Amber Heard psychologist admits Johnny Depp suffered severe injuries | LiveNOW from FOX

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 тра 2022
  • Johnny Depp's defamation trial against his ex-wife Amber Heard is now in its fourth week, with Heard's lawyers now presenting evidence in the case. Dawn Hughes, a clinical psychologist hired by Heard's team, testified about alleged abuse Heard suffered at the hands of Depp. On cross-examination, Hughes was shown photos of injuries Depp suffered in an incident in Australia and the witness admitted the injuries were "severe."
    Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! ua-cam.com/users/livenowfox?su...
    Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
    Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
    Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @Xavierpng
    @Xavierpng 2 роки тому +2245

    She hits him and tells him to stop complaining, and then calls him a baby! After that she accuses him of violence. What a disgusting woman AH is!

    • @LuisSierra42
      @LuisSierra42 2 роки тому

      Hello there

    • @DarkAestheticCosplay
      @DarkAestheticCosplay 2 роки тому

      @[SCLA]MRBIG 323 oh shut up

    • @allyboo7771
      @allyboo7771 2 роки тому +5

      How many names do you have?

    • @nyeemahjones1142
      @nyeemahjones1142 2 роки тому +2

      Very disgusting.

    • @bereal6590
      @bereal6590 2 роки тому +1

      Did you not listen to audio of him saying he headbutted her or than in therapy together his aggression was also brought up and he didn't deny it

  • @BobbyMarley718
    @BobbyMarley718 2 роки тому +1840

    This is ridiculous, this audio alone should have her thrown in jail. This country is ridiculous.

    • @sampyro765
      @sampyro765 2 роки тому +19

      Trust me you should visit belgium and throw a candy bar on the Street With the cops around and taking a leak at the same time in public
      250€ fee. Xp

    • @dandx67895
      @dandx67895 2 роки тому +67

      Amber on tape alone has admitted to hitting Johnny not on defense but she initiated it, pooping on the bed for a joke, while insulting and gaslighting him. If a man does it that’s enough to put him in jail

    • @sayno2lolzisback
      @sayno2lolzisback 2 роки тому +37

      The whole world has gone mad although yes, the USA has always been the ahead of the curve 🤣

    • @tonirvd3650
      @tonirvd3650 2 роки тому

      @@sayno2lolzisback yes, the leader of free world. what's worse is that people in other countries import these twisted values to their countries, and they ruin their countries also

    • @Manar12343
      @Manar12343 2 роки тому +3

      Period

  • @mfxo7755
    @mfxo7755 2 роки тому +2373

    There’s no way an educated psychologist would ever agree that “Slapping & throwing red bull cans and mineral spirits and taking off your husbands finger tip” when she’s angry is not considered “Reactive violence” or classified as “low level violence”. She should have her license pulled for lying under oath for a check. If she’s a “Psychologist” I’m the president. 😭 So distasteful & unprofessional that she’s using her platform to discredit a victim yet advocating for an abuser.

    • @cheahujin1947
      @cheahujin1947 2 роки тому +107

      Heck maybe she’s an abuser herself

    • @jennymachin5532
      @jennymachin5532 2 роки тому +36

      Are your psychologists regulated by a licensed board we should inundate them with emails how has this woman got a licence

    • @theresateegarden9147
      @theresateegarden9147 2 роки тому +57

      She's being paid $500.00 an hour for her exams of AH and her testimony She's going to say what ever AH's attorneys want her to say. I know it's ridiculous but it's what some attorneys do! Wonder what AH is paying her attorneys. She should have to pay Johnny's attorneys also.

    • @mfxo7755
      @mfxo7755 2 роки тому +32

      @@jennymachin5532 Considering she’s being sued for 50M she probably got the cheapest low rated psychologist she could find & this was the result 😭

    • @FalcoBikes
      @FalcoBikes 2 роки тому

      @@theresateegarden9147 Trust me, a LOT of people will be willing to lie for $500/hr... not to mention many would lie for free.

  • @Summer09824
    @Summer09824 2 роки тому +171

    She admitted multiple times that she started the physical fight & admitted to hitting him. What more do we need honestly. This psychologist is so blatantly biased.

    • @bowtoyoursensei554
      @bowtoyoursensei554 2 роки тому

      She's supposed to be. She's a PAID witness for the defense. Just as the other psychologist was a paid witness for the prosecution.

    • @harrymillar4193
      @harrymillar4193 2 роки тому

      @@bowtoyoursensei554 Yes, but Depp’s psychologist had interviews with Amber AND Johnny to determine Amber’s condition and hear both sides of the story. Heard’s psychologist has been shown to cherry-pick information, completely disregard evidence, and it has been suggested that she hates men, and will do anything to secure a legal victory. She is trying to be a lawyer, probably because she hates that one of Heard’s lawyer is male XD

    • @Summer09824
      @Summer09824 2 роки тому +2

      @@bowtoyoursensei554 regardless of who hired them they have a duty to the jury & the court to not be biased & report their findings based on the facts

    • @heartofhearing2413
      @heartofhearing2413 2 роки тому +1

      @@bowtoyoursensei554 she's supposed to be a paid witness of facts. She has ignored any facts that negate her conclusions. She minimized AH abuse as minor violence while calling JD an abuser. She called AH allegations evidence while ignoring actual tapes and other Physical evidence of AH abusing JD. She couldn't name a case where she represented a male in a male female abuse case. She claimed that she testified to facts not on behalf of people then shortly after spoke of testifying on behalf of people. She's bought and paid for.

  • @aniruudhh
    @aniruudhh 2 роки тому +1492

    ”i was not punching you, i was *hitting* you.”
    -Amber heard, apparently a “victim of abuse”

    • @corinnetodd4807
      @corinnetodd4807 2 роки тому +33

      But if the Johnny did that to her,every one would be up in arms

    • @captain007x
      @captain007x 2 роки тому +33

      Imagine if a man said that?

    • @luisitoputirecors1499
      @luisitoputirecors1499 2 роки тому +4

      She specified the way he attached ..him..lol

    • @kygal
      @kygal 2 роки тому +30

      @@captain007x if a man had said that on recording he'd already be in jail and probably paying restitution.

    • @Theyellowpowerpuff
      @Theyellowpowerpuff 2 роки тому +9

      Gaslighting at it's finest, AH's court videos make her look like a cartoon character trying to act sad, this should be over already 🤐 her entire team, even the witnesses seem exactly like her...

