It was not only Pranab Mukherjee lost Prime Ministership but P.C. Alexander also lost Prasidentship of lndia due to the crooked and tactical advice of some Congress leaders.
Y u guys hate Sonia so much? It was upa which gave rti to mgnrega. She is from Italy that's the biggest mistake. But she completely changed here. Y u guys can't understand anything. She lost everything, she refused to join politics but she was convinced and brought congress back to power.
@@vv-sz4yhThat Antonio Maino has no contribution rather than increasing the no of members of parliament,no NRIs in India ,and also burden on this country
And BJP gave him Bharat Ratna !! How ironic. Even TRS, TDP and BJP rever Narsimha rao too but no one speaks about him in Congress. What a family corporation Congress is !! 😐
Sonia Gandhi meeting with Putin!!! Wtf.. Who is she to conduct such a meeting..?? Head of congress!! Imagine JP Nadda conducting a meeting with Jo Biden without Modi or president.
@@comradebrother7411 That is completely your view my friend. I respect that.. But all i requested is a episode on him. because what I see is that this channel is completely unbiased. Which is very hard to remain nowadays.. Good job CRUX
He was one of the last few true Hindus and nationalists that the Congress had. True patriot who had actually worked behind the scenes a lot to stop the worst of the Congress’ worst excesses. But for him our country would have been in even greater danger during the UPA era. That’s y BJP RSS ppl had a lot of regards for him. Still do. Especially Modi and Amit Shah.
@@atulgautam4805 Scindia was opportunist just like his grandmother Raj mata Scindia,who collapsed government of congress in Madhya Pradesh and become Bjp founding member.
He was the first person from West Bengal to hold the post of President of India. In a political career spanning five decades, Mukherjee was a senior leader in the Indian National Congress and occupied several ministerial portfolios in the Government of India.
Though I don’t support congress, I fee Pranab da would have been a better and a strong PM than Dr Singh. I felt Dr Singh was quiet or forced to keep quiet on many issues. Pranab had a better vision and the ability to work with others on the grounds of national development.
#Retweet👇 #GodblessBengali #COMMUNITY #BENGALIS ARE LEGENDS.. THEY HAVE DONE SO MUCH FOR COUNTRY #ROYALBENGALTIGERS OF #BENGALI COMMUNITY WILL START TO RULE THE WORLD AND UNIVERSE VERY VERY SOON👍👍COUNTRY IN EVERY SECTOR AND FIELD GOD BLESS #BENGALI COMMUNITY #JusticeForSubhas
@UCCM8j2aVw4FbM2Uw-g7wrrg apni ki Jokhono Pakistan k dosarop korechen, 1971 er aage Bangladeshe loot, rape, aar mass killing er jonno? Seta Kokhono pathay aase?
Congress can rise again, just need a change of leadership Congress Needs to set back right Gandhis should be given a ceremonial positions but not ruling positions
When world went through global recession india's gdp growth rate was 8% and FYI former finance minister "Arun Jaitley did not know much about economics"said by an MP of BJP
@@freeman4899 He was a great man with zero power. When he did have power though - like when he was Finance Minister in 1991 he took India strides ahead! Most of the reforms that the BJP is making right now would have already been made like GST, Aadhaar, Insolvency & Bankruptcy Act, Land Reforms and now Farm Reforms.
@@tejasdeepsingh456 That's why BJP has come to the power , Manmohanji was pretty much powerless person many people call him mounamohan, except that nuclear deal , I don't remember anything good happened in his tenure .
I wish UPA would have given him PM's seat. Just because of Gandhi family, the efficient leaders of Congress have always been ignored. Otherwise our country would have developed a lot
I seriously wouldn't say Former PM Singh was incompetent he was the most qualified person to hold the post as well as he ran it very efficiently. Moving our country's gdp from 500bn to 2tr. I would also add he was not corrupt not one percent.Still Former President Pranabji would have been great too no doubt about that.
@@theultimateshield5133 Singh was chosen over Pranab because Sonia very well knew Pranab will never become her puppet unlike Singh. India would have been 20 years ahead if he was PM instead of Singh.
