I think Lindsey in action felt as she learns from her mistakes and i agree that she should have won a season because she had the development just right. But i think season 3 should have been the season she should have won in. Mainly because having her win in season 3 would surprise many people. Because having her win season 3 would actually make sense.
List of Legends I was thinking about it; Courtney and Harold become finalists. Courtney wins for herself and Lindsay beacuse the were both bullied by heather and If Harold and Leshawna became a thing again, Harold wins for Leshawna. So Everyone wins. 😁Courtney and Harold would most likely split the money😄
Not to mention that Harold was basically the protagonist of Action in my opinion. They built this rivalry/friendship with Duncan and it was so good. Only to eliminate him instead of Owen for no reason and do nothing with it.
@@nicks.857 Mostly because Duncan's the writers' favorite/second favorite. And I think Beth was there as a replacement to Lindsay, showing that Lindsay was going to win the rest of the challenges and then win and befriend Duncan (which makes more sense) but maybe it's her VA...
1. Courtney 2. Leshawna(who does a lot btw, she was even the first to win a challenge on her own during the merge- I have no idea what you mean when she says she doesn’t do too much, especially compared to the people you put higher than her) 3. Harold 4. Lindsay 5. Scott 6.Sierra 7. Jasmine 8. Dj Honorable mentions Brick Noah
She’s certainly a team player for sure I was meaning in terms of strategic moments overall but her being on the list I definitely think she deserves a win 🏆
@@langdonledwig3734 I disagree with dawn, B and ella. Sure they are all decent characters, but none of them have had the character development needed. Dawn is one of the most overrated contestants of all
LeShawna deserved number 6 or 7. She was not only strong in challenges, but she also was the best social player in TDI, and her strategic game was on point. She was way better than most of the people on this list. (Brick, Lindsay, Justin, Harold, and Sierra)
@@ListsofLegends So by that you are saying the Lindsay, Brick, Harold, and Justin were more strategic than LeShawna. I’ve rest my case. Also the video was “Top 8 Total Drama Characters That Should Have Won a Season” not “Top 8 TD characters with the best strategy that never won.
Brick really deserved to win a season and I’m just shocked that he wasn’t in Total Drama All Stars, I thought he was the best character in the entire Total Drama
I’m pretty sure it’s because Lindsays voice actor had a family emergency during action, so they had to rewrite and cut her plot short, and had to rewrite someone else to win besides Duncan. But I’m pretty sure she was supposed to win.
@@someguydoingthingsNo, it was known by a long time, Lindsay and Harold were supposed to be Final 2 in Action Harold was cut because they thought Duncan would do more than him Lindsay was cut due to a family emergency
Here 10 characters that i think should have won a season 10. Sammy - it's mainly because she can build up as someone who feels more happy when she lasts long in the game. Even if amy was part of the final two with her. This would be an interesting plot of manipulated grows a backbone. 9. Dawn - she was robbed. Give her a break 8. Leshawna - the furthest she got was in island. And i wish she won the game without anyone manipulating the elimination. (Looking at chris,courtney and al) 7. DJ - i feel bad for the dude 6. Jo - she felt hard working enough to make it to 5th place of season 4. Makes you wish she won. 5. Brick - a dumbass with a big heart would be pretty cool to have as a winner. 4. Lindsay - she might be an idiot but she started learning from her mistakes in season 2. And the writers forgot about it. 3. Harold - he would be a perfect winner. Mainly because of how he is smart enough to make it to 5th place in action 2. Izzy - she is pretty neutral chaotic in alignments. She is silly. But we had a couple of people like her win before. 1. Serra - it would be perfect for her to just win total drama and just being in heaven because it would motivate people that you got to earn your dreams fairly.
I saw this on Reddit and this is my new head cannon on why Lindsay got out first in All-Stars Remember that quote she said in Ep22 if she knew about that resort thing she would’ve booted herself out in the first episode And All-Stars is the only other season that takes place at Wawanakwa(that she was a cast in)and she did what she said she would in Island
Another one would be in episode 1 of all stars where she says “ I never thought I’d say this no lip gloss is worth this” it sort of implies she doesn’t want to continue
My list: #8: Dawn #7: Eva (No joke, I see her with redemption) #6: Sierra #5: Noah #4: Jasmine #3: Brick #2: Bridgette #1: Leshawna Honorable mentions: Courtney, Jo, Emma, Kitty, Lindsay, Trent, Cody, Sammy, B, DJ, Harold, & Ella The fact that all of these are characters I like lol
I know she has a soft spot in her, she just doesn't like to show it (Proof, is because when she got too violent with having revenge on Justin, she apologized, so that shows something). So there's something about her...
I don't agree on Dawn she didn't do anything outstanding in roti she is My favourite roti character but she doesn't really deserve to win and if its the argument of she got robbed then b got robbed even harder and was a beast in challenges and would've Been a serious threat if he made merge plus even Scott saw how much of a threat he was that's why he was eliminated so early That took a while to make and Btw no hate 😅
In my opinion Cody should should have won one season I mean not only would it be the ultimate underdog story he has shown that he can do some things other than challenges, in world tour not once was he thought to be a beast at the game which means nobody would try to get him out and we've seen on both seasons with Trent and on most people in world tour he can build trust in relationships easy and in the first season he got robbed I would like to see him win
Personally here's my opinion on who should have won each season TDI - I'm actually okay with this one TDA - Harold/Lindsey/Courtney VS Duncan TDWT - Again I'm okay with this one TDROTI - probably Brick VS Joe TDAS - Courtney VS Scott or Cameron VS Cody If Cody ever made it into the season
Top 8 characters who should have won season (IMO) 8th: Sierra 7th: Jasmine 6th: Lindsay 5th: Brick 4th: Harold 3rd: Emma and Kitty 2nd: Leshawna Honourable mentions: Bridgette, DJ, Anne Maria, Jo, Cody 1st: Scott
Cody would have won wt if sierra didn’t blow up the plane. If Sierra and Cody were the final 2, I think Chris would do something to turn Sierra against Cody so she’d try to win
If we're talking Pahkitew, I honestly would love for Samey/Sammy to win a season if only because she deserves something to feel good about after dealing with Amy's bullshit for so long. And even though her biggest strategic move was against her twin, it still proves she has a cutthroat side to her and could definitely make it pretty far in the show as long as she's not focused on literally just surviving Amy's abuse.
