Review the reservation - not to end - at least those who’s parents have got into education job through reservation should be out of the category - that can be implanted immediately without any change in law. But no government will dare do it as they will lose the votes !
Add income limit to reservation. There are students giving 2lac fees to coaching living privileged life getting equal opportunities and then they want reservation in exams. There is social media and a great wave can be created against these people stabbing their own community. They are modern oppressors of their own community. Getting reservations even in promotions is useless, the army won't follow this as they believe in merit. Use AI do promotions based upon performance of individuals without human interference. Actually Reservations are the reason our public services are so bad. And yeah this guy is just a blatant liar, what nonsense data he is citing, living in his own fantasy world. He was not even worthy to be on this podcast. Atleast there should be another person sitting here to counter his dumb arguments.
रिजर्वेशन की जगह पिछड़ों के काम- धंधे के लिए पॉलिसी बनानी चाहिए थी... - आरक्षण देना , उसकी बाते करना और नेता बनना बहुत असान हे... - बिना आरक्षण अगला वर्ग अभी भी आगे ही हे...
I was also upset when I heard him saying that the working class is lower class. He should remove the Spectacles of seeing everything from the perspective of caste
I'm a Dalit, I've spent my childhood abroad and after I returned to India I never availed reservation benefits, competed in the general category, and proved myself on merit. Yet, despite being more intelligent, sharper, and even better-looking (if I may say so myself), people still didn't consider me equal simply because of my caste. It's a harsh reality that needs to be acknowledged. Now, living in the West, I find myself more accepted and respected among people from diverse backgrounds. It's not that I don't miss India - I do. But the truth is, we still have a long way to go in terms of social equality.
Amazing to see that a PHD scholar is comparing American white support of 21 st century to Indian upper caste Let us check what happened in 18 th and 19 th century in America
Condition of slaves was far better than pathetic and miserable conditions of Dalits of India.Atleast Americans feel sorry for their deeds but savarna people are still the same and these pushes the country 50years back.Every thing is superficial.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab but Dirt poor Dalits who live in village areas are still not getting benefits of reservation, and privileged Dalits who can afford the education and stuffs of their children are still shamelessly using reservation, is this justice? I'm not even talking about finishing the reservation as I know for a fact a section needs it badly but that moron in the podcast said anything about this issue? Or he still think people like Agrawal sweets because of the name Agrawal and not for it's sweets. Majority of bheemta community have brains like this moron, no wonder they get abuse from not only UC but SC STs as well.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab Reservation is also not a get rid of your crime or get job quick scheme. We all know how harijan act works and how harijans use it against other castes.
>Your Tuition Fees are Exclusively Waived off. >Your Seats are Exclusive. >Your Cut-offs are Exclusively Low. >Your Scholarships are Exclusive. >Your Protection Act is Exclusive. >Your Government Jobs are Exclusive. After all these you are Demanding "Equal Citizenship" 👏
Caste card le k dusron caste abuse kar k merit student ki seat mai kabja kar ke they want caste eradication. Kya Joke hai phele apna ideology thick karo
-Tuition is waived for economically weaker section only. - Cutoffs are low because number of candidates are low. - Everyone seat is exclusive - Scholarship is for everyone. - protection is exclusive because crime against dalit is exclusive. - The entire private sector is exclusive
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab how is entire private sector exclusive its all talent based a lot of dalits also are directors and manager not because they re dalits but they deserved that lol. Scholarship are not exclusive. There's a reason it's called unreserved category
Bandaa kahna toh bahut kuchh chahta hei, par kah nahin pa raha hai 😢 There is huge backlog in dalits reservation. Ok. Tell me how it can be solved? Yaar mujhe kya pata! Yeh toh sarkar karegi. Lekin sarkar dalit ki hona chahiye. To bhai mere tu phd hai itna padha likha hai, tu sarkar kyun ni bana raha hai! Yaar mere paas funds ni hai. Sad very sad. Toh jo sarkar mei hei usko karne ke liye bolo. Halaki PM khud obc ke hain, president ST ke hein. Lekin sarkar dalits ke nahin hei. To bhai batao kya karen! 😢 Food is food there's no caste in it. But why there's no chamaar sweet shop? Yeh brahminical patriarchy hai😢😢😢. Kya logic hei bey!
@@dipanshusingh6641 Still 16% reservation quota level in never achieved. Upper castes cleverly want to convert leftover quota seats to general category, during 76 years there is a huge backlog and authorities never tried to fill this back log. But in case of EWS they are sincerely implementing it, despite the merit of EWS quota candidates found less than SC, ST and OBC
Smitha ji should have asked some tough questions like, should a son of IAS or very high position govt job parent get reservation. And if so then whats the point?
Tell me, are you ready to marry your sister with dalit person or are there any brahmins ready for marriage with dalit person? I know that your answer would be - no , how will be this posible? So, so called uresian mind set boy you should Go to library and read annihilation of caste. If you want to know about social justice and casteless society.
@@VikashkumarwithstudentsBrahmin women are not your property, this is the true color of an oppressed moolnivasi, he considers UC women a trophy to be acquired. Keep seething.
A very articulate man and Dalit community needs more leaders like you. I do understand the vicious comments about the upper caste comes from generations of denial of social justice, but we can move forward with a a new generation of leaders within the Dalit community to represent them and not token leaders. As a Hindu and recently many Dalits refuse to call themselves a Hindu, I can say for myself that just like Dr.Ambedkar accepting Buddhist religion today many Dalits doing this is not a shock but very normal as Buddhist religion is a sect within the Sanatan umbrella of Dharmas. Listening about his mother tells us that its temples are also a place where people get a sense of belonging. Great conversation 👏🏼🙏🏼
Before Ambedkar there were thousands of Gurukuls in India where students of all Varna used to get education. Even in our ancient texts, it is mentioned. Nishad Raj and Ram ji studied in the same Gurukul Chandragupta Maurya was a student of Chanakya. Nanda Dynasty was a Shudra dynasty. Maratha confederacy was full of Shudra clans (Gaekwad, Bhosle, Holkar) So many Alvar and Nayanar saints were from Shudra Varna. There were Bheel Kings who helped Rana Pratap against Akbar. There were about 500 Shudra kings all over India when British arrived in India. But victim card doesn't have any Expiry date.
He happens to be so called educated but the intelligent quotient is 10-20, and what can we expect from illiterate ST,SC people.He is saying BJP and Modi will change the constitution that shows his intellectual honesty. These people do not criticize,abuse,the Britishers who were the main culprit behind seeding casteism and caste politics in hindu society.Caste politics should be abolished bcoz there are political parties who are using this fault lines to further divide hindu community 👀🤔
But how, ever wondered that genius ? Forcefully? Hell nah, i dont want massive riots, the only way is to industrialise rapidly and make everybody rich, no one will have time to talk nonsense of caste!! Caste exists only landlord and govt. job seekers
5 lakhs crore rupees to Dalits are given every year by 30 state govts and central govt combined. 2.They get 100% free education + hostels+ housing. 3.They get jobs + promotion 4.They get govt tenders,contracts and petrol pumps. 5. Sc st act is used for extortion and blackmailing. Whining never ends.
WellDone Bro... Your interpretation About Castes And Bramhmical Social Order is Very much Logical. Brahmins are not against for EWS Reservation. At the same time they are against SC, ST, OBCs and Muslims Reservation. Backlogs Full fill by Law...
He is from lala salam.He is a woke dalit. He has nothing to do with welfare of dalit he just want to be an activist. Everything bad around him is because of Brahmin
He is worried because caste is ingrained in his social reality. He and his family has suffered all the socio economic disadvantages inflicted by social structure dominated by caste...
@@t--k. Lol...seriously. How is Caste impacting him, if he's Born in a Buddhist family ? Its just about playing victimcard and crying about it. I have friends who come from SC and ST community...who come from Lower to normal Middle Class background, even they speak against reservations....because Caste is not a factor in today's time, its all about Money and Brains (Skills)..How much you have defines your worth for the society. Many of the Brahmins and Kshatriyas who are in Low-income households or work as Sweepers/househelps...can hardly afford education for their children. But kuch logon ko toh 100% reservation and 100% Fees Maaf chahiye, while the General Category student (howevery sharp or Intelligent they might be) rot in the Merit List.
It's time to introduce Reservations in people daily life & food shop choices too. If an Upper Caste person shops 10 times a day, 7 out of 10 shops should be SC/ST-owned, 2 OBC-owned and 1 should be Muslim-owned. Aggrawal Sweets must offer 110% discount to SC/ST Dalit Customer's
My solution to end descrimination: Dalits should be educated, they should know their rights, they should be taught confidence. Reservation is a paradox because when you say you have reservation to people they get to know that you are Dalit then they will look down on you and then you ask for reservation to compensate. Once a Dalit comes out of poverty and attains education he should stop calling him self a dalit with confidence and give up reservation. Half of the effort must be made by Dalits themselves to come out of discrimination. when you calling yourselves a Dalit you are saying that you belong to "lower category" human being, so do not call/identify yourselves as a dalit.
Tere baap dada mandir s ghr chlate h hmre baap dada khetio m manual civil cleaning etc labours m Hard work krte h..Bina mhnt ki Kom ni h hum tmhre maa bapo ki trh
At least you got a loan even at 10% interest, but when a Dalit goes to take a loan, he does not get the loan. To take a loan, up to 20% of the loan amount is taken as bribe. And no person from his community is on a high position because your people are sitting everywhere, hence he cannot even complain about this. After that he also pays interest. Don't look at what is written on the paper. Look at the ground reality. But you people are hypocrites, you won't see this. You know everything but you come with your mouth raised to do nonsense.
Yes people dont ban intercaste marriage, they ostracize their daughter, or do honor killings. Search haryana honour killing, bas 4 din pahle ka case hy 17 years ke ek ladke ne uske didi ko goli mar dia because she married a dalit.
What about false SC ST cases on general and obc 😂😂😂 always used victim card to get more power and money😂😂 what you done for your society reservation is still from 1950.
How many members into your family are married with sc st and obc? You had an extra right which was given by manu 😂 then why did your family married with mughal and how did this possible that india under the mughl and british ?
