The reason why Yeri looks "bigger" compared to others despite her having the same thin arms and legs is: 1. The stylist does not know how to style her body. 2. Yeri has big breasts but with a flat stomach so when the stylists give her "baggy" crop tops it seems like she's really big. 3. Yeri has an apple shape body.
She also has a wide waist, this isn’t very desired and can often make you look heavier than you actually are. But no matter how much she exercises she can’t change her bone structure
It's because we couldn't deny that she looked alarmingly skinny at a short amount of time. As for her thicker side, it wasn't even bad. I think she's gotten more stable
And she expressed how she was scared of gaining too much weight I think she said something along the lines of " people love me more when I'm thin " so it seems she's developed the same mentality as someone with an eating disorder
@@kimjisoo8689 LITERALLY i hate when so called "fans" or fans from other groups try to call out a member or MULTIPLE members for quote on quote "copying" other groups that their literally friends with.
Why the heck are all the comments about there body types and arguing about hourglass figure? It doesn't really matter, they're all beautiful no matter what 😤💗
I'm sorry but Irene is not an hourglass... And especially not a 'defined' one, as you said. I'd say she is either inverted triangle or rectangle. Her waist isn't small enough compared to her hips to be considered hourglass.
@@remolachin34 Actually no. Many Idols have a inverted triangle type of body, where their shoulder are more prominent than their hips. For example, BlackPink girls... only Jisoo has a rectangle type of body, while the other three are triangle type. Stylist has the job to make them look like they have hourglass body. That's why ChungHa (another example) good look so good, or why Rosé didn't look good with so clothes she wear by a stylist (while when she choose her own clothes she looks like she has hourglass body). That's why probably many Idols don't look good on certain type of clothes or colors, because their stylist are not doing correctly the job.
hoebi hoebi kinda but at the same time her waist in peek-a-boo era wasn’t as big as in dumb dumb era. She always looked good no matter in which era but I feel like in she was extremely attractive in umpah umpah to psycho era like woah she was looking soooo good🤯. Maybe it has sth to do with confidence🤷🏼♀️
RV stylists have always done yeri and joy dirty. Yeri never gets flattering clothes, its like the stylist doesn't even care she has a different body shape they just dress her the same as the other members who look completely different. The stylists also treat Joy like a sex object not a person, the number of times shes had to pull down her short dresses during performances where the other members are all wearing pants is appalling
Yeri has a natural wide structure so she’s probably is at her thinnest. I’m 5’4 but I have broader shoulders and have wide hips so I naturally have a hour glass shape and even when I was at my thinnest I still looked “bigger” so I don’t think people should hate on her she’s beautiful ❤️
Same. Irene's waist doesn’t seem to be at least 8inches smaller than her hips so she isn’t an hourglass but a rectangle in my opinion The nearest would be Seulgi since she has a tiny waist and a bit larger hips but her shoulders are bigger than her hips so she’s not really an hourglass but an inverted triangle.
I saw a video that said Seulgi had an hourglass shape and I forgot who it was but I think they said Joy had inverted triangle shape. But I think Seulgi does have a bit of an hourglass shape and it really shows when she wears dresses that fit/‘hug’ her body and I kinda see it but that’s just my opinion.
@@danicaseymore1047 not exactly she, doesn't have any curves not something bad when she doesn't but sometimes I notice she wears hippads or push-ups that must be why she sometimes looks like a hourglass or rectangle shape.
The reason why peeps bash on Irene’s proportions is because she isn’t (she isn’t hourglass either). Her legs a very short which is why her stylist dress her in short everything to make them appear longer
For me, the thinnest era for Seulgi was in Russian roulette and Rookie. And the thickest era is Psycho for the same reasons, her look like they have gained some muscles and also you can notice that her booty. She is body goals fr
Wendy honestly has never been “big” ever. She looks bigger than she is when she gains weight because the weight gain tends to happen in her legs and her face bloats a bit. Even looking at her when she was at her thickest point her abdominal area was thin. With Yeri her limbs have always been really thin. She just doesn't have a super defined waist-line plus there’s the fact that she has a fuller chest that the stylists don’t really know how to flatter. With Irene I don’t understand the proportion bashing. She’s short yes. Her legs are a pretty average length for her height but she has a really thin waist and small head.