@@shree_ram_5971 Had BJP won 2004, ABV would have retired in 2005 end Iike he did and Advani would have become PM atleast till 2009. Then, if he had/hadn't made trip to Pakistan and praised Jinnah and then Jaswant writing book on him would have been interesting. Maybe INC would have won 2009. Then 2014 would surely have been different. Also, Pramod Mahajan and Modi were severe Adversaries. Had Mahajan not died in 2006 and With Rajnath-Gadkari-Sushma-Shivraj-Vasundhra-Gopinath Munde (not including Jaitley and Parrikar as they supported Modi after 2002), Modi-Shah wouldn't have been able to get BJP in his hands.
There was a time... When people like Pranab Mukherjee, APJ Abdul Kalam, Manmohan Singh, Atal ji, Joyti Basu.. left, Right or Center.. these guys were genius.
that's could happen now also bjp also may start falling but it depends upon media if they always shows positive side of government its very difficult to dethrown it
@@atulgautam4805 you are living in a different world if tou can't see media showing negatives of present government. Sometimes they are fake also. But many media houses are showing only bad or only good. It's simple, left vs right. And people don't want leftists.
For today's politicians a Manmohan Singh-Pranab Mukherjee situation would be a reason to clash and break out from service. However, these two individuals maturity never caused a single friction between them. But yes, in one way, they empowered Gandhis, something they shouldn't have. Something had they stood up against, perhaps would have made the political course of India a bit different.
#Retweet👇 #GodblessBengali #COMMUNITY #BENGALIS ARE LEGENDS.. THEY HAVE DONE SO MUCH FOR COUNTRY #ROYALBENGALTIGERS OF #BENGALI COMMUNITY WILL START TO RULE THE WORLD AND UNIVERSE VERY VERY SOON👍👍COUNTRY IN EVERY SECTOR AND FIELD GOD BLESS #BENGALI COMMUNITY #JusticeForSubhas
@Muslimcel Gandhi pariwar kehi karan Congress ka ye haal hei. Congress me achhe logoki kami hei nehi but Gandhi logoke sab khatam kardiye hei. Inko inteospect karni chahiye
No one wants the Congress anymore. Them and their stupid secularism anymore. However I agree Pranab da was a truly great leader. He should have been in BJP RSS.
@@kumarsrikanthan5046 no way bro, not all people need to be slaves of rss, you gotta accept there are Good and bad people everywhere, even many rss people are bad.
@@hyronium5752 taking a stint at the situations in bengal, and how it'll be in kerala in 5 years, bip and rss is very much needed, if congress had some actual leaders, itld wouldve been great
This man single handedly made India shoot itself in the foot because of his humongous ego. The retrospective tax was such an anti India move that it almost completely destroyed any scope of future FDI into India. Horrible horrible neta. If he was a favourite neta then I can see why china is where it is in comparison
Such an amazing person... must've stood as PM candidate in 2004... wouldve made much needed reforms... and brought the Congress out of doom and corruption
@@hansdsouza economy isnt the only job of the PM though. Pranab da wouldve been a much better PM in general. More strict with allies and ministers. Defence files wouldve come to the PM first before going to 10,Janpath
What a great son of India.The late president was liked by all parties. Bengal has produced lot of brilliant intellects and our late president is one of them. May his soul rest in peace
Just compare Lives of LK Advani and Pranab Mukherjee: both didnt get to become PM,ok? But one got President post,Bharat Ratna and was called Father-like by his opposition's party's leader. Whereas one neither got President post despite his party being in power and sidelined in his own party and definitely won't be getting Bharat Ratna.
RIP Pranab Da 🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
Congress and India would have been different if Pranab da was PM and if Sonia was not there.
It was not only Pranab Mukherjee lost Prime Ministership but P.C. Alexander also lost Prasidentship of lndia due to the crooked and tactical advice of some Congress leaders.
