Rob Ager's top 25 horror movies of all time

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 чер 2024
  • Also check out my list of top 25 sci-fi movies of all time • Rob Ager's top 25 sci-...
    WEBSITE: www.collativelearning.com/FILM...
    PATREON: / robager
    FACEBOOK: / robagerpublic
    TWITTER: RobAger?ref_src=t...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,7 тис.

  • @collativelearning
    @collativelearning  5 років тому +238

    Honorable mentions ... many of these might have made the list if I'd compiled it on a different day.
    Halloween and Halloween 3 (the latter is very underrated because it should have been a separate movie from the Myers franchise, but it's still a crazy and very original horror flick)
    Carrie
    Psycho 2 (in hindsight this would be in my top 15, but I'd forgot it while compiling)
    Evil Dead 2 (just for the fun of it)
    Night of the Demon
    The Wailing (yes, another modern horror)
    The Brood
    Cat's Eye
    Scanners
    Texas Chainsaw Massacre
    Devil Rides Out
    Event Horizon
    Blair Witch Project
    Exorcist 2 & 3 (yes I like both of them)
    Exorcism of Emily Rose (too many court scenes, but the horror stuff is very good)
    Day of the Dead
    Ghost Story
    Babadook
    The Grudge (Jap version)
    The Eye

    • @Akimbofrenchfries
      @Akimbofrenchfries 5 років тому +4

      So is it ''Night of the Demon'' or ''Night of the Demons''? I have to be sure :-)

    • @KevsHardLemonade
      @KevsHardLemonade 5 років тому +6

      Curse/Night of the Demon is very underrated. If you have not seen Blood on Satan's Claw I recommend it for sure. Somewhat silly title but very good, creepy, interesting satanic folk horror

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +8

      @@Akimbofrenchfries The old black and white one, whichever that is

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +2

      @@KevsHardLemonade I couldn't get into Blood on Satan's Claw personally.

    • @leej70
      @leej70 5 років тому +10

      Not a fan of Suspiria then?

  • @CoronaTwerking
    @CoronaTwerking 5 років тому +541

    25- Videodrome (1983)
    24- The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957)
    23- The Legend of Hell House (1973)
    22- Audition (1999)
    21- Salem's Lot (1979)
    20- Murder by Decree (1979)
    19- Night of the Living Dead (1968)
    18- Amityville II: The Possession (1982)
    17- Rosemary's Baby (1968)
    16- Fright Night (1985)
    15- Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978)
    14- The Fly (1986)
    13- The Twilight Zone (1983)
    12- Creepshow (1982)
    11- Hellraiser (1987)
    10- The Exorcist (1973)
    9- Psycho (1960)
    8- An American Werewolf in London (1981)
    7- Silence of the Lambs (1991)
    6- Hereditary (2018)
    5- Nightmare on Elm Street (1984)
    4- The Shining (1980)
    3- Poltergeist (1982)
    2- Alien (1979)
    1- The Thing (1982)

    • @veilofreality
      @veilofreality 5 років тому +39

      No "Texas Chainsaw Massacre"?!

    • @theducksneezes4987
      @theducksneezes4987 5 років тому +19

      Thank you for posting this ... after I watched the whole vid

    • @adamarens3520
      @adamarens3520 5 років тому +2

      Thank you!

    • @newnum2
      @newnum2 5 років тому +14

      Thank you. None of them are on Netflix by the way.

    • @eLiFILMSinc
      @eLiFILMSinc 5 років тому +8

      Ahhhh thank you so much. Now I don't have to sit through the whole long as fuck hour. It could've been 20 mins, maybe 30 mins at most. And i would've been pissed anyway when The Exorcist popped in. Gross. Halloween not making it is a mistake and awful. Kind of makes the list and opinion kind of worthless.

  • @olaniyi570
    @olaniyi570 5 років тому +487

    Don't forget Ghostbusters 2016. Truely horrific.

    • @joshjohnson3347
      @joshjohnson3347 5 років тому +36

      Idk that live-action Aladdin with the CGI Will Smith genie was pretty scary

    • @MikkoVille
      @MikkoVille 5 років тому +9

      Indeed. I was truly traumatised by this movie.

    • @OmarHudson
      @OmarHudson 5 років тому +2

      😂😂

    • @anastasiabananastasia
      @anastasiabananastasia 5 років тому +1

      i was 3 when i saw it the first time .. i can tell u the Marshmallow Puff Man was terrifying :)

    • @mynyddyquartzite2034
      @mynyddyquartzite2034 4 роки тому +1

      I had a feeling you would mention Halloween 3, great film I must say

  • @philrobertson647
    @philrobertson647 4 роки тому +75

    Jacob's Ladder was a great horror/thriller film. The demonic portrayals were both original and bone chilling plus Tim Robbin's performance was fantastic

    • @rachaelhogan7850
      @rachaelhogan7850 2 роки тому

      Watch the remake Phil

    • @thebiggusdonnus8453
      @thebiggusdonnus8453 Рік тому +5

      If you loved Jacob's Ladder Phil, check out the Silent Hill Video Game Series. Even if you aren't a gamer, there are plenty of cutscenes and footage online, it's practically a spiritual successor!

    • @tortuga7160
      @tortuga7160 11 місяців тому +3

      @@rachaelhogan7850 There's a remake?

    • @rachaelhogan7850
      @rachaelhogan7850 10 місяців тому

      @@tortuga7160 yes I no Hun not keen

    • @jonathanmoore5619
      @jonathanmoore5619 3 місяці тому

      Great film. Remake is trash.

  • @SequentiallyCompact
    @SequentiallyCompact 5 років тому +24

    One film I don't want to disappear into film history is The Hitcher. The entire film is just so surreal, and Rutger Hauer's character has an almost otherworldly presence, as if he just stepped out of the landscape of the American roadways. Superb film IMO.

  • @collativelearning
    @collativelearning  5 років тому +139

    BTW folks, I started out with Carpenter's Halloween on the list and for some reason it dropped off and I forgot about it, which kinda says in itself I don't rate it as high as I thought I did. It's still excellent of course and may have end up somewhere around the 15 to 20 mark if I'd remembered.