Dumb Dumb was everyone's era because they looked soooo good! They were a healthy thicc size and I loved how energetic they were on stage. Not to say them slimming is bad, I just want them to be happy and comfortable with their bodies.
Seulgi is naturally thin, but she's been able to gain some serious muscle which is really impressive. Also love the Double Toasted gif in Irene's section lol.
wendy's weight had stabilized starting from power up...and then her accident happened. I hope people don't give her any shit for her changes in weight after she makes her full return.
I have the same body shape that Irene has- which isn’t an hourglass but rather a column. The difference in hourglass and column is the waist to hip ratio. The column body shape can often be mistaken for an hourglass but a true hourglass has a very noticeable difference between waist and hip. Columns often look like hourglass with a slightly bigger waist. The column body shape can also sometimes be mistaken for an inverted triangle body shape depending on how skinny/ thiCC u are ^-~
Omg I finally know the name of the body type i have ty! I couldn't figure out if a was an inverted triangle or hourglass cause I fit some characteristics but not all
Seulgi looks like an hourglass when she had more weight on her bones , it seems she gains weight around her hip area so her body shape appears to change depending on her weight
Netizens want too much out of Idols. How can you tell Seulgi or Irene of all people their bodies aren't proportional? It's clear they want a PERFECT image while not even reflecting that themselves. All the members would have found the dieting/exercising they're comfortable with if it wasn't for SBS. We know how hard recovering it's going to be for Wendy and to have to then factor in dieting and exercising? I hope she doesn't quit. It sounds like A LOT for one person.
seulgi's excellent weight maintainance is a huge relief for me... a lot of my friends asume she must be unhealthy due to how thin she is. however, considering that her weight hasnt changed for years i dont think thats the case! her bone structure must be small, and her metabolism must be high. imo if she was unnaturally underweight (by not eating enough), there would be periods of slight weight gain and loss, right? it conforts me, as a fan
Irene is definitely an inverted triangle and to me she looked thickest during debut to ICC then she slimmed down. I think the groups thickest era was Happiness and Dumb Dumb. Their thinnest was definitely Red Flavor, RBB, and Russian Roulette. Now I’d say they all found a way to manage their weights bc their bodies haven’t changed much since RBB and they all look great!
@美珠 I hate when ppl say that a person doesn’t naturally have a body like them bc I do have such a body and I eat like a pig 🐷 Please don’t overwork yourself and remember there’s only one person in the world with a specific body so you won’t look exactly like one of them and no one will look like you. I wish you good luck on your journey. You have all my moral support ❤️❤️❤️❤️
S D，Thanks for your concern. I know some people try to achieve their body goals through dangerous methods... I am already skinny, but I want the muscle definition Lisa has ☺️
@美珠 I’m glad you care about your healthy first. And me too girl like I am skinny but I need more muscles but everything is closed and not safe right now so I can’t go to the gym😔
Out of all the members of Red Velvet - when Wendy trains her body hard...damn her abs - its like 11 line abs. She needs to drop a workout routine quick
people disagree with saying hourglass coz they’re thinking of curvy Kim kardashian types but Irene is hourglass for a skinny person that’s her natural line. The Instagram skinny people who are more are probably photoshopped/rib removed. Compare her to another skinny person yeri who is not hourglass
No Kim doesn't have an hourglass, an hourglass is when the shoulders and hips align with a defined waist, which none of them have, but some do have a softness and curvature from waist to hips that trick a person like Seulgi but her shoulders are broader than her hips, shes like a soft inverted triangle
an hourglass figure is when your waist is small and your hips are larger, Irene doesn't have that figure bc her waist and hips aren't that different from each other
It makes me sad that netizens keep body shaming Joy. Like, she has the perfect body!! I envy her every time I see her bc she has the perfect body : not too skinny and just the right amount of meat on the bones lol it sounds creepy to put it like that but I dont wanna call it fat. Any was she is body goals and I wish I had her body :(((
They were just a beautiful and happy girls in that era but because the hate comments about their body they starting to lose weight. The knetizens even called them Pig Velvet, I'm so mad with that but if they're happy with their actual bodies I'm happy for them too
It really upsets me how stylists dress yeri. The clothes they choose almost always aren’t appropriate for her body type, they make her body look bigger than how it really is, I mean you are right, in peek-a-boo era stylists finally dressed her correctly and she looked amazing
Yeri’s body type is rare bc she has a wide rib cage and big breasts so this makes her appear bigger even if she may not be. We should learn from Yeri bc she has said that instead of going on extreme diets she is switching to a more healthy and balanced diet along with doing exercise such as pilates. Its a gradual weight loss but it is a healthy one!
