I know this is very late but if your still interested she has a UA-cam channel called You's drum where she does drum covers. Here's a link to her channel: ua-cam.com/channels/4qYx0MtuCxz4f0aU6RVFXw.html
I'm a professional bassist. I've been playing since I was 8 years old, and now I make a living playing as an adult. And I absolutely suck at thumb slapping. Mina deserves way more credit here. She had the hardest instrument and she absolutely crushed it
@@gavburgerit's not the hardest if you're plucking it normally, in that case it's pretty average of an instrument to learn. But, SLAP BASS ... Now you've turned a normal instrument into a beast to learn to play correctly
tbh, i feel like their company should give this sub-unit a comeback now that AOA is really popular, so that all the new AOA fans would know that Yookyung exist :/
Seriously who will can dislike a band of talented ladies playing instruments? Love AOA^^ I find them extremely talented and I love Youkyung too! Not to forget that our ladies can dance well as well! AOA definitely deserves more love and support! AOA fighting^^
Watching these AOA mvs it becomes obvious that Yuna is in fact the most gifted member of all, has talent, looks as well as sexiness and is promoted in both sub-units AOA Black and AOA Cream. She just isn't the most popular.
they can play this live i've watched couple of live performances where they did it live. there are just instances they have to pre-record it in broadcast. the fact that yuna is casted in AOA because of her talent in playing keyboard plus in an interview they mentioned they practice separately as a band unit from the dancing group aoa white means they really are a band. and besides, why would FNC create a "fake" girl band if they have created real boy bands, FT Island and CNBlue?!?! it just shows these girls are multi-talented. too bad they had to resort to sexy concept to get more attention since there are too many girl groups nowadays and girl band doesn't click much in korea. they should promote more in Japan. js ^^
it just seems like that. there are many artists that play instruments like they don't know what they're doing but they're actually good at it. have you ever seen Younha's Houkiboshi MV? it's an old one, but when you look at her style of playing the piano, it seems like she's just smashing the keyboard. But she's actually playing it exceptionally well.
Sorry, it's a pretty late answer, but it's got ended on her call. She will still participate on AOA events tho, when they need a drummer or something like that. It's better for her tho than rotting in FNC's basement. Basically, if I understood it right, IF AOA Black would get a comeback, she would play with them again, I think
I know this is very late but if your still interested she has a UA-cam channel called You's drum where she does drum covers. Here's a link to her channel: ua-cam.com/channels/4qYx0MtuCxz4f0aU6RVFXw.html
This song is pretty strong actually. I prefer Elvis' band version tbh. FNC really have to bring AOA Black back because AOA Black is the real FNC's style.
AOA Black needed so much more love than they got. Drives me crazy that FNC dropped the band concept completely. Still we got some good songs before they went full "dance/sexy" mode.
I just notice that the name Yookyung always "left in the group". I mean... in Apink, Yookyung left. Then, in AOA Black, Yookyung didn't became a member in AOA because she only wants to be a drummer and wants to focus on her studies (same as the Yookyung in Apink)....
+Seon Ro Well not only did she want to focus on Studies but she's only the drummer she never did singing or dancing she just played the drums but since AOA stopped doing the AOA Black she hasn't been needed so she's not in the mv's or live performances, even more since they started doing the sexy style more instead of cute pop rock
shes still in the band but they just don't do the band thing anymore so she isn't really needed rn..if AOA does any band stuff like this era or AOA Black does then they might use her again but since its been so long idk if shes still with the company or not, nothings been said for now..
+Sherri “Shearbear” Renee i read that aoa black will comeback this year, and she'll be back to drum for the band, i kinda compare her to henry or zhoumi of suju M
You know what would be awesome? A version of K-On! featuring these girls. O.o You could switch up their personalities if you wanted, but k-on is also a 5 member group with two guitar players, one base player, one keyboard player and one drummer. It practically writes itself! :D
i LOVE THEM as a BAND more than a girl dance group. Too bad "Moya" flopped or else the fnc may continue to promote them as a band/girl group. Now I don't entirely enjoy there performance anymore.
actually, moya did pretty good:) it hit number one on quite a few online charts the day of release and did better than their newer songs on gaon charts~ ^^ Hope the band concept comes back... AOA black
PMR RoyRoy AOA Black is the sub unit. AOA Black only put out 1 mini. They just didn't get much love. I bet a new AOA Black release would do much better now.