@@Vikashkumarwithstudentsyes, Brahmins clean the drains too, read françois guatier's research. Although I don't expect you to read otherwise you wouldn't have needed reservations lmao
@@manansharma9872 how many Brahmins died in India during cleaning the drain ? And how many Brahmins get down in the gutters? And you are a real reservation hunter and eating 🤣🤣🤣 10% sudama kota.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents 3 members infact my paternal grandmother is SC that too someone who migrated from BGD to India during partition. Infact my paternal grandfather is Kshatriya grandma SC. Infact my mother's side of my family is Baniya. One of my cousin sisters is already married to an OBC guy. And another cousin sister is getting married this November to a Brahmin guy. And no I am not bluffing and before you accuse me of that let me tell you my cousins from that side of the family till now take Reservation BTW the last thing to accuse me of is of being casteist. Bramhan ke alwawa sabka khoon hai mujhme😅😅
Not even them Satya Nadella great grandfather was farmer who died young His grandfather was teacher (who's brother worked as a laborer so that he can study) His father was IAS (a teacher's son) Then Satya went to manipal and MS in the US. A hard ladder vs someone who gets failed marks and still qualifies
Bhim Army supporters first kiIIed a Brahmin man and then kidnapped the son of the deceased Ashish Mishra. Instead of taking action, UP police has registered two cases of the SC ST act on the victim family. Dhanjay Mishra, 18 years old son of the deceased, was kidnapped on 19 March but yet not found. No media is interested in showing such matters. Neo Politico spoke to the victims. An incident from Bahraich, UP.
@@drscience_xobru my neighbour is a dalit he owns a 5bhk in Mumbai. According to this guys logic he shouldn't get flat in nice neighborhood. It's all bs paisaa bolta hai. A lot of upper caste live in Chawl as well grow up
1) Dalit reservations were never implemented completely, vacancies in lakhs exist till date 2) govt. jobs are only 2% of jobs available, in private sector the representation of sc/st/obc is abysmal 3) google sc/st act and you will find how lower castes are forced to take back their complain. Hathras is a great example of the same. Yesterday, thehindu also reported a similar case. 4) reservation in promotion is an enabling provision and thus, most govt. do not implement the same. Moreover, reservation in promotion was limited by the court by applying the creamy layer In my opinion, sub classification along with reservation in private sector and intercaste marriage will solve everything, but unfortunately, these progressive measures will be resisted.
Thanks Smita for this interview which gives us an insight in to the world of Dalits in this 21 st century. Power to you Rahul, just great. Its sad that Indians have carried racism to the 21st century from the days of Manusmriti , a shame indeed.
Stop caste based reservation Start economic based reservation Not getting chances is higher education and jobs for reservation I am a middle class so called upper caste
@@SeekerSeeker Bhai Bengali hun pr jo attyachar hum general o ko sc st krte h kitni general ldko ne apne jan diyi h pata h .... Sala 80 85 mark lane k bd bhi hum ko waiting krar dete h mm to krta h ki Chad se kud jye sala general hona hi pap h
Oppressor vs oppressed...non Dalits vs Dalits...rich vs poor...Brahmin vs non Brahmins... This is Leftist, commie, woke teaching in JNU...and you get a professor ship in this..
We have been buddhist from ancient times. You should be listen to osho lecture and you need to read more Intelactual books. When we read about our history then we knew who was my ancesters . And also we knew that brahmins are विदेशी😂😂
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents abhi reservation ke bharose nahi padha hota to English dhange se to aata tereko km se km, jab aata nahi hai to Hindi mein bol ya Bheemte log jo bhasha jante hain usme bol? Jo videshi theory leke ghum raha hai usko bahut bar debunk kiya ja chuka hai, Osho lecture sunne se pahle lecture ka spelling padh ke aa, fir yaha gyan batna.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents bahut badhiya comeback bete, abhi aaya na line mein. Jab kuch cheez aati nahi na to koshish mat Kiya kar, kya hai na language sikhne mein koi quota system nahi hota hai, khud dhyan laga kar padhke seekhna padta hai.
He can get 100% reservation in Private sector if he wants Reserved category people can start their own firm let's say an IT firm and hire only workers from their own community
Bhai what a liar “upsc me written me lower castes ke jyada aata hai “.. check the cutoffs of 2023 upsc cse exam.. there is a gap of 50-60 marks in written cutoffs also 😂😂
Jo scame hota h wo seat uc ko hi milta h pese deke Or upsc me v Casteism hota h school me v practical me no km milte h to upsc ka chairman kon sa dudh ka dhula h
Paper set karega sharma,exm lega dube, copy check krega Trivedi, result dega Agarwal aur interview lega mishra to... jyada number aayenge hi....mukh se paida hone wale. Prani😂😂
Let's not blow up caste based discrimination top much! Yes it exists, but it's not the root cause of all the problems. This country is not that rejecting to anyone who is really exceptional...in that case, caste has always become secondary, despite hurdles!
It is very simple to say like this. It so happened that upper castes became rich. Everyone benefited from caste system. Upper castes were also ruined during Mughal rule by paying huge taxes. Lower castes enjoyed the market monopoly till mediaeval times. It was most simple work with less labour. British ruined their livelihood by dumping cheap goods from Britain. Now they are poor from 2 centuries. It's very complex!!!
They want benefits also and ye faltu ka rona bhe ...har jgh pr less marks score krke quota le kr ke general or deserving ke seat khate ho or ye faltu ka rona bhe rona hota hai ..woww hypocrisy ka level .padho karo hamari jitne mehnat aoe open category main fir hum bhe tume uss equality se dekhege...
85 percent Mulnibasi log Govt benefits lena anyai hai kia ?? 85 percent Mulnibasi log tax Jada pay karta hai upna Matrubhumi ka Lia, Videshi logoko kiu shubidha milega Bhai.
@@Help_journey mulnivasi propaganda band karo, it's proven by scientists & by archaeological data you are not mulnivasi or that crap, everyone has the same DNA genealogical connect. Kuch padh liya karo, har jagah reservation kaam nahi aata. 40years pehle hi mulnivasi ka jhoot pakda gaya hai.
Means mam you clearly want to say that you believe that we are not equal this what the real moto of reservation aap sab logoko equal samjo aur rahi baat marks ki your ancestors may be literate but ours not we are second or third generation of our caste who are taking education you already have the privilege in every factor you get to go in good delicate private school and we are going in government Zilla Parishad schools and everyone knows what is the condition of govt schools toh percentage pe faraq toh 100% padega and I do agree that some deserving didn't get change but EWS bhi toh hain agar sach mein economically weak hain so they are getting chance too aap thoda phele research karlo
Rahul bhai is the best thinker of current times... he keeps bringing fresh thoughts with long-terms vision... I look forward to his leadership in future.. i hope he gets time to publish many of his thoughts in books or other forms... this would prove to be great literature in coming times!!! he made so many important points that completely flew above the head of many uppercaste viewers here. no wonder these people came here to argue with anxieties as has Rahul bhai repeatedly said... 1. his analysis about social dynamics from political system to constitutional system, 2. his analysis about caste as problem of behaviour and then political economy, 3. privileged people perceiving reality/problem through a spectacle (both in cases of caste and gender), 4. his argument about the policy enactment first to eliminate structural barriers then the skill gap will take care of itself-- is very insightful
Is there any Justice Where OBC and General People Getting MBBS seats Marks Of 650 and SC ST Students Getting Seats by scoring 400 marks 😂 And He says Reservation Should be Increased
Listen me ureshiyan mind boy Is there any justice where so called upper caste have 5 acare land and 8 lakh yearly incomes still they are getting 10% ews reservation. Second things - has any person into your family discriminated?
This guy is a completely leftist inspired bloke. Churning out the same shit that we have been peddling for last 75 years. Time for some original thinkers to rise up from the bahujan community who can offer some realistic solitions.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab tell me one guy from your community other than Baba saheb who did something good for this country? From mayawati to lalu everyone just ruined the society.
@@walterpinkman5249We don't have to say like that. I'm sure there are countless lower caste people who worked on themselves and made it to the top tier on their own merit and skill. The thing is people don't even ask for vaaste anymore. I haven't.
I am watching this with my friend. Who is a dalit. He is 😂 on him. He just hates upper caste. He is saying, mere samne baithao batata hu. Pata nahi kaunse discrimination ki baat kar raha hai.
Gond Kingdom was prevalent around MP, Chhattisgarh, Orissa. Right?? Many Gond Kings had established marital relations with Rajput kings also. Correct?? Padhne likhne ka adhikar nahi tha lekin King banne adhikar tha??
Summary, remove all exams everywhere, implement reservation everywhere, baaki sab hain ghanta, he’s ideal person for garbage like equality labs, CEO position
Is working class = lower class?Really? My father worked so hard and many times he struggled too, that was equivalent to working class of carpenters,plumbing,mechanics. And my family is OC reservation. Even now,he is having a micro business and even then I don't get study enough. So, you want me to become a Muslim?
I feel you. Our parents have worked hard from being the same lower class poor people who had nothing to middle class working people and our caste and religion had nothing to do with that.
@@rajkumar-em9id Toh aapka kya kehna hai? Ki logo ko ye so-called caste ya jaati basis par reservation hona chahiye aur economic basis par reservation nahi hona chahiye jo sabke liye acha hai. Isse economic reservation har 5 saal ka census hoga aur sab log apna reservation economic basis par govt chunega ya ek strict digital, automatically enhanced system lagaya jaye taaki kon kis category mai aayenge pata chal jayega.
@@kv4720 reservation garibi hatao program ni hai Aap Logo ko caste reservation se bahut problem hai but EWS se ni jo ki reality mein ek caste basis reservation hi hai kuki wo sirf general caste ke liye hai EWS par aapka stand kya hai? Mera manana ye hai ki india ke sawarna jaati ko reservation chhorkar jaati ko khatam karne ka solution dhudna chahiye aur intercaste marriage sath khana peena and all thing start kar dena chahiye aur is kaam ke liye aandolan karna chahiye jab jaati mit jayegi reservation apne aap khatam ho jayega
We jains dont ask anything from goverment .we have gareab people. We get help from our mandir. App mandir banao , goverment will give money to mandir and you help your people. Start school business
Ye mandir banane ke baad, waha par bhi reservation chalu karenge, govt se financial subsidiary mangenge, inko muscle power aur mehnat karke kamana nahi hai, sirf sarkari jamai banna hai.
Only minorities I love and adore are jains❤ we love you all, aap in ambedkarites aur mullo ki tarah rote ni rehte hakk se kamate ho aur desh ke liye kaam krte hoo love you❤
Jain sthanak are minority institutions you can control and operate them as you like but hindu temple are legally under control of government including its donations are taken back by government.
IAS got reservation and become IAS, his son gets reservation and so on story goes. remove reservation for rich dalits. introduce creamy layer in SC,ST,NT reservation. remove reservation on promotions... after taking reservation in college,university,graduation,post gradyation,job they still want reservation in promotion. still they will cry they are poor, they are discriminated. reservstion is 55% which is contradictory to Dr.Ambedkar sir own vision and intention.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents Ku mai na dalit se shadi kar ke samanta lau ??? So you don’t believe equality between sexes ? Sir there is no caste today in Nagpur there is only class based discrimination . My friends marks in prelims is better than both Tina dabi and Ria dabi guess what they used to come in cars some time in my friend was sweeping the floor of same class to sustain himself after 3rd attempt , class name Shubhra Ranjan political science , I have seen his suffering , you people just want abuse the sister , daughter of other caste in name of imaginary discrimination . Class >>>>> caste . Reservations is blatant discrimination, even if person become the group A officers and his/her son/daughter using reservation and claim that son/daughter of daily wedge labour discriminate against him is joke of this constitution .