@@ListsofLegends I love a good underdog story, honestly, and if anybody would and should be the star of an underdog story, it's definitely her. I don't know who she'd be in the finale with, but she should definitely make sure Amy is eliminated either as soon as possible or right before the finale.
Team amazon is the best team the chemistry when singing all of them did great this season since they survive elimination till ep 15 and 3 of them making into finale is a winner material
I also think Sierra deserved to win but I also think she would've gotten voted out just by being annoying haha I personally think she was extremely lucky on world tour being on team amazon and in the merge everyone else was just targeted except her (Blainely, Courtney, Duncan, Owen) also for some reason I can't remember 1 thing about all stars even though i know I've watched it(i know scott and courtney were together but anything other than that i forgot) going to rewatch it and see if she performs pretty well there
I feel like Zeke should have won a season (hear me out) I feel like the main reason people dislike Ezekiel is because we never got to see him grow, he was always booted first and barley got any screen time, he had potential especially in world tour I mean he was the only character to be booted first twice and at that point why would they even bring him back, he could have went from first boot in island to 1st place in world tour undergoing a MASSIVE character arc, I feel like feral Zeke was a really dumb idea because the writers took a character with huge potential and turned him into a LOTR reference. People say that Zeke wasn't qualified for TD and while that is kinda true I still would have loved to see his character grow into something more than a meme
YES. I have the same opinion. He only came to the show to help his parents, try to adapt to his vitamin D deficiency and try to socialize more. He only made that sexist comments because his father thaught that. And if the other contestants listened and corrected him, he could have gotten, at most, five episodes further.
I heard that they tried to make a running Gag with him always getting eliminated first and they turned him into a feral freakshow because some Ezekiel Fans harassed the Producers or the Writers
I actually think Geoff deserved a win at some point. The dude was a beast in many challenges and was constantly showing his caring and kind side to many other characters. He was eliminated 6th or 5th place in Island ONLY due to his kindness, Duncan even admitted if they didn’t vote him off there, he possibly could’ve made it to the final 4 or even higher. In Action I wished they never did the whole double elimination thing and instead let Geoff stick around. I would’ve loved to see how far he would’ve gone in that season. After that he was only ever in the spin-off race season where he was the Alternative winner. At the end of the day I wish they would’ve given us more Geoff and see more development from him to actually win a season. I think he deserved at least a finals appearance.
@@ListsofLegends that's cool but it still would've been cool to see Noah win a season. I wouldn't say he's underrated since he's a fan favorite but I think he's the most wasted potential of a character as he should've gotten more screentime and could've been a villain.
Leshawna has way more strategic moments than nearly everyone you put above her? In my opinion, I think you should rematch the season because she was by far the 2nd most strategic player in island
Here's my way of the Total Drama finals (including RR) Island: Same (Owen VS Gwen) Owen wins Action: Lindsay VS Harold Lindsay wins World Tour: Alejandro VS Ezekiel Ezekiel wins Revenge of the Island: Lightning VS Scott Lightning wins All Stars: Leshawna VS Courtney Leshawna wins Pahkitew Island: Same (Shawn VS Sky) Sky wins Ridonculous Race: The Sisters VS The Stepbrothers The sisters win
@@ListsofLegends I also made my way of All Stars, including the Pahkitew cast, with 16 players on each team: Heroic Hamsters: Mike, Zoey, Cameron, Courtney, Lindsay, Sierra, Noah, Owen, Rodney, Brick, Beardo, Leshawna, Harold, Tyler, Cody and Ezekiel Villanous Vultures: Eva, Sky, Dave, Max, Sugar, Topher, Alejandro, Justin, Heather, Jo, Scott, Lightning, Duncan, Gwen, Anne Maria and Izzy Yes, i'm still putting Courtney as a hero and Gwen as a villain, and on this version, All Stars is after Pahkitew. Some characters like Zeke, Rodney or Beardo are on this list because on this alternative universe, they had big character developments.
For me Island: Duncan vs Gwen Gwen wins Action: Lindsay vs Trent (since Island focused on Gwen, I'd have Action focus on Trent) Lindsay wins World Tour: Same as the show, Heather wins Revenge of the Island: Brick vs Dawn (but I'd have Jo at the final three) Dawn wins All-Stars: Courtney vs Leshawna Leshawna wins Pahkitew Island: Jasmine vs Sky Jasmine wins Ridonculous Race (three alternate endings) Goths vs Sisters vs Reality TV Pros Goths win
I love dawn! Even put her on my most underrated characters list but lot of people pointed out to me that she doesn’t do much which is unfortunately is true in my opinion now, if she returned one day and they give her more screen time and a better role most definitely
Amazing video and a very interestingtopic. You mentioned many things nobody did before. Maybe a bit to many contestants in my opinion, i don't agree on Justin for example.
