Beyond Germany: The Internationalisation of the War | Thirty Years War 3
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 тра 2024
- Claim your SPECIAL OFFER for MagellanTV here: try.magellantv.com/sandrhoman.... Start your 1 month free trial TODAY so you can watch “Ancient Warriors” and the rest of MagellanTV’s history collection: www.magellantv.com/series/anc...
In this video, we will look at what is referred to as the Palatinate Phase of the Thirty Years’ War. This phase is crucial to understand why the war exploded from a local conflict in Bohemia to a “European catastrophe and German Trauma” as the Professor of Political Theory Herfried Münkler aptly calls it.
Patreon (thank you): / sandrhomanhistory
Prints & T-Shirts: sandrhoman.creator-spring.com/
Paypal (thank you: www.paypal.com/paypalme/SandR...
Twitter: / sandrhoman
Chapters:
00:00-02:13 Internationalisation
02:13-03:24 MagellanTV
03:24-23:06 Palatinate Phase of the Thirty Years' War
#history #germany #education
Bibliography:
Guthrie, William, Battles of the Thirty Years War: From White Mountain to Nordlingen, 1618-1635, 2001.
Clifford, J. R., The military revolution debate. Readings on the military transformation of early modern Europe, 1995.
Clifford, J. R., Tactics and the Face of Battle, in: Tallet, F., (editor), European Warfare 1350-1750.
Frost, R., Northern Wars, State and Society in Northeastern Europe 1558-1721, 2000.
Höbelt, Lothar, Von Nördlingen bis Jankau. Kaiserliche Strategie und Kriegführung 1634-1645, 2016.
Münkler, Herfried, Der Dreißigjährige Krieg, Europäische Katastrophe, deutsches Trauma 1618 - 1648, 2019.
Parker, C., The Cambridge History of Warfare, 2005.
Roberts, M., Gustav Adolf and the Art of War (first printed 1955), in: Essays on Swedish History, 1967.
Rady, M., The Habsburgs, 2020.
Ribas, Alberto Raul Esteban, The Battle of Nördlingen 1634. The Bloody Fight Between Tercios and Brigades, 2021.
Spring, Laurence, The Battle of The White Mountain 1620 and the Bohemian Revolt 1618-1622, 2018.
Van Nimwegen, Olaf, The Dutch Army and the Military Revolutions, 1588-1688, 2010.
Von essen, M. F., The Lion from the North: Volume 1+2 The Swedish Army of Gustavus Adolphus, 2020.
Wilson, Peter, The Thirty Years War: Europe’s Tragedy, 2009.
Claim your SPECIAL OFFER for MagellanTV here: try.magellantv.com/sandrhomanhistory. Start your 1 month free trial TODAY so you can watch “Ancient Warriors” and the rest of MagellanTV’s history collection: www.magellantv.com/series/ancient-warriors
🙂🙃
😎
nice
If I had one florin for every time Bavaria oportunistically joins a major conflict in Europe to gobble up huge swathes of land without having to return it afterwards, I'd have 2 florins. Which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice.
Step 1: Gobble up land
Step 2: Complain that the people from the new land aren't "true" Bavarians
Step 3: ???
Step 4: Profit
@@Thraim. Saxony: Surprised Picachuface^^
Von Doofenschmirz of Bayern lol
Tell me about it. Franconia forever 😢
If I had a florin every time Bavaria was in a position to become a European great power in alliance with the strongest continental states but being dragged into global conflict where they couldn’t perform and lost because of their alliances I would have um 2 maybe 3 florins?
I’m referring to war of Spanish succession and war of Austrian succession but ig 30 years war could be included also since Bavaria almost became the hre but maxamillian didn’t want it.
The Dutch and harboring German exiles. A story as old as time. From Frederick V to Wilhelm II
bullshit
Frederick was born in a hunting lodge and stuck with spending money for leisure. When he received war funds from King James VI of Scotland and England he built a palace instead of getting an army.
10 000iq move
Dude was investing in the future of his realm, truly a giant of intellect.
@@mihovilraboteg6160 8 m n m
Based
Respect the grift
Had forgotten how much trying to follow the twists and turns of the Thirty Years' War gave me headaches :) Thanks for breaking it down into smaller chunks!
0:18 DAMN. Nevermind white mountain. Frederick will never recover from a burn such as this!
It seems so many defeats could be avoided by proper scouting.
12:13 It's crazy that my 12.000 inhabitants hometown is mentioned in such a video. But the name is "Ladenburg" not "Landenburg" and it was, as pounted out at 14:42 completely plundered by Mansfeld which marked the end of it's importance in the region.
Spain was literally everywhere lol
Gabor Bethlen is really not doing anything ever, is he? He is just kinda there too. Went along with the ride but was entirely unimportant.