Rahul makes many valid points regarding reservations. I might not agree with the side he is, as a whole, but I can definitely acknowledge with the many dalit issues he points out during this podcast. Casteism although fading away, is unfortunately still rampant in our society, so we can’t expect reservations to go away just like that until Dalit issues are remedied on not just the state but at a social level.
"Agarwal Sweets naam ki wajah se log sweets khaane jaate hai", what a logic😂😂😂😂😂, this man is a walking joke, koi bhi aadmi apne naam par khud ki dukaan ka naam rakhega na, uske dukan mein log uske surname ke karan aate hai, ye jhand jaisa conclusion lga raha hai 😂😂.
Chamar, kasai sweets rahega toh obviously because it's associated with meat koi nahi jaayega. But Meena sweets, Jatav sweets, Mandal sweets se merko nahi lagta kisiko koi problem hoga. Ye example jaanbuj ke isne liya hai.
@@nirbhaygor We have a mandal chowmin and fast food in our city which is quite famous, no one cares for his caste. But this man is a complete idiot quoting some random things. He is following a line of agenda which is political.
As a leader and Dalit intellectual I was expecting the guest to talk about caste discrimination within the Dalits. What does he think about Dalits who do caste discrimination against other Dalits?
Power to you Rahul Sonpimpale. Really Great , soul stirring and powerful talk. Its high time Indian people and politicians hear such and think of equality and compassion for human beings . Work towards doing some good Karmas all the racist Indians
There should be "reservation quota" system in Olympic games too, so they can get representation in sports too Like in 100m race, if a "d@lit" competitor completes the race in 11 seconds, he must be declared the winner and gold medal must be handed over to him
What he talked about beef is very unrealistic in Dalits and Buddhists also. He is totally lying about that things or brainwashed in communists ecosystem. Non-vegetarian doesn't means beef.
Kafi struggle k baad last 30 years me sab log ek dusre k sath ghulne milne lage the ...all castes were slowly adapting each other but in last 10 years something is going wrong.
@1:34:16 his argument is completely nonsensical. Because, like he said, dalit students are restricted to their 16% quota, not because they don't want dalits in open seats, but simply because there not enough dalit students breaking that cutoff barrier. And those some ppl scoring more than cutoff are hence, put in the quota just so that quota no is fulfilled and open students can be compensated. He's simply using the outstandingly better performing dalit students examples and making it sound like a norm. Again he says the dalit/obc/st cutoff is close to open. That too is incorrect. Obc cutoff might be close to open cutoff but there is marginal difference when sc and st cutoffs are to be looked at. Take CAT cutoffs for IIMs(all) for example for OPEN they simply have to be above 85, OBC atleast 75 and SC and ST its 54 and ST its 40 (all in percentile) I've also witnessed a scenario where simply after multiple rounds in UG medical college admissions the ST seats weren't getting filled bcoz the ST students weren't either scoring the cutoff/were inelligible bcoz they had less than 40% in boards. He keeps saying there is backlog, because lets say for any govt job exams even when their seats are reserved, there simply are not enough sc/st students clearing that cutoff and then some commission tells they can't go below certain score, and hence they are vacant
Very unfortunate and painful. Dalits+OBCs+EcoWeaks be given completely free educations, transportation, houses, medical, 5kg per month per person upto a max 4nos per family each of pulses, wheat, veg oil+spices+salt, rice equivalent of Money in account, interest free loan of up to 20times of per capita income repayable over 15years for setting up businesses or perusing higher studies, 100% of airfare for study abroad (once in three years), 20times of interest free debt for industrial R&D, 2times per capita income to support studies so far the student scores >70% marks in the exam/s; This all student/ studies support until the age of 30years. In addition, State & Govt must open at least 15% of all categories of educational institutions ( nursery thru postgrad) with all faculties that only employ and educate such uniquely positioned
.01% भी IAS IPS IRS IFS नही हम महादलित यहाँ तक कि ऑफिसर भी नही,, 70 साल से शोषित हो रहे है हम,, गाँव के दूरस्थ छोर पर हमारी कच्ची बस्तियाँ, जहाँ कोई दलित नही आता,, झाड़ू 70 साल से थी आज भी हम वाल्मीकियो के पेट भरने के काम आ रही टॉयलेट, सेप्टिक टैंक हमारे कार्य स्थल है,, किस्मत अच्छी हो तो सरकारी सफाई कर्ता की नौकरी मिल जाती है SC के आरक्षण के असली हकदार हम है,, पर आरक्षण हमें छु कर भी नही गया 50% SC VARG मे से शुद्ध आरक्षण दो, बैक लोग के साथ,, अन्यथा हमें मजबूरन आंदोलन पर उतरना होगा, अब मलाई नही चाटने दी जाएगी,, महादलित की स्थिति एक महादलित ही समझ सकता है जय महादलित आरक्षण संघ शक्ति,, जय वाल्मीकि
Data says this. Which Data is that. Let me give you that fool. NEET cut off for my state. 610 for Gen 580 for OBC 480 for SC 400 ST It takes 3000 yes just that much money to study from PW coaching and score better. Who would become a good doctor?? Any Guesses??
Entry mark does not indicate anyones capacity.Anyone can become a good doctor by scoring 100/720. Because there are 55 percent private mbbs seats in India and so many good doctors comes from private medical colleges.
This guy is totally toxic and caste obsessed. Sorry, 13mins were torture, can’t watch the remaining 130mins. Big thumbs down to this podcast Smita, I watch all your podcasts, even with Owaisi wasn’t this regressive.
Ye working class= lower class ki bakwaas mat karo. Pahale ja k data check karo. Education free lo, kya desh lena chahte ho. Har jagah reservation dene par society me problem hui h uska bhi socho. Kaam karte nahi, kota pura chahiye. Ye soch ko bhi badalo.
जमीनों का समान वितरण pr chup kyu jo jate ho? Free education to tumlog bhi le rhe ho और तो और भीख माँगने का nya tarika paida kiye ho n dharm और palhand ke nam pr 😂. Tum ko reservation se dikkat hai to 10% chhod kyu nhi dete ho?
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents Wahi toh....you don't want to end reservation at all. Reservation was introduced to provide equity to those who are at odds with right to opportunity, caste basis. You'll be behind reservation your whole life?? Isnt education enough for you? Why don't you compete with others by applying for General category? Let's make it fair, if you want fair
@@gopald9962 This is bullshit the fair competition is bullshit the fair competition means when oll community in the past have same education but in this country the upper cast are ruler class and other not not so their is no way fair competition the fair competition means in which everybody is equal both in past and present times what nonsense one community are educated in the olden times do you think who are know getting some educational give them fair competition this is bullshit
@@Patr600 so you're saying you can't rely on yourself to make the decisions that change your life for your good. Thanks for letting me know you can't do anything on your own. You need handovers. And some more help.
Excellent interview . The first time interviewer is supportive in finding a solution to the caste menace. The interviewee is a highly informed and very knowledgeable person. Excellent.
Reservation percentage: SC -15%, ST -7.5, other BC -27% and poor FC’s whose income is less than 8 lakhs get 10%. Why these caste and religious extremists talking like only SC/ST’s get reservation and enjoying the opportunities?😅After reading the comments I am realizing the hate for Dalits is so extreme even in this contemporary society. jai hind😅
Reservations will be dangerous without merits. It will drown Indian once again, rather government launch skills programs and give jobs to any skilled workers
oh you mean just like we have all the doctors from capitation fee colleges where exorbitant fees is the main criteria for admission rather than merit, now who are become criminals charging exorbitant hospital fees and killing patients. Is this dangerous or not
People love their caste identity irrespective of what they have to deal with because of that. No caste, lower or upper wants to do intercaste marriage and casteism won't be an issue if majority stops benefiting using their caste identity.
Comment section testifies the current condition of Dalits and the mindset of so called upper castes! Finally somebody called a dalit person to talk abt caste system , and their issues, ni toh its all savarns only talking abt reservation and how caste system is no longer existent which is nthing bt bullshit. Its now not that overt bt covert. And people talking how reservation should be removed ...never utter a line on how caste based discrimination shud be removed. Never! They want reparation and apology from the britishers, but apne girebahn me kon jhakta hai. They still practice caste biasness, bt have the audacity to claim their is no discrimination..just dalits were lame ! The oppression that they did for thousands of years was worse than any invader or oppressor. But the fact is they are proud of their actions ..and still proud. This is the core issue ..towards this they will happily close their eyes . We complain hw brtishers are not taught theri own colonial history of wt they did around the world, in our nation , the savarns have no idea what they take pride in , has a history one shud be ashamed of. Instead only dalits are shamed( not even obcs bagging highest pcrntge of reservation)
@@तुषारप्रकाशमिश्रा looks like you dont follow newspapers..and authentic media streams ...you seem to be following the mainstream media owned and run by savarns with an agenda. Try to know abt the real life experiences from the perspective of dalit media too! You cannot be the spokesperson of the harassed and just deny things that are blatant. Educate urself first. Get a 360 degree view.
And its from my own experience... Caste discrimination happens in multinational companies as well , so its not a remote village thing..and you cannot speak on my behalf , Its my experience! its full fledged everywhere despite the laws...as most of the enforcers themselves are casteists! And reservation is abt representation. And distribution of power..not financial status.
@@kaverikumari9332 Representation?? Then please give up your Reservation and let the poor Sanitation Worker's son get that Reservation for the REPRESENTATION
@@docno1117 ah well, then why are you cribbing so much abt reservation... Now you guys are acting like its somewhat better off people ( only Scs) are doing injustice to the others...are u kidding me...some of them ve just gained financial stability( decent posts) probably from this generation. Still the reserved posts go unfilled or converted to unreserved slyly( discrimination exists still every where as in ur mind too) . The climb is steep so its gonna take time... The generational abuse of thousands of yrs..and reservation for only ehat 70 yrs. And you are right ....as per requirement..the reservations should increase for the sanitation workers and other scheduled castes also ...tht you wont even have any idea( thnx to ur privileges) . But then , you should also stop denigrating them as untouchables..( dint your ancestors start and practice this religiously! And you're still. Try marrying an educated , well off person fron the very sanitation workers caste, before u preach) Lets have more reservations for people ..cz the savarns did really do a good job in exploting 80prcnt of the population! And by the way..fyi...OBCs (non creamy layer) still more affluentand land holders than than Affluent Scs /sts....! Do some proper research..and know the difference between sacrifice and reparation ! For the savarns...its not sacrifice...but its reparation for their own dark abominable deeds!
if after reservation has not worked and this guy is still crying. so rrservation is not fruitful. remove reservstion. backlog is because they cant scire good marks, dont have skills. with this logic. 45% will become doctor, B.E and then ppl will be treated wrongly, brudges will collapse.
