case fiIes?
😢
Emiya is just that guy and being that guy just sucks
He need more Buff
Emiya Stocks are rising.
So his fate is either suffer to fight or bliss in nothing?
Yesss, they haven't even tapped the ultimate moneypool, the husbandos.
What I would do for a Summer Gilgamesh, man
I fucking grailed and gold foued Percival to maxed, please more husbandos lol
Where do you read fate at
26:35 nah you giving good ideas. If it's for guys it's a nah. If it for the waifus it gets them money.
what about Shiki Tohno
Let's just take a moment and look at 8:30. You can't help but admire the artist's talent and how punchable they made that man's face.
my question is, who is Taiga's son father???
👍
Ok
Being a fate protagonist is a curse. Harem protag EX isnt worth it either.
How can I find the manga,,
Name??
SERAPH, Cyber abyssal paradise.
Emiya alter is a side character here. The main characters are Fujimaru Ritsuka and Meltryllis.
bro why is shirou always getting bad treatment
He’s supposed to have dark skin right? These manga panels don’t convey that.
24:24 except for this BERSERK moment
At least the manga version makes him look more like an adult Shirou, instead of a generic black dude