    • @rengokuwon1999
      @rengokuwon1999 5 років тому +5

      Cool, thanks for this. Do you put any stock in sight and sound magazines greatest films of all time decennial list? Can you give us a list of films you consider the greatest? Thanks in advance.

    • @GamerWordDotNet
      @GamerWordDotNet 5 років тому +5

      I like the list better this way ;-)

    • @genejordan6248
      @genejordan6248 5 років тому +3

      james mason, star of murder by decree, appeared on set of the shining... in costume. you featured this on a kubrick analysis ...both films were being filmed simultaneously

    • @eLiFILMSinc
      @eLiFILMSinc 5 років тому +3

      Leaving it out is a mistake on any list but we'll see what youre thinking here

    • @eLiFILMSinc
      @eLiFILMSinc 5 років тому

      Also I believe Halloween 1 and 2 should be one movie

  • @danzemacabre8899
    @danzemacabre8899 4 роки тому +132

    The Exorcist III is criminally underrated, and one of my favorites.

    • @LO-zs3db
      @LO-zs3db 4 роки тому +4

      Danse Macabre I second that opinion

    • @Julian-bq9qv
      @Julian-bq9qv 4 роки тому +7

      *YES - the term 'criminally underrated' is very appropriate - the fine cast provided the perfect ensemble, in my opinion, and the building of the intensity was well paced. One scene that really shook me was the one where the young nurse turned and walked off screen into a corridor, and the shrouded figure with the surgical implement suddenly appeared and rushed after her. Almost Hitchcockian in the subtlety !*

    • @coolmacatrain9434
      @coolmacatrain9434 4 роки тому +1

      @@Julian-bq9qv I remember watching that scene with my cousins shortly after it was released on video. We didn't really know what to expect from the movie itself and it seemed a bit of a slow burner ...and then that scene! We still talk about it yet.

    • @jeanlove8510
      @jeanlove8510 4 роки тому

      "We're fine!"

    • @azalearosid504
      @azalearosid504 4 роки тому

      Which version?

  • @stevesmith3515
    @stevesmith3515 5 років тому +24

    The Exorcist III is my favorite. The dialogue in this movie is just amazing.

  • @LINKMASTERX
    @LINKMASTERX 5 років тому +30

    Love you for this! barely any spoilers but satisfactory reviews for sure! your fans lucked out when you decided to expand the list to 25!!! your work is greatly appreciated Rob!

  • @christophermoonlightproduction
    @christophermoonlightproduction 5 років тому +52

    Shrinking Man and Hell House are both written by Richard Mathison. Shrinking Man was first a book by him and was amazing but of course, his most famous novel is I Am Legend. He also was responsible for the best Twilight Zone episodes, one of which (yes) was redone with John Lithgow on an airplane.

    • @tskmaster3837
      @tskmaster3837 5 років тому +5

      Cute but Richard Matheson wrote Duel which blows everything else he wrote out of the water. And this is from someone who likes the Incredible Shrinking Man but Duel is horror without any trace of horror. It doesn't play like an extended Twilight Zone episode, there's no moral or lesson learned or even a philosophical contemplative ending. It's 100% primal in how one man... named David Mann... fights a faceless Goliath to the death.

    • @christophermoonlightproduction
      @christophermoonlightproduction 5 років тому +7

      @@tskmaster3837 I'm not sure I understand what you mean by cute but to say Duel blows everything else out of the water is a mite subjective. No disrespect meant. Matheson was very prolific, writing both novels and for the screen for decades. I don't know if Duel was originally a book but I know he wrote the screenplay. It wasn't bad and Spielberg probably couldn't have mastered his craft enough to do Jaws justice without having his run at it but it never did anything for me for the very reasons you believe it to be the best. There's nothing wrong with that, mind you. Like I say, it's subjective. However, I certainly wouldn't call it horror. It's 100% suspense. I'd actually say the same for Jaws, too. I never saw it as a horror movie and am baffled whenever I see it on a list of top horror films. It's more of a "Man vs. Nature" adventure with heavy suspense elements.

    • @Fluoride_Jones
      @Fluoride_Jones 5 років тому +3

      +Christopher Moonlight Productions
      I think many people's definition of horror is based on what personally scares them, regardless of the filmmaker's original intent. I would say that "Duel" and 'Jaws" could both be categorized as horror, as there are horrific elements to both. Though, I would definitely categorize "Duel" as a thriller, which is a broad category, itself.

    • @christophermoonlightproduction
      @christophermoonlightproduction 5 років тому +2

      @@Fluoride_Jones Yes, it's subjective, to a degree but I think it's important to try and define definitions. (Does that sound redundant?) I find that is we all just go around telling people "It is what I feel it is." we're going to all get tired out. While there are moments of horror in Jaws, for example, the focus isn't on horror. Horror movies also rely heavily on suspense yet the aim is to make the audience feel horror. It's all in the focus. Suspense aims to make you feel the intensity of the chaise while horror's focus is to make you feel you are experiencing being eaten. I'm being partially metaphorical but hopefully, that helps to clarify what I'm getting at.

    • @Fluoride_Jones
      @Fluoride_Jones 5 років тому +3

      +Christopher Moonlight Productions
      I definitely understand your perspective, and even somewhat agree with you. It's just that in "Jaws," for instance, people get eaten by a giant shark. It's horrible, if you put yourself in the shoes of the on-screen victims. There are people to this day that claim they won't go in the ocean because of that movie. It was released almost forty-four years ago! Name a horror film that has had that kind of lasting impression with it's viewing audience, with the exception of "The Exorcist."

  • @Tennantude
    @Tennantude 5 років тому +10

    Mr. Ager as a fan of yours and of horror, thank you for solving the mystery of a film whose title has eluded me since childhood. For years I have been describing the plot of "The Legend of Hell House" to every horror fan I know and no one had any recollection of the film or its title. My sincere thanks, sir.

  • @Myndir
    @Myndir 5 років тому +4

    One of the reasons I like you videos is that you don't just criticise "bad" films (like a lot of critics) but you actually give good pointers about films to watch, and also help explain why certain things work (which helps me as a non-expert viewer). Thanks!

    • @Myndir
      @Myndir 5 років тому +1

      * your

  • @bobbylee7917
    @bobbylee7917 5 років тому +190

    The Thing is my fav movie

    • @theducksneezes4987
      @theducksneezes4987 5 років тому +10

      The Thing is iconic!