There's a reservation for sc st OBC to get admission in medical College ok but to clear mbbs or any examination there's no any reservation pls join any library read some books
Dalito me bhi wo jatiya dal di hi jinpar discrimination nahi hota jese up me dhobi pasi gadariya, madhya pradesh me dhobi , maharashtra me chambhar, haryana me dhanuk ,vese bahut sari caste he jo OBC me honi chahiye thi par inko SC me dala he pahle inko nikalo SC se bahar 💙🔥💪
Thats true and thats why the converted Christians eat beef cause all of them were poor and they converted religion for basic necessities like food and the consistent discrimination and atrocities.
Reservations should be upto certain extent, like in medical, it should be only till mbbs and not in MD level, after mbbs, you are capable enough to fund your tution fees, also what i noticed in my government college during Md, max people who took sc/st seats, were more wealthy than general seat people, i am not against reservations but it should be limited to certain level
People like him who invokes & propaganda, hatred, enimity, violence in name of fighting rights for sc/st/dalits. They themsleves leaves good capitalistic luxury lifestyle and wants other to follow socilistic life. They have zero contribution towards field of commerce and science. @ANI News shld avlid to advocate and invite such people.
Throughout this guy only speaks about getting everything free. Why not Dalit who became prosperous open free schools, tuitions for other Dalit ? Why not Dalit build temple, society for themselves and then if they want they can stop other upper caste from entering there. I am not an upper caste but I have not seen lower caste supporting their own community , working hard etc. all they want without working hard. My grandparents came from dirt poor background, they taught their kids and in turn my parents taught us. We have reached to a level through shear hard work not by protesting, blaming upper caste, playing victim card.
While left liberals ignore scholars from subaltern backgrounds atleast the mainstream channels. Kudos to ANI for atleast considering different persepectives despite the difference in opinion. :)
Brings tears to my eyes...education and eliminating poverty is just a drop in the ocean...social reform within Islam..at least in India is a must...and the change must come from within
What nonsense. Students study in same school. During boards general students score more than Dalits. And im boards name of the students everything is kept hidden. Them who is stopping who??
@@anishchoudhury4973 Brahmin 20/- dan lala vik samj ka 🖕 Tara pora khandan to gribo ko loot ka bana hai andhvishwas ke naam pe , ab Tara superiority nahi chala ga
You ask a fair opinion from ST of any jharkhand, Chhattisgarh then you will realise the effect of reservation. Clerks can't take the print out in front and back mode, required educated person to assist him for filling a simple form. Even a honest ST will criticize the reservation..😢😢
Time to End Reservations in India? What do you think?
Review the reservation - not to end - at least those who’s parents have got into education job through reservation should be out of the category - that can be implanted immediately without any change in law. But no government will dare do it as they will lose the votes !
Hell yeah!
Add income limit to reservation. There are students giving 2lac fees to coaching living privileged life getting equal opportunities and then they want reservation in exams. There is social media and a great wave can be created against these people stabbing their own community. They are modern oppressors of their own community. Getting reservations even in promotions is useless, the army won't follow this as they believe in merit. Use AI do promotions based upon performance of individuals without human interference. Actually Reservations are the reason our public services are so bad.
And yeah this guy is just a blatant liar, what nonsense data he is citing, living in his own fantasy world. He was not even worthy to be on this podcast. Atleast there should be another person sitting here to counter his dumb arguments.
रिजर्वेशन की जगह पिछड़ों के काम- धंधे के लिए पॉलिसी बनानी चाहिए थी...
- आरक्षण देना , उसकी बाते करना और नेता बनना बहुत असान हे...
- बिना आरक्षण अगला वर्ग अभी भी आगे ही हे...
और भाई हम चमार को जुते बनाने आते है.. मिठाइयाँ नही..
मिठाइयाँ तो अग्रवाल चाचा ही अच्छे बनाते हे
Waah working class = lower class. Jiyo mere JNU ke sher. This is the level of our M.Phil and PhD holders to interpret data.
I was also upset when I heard him saying that the working class is lower class. He should remove the Spectacles of seeing everything from the perspective of caste
That's a fact. You could cry about it but facts doesn't care about your emotions
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrabworking class matlab sab kaam karne vale insaan ho gaye, usme caste kaha se aaya bhai, sab log kaam kar rahe hai
Tujhe samajhne ke liye time lagega. Datas jo screen mein dikhe wo check kar bewakuf.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab
Facts Data Se Define Hote Hain . Hava Mei Baat Matt Kar . GST Jyadatar Trader Use Karte Hai.
I'm a Dalit, I've spent my childhood abroad and after I returned to India I never availed reservation benefits, competed in the general category, and proved myself on merit. Yet, despite being more intelligent, sharper, and even better-looking (if I may say so myself), people still didn't consider me equal simply because of my caste. It's a harsh reality that needs to be acknowledged. Now, living in the West, I find myself more accepted and respected among people from diverse backgrounds. It's not that I don't miss India - I do. But the truth is, we still have a long way to go in terms of social equality.
That's why most rich Dalits are leaving India
True i can understand you...❤
@@SentinelBlaze give an one example of one dalit billionaire
When dalit become rich then he should left caste because there is no value of caste
@@unknownman-q5l tell me how is it possible to leave any caste?
Amazing to see that a PHD scholar is comparing American white support of 21 st century to Indian upper caste
Let us check what happened in 18 th and 19 th century in America
Condition of slaves was far better than pathetic and miserable conditions of Dalits of India.Atleast Americans feel sorry for their deeds but savarna people are still the same and these pushes the country 50years back.Every thing is superficial.
Your statement proves the whole podcast correct
They are not ready to accept that poor dalits need reservation not rich one. Kyuki khud ki reservation chali jayegi
Exactly because if they do so reservation will eventually end and moving forward they won’t be able to exploit it further
Reservation isn't a poverty alleviation scheme.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab Education and Service opportunities are not playgrounds for caste politics
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab but Dirt poor Dalits who live in village areas are still not getting benefits of reservation, and privileged Dalits who can afford the education and stuffs of their children are still shamelessly using reservation, is this justice? I'm not even talking about finishing the reservation as I know for a fact a section needs it badly but that moron in the podcast said anything about this issue? Or he still think people like Agrawal sweets because of the name Agrawal and not for it's sweets. Majority of bheemta community have brains like this moron, no wonder they get abuse from not only UC but SC STs as well.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab Reservation is also not a get rid of your crime or get job quick scheme. We all know how harijan act works and how harijans use it against other castes.
>Your Tuition Fees are
Exclusively Waived off.
>Your Seats are Exclusive.
>Your Cut-offs are Exclusively Low.
>Your Scholarships are Exclusive.
>Your Protection Act is Exclusive.
>Your Government Jobs are Exclusive.
After all these you are Demanding
"Equal Citizenship" 👏
Caste card le k dusron caste abuse kar k merit student ki seat mai kabja kar ke they want caste eradication.
Kya Joke hai phele apna ideology thick karo
-Tuition is waived for economically weaker section only.
- Cutoffs are low because number of candidates are low.
- Everyone seat is exclusive
- Scholarship is for everyone.
- protection is exclusive because crime against dalit is exclusive.
- The entire private sector is exclusive
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab private sector is free idiot, not exclusive.
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab how is entire private sector exclusive its all talent based a lot of dalits also are directors and manager not because they re dalits but they deserved that lol. Scholarship are not exclusive. There's a reason it's called unreserved category
Totally wrong😂😂@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab
10% rich so called dalit eating entire SC reservation.
He already mentioned that hardly 3% of total 16% filled by govt. Then tell me who is eating.
Meena is ST
How many government jobs are there in total
Bandaa kahna toh bahut kuchh chahta hei, par kah nahin pa raha hai 😢
There is huge backlog in dalits reservation. Ok. Tell me how it can be solved?
Yaar mujhe kya pata! Yeh toh sarkar karegi. Lekin sarkar dalit ki hona chahiye.
To bhai mere tu phd hai itna padha likha hai, tu sarkar kyun ni bana raha hai! Yaar mere paas funds ni hai. Sad very sad. Toh jo sarkar mei hei usko karne ke liye bolo. Halaki PM khud obc ke hain, president ST ke hein. Lekin sarkar dalits ke nahin hei.
To bhai batao kya karen! 😢
Food is food there's no caste in it. But why there's no chamaar sweet shop? Yeh brahminical patriarchy hai😢😢😢.
Kya logic hei bey!
@@dipanshusingh6641 Still 16% reservation quota level in never achieved. Upper castes cleverly want to convert leftover quota seats to general category, during 76 years there is a huge backlog and authorities never tried to fill this back log. But in case of EWS they are sincerely implementing it, despite the merit of EWS quota candidates found less than SC, ST and OBC
Smitha ji should have asked some tough questions like, should a son of IAS or very high position govt job parent get reservation. And if so then whats the point?
No point. They are selfish and greedy and using the 'discrimination' plan is their only way to illegally hog benefits
Tell me, are you ready to marry your sister with dalit person or are there any brahmins ready for marriage with dalit person?
I know that your answer would be - no , how will be this posible?
So, so called uresian mind set boy you should Go to library and read annihilation of caste.
If you want to know about social justice and casteless society.
Arey in logo ki bhi fat rahi hogi itne sensitive topic pe baat karke. This is ANIs monkey balancing act😄😄😄
@@VikashkumarwithstudentsBrahmin women are not your property, this is the true color of an oppressed moolnivasi, he considers UC women a trophy to be acquired. Keep seething.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents why u want to marry brahman women make dalit women marry brahman man v know the agenda mr reservation
'Reservation in Private Sector!' What a supremely rubbish idea!
They realised that development can happen only through privatisation, so now this incompetent man wants to free-feed in private sector as well.
Privitizing public sectors and hence taking away government based jobs. What a supremely rubbish idea!
A way to destroy the country
Reservation - Rubbish, Discrimination - God Gifted
A monkey can eat sun it is ok but....
A very articulate man and Dalit community needs more leaders like you.
I do understand the vicious comments about the upper caste comes from generations of denial of social justice, but we can move forward with a a new generation of leaders within the Dalit community to represent them and not token leaders.
As a Hindu and recently many Dalits refuse to call themselves a Hindu, I can say for myself that just like Dr.Ambedkar accepting Buddhist religion today many Dalits doing this is not a shock but very normal as Buddhist religion is a sect within the Sanatan umbrella of Dharmas.