If sonia wasn't there then congress would have finished in 1999 man fool. Go and see history first
Y u guys hate Sonia so much? It was upa which gave rti to mgnrega. She is from Italy that's the biggest mistake. But she completely changed here. Y u guys can't understand anything. She lost everything, she refused to join politics but she was convinced and brought congress back to power.
@@vv-sz4yhThat Antonio Maino has no contribution rather than increasing the no of members of parliament,no NRIs in India ,and also burden on this country
This clip isn’t complete without Rajdeep Sardesai 🙊😂😂😂
😂😂
😂
Rajdeep: Bhaiya galti se nikal gayi muh se 😂😂
😂😂
Great achievement throughout life.Thanks, your contribution in framing India will be evergreen
And BJP gave him Bharat Ratna !!
How ironic.
Even TRS, TDP and BJP rever Narsimha rao too but no one speaks about him in Congress.
What a family corporation Congress is !! 😐
Congress party lacks a trouble shooter. Party lacks vission. Party sees gains in the utter failures.
I am a strong BJP supporter...But I like Pranab da🙂🙂🙂
He is from our lovely state wb.
Kabhi Ana Bengal mein.😊
All hiel to our fascist leader modi
@@brianjongwe9824 ha zarrron aahuga eek dan
Me too bhai. BJP supporter who likes Pranab Mukherjee.
@@sharathchandragaddam3971me too.....
Finally Thank you Crux waiting for your files since a long time
We want PV Narasimha raos episode
Sonia Gandhi meeting with Putin!!! Wtf.. Who is she to conduct such a meeting..?? Head of congress!! Imagine JP Nadda conducting a meeting with Jo Biden without Modi or president.
😂😂
Can u pls make a crux files on Jyoti Basu.. Its a earnest request..
I do not like Jyoti Basu's attitude and his authoritarian regime , but, he was a really great political thinker
@@comradebrother7411 That is completely your view my friend. I respect that.. But all i requested is a episode on him. because what I see is that this channel is completely unbiased. Which is very hard to remain nowadays.. Good job CRUX
@@sankhyasen3368 correct
Wait till he's dead
@@karthikn8536 My dear learned friend Jyoti Basu died 10 years ago. On 17th January 2010
9:42 same thing happening now with Nirmala tayi.
It's Nirmala sitharaman ig
But, he had done excellent for the economy, she hasn't.
correction , it is Vidyasagar College not Vidya nagar college
Pranab Da was a great leader. India is blessed to have such leaders.
He was one of the last few true Hindus and nationalists that the Congress had. True patriot who had actually worked behind the scenes a lot to stop the worst of the Congress’ worst excesses. But for him our country would have been in even greater danger during the UPA era. That’s y BJP RSS ppl had a lot of regards for him. Still do. Especially Modi and Amit Shah.
That is why he was given the Bharat Ratna by BJP.
He was a skilled and witty speaker!!
Pranab Da RIP 🙏🏻
India well matched #PrimeMinister ...
She didnt refused prime ministership as pm, Indian constitution saved us, #Everyone ☮
Please make videos on late leaders like Jayaprakash Narayanan, lal Bahadur shastri, etc
Mukherjee jaise vafadar kam hain Scindia ko dekho jis thali mein khaya usimein chedh kiya💪💯
speaking out the bad deeds matters too
Sahi kaha
ya he remains congress MP so many times ,and what kamalnath got till now , everyone should get oppurtunity ,schindiya should wait for his opportunity
@@atulgautam4805 Scindia was opportunist just like his grandmother Raj mata Scindia,who collapsed government of congress in Madhya Pradesh and become Bjp founding member.
@@adarsh3179 everyone is opportunist
I am very proud of this man. 💛
I don't know who the hell disliked it
i voted for BjP...but i like Pranab ji for his intellligence
Rest in peace 🙏 sir
We miss you
Another reason to hate congress " didn't gave have him PM run but served it to Rahul baba 😐
Karan thapar critical taunting bring everyone to the edge
What About = New "Policy" = That We ( i ) Demand ?🙏
If u have money then u will be in parliament for 5 yrs... but, if u r guru in dealing political issues... u will be for 50 yrs in parliament ...