They used to be so good and unique with the band part of the group. It is so disappointing and infuriating that they seem to have dropped it. Now they are like any other girl group and that is boring. They used to be unique.
Looks like I'll have to stick to Japan to fulfill my female band needs. Korea needs them, too bad no one seems to care about anything but dancepop groups.
there are actually quite a few good korean bands, they just don't hit it off with the mainstream music audience as well. if you want a true all-girl power band you might wanna check out bebop
I like this version more simply because of Youkyung and I really want to see more of her. She's adorable.
Same
Cameron Hyatt i like the music for this one too...i can listen to that by itself
I know this is very late but if your still interested she has a UA-cam channel called You's drum where she does drum covers.
Here's a link to her channel:
ua-cam.com/channels/4qYx0MtuCxz4f0aU6RVFXw.html
I'm a professional bassist. I've been playing since I was 8 years old, and now I make a living playing as an adult. And I absolutely suck at thumb slapping. Mina deserves way more credit here. She had the hardest instrument and she absolutely crushed it
I respect your profession but bass is not the hardest instrument unless everyone else is playing the triangle.
@@gavburger You say you respect there profession and then talk bad about it 😀
@@gavburger i think they meant hardest out of the ones in the video
@@gavburgerit's not the hardest if you're plucking it normally, in that case it's pretty average of an instrument to learn. But, SLAP BASS ...
Now you've turned a normal instrument into a beast to learn to play correctly
Mina is now a bully
tbh, i feel like their company should give this sub-unit a comeback now that AOA is really popular, so that all the new AOA fans would know that Yookyung exist :/
she hasn't renovated contract so mm no i dont think so. would be nice tho
I wish they can have a comeback as a band this year... I miss their unique style... I miss our cutie pop-rock girls T.T
same -_-
they will have a Comeback next year :D
NerdSocken really? It's official?!
+LemonCandy Jun yes they posted it on a korean site and some guys translated it ^^
NerdSocken omg. Finallyyyyyyy
Seriously who will can dislike a band of talented ladies playing instruments? Love AOA^^ I find them extremely talented and I love Youkyung too! Not to forget that our ladies can dance well as well! AOA definitely deserves more love and support! AOA fighting^^
I think Jimin's voice really suits the whole band thing she just has that certain squeaky voice that sounds good with guitars and drums. Idk.
Why can't K-pop have more girl bands? (As in instrumental bands, not just dancing bands) ... >
i know right.
wonder girls
私もそう思います。＾－＾ｖ
I prefer their older songs but their recent styling has made them look a LOT better.
Watching these AOA mvs it becomes obvious that Yuna is in fact the most gifted member of all, has talent, looks as well as sexiness and is promoted in both sub-units AOA Black and AOA Cream. She just isn't the most popular.
Tekaruchi Nokatome she's literally perfect, I'll never understand how people sleep on her
Was, is, always will be a great song. The fact that this video only has 769K views after three years is not just sad its absurd.
AOA, wonderful, amazing, and fantastic K-pop girls! 🎉🎉🎉
I love AOA, both as a dance group and as a band, but please FNC, a lot of ELVIS wants AOA Black's comeback!! I miss them so much!
*miss this era of kpop the music the outfits, make up everything about it was just icon* ✨
I wish they never abandoned doing Band versions
this is my first time hearing this song from AOA! I find this song the best song from them!! ♥
#AOA
This is better than I expected! Awesome!! AOA's style is so interesting.
OMG
Jimin looks soooo much pretty back in her debut days!
I love the rapper girl on the right, the way she rap and play that guitar is just.. WOW!!
love the image they portray, really good
I'm loving AOA these days ^_^ ...
they can play this live i've watched couple of live performances where they did it live. there are just instances they have to pre-record it in broadcast. the fact that yuna is casted in AOA because of her talent in playing keyboard plus in an interview they mentioned they practice separately as a band unit from the dancing group aoa white means they really are a band. and besides, why would FNC create a "fake" girl band if they have created real boy bands, FT Island and CNBlue?!?! it just shows these girls are multi-talented. too bad they had to resort to sexy concept to get more attention since there are too many girl groups nowadays and girl band doesn't click much in korea. they should promote more in Japan. js ^^
AOA started with 7 members in 2012. Now in AOA there are 3 members - Chanmi, Seolhyun, Hyejeong.