That’s alright, thanks for sharing! And yeah sorry lol top 8 is my thing for the most part there just people on the list I think could have won a season
heres who shouldve been the REAL finalists: s1: izzy & geoff s2: harold & duncan s3: sierra & ezekiel s4: staci & lightning s5: scott & sam s6: leonard & max s7: tennis rivals & stepbrothers s8: zee & scary girl s9: ripper & damien now for the first boots: s1: gwen s2: leshawna & heather s3: cody s4: anne maria s5: zoey s6: jasmine s7: sisters s8: bowie s9: priya
I have to agree with most of your choices. seeing as most of them had more personality than some of the actual winners. I really think Leshawna would have been in the top 4 or maybe higher if they hadn't eliminated her the way they did. Can you imagine her in Gwen's place during the Dare chalIenge? I was just waiting for her and Heather to get in a true brawl and Heather get the snot beat out of her in Island. I would probably add DJ and Izzy myself. I do agree with you on Pahkitew Island in that most of the characters were boring. Jasmine and Ella were about the only two who were interesting at all. I think it should have come down to Jasmine vs Skye in the finale.
mi top: 1-lindsay 2-cody 3-jasmine 4-leshawna 5-samey 6-brick 7-harold 8-bridgette 9-crimson o ennui 10-tom o jen p.d: ojala courtney nunca gane quien la aguanta despues presumiendo y menospreciando al resto, como maximo a los 3 finalistas
i'm surprised you didn't mention B at all. man was the MVP for all the challenges he competed in.....to the point where Scott was threatened by him and had to take him out. Otherwise he would've won (at least IMO)
My question is: why isn't zeke on here? If he didn't say anything in island, he could have won, and he wouldn't have gone feral because he would already have the money he stayed on the plane to get, and wouldn't be as determined to get the money.
my opinion on how the finals should have been: TDI: Leshawna x Duncan TDA: Lindsay x Harold TDWT: Alejandro x Sierra x Heather TDROTI: Brick x Dawn TDAS: Courtney x Scott TDPI: Sugar x Ella RR: Ice Skaters x Sisters TDRS1: Bowie x Priya ✔️ TDRS2: Julia x Damien and all of them deserve at least a scene of them being the winner!! (talking about Bowie and Julia here)
Honestly? Scott was a lot more fun than Heather, Courtney, and Alejandro because he wasn't just a retred of the extreme manipulation or aggressive bullying. that got old REALLY fast. Harold is that person who brags about what he knows and can back it up but because it's constant? The impressiveness wears off. He's the more competent version of Courtney, Joe, and even Heather or Alejandro in some cases.
I never want Courtney to win Season 1. She’s annoying with her CIT Season 2 her lawyer bullshit Season 3 her best but she’s just there Season 5 she’s just bad She’s the worst person of the cast even worst then heather Heather knows she’s mean Courtney doesn’t and that makes her worst
With a lot almost every character in the series they got derailed in someway Ngl with leshawna I was just confused they established LaShawna was kind of becoming friends with Heather in action then suddenly they hate each other again and Scott he’s legit my favorite character and all stars I admit he was funny but like you said he should’ve kept some of his villain intends it would’ve made all stars and more entertaining Season if there was another villain like Scott and Lindsay i’m still confused on my beth made it to the final instead of Lindsay and this is kinda off topic but I love how dramatic the eliminations are with Duncan since duncan is my second favorite character I loved the suspense built up in Lindsay and Justin’s elimination in action and especially with Duncan’s eliminations through out action island and world tour
Glad to see that there are a few people that actually notice that Harold is stronger and more skillful than he looks, as quite a few people think he's weak.
If I'm honest.... I don't like Sierra either and her plot relied heavily on Cody not being capable in a majority of the competition. Which did my boy dirty if I'm honest. I mean if she and Ezekiel had switched roles and Zeke was on the Amazon team, he and Cody would have been seen as the unreliable guys on the team and actually show that they could compete against others and be seen as Equals to strong players like Heather, Courtney and Gwen.
Lindsey was suposed to win one of the series I forgot wich, her voice actor didn't want to do her voice anymore thats why she voted herself out kinda sad
i would love to see Lindsay and Leshawna win, but i have to in world tour heather deserved the win and i don't care if you hate it i was so happy when she won
Also Ciara goes like insane when ever Cody is in trouble so if she used that in challenges for herself she could have fr won ever challnge sigle handly
Opinions on all finale. Island- Perfect Finale. Noo need to change anything Preferred winner- Equal Action- Shoulda been Duncan vs Harold. Beth did not deserve to be a finalist. Preferred winner-Duncan World Tour-Nothing to change here either. Preferred winner-Alejandro Revenge-This finale is good. I don't see any reason to change it. I like Island's more though Preferred winner-Cameron All Stars-Bad finale. This finale was so bland. Zoey and Mike didn't deserve this, mike was carried by Mal(Worst Villain of all time) more than half the season, and Zoey is a bland moron in this season. Overall this season is the worst, so I can hary expect anything from it, but a better finale would be Scott v Courtney Preferred winner-They both stink Pakhitew-This is fine Preferred winner-Shawn RR-Same as pakhitew Preferred winner-Surfers
In pahkitew I want to win Ella,Shawn and Jasmine and In Ridonculous Race I want are the Sisters,Goths, and Tv bros or Ice dancers if you put the pahkitew and ridonculous that's what I want to win on that season
The only total drama season I have watch so far was pahkitew island. To be honest it wasn’t fair and right for the creators of the show to have eliminated sammy to early on the show .. Sammy should have moved on forward and should have became one of the two characters in the semifinals and won the show . I feel like Sammy was robbed in the show not only because the creators decided to eliminated her off the show early , Amy shouldn’t have came back to the show just to get revenged on Sammy on what she did to her …!
The characters that I thought should win 8, LaShawna 7 Justin 6 Dawn 5 brick 4, Jo 3 Harold 2,b 1 Scott the characters I forgot to tell you I wanted to win ava
@@ListsofLegends I would also love to see Lindsay win a season but i don't want to take the win away from Owen,Duncan or Heather so i guess that means that Lindsay is the winner of Total Drama All Stars
if Mal was in total drama revenge of the island mike would of won scott probably wouldnt vote mike because mal is broken hes my favorite character but he did got revenge on scott on all stars
@@onetallpheeesh yeah tv on everything about the show to the point of knowing literally everything about all the characters, while Jasmine on the other hand basically won because of Shawn. Cody didn’t win so she didn’t get anything
Just me but if they didn't derail Dave he would have made it so much farther. Or if they didn't derail scarlet and she was a strategy antagonist Patew would be so much better. Is till rate patiew a B
Yeah he would have made it a little farther but I don’t think he would have made it to the finale with Shawn and Sky being so much more powerful and his love for sky
I think dawn should have won a season I think if they brought her back for all stars there was a lot of stuff they could of done with her character she possibly could of ended up winning that season she possibly could of went up against people like scot or Courtney or leshawna but I guess it’s good they didn’t bring her back since that season was trash
She’s definitely one of my favorite characters for sure just wish she could have done more in revenge of the island if they ever did have a new season with the og characters would love to see her in a more better role
@@ListsofLegends yea I think they booted her and B of to quickly I get that they had to get rid of B since he didn’t talk but dawn could of at least made it to the merge
Oh yeah theory mal is mikes old self until mike came along because how else could mal gain control over mike revenge of the island wasnt fair for mike mal only return because of mike when he gets angry inside so he resort to mal
Apologize for the few editing mistakes, this heat is taking its toll on me lol
I think Lindsey in action felt as she learns from her mistakes and i agree that she should have won a season because she had the development just right. But i think season 3 should have been the season she should have won in. Mainly because having her win in season 3 would surprise many people. Because having her win season 3 would actually make sense.