Listening about his mother tells us that its temples are also a place where people get a sense of belonging.
Great conversation 👏🏼🙏🏼
Ambedkar was a British agent.
His father was a SUBEDAR in British administration.
There is a difference between DALIT and SHUDRA.
DALIT means "OPPRESSED"
SHUDRA means "Working Class"
Before Ambedkar there were thousands of Gurukuls in India where students of all Varna used to get education.
Even in our ancient texts, it is mentioned.
Nishad Raj and Ram ji studied in the same Gurukul
Chandragupta Maurya was a student of Chanakya.
Nanda Dynasty was a Shudra dynasty.
Maratha confederacy was full of Shudra clans (Gaekwad, Bhosle, Holkar)
So many Alvar and Nayanar saints were from Shudra Varna.
There were Bheel Kings who helped Rana Pratap against Akbar.
There were about 500 Shudra kings all over India when British arrived in India.
But victim card doesn't have any Expiry date.
He happens to be so called educated but the intelligent quotient is 10-20, and what can we expect from illiterate ST,SC people.He is saying BJP and Modi will change the constitution that shows his intellectual honesty. These people do not criticize,abuse,the Britishers who were the main culprit behind seeding casteism and caste politics in hindu society.Caste politics should be abolished bcoz there are political parties who are using this fault lines to further divide hindu community 👀🤔
Did britishers introduced things like untouchability
Simple.. Remove caste system, remove reservation also...
There is no system of caste. Caste was found in Japan and Germany
Yeah now he want reservation in private organisation
But how, ever wondered that genius ? Forcefully? Hell nah, i dont want massive riots, the only way is to industrialise rapidly and make everybody rich, no one will have time to talk nonsense of caste!! Caste exists only landlord and govt. job seekers
Phir nhi in logo ko reservation chahiye.....chor r sale
Why do you want to reform a religion? Just convert out lmao, but nahi fir reservation bhi nahi milega na😂
5 lakhs crore rupees to Dalits are given every year by 30 state govts and central govt combined.
2.They get 100% free education + hostels+ housing.
3.They get jobs + promotion
4.They get govt tenders,contracts and petrol pumps.
5. Sc st act is used for extortion and blackmailing.
Whining never ends.
if all that was true the economic condition of dalits would not not have been abysmal.
@@rahul_khairnar economic condition of top 5% dalits are very good bcoz they eat reservation of poor dalits
@@upsemotivationchannelhe is one of the.
@@akashpandey9726 I agree with you
@@rahul_khairnar tu reservation chhod de bina reservation se tujhse kya hoga
WellDone Bro... Your interpretation About Castes And Bramhmical Social Order is Very much Logical. Brahmins are not against for EWS Reservation. At the same time they are against SC, ST, OBCs and Muslims Reservation. Backlogs Full fill by Law...
Reservation made dalits more Incompetent..😢
And lost generation old Hard Skills 😮
they are more than competent to displace savarnas.
@@rahul_khairnarhaan that’s the reason they want to keep using reservations to get into everything
ऊंची जात हो क्या?
@@rahul_khairnar Savarnas? You means these people dont have a varna?
And why have they not displaced so far inspite of so many dols.
😂😂😂😂 haan eskliye bass reservation pe pal rahe@@rahul_khairnar
I liked how he tried to give examples to try her understand real problems and Thanks to Smita, she also took efforts to understand 👏👏
He is from lala salam.He is a woke dalit. He has nothing to do with welfare of dalit he just want to be an activist. Everything bad around him is because of Brahmin
He should be asked which community exploits Dalit girls? Which Brahmins did riots against the Dalits ?
That's the technique of bramhins.. They hide behind the door and let their puppets do the things..
@@pratikkhobragade2871 loosers have a common trait of complaining and blaming others for their own failure, boy.
@@pratikkhobragade2871keep blaming Brahmins commies........
Please Listen whole video again and then come back to comments
This guy is a bit neo Buddhist, why he is worried about caste he ain't no Hindu anymore.
He is worried because caste is ingrained in his social reality. He and his family has suffered all the socio economic disadvantages inflicted by social structure dominated by caste...
@@t--k.I really don't think so. He just feels he is entitled to do away with anything he wants and says.
@@Dacro you think!! Oh! So what you think is more imp than what he faced and lived
@@t--k. Faced what and by whom? Everyone is facing something and living their own lives. Come on
@@t--k. Lol...seriously. How is Caste impacting him, if he's Born in a Buddhist family ?
Its just about playing victimcard and crying about it.
I have friends who come from SC and ST community...who come from Lower to normal Middle Class background, even they speak against reservations....because Caste is not a factor in today's time, its all about Money and Brains (Skills)..How much you have defines your worth for the society.
Many of the Brahmins and Kshatriyas who are in Low-income households or work as Sweepers/househelps...can hardly afford education for their children. But kuch logon ko toh 100% reservation and 100% Fees Maaf chahiye, while the General Category student (howevery sharp or Intelligent they might be) rot in the Merit List.
It's time to introduce Reservations in people daily life & food shop choices too.
If an Upper Caste person shops 10 times a day, 7 out of 10 shops should be SC/ST-owned, 2 OBC-owned and 1 should be Muslim-owned.
Aggrawal Sweets must offer 110% discount to SC/ST Dalit Customer's
What nonsense. These kinds of idiotic ideas will lead to the ruin of the country. Who r u to decide how a person spends their own hard earned money.
reservation se 55% par pass hone wala doctor tumhara ijaal karega thats great for economy and make India great according to this guy
@@Ganguly0106 bro that's sarcastic.
@@nirbhaygor Hopefully
@fight0007 still they will cry
His entire argument just 'reservation', 'reservation' and 'reservation' 😂😂😂, he is simply blaming caste for his incompetence.
asking for CEO post in a tech company after completing BA in humanities 😅
@@spinnerlake actually there should be reservation to make sure at least 50% companies in this world have SC ST CEOs😂.
@@hrishikeshbandgar2162 bhai kabil ban, world bank ka ceo ban jayega
@@harshitrathi5824 joke tha be 😂
And your people blame reservation for their own incompetence 🤣
Born Victim ... Without any Hesitation .
Ye to tum log krte ho 1000 sal tk 100% reservation lene k bad
My solution to end descrimination:
Dalits should be educated, they should know their rights, they should be taught confidence.
Reservation is a paradox because when you say you have reservation to people they get to know that you are Dalit then they will look down on you and then you ask for reservation to compensate. Once a Dalit comes out of poverty and attains education he should stop calling him self a dalit with confidence and give up reservation. Half of the effort must be made by Dalits themselves to come out of discrimination. when you calling yourselves a Dalit you are saying that you belong to "lower category" human being, so do not call/identify yourselves as a dalit.
When I went to bank for education loan i told them my caste I was charged 10 percent interest and SC St had the facility of 75% subsidy
toh apni behen byaah de kisi Ambedkarite se
Tere baap dada mandir s ghr chlate h hmre baap dada khetio m manual civil cleaning etc labours m Hard work krte h..Bina mhnt ki Kom ni h hum tmhre maa bapo ki trh
@@rahulparewa6535 beta ye jo jahil pane ki tune baat ki hai vahi siddh kar rahi hai ki teri jaati achoot kyo hai
Pehle loan tho Milne de yaar
At least you got a loan even at 10% interest, but when a Dalit goes to take a loan, he does not get the loan. To take a loan, up to 20% of the loan amount is taken as bribe. And no person from his community is on a high position because your people are sitting everywhere, hence he cannot even complain about this. After that he also pays interest. Don't look at what is written on the paper. Look at the ground reality. But you people are hypocrites, you won't see this. You know everything but you come with your mouth raised to do nonsense.
No one has banned inter caste marriages. If no one is marrying you its not a crime. 😂😂😂😂😂
Even within schedule castes there is hardly any inter marriages.
Mfw suvhuman looking moolnivasi cries oppression when he doesn't get laid 😂
Bc then why owner killing happening in India
Yes people dont ban intercaste marriage, they ostracize their daughter, or do honor killings.
Search haryana honour killing, bas 4 din pahle ka case hy 17 years ke ek ladke ne uske didi ko goli mar dia because she married a dalit.
@@SeekerSeeker that's a law and order issue
What about false SC ST cases on general and obc 😂😂😂 always used victim card to get more power and money😂😂 what you done for your society reservation is still from 1950.
How many members into your family are married with sc st and obc?
You had an extra right which was given by manu 😂 then why did your family married with mughal and how did this possible that india under the mughl and british ?
How many Brahmins clean the drain?
@@Vikashkumarwithstudentsyes, Brahmins clean the drains too, read françois guatier's research. Although I don't expect you to read otherwise you wouldn't have needed reservations lmao
@@manansharma9872 how many Brahmins died in India during cleaning the drain ? And how many Brahmins get down in the gutters?
And you are a real reservation hunter and eating 🤣🤣🤣 10% sudama kota.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents 3 members infact my paternal grandmother is SC that too someone who migrated from BGD to India during partition. Infact my paternal grandfather is Kshatriya grandma SC. Infact my mother's side of my family is Baniya.
One of my cousin sisters is already married to an OBC guy. And another cousin sister is getting married this November to a Brahmin guy. And no I am not bluffing and before you accuse me of that let me tell you my cousins from that side of the family till now take Reservation BTW the last thing to accuse me of is of being casteist. Bramhan ke alwawa sabka khoon hai mujhme😅😅
Only poor people need reservations...no one else
Not even them
Satya Nadella great grandfather was farmer who died young
His grandfather was teacher (who's brother worked as a laborer so that he can study)
His father was IAS (a teacher's son)
Then Satya went to manipal and MS in the US. A hard ladder vs someone who gets failed marks and still qualifies
+1. Poor people are disproportionately LC.
@@idzkkthe reservation is important just se the varn vyavastha and hindu cult in this country
Kya tu apni behen ki shaadi. Dalit se karega. ?
@@shubhamdupare9809so long as he follows hindu religion which comprised of vegetarianism and benevolent 😊
What Britishers wants from Ambedkar; Ambedkar did ; what Ambedkar did, their followers are continuing it.
What Mughals wanted u also did.
@@rohitpratap5946 oh n that's u knew by ur British fathers Isn't it.
@@rohitpratap5946 When there is no logic then one has to resort to fallacy.
@@s.s.rajput2800No, I know this by reading class 7 NCERT which is written by ur actual father who wipe out ur clan 21 times😂😂
@@rohitpratap5946 You have proved that you are an Ambedkarite.