All of the aoa black members left 😔.
they started with 8, you forgot the drummer youkyung she counts as a member too
Shame on you for forgetting Youkyung
Ooooh, I am loving these girls!
As a bass player and kpop lover I'm in love with this group!!
I love this version so much!!!!!!!!!!!
Their literally the cutest!!!! I miss this!!!
please comeback...
Esta se a convertido en mi cancion favorita... ME ENCANTAAAA!!!
sigue siendo tu canción favorita?
Jimin is everything in this video.
La perfezione!!! Sono magnifiche, con talenti incredibili! Non aggiungo altro visto che scriverei un poema incredibile!
AOA Saranghae! Elvis forever
They're going to have a comeback this year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
YUS I LOVE HOW THE DRUMS AND BASS ARE MORE PROMINENT.
And yay Youkyung! You keep on being the badass drummer!
Who is the drummer? She looks so cool! I wish I could pull off short blonde hair like her! Lol
she's youkyung!
+paradis3ra Seo Youkyung =)
She is my favourite so cool so pretty Lol
it just seems like that. there are many artists that play instruments like they don't know what they're doing but they're actually good at it. have you ever seen Younha's Houkiboshi MV? it's an old one, but when you look at her style of playing the piano, it seems like she's just smashing the keyboard. But she's actually playing it exceptionally well.
i prefer them in band version.
We love you aoa
very coll
I wish to see they perform as the band again!
I feel so sad I just discovered this group this year and the fact that this group is already basically dead makes me sad Im so lame 😭😭😭
i miss the band version of AOA!! but i still love them, just hoping for more exposure of the band
WE NEED TO SEE YOUKYUNG AGAIN IT'S AN EMERGENCY FNC PLEASE I REPEAT WE REALLY NEED SEO YOUKYUNG
THEY JUST ENDED HER CONTRACT - WELL DONE FNC
Sorry, it's a pretty late answer, but it's got ended on her call. She will still participate on AOA events tho, when they need a drummer or something like that. It's better for her tho than rotting in FNC's basement. Basically, if I understood it right, IF AOA Black would get a comeback, she would play with them again, I think
I know this is very late but if your still interested she has a UA-cam channel called You's drum where she does drum covers.
Here's a link to her channel:
ua-cam.com/channels/4qYx0MtuCxz4f0aU6RVFXw.html
@@HAB0621 oh i wasn't aware, thank you!!
Damn this sounds super good, they should do more of these
I love this video more than the dance version :) but both are good just love this one more ;)
augustin sanchez You should see Get Out live version.
I love both the dance version and the band version. The versatility AOA has is amazing. :)
735K visits... what? This video DESERVES more visits :( i love the girls, but i really really want they play instruments again...
Daaaamn ! I felt so lonely before I saw your comment ! That slap during the chorus just bloddy rocks right ?!
This song is pretty strong actually. I prefer Elvis' band version tbh. FNC really have to bring AOA Black back because AOA Black is the real FNC's style.
I Love this version so much.. thank you FNC...
AOA Black needed so much more love than they got. Drives me crazy that FNC dropped the band concept completely. Still we got some good songs before they went full "dance/sexy" mode.
omg so good I love it
their debut era was so good but then suddenly they became a dance band like dang
me encantan espero con ansias sus próximos vídeos!!!!
when will aoa black make their comeback???
To my knowledge, it hasn't even been talked about :(
Amooo essa musica!
I love this song!!!
holy shit choa looks so different with this hairstyle no wonder i don't rmbr her :S but now she's my fave lol
Finally some K-Pop with people who can actually play an instrument, love it!
AOA black needs more love especially Y
I LOVE the Japanese version of this song, but then I heard this version and now I'm in love
I just notice that the name Yookyung always "left in the group". I mean... in Apink, Yookyung left. Then, in AOA Black, Yookyung didn't became a member in AOA because she only wants to be a drummer and wants to focus on her studies (same as the Yookyung in Apink)....
+Seon Ro haha I was thinking that too ;)
+Seon Ro Well not only did she want to focus on Studies but she's only the drummer she never did singing or dancing she just played the drums but since AOA stopped doing the AOA Black she hasn't been needed so she's not in the mv's or live performances, even more since they started doing the sexy style more instead of cute pop rock
+Sherri “Shearbear” Renee so she left the band?!?!??!?!
shes still in the band but they just don't do the band thing anymore so she isn't really needed rn..if AOA does any band stuff like this era or AOA Black does then they might use her again but since its been so long idk if shes still with the company or not, nothings been said for now..