  • @50k_Challenge_with_0video
    @50k_Challenge_with_0video 2 роки тому +2090

    She's literally on tape admitting she assaulted him. How is she not under criminal investigation?

    • @normette
      @normette 2 роки тому +96

      Because he didn’t press charges

    • @asiajake
      @asiajake 2 роки тому +160

      He never pressed charges....men rarely report abuse an unfortunately they get the short end of the stick.

    • @wolfxp
      @wolfxp 2 роки тому +31

      The above replies are correct, the reason though is that you can't use evidence from one trial in another to create a complaint.

    • @dragonlady3278
      @dragonlady3278 2 роки тому +12

      And the statute of limitations is up so he can’t now

    • @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736
      @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736 2 роки тому +12

      I wish he would’ve pressed charges

  • @mahamotiv8100
    @mahamotiv8100 2 роки тому +494

    It is unacceptably unprofessional to decide a someone is a victim of DV based on their gender and based on a one sided story. It does not matter how many hours, days or years she has spent listening to one side of the story, it is one sided. She will never understand how unprofessional her statement was until it happens to her one day. I would never trust to recommend anyone who would need mental help to her.

    • @troki8605
      @troki8605 2 роки тому +14

      On the other hand people who are willing to falsely accuse someone might go to her. I mean she will get clients/abusers 😬

    • @Anisky123
      @Anisky123 2 роки тому +4

      T Bingo.

    • @Aquanios08
      @Aquanios08 2 роки тому +1

      “Until it happens to her”
      You’re being generous. Even then, I doubt it’d get through to her with how dense she is.

  • @nyeemahjones1142
    @nyeemahjones1142 2 роки тому +405

    I dated a man who has a history of violence against women. We were together for a few years before he finally physically assaulted me. The verbal abuse was already there and started early on in the relationship. Because, I am one that stands up for myself, I believe the physical violence started much later and I left him because of it. I say that to say this, if Johnny Depp truly abused her, there would certainly be other women coming forward.

    • @dimensia6942
      @dimensia6942 2 роки тому +82

      His past girlfriend’s have all stated that he was never the violent one. They even came to defend him. It speaks volumes

    • @luisitoputirecors1499
      @luisitoputirecors1499 2 роки тому +6

      Thank u

    • @a.b.1246
      @a.b.1246 2 роки тому

      This case is a lose lose for both of them. Even if he didnt assault her physically I doubt reading text messages in court saying he wants to f her dead corpse is helping his career.

    • @ThisIsWizardsHandle
      @ThisIsWizardsHandle 2 роки тому +3

      @Creative Innovative ikr 😅

    • @eveningstar6700
      @eveningstar6700 2 роки тому +1

      Great point!!!

  • @brooke3140
    @brooke3140 2 роки тому +175

    Imagine if a woman was abused and told it was "low level violence". Wtf

    • @everforward8651
      @everforward8651 2 роки тому +14

      I thought the same thing.

    • @spiritpearls2091
      @spiritpearls2091 2 роки тому

      Yep! New terminology made up by these new styled psychologists who can get their certificates without proper education, experience, strict evaluation and oversight by actual doctors and seasoned mental health and abuse experts. Pathetic

    • @pickitup7008
      @pickitup7008 2 роки тому

      This comment is the reason why women are afraid to tell their stories. You should be ashamed

    • @brooke3140
      @brooke3140 2 роки тому +7

      @@pickitup7008 Sit down. This is why MEN are afraid to tell theirs. As Amber says “Tell the world, Johnny, tell them ‘I, Johnny Depp, a man, I’m a victim, too, of domestic violence… and it’s a fair fight.’

    • @pickitup7008
      @pickitup7008 2 роки тому

      @@brooke3140 you are just a racist

  • @mayella376
    @mayella376 2 роки тому +31

    So there's evidence that she hit him, but no evidence of him hitting her and she's still playing the victim. She disgusts me. Amber is officially the lowest form of life

  • @notanothernerdypodcast
    @notanothernerdypodcast 2 роки тому +120

    She’s not a doctor?! How can she decide something is a severe injury or actually occurred when she wasn’t there? Where are these medical documents? She’s a 1 star psychologist whose primary “experience” is being a tv psychologist

    • @claudiaestela3135
      @claudiaestela3135 2 роки тому +8

      She’s trying so hard to defend AH… whenever they bring up situations of her being reactive. And she keeps saying “well if your running away from your spouse…blah blah blah”

    • @Sunshine-is_here_to_stay
      @Sunshine-is_here_to_stay 2 роки тому +1

      You're exactly right. A psychologist would be consistent with every answer. She should have her license revoked for being so biased & even flat out lying. 🤥

  • @alexandradane3672
    @alexandradane3672 2 роки тому +1268

    This “therapist “ is a perfect example of unqualified “kitchen table “ physcology which explains why so many people in the US , in “ therapy “ are so misguided and positively unhinged?

    • @GuysIFinally
      @GuysIFinally 2 роки тому +49

      I’m in school to become a psychologist, and there’s a wide discrepancy between the lowly therapists and the high class psychologists like Depp’s psychologist

    • @farrelnadi9799
      @farrelnadi9799 2 роки тому

      I hope this woman can a sleep at night for her one sided testimony..

    • @seekthtruth
      @seekthtruth 2 роки тому +3

      Well said

    • @seanthiar
      @seanthiar 2 роки тому +41

      @@GuysIFinally And remember Dr. Curry is not board certified, but Ambers is - Shows how much worth has a board certification that is so important for AH lawyers. There is enough critique that board certified is no longer a sign of quality of a specialist.

    • @chanbella6941
      @chanbella6941 2 роки тому

      I can’t imagine how she can practice so many years

  • @bpxl53yewz29
    @bpxl53yewz29 2 роки тому +2784

    This so-called psychologist is ridiculous. Interesting she keeps defending AH when there’s a lot ot evidence that Johnny was the one who was abused. I hope she realizes that her license and credibility is on the line.

    • @andremartins5453
      @andremartins5453 2 роки тому +24

      I would like to know if you are a specialized professional to say that?

