What would the UK look like under a Labour government? | LBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
- Andrew Marr joined Shelagh Fogarty to discuss how the UK's political landscape would change should Labour come into power.
Among the topics discussed, the two pondered how Sir Keir Starmer would negotiate the challenge of entering back into a trade agreement with the European Union.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#andrewmarr #shelaghfogarty #generalelection #brexit #eu #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
If you really want politics to be different, drive the Tories into third place or less.
Having a sane party as the official Opposition would lead to constructive debate, and votes based on contents of bills, instead of the Tories blindly opposing everything.
Are you on... Kratom?
I totally agree the Tories are not worthy even to be in opposition.
The trouble is if reform are the opposition they don't actually work, their policies for the NHS are solely aimed at breaking it up, farage wants to hand his mate trump a slice of it if he gets back in power
Ideally Lib Dems but even Reform would be better than the Tories!
@@R1cHarrisLibdems👍🏼
Reform 👎
The press and mainstream media will call Labour to task and expect change. They never question the Conservatives
Nearly all the press is owned by the Tories.
We need press & media reform as well as electoral reform, and we need it urgently!
The same media that gives Farage all press he needs but fails to give anyone else that been putting MPs on to the commons even a minute
I’ve said it for years, Labour is held to incredibly high standards and woebetide if they fall short. Tories being crooked, self serving and useless is fully expected so they have to be particularly atrocious for people to sit up and take notice.
Ever it was thus.
I don't think there has ever been a time in history when a 7x failed MP and his party is interviewed more than any other party in the country. It is bizarre and shows we need to have changes to media, it is no wonder that reform get a boost when he's on TV more, his support has been largely manufactured by the media giving him much more platform than any metric shows he deserves and never even giving mild push back or even devil's advocate.
😂
Agreed mate, had to switch the radio off the other day as he was the point of discussion on every station.
Lol, along with Thatcher and Blair he's the most influential politician in the last forty years so yeah he should be given airtime.
@@balthus9105 given airtime, of course, but not excessively to the point that you can’t get away from him.
@@balthus9105influential politician?
Lost to a dolphin didn’t he once?
Why is Farage still here? He said he would leave if Brexit was a failure. He has acknowledged exactly that. So why hasn’t he left.
He has much work to do, here, and we are grateful for that.
Because we never got Brexit, we got Brino. (Brexit In Name Only)
Too many people believed that the result would be a total wipe out.
Too many people believed that "everyone" else would vote.
Too many people stayed at home because their votes weren't 🗳 needed. And that my friends, was how Labour lost "For Ever" its one chance to destroy the Tories.
Labour are tories though
Quatsch
@@timminsmark So the Tory trolls keep telling us.
The Tory’s are all on their own
What was the deal that we got? A guaranteed increase in poverty, prices and lack of labour mobility?
That was a failure of government not Brexit, but Brexit is an easy excuse, like the war in Ukraine and the pandemic! Ask yourself who is richer and who is poorer.
@@Aguyfromthe60sNigel Farage is richer, most workers in most industries are poorer
@@Aguyfromthe60s But were this not cornerstones of brexit policy?
@@andal7404 exactly and our government should have sorted it out, but have sat on their hands, and now labour look certain to win the election, we’ll be back in forthwith. We live in a democracy ya know!
@@Aguyfromthe60s Looks like the penny still hasn't dropped.... The rich got richer and the poor got poorer after 14 years of the Tories regardless of Pandemic and Ukraine.
Farage is already on the airwaves all the time - and far too much given his support. So what Andrew is suggesting is not really a change
No, Farage won't be a significant noise if he gets a seat in Clacton. He got was a member of the European Parliament and was widely ignored. Farage is at best a heckler. You can choose to ignore him, he has no real power other than being a nuisance. He wouldn't know what to do with real power.
Farage has very little to say, so Marr suggesting he will be a nuisance at PM questions every week is a bit much.
What concerns me is that many of us thought the same in the context of the Brexit referendum, and look what happened there.
Not sure it makes sense to ignore Nigel’s rhetoric to the extent he represents the views of voters who feel they are ignored … regardless of their views.