I hate how All stars ruined characters like Lindsay, Jo, Heather, Sierra, Duncan, Alejandro, Courtney and Gwen
@@iludhuka1211 by far they DESTROYED their character
List of Legends I was thinking about it; Courtney and Harold become finalists. Courtney wins for herself and Lindsay beacuse the were both bullied by heather and If Harold and Leshawna became a thing again, Harold wins for Leshawna. So Everyone wins. 😁Courtney and Harold would most likely split the money😄
BUT YOUR PFP IS FIRE
Not to mention that Harold was basically the protagonist of Action in my opinion. They built this rivalry/friendship with Duncan and it was so good. Only to eliminate him instead of Owen for no reason and do nothing with it.
Yeah Harold flat out should have been the one to go in
You forgot Lindsay's development
Ngl Harold should've won
@@kingmasterboi1163 i think so too, but fanservice was the writers priority.
@@nicks.857 Mostly because Duncan's the writers' favorite/second favorite. And I think Beth was there as a replacement to Lindsay, showing that Lindsay was going to win the rest of the challenges and then win and befriend Duncan (which makes more sense) but maybe it's her VA...
1. Courtney
2. Leshawna(who does a lot btw, she was even the first to win a challenge on her own during the merge- I have no idea what you mean when she says she doesn’t do too much, especially compared to the people you put higher than her)
3. Harold
4. Lindsay
5. Scott
6.Sierra
7. Jasmine
8. Dj
Honorable mentions
Brick
Noah
She’s certainly a team player for sure I was meaning in terms of strategic moments overall but her being on the list I definitely think she deserves a win 🏆
@@ListsofLegends oh okay, I sort of know what you mean now
For me I would have
8. Dawn
7. Cody
6. B
5. Noah
4. Lindsay
3. Ella
2. DJ
1.Harold
@@langdonledwig3734 very nice 👍🏽
@@langdonledwig3734 I disagree with dawn, B and ella. Sure they are all decent characters, but none of them have had the character development needed. Dawn is one of the most overrated contestants of all
LeShawna deserved number 6 or 7. She was not only strong in challenges, but she also was the best social player in TDI, and her strategic game was on point. She was way better than most of the people on this list. (Brick, Lindsay, Justin, Harold, and Sierra)
She was certainly a strong player I was just meaning more in terms of strategic moments but no question I was glad to put her on the list
@@ListsofLegends So by that you are saying the Lindsay, Brick, Harold, and Justin were more strategic than LeShawna. I’ve rest my case. Also the video was “Top 8 Total Drama Characters That Should Have Won a Season” not “Top 8 TD characters with the best strategy that never won.
@Bara Bro she made up for it chill. Why are you making this like Survivor?
Na she wasn't as good as Sierra
Brick really deserved to win a season and I’m just shocked that he wasn’t in Total Drama All Stars, I thought he was the best character in the entire Total Drama
Literally exactly lol
Somehow Joe makes it or Sam but him not.. weird
Imagine Ezekiel winning a season. Going from being first out in every season he participated in to winning a season. That would rule lol
Based off that gag ya lol
I feel bad for Scott, he was completely separated from his whole body in ROTI. Now I wonder how did he get his body back for All Stars?
The magic of total drama
Lindsay and Duncan shouldve been the F2 of Action & Courtney and Scott for All Stars
Yeah I don’t understand why they chose Beth instead
I’m pretty sure it’s because Lindsays voice actor had a family emergency during action, so they had to rewrite and cut her plot short, and had to rewrite someone else to win besides Duncan. But I’m pretty sure she was supposed to win.
@@itz_lizzyy Wrong character. Apparently it was Leshawna's actor in Island that had a family emergency, which is why her elimination was forced.
@@someguydoingthingsNo, it was known by a long time, Lindsay and Harold were supposed to be Final 2 in Action
Harold was cut because they thought Duncan would do more than him
Lindsay was cut due to a family emergency
Here 10 characters that i think should have won a season
10. Sammy - it's mainly because she can build up as someone who feels more happy when she lasts long in the game. Even if amy was part of the final two with her. This would be an interesting plot of manipulated grows a backbone.
9. Dawn - she was robbed. Give her a break
8. Leshawna - the furthest she got was in island. And i wish she won the game without anyone manipulating the elimination. (Looking at chris,courtney and al)
7. DJ - i feel bad for the dude
6. Jo - she felt hard working enough to make it to 5th place of season 4. Makes you wish she won.
5. Brick - a dumbass with a big heart would be pretty cool to have as a winner.
4. Lindsay - she might be an idiot but she started learning from her mistakes in season 2. And the writers forgot about it.
3. Harold - he would be a perfect winner. Mainly because of how he is smart enough to make it to 5th place in action
2. Izzy - she is pretty neutral chaotic in alignments. She is silly. But we had a couple of people like her win before.
1. Serra - it would be perfect for her to just win total drama and just being in heaven because it would motivate people that you got to earn your dreams fairly.