    • @OlgaSmirnova1
      @OlgaSmirnova1 2 роки тому +20

      She is the defense witness that what she is paid for

    • @ricksterdrummer2170
      @ricksterdrummer2170 2 роки тому +139

      @@andremartins5453 Why would he need to be? It’s stating the obvious, hunny…

    • @HK-gm8pe
      @HK-gm8pe 2 роки тому +26

      most she says is just hearsay

    • @lawncuttingplusdelta
      @lawncuttingplusdelta 2 роки тому +76

      Defense witness is practically lying and conjuring up that anything amber did was in reaction to “ violence” on johnnys part ….. he always wants to leave , why wouldn’t she be the one running if she is scared 😱!!!it’s pathetic

  • @JimboBillyBob
    @JimboBillyBob 2 роки тому +38

    She said “in this instance if true” yet she has been making statements where she has assumed every single thing Amber has said has been fact. So why wouldn’t she take this as fact?

  • @nashily
    @nashily 2 роки тому +33

    She's, clearly, a MAN-HATER. I mean, look at the way she presents the information, all women are saints, all men are abusers. If a woman hurts a man, it's because of self-defense. She never once questions whether she was been manipulated by a woman, just assumes whatever the woman is saying is the absolute facts and then starts to find data, which will support it and disregard everything that contradicts that.
    The only vibe I get from her is, that she's a man-hater.

    • @teri-lynnbushbaum587
      @teri-lynnbushbaum587 2 роки тому +1

      I’m sure her practice has done well under the “metoo movement” but I wonder how it’s going to do going forward after this?

  • @johndilig6719
    @johndilig6719 2 роки тому +350

    "low level violence." now, we're nitpicking abuse based on how much damage it does...

  • @Janeeedoe62849
    @Janeeedoe62849 2 роки тому +272

    So she read some notes, ignored the parts she didn't like , talked to AH for 29 hours and concluded that AH is the victim. Tell me again how did she get her license and board certification???

    • @OmegaGirl3
      @OmegaGirl3 2 роки тому +10

      She should lose her license

    • @xivix6710
      @xivix6710 2 роки тому +13

      Probably many psychologists refused the offer. Only the greedy or the disparate will do this job for the money regardless of the effects the testimony would bring in the future.

    • @lufciferslilith9858
      @lufciferslilith9858 2 роки тому +3

      This her testimony is absolutely absurd

    • @Janeeedoe62849
      @Janeeedoe62849 2 роки тому

      @@lufciferslilith9858 still better than ambers

  • @Khali2K
    @Khali2K 2 роки тому +22

    Throughout the entire replay of the recording, Amber is LITERALLY smirking and trying to hold it back. Even when they show Johnny's severed finger she's smiling! She is sooo full of herself. I guarantee you if it was me, being abused and heard these recordings, I'd react traumatized when reliving this "memory". There's no way she's innocent about her abuse. She is sooo content about her arguments and the severed finger, she is definitely an abuser

  • @knoxschyuler5716
    @knoxschyuler5716 2 роки тому +29

    I love how she outright said there was medical records of Amber getting hurt, yet it was just notes and claims FROM AMBER, yet insisted it was fact. Same thing with the bottles. She said it depends on the context, then immediately says throwing bottles in any context is unacceptable. She stretches the truth so damn much I’m surprised the lawyers aren’t pushing for things like this. Especially for not actually answering questions and just talking for a while.

    • @Kratos263
      @Kratos263 2 роки тому

      Could be a strategy. If you don't press her every time she digs herself a hole she'll think she's doing a good job and keep doing it

  • @preciousgemstylez1768
    @preciousgemstylez1768 2 роки тому +406

    She punches him, then tells him to stop whining, o boy, had he hit her and said stop whining, he'd be in jail. She's horrible.

    • @fe723
      @fe723 2 роки тому +9

      Gender Equality should be a thing when it comes to this cases.

    • @kalls2k907
      @kalls2k907 2 роки тому +3

      How far have we fallen.... What kind of a World do we live in 😔

    • @christophluger793
      @christophluger793 2 роки тому +5

      Same for custody cases. The man has to bring so much proof and probably still loses even when the mother abuses the kids. That's shameful.

    • @scottcheg9
      @scottcheg9 2 роки тому

      @@fe723 there hasn’t been gender equality for years because women have more rights than men and the court system favours women.

    • @tessa7413
      @tessa7413 2 роки тому +1

      Right, and if he actually was abusive, she’d never have the confidence to do that. If you hit a violent person, or belittle them, then you’d better expect to them to react violently. She had absolutely no fear of him whatsoever.

  • @meredith0427
    @meredith0427 2 роки тому +849

    “I’m sorry that I didn’t hit you across the face in a proper slap. I was hitting you I did not punch you.” Wonder how she keeps a straight face through the whole recording when she just lied about everything before.

    • @holzgrevenick
      @holzgrevenick 2 роки тому +7

      Hope her new man, Knows how to fight back. Hope next Time she is the crying Baby.

    • @bigpete4227
      @bigpete4227 2 роки тому +2

      She’s an actress.

    • @johannarollery9694
      @johannarollery9694 2 роки тому +20

      She didn’t, she broke character and you can see her half smirk when she calls him a baby the first time and when she said I did start the fight you see her start to smirk and then catch herself

    • @bibibabibu1
      @bibibabibu1 2 роки тому

      @Don't click profile photo k but I'll report your account for spam

    • @TheFartofGod
      @TheFartofGod 2 роки тому +3

      It almost looked like she was trying to hide a smile

  • @cedricrickdelsol9767
    @cedricrickdelsol9767 2 роки тому +12

    Everyone is talking about the difference between punching and hitting, yet nobody's talking about the emotional aspects behind it. Being hit by the person you swore to love, does more than just physical damage. The message it conveys is far worse than the actual impact.
    My SO slapped me once (not a punch, not a hit, but "just" a slap) and I bursted into tears. It didn't even leave a mark on my cheek, but her being able to do that, kinda broke me.

  • @marcust123
    @marcust123 2 роки тому +14

    Shocking how she can be called a professional wow imagine people paying this narcissistic for therapy crazy!

  • @Techno_VFX
    @Techno_VFX 2 роки тому +273

    “I didn’t punch you, I was just hitting you”
    - famous last words

    • @henrikr7445
      @henrikr7445 2 роки тому +2

      Amber “Wiseau” Heard: “I did not hit him I did naaaat”

    • @gameone7717
      @gameone7717 2 роки тому

      Poor johnny 😐

    • @PringleandCheese
      @PringleandCheese 2 роки тому

      Someone please explain how hitting is better than punching because Turd seems to suggest something like that

  • @mashiela7189
    @mashiela7189 2 роки тому +566

    This witness is so judgemental, also so full of herself like AH's attorneys...so rude

    • @captain007x
      @captain007x 2 роки тому +4

      She is employed and paid by AH defence team.