Democracy doesn’t always result in positive economic or progressive social outcomes - eg 1930s Germany, modern Russia, modern South Africa, modern India etc are all democracies.
The problem is that even if reform get one seat, Farage will still get more coverage in the bias right wing media than all other political parties
I think Farages power will come from across the Atlantic. A Trump win will be very interesting in terms of his relationship with the UK and his mate Farage.
Agreed. Similar as not having heard much from George Galloway since he became MP. They’ll be sitting in silence in parliament and try stir up noise with interviews. He’ll be irrelevant with at max a handful of his own party MPs.
I hope we get to see electoral reform as well as parliamentary reform. We need PR and a proper
Senate and upper house.
In 2011, 67.9% of people rejected an Alternative Vote in a referendum (turnout 42%). I am aware that AV is not PR.
@@FontaineDerby as usual because the establishment really didn’t promote its benefits. Just like Brexit.
I agree absolutely but I fear that whilst Labour are a massive improvement on the Tories with their policies, their democratic intentions are little different. Neither leadership wants to give up their absolute power when in office.
Farage will only be as big as the media make him. Right now he is talked about as much as the main parties and is interviewed more, even though polls have him 1 3rd of labour, even though there party did terribly in the local elections and the lib dems who came second can only get 10 second mention if they canoe off of a waterfall. It is the media's constant overhyped of him and lack of pushback that pushes reform to have so many votes.
Because he gets clicks, it's that simple. The media doesn't care about fairness or being accurate, they care about clicks.
We’ll see on the 4th. I think you’ll be surprised by the number of votes Reform get (not seats won).
If they are anything like the last labour government which wasn't perfect, but everything was better. The average disposable income was £11,000 a year compared to today. The NHS was the considered one of the best healthcare systems on the planet and there was huge investment in education. Low child poverty etc.
True, but they failed to change the electoral system and parliament, lords abolition etc. if they actually reformed the system we wouldn't be in this mess
Then they opened the floodgates to rub our noses in diversiteeee. And the NHS is overwhelmed as our our schools, housing. Life was better in 1997. I was in my twenties and living in my own property. Not many twentysomethings could do that now.
If things were so great, why were Labour voted out?
@@Steve-fk1jg because it was worse than a few years prior, they were blamed for the global recession, people believed the economically illterate position that you need austerity after and during a recession. Not to mention no party got a majority.
Schools were underperforming, child poverty was worse, and the health care system was reviewed by independent think tanks that Labour set up and paid to give positive reviews, the reality is the open borders system crashed the NHS, schools, dentists and all the other free services due to an increase 10,000 x demand.
We should have freedom of movement. We lost our EU rights and now stuck on this backward island unless we rejoin
You could always leave this backward island as you put it!! Fella...
Because of Brexit we lost our freedom to live, work, retire and study visa free in 27 member states and this is not an option. But then you knew that didn’t you?
@@smxlad Emigrate and stop whining.
@@suttercane6 He can't. That's the point.
@@robmarshall9026 Of course he can. People emigrate to non-EU countries all the time. Alternatively he could get on a boat, cross the channel and claim asylum in France!
So Labour can do nothing with massive majority but Nigel with one seat will make an impact
Please make this make sense?
right wing media bias
Per seat
@@ECoventry still not making sense
The Tory supporting media would vote for a turnip.
It's journalists inflating Farage beyond his actual power again, these people are constantly boosting him beyond what he's actually accomplished.
I think there are many things the British public would be willing to accept because it makes their lives better. For example a Labour government might adopt a number of EU regulations on the pollution of our rivers, lakes and seas. The Water companies are already deeply despised for the way they have been dumping raw sewage and using failing infrastructure as an excuse. The very infrastructure they have been saying for years is the reason for our high water bills. While the Brexiteers have for years blamed the EU for every ill in this country, Labour could blame those private companies for the damage they have caused and use the EU as an example of how they can give us clean water. We don't have to say it's from the EU just that we are copying what they do. When people see an improvement they don't really care where it came from.