In Korea it is a bad thing, because the way feminism is shown makes it look bad. Feminism is just equal rights for women but some “feminists” just made it all about hating men
I have no idea how idols get shamed for weight gain. I’m a big girl and it makes me insecure hearing people comment on how these girls gain weight, even though they look healthy.
Ireeeeene 😍😍 I don't really care with the rumors of her bad attitude everyone has a bad side!! I love her smile so much it brightens up my dayyy.. so cute so cute!!
I think they all looked healthy in all eras but maybe Wendy during the red flavor era was a bit shocking for me cause she was thin during the dumb dumb era too in my opinion.
I personally don’t think that Seulgi is skinny because of a good “management”, not saying that she eats bad tho, but i really believe that she and Irene have a skinny complexion, I’ve never seen them more chubbier or skinnier, they look always the same, maybe it’s just me but i think that:)
people in the comments really think hourglass has to do with bigger bodies that have boobs & butt? no. it's bone structure. Irene is an hourglass because her hips and shoulder stretch out to the same length and her waist goes inward. Seulgi is more of a pear in my opinion, but i digress. you don't need to be thick to be an hourglass. stay mad.
say what you want about bad boy, but no one can deny that the stylists didn’t come through with flattering amazing outfits that were unique to each members body type and made them look so good for every stage/promo
i've seen them irl at my school's festival (lol life in korea) and i've enver seen girls so skinny irl, like never, that was almost scary. We're so used seeing them through a screen that we don't realize how thin they really are
The girls should wear what ever they want, but people are so rude. People think that being thin is the same as being healthy and that is not, we should all understand that we have no right to criticize any body.
Joy have the best body compared to other members and that's the truth I am not saying this because I swear I am saying this because her curves her body proportions her hight all are perfect And she look so healthy even when she get thick that's why I love body
@@sofiacorzo8965 why do people always have to comment like u about Seulgi or other idols that are so skinny when joy is praised like let the thicc idol live wtf?? 😒
Its very common for idols to gain weight after debut bc before then they are preparing and dieting really hard, once the releif of all that bejng done hits, its easy to gain a little weight
I am madly in love with red velvet, and I don't care, and will always care, how much they weigh.These girls have a unique charisma and talents, they inspire me and give me a good mood,they are all beautiful, each of them is very beautiful,I worry about them when I see their very thin bodies, let them be moderately thin, I believe that everyone who writes about them that they are fat and ugly is wrong.I hope that in the near future people will stop insulting artists for their appearance or even judging someone for it,and thinness will stop being an icon of beauty, which everyone aspires to
I relate with Yeri so much. Might not be an apple shape cuz I'm a rectangular/square shape, I also have a short torso and it's hard to dress when you have a short torso.
well wendys black girl wasnt unnecessary and misognynoir-istic but the hate for her weight gain was edit: im not gonna argue w anyone!! that is my truth and im not interested in debating it
@@seolataelala376 pretty sure you're not fluent in Korean and neither is the UA-camr so how about you guys stop trusting on mistranslations and hating on a person based on that?
The reason why Yeri looks "bigger" compared to others despite her having the same thin arms and legs is:
1. The stylist does not know how to style her body.
2. Yeri has big breasts but with a flat stomach so when the stylists give her "baggy" crop tops it seems like she's really big.