    • @calebhorton4701
      @calebhorton4701 5 років тому +2

      Bobby Lee Mine as well.

    • @chrisd6736
      @chrisd6736 5 років тому +6

      Watched it one snowed in Saturday morning when I was home alone at the age of 12. Nightmares for weeks!

    • @LordMalice6d9
      @LordMalice6d9 5 років тому +4

      @@theducksneezes4987 The Thing inspired a lot of "things", like graphic novels, Video games such as Deadspace and Resident evil with its body horror, and inspired a legion of "imitators" (no pun intended), but none of those imitators are as good.

    • @joem8887
      @joem8887 5 років тому +1

      Same here!

  • @ZheadMonkey
    @ZheadMonkey 5 років тому +11

    Been looking for something interesting all night, just going to bed and this is uploaded. That's 70 minutes of tomorrow evening sorted.
    Cheers, Rob.

  • @TheNightBadger
    @TheNightBadger 5 років тому +11

    # 20: 'Time After Time' - HG Wells actually builds a time machine, and his friend (who is Jack the Ripper) uses it to evade capture and come to modern (1970's) day San Francisco. HG Wells pursues him there to try and stop him. Malcolm McDowell is HG Wells and David Warner is Jack the Ripper. To make it more meta, the time machine Wells builds is the same one used in the classic George Pal movie version of The Time Machine.

  • @jimpickard3850
    @jimpickard3850 5 років тому +6

    Very interesting Rob, I'm gonna re-watch a number of these as a result of this video .. thanks !

  • @DimitriVHefley
    @DimitriVHefley 5 років тому +68

    Absolutely agree Rob! The Thing is the definitive horror film.

    • @Gunners_Mate_Guns
      @Gunners_Mate_Guns 4 роки тому

      Seconded
      It's one of those rare movies with a total package that worked, audio, soundtrack, lighting, acting, script, and (obviously) the best special effects of all time.
      It's a paranoid's tour de force.

    • @MrTommyc7590
      @MrTommyc7590 4 роки тому +1

      It ain't scary though

    • @keepitsecret-dl1pr
      @keepitsecret-dl1pr Місяць тому

      @@MrTommyc7590 yes it is, tell me that if you were in that situation you'd be just fine with it? What a stupid comment

  • @LordMalice6d9
    @LordMalice6d9 5 років тому +74

    The Thing happens to be a lot of peoples favorite horror films, and I can't really blame them. The Thing is a masterpiece! I also agree that Hereditary is an understated modern masterpiece, but not everyone likes slow-burn arthouse styled films let alone horror films.

    • @lynnritchie231
      @lynnritchie231 Рік тому

      Loved Hereditary.

    • @vova47
      @vova47 7 місяців тому

      @@lynnritchie231 Real feelgood film!!😅

    • @keepitsecret-dl1pr
      @keepitsecret-dl1pr Місяць тому

      @@lynnritchie231 dreadful, overrated crap

    • @keepitsecret-dl1pr
      @keepitsecret-dl1pr Місяць тому

      The Thing is in my top 5 horrors, I love Kurt Russell and I think it's such a creepy movie - was lucky enough to catch a re-screening at Everyman cinema - was absolutely incredible

  • @frankielogan9773
    @frankielogan9773 5 років тому +1

    I really enjoy your take on all the films you take interest in. You put such “a matter of fact” tone and that makes it so interesting. I’m a fan 👍🏾

  • @chrisdavies73
    @chrisdavies73 5 років тому +53

    The Wicker Man (1973).
    Still disturbing.

    • @sourjellybaby4286
      @sourjellybaby4286 5 років тому +4

      Good shout that

    • @Ryno87
      @Ryno87 5 років тому +3

      I’m surprised that didn’t make the list.

    • @SlothhhKinggg
      @SlothhhKinggg 5 років тому

      Nice profile pic

    • @adamiadamiadami
      @adamiadamiadami 4 роки тому

      disturbing? even though i love horror and the wicker man is one of my all time favourite movies, i wouldn't even consider it horror. more like a suspense-filled musical with a positive but also nihilistic take on sacrificial rituals.

    • @LisaSimpsonRules
      @LisaSimpsonRules 4 роки тому +1

      yeah, I agree. But it is disturbing in a different way...

  • @solomonlestrade2210
    @solomonlestrade2210 5 років тому +13

    Excellent list; well thought out, well reasoned and properly balanced. Very good work as always.

  • @Wills_Duffy
    @Wills_Duffy 5 років тому +41

    Gregory Peck The Omen ... ? Patrick Troughton >>> surely deserving top 10!!

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +12

      I've always considered it decent, but overrated.

    • @jaybird8192
      @jaybird8192 4 роки тому +4

      @@collativelearning Overrated?? The 1976 Omen is arguably the best anti-christ movie ever!

  • @zackfromtheburgh
    @zackfromtheburgh 5 років тому +16

    Proud of your number one pick, my boy. It is a masterpiece, and my own favorite horror movie as well. It very well could be my overall favorite movie period.

    • @Redmenace96
      @Redmenace96 4 роки тому +1

      Kurt Russel should have 12 Oscars. But, one for The Thing would be the right thing to do.

    • @dayhawkify
      @dayhawkify 4 роки тому +3

      Tell the Oscar's hell's coming, and Kurt's coming with it

  • @sebastianfitzptraick7395
    @sebastianfitzptraick7395 5 років тому +1

    Great video man, love your videos so much. I'd like to see you do a video on what you think are some good directors/extended cuts.

  • @mmp2010
    @mmp2010 5 років тому +13

    Doing a top 25 sci-fi list would be a natural follow-up which I would be really glad to see! (Of course omitting the SF films listed here)

  • @egoborder3203
    @egoborder3203 5 років тому +3

    always great to hear you talk about movies Rob! I know you focus more on heavy duty analyses, but I think we'd all love more of this "casual" content from you. For example, not that I'd want your channel to turn into a Marvel/DC channel, but I would like to hear what you make of the takeover by superhero movies of cinemas. And there's a few TV series I'd like to hear your opinion on (True Detective, Dark). So if you find a way to give us more of this from time to time, we'll eat it up
    BTW I'm glad you included Fright Night, it doesn't get enough respect but I remember it fondly, especially after Roddy McDowall realizes the neighbor really is a vampire

    • @vivianhall5259
      @vivianhall5259 5 років тому +1

      egoBorder May I second that too, please? Maybe a quick review segment? I know how meticulous you are in your analysis (so it may be a challenge) but it would be great to hear your thoughts on some current stuff even if you would never consider them for an in-depth analysis.