As more and more things are copied people will begin to ask why are the EU coming up with better ideas than us. This will change the negative impression of the EU that has been spread for years which will then lead to people been open to other changes.
The LD would get no coverage if Ed Davies wasn't paddle boarding or taking amusement park rides.
Because they're the Tories biggest threat in southern England. So the Tory media is hoping that if they ignore them, people won't vote for them. Kinda like the producers of IACGMOOH not giving someone screen time, because they don't want them to win
Our country will be far better under a Labour government, more fairer, less corrupt better chances for the majority of our people.
😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂🤢🤮
It won’t labour are just red tories these days
But not under Starmer - no integrity,
@@andreer-k6136You need to understand the meaning of the word integrity before using it.
No it wont be!
The electorate will expect a new government and do the only sensible thing, which is to get the UK back into the EU as soon as possible. I'd also look into the prosecutions of those who funded the campaign of sheer lies that conned fools and bigots into voting leave. Thankfully many of them will have died since the vote, the young who have been betrayed by the vote and denied free movement in Europe will want to see their rights restored pronto.
The UK is not going back into the European Union because we in the 27 member states will NEVER unanimously vote to accept your application.
We're never going back in because that would be completely undemocratic and its actually a disgrace for any British citizen to go against a democratic vote. Unless we had another referendum (which you would lose again). Its been 8 years.
Its time to move on. Stop the crying
If a new votes happens people will vote to rejoin again no doubt!
True.
@@Danny-is5if How is something voted for by 26% of elegible voters and in the future being overturned by a majority undemocratic and how is disenfranchising 5 million voters who where living in the EU at the time democratic?
You don't get as many Commons seats as you feel that your vote share deserves? Welcome to the Lib Dem & Green club, and our FPtP system.
Britain needs Reform!
What!
Reform. uk.
# Amateurs
Lead by
Del Boy Faragio.
@@YankaBakasci And you're going to vote for somebody who wanted longer, harder lockdowns? How clever you are.
10 minutes of Marr fantasising about cherry-picking EU-perks without wanting any obligations, the usual UK stance.
_Among the topics discussed, the two pondered how Sir Keir Starmer would negotiate the challenge of entering back into a trade agreement with the European Union_ Entering back? There is a recently signed trade agreement between the UK and the EU: the TCA. Without any *negotiation-option* available for the UK, it's merely the *implementation* of the TCA that is *up for review* in 2026. European Commission Vice-President Maros Sefcovic already told the UK back in 2023 that it would be just that: reviewing the implementation of the deal rather than wholesale changes. Mr Sefcovic said customs checks at the border would likely remain but stressed the TCA had not been used to its “full potential”. He said the review doesn’t constitute a commitment to reopen the TCA or to negotiate supplementary agreements. “The TCA will simply not be able to recreate any kind of notion of the Single Market.” In other words: no more cherry-picking for the UK.
Really illustrates the totally undemocratic nature of first past the post
Love how after all these years the little, foggy island still has no clue how the EU works.
You lot have 27 SOVEREIGN AND INDEPENDENT countries to please with the terms of any agreement.
A phrase about "cards" and "holding" springs to mind...
I genuinely believe that a labour government will serve the public and not themselves. An end to the vile language used against certain groups in our society, integrity and compassion
We need freedom of movement back.
Just do it labour...
Please please please for the sake of the country vote reform! 🙏. I voted for brexit and would again.
🥴
Brits still believing they can cherry pick.. dream on folks
Not very much different. I’m not impressed with the Labour front bench I think they will be more managerial then anything else. People expect Labour to be radically reforming in government. I just don’t see it with this group of very comfortable people. At least the last Labour government had a left wing figure like Clare Short
I'll take boring managerial government over the literal criminals we've had with the Tories.
Crazy how we care about millions of reform voters not being heard but when we were all out on a hard or soft Brexit the almost half of voters that didn't want any form of Brexit didn't matter.