3. Yeri has an apple shape body.
She also has a short torso and long legs! It can be a bit tricky to dress that body type
She also have a bigger hip bones but maybe that what you mean in apple body shape
She also has a wide waist, this isn’t very desired and can often make you look heavier than you actually are. But no matter how much she exercises she can’t change her bone structure
Nochu Mochi she’s actually a rectangle shape
wynaoming joy's body is a rectangle, so i think yeri is an apple because their bone structure isn't similar
Omg wendy gets so much hate when she gains weight and gets attacked when she's skinny too
People just can't let her breathe
yea i can’t believe people are so toxic
It's because we couldn't deny that she looked alarmingly skinny at a short amount of time. As for her thicker side, it wasn't even bad. I think she's gotten more stable
My point 😥
And she expressed how she was scared of gaining too much weight I think she said something along the lines of " people love me more when I'm thin " so it seems she's developed the same mentality as someone with an eating disorder
I can’t believe it’s 2020 and people still hate on Yeri like-
I was literally about to say the same thing. For all those people who called that girl ugly is insane. Yeri is so breathtaking it’s ridiculous 😍
People need to get their eyes checked, because Yeri is so beautiful like I would do anything to look like her
Emily Hanson SIS SAME!!
I actually can’t believe someone called yeri an blackpink wannabe chase she called blackpink like what?? That person is messed up
@@kimjisoo8689 LITERALLY i hate when so called "fans" or fans from other groups try to call out a member or MULTIPLE members for quote on quote "copying" other groups that their literally friends with.
Seulgi looks so good with more weight on. Well, she looks good either way so like...
All of them
All of them look better with some weight, I think it makes them look more sexy and cute
every idol should be able to have some weight on them ,
Y’all are soo weird it’s her body!! If she wants to be toned and skinny let her don’t praise her at one size if u ain’t goin lover her every size
@@nereaa7896 actually she’s a inverted triangle. She just has nice Proportions which gives this illusion of an hourglass
Time for us to stop worrying about how skinny they look and more into if they’re healthy physically and mentally
Which is why we are worrying about their weight. Whether they are too skinny, crash diets, etc. But yes knowing pysically and mentally would be nice
When their thickest is your thinnest😑
Neo Crackhead Squad
I can relate 😂😂😂😂
Me too
Or my goal weight😂
ah yeah hahahaha
Or when their thinnest moments are your thickest :(
Why the heck are all the comments about there body types and arguing about hourglass figure? It doesn't really matter, they're all beautiful no matter what 😤💗
Honestly like keep your dang opinions to yourself its so dumb like yall really arguing abt body types ??? Like tf💀
I'm sorry but Irene is not an hourglass... And especially not a 'defined' one, as you said. I'd say she is either inverted triangle or rectangle. Her waist isn't small enough compared to her hips to be considered hourglass.
Her waist it actually small
@@hussey3867 but not compared to her upper body and hips
LUSH Official having a small waist doesn’t necessarily mean you’re an hourglass
i think seulgi’s the hourglass figure
@@lidia9222 it does
Joy’s relationship with food and her body is honestly so inspiring, I wish to have a mindset as positive as hers! She’s literally so stunning💚💚💚
actual red velvet body tyles:
IRENE: inverted triangle
SEULGI: inverted triangle
JOY: rectangle
WENDY: rectangle
YERI: apple
isn't seulgi hourglass?
@@remolachin34 Actually no. Many Idols have a inverted triangle type of body, where their shoulder are more prominent than their hips. For example, BlackPink girls... only Jisoo has a rectangle type of body, while the other three are triangle type.
Stylist has the job to make them look like they have hourglass body. That's why ChungHa (another example) good look so good, or why Rosé didn't look good with so clothes she wear by a stylist (while when she choose her own clothes she looks like she has hourglass body).
That's why probably many Idols don't look good on certain type of clothes or colors, because their stylist are not doing correctly the job.