I am from Bengal and I am also a strong supporter of BJP although Pranab Mukherjee is always respected by me
You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough
Agree friends ? 😊
He was the first person from West Bengal to hold the post of President of India. In a political career spanning five decades, Mukherjee was a senior leader in the Indian National Congress and occupied several ministerial portfolios in the Government of India.
Indo-us nuclear deal paved the future of our nuclear industry and secured our nuclear deterrence as well. Truly a great personality.
Even a single visit in RSS lead the Congress completely avoid all his works
The PM we never had, thanks to dynasty politics
People are saying that he could be PM candidate but i feel Dr manmohan singh was no less than him.
Series he was freedom fighter man
Pitaji Pahele Aap 🙏😀😀😀
Pranab Mukherjee could've become PM. But, Sonia Gandhi gave chance to MMS for a reason.
Yes so that he could be a silent PM, and so that all other ministers could do scams and earn money
@@prernagoyal7002 Silent PM was never afraid to give Press conference's. No one is more corrupt than BJP. Corruption is present in all parties.
@@hansdsouza yes and that's why after 60 years of congress rule, after so many 5 year plans, Indians are still poor
Though I don’t support congress, I fee Pranab da would have been a better and a strong PM than Dr Singh. I felt Dr Singh was quiet or forced to keep quiet on many issues. Pranab had a better vision and the ability to work with others on the grounds of national development.
Bengal Ho = Itne Question To Banta Hain To ?🙏😀😀😀
Namoh
#Retweet👇
#GodblessBengali #COMMUNITY
#BENGALIS ARE LEGENDS.. THEY HAVE DONE SO MUCH FOR COUNTRY
#ROYALBENGALTIGERS OF #BENGALI COMMUNITY WILL START TO RULE THE WORLD AND UNIVERSE VERY VERY SOON👍👍COUNTRY IN EVERY SECTOR AND FIELD GOD BLESS #BENGALI COMMUNITY #JusticeForSubhas
🙏😀😀😀 Pakarliya 😁😁
Please make a video about kcr
🙏😀😀😀
To = Give me more 5 Years ?🙏😁😁😁
And yet some people can’t pronounce my name properly 😓
Baseless & Working on = Metro = ?🙏😇
Still Modi is Great Actor 😉
😁😁😁😁😁 my father not leader so I do work in company
Pranab Mukherjee : Economy & corruption grew
Nirmala Sitharaman : Economy & corruption declined
Perfectly put.
India is most corrupt country in Asia
@rahul Dio see I gave u link
ua-cam.com/video/507yi0a5S3I/v-deo.html
Lol. Gas 1000 crossed
HE IS THE MASTER MIND , DESTROYING OF BANGLADESHI DEMOCRACY .
Keno bolchen
Huh ? Kichu bujhlam na
@@xenomoe9519 Do you remember 1/11 aftermath..?
@UCCM8j2aVw4FbM2Uw-g7wrrg apni ki Jokhono Pakistan k dosarop korechen, 1971 er aage Bangladeshe loot, rape, aar mass killing er jonno? Seta Kokhono pathay aase?
@@xenomoe9519 দূর মিয়া এ কথা বলে ফয়দা নিবেন আর কতদিন । কৃতজ্ঞতা কম প্রকাশ করিনি ।
খাওয়ার ইতিহাস শিখেছে
Remove the nepotism and he would have been congress leader in 1984
Congress can rise again, just need a change of leadership
Congress Needs to set back right
Gandhis should be given a ceremonial positions but not ruling positions
But by seeing current situation , it seems that bjp might again come with majority in 2024 , congress should forget 2024 better plan for 2029
Stop gloryfying him..He was the worst Finance Minister
When world went through global recession india's gdp growth rate was 8% and FYI former finance minister "Arun Jaitley did not know much about economics"said by an MP of BJP
14:30 and 17:40 full nautanki 😂😂😂
No
Yes
@@rupeshreddy1713 no
Had it not been for Sonia Gandi he would have been the PM and a great one at that!