Bhim Army supporters first kiIIed a Brahmin man and then kidnapped the son of the deceased Ashish Mishra. Instead of taking action, UP police has registered two cases of the SC ST act on the victim family. Dhanjay Mishra, 18 years old son of the deceased, was kidnapped on 19 March but yet not found. No media is interested in showing such matters. Neo Politico spoke to the victims. An incident from Bahraich, UP.
Ladwa ehai hammar jhuttha saale source de
PM OBC , president ST but BJP is party of upper caste 😅
You watch the interview again, specially the part where Mr. Sonpimple, was explaining about TOKENIZATION.
Pm obc kb ho gya❤de😂
President?
She can't inaugurate anything.
She can't enter mandirs.
@@amandmxmodiji obc hai bhai modi caste obc category mein atti hai
Kya fayda jbb chalana nagpur se ho hai to
This man is clearly over exaggerating the caste issue in cites
you will only understand if you are dalit in a city
@@drscience_xo Women also give answers like this - you will only understand if you are a woman
@@drscience_xobru my neighbour is a dalit he owns a 5bhk in Mumbai. According to this guys logic he shouldn't get flat in nice neighborhood. It's all bs paisaa bolta hai. A lot of upper caste live in Chawl as well grow up
@@drscience_xomy gf is SC and i am jat, so shut up, i only came to know about her and my other st friend bcz of admission rules in clg
@@mangoman-vx4pz Same here also bro these SC ST are loving 5 storey houses ... theses SC and ST are far more dengerous than brambhins...
1) Dalit reservations were never implemented completely, vacancies in lakhs exist till date
2) govt. jobs are only 2% of jobs available, in private sector the representation of sc/st/obc is abysmal
3) google sc/st act and you will find how lower castes are forced to take back their complain. Hathras is a great example of the same. Yesterday, thehindu also reported a similar case.
4) reservation in promotion is an enabling provision and thus, most govt. do not implement the same. Moreover, reservation in promotion was limited by the court by applying the creamy layer
In my opinion, sub classification along with reservation in private sector and intercaste marriage will solve everything, but unfortunately, these progressive measures will be resisted.
Thanks Smita for this interview which gives us an insight in to the world of Dalits in this 21 st century. Power to you Rahul, just great. Its sad that Indians have carried racism to the 21st century from the days of Manusmriti , a shame indeed.
Stop caste based reservation
Start economic based reservation
Not getting chances is higher education and jobs for reservation
I am a middle class so called upper caste
stop the caste system first. Start protesting to remove the caste system then reservation will be removed automatically
Caste system kb ka khtm ho chuka h but in logo ne caste system ko bol bol k bacha rkha h kyunki sabse jyada fayda to yahi log utha te h caste ka
@@sushrutrodge5437how? You tell me?
Tu bangal se hy isliye tu samajh nhi pa rha hy. Bangal main caste ka pbm hy nhi.
Lekin hamare inha log apni ladki ki honor killing kr dete hy
@@SeekerSeeker Bhai Bengali hun pr jo attyachar hum general o ko sc st krte h kitni general ldko ne apne jan diyi h pata h .... Sala 80 85 mark lane k bd bhi hum ko waiting krar dete h mm to krta h ki Chad se kud jye sala general hona hi pap h
Oppressor vs oppressed...non Dalits vs Dalits...rich vs poor...Brahmin vs non Brahmins... This is Leftist, commie, woke teaching in JNU...and you get a professor ship in this..
Reservation lene ke liye dalit reservation se naukari milane ke bad Buddhist aur Christian what a bullshit😂😂😂
We have been buddhist from ancient times. You should be listen to osho lecture and you need to read more Intelactual books.
When we read about our history then we knew who was my ancesters .
And also we knew that brahmins are विदेशी😂😂
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents abhi reservation ke bharose nahi padha hota to English dhange se to aata tereko km se km, jab aata nahi hai to Hindi mein bol ya Bheemte log jo bhasha jante hain usme bol? Jo videshi theory leke ghum raha hai usko bahut bar debunk kiya ja chuka hai, Osho lecture sunne se pahle lecture ka spelling padh ke aa, fir yaha gyan batna.
@@walterpinkman5249 बढ़िया है sale jija se majak 🤣🤣
@@walterpinkman5249
तैयार रहना चिराग paswan bhaiya tumhara अगला जीजा banne vale hai 🤣
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents bahut badhiya comeback bete, abhi aaya na line mein. Jab kuch cheez aati nahi na to koshish mat Kiya kar, kya hai na language sikhne mein koi quota system nahi hota hai, khud dhyan laga kar padhke seekhna padta hai.
all comments are against him telling indian people still not changed
Calling wrong as wrong is not wrong . He is not saying anything sensible .
Reservation in private hello!!
Also cracked good working class jokes😂
He can get 100% reservation in Private sector if he wants
Reserved category people can start their own firm let's say an IT firm and hire only workers from their own community
Bhai what a liar “upsc me written me lower castes ke jyada aata hai “.. check the cutoffs of 2023 upsc cse exam.. there is a gap of 50-60 marks in written cutoffs also 😂😂
Jo scame hota h wo seat uc ko hi milta h pese deke Or upsc me v Casteism hota h school me v practical me no km milte h to upsc ka chairman kon sa dudh ka dhula h
True bro am one of the victim two times,, even in UPSC and PG..
Paper set karega sharma,exm lega dube, copy check krega Trivedi, result dega Agarwal aur interview lega mishra to... jyada number aayenge hi....mukh se paida hone wale. Prani😂😂
Military/Army mei toh kabhi reservation nhi manga 😂😂😂
Let's not blow up caste based discrimination top much! Yes it exists, but it's not the root cause of all the problems. This country is not that rejecting to anyone who is really exceptional...in that case, caste has always become secondary, despite hurdles!
It is very simple to say like this.
It so happened that upper castes became rich.
Everyone benefited from caste system.
Upper castes were also ruined during Mughal rule by paying huge taxes.
Lower castes enjoyed the market monopoly till mediaeval times. It was most simple work with less labour.
British ruined their livelihood by dumping cheap goods from Britain.
Now they are poor from 2 centuries.
It's very complex!!!
They want benefits also and ye faltu ka rona bhe ...har jgh pr less marks score krke quota le kr ke general or deserving ke seat khate ho or ye faltu ka rona bhe rona hota hai ..woww hypocrisy ka level .padho karo hamari jitne mehnat aoe open category main fir hum bhe tume uss equality se dekhege...
85 percent Mulnibasi log Govt benefits lena anyai hai kia ?? 85 percent Mulnibasi log tax Jada pay karta hai upna Matrubhumi ka Lia, Videshi logoko kiu shubidha milega Bhai.
@@Help_journey mulnivasi propaganda band karo, it's proven by scientists & by archaeological data you are not mulnivasi or that crap, everyone has the same DNA genealogical connect.
Kuch padh liya karo, har jagah reservation kaam nahi aata.
40years pehle hi mulnivasi ka jhoot pakda gaya hai.
@@TruthAlwaysWinsतुमहरा पिताजी दयानंद सरस्वती का किताब पढ़ो, सब कुछ पता लग जायेगा। मोहन भागवत का भाषण सुनो, तब यूरेशिया पिताजी का याद आ जायेगा।
Ews ke baare m bhi bol do.। Free ka garib logon ka hissa kha rhe ho
Means mam you clearly want to say that you believe that we are not equal this what the real moto of reservation aap sab logoko equal samjo aur rahi baat marks ki your ancestors may be literate but ours not we are second or third generation of our caste who are taking education you already have the privilege in every factor you get to go in good delicate private school and we are going in government Zilla Parishad schools and everyone knows what is the condition of govt schools toh percentage pe faraq toh 100% padega and I do agree that some deserving didn't get change but EWS bhi toh hain agar sach mein economically weak hain so they are getting chance too aap thoda phele research karlo
IMPRESSED BY HIS INTELLECTUALISM 💪
Rahul bhai is the best thinker of current times... he keeps bringing fresh thoughts with long-terms vision... I look forward to his leadership in future.. i hope he gets time to publish many of his thoughts in books or other forms... this would prove to be great literature in coming times!!!
he made so many important points that completely flew above the head of many uppercaste viewers here. no wonder these people came here to argue with anxieties as has Rahul bhai repeatedly said...
1. his analysis about social dynamics from political system to constitutional system,
2. his analysis about caste as problem of behaviour and then political economy,
3. privileged people perceiving reality/problem through a spectacle (both in cases of caste and gender),
4. his argument about the policy enactment first to eliminate structural barriers then the skill gap will take care of itself-- is very insightful
He is laying, Being Dalit SC-ST lot of benifits and perks are there in Government and in Society..
Is there any Justice Where OBC and General People Getting MBBS seats Marks Of 650 and SC ST Students Getting Seats by scoring 400 marks 😂 And He says Reservation Should be Increased
Listen me ureshiyan mind boy
Is there any justice where so called upper caste have 5 acare land and 8 lakh yearly incomes still they are getting 10% ews reservation.
Second things - has any person into your family discriminated?
@@saiprasadpatil3251 Btw, this year cutoff for SC ST was 300 to 350.
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents listen to me meemta boy if a dalit has 5 acres land and 50 lakh income does he enjoy reservation or not?
Abe salo sc population h uska adha v reservation ni milta 😂😂😂 or general se adhi v seat ni hoti sc st ki😂😂
@@Vikashkumarwithstudentsलिखना तो सीख ले डांग के मैल ।
This guy is a completely leftist inspired bloke. Churning out the same shit that we have been peddling for last 75 years. Time for some original thinkers to rise up from the bahujan community who can offer some realistic solitions.
These people should be asked about Dr Ambedkar s views about Pakistan and generally partition.
We don't any advice from savarnas on how to run our movement. You don't have any right to tell us how to fight for justice
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab thik hai Bhai. Tum log ki strategy bahut successful Hui Kya?
Mayawati ke admin main UP top pe chala gaya Kya?
@@AbhishekKumar-pattycrab tell me one guy from your community other than Baba saheb who did something good for this country? From mayawati to lalu everyone just ruined the society.
@@walterpinkman5249We don't have to say like that. I'm sure there are countless lower caste people who worked on themselves and made it to the top tier on their own merit and skill. The thing is people don't even ask for vaaste anymore. I haven't.
I am watching this with my friend. Who is a dalit. He is 😂 on him. He just hates upper caste. He is saying, mere samne baithao batata hu. Pata nahi kaunse discrimination ki baat kar raha hai.
Meri chachi bhi gujarati dalit family se hai but woh aisi harkate nahi karti hai😂 Woh bahut achhi hai ❤
Working class = Worker labourers sweepers... waaaah Bhai waaah .. kya intelectualism ki MCdi hai
Working class= OBC SC ST
I love how people are offended just by listening to him.
Well he's just spitting venom from his mouth what do you expect.