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +2

      Cheers, I def want to do more casual stuff. Been waiting to set up studio space, which has been on hold for quite a while.

  • @damobyrne
    @damobyrne 5 років тому

    Thanks great vid Rob. Though I enjoy you’re analysis vids - I also enjoy these informal vids - keep em both coming I say!

  • @timheavyable
    @timheavyable 4 роки тому

    love your videos. Always great takes on some of my favourite films. Superb narration and clear asessments of some scenes. Keep this stuff coming. I was about 8 when i saw the later Bodysnatchers film late at night ,around 85 and even then i felt something special about it. The bagpipes playing and the reveal ,classic .

  • @davedavidh3328
    @davedavidh3328 3 роки тому +11

    "It follows " is a great horror movie it sends shivers down your spine.

    • @evanabbott2737
      @evanabbott2737 3 роки тому

      That was filmed in my town! It’s a great suspense/horror movie, too.😁

    • @dannygray4898
      @dannygray4898 3 роки тому +1

      Babadook is also a good scarer.

  • @nwobw
    @nwobw 4 роки тому +17

    You nailed it with Alien. My favorite parts of Alien are everything not involving the xenomorph. The interaction between the actors, the portrayal of fear, the look on their faces as they try to reason through the problem...all of it. It's a masterclass of acting.
    The xenomorph stuff is great, but it's the actors who make this movie.
    I actually have taken to watching the "Director's Cut" more often (I've seen the theatrical so much) because it has some alternate dialogue in a scene or two.

  • @PicturesOnMyMind
    @PicturesOnMyMind 5 років тому +1

    Amazing work Rob. Thank you for sharing.

  • @briharrisWarhmmer40kfan
    @briharrisWarhmmer40kfan 5 років тому

    Your insights are always interesting and thought provoking rob thanks for your work and please keep them coming 👍👍👍

  • @countdublevay7327
    @countdublevay7327 5 років тому +13

    The fellow that owns The Incredible Shrinking Man oughta kick some cash your way.
    You sold it.

  • @TheGreatBaronOBeefDip
    @TheGreatBaronOBeefDip 5 років тому +21

    DUDE I love Amityville II: The Possession, especially the effects with him changing into that demon and the sounds he makes are just awesome and me and my buds howl along with him, that is a legit great movie. If that were my sister, I just don't know what I'd do either.

    • @abegarfield3754
      @abegarfield3754 5 років тому +1

      MacCauley Crawford, Right on.
      I thought I was the only one.

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +2

      Haha, a buddy of mine and I said the same thing when we were watching it.

    • @RighteousBrother
      @RighteousBrother 5 років тому

      Diane Franklin corrupted my young mind!

    • @lunarvision
      @lunarvision 4 роки тому

      When their front door is blown off... something realistically disturbing (vulnerability) about that.

    • @gabrielegagliardi3956
      @gabrielegagliardi3956 4 роки тому

      Damiano Damiani is a really good director

  • @seanuio
    @seanuio 5 років тому

    Great list. Thank Rob. I missed a few of them. Got some movies to check out this weekend.

  • @marcellogenovese199
    @marcellogenovese199 5 років тому

    I loved this, really interested to see more of these. A list of action movies, war films etc etc. Really good stuff and a lot of fun thinking about what my own list would be.

  • @marcopederzoli4939
    @marcopederzoli4939 5 років тому +27

    One of my favorite horror movies is "Session 9" by Brad Anderson. In some elements it reminded me Hereditary

    • @davidrolston2249
      @davidrolston2249 4 роки тому +1

      Great movie.

    • @jackiemclean2776
      @jackiemclean2776 3 роки тому +1

      Marco Pederzoli I rate session 9 way above hereditary, and I would place it in my top 5

    • @garth2445
      @garth2445 3 роки тому +3

      @@jackiemclean2776 slow down there, cheif.

    • @evanabbott2737
      @evanabbott2737 3 роки тому

      One of my favorites.👍

    • @KajiCarson
      @KajiCarson 3 роки тому

      Session 9 is amazing.

  • @speedystriper
    @speedystriper 5 років тому +25

    My top 10 would be The Shining, The Exorcist, Psycho, Jaws, Alien, The Thing, Halloween, The Bride of Frankenstein, Night of The living Dead, Dracula (Copolla version)

    • @Vignalistudio
      @Vignalistudio 5 років тому +4

      I was with you all the way up until Copolla’s Dracula.

    • @jasrob009
      @jasrob009 2 роки тому +1

      @@Vignalistudio So much potential with Coppola directing, Oldman and Hopkins who are always great. Then there's the decision to cast Keanu and Winona in a serious film requiring British accents. Nothing against either actor I like them both just not in this film.

    • @Vignalistudio
      @Vignalistudio 2 роки тому

      @@jasrob009 ... maybe it was level of expectation too. The first act of that film seemed to exceed my expectations...and then after that it just kept losing steam. At a certain point I just wanted out of the theater.

    • @jasrob009
      @jasrob009 2 роки тому

      @@Vignalistudio yeah it could have been really great but just didn't pull it all together.

  • @tojorozombie
    @tojorozombie 3 роки тому

    A fine list, Sir! Thank you!
    By all means, please continue your Heriditary analysis.
    Such a well done film!