Manmohanji is also a great man and deserved that position .
@@freeman4899
He was a great man with zero power. When he did have power though - like when he was Finance Minister in 1991 he took India strides ahead!
Most of the reforms that the BJP is making right now would have already been made like GST, Aadhaar, Insolvency & Bankruptcy Act, Land Reforms and now Farm Reforms.
@@tejasdeepsingh456 That's why BJP has come to the power , Manmohanji was pretty much powerless person many people call him mounamohan, except that nuclear deal , I don't remember anything good happened in his tenure .
@@freeman4899 don't worry, even manmohan doesn't remember 😂
Had he been the PM, India would have gone all out Socialist mode, and that would have been disastrous.
This biography videos of politicians made by crux channel is more informative and unbiased and I am a regular follower of your videos ❤️❤️❤️
I wish UPA would have given him PM's seat. Just because of Gandhi family, the efficient leaders of Congress have always been ignored. Otherwise our country would have developed a lot
Congress has Developed this country. You can't just see what MMS did. Pranab Mukherjee was President, what more do you want.
I seriously wouldn't say Former PM Singh was incompetent he was the most qualified person to hold the post as well as he ran it very efficiently. Moving our country's gdp from 500bn to 2tr. I would also add he was not corrupt not one percent.Still Former President Pranabji would have been great too no doubt about that.
@@theultimateshield5133 Singh was chosen over Pranab because Sonia very well knew Pranab will never become her puppet unlike Singh. India would have been 20 years ahead if he was PM instead of Singh.
Same is now also happening in the bjp actual performers are sidelined and hatemongerers are promoted now instead of gandhi loyalists
@@aryaaswale7316Modi is a hatemonger
#PranabMukherjee would have been a #PM that matters for #India
Then BJP didn't get in power in 2014
@@shree_ram_5971 Rightly said
@@shree_ram_5971 ya bro congress is the one who destroyed his own career.
@@shree_ram_5971 Had BJP won 2004, ABV would have retired in 2005 end Iike he did and Advani would have become PM atleast till 2009. Then, if he had/hadn't made trip to Pakistan and praised Jinnah and then Jaswant writing book on him would have been interesting. Maybe INC would have won 2009. Then 2014 would surely have been different. Also, Pramod Mahajan and Modi were severe Adversaries. Had Mahajan not died in 2006 and With Rajnath-Gadkari-Sushma-Shivraj-Vasundhra-Gopinath Munde (not including Jaitley and Parrikar as they supported Modi after 2002), Modi-Shah wouldn't have been able to get BJP in his hands.
obviously, he becomes everyone's favorite after he died...and that's just not the case with him.
Was he hated when he was alive?
@@bd3675 no, not at all n
There was a time... When people like Pranab Mukherjee, APJ Abdul Kalam, Manmohan Singh, Atal ji, Joyti Basu.. left, Right or Center.. these guys were genius.
Now all are a piece of shit
The Prime Minister who wasn’t 😢
Pranab Da... We need more men like him in India's politics..!!
TMC goon will kill that leader
@@shaileshagrawal7242 hahaha u r absolutely true man😂😂
he could have been the pm but the nepotism did not let him be
4:47 thats when congress started falling
that's could happen now also bjp also may start falling but it depends upon media if they always shows positive side of government its very difficult to dethrown it
@@atulgautam4805 you are living in a different world if tou can't see media showing negatives of present government. Sometimes they are fake also. But many media houses are showing only bad or only good. It's simple, left vs right. And people don't want leftists.
Dada will be remembered
You are here too....😂
@@gumnaamhaikoyi_who why he is everywhere ?
@@gumnaamhaikoyi_who i saw him yesterday
For today's politicians a Manmohan Singh-Pranab Mukherjee situation would be a reason to clash and break out from service. However, these two individuals maturity never caused a single friction between them. But yes, in one way, they empowered Gandhis, something they shouldn't have. Something had they stood up against, perhaps would have made the political course of India a bit different.