αé'sthetic β no her hips aren’t wider than her shoulders
αé'sthetic β it’s ok
Joy is pear
From Yeri’s Instagram I conclude that she knows how to dress herself for her body type, and dresses herself better than RV’s stylists lol
I actually think Wendy was the thickest around Peek-a-boo era 😅
hoebi hoebi kinda but at the same time her waist in peek-a-boo era wasn’t as big as in dumb dumb era.
She always looked good no matter in which era but I feel like in she was extremely attractive in umpah umpah to psycho era like woah she was looking soooo good🤯.
Maybe it has sth to do with confidence🤷🏼♀️
I think its Bad boy thoo
Ughh I loved her legs they were so gorgeous, but if shes healthy and happy at her weight now and managing it well I'm happy for her
I think Ice Cream Cake
The stylist did her so dirty with that plaid babydoll dress, it made her look bigger than she is. 😥
RV stylists have always done yeri and joy dirty. Yeri never gets flattering clothes, its like the stylist doesn't even care she has a different body shape they just dress her the same as the other members who look completely different. The stylists also treat Joy like a sex object not a person, the number of times shes had to pull down her short dresses during performances where the other members are all wearing pants is appalling
Why are people comparing their body types and saying which is their favourite like that's hella weird...
ikr.. can we just love them for their personality and skills rather than discussing whether someone is a rectangle or an hourglass 😿
Have the same issues when people comment -“x” has the best body in kpop - based on what trend is in it at the moment
Yeri has a natural wide structure so she’s probably is at her thinnest. I’m 5’4 but I have broader shoulders and have wide hips so I naturally have a hour glass shape and even when I was at my thinnest I still looked “bigger” so I don’t think people should hate on her she’s beautiful ❤️
I don't think anyone in red velvet has a hourglass shape🤔
Same.
Irene's waist doesn’t seem to be at least 8inches smaller than her hips so she isn’t an hourglass but a rectangle in my opinion
The nearest would be Seulgi since she has a tiny waist and a bit larger hips but her shoulders are bigger than her hips so she’s not really an hourglass but an inverted triangle.
I saw a video that said Seulgi had an hourglass shape and I forgot who it was but I think they said Joy had inverted triangle shape. But I think Seulgi does have a bit of an hourglass shape and it really shows when she wears dresses that fit/‘hug’ her body and I kinda see it but that’s just my opinion.
Seulgi is hourglass
@@danicaseymore1047 Joy is a rectangle, her waist is not defined and her hips are not prominent
@@danicaseymore1047 not exactly she, doesn't have any curves not something bad when she doesn't but sometimes I notice she wears hippads or push-ups that must be why she sometimes looks like a hourglass or rectangle shape.
For me they’re beautiful no matter how thick or thin they’re
The reason why peeps bash on Irene’s proportions is because she isn’t (she isn’t hourglass either). Her legs a very short which is why her stylist dress her in short everything to make them appear longer
For me, the thinnest era for Seulgi was in Russian roulette and Rookie. And the thickest era is Psycho for the same reasons, her look like they have gained some muscles and also you can notice that her booty. She is body goals fr
IKR, her legs look really toned since Greedy in Chile
Wendy honestly has never been “big” ever. She looks bigger than she is when she gains weight because the weight gain tends to happen in her legs and her face bloats a bit. Even looking at her when she was at her thickest point her abdominal area was thin.
With Yeri her limbs have always been really thin. She just doesn't have a super defined waist-line plus there’s the fact that she has a fuller chest that the stylists don’t really know how to flatter.
With Irene I don’t understand the proportion bashing. She’s short yes. Her legs are a pretty average length for her height but she has a really thin waist and small head.
Wendy's styling was terrible. They gave her heavy tops making her look bigger. Although, she is bigger than her members, she is still nowhere near fat
Dumb Dumb was everyone's era because they looked soooo good! They were a healthy thicc size and I loved how energetic they were on stage. Not to say them slimming is bad, I just want them to be happy and comfortable with their bodies.