  • @Xxlibra1018xX
    @Xxlibra1018xX 5 років тому

    Just also want to say, great job on this video, Rob! Not like your other videos, but glad to see a top video countdown from you for once just to see what all other films you like (other than The Thing lol). There were definitely some on here I haven't yet seen, and I have definitely been wanting to see Hereditary myself, and seeing that you actually put it on your top 25 of all time video here, well, that just exponentifies my desire to go see it now!
    I was honestly really shocked that one of my other favorites didn't make the cut on this list of yours here, and that would be the 1973 The Wicker Man. I do understand that some may not consider it a typical horror film, but even so, I do believe it still falls under the genre. I personally think it was such an underrated movie, and was kind of shadowed by it's 2006 remake, even though that one gained more notoriety for being one of the Golden Raspberry Awards movies (both known, but each for completely opposite-reciprocal reasons). The 1973 original though, was such an underrated film, and in my opinion is a cult-classic for its questioning of people who just blindly follow religion, as well as related topics that it brings up.
    Again, just wanted to say, great job on this video, always enjoy your work, sir.
    P.S. - John Carpenter's The Thing is definitely the best of all time, lol 😁

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому

      i like the ending of The Wicker Man, but couldn't stand the rest of the film

  • @monacaravetta
    @monacaravetta 2 роки тому +4

    Lambert's off camera death is one of the most frightening and incredibly sad deaths I have experienced in a film. It's horrifying and simultaneously heartbreaking. So raw and so real feeling. I first saw it on its opening weekend at 14 and that stood out to me even then. One of the greatest cinematic moments.

  • @NateSpurs
    @NateSpurs 5 років тому +3

    Nice list. Invasion of the Bodysnatchers 78 is one of my favourite films generally. The ending is so bleak. It's terrifying! And your top two are the same for me.

  • @jmferris1138
    @jmferris1138 5 років тому

    Mr. Ager, i thoroughly enjoyed this video. I learned so much. For me, i would have ranked The Shining slightly higher, but i am biased toward the music in the movie as it has grown on me over the years. Some of the other movies on your list i had not heard of, like Murder by Decree. Others i had heard of, but never taken the time to check out, like The Incredible Shrinking Man, but i really want to watch them now. Thank you for your detailed and insightful critical analysis of cinema. Take care, Sir, and all the best to you in this New Year.

  • @joeyb6285
    @joeyb6285 10 місяців тому

    i've been watching your channel for a few months now and have been blown away by the in-depth analysis of the horror movies i enjoy! i must say for this video i am extra pleased that you have ranked Hereditary so high on the list...and that The Thing is #1 which is my favorite movie as well. Would love to check out the Incredible Shrinking Man (never seen it). Great video!!!

  • @TheJollyMisanthrope
    @TheJollyMisanthrope 5 років тому +7

    I love that you included Fright Night. For pure enjoyment it is definitely in my top 10, and part of my Halloween movie binge every year. RIP Roddy McDowall.

    • @AimeeFleck
      @AimeeFleck 3 роки тому

      yes one of my favorites!

    • @mikemcconville2495
      @mikemcconville2495 2 роки тому

      I’ve seen it so many times I have much of the dialogue memorized

    • @TheJollyMisanthrope
      @TheJollyMisanthrope 2 роки тому

      @@mikemcconville2495 Same here. A few hundred times at least.

    • @paulbrown6464
      @paulbrown6464 8 місяців тому

      Evil Ed became a vampire, not a werewolf, why would someone turned by a vampire become a werewolf, he was even killed by a stake through the heart! Vampires have been shown to turn into animals and that’s what happened here

  • @gordo64ful
    @gordo64ful 5 років тому +3

    Yes! You included Invasion Of The Body Snatchers! My respects!

  • @petrirantanen
    @petrirantanen 5 років тому

    WOW! Great list and the way you present your films and the flow of your speaking is music to my ears. Huge fan of your work. My only gripe in general is that Ken Russell's The Devils don't get any love in any kind of lists and for me it's top 10 film of all time. Would love to see more lists like these. Hope this get enough views and positive feedback so you'll do another list. Hats off!
    Cheers from Finland, Petri

  • @Fortress333
    @Fortress333 5 років тому +1

    Thank you for this video (list). I like your choices and appreciate your argumentation to back up your choices. First of all, I selected An American Werewolf in London as a film to watch, because your description of it sounded like the film is worth my time. I had heard of it before, but had somehow chosen to ignore it, probably due to bad reviews. Stupid me; the film is actually great and I love it.
    Most of the other films on your list are familiar to me already. I watched The Thing for maybe the third time a few days ago. It remains a classic.
    Up next from this list is probably going to be Murder by Decree, but I also like to watch Hellraiser again.
    Another list on another 'genre' would be much appreciated. Perhaps science fiction?

  • @wewillwin24
    @wewillwin24 Рік тому +3

    In no way is Poltergeist a better movie than The Shining..

  • @yredtwo2782
    @yredtwo2782 5 років тому +93

    You forgot the 1970s “The Omen”.

    • @rhabdob3895
      @rhabdob3895 5 років тому +4

      That movie sucked

    • @pheresy1367
      @pheresy1367 4 роки тому +6

      I saw that movie when it first came out in the theaters.... didn't really frighten me, though it was a dark and blood soaked story.
      Whenever the topic of "scary movies" comes up among friends, over the years. It seems that movies like "The Omen", "The Exorcist" and "Rosemarie's Baby" seem to especially effect friends who were raised in strict Christian households (especially Catholic).
      Anybody else find that to be true?

    • @gamleskalle1
      @gamleskalle1 4 роки тому +6

      @@rhabdob3895 remake is crap, the original is great

    • @benfranklin3638
      @benfranklin3638 4 роки тому +2

      I always considered The Omen more of a suspense movie....

    • @holden6104
      @holden6104 4 роки тому +5

      The Omen is scarier to those of religious backgrounds, but I would not say it's exclusive to that demographic at all. I would disagree that it's a suspense film--it's really a straight horror film. There are a lot of very memorable and scary scenes in the Omen, and the soundtrack's one of the greatest horror achievements of all time. Looking back on it today, there are a few things that would be considered silly by today's standards, but overall the film is an absolute classic and holds up well.