Put simply much better than it has been under the Conservatives. Vote Labour 👍🏼✌🏼️💖😊
👍
Politics will be so different because Laura Kuenssberg et al will be sad because all their WhatsApp contacts will have lost their jobs
Marr is correct, there is no way back in to EU for Britain except the Single Market. We pay for the club but can not vote or make rules for the club.
Expecting Labour to be able to clean up the mess the Tories have made is deluded.
True I expect at least two terms in office if not possibly a third? That’s my opinion everyone has their own.
EXSPECTING NOTHING DIFFERENT THEY ARE BOTH NOT FIT FOR OFFICE EDUCATED FALLS WITH NO COMMON SENSE POLITICIANS NOT BUSINESS MIND NONE OF THEM
Or any party for that matter.
Seeing as they have almost the same policies yeah.
@@JohnnyCrash-ug8zt That's right, if we don't make a start it'll never be fixed.
There's so many Russian (Reform) bots on here it's hilarious.
Reform is a joke ,albeit not a very funny one.
A lot better than it is now with starmer in charge,
The food crisis doesn’t seem to have affected the host.
We will soon find out.
to think what a labour government could achieve with this kind of majority, such a shame we have such neo liberal suits to look forward to
But would they get such a majority if they were more overtly left-wing? An important question, but not really answerable at present.
@@andrewmcgee382 no one is voting for labour, they're voting against the tories, people want change and the moment they realise starmer is just the same the opinion polls will tear the new gov to shreds
@@Waywoodprojectslet’s just hope that once they get in with a supermajority they will be more ambitious
@@user-pp9yk3tu4z when has a government ever been more radical in government than when they were running for election?
Isn't an " Association Agreement" similar to the " Memoranda of Understanding" that Tories trumpet about having with a couple of US States, who do NOT make independent trade deals? Association agreements with the EU have much more economic impact than a MoU with Florida.
No, an agreement as quite different from an understanding.
An association agreement is a bilateral agreement between the EU and a third country. *In the context of accession to the EU* it serves as the basis for implementation of the accession process. Turkey currently has an association agreement. Association agreements between the Western Balkan countries and the EU and its Member States are called 'stabilisation and association agreements'.
"He gets so much air time because so many people have voted for him..." he has failed to win a seat SEVEN times so that is clearly not true!
this is all fine, but they need to tell the electorate this. havent heard a word on this from them.
This pair ain't celebrities on their looks
I don't see how this is ok given people voted to leave the EU? Any decision to move closer to the EU should go to a referendum.
But more people want to rejoin the EU now, right?
Why would we?
@@Dynasty1818You would have to ask the majority of Brits that have come to realization that the Brexit was wrong, and want to rejoin the EU.
No
We couldn't afford to.
@@rb1062 Says the guy who voted to impose the economical sanction on his own country. I feel pity for you.
On page 2 of Braverman's letter to Sunak on 15/11/23 she states; "You never had any intention of keeping your promises" -
Was Ritchie lying all along....
So large numbers of people won't have their views represented in Parliament, tell us something new. Large numbers of people oppose Privatisation of the Utilities and the Railways, the selling of Council Houses and the Royal Mail but they were pushed through by the Torys. So why is this now such a big deal now it looks like there'll be a Labour government.
Total recall ♥️
1) It was an advisory referendum.
2) A Conservative Prime Minister (DC) said he would respect the outcome.
3) Another Conservative Prime Minister (TM) said "Brexit means Brexit".
4) Another Conservative Prime Minister (BJ) said "Get Brexit Done" and he did.
5) Keir Starmer will rightly say "I'm a Labour Prime Minister and I am not bound by the promises made by Conservative Prime Ministers. Oh, and it was an advisory referendum. The UK is rejoining the EU."
QED 😂🎉
_The UK is rejoining the EU_ Say that it goes like that. And say the UK will be swiftly grandfathered in by the EU. Won't happen, but for the sake of argument. 5 years down the line, the Tories win the elections and the new Tory PM will state: "I am not bound by the promises made by a Labour Prime Minister." Then what: the whole circus all over again? The EU is not a revolving door.
The UK can apply just like any other country, but it will take at least two consecutive governments where both the party in power and the main opposition commit to re entry...