Seulgi is naturally thin, but she's been able to gain some serious muscle which is really impressive. Also love the Double Toasted gif in Irene's section lol.
wendy's weight had stabilized starting from power up...and then her accident happened. I hope people don't give her any shit for her changes in weight after she makes her full return.
Seulgi thickest moments is my goals.
i think seulgi has fast metabolism(?) so that makes her body weight didn't really change that much
Yup
Am i the only one who think Seulgi's thinnest era was on her debut?
same
I have the same body shape that Irene has- which isn’t an hourglass but rather a column. The difference in hourglass and column is the waist to hip ratio. The column body shape can often be mistaken for an hourglass but a true hourglass has a very noticeable difference between waist and hip. Columns often look like hourglass with a slightly bigger waist. The column body shape can also sometimes be mistaken for an inverted triangle body shape depending on how skinny/ thiCC u are ^-~
Omg I finally know the name of the body type i have ty! I couldn't figure out if a was an inverted triangle or hourglass cause I fit some characteristics but not all
Seulgi looks like an hourglass when she had more weight on her bones , it seems she gains weight around her hip area so her body shape appears to change depending on her weight
Netizens want too much out of Idols. How can you tell Seulgi or Irene of all people their bodies aren't proportional? It's clear they want a PERFECT image while not even reflecting that themselves. All the members would have found the dieting/exercising they're comfortable with if it wasn't for SBS. We know how hard recovering it's going to be for Wendy and to have to then factor in dieting and exercising? I hope she doesn't quit. It sounds like A LOT for one person.
what i've noticed in this video?
dumb dumb era is the era where all the members(besides irene) had their thickest moment
seulgi gotta be hourglass do you see the waist and hip ratio,, BODY GOALS✨
Joy weight loss was bc she exercised and ate healthy. That should be the aim and the standard. Not focusing on body weight but body health
I’d say Seulgi’s thinnest moment was during Russian Roulette and Yeri’s during ICC
I hate when people call Yeri fat, she’s so beautiful and healthy. Even slightly skinny and she has abs. People need to stop hating on Yeri
seulgi's excellent weight maintainance is a huge relief for me... a lot of my friends asume she must be unhealthy due to how thin she is. however, considering that her weight hasnt changed for years i dont think thats the case! her bone structure must be small, and her metabolism must be high. imo if she was unnaturally underweight (by not eating enough), there would be periods of slight weight gain and loss, right?
it conforts me, as a fan
Wendy looks good with weight on... can't believe you said that her thinnest is "healthy"
Irene is definitely an inverted triangle and to me she looked thickest during debut to ICC then she slimmed down.
I think the groups thickest era was Happiness and Dumb Dumb. Their thinnest was definitely Red Flavor, RBB, and Russian Roulette. Now I’d say they all found a way to manage their weights bc their bodies haven’t changed much since RBB and they all look great!
Could you do a Blackpink one since Chaelisa are getting so much hate for their bodies
Love your content 🥰🥰😘
S D, They are just jealous. Seriously, they have amazing bodies and I am working to look more like them by doing a healthy lifestyle 😄
@美珠
I hate when ppl say that a person doesn’t naturally have a body like them bc I do have such a body and I eat like a pig 🐷
Please don’t overwork yourself and remember there’s only one person in the world with a specific body so you won’t look exactly like one of them and no one will look like you.
I wish you good luck on your journey.
You have all my moral support ❤️❤️❤️❤️
S D，Thanks for your concern. I know some people try to achieve their body goals through dangerous methods... I am already skinny, but I want the muscle definition Lisa has ☺️
@美珠
I’m glad you care about your healthy first.
And me too girl like I am skinny but I need more muscles but everything is closed and not safe right now so I can’t go to the gym😔
@@SD-ww6oh wow lucky :( i hate that i have to constantly worry about what i eat. chalisas bodies are my goals :(
Out of all the members of Red Velvet - when Wendy trains her body hard...damn her abs - its like 11 line abs. She needs to drop a workout routine quick
Thin or thick- as long as the doctor says they're healthy, they are great.
i think Seulgi's thinnest era could be peek a boo, you can really see it on that one stage where she is wearing the green jumpsuit!