Pls can ur next video be about jyoti basu or karunanidhi plsss
#Retweet👇
#GodblessBengali #COMMUNITY
#BENGALIS ARE LEGENDS.. THEY HAVE DONE SO MUCH FOR COUNTRY
#ROYALBENGALTIGERS OF #BENGALI COMMUNITY WILL START TO RULE THE WORLD AND UNIVERSE VERY VERY SOON👍👍COUNTRY IN EVERY SECTOR AND FIELD GOD BLESS #BENGALI COMMUNITY #JusticeForSubhas
Joy bangla! Let's reunite bengal and free our homeland from islamism
@@comradebrother7411 your name is contradictory to your comment 😂😂😂
He contested his first election in 1980
He would've been prime minister if Sonia Gandhi didn't take over party
Proud of My Hero❤️
He aslo knows I have no choice in it, what a shame. A prime minister of india😳.
4:49 😅😅😅
He, vajpayee jee and somewhat I personally feel Sashi tharoor are really "Man of all seasons" of modern Indian politics.
4:48 😂
4:55🙏🙏😂😂
04:45 What a pity..!
Congress just need a good leader like him to return to power
@Muslimcel Gandhi pariwar kehi karan Congress ka ye haal hei. Congress me achhe logoki kami hei nehi but Gandhi logoke sab khatam kardiye hei. Inko inteospect karni chahiye
No one wants the Congress anymore. Them and their stupid secularism anymore. However I agree Pranab da was a truly great leader. He should have been in BJP RSS.
@@kumarsrikanthan5046 no way bro, not all people need to be slaves of rss, you gotta accept there are Good and bad people everywhere, even many rss people are bad.
@Siddhesh Arora Thi Lekin Now We dont Need BJP or Rss , Become Atmarnirbhar
@@hyronium5752 taking a stint at the situations in bengal, and how it'll be in kerala in 5 years, bip and rss is very much needed, if congress had some actual leaders, itld wouldve been great
This man single handedly made India shoot itself in the foot because of his humongous ego. The retrospective tax was such an anti India move that it almost completely destroyed any scope of future FDI into India. Horrible horrible neta. If he was a favourite neta then I can see why china is where it is in comparison
Pranab da we all love you ❤️
Such an amazing person... must've stood as PM candidate in 2004... wouldve made much needed reforms... and brought the Congress out of doom and corruption
MMS still handled it well. Pranab Mukherjee wouldn't have handled economy better than MMS.
@@hansdsouza economy isnt the only job of the PM though. Pranab da wouldve been a much better PM in general. More strict with allies and ministers. Defence files wouldve come to the PM first before going to 10,Janpath
Micheal Corleone vibes....
Why don't talk CRUX about shameless congress treating him badly .
Respect 🙏🏿 to this man
What a great son of India.The late president was liked by all parties.
Bengal has produced lot of brilliant intellects and our late president is one of them.
May his soul rest in peace
𝒏𝒆𝒙𝒕 𝒔𝒕𝒐𝒓𝒚 𝒐𝒇 𝒂𝒏𝒏𝒂 𝒉𝒂𝒛𝒂𝒓𝒆
one video on George Fernandes
Just compare Lives of LK Advani and Pranab Mukherjee: both didnt get to become PM,ok?
But one got President post,Bharat Ratna and was called Father-like by his opposition's party's leader.
Whereas one neither got President post despite his party being in power and sidelined in his own party and definitely won't be getting Bharat Ratna.
Welcome to 'Politics'.. 'Rajniti', 'Rajao ki niti'
@@somdeepkundu2506 True
Want Joyti Basu vedio ❤️✊
Congress nepotism sidelined so many good leaders.
Congress needs responsible leaders in driving seat else BJP wins even with all its flaws
Simplicity is the key to brilliance 🎓
A True Legend. Immense Respect 🙏
Respect Our Former President 🙏
not house wife say home maker
He is such a humble person ❤️ full respect sirr💖💖💯💯💯
UPA-2 should have been led by him. manmohan ji did well in UPA-1
Transfer some money to hdfc bank