I saw this on Reddit and this is my new head cannon on why Lindsay got out first in All-Stars
Remember that quote she said in Ep22 if she knew about that resort thing she would’ve booted herself out in the first episode
And All-Stars is the only other season that takes place at Wawanakwa(that she was a cast in)and she did what she said she would in Island
Another one would be in episode 1 of all stars where she says “ I never thought I’d say this no lip gloss is worth this” it sort of implies she doesn’t want to continue
i dont buy it but... yeah i guess
Yeah but they have All-Star bonus clips that show she was flushed to New York
My list:
#8: Dawn
#7: Eva (No joke, I see her with redemption)
#6: Sierra
#5: Noah
#4: Jasmine
#3: Brick
#2: Bridgette
#1: Leshawna
Honorable mentions: Courtney, Jo, Emma, Kitty, Lindsay, Trent, Cody, Sammy, B, DJ, Harold, & Ella
The fact that all of these are characters I like lol
Yes! Finally someone who gives Eva respect!
I know she has a soft spot in her, she just doesn't like to show it (Proof, is because when she got too violent with having revenge on Justin, she apologized, so that shows something). So there's something about her...
I don't agree on Dawn she didn't do anything outstanding in roti she is My favourite roti character but she doesn't really deserve to win and if its the argument of she got robbed then b got robbed even harder and was a beast in challenges and would've Been a serious threat if he made merge plus even Scott saw how much of a threat he was that's why he was eliminated so early
That took a while to make and Btw no hate 😅
In my opinion Cody should should have won one season I mean not only would it be the ultimate underdog story he has shown that he can do some things other than challenges, in world tour not once was he thought to be a beast at the game which means nobody would try to get him out and we've seen on both seasons with Trent and on most people in world tour he can build trust in relationships easy and in the first season he got robbed I would like to see him win
Yeah he’s a great underdog
Cody should have won a Season
They should've kept it the same, but include him in all stars and have him win/runner up.
in action i REALLY wanted to see courtney and duncan get to the finale just to see what would happen tbh
I did too
@@ListsofLegends That would have been basically impossible, Courtney couldn't have made finale being carried by her lawyers
Personally here's my opinion on who should have won each season
TDI - I'm actually okay with this one
TDA - Harold/Lindsey/Courtney VS Duncan
TDWT - Again I'm okay with this one
TDROTI - probably Brick VS Joe
TDAS - Courtney VS Scott or Cameron VS Cody If Cody ever made it into the season
Top 8 characters who should have won season (IMO)
8th: Sierra
7th: Jasmine
6th: Lindsay
5th: Brick
4th: Harold
3rd: Emma and Kitty
2nd: Leshawna
Honourable mentions: Bridgette, DJ, Anne Maria, Jo, Cody
1st: Scott
Scott and Dawn would've been pretty good, or if we're going with both being males like on canon ROTI then Scott vs B would've been cool
Cody would have won wt if sierra didn’t blow up the plane. If Sierra and Cody were the final 2, I think Chris would do something to turn Sierra against Cody so she’d try to win
Three words
LINDSAY AND LESHAWNA!!!
Definitely agree I’m team Lindsay lol
If we're talking Pahkitew, I honestly would love for Samey/Sammy to win a season if only because she deserves something to feel good about after dealing with Amy's bullshit for so long. And even though her biggest strategic move was against her twin, it still proves she has a cutthroat side to her and could definitely make it pretty far in the show as long as she's not focused on literally just surviving Amy's abuse.
I wouldn’t be opposed to that underdog for the win kinda thing
@@ListsofLegends I love a good underdog story, honestly, and if anybody would and should be the star of an underdog story, it's definitely her. I don't know who she'd be in the finale with, but she should definitely make sure Amy is eliminated either as soon as possible or right before the finale.
Omg I would love to see some of theese characters win a season, like Sierra that would be so funny
Sierra's one of my favorite characters that i thought she would've made merge in All Stars
Lot of disappointment in all stars that’s for sure lol
WE DONT TALK ABOUT ALL STARS
@@OneAndOnly_Howii Yes.
Team amazon is the best team the chemistry when singing all of them did great this season since they survive elimination till ep 15 and 3 of them making into finale is a winner material
Very true, world tour was god tier
It was episode 16, and only 1 of them made the finale.
@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 episode 16 Gwen gets eliminated and by mean that final is final four with Sierra,Cody,Heather and Alejandro
@@rheynherrera4232 ok
No, Team Victory should have always had those reward challenges or none eliminations.
I also think Sierra deserved to win but I also think she would've gotten voted out just by being annoying haha
I personally think she was extremely lucky on world tour being on team amazon and in the merge everyone else was just targeted except her
(Blainely, Courtney, Duncan, Owen)
also for some reason I can't remember 1 thing about all stars even though i know I've watched it(i know scott and courtney were together but anything other than that i forgot)
going to rewatch it and see if she performs pretty well there
TDI: Trent
TDA: Justin
TDWT: Duncan
TDROTI: Brick
TDAS: Scott
TDPI: Topher
TDRR: Rock&Spud
Duncan Won Season 2
@@bfdixiifan These are my preference. I want Justin against Harold/Lindsay as i want Duncan against Alejandro on s3
@@duncan3998 Oh OK
I feel like Zeke should have won a season (hear me out) I feel like the main reason people dislike Ezekiel is because we never got to see him grow, he was always booted first and barley got any screen time, he had potential especially in world tour I mean he was the only character to be booted first twice and at that point why would they even bring him back, he could have went from first boot in island to 1st place in world tour undergoing a MASSIVE character arc, I feel like feral Zeke was a really dumb idea because the writers took a character with huge potential and turned him into a LOTR reference. People say that Zeke wasn't qualified for TD and while that is kinda true I still would have loved to see his character grow into something more than a meme
there's only two things i don't like
his sexist learning's
and he's annoying srry he would make it far but not win
YES. I have the same opinion. He only came to the show to help his parents, try to adapt to his vitamin D deficiency and try to socialize more. He only made that sexist comments because his father thaught that. And if the other contestants listened and corrected him, he could have gotten, at most, five episodes further.
If they didn’t turn him into a zombie/meme and gave him more screen time and character development, yeah most definitely!