  • @erickenneycreative
    @erickenneycreative 5 років тому

    Thanks for this .. always love your perspective on films

  • @metalstorm7506
    @metalstorm7506 Рік тому

    Rob, I’ve been following your channel for years now and I admire your dedication, love for what you do and love for the art of cinema in general. They are contagious and sometimes I catch myself enjoying your analyses of my favorite movies rather than binge rewatching them over and over again with my limited knowledge and yet, your videos boost my fascination for a particular movie when you make your videos so interesting.
    I have always wondered, what do you think about “The VVitch ? “ ( 2015). I would love to see an in depth analysis of this particular movie provided that you love it in the first place.
    [ English is obviously not my native language, so accept my apologies if a message feels unclear somehow ]

  • @43nostromo
    @43nostromo 5 років тому +12

    Great job, Rob, but I'm incredulous that you left off movies like "Beaches" "Steel Magnolias" and "The Divine Secrets of The Ya Ya Sisterhood". I can't think of many films where I walked out of the theater in absolute horror. Generally within the first 5 minutes. But, seriously, I would have considered "The Funhouse (1982)" d: Tobe Hooper. Many interesting elements, including a really nice and underrated score by composer John Beal.

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +1

      Haha

    • @grossliz1995
      @grossliz1995 4 роки тому +1

      Funhouse freaked me the fuck out and I never hear about it! That thing laughing at the end was so creepy.

  • @softbatch1
    @softbatch1 5 років тому +3

    I will definitely check out Murder by Decree. It's the only movie on this list that I'm not aware of. Thank you for including The Legend of Hell House on your list.

  • @14Gab88
    @14Gab88 5 років тому +1

    Great video! wish you could make more of these

  • @zakerymizell8838
    @zakerymizell8838 5 років тому

    Thanks so much for this list! Lots of movies to add to the watch list

  • @tigrispeter
    @tigrispeter 5 років тому +21

    The Evil Dead '81.

    • @Gunners_Mate_Guns
      @Gunners_Mate_Guns 4 роки тому +1

      Looooooooooove it!

    • @davidrolston2249
      @davidrolston2249 4 роки тому

      Agree 100%. Belongs on any top 25 list. I wrote an article that goes into the history of the film for movie-gurus in my review of Evil Dead II

  • @keikurono192
    @keikurono192 5 років тому +75

    Did you see The Witch? That was one of the best horror movies I've seen in the last 10-15 years.

    • @Sam-mw4lh
      @Sam-mw4lh 5 років тому +13

      That movie still creeps the shit out of me

    • @mk-ultramags1107
      @mk-ultramags1107 5 років тому +9

      You can tell Eggers was a production designer whatever because its incredibly authentic and the natural lighting keeps you looking for things in the shadows and essentially OFF SCREEN. Its in my Top 5-7

    • @Ryno87
      @Ryno87 5 років тому +4

      Very underrated film in my opinion. It has an eerie, creepy feel. Very unsettling movie.

    • @Gunners_Mate_Guns
      @Gunners_Mate_Guns 4 роки тому +3

      Have to agree here.
      Can't believe it wasn't more successful.
      Damn creepy atmosphere, and I love how it kept things so ambiguous.

    • @juggernautakira
      @juggernautakira 4 роки тому +6

      Movie was a mess.

  • @davidmacleod5753
    @davidmacleod5753 5 років тому

    Most underrated youtube channel ever. Keep it up, Rob

  • @cygnusx-1260
    @cygnusx-1260 4 роки тому

    Didn’t even finish the video yet, paused it to give the rest of it my blessing, just because you said “ Fright Night”. I’m new to your channels, but I am throughly enjoying your videos.
    GOOD SHOW

  • @rengokuwon1999
    @rengokuwon1999 5 років тому +22

    25 videodrome
    24 the incredible shrinking man
    23 the legend of hell house
    22 audition
    21 Salem's lot
    20 murder by decree
    19 night of the living dead
    18 Amityville 2 the possession
    17 Rosemary's baby
    16 fright night
    15 invasion of the body snatchers 1978
    14 the fly 1986
    13 the twilight zone movie
    12 creepshow
    11 hellraiser
    10 the exorcist
    09 psycho
    08 an American werewolf in London
    07 silence of the lambs
    06 hereditary
    05 nightmare on elm Street
    04 the shinning
    03 poltergeist
    02 alien
    01 the thing 1982

    • @michaelcarr8625
      @michaelcarr8625 5 років тому +1

      Poltergeist is indeed brilliant! :)

    • @Solar_Sounds
      @Solar_Sounds 4 роки тому

      @@michaelcarr8625 Am I literally the only person alive that didn't like poltergeist? I found it over the top, predictable, and not scary.

    • @lampad4549
      @lampad4549 3 роки тому +1

      @@Solar_Sounds what was predictable about it?

    • @jasrob009
      @jasrob009 2 роки тому +1

      @@Solar_Sounds I watched it in theaters at like 7 years old when it came out in the early 80s and it scared the shit out of me. I saw it years later and it was still good but not near as scary.

  • @miguelcorona6897
    @miguelcorona6897 5 років тому +8

    Videodrome define my childhood of the video rental horror era

    • @MikkoVille
      @MikkoVille 5 років тому +1

      Same here! Haven't seen it in years, though. Maybe need to rewatch it.

  • @Gunners_Mate_Guns
    @Gunners_Mate_Guns 4 роки тому

    I was up in the air on many of your other choices, especially for your top 10 ("The Shining," I'm looking right atcha), but agree 100% for your #1 and #2.
    So glad that "The Thing" has finally gotten the love and respect from so many that it so greatly deserved, yet didn't get when it was originally released.

  • @peregrinec5477
    @peregrinec5477 Рік тому

    This is an AMAZING LIST! Only a couple I have never seen...I need to rectify that asap.

  • @jamstonjulian6947
    @jamstonjulian6947 5 років тому +11

    Have you seen Night of the Creeps? Similar in style to Return of the Living Dead or Fright Night. Lots of fun.
    Also I was surprised not to see Don't Look Now or The Wicker Man.

    • @theducksneezes4987
      @theducksneezes4987 4 роки тому

      Night of the Creeps was a fun movie and a must-see! Not good in the genre of horror tho

  • @jwnj9716
    @jwnj9716 5 років тому +14

    Stephen King's The Long Walk would make a great movie if they pick the right director. Its my favorite book. Its simple but brutal.

    • @elpascalmods7384
      @elpascalmods7384 5 років тому +1

      Apparently there are plans to make it into a film, so let's hope for the best.

    • @jwnj9716
      @jwnj9716 5 років тому

      Yeah Frank Darabont was the first choice but that wont happen.

    • @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017
      @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017 5 років тому

      Wasn't that a short story?