Guy is a RED through and through
Gond Kingdom was prevalent around MP, Chhattisgarh, Orissa. Right??
Many Gond Kings had established marital relations with Rajput kings also. Correct??
Padhne likhne ka adhikar nahi tha lekin King banne adhikar tha??
They can't digest the truth😂
@@amandmx
The truth that You can't beat the General Candidates even with the help of that Caste-Certificate 😂😂😂
@@amandmx
The truth that SC/ST people can't compete that's why they blame General Category for their own Incompetence 😂😂😂
Summary, remove all exams everywhere, implement reservation everywhere, baaki sab hain ghanta, he’s ideal person for garbage like equality labs, CEO position
Every Dalit face casteism in his daily life in this bloody casteist society........😢😢😢
Is working class = lower class?Really?
My father worked so hard and many times he struggled too, that was equivalent to working class of carpenters,plumbing,mechanics.
And my family is OC reservation.
Even now,he is having a micro business and even then I don't get study enough.
So, you want me to become a Muslim?
I feel you. Our parents have worked hard from being the same lower class poor people who had nothing to middle class working people and our caste and religion had nothing to do with that.
Wel overwhelmingly the working class is OBC SC ST because we are the largest population group. Dont take it personal. This is about a larger group
Aap sab kuch samjhne ke baad bhi statement ka galat matlab nikalne ki koshish kar rahe hai yahi jatiwaad hai
@@rajkumar-em9id Toh aapka kya kehna hai? Ki logo ko ye so-called caste ya jaati basis par reservation hona chahiye aur economic basis par reservation nahi hona chahiye jo sabke liye acha hai.
Isse economic reservation har 5 saal ka census hoga aur sab log apna reservation economic basis par govt chunega ya ek strict
digital, automatically enhanced system lagaya jaye taaki kon kis category mai aayenge pata chal jayega.
@@kv4720 reservation garibi hatao program ni hai
Aap Logo ko caste reservation se bahut problem hai but EWS se ni jo ki reality mein ek caste basis reservation hi hai kuki wo sirf general caste ke liye hai
EWS par aapka stand kya hai?
Mera manana ye hai ki india ke sawarna jaati ko reservation chhorkar jaati ko khatam karne ka solution dhudna chahiye aur intercaste marriage sath khana peena and all thing start kar dena chahiye aur is kaam ke liye aandolan karna chahiye jab jaati mit jayegi reservation apne aap khatam ho jayega
We jains dont ask anything from goverment .we have gareab people. We get help from our mandir. App mandir banao , goverment will give money to mandir and you help your people. Start school business
Ye mandir banane ke baad, waha par bhi reservation chalu karenge, govt se financial subsidiary mangenge, inko muscle power aur mehnat karke kamana nahi hai, sirf sarkari jamai banna hai.
Jains hi milta hai ya kamate hain usko bhi daan de dete hain, inlog bas mangte hi rahte hain.
Only minorities I love and adore are jains❤ we love you all, aap in ambedkarites aur mullo ki tarah rote ni rehte hakk se kamate ho aur desh ke liye kaam krte hoo love you❤
@@chhayashah1401 Jains work for welfare of society, their aim is to make world a better place, unlike other communities who dream of ghazwa-e-hind.
Jain sthanak are minority institutions you can control and operate them as you like but hindu temple are legally under control of government including its donations are taken back by government.
IAS got reservation and become IAS, his son gets reservation and so on story goes. remove reservation for rich dalits. introduce creamy layer in SC,ST,NT reservation. remove reservation on promotions... after taking reservation in college,university,graduation,post gradyation,job they still want reservation in promotion. still they will cry they are poor, they are discriminated. reservstion is 55% which is contradictory to Dr.Ambedkar sir own vision and intention.
A new privileged.society being born
Tum bas sudama kota me खुश रहो😂😂
Nahi to apni बहन का विवाह kisi st sc se karva do
सामाजिक samanta bhi aaegi Or tujhme samjh bhi aaega
@@Vikashkumarwithstudentsholy shit you're literally begging for Brahmin girls in everyone's comments, so disgusting 🤢🤮
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents
Ku mai na dalit se shadi kar ke samanta lau ???
So you don’t believe equality between sexes ?
Sir there is no caste today in Nagpur there is only class based discrimination .
My friends marks in prelims is better than both Tina dabi and Ria dabi guess what they used to come in cars some time in my friend was sweeping the floor of same class to sustain himself after 3rd attempt , class name Shubhra Ranjan political science , I have seen his suffering , you people just want abuse the sister , daughter of other caste in name of imaginary discrimination .
Class >>>>> caste .
Reservations is blatant discrimination, even if person become the group A officers and his/her son/daughter using reservation and claim that son/daughter of daily wedge labour discriminate against him is joke of this constitution .
Rahul makes many valid points regarding reservations.
I might not agree with the side he is, as a whole, but I can definitely acknowledge with the many dalit issues he points out during this podcast.
Casteism although fading away, is unfortunately still rampant in our society, so we can’t expect reservations to go away just like that until Dalit issues are remedied on not just the state but at a social level.
Nonsensical chap. Utter nonsense he has uttered.
Tu Bhai ganja phuk. Terko samjhega kaise ?
"Agarwal Sweets naam ki wajah se log sweets khaane jaate hai", what a logic😂😂😂😂😂, this man is a walking joke, koi bhi aadmi apne naam par khud ki dukaan ka naam rakhega na, uske dukan mein log uske surname ke karan aate hai, ye jhand jaisa conclusion lga raha hai 😂😂.
Mai to dukan ka naam Ronaldo Sweets rakhunga
Ch@mar sweet kholega aur fir blue color ka peda aur rasgulla bechega to kaun khayega 😂😂😂
@@walterpinkman5249 😂😂😂
Chamar, kasai sweets rahega toh obviously because it's associated with meat koi nahi jaayega. But Meena sweets, Jatav sweets, Mandal sweets se merko nahi lagta kisiko koi problem hoga. Ye example jaanbuj ke isne liya hai.
@@nirbhaygor We have a mandal chowmin and fast food in our city which is quite famous, no one cares for his caste. But this man is a complete idiot quoting some random things. He is following a line of agenda which is political.
As a leader and Dalit intellectual I was expecting the guest to talk about caste discrimination within the Dalits. What does he think about Dalits who do caste discrimination against other Dalits?
Dalit always talk about discrimination against upper caste but they never talk discrimination they face from Muslim, Christian or any other religion.
Why do you think Muslims and Christians don’t have the so called upper caste?
Power to you Rahul Sonpimpale. Really Great , soul stirring and powerful talk. Its high time Indian people and politicians hear such and think of equality and compassion for human beings . Work towards doing some good Karmas all the racist Indians
There should be "reservation quota" system in Olympic games too, so they can get representation in sports too
Like in 100m race, if a "d@lit" competitor completes the race in 11 seconds, he must be declared the winner and gold medal must be handed over to him
Nice idea,a perfect candidate for social justice minister 🎉
Currently there is no quota. With 140cr+ we can't bring single gold medal.
Kutarak karne ho to kuch bhi karo...
@@t--k. Kutark karne hai toh kuch bhi Karo..Dude shuru kisne Kiya
@@t--k. Neeraj Chopra kya bhains pakad laaya tha kya bhala fek ke? Ya gold medal kaat ke uska bhi hissa de tab manoge?
@@nirbhaygor😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
What he talked about beef is very unrealistic in Dalits and Buddhists also.
He is totally lying about that things or brainwashed in communists ecosystem.
Non-vegetarian doesn't means beef.
Kafi struggle k baad last 30 years me sab log ek dusre k sath ghulne milne lage the ...all castes were slowly adapting each other but in last 10 years something is going wrong.
Bhimto navbuddhisto ke rise ke baad wapis casteism rise hua hai
Whatever he can't defend, he'll deny! 🙄
Lol ANI normal user base got really mad in the comment section lol
buddhism is a religion of intellect
Nothing to learn from this podcast. Many of the statements is false.
@1:34:16 his argument is completely nonsensical. Because, like he said, dalit students are restricted to their 16% quota, not because they don't want dalits in open seats, but simply because there not enough dalit students breaking that cutoff barrier. And those some ppl scoring more than cutoff are hence, put in the quota just so that quota no is fulfilled and open students can be compensated. He's simply using the outstandingly better performing dalit students examples and making it sound like a norm. Again he says the dalit/obc/st cutoff is close to open. That too is incorrect. Obc cutoff might be close to open cutoff but there is marginal difference when sc and st cutoffs are to be looked at. Take CAT cutoffs for IIMs(all) for example for OPEN they simply have to be above 85, OBC atleast 75 and SC and ST its 54 and ST its 40 (all in percentile)
I've also witnessed a scenario where simply after multiple rounds in UG medical college admissions the ST seats weren't getting filled bcoz the ST students weren't either scoring the cutoff/were inelligible bcoz they had less than 40% in boards.
He keeps saying there is backlog, because lets say for any govt job exams even when their seats are reserved, there simply are not enough sc/st students clearing that cutoff and then some commission tells they can't go below certain score, and hence they are vacant
Very unfortunate and painful.
Dalits+OBCs+EcoWeaks be given completely free educations, transportation, houses, medical, 5kg per month per person upto a max 4nos per family each of pulses, wheat, veg oil+spices+salt, rice equivalent of Money in account, interest free loan of up to 20times of per capita income repayable over 15years for setting up businesses or perusing higher studies, 100% of airfare for study abroad (once in three years), 20times of interest free debt for industrial R&D, 2times per capita income to support studies so far the student scores >70% marks in the exam/s; This all student/ studies support until the age of 30years. In addition, State & Govt must open at least 15% of all categories of educational institutions ( nursery thru postgrad) with all faculties that only employ and educate such uniquely positioned
.01% भी IAS IPS IRS IFS नही हम महादलित यहाँ तक कि ऑफिसर भी नही,, 70 साल से शोषित हो रहे है हम,,
गाँव के दूरस्थ छोर पर हमारी कच्ची बस्तियाँ, जहाँ कोई दलित नही आता,,
झाड़ू 70 साल से थी आज भी हम वाल्मीकियो के पेट भरने के काम आ रही
टॉयलेट, सेप्टिक टैंक हमारे कार्य स्थल है,, किस्मत अच्छी हो तो सरकारी सफाई कर्ता की नौकरी मिल जाती है
SC के आरक्षण के असली हकदार हम है,, पर आरक्षण हमें छु कर भी नही गया
50% SC VARG मे से शुद्ध आरक्षण दो, बैक लोग के साथ,, अन्यथा हमें मजबूरन आंदोलन पर उतरना होगा, अब मलाई नही चाटने दी जाएगी,, महादलित की स्थिति एक महादलित ही समझ सकता है
जय महादलित आरक्षण संघ शक्ति,, जय वाल्मीकि
Data says this. Which Data is that. Let me give you that fool.