  • @Rizwaan122
    @Rizwaan122 2 роки тому +16

    "I was hitting you"
    "I started physical fights"
    Regardless of the fact this is a defamation case and not an abuse one, how has this case lasted beyond 5 mins?

  • @heartsmyfaceforever8140
    @heartsmyfaceforever8140 2 роки тому +1

    Low level violence? Assault is assault.

  • @tcmomcoffey4028
    @tcmomcoffey4028 2 роки тому +701

    AS A VICTIM OF ABUSE SHE'S NOT ABUSED SHE IS NOT SCARED SHE'S TRYING TO PROVOKE A FIGHT ETC ALSO MANY OTHER PPL I KNOW MEN N WOMEN VICTIMS OF ABUSE ALL AGREE THE BEHAVIOR LIKE RECORDING N THEN PROVOKING SOMEONE IF U ARE A VICTIM U WILL NOT WANT TO HAVE ANY ADDED FIGHTS ETC EVEN AT HIS MAD POINTS HE SLAMMED HIS OWN CABINETS

    • @fayescammell8712
      @fayescammell8712 2 роки тому +16

      Too true, are there any abused women out there who fought back and ‘only hit’ their abuser ?

    • @Theredstar2478
      @Theredstar2478 2 роки тому

      @@k666ti because women fear for their life if they fight back, they could be killed

    • @dimitrachatzim
      @dimitrachatzim 2 роки тому

      You speak on behalf of other victims and know their stories???? BS

    • @eveningstar6700
      @eveningstar6700 2 роки тому +1

      well is she scared but not in a way we naturally think. She's scared of being a loser and having nothing and no one. shes scared to be anything other than bad

    • @eveningstar6700
      @eveningstar6700 2 роки тому

      @@dimitrachatzim
      Dont get sh*t twisted here.
      We all amber is the abuser and a liar and thats the point.

  • @myrapatterson2869
    @myrapatterson2869 2 роки тому +553

    Being a victim myself, does any one notices if Depp hit her why hasn't anyone else come out? If someone hits you in a relationship they will hit others. There is no report of any abuse from his ex wife or ex girlfriends.

    • @TheMoistGrapefruit
      @TheMoistGrapefruit 2 роки тому +79

      That and she’s supposed been filming everything and absolutely nothing so far indicates he hit her, if they had any evidence he hit her it’d have been presented already and she would have won the trial.

    • @lissabrutus4652
      @lissabrutus4652 2 роки тому +43

      @@TheMoistGrapefruit right she has evidence of everything but the actual abuse

    • @spencerrizkallah7171
      @spencerrizkallah7171 2 роки тому +64

      As far as I could find, his ex's (even one who he cheated on) have been very clear that he has problems with substances but has never even thought about trying to harm any of them

    • @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736
      @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736 2 роки тому +51

      From my experience, people don’t TYPICALLY become violent out of nowhere, especially in their 40s or 50s. Once an abuser always an abuser

    • @princezzpuffypants6287
      @princezzpuffypants6287 2 роки тому

      But Heard has a history of beating her girlfriends....

  • @jibijay
    @jibijay 2 роки тому +30

    This is not how I would ever imagine someone talking to someone they have been abused by. The arrogance, fearlessness and cocky attitude. If JD had hit her anytime before this recording it would have been brought up by her in this exact moment 100%. Something along the lines of "Now you know how it feels" in response to JD being upset at being hit.

    • @N..P..
      @N..P.. 2 роки тому +2

      When dealing with abuse victims that are female, you virtually never see or hear them be this belligerent towards their "abuser", even when they know they're safe, much less alone with them.

  • @anonymouscontent940
    @anonymouscontent940 2 роки тому +18

    It's been said, "If you want to know why the person is the way that person is, then you should ask yourself what the person experienced in childhood." His best friend said that he was never violent even when he was at school. And when I hear all the witnesses and other acquaintances of Johnny Depp saying that he was never violent towards anyone, I believe with all my heart that he never even considered hurting AH. What he had experienced in his childhood, he would never want others to have to go through what he went through.
    As far as I could find, his ex's (even one who he cheated on) have been very clear that he has problems with substances but has never even thought about trying to harm any of them.

  • @Kelly-nt2rq
    @Kelly-nt2rq 2 роки тому +384

    Johnny's psychologist was SO much more well spoken, and more intelligent than this lady. I love that HER witnesses make HER look worse

    • @dragonlady3278
      @dragonlady3278 2 роки тому +21

      I’ve missed who this lady is but I read she was AH’s treating shrink.. there’s the difference. Curry was an expert witness who was only there to testify the facts she found to the court.. regardless of who it favored. This chick is just talking about her time treating Turd

    • @chrismulkey7341
      @chrismulkey7341 2 роки тому +4

      ​@@dragonlady3278 Previous video, while she says she is not an expert witness, she even did a speech about being an expert witness.
      Also, she isn't AH's shrink, she is specifically brought on for cases like these. They talk about AH's therapist in other videos.

    • @lauragourley6902
      @lauragourley6902 2 роки тому +4

      @kelly sanders that's because anyone that has a brain can see she's a compulsive liar and wouldn't take the risk of coming to her defense

    • @mako3197
      @mako3197 2 роки тому +15

      the thing is Dr Shannon Curry is a FORENSIC psychologist, who ultimately has a duty to the trier of fact. She was retained for the purposes of the trial. As she explained, a CLINICAL therapist should not testify due to a conflict of interest - it is impossible for them not to have an obvious bias and an obligation/instinct to protect their client. I'd wager Dr Curry's testimony has more weight due to these circumstances. Edit: at this point I'm not sure if this psychologist has been treating Amber long term or was hired for the purposes of evaluation for trial but again her position should mean a less compelling testimony, regardless of board certification.

    • @Jiron127
      @Jiron127 2 роки тому +2

      That's the difference between an A student in Johnny's psyche and Heard's C level psyche

  • @susanharris1694
    @susanharris1694 2 роки тому +942

    Ambers psychologist is a horrible witness and a liar, IMO… she seems to be unwittingly helping JD! 😂

    • @paulauspitz1905
      @paulauspitz1905 2 роки тому +2

      So your on Amber the sociopaths side!!