I personally love joy and irenes body, they are seriously body goals
this actually was a wholesome video thank you
people disagree with saying hourglass coz they’re thinking of curvy Kim kardashian types but Irene is hourglass for a skinny person that’s her natural line. The Instagram skinny people who are more are probably photoshopped/rib removed. Compare her to another skinny person yeri who is not hourglass
No Kim doesn't have an hourglass, an hourglass is when the shoulders and hips align with a defined waist, which none of them have, but some do have a softness and curvature from waist to hips that trick a person like Seulgi but her shoulders are broader than her hips, shes like a soft inverted triangle
an hourglass figure is when your waist is small and your hips are larger, Irene doesn't have that figure bc her waist and hips aren't that different from each other
Hourglass is a specific measurement ratio it isn't a look.
It makes me sad that netizens keep body shaming Joy. Like, she has the perfect body!! I envy her every time I see her bc she has the perfect body : not too skinny and just the right amount of meat on the bones lol it sounds creepy to put it like that but I dont wanna call it fat. Any was she is body goals and I wish I had her body :(((
@BTSJIMIN Army yeah also wendy who has been hated on her weight every era
tysm for the video
the thickest for the whole group was in dumb dumb era hahaha what was happening that time
And what matter what happened in that era? They looked so beautiful in dumb dumb.
Montserrat Torres so do I, it was just a question i love the girls
They were just a beautiful and happy girls in that era but because the hate comments about their body they starting to lose weight.
The knetizens even called them Pig Velvet, I'm so mad with that but if they're happy with their actual bodies I'm happy for them too
@@floridak1los "Fancams" didn't make a hateful comment, don't make fandom look bad with your overreaction🙄
Omg love your videos ❤️❤️❤️
irene does not have an hourglass, she’s a inverted triangle.
It really upsets me how stylists dress yeri. The clothes they choose almost always aren’t appropriate for her body type, they make her body look bigger than how it really is, I mean you are right, in peek-a-boo era stylists finally dressed her correctly and she looked amazing
Seulgi's thinnest moment is Russian Roulette era.
Yeri’s body type is rare bc she has a wide rib cage and big breasts so this makes her appear bigger even if she may not be. We should learn from Yeri bc she has said that instead of going on extreme diets she is switching to a more healthy and balanced diet along with doing exercise such as pilates. Its a gradual weight loss but it is a healthy one!
They really can’t leave Wendy alone, one minute they’re hating on her to gaining weight then the next they’re hating on her for losing weight :((
Red velvet's stylist litterally gives yeri the worst outfits that dont fit her figure even though she's really stunning
Omg this video make me realised that i miss them so mush
I don't think Irene is a hourglass, I think she's an inverted triangle
Thank you for making this video positive and discussing the proper ways to lose weight/stay healthy
"some fans have claimed that Irene was a feminist"
......
You say that like its a bad thing
In Korea it is a bad thing, because the way feminism is shown makes it look bad. Feminism is just equal rights for women but some “feminists” just made it all about hating men
@@cyndixx Shut up.
Yeri: *inhales*
Haters: FaTtY!!1!!11!
I have no idea how idols get shamed for weight gain. I’m a big girl and it makes me insecure hearing people comment on how these girls gain weight, even though they look healthy.
I really like thicc wendy... 😍
Ireeeeene 😍😍 I don't really care with the rumors of her bad attitude everyone has a bad side!! I love her smile so much it brightens up my dayyy.. so cute so cute!!
Poor Wendy
They are all so beautiful and talented
I don't speak good english but understand what you say in all your videos. Besides, i like them so much
Before I watched this video, I noticed too that their thickest moments are all in dumb dumb era
How can anyone say Irene doesn’t have good proportions like other idols aren’t just as short ??
Thicc joy is best joy
I think they all looked healthy in all eras but maybe Wendy during the red flavor era was a bit shocking for me cause she was thin during the dumb dumb era too in my opinion.
They all look good. I love you Red Velvet.