NEET cut off for my state.
610 for Gen
580 for OBC
480 for SC
400 ST
It takes 3000 yes just that much money to study from PW coaching and score better.
Who would become a good doctor?? Any Guesses??
EWS bhul kyun Gaya. Wo bhi mention kar
@@democracy123 bro CDP, EWS,PwD,Girl Child, PSP,RBA.....hmre yaha bohot hai....sare mention krta toh 100 aur gali padti
Entry mark does not indicate anyones capacity.Anyone can become a good doctor by scoring 100/720. Because there are 55 percent private mbbs seats in India and so many good doctors comes from private medical colleges.
Or reservation ka baat to chhor hi do vai,India te ST se zyada General walo ko reservation milta hai, 10 percent EWS reservation.
This guy is totally toxic and caste obsessed. Sorry, 13mins were torture, can’t watch the remaining 130mins. Big thumbs down to this podcast Smita, I watch all your podcasts, even with Owaisi wasn’t this regressive.
JNU me padh leta to kaam aajata bas politics me lagey rahe chacha 😂😂
So many manuvaadi comments in comment section are about RESERVATION. No one comment about CASTE DISCRIMINATION in india.
Ye working class= lower class ki bakwaas mat karo. Pahale ja k data check karo.
Education free lo, kya desh lena chahte ho. Har jagah reservation dene par society me problem hui h uska bhi socho. Kaam karte nahi, kota pura chahiye. Ye soch ko bhi badalo.
जमीनों का समान वितरण pr chup kyu jo jate ho?
Free education to tumlog bhi le rhe ho
और तो और भीख माँगने का nya tarika paida kiye ho n dharm और palhand ke nam pr 😂.
Tum ko reservation se dikkat hai to 10% chhod kyu nhi dete ho?
@@Vikashkumarwithstudents Wahi toh....you don't want to end reservation at all. Reservation was introduced to provide equity to those who are at odds with right to opportunity, caste basis. You'll be behind reservation your whole life?? Isnt education enough for you? Why don't you compete with others by applying for General category? Let's make it fair, if you want fair
@@gopald9962 This is bullshit the fair competition is bullshit the fair competition means when oll community in the past have same education but in this country the upper cast are ruler class and other not not so their is no way fair competition the fair competition means in which everybody is equal both in past and present times what nonsense one community are educated in the olden times do you think who are know getting some educational give them fair competition this is bullshit
@@Patr600 so you're saying you can't rely on yourself to make the decisions that change your life for your good. Thanks for letting me know you can't do anything on your own. You need handovers. And some more help.
Mhnt khud s hoti ni jnm jaat Bhikari Kom
Sirr mndir s ghr chlta h
Excellent interview . The first time interviewer is supportive in finding a solution to the caste menace. The interviewee is a highly informed and very knowledgeable person. Excellent.
EWS... is Anti Constitutional...8 Lakh Is Income Criteria ...
66700/ Month is Poor...
Economical Weeker...?
Waah Modiji Waha....?
Reservation percentage: SC -15%, ST -7.5, other BC -27% and poor FC’s whose income is less than 8 lakhs get 10%. Why these caste and religious extremists talking like only SC/ST’s get reservation and enjoying the opportunities?😅After reading the comments I am realizing the hate for Dalits is so extreme even in this contemporary society. jai hind😅
Reservations will be dangerous without merits. It will drown Indian once again, rather government launch skills programs and give jobs to any skilled workers
oh you mean just like we have all the doctors from capitation fee colleges where exorbitant fees is the main criteria for admission rather than merit, now who are become criminals charging exorbitant hospital fees and killing patients. Is this dangerous or not
People love their caste identity irrespective of what they have to deal with because of that. No caste, lower or upper wants to do intercaste marriage and casteism won't be an issue if majority stops benefiting using their caste identity.
Comment section testifies the current condition of Dalits and the mindset of so called upper castes! Finally somebody called a dalit person to talk abt caste system , and their issues, ni toh its all savarns only talking abt reservation and how caste system is no longer existent which is nthing bt bullshit. Its now not that overt bt covert. And people talking how reservation should be removed ...never utter a line on how caste based discrimination shud be removed. Never! They want reparation and apology from the britishers, but apne girebahn me kon jhakta hai. They still practice caste biasness, bt have the audacity to claim their is no discrimination..just dalits were lame ! The oppression that they did for thousands of years was worse than any invader or oppressor. But the fact is they are proud of their actions ..and still proud. This is the core issue ..towards this they will happily close their eyes .
We complain hw brtishers are not taught theri own colonial history of wt they did around the world, in our nation , the savarns have no idea what they take pride in , has a history one shud be ashamed of. Instead only dalits are shamed( not even obcs bagging highest pcrntge of reservation)
It's 2024 ... There are strict laws for discrimination... No one do anything on Basis of caste everyone is free do to anything ..
@@तुषारप्रकाशमिश्रा looks like you dont follow newspapers..and authentic media streams ...you seem to be following the mainstream media owned and run by savarns with an agenda.
Try to know abt the real life experiences from the perspective of dalit media too!
You cannot be the spokesperson of the harassed and just deny things that are blatant. Educate urself first. Get a 360 degree view.
And its from my own experience... Caste discrimination happens in multinational companies as well , so its not a remote village thing..and you cannot speak on my behalf , Its my experience! its full fledged everywhere despite the laws...as most of the enforcers themselves are casteists! And reservation is abt representation. And distribution of power..not financial status.
@@kaverikumari9332
Representation??
Then please give up your Reservation and let the poor Sanitation Worker's son get that Reservation for the REPRESENTATION
@@docno1117 ah well, then why are you cribbing so much abt reservation... Now you guys are acting like its somewhat better off people ( only Scs) are doing injustice to the others...are u kidding me...some of them ve just gained financial stability( decent posts) probably from this generation. Still the reserved posts go unfilled or converted to unreserved slyly( discrimination exists still every where as in ur mind too) . The climb is steep so its gonna take time... The generational abuse of thousands of yrs..and reservation for only ehat 70 yrs. And you are right ....as per requirement..the reservations should increase for the sanitation workers and other scheduled castes also ...tht you wont even have any idea( thnx to ur privileges) . But then , you should also stop denigrating them as untouchables..( dint your ancestors start and practice this religiously! And you're still. Try marrying an educated , well off person fron the very sanitation workers caste, before u preach)
Lets have more reservations for people ..cz the savarns did really do a good job in exploting 80prcnt of the population! And by the way..fyi...OBCs (non creamy layer) still more affluentand land holders than than Affluent Scs /sts....! Do some proper research..and know the difference between sacrifice and reparation ! For the savarns...its not sacrifice...but its reparation for their own dark abominable deeds!
if after reservation has not worked and this guy is still crying. so rrservation is not fruitful. remove reservstion.
backlog is because they cant scire good marks, dont have skills. with this logic. 45% will become doctor, B.E and then ppl will be treated wrongly, brudges will collapse.
Remove EWS. Full support
There's a reservation for sc st OBC to get admission in medical College ok but to clear mbbs or any examination there's no any reservation pls join any library read some books
Actually people like him wants to keep caste topics alive, so that he can thrive on it
Dalito me bhi wo jatiya dal di hi jinpar discrimination nahi hota jese up me dhobi pasi gadariya, madhya pradesh me dhobi , maharashtra me chambhar, haryana me dhanuk ,vese bahut sari caste he jo OBC me honi chahiye thi par inko SC me dala he pahle inko nikalo SC se bahar 💙🔥💪
beef is cheaper than daal? what is he high on?
High on reservation
Thats true and thats why the converted Christians eat beef cause all of them were poor and they converted religion for basic necessities like food and the consistent discrimination and atrocities.
Reservations should be upto certain extent, like in medical, it should be only till mbbs and not in MD level, after mbbs, you are capable enough to fund your tution fees, also what i noticed in my government college during Md, max people who took sc/st seats, were more wealthy than general seat people, i am not against reservations but it should be limited to certain level
People like him who invokes & propaganda, hatred, enimity, violence in name of fighting rights for sc/st/dalits. They themsleves leaves good capitalistic luxury lifestyle and wants other to follow socilistic life. They have zero contribution towards field of commerce and science. @ANI News shld avlid to advocate and invite such people.
He's from jnu what else u expect
Excellent dialogue with Dr Sonpimple. Thanks Madam Smita Prakasji for a thought-provoking interview
Reservation in Private sector......seriously....wake up kid!!!
We should have reservation in newspapers and news channels. There is hardly any representation of Dalits in National press.
@@AjitJoshi686why? Why should they be represented?
@@manansharma9872 The Dalits don’t have voice on news channels. So they cannot set narrative in the country.
@@manansharma9872Representation matters for the overall betterment of society
@@suyogshishupal30 How? Can you elaborate?
this guy is lying on face.
isko dalit reservation bhi chaheyaur buddhist bhi ban na hai
ईन जैसे लोगों को भागवान भी खुश नहीं कर सकता।
Throughout this guy only speaks about getting everything free. Why not Dalit who became prosperous open free schools, tuitions for other Dalit ? Why not Dalit build temple, society for themselves and then if they want they can stop other upper caste from entering there. I am not an upper caste but I have not seen lower caste supporting their own community , working hard etc. all they want without working hard. My grandparents came from dirt poor background, they taught their kids and in turn my parents taught us. We have reached to a level through shear hard work not by protesting, blaming upper caste, playing victim card.
I fully support removal of EWS reservation.
While left liberals ignore scholars from subaltern backgrounds atleast the mainstream channels.
Kudos to ANI for atleast considering different persepectives despite the difference in opinion. :)
Brings tears to my eyes...education and eliminating poverty is just a drop in the ocean...social reform within Islam..at least in India is a must...and the change must come from within
What nonsense. Students study in same school. During boards general students score more than Dalits. And im boards name of the students everything is kept hidden. Them who is stopping who??
Learn about cultural capital of Pierre burdiou
"Everything Looks Yellow To The Jaundiced Eye".
Bkl 76 years reservation k baad v rr band nehi hua......
Ye pagal he dimagi bimar he ye
1000 saal ka castism ka reservation bhi mila woh bhi dekh
@@anishchoudhury4973 Brahmin 20/- dan lala vik samj ka 🖕 Tara pora khandan to gribo ko loot ka bana hai andhvishwas ke naam pe , ab Tara superiority nahi chala ga
Cut offs of reservation category are way way below that of general category.
You ask a fair opinion from ST of any jharkhand, Chhattisgarh then you will realise the effect of reservation. Clerks can't take the print out in front and back mode, required educated person to assist him for filling a simple form. Even a honest ST will criticize the reservation..😢😢
India need reservation . Reservation is totally justified.