    • @Rebecca236
      @Rebecca236 2 роки тому +6

      @@paulauspitz1905 There seems to be a lot of them.

    • @lorrainecreighton5690
      @lorrainecreighton5690 2 роки тому +4

      Dr KAREN Hughes they've got you

    • @bridgettschreuder5708
      @bridgettschreuder5708 2 роки тому

      🙏

    • @andreakatz6109
      @andreakatz6109 2 роки тому +1

      Yeah I had this Psychologist, poor Amber, she can't catch a break. JD is horrible and an abuser who plays victim.

  • @janetuss6496
    @janetuss6496 2 роки тому +32

    it cannot be low level violence and then severe injuries at the same time, who ordered Dr. Curry from walmart and got this abomination. It's telling how everyone associated with Amber is just as horrible and unlikeable as her. Note how nice Johnny's lawyers are, letting them speak and finish their damn sentences at least. If it was Amber's lawyers, they would be cutting them off every 2 seconds, hitting them with a "just give me a yes or no", and bullying/degrading them.
    edit: I was being nice with the walmart, I really wanted to say second-hand flea market, or Facebook Marketplace on sale.

  • @sabzteenwitchhufflepuff719
    @sabzteenwitchhufflepuff719 2 роки тому +2

    IF HE HAD SAID THAT TO HER, HE'D BE IN JAIL LONG AGO! 😤

  • @Firellius
    @Firellius 2 роки тому +546

    "You agree with ms. Heard that it is admirable to run from a fight?"
    "Is it admirable?"
    Maybe I'm misinterpreting something here, but for a second there, it felt like she was legitimately going to contest the idea that de-escalating a violent situation is the right thing to do.

    • @m18m40
      @m18m40 2 роки тому +28

      Bra she was getting ready 🤣🤣🤣🤣✊🏾

    • @LuisSierra42
      @LuisSierra42 2 роки тому +17

      She will just do what she was paid to do

    • @barbados7550
      @barbados7550 2 роки тому +13

      That's exactly what she was doing. if a lot of us sees it the Jury sees it too. theyre burying their own grave

    • @kalls2k907
      @kalls2k907 2 роки тому +11

      She brain farted for a second then realised she's on court XD

    • @ElizRued
      @ElizRued 2 роки тому +11

      She seems as manipulating like her client

  • @Leche_Flan
    @Leche_Flan 2 роки тому +295

    Guys I have said this in other videos… I’m impressed by how Depp’s attorney controlled the examination by showing faults of incompetence and non-credible testimonies from this “expert psychologist” who never even met Johnny. And the attorney did it without being rude.

    • @robingrg1
      @robingrg1 2 роки тому +4

      It is clear to any thinking person that she is hired to prove a lie. She is just doing her job.

    • @ABC-ln9oi
      @ABC-ln9oi 2 роки тому +4

      Sie ist schon ganz rotes Gesicht 😡.

    • @andeejager1753
      @andeejager1753 2 роки тому +14

      @@robingrg1 she can lose her license very easily
      What she has said and done now reflects back on the other psychologist who work w her

    • @HeadbangoO
      @HeadbangoO 2 роки тому +8

      No he's not clear enough on the inconsistencies of that woman. She answers everything with thousands of words, just drowning the evidences under heaps of non-sense fillers.
      It's a very weak cross-examination so far, jury won't remember anything.

    • @victbsh.3089
      @victbsh.3089 2 роки тому

      @@HeadbangoO he's Bad poor Johnny 🥺

  • @jenniferpollock7677
    @jenniferpollock7677 2 роки тому +10

    I wish the attorney would point out in this audio clip how she does NOT sound like she is afraid of Johnny! If she was truly afraid of him, as she "claims", she would NOT be picking a fight with the supposed abuser (as Amber claims Johnny is) as she was hitting him and calling him a baby as Amber clearly did!!!

  • @tabularasa7711
    @tabularasa7711 2 роки тому +7

    in bullying research, the "target" is often someone admirable. the definition of a bully who is not satisfied by the reaction of her target is as we hear here: the bully is crying and taunting her target, "your such a baby!" She's calling out her target's voice and saying he is not an "adult" because he dares to be complaining about her physically hitting him. he doesn't hit her back. but she verbally abuses him, with taunting language, mocking him, trying with words now, to get her target to react physically. for anyone who has been bullied by a clever bully who is seeking a "fight" this is very triggering. after this, we all need proper therapy from a trained, licensed therapist (not an apologist for a paying victim). such trauma as JD experienced and is reliving arouses the public's compassion. the abuser, the bully is recognized. the victim, the target of abuse is recognized. the OpEd piece is another act of bullying. JD wants a time machine to the casting of Rum Diary where he'll say "let's go with the brunette: less trouble!"

  • @Underratedmen
    @Underratedmen 2 роки тому +63

    She’s literally attempting to push AH’s narrative. This person isn’t impartial enough to be in her field. She should have her license revoked.

    • @bowtoyoursensei554
      @bowtoyoursensei554 2 роки тому

      🙄🙄🙄She's not supposed to be impartial. She's a *paid* witness for the defense. Her literal JOB is to present Amber's problems in the best light without out-and-out lying. She's walking a tightrope, and with the evidence already presented against Heard, she has her work cut out for you.

  • @unlinkedcarbon1910
    @unlinkedcarbon1910 2 роки тому +230

    I am watching this trial and got to say this lawyer gentleman of JD is slowly and steadily killing this “Notes” psychologist and proving her examinations are not reliable.

    • @marrova
      @marrova 2 роки тому +10

      I hope he wins.

    • @FerdaGonca
      @FerdaGonca 2 роки тому +26

      He is doing a great job. No annoyance or bullying of any kind like Amber's lawyers did when they were questioning the JD's witnesses. He got her cornered.

    • @supreethcdscaroline
      @supreethcdscaroline 2 роки тому +7

      but why does he speak that way., he puts a thousand pauses in one sentence. I feel like pulling my brains out of my skull.

    • @chrismulkey7341
      @chrismulkey7341 2 роки тому +6

      @@supreethcdscaroline I think it's his way of speaking carefully. Drives me nuts too though lol.