I personally don’t think that Seulgi is skinny because of a good “management”, not saying that she eats bad tho, but i really believe that she and Irene have a skinny complexion, I’ve never seen them more chubbier or skinnier, they look always the same, maybe it’s just me but i think that:)
Am I the only one that prefers them when they gain weight? Like it makes them look healthier
i'll never get over how beautiful they all are, no matter what the weight.
people in the comments really think hourglass has to do with bigger bodies that have boobs & butt? no. it's bone structure. Irene is an hourglass because her hips and shoulder stretch out to the same length and her waist goes inward. Seulgi is more of a pear in my opinion, but i digress. you don't need to be thick to be an hourglass. stay mad.
Irene is not hourglass, she is column, but who cares, wish her happiness...
almost every member of red velvet has gotten serious hate for their weight
say what you want about bad boy, but no one can deny that the stylists didn’t come through with flattering amazing outfits that were unique to each members body type and made them look so good for every stage/promo
How are there stomachs always so flat doe 👁👄👁😭😭😭
Wendy looked the best to me during OOTN era. People are crazy to think she was fat. I'd love to be fat like her 🤣🤣🤣
i've seen them irl at my school's festival (lol life in korea) and i've enver seen girls so skinny irl, like never, that was almost scary. We're so used seeing them through a screen that we don't realize how thin they really are
Thickest better for me, but i like all kinds of Red Velvet
i can't see any differences for seulgi and irene ~
The girls should wear what ever they want, but people are so rude. People think that being thin is the same as being healthy and that is not, we should all understand that we have no right to criticize any body.
So in short, Dumb Dumb era was them at their "thickest" (Except Irene) love that era though
Joy have the best body compared to other members and that's the truth
I am not saying this because I swear
I am saying this because her curves her body proportions her hight all are perfect
And she look so healthy even when she get thick that's why I love body
That's ur opinion tho ........
For me the best body among them is Seulgi, she has a very defined waist, beautiful hips and toned arms. But tbh all of them have amazing bodys
In my opinion it's seulgi
@@peppaPig-nc8ho so it is thicc bodies more called curvey bodies are in trend when 20 years before were skinny bodies.. Why do u sound so insecure🤔?
@@sofiacorzo8965 why do people always have to comment like u about Seulgi or other idols that are so skinny when joy is praised like let the thicc idol live wtf?? 😒
Its very common for idols to gain weight after debut bc before then they are preparing and dieting really hard, once the releif of all that bejng done hits, its easy to gain a little weight
If they were thicc then I'm an effing elephant.
Please stay healthy Red Velvet
I am madly in love with red velvet, and I don't care, and will always care, how much they weigh.These girls have a unique charisma and talents, they inspire me and give me a good mood,they are all beautiful, each of them is very beautiful,I worry about them when I see their very thin bodies, let them be moderately thin, I believe that everyone who writes about them that they are fat and ugly is wrong.I hope that in the near future people will stop insulting artists for their appearance or even judging someone for it,and thinness will stop being an icon of beauty, which everyone aspires to
Yeri really mantain herself since 2017 she being the same
So sad that Wendy looked so malnourished during their concert some months ago. I only wish her the best
imo dumb dumb is the best era
goddddd i hate yeri's stylists sm 🤧🤧🤧 they do her so dirty
I relate with Yeri so much. Might not be an apple shape cuz I'm a rectangular/square shape, I also have a short torso and it's hard to dress when you have a short torso.
I'll always love them no matter what
The end, stan red velvet. 👁️🔫
well wendys black girl wasnt unnecessary and misognynoir-istic but the hate for her weight gain was
edit: im not gonna argue w anyone!! that is my truth and im not interested in debating it
Vrene i said what i said
Vrene ua-cam.com/video/sXnSPYzagvQ/v-deo.html mwah
@@seolataelala376 pretty sure you're not fluent in Korean and neither is the UA-camr so how about you guys stop trusting on mistranslations and hating on a person based on that?
Seeing Wendy being THAT thin almost hurts, like, it must have been really difficult
Ooof Im so early 😂😂😂
i mean all of 'em are my body goals, like have those haters seen their bodies?????????