@@zivkovicable Not true. The UK is the ONLY country to have left the EU. Its position is therefore unique 🇨🇵🇪🇺.
Wrong.
Algeria (France) left and Greenland (Denmark)left.@@andrewrobinson2565
VOTE!! Or nothing changes
It will look worse than it did in the 1970s
These are more reasons for stammer to have addressed this proactively.
And millions of people have felt they are not represented at every election in their life time, so why is it suddenly an issue now? Purely because the media love Nigel and his 'engagement'. He's 'one of them', goes to the same clubs, knows all the right people because of his privileged background. However, if he does end up leading some sort of campaign for electoral reform, I might have to give him credit for doing one useful thing in his career.
A lot better than now.
There's only a few of those voters lefts tbh.
UK has become a very lonely island after Brexit, Labour should negotiate a much better deal to grow the UK economy, education, health and security interests, if this allows free movement of people so be it. This pathetic conservative government destroyed the UK in every single aspect. We are a limp island on the edge of a European continent and they are laughing hard at us,
All the reasons we left the UK last year.
Hear that? No? Yeah that's the sound of people giving an F.
Don’t rush back .
@@clario2178 laughs on you buddy, stuck on mud island 😂😂😂😂
Not sure what part of East London he's walking through but it's clearly a lie.
I was born and raised there and currently work there.
His anecdote is a well worn falsehood.
It will look like a slightly more competent version of the Sunnak Tory government. Starmer doesn´t want to change anything fundamentally.
One thing that might happen, is you might get some odd renationalisations, but that´s partly because quite a lot of railway companies are not doing that great and at least one of the water companies might go bust.
English exceptionalism still hasn't changed, you think they'd have learned a lesson the past few years.
No! he get air time becase he gets ratings before brexit he was on the telly all the time.
Farage is influential because he has been given a vast amount of airtime, even long before 2016. More appearances on QT than anyone else, by a very long way.
Free Movement can be negotiated. Hospitality, the health service they need workers, so why don't we do a year visa free and allow people to try and get a job, if they succeed they will need to use a unique residence card ( lots of countries have them). They may have to pay more tax and vice versa but at least Brits get opportunities again. Do not listen to Farrage he caused all this.
Who would move to pay more tax than doing the same job??? Seriously, they already have to pay £600 odd to the NHS fund without paying higher taxes. Nobody will go. Not a hope.
@tomwalsh2244 I'm not saying British people, i am saying foreigners. I am looking at alternatives
@@MrGCB Eh so am I…again I say why would a foreigner go to the uk currently. They’re not wanted by a huge amount of people, they have to pay an NHS charge of £600 approximately. You’d give them a free visa and then charge more them more tax to do the same job? Seriously, am I missing something here? Why would they come?
Rejoin by the back door ?
No thanks !
I'm hoping there will be a massive change in the mood and that Starmer does Levison 2 eventually as well as making friends with America, Australia and New Zealand with student visas and gap years as we need skilled labour and to give something for the young as my nephew really fell off the rails a
Where's sangeeta shelagh?
BBC Radio 4 mentioned the rise of the Far Right 42 times yesterday.
Finding Andrew's argument that the algorithm media use to determine airtime is a bit odd. Not that he's wrong, but this has been the case election after election since the Liberal-SDP Alliance in the 1980s. Why now but not then?
It's a shame that Andrew Marr didn't actually anawer the question about why Farage seems to get quite a lot of slots on the news and radio shows. He, as yet, is unelected, perhaps that will change though.
One that works an one with no corruption 😂
If we don't rejoin the EU, we will have no say either.
Economically it will look exactly the same as Labour are continuing with austerity, sorry it's called fiscal rules or some other buzz word to hide what it is..
It will look like a toilet that hasn’t been flushed for 12 months!
better than the toilet thats been overflowing with
💩 for the last 14 years
@@voidrat9176 better? You obviously don’t have a clue what’s about to happen.
@@Aguyfromthe60s anything is better than the tories ANYTHING!