    • @supreethcdscaroline
      @supreethcdscaroline 2 роки тому +2

      @@chrismulkey7341 Yeah I get that. I just wish he got it out sooner coz on the one hand I want him to decimate that Karen but the anticipation of that being delayed coz of his grunty slow ass delivery is driving me insane. Maybe I need to relax. Come back to it later

  • @victorjames7
    @victorjames7 2 роки тому +6

    When a woman is brushed accidentally on the arm by a man, it's classified as a sexual assault. Even if a man raises his voice to a woman it's classified as assault. But, if a woman cuts off a man's finger it's classed as a low-level situation 🤔

    • @teri-lynnbushbaum587
      @teri-lynnbushbaum587 2 роки тому

      It’s disgusting how the “metoo movement” made every single woman a victim and every single man an abuser! Evidence or proof be damned! Hopefully this very public trial will help put an end to this extreme bias and hatred of men! Too many women are using this time to destroy men’s lives and they don’t even have to have proof because “all women are to be believed NO MATTER what!” 😠

  • @1tonybricky
    @1tonybricky 2 роки тому +5

    I'm so glad Johnny found the immense courage it took to take a stand against AH and show her for what she really is... but I can't imagine the pain he's going through inside to have to relive these horrific crimes of violence and mental abuse... Justice for Johnny

  • @carolynbridgeman5981
    @carolynbridgeman5981 2 роки тому +99

    I really don't understand how Amber Heard's attorneys think that these witnesses are actually helpful to her.

    • @tessa7413
      @tessa7413 2 роки тому +4

      I guess it’s the best they’ve got. Lol

    • @roy5815
      @roy5815 2 роки тому +2

      Beggars can't be chosers.

  • @crimsonplate270
    @crimsonplate270 2 роки тому +398

    I'm not a psychologist, just been abused by my parents and now suffers from PTSD for real, and i now i feel like crying and scared by how this psychologist ignore and testifies to an obvious abuser. Amber Heard, with her argumentative tone, manipulation, actions and attitude reminds me of my parents. I'm so angry how can a 'PYSCHOLOGIST' do this. I'm scared who to trust. I can't even look at Amber's face without feeling scared, angry or disgust.

    • @woolie2459
      @woolie2459 2 роки тому +20

      Im sorry you have suffered through that

    • @victimofpsychiatry
      @victimofpsychiatry 2 роки тому

      Never trust a psych, that is for sure. They have ruined countless of lives, mine included. They escalate, twists, lie, coerce and abuse. Then everyone else believes them over the patient they slandered without solid evidence.

    • @jens2049
      @jens2049 2 роки тому +6

      Same. I can't watch this it scares me and makes my heart rate go to 1000

    • @willow-sagetarot2884
      @willow-sagetarot2884 2 роки тому +12

      Not everyone is this disgusting my love... Don´t let it silence you shoukd you suffer further in the future. The truth always comes out xxx

    • @donnapage3922
      @donnapage3922 2 роки тому

      Trusting in anything in the medical field or even going to any of these social workers, psychiatrists, counselors, they are paid little beaurocrats, who make a living off really bad diagnoses. The lawyer's make millions later off the malpractice issues it's all about the Benjamin's. Everyone is full of crap. Johnny Depp's and his Lawyer's are at least a sign of hope. They are straight forward and facts are being presented. Its driving AH bozos crazy🤘🤩

  • @Flashkoch
    @Flashkoch 2 роки тому +1

    This woman should never work as a psychologist again. She is a shame for her entire profession.

  • @pj655
    @pj655 2 роки тому

    Why is she still looking at a jury while answering.

  • @jungkookwillbethedeathofme
    @jungkookwillbethedeathofme 2 роки тому +195

    no way this woman is a real psychologist 😭😭

    • @AndRandomYT
      @AndRandomYT 2 роки тому +4

      Why not you guys share her name, photo and position that her get to all you're friend so every if them can check her background

    • @dll7658
      @dll7658 2 роки тому +19

      @@AndRandomYT I think he/she's just concerned that people these bad are actually psychologists, not that they're denying that she's one

    • @kaybee2286
      @kaybee2286 2 роки тому +38

      I’m a therapist and am appalled at this therapist’s judgement. She is acting unethically.

    • @kaybee2286
      @kaybee2286 2 роки тому +19

      To add: she’s not considering the facts and she’s not making an unbiased opinion based on the scope of her practice. She’s making so many assumptions and her judgment is clouded by her very obvious bias.

    • @dandx67895
      @dandx67895 2 роки тому

      Why would anyone want to have this woman as a psychologist I’m scared looking at her face alone she looks like she’s about to hit me

  • @hondo1650
    @hondo1650 2 роки тому +116

    For someone that was being abused Amber Heard didn't have that in mind when she's assaulting Johnny Depp

    • @sue-annewalklett7960
      @sue-annewalklett7960 2 роки тому +1

      Exactly, she calls him a baby because it's OK for her to hit him.

  • @jayu7141
    @jayu7141 2 роки тому +1

    This psychologist has no basis to conclude that those bruises reported in a therapy context were the consequence of IPV.

  • @calador1918
    @calador1918 9 місяців тому +1

    She's literally throwing a fit at him because he's calling her out for assaulting him

  • @devanshpandey4944
    @devanshpandey4944 2 роки тому +79

    What type Psychologist do say punching is a low level of violence ? Do someone tell me where such studies taught in US !

    • @rafkong
      @rafkong 2 роки тому +1

      Physiology text books

    • @Erickhetfield
      @Erickhetfield 2 роки тому +2

      A punch/slap is definitely not comparable to a stab wound or rape,

    • @feluto7172
      @feluto7172 2 роки тому +5

      The same one that says throwing bottles at someone when you're angry is okay

    • @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736
      @donttalktomeyoureannoying8736 2 роки тому +1

      @@Erickhetfield for instance, if the abuser is a professional boxer, you tell me if a punch is worse

  • @misbahkhan2868
    @misbahkhan2868 2 роки тому +64

    What a horrible example for a psychologist...

  • @Xxbladeajn88xX
    @Xxbladeajn88xX 2 роки тому +4

    What!? How is that NOT reactive violence!? I can’t believe she would put her reputation on the line. She’s defensive over her diagnosis and it’s clear

  • @lesiap9198
    @lesiap9198 2 роки тому +2

    I like how amber smirks when they show Johnny's finger injury.