I heard that they tried to make a running Gag with him always getting eliminated first and they turned him into a feral freakshow because some Ezekiel Fans harassed the Producers or the Writers
And why the fuck was Ezekiel not on the list
I actually think Geoff deserved a win at some point. The dude was a beast in many challenges and was constantly showing his caring and kind side to many other characters. He was eliminated 6th or 5th place in Island ONLY due to his kindness, Duncan even admitted if they didn’t vote him off there, he possibly could’ve made it to the final 4 or even higher.
In Action I wished they never did the whole double elimination thing and instead let Geoff stick around. I would’ve loved to see how far he would’ve gone in that season.
After that he was only ever in the spin-off race season where he was the Alternative winner.
At the end of the day I wish they would’ve given us more Geoff and see more development from him to actually win a season. I think he deserved at least a finals appearance.
Good thing he won RR
He won ridonculous race in an alternate ending
@@Mimi._.Haruno_ I mentioned that
@@Trottskee oh, I didn't read the whole thing just skimmed through it 💀
@@Mimi._.Haruno_ it’s all good! Thank you though. I just wish Geoff was given an actual cannon win. If that makes sense?
I think Justin should have been in wt and had a rivalry with Alejandro. That would have been interesting.
My thoughts exactly lol
@@ListsofLegends ye
Didn't see the vid yet, but my top3 is Courtney, Lindsay and Leshawna.
Noah should've been on this list. I would've like to see him win a season
He’s in my underrated characters list at least lol
@@ListsofLegends that's cool but it still would've been cool to see Noah win a season. I wouldn't say he's underrated since he's a fan favorite but I think he's the most wasted potential of a character as he should've gotten more screentime and could've been a villain.
Leshawna has way more strategic moments than nearly everyone you put above her? In my opinion, I think you should rematch the season because she was by far the 2nd most strategic player in island
I disagree but that’s just my opinion
Season 2 Lindsay had her highest peak she had a lot of smart moments but then they dropped them once season 3 came!
I will love to see leshawn vs DJ. Izzy vs brick and Lindsay v harold
Heck ya
1st round leshawna wins second round izzy wins 3rd round lindsay
i was working on this season plan and it was a three way finale. Lindsay vs Leshawna vs DJ
@@DJEKEA89f were talking about how they would do I would say leshawna would win then brick would win and then harold since Lindsay is too stupid
If*
Here's my way of the Total Drama finals (including RR)
Island: Same (Owen VS Gwen)
Owen wins
Action: Lindsay VS Harold
Lindsay wins
World Tour: Alejandro VS Ezekiel
Ezekiel wins
Revenge of the Island: Lightning VS Scott
Lightning wins
All Stars: Leshawna VS Courtney
Leshawna wins
Pahkitew Island: Same (Shawn VS Sky)
Sky wins
Ridonculous Race: The Sisters VS The Stepbrothers
The sisters win
dont forget about alt endings
Very nice! I’m not a fan of zeek they basically kept using the zeek gag and made him a zombie other than that very good!
@@ListsofLegends
I also made my way of All Stars, including the Pahkitew cast, with 16 players on each team:
Heroic Hamsters: Mike, Zoey, Cameron, Courtney, Lindsay, Sierra, Noah, Owen, Rodney, Brick, Beardo, Leshawna, Harold, Tyler, Cody and Ezekiel
Villanous Vultures: Eva, Sky, Dave, Max, Sugar, Topher, Alejandro, Justin, Heather, Jo, Scott, Lightning, Duncan, Gwen, Anne Maria and Izzy
Yes, i'm still putting Courtney as a hero and Gwen as a villain, and on this version, All Stars is after Pahkitew. Some characters like Zeke, Rodney or Beardo are on this list because on this alternative universe, they had big character developments.
For me
Island: Duncan vs Gwen
Gwen wins
Action: Lindsay vs Trent (since Island focused on Gwen, I'd have Action focus on Trent)
Lindsay wins
World Tour: Same as the show, Heather wins
Revenge of the Island: Brick vs Dawn (but I'd have Jo at the final three)
Dawn wins
All-Stars: Courtney vs Leshawna
Leshawna wins
Pahkitew Island: Jasmine vs Sky
Jasmine wins
Ridonculous Race (three alternate endings)
Goths vs Sisters vs Reality TV Pros
Goths win
@@aquaig Interesting
I was thinking Dawn before the last character you shown. 🤯
I love dawn! Even put her on my most underrated characters list but lot of people pointed out to me that she doesn’t do much which is unfortunately is true in my opinion now, if she returned one day and they give her more screen time and a better role most definitely
Mine is:
Leshawna
Lindsay
Courtney
Harold
Tyler
Noah
Justin
Bridgette
DJ
Jo
Scott
Brick
Dawn
B
Jasmine
Scarlett (without her evil shape)
Great video! I would add Trent, Samey, Tyler, Bridgette, Dakota, Dawn, and DJ
Thank you! Would love to see all of them come back
Amazing video and a very interestingtopic. You mentioned many things nobody did before.
Maybe a bit to many contestants in my opinion, i don't agree on Justin for example.
That’s alright, thanks for sharing! And yeah sorry lol top 8 is my thing for the most part there just people on the list I think could have won a season
Justin is in my top 10 characters because he is so funny and underestimating
I also love Sierra and she is my 3rd favorite character and also deserves the win
@@bradytallent8269 deserves yes
Tyler and Cody should have been in Action
Agreed 👍🏻
Leshawna deserved that reward, she solved the challenge.
heres who shouldve been the REAL finalists:
s1: izzy & geoff
s2: harold & duncan
s3: sierra & ezekiel
s4: staci & lightning
s5: scott & sam
s6: leonard & max
s7: tennis rivals & stepbrothers
s8: zee & scary girl
s9: ripper & damien
now for the first boots:
s1: gwen
s2: leshawna & heather
s3: cody
s4: anne maria
s5: zoey
s6: jasmine
s7: sisters
s8: bowie
s9: priya
I have to agree with most of your choices. seeing as most of them had more personality than some of the actual winners. I really think Leshawna would have been in the top 4 or maybe higher if they hadn't eliminated her the way they did. Can you imagine her in Gwen's place during the Dare chalIenge? I was just waiting for her and Heather to get in a true brawl and Heather get the snot beat out of her in Island. I would probably add DJ and Izzy myself. I do agree with you on Pahkitew Island in that most of the characters were boring. Jasmine and Ella were about the only two who were interesting at all. I think it should have come down to Jasmine vs Skye in the finale.