    • @jwnj9716
      @jwnj9716 5 років тому +1

      No its one of the Bachman books.

    • @possessedslig
      @possessedslig 5 років тому +1

      One of my favourites too, one of Stephen King's best, most overlooked novels

  • @justinc4782
    @justinc4782 5 років тому

    Thanks Rob, appreciate everything you do!

  • @TheTemplarKnight
    @TheTemplarKnight 5 років тому

    Nice list Rob it is always interesting to see what others like plus there are some i have never heard of that i must watch now.

  • @Juno-ue9vs
    @Juno-ue9vs 5 років тому +39

    Will you Collective Learning do one day an Analyzed video on Wes Craven The People's Under The Stair's

    • @javagirl69
      @javagirl69 5 років тому +9

      I would watch the HELL out of that, and I would also buy it, of course!

    • @trevorreznik9881
      @trevorreznik9881 5 років тому +4

      People under the Stairs was a black comedy to me but it was a good movie.

    • @TheJollyMisanthrope
      @TheJollyMisanthrope 5 років тому +5

      Funny that it had the actors that played Ed and Nadine Hurley from Twin Peaks as the main villains.

    • @peppermintcatsass3141
      @peppermintcatsass3141 5 років тому +2

      ..when they finally came out from the walls, they all looked like 1980s Heavy Metal Fans....on a good day!

    • @nickpastorino5370
      @nickpastorino5370 3 роки тому

      You mean CollAtive Learning?

  • @misacruzader
    @misacruzader 3 роки тому +3

    I think 28 Days Later is quite brilliant and I'm surprised it didn't make either of your lists. My new favorite horror film is Midsommar. I think there's a lot to unpack in it about cult indoctrination and feminism. These days I'm not about jump scares, I prefer to explore existential dread, maybe because as I get older I already know what goes bump in the night but I still struggle to understand how my own thoughts can scare me so much.

  • @Abaris84
    @Abaris84 5 років тому +1

    Great list, Rob!
    Wholeheartedly agree with your number 1 spot. I would have added Suspiria to the list, though :)

  • @bobz1736
    @bobz1736 4 роки тому

    Great reviews. Got my grey cells going. I remember seeing the Shrinking Man at a very young age in the 60s and found it so sad and moving. Thanks for the memories... 😎

  • @bobhuber8480
    @bobhuber8480 5 років тому +18

    Phantasm!

    • @bobhuber8480
      @bobhuber8480 5 років тому

      @Daniel Grozier IDK what that means. Yes, vaccinations are good. ??

    • @bobhuber8480
      @bobhuber8480 5 років тому

      @Daniel Grozier Thanks for that clarification. I honestly thought it was steroids because of the bicep. I'm all about Evil Dead 2. :-)
      Groovy!

    • @evanabbott2737
      @evanabbott2737 3 роки тому +1

      I love Phantasm.😁

  • @timeforbooks566
    @timeforbooks566 5 років тому +15

    Is 28 Days Later on it? That is my favorite horror film of all time. 😊😊😊

    • @aegisgfx
      @aegisgfx 5 років тому

      nothing new in that movie really

    • @timeforbooks566
      @timeforbooks566 5 років тому +9

      @@aegisgfx The character of Jim is actually intensely interesting to me. Specifically the psychological changes that he goes through throughout the film. I also think it's beautifully shot, especially considering the subject. The soundtrack is fantastic... but thanks for your comment!

    • @timeforbooks566
      @timeforbooks566 5 років тому +9

      Oh and also fast moving running 'zombies' was something new.

    • @johndawhale3197
      @johndawhale3197 5 років тому +6

      I love 28 Days Later so much...It's really grown on me in recent years because the UK has changed so much (mostly for the worse imo) since the times of that movie, 2002. It's the only movie of the 21st century which I feel shows British people in a positively brilliant way. Jim, Selena and Frank are 3 of the most BRILLIANT and inspiring characters ever.

    • @esyphillis101
      @esyphillis101 5 років тому +4

      @@timeforbooks566 As was the idea of a virus that turns it's victims into zombies within mere seconds.

  • @damianstenberg3761
    @damianstenberg3761 4 роки тому

    This is a great list and rekindles much of my VHS/videostore childhood...pleased to see murder by decree and amityville 2 in there (both massively underrated).and roddy macdowell popping up here and there too...plus i always found the claustophobic paranoia and sfx in bodysnatchers very similar/or a precursor to the thing...be good to see more of these lists rob thnx👌🏻

  • @bombatamiasmata283
    @bombatamiasmata283 4 роки тому

    Great Movies, great List. "The Thing" is also my favorite Horror-Movie, along with "Alien", "Jacob's Ladder" and "Exorcist III". I really enjoy your smart Documentaries. Keep up the good Work, dear Rob.

  • @rorypatterson4548
    @rorypatterson4548 4 роки тому +3

    Rob, I can’t recommend the 1960s French film Eyes Without A Face, it’s incredible and such a creepy film what really gets under the skin.

  • @DirectorSmiley
    @DirectorSmiley 5 років тому +5

    Have you finally seen Dead Calm yet with Nicole Kidman and Sam Neill? I'd be curious what you'd think of it since it's one of Kidman's best rated films and Billy Zane makes for a charming yet horrific psycho.

    • @eggZ663
      @eggZ663 5 років тому +1

      Good film that

    • @infinitesimotel
      @infinitesimotel 5 років тому +1

      Very good watch that one

    • @DirectorSmiley
      @DirectorSmiley 5 років тому

      @newclique and Nicole Kidman is powerful in it. There's a lot of content in the film for a full analysis I'd love to hear some day.

  • @iAmiSaid
    @iAmiSaid 3 роки тому

    Thoroughly enjoyed this video, thank you for sharing!

  • @WrvrUgoThrUR
    @WrvrUgoThrUR 3 роки тому

    I’m willing to consider contesting my own list as compared to yours based solely on your brilliant breakdown of ‘The Exorcist’. Before your review, I was distracted by the horror of the possession and makeup. That became forever secondary to me after your breakdown. Can’t thank you enough for making it, not only the best horror movie ever in my view, but also making one of my favorite films in general.