I loved the format with which you explained this video, everything well summarized and objectively explained, means that this will be one of your best series on the channel. This phase is the one that is least commented on in the other UA-cam videos on the subject, just like the Danish one, so you did an excellent job; I would have liked to see the Battle of Fleurus (1622) as well, but since it was a fight outside the Holy Roman Empire, it makes sense that it was only mentioned (plus it is usually included as part of the 80 Years War, being a theme apart), but on the other hand, I welcome the fact that the other battles in this phase have been explained, since they are less well-known and that makes them more interesting, at the same time that it makes many characters stand out, such as Tilly, Mansfeld, Córdoba, etc. Ferdinand II of Habsburg made a big mistake at the end of this phase, his stupidity prolonged a war that could have been finished at that very moment if he had been lenient with the losers (he made the same mistake as Charles V several decades ago). =/
Interesting fact. The tree line where the imperial troops from Nürnberg and Würzburg stood at the battle of Wimpfen is still pretty much exactly in the same position, and it's where we camped at the 400 years anniversary of the battle.
Summon the elector counts, SandRhoman has dropped another video!
No mustache or beard worth of mention...damn poor Fred
You’re the best when it comes to the 16th and 17th centuries in Europe. Such an interesting mix of armies with the use of armor and firearms at the same time.
What a great in depth topic, i hope you could continue making this topic
more to come!
Awesome🎉 another great video! Keep up the great work can't wait for more of you're content
Thank you! More to come!
This was fantastic. I love the style and flow of this video and I always like Thirty Years' War as a topic.
I love these videos. Bravo!
A whole 7 days after upload, UA-cam finally manages to put this in my feed. Anyways, great video, always amazed with the quality and character!
A complete masterpiece!! It's great to see the evolution of this channel.
"Opposed by an ambitious young man named Wallenstein...." dun DUN DUNNNN!!!
Don't know why he calls him "Waldstein" though.
@@karlkarlos3545 Might be a translation difference. Probably how its spelled in the original German while Wallenstein is an English bastardization.
@@Boxghost102 No, he is only Wallenstein in German.
his name was indeed Waldstein, historiography has always called him Wallenstein though.
@@SandRhomanHistory The more you learn... thanks.
God damn that was complicated... but frickin great! Thanks for this as always
very nicely done, thanks for the video of good info.
brilliantly explained much that i did not know
Thanks a lot your vids are great.
Glad you like them!
UA-cam needs more content like this keep up the good work :)
Thank you for the nice enlightening videos.
Glad you like them!
Very informative. Thank you.
Thanks for watching!
Thank you for including the combat at Waidhaus and the battle of Mingolsheim. I wrote about Mingolsheim at our blog and described it differently. But I think that the battle is more complex then Wimpfen and White Mountain to reflect in a short time. Great video. I love your way to use contemporary paintings in your own artwork.
Yessss more content 👍👍👍👍
great video i read Herfried münklers book about the Thirty Years war and i love your sreies,it is especially great if your new to it you really go into deatail
Very interesting! Thanks for your efforts. Protestants no unified command & a lack of co-ordination. River crossings always a hazardous undertaking especially if you don't know where the enemy is.
Looking forward to the next episode 😀
Thank you for this awesome video!
are you the real account?
@@gabrielvanhauten4169 Yup!
Awesome as always
Thank you! Cheers!
Like you other videos. Love this series so far
Glad you enjoy it!
Incredible!
Cool video and great topic
Thanks!
Please more videos. I love these
more to come!
And it all started with three guys tossed out of a window 🙄
Nothing beats defenestration.
Nicely done video
Thanks for the visit
@@SandRhomanHistory---Your welcome. I often find your video's to be very interesting and informative.
This is lovely.
The biggest city in Baden today Karlsruhe, near Knielingen as mentioned in the video didnt exist back then closeby there is Durlach (today part of Karlsruhe).
I’m addicted to this Thirty Years War content
glad to hear it!
Hey man, great vid as always, been a fan of your work for quite some time and I was wondering whether a series specifically centered around the lives of the great military minds of the 16-17th century (Gustavus Adolphus, Turenne, Condé, Maurits of Nassau etc.) was something you'd consider doing ?
Yeah, we’re thinking about that!
@@SandRhomanHistory don't forget Prince Rupert of the Rhine, one of the most amazing commanders of the century
Thanks
I have a growing suspicion that the cossacks you are mentioning in the video are in fact not cossacks. To be honest I know they are not cossacks and you are in fact referring to Lisowczycy cavalry sent by Sigismund.
But otherwise, it is a great video. Can't wait for the next part.
These videos are a lot of fun.