  • @pignapoke6772
    @pignapoke6772 2 роки тому +17

    Ah. It's the "look what you made me do" defense! Wow.

  • @AA-gu5jv
    @AA-gu5jv 2 роки тому +116

    So you’re saying that I can throw anything at anyone whenever I want if I feel like I am defending myself? So if my spouse walk in to the bedroom from work and I just “felt threatened” by them just walking and in, I can throw stuff at them right?
    That is just a very selective judgement isn’t it?
    This doctor is a whack. You can’t be basing your assumptions or your diagnosis of your client on what they tell you. It has to be what you observe if your conversation with them during the hours they spent with you and through tests they have to take.
    I don’t like this lady

  • @davealmighty9638
    @davealmighty9638 2 роки тому +1

    She is literally testifying her entire career away.

  • @timaa.4379
    @timaa.4379 2 роки тому +1

    Depp’s lawyers should investigate this psychologist’s coffers. How much did they pay her so that she lies for them.

  • @mrsannad30
    @mrsannad30 2 роки тому +6

    Why does she keep looking at the jury…

  • @williamlacentra2808
    @williamlacentra2808 2 роки тому +48

    This Psychologist for amber is an excellent witness for Johnny .!

  • @jetstream9480
    @jetstream9480 2 роки тому +15

    I feel this lawyer could have pressured her more. There’s so many places where he could have trapped especially after the audio and her saying it’s minimal violence. This so called expert has already decided that Johnny is the perpetrator. 🤯

    • @JanetSmith900
      @JanetSmith900 2 роки тому +2

      I think a big part of their questioning should have been about the therapists notes. She keeps saying she based her conclusion on her meetings and what AH told her and on the notes of the therapists made, which was what AH told them. But Dr. Curry said that therapists are supposed to believe the client, but a forensic psychologist is not supposed to believe the client, but do an independent evaluation. That seems like a really important point.

  • @GoldenLight22
    @GoldenLight22 2 роки тому

    Wow! Just keep playing that audio over and over again of her saying she was hitting him. That says it all. What more is needed

  • @lili8686z
    @lili8686z 2 роки тому +76

    I'm so sick of this b****, I'm sure Johnny is beyond sick of it....I hope he receives justice!

    • @pickitup7008
      @pickitup7008 2 роки тому

      No he’s a white male. Amber herd is a female and deserves all the justice

    • @laurenhudson8317
      @laurenhudson8317 2 роки тому

      PICK IT UP!! You got a few loose screws there, huh?

    • @pickitup7008
      @pickitup7008 2 роки тому

      @@laurenhudson8317 no justice is justice

  • @dkg_gdk
    @dkg_gdk 2 роки тому +96

    She was the one abused by him but he is the one who ended up in the ER with a severed finger and a burn mark on his face, she was the one abused by him but he is the one always trying to escape from physical fights started by her... apparently he abused her by running away from her.

  • @blink4blvckpink728
    @blink4blvckpink728 2 роки тому

    Dr. Hughes slowly realizing that lying in court was not a good idea

  • @UwU-eb3hq
    @UwU-eb3hq 2 роки тому +2

    the * australia* incident - smfh that has no report, no treatment , no injuries , no MEICAL RECORD - after 3 days of a brutal attack with glass everywhere including inside her ....riiiiggghhhhttttt - this is absolutely disgusting - AH has abused not only johnny depp but all victims, male and female of true abuse. justice is coming

  • @cookiecookie1380
    @cookiecookie1380 2 роки тому +22

    That lawyer is really good. 👌

  • @amacmaster6
    @amacmaster6 2 роки тому +16

    She's been compromised.

  • @foxbear60
    @foxbear60 2 роки тому +1

    7:07 That moment when you realize someone's about to say "Checkmate" in a few turns.

  • @priyankabhowmick7143
    @priyankabhowmick7143 2 роки тому

    This is not getting anywhere now. Both parties have pics of injuries, psychologists saying they are nuts, and so on.

  • @reshaawad4761
    @reshaawad4761 2 роки тому +33

    Don’t trust that woman

  • @gabrielakcedeno
    @gabrielakcedeno 2 роки тому +35

    She’s the type of therapist who would make you feel even worse after seeing her 😭😭 had one of those and stopped seeing them after 2 sessions 😅 yikes

  • @Jajabinx69
    @Jajabinx69 2 роки тому

    Whenever Johnny's Lawyer says "Ah"
    I SMILE LIKE A MADMAN.
    Hahahaha
    His tone is absolutely lovely!

  • @sarahb6758
    @sarahb6758 2 роки тому

    This is sickening

  • @adrijonorge9816
    @adrijonorge9816 2 роки тому +65

    "Tell the world, Johnny, tell them, 'Johnny Depp, I, a man, I'm a victim too of domestic violence'. And see how many people believe or side with you"

    • @infiniteloops1879
      @infiniteloops1879 2 роки тому +2

      If you read it carefully you see that line includes an insult and very dangerous thought of ideas that as a man can you tell that openly without embarrassing yourself and also who would believe you as the media is biased towards woman perspective. AH is manipulative narcissist.

  • @terrisannbrooks2724
    @terrisannbrooks2724 2 роки тому +16

    When is Amber taking the stand? I want hear her testifying..

    • @kamolkarmakar6568
      @kamolkarmakar6568 2 роки тому +3

      ✋ Same here

    • @Gramasz
      @Gramasz 2 роки тому +2

      She will commit perjury. No other way she can get any points

  • @totukimou
    @totukimou Рік тому +1

    Every single person, that testified for her benefit, is going to face consequences, because they all testified lies..

  • @hummzwallypeez8294
    @hummzwallypeez8294 2 роки тому

    She’s avoiding giving any answers!!!

  • @maysunktong7612
    @maysunktong7612 2 роки тому +79

    How much money you get to risk your career like this? I am so speechless. Her testimony is the same level as opinions I got from a Karen aunt near my house. So biased! I feel sorry for patients who went to her. It seems like she will not give a proper treatment patients deserve but rather believe in their lies and boost their toxic actions. Hard to believe this is a trained psychologist to treat ppl with traumatic background.

    • @feluto7172
      @feluto7172 2 роки тому

      Lying for the right people is profitable. She's an unhinged man hating crone

    • @rubycardenas7646
      @rubycardenas7646 2 роки тому +2

      I think the type of psychologist she is she is required to take her clients word for truth, so she is only doing her job. But ambers Lies are too obvious and there is too much evidence against her.