  • @josephtopete1492
    @josephtopete1492 5 років тому +11

    Brilliant list of horror movies.

  • @AntoniePereira
    @AntoniePereira 5 років тому +5

    love it

  • @thestrongseminarian
    @thestrongseminarian 5 років тому

    Great video! Definitely a few I’ve never seen that I’m going to watch.

  • @punchfisttop
    @punchfisttop 3 роки тому

    GREAT LIST! and thank you for including CREEPSHOW! King's and Romero's best work.

  • @raniboy6
    @raniboy6 5 років тому +6

    good list but why not add Dario argento's suspiria?

  • @free2game
    @free2game 5 років тому +20

    I'm surprised to not see Suspiria on there.

    • @ThePhantomLK
      @ThePhantomLK 5 років тому +2

      Do you know if Rob has seen that?

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +9

      not seen that yet.

    • @GuamoKun
      @GuamoKun 5 років тому +4

      2018>>>>>>>>>>>1977

    • @benwinter2420
      @benwinter2420 5 років тому +1

      Coloured stage lights do not make a horror movie

    • @willthomas2310
      @willthomas2310 5 років тому +1

      The original is overrated, i actually think the newer version is better.

  • @diaz5292
    @diaz5292 5 років тому

    Ya this was fun, Rob. Do more rankings of movies. And thanks for doing this!!

  • @LordWyatt
    @LordWyatt 3 роки тому

    Great list:) The Thing is my favorite horror sci-fi and Alien is my favorite sci-fi horror. I think they encapsulated precisely what they were trying to go for and they’re both done practically flawlessly.

  • @erdingtonsfinest937
    @erdingtonsfinest937 5 років тому +3

    I saw Nightmare on Elm St when I was very young and no other film has gave me as many bad dreams. A paedophile with a burned face and a bladed claw for a hand who can kill you in your sleep? It's just sounds terrifying.
    Also, Texas Chainsaw Massace made me feel very uncomfortable and stayed with me for a long time after watching it. The Fly, Blair Witch Project and Candyman are the rest of my top 5,for very different reasons.

    • @davidrolston2249
      @davidrolston2249 4 роки тому

      Kuddos for bringing up Candyman, which is criminally underrated.

  • @yrebrac
    @yrebrac 5 років тому +44

    Any (horror) love for Event Horizon?

    • @collativelearning
      @collativelearning  5 років тому +13

      Was considering it. Good movie. Very creepy.

    • @TreatzTMA
      @TreatzTMA 5 років тому +2

      Plenty!

    • @kasparov937
      @kasparov937 5 років тому +1

      @@collativelearning The Witch?

    • @MCCrleone354
      @MCCrleone354 5 років тому +1

      kasparov9
      Rob said somewhere that he could not finish The Witch.
      Indicating that he watched some of it. Honestly I don’t blame him. The Witch was very muddled in terms of script writing. Why would Anya Joy’s character join a witch cult that murdered her family?

    • @mk-ultramags1107
      @mk-ultramags1107 5 років тому +1

      Bought it recently after watching it on Prime Video. I knew i liked it but i absolutely love it now. Its fantastic. Plus its a quick watch. Id love to see the lost footage but it works anyways

  • @iceveiled
    @iceveiled 3 роки тому

    Nice, your list has 10 of my favorites. My #1 is The Exorcist, but The Thing is in my top 5. The practical effects are so strong and stand the test of time. Shoutout to 'Cabin in the Woods', not on your list, but a very fun film that is self-aware of its own campiness. I would place Creepshow 2 before Creepshow 1, but that's just me. The story 'The Raft' in Creepshow 2 does an amazing job at establishing and building up tension (the other two stories are worthwhile, but not as good), while the animated story that happens at the beginning, end, and between each of the 3 stories, is darkly amusing.

  • @Vereid
    @Vereid 5 років тому

    I love your videos and critiques Rob. I almost wish you were a fan of Final Fantasy 7, 8, 9 or 10 just to see your videos on them lol. I also watched The Exorcist at around 9/10 and I had many restless nights expecting my bed to start shaking all over the place. Love The Thing and Alien also. I need t get around to watching The Bodysnatchers- heard good things about it. Great video as usual.

  • @ThePhantomLK
    @ThePhantomLK 5 років тому +7

    If you think "Dawn of the Dead" could have been tighter in editing, I'd succest to watch the official italian/european cut made by Dario Argento which has excactly that purpose.

    • @DoomHacker83
      @DoomHacker83 5 років тому +5

      Plus it has the awesome soundtrack by Goblin.

    • @abegarfield3754
      @abegarfield3754 5 років тому

      I'm still looking for that version.

    • @MegaRockstar48
      @MegaRockstar48 5 років тому

      I found the hill billies near to the start the only bit I would of edited out. It could of done with more after the first officer died before the bikers turn up

  • @spalf0
    @spalf0 5 років тому +11

    The Wicker Man (1973)?

    • @epichal4883
      @epichal4883 4 роки тому

      He called it boring when talking about Midsommar recently. I haven't watched it but it looks good to me.

  • @roybatty3989
    @roybatty3989 Рік тому +1

    Poltergeist is DEFINITELY that good.
    Great to see your top 25. Even one movie in there I've never seen. Thanks for making this!

  • @seanledden4397
    @seanledden4397 4 роки тому +1

    Very happy to see Fright Night on this list! Like Star Wars (A New Hope), Raiders of the Lost Ark, and Tremors, it used state of the art filmmaking to revisit an old genre. And it did so with both humor and respect. I love all of those movies.

  • @popeinnocentiii6315
    @popeinnocentiii6315 5 років тому +4

    Thanks for sharing, this gives me a lot of watching material. Another horror film I love is Carnival of Souls. And the scariest film I've ever seen is Inland Empire.

  • @Mike_A_
    @Mike_A_ 4 роки тому +3

    Hereditary was fascinating. I need to see it again.

  • @Jerusalem_777
    @Jerusalem_777 4 роки тому +1

    Great list. I think this would take me forever to actually make my own. Love seeing Amityville II!

  • @Kartsah
    @Kartsah 5 років тому +1

    Interesting and well explained choices. My list would be somewhat similar but with possession(Zulawski) and videodrome near the to, and maybe witch and suspiria featured somewhere near spot 25.