I'm Polish, I don't know what nationality you are. I would like to say that I like to think I am pretty good at History. I am astutely aware of my birthcountries border history with countries like Germany and Russia. I am also aware of people being misinformed about this and also having a personal opinion/bias. To conclude I trust everything you say that I don't know about history. This is because you have always handled the subjects relevant to me with great care, professionalism and truth. They match up with what I know. Thank you for your videos. Much respect x
Not a good time to be alive in my home region, the Palatinate ...the Spanish in Frankenthal, the Bavarians in Heidelberg, later shortly interrupted by a Swedish occupation and finally complemented by the French in Philippsburg. All these soldiers forcing you to supply them or outright pillaging and murdering. Not easy to survive. But seen from today, a fascinating history!
Nice work on the animated rooster.🐓
We Dutchies stood alongside our German protestant brothers 👍 as they stood with us in our 80 year war against Spain.
Contra España? No había muchos españoles al servicio del rey en Flandes, la mayoría obviamente, eran valones católicos, pero es no son tus hermanos verdad? Solo hay que ver que hicisteis con ellos.
Aquello no fue una guerra de independencia contra los españoles, fue una rebelion contra el soberano legitimo que se enquisto en una guerra de civil entre los católicos fieles la rey de España y los protestantes rebeldes que paoyaban a las provincias holandesas. Si, los tercios subieron con españoles, pero la mayoría eran alemanes o italianos, y hubo gobernadores y oficiales españoles, pero cuántos hubo de Italia, valones o bávaros? Al rey católico lo servían multitud de nacionalidades, y en Flandes la.mayoria de los que luchaban por el de castellanos tenían poco, como es obvio. Cada país tiene su propaganda histórica por diferentes motivos, y entiendo que en el mito de fundacion holandés por ejemplo,aucha contra el invasor español es importante y tal, pero en un canal especializado como este, estaría bien que pudiésemos observar los hechos históricos de una forma más amplia y objetiva y no hacerlo de forma simplista y viéndolo con los ojos de hoy y los sentimientos nacionales de hoy en día.
Thirty years war is such a convoluted mess.
Such a great channel just curious how close are y'all to 600 a month in support and donations
450/600 at the moment!
22:14
States Rights to what?!
......Oh wait this isnt the Civil war
Well, it kinda is, just not the American one.
But to answer the question: In this instance, a right to self determine what form of Christianity to adhere to.
Yeah, there's no right to be a heretic.
The Germans always resist centralization to this day, only during NS era that they actually living in centralized state.
18:34 to 18:35
What was up with the subtitles there? Was a section of the video cut in editing?
yeah that was cut. probably some error in the audio or we deemed unnecessary.
I always think of upper to mean north and lower to mean south. Nice of the HRE to make it east and west. Also Saxony moving east from being west 5 centuries earlier. I need to pay careful attention to not get confused by the geography and titles of the German nobility and regions.
"Upper" and "lower" usually refers to the elevation of the land here; the mountainous regions are "up", the flat regions are "low". Even today there is the German state of Lower Saxony in the north German flatlands (named after the earlier Saxons you mentioned; the current anthem of Lower Saxony mentions Widukind, the Saxon leader of the resistance against Charlemange ) northwest of Saxony, and the region of Lower Bavaria is north of the more alpine Upper Bavaria.
It shows how we modern people look at the world through maps with cardinal directions in mind, while the people back then only had the perspective of their own eyes.
Meanwhile in Egypt "upper" means south, "lower" is north (referring to the flow of the Nile, Upper Egypt is upstream, Lower Egypt is the delta region).
also Lower Austria is in the north-east part of the country. But I was confused by that too when I was young. I even remember we learned about Upper Egypt in school and no one clarified why it is called Upper Egypt when it is in south...
Hint: the closer it to the see usually it is "lower" in name.
Yes!!
At 9:05 or so, when speaking of Germersheim, you missed the first r and said Gemersheim.
when is the next one
It's always a bad sign when you get remembered by history as a fuck up enough to get a nickname. Because that shit STICKS
Britney Spears was clearly inspired by the 30 years wars when she wrote "toxic" (?)
The chicken animation 🤌🤌
I'm sure Christian the Younger was really into chivalry, lol.
So…. The 30 year war was about state’s rights?!
Well, it was about Protestants VS Catholics at it's core, but also about power struggle as usual, most wars tend to have multiple reasons.
Holy Roman Empire was not a complete unified nation, it was a combined rule of multiple states and the split between Protestants VS Catholics evaporated the little unity they shared, some fought for their right to their religious belives, others used the situation to grow personal power/influence, and the habsburg sought to secure their dominance and become a more solidified absolute ruler of the empire.
You can compare it to USA in a lot of ways, with how each state had more otomoty earlier, the war was similar to the civil war of USA just different reasons for a war, and habsburg line tried to make the Holy Roman Empire more into a single nation that they had absolute control over rather then minor power over.