@@voidrat9176 give it 3 month and you’ll be crying that anything would be better than labour, ANYTHING!
under Labour Govt - UK will follow Sharia law
Blue tories red tories so no change
If there is a majority of people regretting Brexit, will they mind Starmer improving things with the EU?
We never got Brexit, we got Brino (Brexit In Name Only) The people who voted Brexit still want true Brexit
@@djcarlwalkerLet's add too the blue passports and raw sewage benefits 😆😂
"So many people have voted for him" - 0 votes so far...
Labour will be a bun fight between the Blairites and Corbynistas
Rejoin the EU we are in the mess because of brexshit
Every time I see Sheila she loses more of her chin
Exactly the same as it does right now, except with 2% more nurses, 1% more teachers, and VAT charged on school fees.
And the guy in number 10 is wearing a red tie not a blue one. So there's that.
The smell of Tory desperation is just like the rivers they pollute for money.
So are you saying it will look similar to how it does now, except better?
@@drummingtildeathNo, there will be more immigrants.😂
no different to how it looks under tories. It will continue to get worse and worse until these two parties are gone
Andrew showed his Brexit colours there. The far right did have improved results in the EU election, but the centre and left still have overall control.
Stop the rhetoric, be real professional journalists, and stick with the facts.
It will look the same as it has for the last 14 years, just with a different colour tie.
North Korea.
SELL OUT!!!!
Who?
@@IamRobotMonkey Labour on brexit if they go ahead with these alignments
Andrew Marr is properly going to bat for Sir Kid Starver here. Hes already making excuses for an impotent government who constantly give way to the right.
Millionaire Marxist Marr 😂
@@clario2178 if only he were a Marxist, he might have some answers
What would the UK look like under a Labour government? Like Shelagh Fogarty I reckon…
Learn some respect. Our country needs some human decency, try it some time.
😆😆😆
Broken beyond repair
Making excuses already
Wishful thinking Andrew.
Labour doesn´t have the cojones to take on and defeat Reform in the battle of ideas!!!
What ideas do Reform have? They don’t need to debate with them as Reform are a tiny party.
It would be a battle of wits, and sadly, Reform will come unarmed.
REFORM UK SAVE OUR COUNTRY!!!!
How can a UK party save Russia?
Botty, is that you?
Nothing changes 😔😕
It did under the last Labour government. By all measurable factors the Blair/Brown government was the most successful since world war 2. Admittedly the Major government hadn't caused the damage that this tory shower have done but, by any measurable standards everybody except millionaires are better off under a labour government "Always"
@@brianferguson7840
The last Labour government was so successful that the electorate decided to kick them out in 2010.
@@brianferguson7840So why were they voted out?
*More benefits for all
*More immigration
*More PFI contracts
*More deregulationn of the money markets
I wish there was more benefits for all.
@@tonycowin who pays for them? If everyone was on benefits we'd have nothing to go round
Some people need support. You might one day, and then you'd be outraged at how badly you were being treated.
Yes, the fertility rate means either some immigration (but not as high as the Tories or Reform would have - that's what the rich who support those 'parties' want to create mass unemployment). So less immigration.
No PFI contracts - it was a bad idea when the Tories brought it in, and it was a bad idea when Labour continued with it. Fortunately, Labour has learned from that. Reform, on the other hand, being financed by the very rich, may well have to pay them back if ever they got into government.
Labour was too Right-wing under Blair. Again, they oppose deregulation, but it's a Right-wing idea supported by those who got rich from the money markets - Farage and Sunak.
@@Mick526 Who said everyone would be on benefits? What you posted says nothing about more people receiving benefits.
Farage has always been a noise
A big noise, yes. He's making himself heard on behalf of the based in this country.
Rishi Sunak undemocratic 👇
Why? Explain yourself?
Nobody knew how different the UK would look after Tory government, but it's awful.
Nothing will change. Especially for the poor even the Working poor and when I say poor I mean people on minimum wage. Tax more for more equality.
The rich will pay a bit more, but sadly not enough to make a dramatic change.
She's looks a mess
Probably like the dark ages..
Ultra woke lunacy
Pleased to meet you. I'm Alan.