Most people might disagree but I would like Scott to win
My Top 8 characters that should win a season:
8.Harold
7.Sierra
6.Katie
5.Leshawna
4.Lindsay
3.DJ
2.Tyler
1.Cody
Great List 😀
mi top:
1-lindsay
2-cody
3-jasmine
4-leshawna
5-samey
6-brick
7-harold
8-bridgette
9-crimson o ennui
10-tom o jen
p.d: ojala courtney nunca gane quien la aguanta despues presumiendo y menospreciando al resto, como maximo a los 3 finalistas
Great list
My Top 8:
8: Lindsay
7: Justin
6: Tyler
5: Noah
4: Brick
3: Harold
2: LeShawna
1: Courtney
Love it
My list is Courtney, Leshawna, Lindsay, Scott, Harold, Justin, Bridgette and Jo is my list
Great list!
@@ListsofLegends I just realised I said my list twice-
“lashawna”💀💀💀💀
Yes bro
i'm surprised you didn't mention B at all. man was the MVP for all the challenges he competed in.....to the point where Scott was threatened by him and had to take him out. Otherwise he would've won (at least IMO)
I did in my characters who should have been in all stars but got a lot of hate for it personally I love B one of my favorites for sure
Ezekiel should win a season
Hmmm
My question is: why isn't zeke on here? If he didn't say anything in island, he could have won, and he wouldn't have gone feral because he would already have the money he stayed on the plane to get, and wouldn't be as determined to get the money.
Lindsay should’ve definitely won TDA!
I wish
Same
Unpopular pick: izzy
mr coconut shouldve won
Yeah most definitely
My list
1 leshawna
2 brick
3 Lindsay
4 Harold
5 Scott
6 dj
7 jasmine
8 Noah
9 dawn
10 Sammy
Great list
my opinion on how the finals should have been:
TDI: Leshawna x Duncan
TDA: Lindsay x Harold
TDWT: Alejandro x Sierra x Heather
TDROTI: Brick x Dawn
TDAS: Courtney x Scott
TDPI: Sugar x Ella
RR: Ice Skaters x Sisters
TDRS1: Bowie x Priya ✔️
TDRS2: Julia x Damien
and all of them deserve at least a scene of them being the winner!! (talking about Bowie and Julia here)
Useless fact: Beardo's design is based on a microphone.
Haha very much so
Honestly? Scott was a lot more fun than Heather, Courtney, and Alejandro because he wasn't just a retred of the extreme manipulation or aggressive bullying. that got old REALLY fast.
Harold is that person who brags about what he knows and can back it up but because it's constant? The impressiveness wears off. He's the more competent version of Courtney, Joe, and even Heather or Alejandro in some cases.
1:28 but the same could be said about Courtney. Duncan split his tda winnings with her
Yes that is true but I was saying Jasmine and Shawn because it was confirmed on screen
@@ListsofLegends ok
I never want Courtney to win
Season 1. She’s annoying with her CIT
Season 2 her lawyer bullshit
Season 3 her best but she’s just there
Season 5 she’s just bad
She’s the worst person of the cast even worst then heather
Heather knows she’s mean
Courtney doesn’t and that makes her worst
In Island she was more of team player but then they kind of escalated her into a new Heather
Harold, our lord and saviour
Is That at 0:15 real Or is it fan made cause this just looks real?
It’s real, it’s in the first world tour aftermath episode (i don’t remember what it’s called tho)
I feel Like Noah Should have won world Tour, but that's just my opinion
He’s definitely got the brain power haha
Yeah Sierra deserves to win!
With a lot almost every character in the series they got derailed in someway Ngl with leshawna I was just confused they established LaShawna was kind of becoming friends with Heather in action then suddenly they hate each other again and Scott he’s legit my favorite character and all stars I admit he was funny but like you said he should’ve kept some of his villain intends it would’ve made all stars and more entertaining Season if there was another villain like Scott and Lindsay i’m still confused on my beth made it to the final instead of Lindsay and this is kinda off topic but I love how dramatic the eliminations are with Duncan since duncan is my second favorite character I loved the suspense built up in Lindsay and Justin’s elimination in action and especially with Duncan’s eliminations through out action island and world tour
Yeah unfortunately they’re pretty good at character regression some more than others that’s for sure.
Hope my boi Scott makes it
I think you’ll be happy lol
DJ deserved to win more than most people on this list especially Courtney and Serria
I think leshwana Courtney should have won at least one of them
100% agreed
9:46 Yeah Sierra should return and Won!!!
She def put lota work in that season
Glad to see that there are a few people that actually notice that Harold is stronger and more skillful than he looks, as quite a few people think he's weak.
Yeah I hate the Harold downplay it’s so undeserved
I kinda agree with all of these tbh
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
If I'm honest.... I don't like Sierra either and her plot relied heavily on Cody not being capable in a majority of the competition. Which did my boy dirty if I'm honest. I mean if she and Ezekiel had switched roles and Zeke was on the Amazon team, he and Cody would have been seen as the unreliable guys on the team and actually show that they could compete against others and be seen as Equals to strong players like Heather, Courtney and Gwen.