+Sherri “Shearbear” Renee i read that aoa black will comeback this year, and she'll be back to drum for the band, i kinda compare her to henry or zhoumi of suju M
Whoever's the acoustic is miyavi tier! Damn these girls rock!
You know what would be awesome? A version of K-On! featuring these girls. O.o
You could switch up their personalities if you wanted, but k-on is also a 5 member group with two guitar players, one base player, one keyboard player and one drummer.
It practically writes itself! :D
Love the instruments !
AOA Black
i hope AOA will finally get their concert soon, or maybe another band comeback!!
I cameback here after Jimin's performance in Queendom. I really miss AOA Black.
Love the song!
i think band version is more cool :) no comeback yet?
I really love the bass sounds.
ARGGGH
i LOVE THEM as a BAND more than a girl dance group. Too bad "Moya" flopped or else the fnc may continue to promote them as a band/girl group. Now I don't entirely enjoy there performance anymore.
actually, moya did pretty good:) it hit number one on quite a few online charts the day of release and did better than their newer songs on gaon charts~ ^^ Hope the band concept comes back... AOA black
they are really beautiful and they are a beautiful voice
Such a big sound here, can't Seolhyun and Heyjeong be working a tambourine, maracas, ....something? Chanmi could at least pop in for her rap feature.
I want more!!!
I really like this concept on them, but of course they had to go with the sexy concept to make it
I LOVE IT!!
oh wait .. did i just saw Mina ? :D my biasssss
nice i love this
I miss AOA Black ,, youkyoung . . .
It's pretty cool to watch the band version and the original side by side :D
Does anyone here after the scandal? I miss old AOA in band/
Band version is the reason why I got hooked to AOA. That bass.
JiMin was way more badass in this
I LOVE THIS SOOOOONG!
Wait.. Let me get this straight.. WHAT IS THE SUBUNIT.. AOA BLACK? Or AOA?
PMR RoyRoy AOA Black is the sub unit. AOA Black only put out 1 mini. They just didn't get much love. I bet a new AOA Black release would do much better now.
AOA was the subunit. I don't think they use the main unit AOA Black anymore.
PMR Roy-Roy
AOA (8 members) - band and dance, main group
AOA Black (5 members) - band, subunit
i looooove the guitar in this
OMG the guitarist on the right's capo is so cute! It's a cat! (◕‿◕✿)
Jimin...leader
James Hardway Sorry ^^; I don't really know AOA that well but thank you for telling me!
早安，很好聽哦！
Even though this video isn't actually live, I'm disappointed in the guitarists. They could have at least played actual chords.....
They do . If u look closely they make use of power chords
and jimin is even playing solos
Awesome, i love this.
Why do I always see people complaining about a girl group with a sexy concept? What a so bad about being sexy?
People think that they use their bodies to sell rather than their talent and the quality of the music.
Zoe Ankrum and the crazy part is the drummer is the only one covered.
Loving this version! I want more Y though
They used to be so good and unique with the band part of the group. It is so disappointing and infuriating that they seem to have dropped it. Now they are like any other girl group and that is boring. They used to be unique.
Looks like I'll have to stick to Japan to fulfill my female band needs. Korea needs them, too bad no one seems to care about anything but dancepop groups.
Mindy Pajor They haven't dropped, have you seen 'AOA Black'? It is the band part of the group.
AOA Black are the band, AOA are an idol group.
there are actually quite a few good korean bands, they just don't hit it off with the mainstream music audience as well. if you want a true all-girl power band you might wanna check out bebop
Mindy Pajor I guess, playing instruments giving them headaches. There is still Jrock. If you want all girl band you can check out SCANDAL.
0:01 Choaya
0:09 Jinminel (Leader)
0:23 Minaring (The one singing)
1:01 Yunaria
1:17 Y (Yu Gyeong) The one with the drums
I didnt notice that the straight longed hair girl was Jimin XD
+Kbe Syson me too! at first i thought that was chanmi but i was like "hell nah chanmi is in aoa black!"
I really like the bass at the chorus. :D
I really hope they have a chance to play this live somewhere.
I honestly like this more than aoa white
Such a talented group,they should get recognised!
love it ♡
ชอบจังงงงงงงง เท่ห์มากกกกก ♥
genial, me encanta y tambien la version dance :)
Thank you!