    • @loulinaz3770
      @loulinaz3770 2 роки тому

      Hahahaha

    • @serpentine1983
      @serpentine1983 2 роки тому +2

      Ummm. If her career is based on defending lies, then her reputation will skyrocket amongst the people that are like Heard...

    • @ajgallegos7432
      @ajgallegos7432 2 роки тому

      @@rubycardenas7646 you have to be kidding? You actually think she believed herd? She Was payed to testify! Its not about what she believes, shes bought out. Ita called "hired gun".

  • @ohidontknow25
    @ohidontknow25 2 роки тому +17

    Reactive violence??? Johnny stands BEHIND a body guard and she lands a full bloodied hook on him.
    It's just volience.

  • @horuslupercal9936
    @horuslupercal9936 2 роки тому +1

    Why does she always sound like a 6 year old when she gets in an argument.

  • @lisaann9749
    @lisaann9749 2 роки тому

    What is wrong with this "psychologist"?! How unprofessional.

  • @skinnybonesjonestheallseei74
    @skinnybonesjonestheallseei74 2 роки тому +27

    They got this "phychologist" from fiverr to pretend to be a phychologist

  • @cookiecookie1380
    @cookiecookie1380 2 роки тому +13

    That woman is paid to say what she saying .

  • @oakleyducati1
    @oakleyducati1 2 роки тому

    Goodbye to this psychologist’s career. What a sham, and shame!

  • @TheLoneRanger745
    @TheLoneRanger745 2 роки тому +6

    I had a ex-girlfriend tell me the same EXACT THING , and I NEVER hit her back cause she was hoping I would just so she could call the cops and blame me , I knew what she was up to ! She wanted to steel my man card (dignity , honor ) and she was after MONEY ! SOUNDS FAMILIAR

  • @timomajere
    @timomajere 2 роки тому +79

    BUT.. how does she know if she herself never interviewed, much less talked to Depp himself?
    This 'woman' is a bully.
    She sits aimed at the jury, starring at them at times.
    Every time she speaks she stares at the jury as if it is too enfeebled itself to keep up and she MUST explain it to them.
    Then when she tries to sneak in something that was NOT allowed, she starts with a smart mouth and smarmy attitude, leers at the jury like its their fault they have male genitals and acts indignant when her faults are called upon and name public.
    Stuff like she claims to have council to abusive relationships before. but the group of super star celebrities lands on her lap and she just takes ONE side, assumes the rest through documents and then continues on THAT crusade? And she dares to act as if that was perfectly okay to do.
    She's literally hanging her own career on a noose right now. Hope she's paid well because this is what you're getting, prosecutors.
    Defense is literally dismantling her from the career up.

    • @teri-lynnbushbaum587
      @teri-lynnbushbaum587 2 роки тому

      She is extremely abrasive, impatient, condescending, rude, and shows clear bias! She didn’t even interview AH until YEARS later, but acts like she had front row seats to every single incident and presents it as FACTS! I do get a chuckle out of how red her face gets under cross from JDs lawyers! She does NOT like being doubted/question on HER opinions, especially by a MAN (JDs lawyer)! I am just waiting for AHs witnesses to testify! Elon Musk and James Franco have already backed out as witnesses FOR AH! 🤗😂

  • @eg8713
    @eg8713 2 роки тому +3

    What, is she trying to justify abuse

  • @mindyourbusiness9917
    @mindyourbusiness9917 2 роки тому +1

    She agreed to what the lawyer said in the end and when he RE-SAID it she realized she agreed with him and then SWITCHED her answerrrr how tf NOONE caught that !!!!!!!!

  • @vicoor5896
    @vicoor5896 2 роки тому +1

    Low level violence and severe injuries,this woman is unqualified

  • @8thhousealchemist600
    @8thhousealchemist600 2 роки тому +3

    When is AH going to take the stand? This is taking forever.

  • @rogero8061
    @rogero8061 2 роки тому +35

    Watching all this craziness, I am left wondering, how could JD loose the lawsuit in London? How could that have happened? What did the jury/judge there hear or see to make them decide AH was even remotely telling the truth? Someone pls make this make sense!

    • @mlmf2012
      @mlmf2012 2 роки тому +3

      Im wondering this too. How did she win when she has no proof?

    • @Moss_piglets
      @Moss_piglets 2 роки тому +21

      No jury. They later found out her family knows the judge. JD was also wasn't allowed to provide evidence. The defamation laws are very different in the UK.

    • @Moss_piglets
      @Moss_piglets 2 роки тому +10

      @@mlmf2012 it wasn't her case. She was just a witness. The trial was against the Sun.

    • @Gramasz
      @Gramasz 2 роки тому

      The case was against the sun. It's basically ended when AH testify that was regularly beaten by JD. The judge had no choice. (Yes. She committed perjury)

    • @billybussey
      @billybussey 2 роки тому

      England is even dumber than America.

  • @cheechierocks
    @cheechierocks 2 роки тому

    That last minute, I think the dr is thinking ‘I don’t think I’m supporting the right side of this argument’. 😂😂

  • @ChandraChandra-wx9em
    @ChandraChandra-wx9em 2 роки тому +1

    if we were in the jury folks, this case is already over.

  • @ibex1735
    @ibex1735 2 роки тому +8

    Hitting: not punching
    Complaining: being a baby
    Amber: a victim
    Hotel: trivago

  • @anweshmishra6944
    @anweshmishra6944 2 роки тому +37

    Anybody non biased listening to both the psychologists will believe Dr curry without any questions. This doctor idk if she is one or not, can't talk for anything. She has a weird way of eye contact.

  • @jessa9877
    @jessa9877 2 роки тому

    There's a note that she went, but no medical records... says it all

  • @moo1388
    @moo1388 2 роки тому

    Why is her therapist even allowed to testify?? a therapist has to believe what their client says

  • @syav4467
    @syav4467 2 роки тому +46

    Straight up if I was on a jury right now for this as "one of their peers" I would be entirely in Johnny's favor at this point for defamation. They have proven She was abusive, proven she lied, and proven it was financially damaging to him. There is absolutely no credibility to support Amber as a victim, only an aggressor. Sufficient amount of evidence, sufficient amount of witnesses. Without some kind of major and as yet unheard revelation (that is likely not to come at this point) this would be an easy decision for me.