Lindsey was suposed to win one of the series I forgot wich, her voice actor didn't want to do her voice anymore thats why she voted herself out kinda sad
Heard many stories about it but all seems to point to that
Fr i dont like harrold courtney scott justin and Sierra
Where is jo?
the new season the final i hope would be a courtney vs harold
One day lol
My opinion:
Charactters that should have won are:
Dawn
Leshawna
Dawn
Brick
Dawn
Lindsay
Dawm
Izzy
Dawn
Brick 100% should have won
@@ListsofLegends Agreed
leshawna should have won and be in all stars
i would love to see Lindsay and Leshawna win, but i have to in world tour heather deserved the win and i don't care if you hate it i was so happy when she won
I’d like to see a final 2 with Lindsay and Courtney or Harold and Courtney oo or Duncan vs Courtney or Duncan vs Harold
I hope to see that one day
You have my bros name in the into it’s the number eight 🤣
Haha 😂
It’s like Total Drama is in a coma right now! Where is the info about the new seasons?
They’re definitely keeping things quiet
@@ListsofLegends I'm actually very impressed. Usually, shows leak something by now
I think:
Island=OWEN (2nd Leshawna)
Action=LINDSAY (2nd Courtney)
World Tour=HEATHER (2nd Alejandro), nothing change
ROTI=CAMERON (2nd Dawn)
All Stars=ALEJANDRO (2nd Scott)
Pakitew=SHAWN (2nd Sky), nothing change
Nice!!
tysm for spoilers bae 🤪🤪
@@jaykis9143 lol
Also Ciara goes like insane when ever Cody is in trouble so if she used that in challenges for herself she could have fr won ever challnge sigle handly
If you put that way ya she kicks serious butt lol
Opinions on all finale.
Island- Perfect Finale. Noo need to change anything
Preferred winner- Equal
Action- Shoulda been Duncan vs Harold. Beth did not deserve to be a finalist.
Preferred winner-Duncan
World Tour-Nothing to change here either.
Preferred winner-Alejandro
Revenge-This finale is good. I don't see any reason to change it. I like Island's more though
Preferred winner-Cameron
All Stars-Bad finale. This finale was so bland. Zoey and Mike didn't deserve this, mike was carried by Mal(Worst Villain of all time) more than half the season, and Zoey is a bland moron in this season. Overall this season is the worst, so I can hary expect anything from it, but a better finale would be Scott v Courtney
Preferred winner-They both stink
Pakhitew-This is fine
Preferred winner-Shawn
RR-Same as pakhitew
Preferred winner-Surfers
For me I would have liked to see Heather in Island finale (alternate universe where WT finale still exists)
In pahkitew I want to win Ella,Shawn and Jasmine and In Ridonculous Race I want are the Sisters,Goths, and Tv bros or Ice dancers if you put the pahkitew and ridonculous that's what I want to win on that season
The only total drama season I have watch so far was pahkitew island.
To be honest it wasn’t fair and right for the creators of the show to have eliminated sammy to early on the show ..
Sammy should have moved on forward and should have became one of the two characters in the semifinals and won the show .
I feel like Sammy was robbed in the show not only because the creators decided to eliminated her off the show early , Amy shouldn’t have came back to the show just to get revenged on Sammy on what she did to her …!
The characters that I thought should win 8, LaShawna 7 Justin 6 Dawn 5 brick 4, Jo 3 Harold 2,b 1 Scott the characters I forgot to tell you I wanted to win ava
Great list
@@ListsofLegends thanks
The Finale of Total Drama Action should have been Duncan vs Harold
Fr lol
@@ListsofLegends I would also love to see Lindsay win a season but i don't want to take the win away from Owen,Duncan or Heather so i guess that means that Lindsay is the winner of Total Drama All Stars
Ezekiel deserves won
He definitely shouldn’t have been treated like a zombie/meme that’d for sure
Lindsey is funny dumb, that’s why she is definitely one of the best characters in total drama history
By far yes, all hail queen Lindsay
Cody should have won World Tour
Izzy
Lindsay
LeShawna
Bridgette
Harold
Emma and Kitty
Dawn
He’s an underdog for sure
Heather actually won World Tour so that considers she won a season
Very true
if Mal was in total drama revenge of the island mike would of won scott probably wouldnt vote mike because mal is broken hes my favorite character but he did got revenge on scott on all stars
If Mal was in revenge of the island that would be interesting might make a video out of it
Courtney should’ve won Total Drama
Fax
ok that sam thing was not villainous if you were playing dodgeball and were getting hit ya your going to use a human shield everyone has done it.
Okay you have a point there imao
Jasmine belongs on this list.
Yall just haters.
I did want to include her but it would be pointless because she made a deal to split the million with Shawn no matter who won which he did
@@ListsofLegends but you included Sierra because she watches TV lol
@@onetallpheeesh yeah tv on everything about the show to the point of knowing literally everything about all the characters, while Jasmine on the other hand basically won because of Shawn. Cody didn’t win so she didn’t get anything
I agree on Justin for rr that’s whAt I thought😊
Yeah I like him in action but he definitely could have been so much more of a threat
I agree but he’s still my fourth favorite
@@HunterBATLightning I love Justin for sure would love to see him return with Alejandro RR 2
Check out mystic dream catchers r 2
@@HunterBATLightning I do hear he has great content for sure :)
Just me but if they didn't derail Dave he would have made it so much farther. Or if they didn't derail scarlet and she was a strategy antagonist Patew would be so much better. Is till rate patiew a B
Yeah he would have made it a little farther but I don’t think he would have made it to the finale with Shawn and Sky being so much more powerful and his love for sky
I think dawn should have won a season I think if they brought her back for all stars there was a lot of stuff they could of done with her character she possibly could of ended up winning that season she possibly could of went up against people like scot or Courtney or leshawna but I guess it’s good they didn’t bring her back since that season was trash
She’s definitely one of my favorite characters for sure just wish she could have done more in revenge of the island if they ever did have a new season with the og characters would love to see her in a more better role
@@ListsofLegends yea I think they booted her and B of to quickly I get that they had to get rid of B since he didn’t talk but dawn could of at least made it to the merge
@@hotdogwater2770 she should have got more screen time that’s for sure
Oh yeah theory mal is mikes old self until mike came along because how else could mal gain control over mike revenge of the island wasnt fair for mike mal only return because of mike when he gets angry inside so he resort to mal
Great take on that it’s possible