Sort of. It was a conflict mainly driven by a north-German desire to oppose the more powerful south-Germans without directly opposing the emperor.
The religious aspect is overemphasized. Much like the crusades, religion was just a convenient excuse for weaker nobles to grab more wealth and influence.
This is why Catholic France and Sunny Ottomans supported the protestants, to erode the power of Austria and Spain, and further divide their enemies.
3:37 polish south border looks kinda strange
Just like when you've fought a bigger army in Mount and Blade and you lose everything from suffering a string of defeats and forced to fight for another faction for coin.
👍👍
👍👍👍
Holy shit, that's lots of people doing lots of stuff with lots of shifting alliances.
It's a miracle the HRE lasted as long as it did.
true. it was quite a messy war.
Hey sandrhoman history chanel guys. Have you heard of the tartar empire? Are those waters to deep for you?
We are right there again
when more Forces enter
and no way to STOP
Total War
total destruction
Hate
for Generations
"Emperor Palatine" is all I can think off😬
0:20 he fell of with the facial hair insult. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
we still use them in the arab world as a complement and an insult.
9000 Cossacks?
It was the Polish Lisowczycy, which were mentioned in the previous episode. They were 'cossacks', which is a type of natively Polish light cavalry and, confusingly, shares the name with the Zaporozhian and other Cossacks.
Top
Again, if Sultan Osman II decided to launch his own Siege of Vienna instead of going to battle against the Commonwealth of Poland and Lithuania, the Ottoman Empire will officially joined the Thirty Years' War and might actually seized Vienna and held it for a few generations.
Yeah, sure..
GeRmersheim not Gemersheim, my dear Swiss friends. Ts ts ts
Or if you wanna go local: 's Germersche 😏
Always thought he said Gamers' Heim
Count Palpatine, Holy Roman Emperor
It's "Wallenstein" not "Waldstein".
his name was in fact waldstein. historiography has called him wallenstein for whatever reason. maybe due to schiller.
@@SandRhomanHistory Really? Interesting, never heard that. But happy to learn something new!
More Disney animals….such an odd choice 🤦🏼♂️
The Swedes helped end the 30 years war
Sweden prolonged the war by 18 years.
Yes, by losing.
Sweden helped the 30 years war become famous. You can’t deny it.
This is why Freemasons had to destroy the Spanish Empire from within , the Spanish Empire when United is simply unstoppable.
Freemasons? You mean the Spanish monarchy being the greatest tyrany ever? In 1558 catholic Germans were so tired of Spanish depravations that they banned them from their lands
Yep. Just like they did to the Romanovs/Russia 300 years later.
@@il_solitario55 They got them too ? 😂 how many empires have these mfs destroyed ?
@@hugojaime9565 All of them I think.
@@il_solitario55Damn i love Freemasons now
I see no reason for you to say the old timey name of "The Hague" Ive heard that most people these days refer to it as "Den Haag" no matter the language they speak.
we use the English version if it exists. if not we try to say the names as they would be pronounced in their respective languages.
@@SandRhomanHistory In my opinion in english Den Haag is more popular than The Hague, atleast online.
'S-GRAVENHAGE!
@@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 I have never heard it referred to as anything other than The Hague in English.
@@Fronzel41 I think Ive heard The Hague twice, Ive heard Den Haag a dozen times (in english).
🙂🙃🙃
How come there's people whose name is "Christian" but there's not people whose name is "Muslim" or "Jewish"?
Some muslims have "muslim" in his/her name such as "Muhammad Muslim" or "Ayu Muslimah". Idk with the jews one tho.
It would REALY help if you refrained from using the Germanized names of people and places. . It is doubtful that most people seeing this realize you are doing it. For example, Albrecht Wenzel Eusebius von Wallenstein IS Czech: Albrecht Václav Eusebius z Valdštejna and was a Bohemian.
He was German.
The part of Bohemia were he was born did almost exclusively speak German. Don't know why you desperately want him to be Chech. It's like Poles claiming numerous German scientists because they were born in lands that are part of the polish state today lmao
@@helmuthvonmoltke5518 XDDDDD it is litrly on any sorse you can finde he was Czech
@@helmuthvonmoltke5518 + When do you think Germans got there ??? first, come in 1240 but that was already after the Waldstein existed. the one who built the castle Waldstain (Jaroslav z Hruštice) was born before that and came from an even older Czech aristocratic family.
@@helmuthvonmoltke5518 personally I am Czech but most of my blood is Germanic origin my family not like the other Germans helped Czechs in ww2 so we were allowed to stay and we enjoy living here and if you look newest genetical data Czechs have more Germanic ancestors than Austrians so i do not care why he could not be a normal Czech German like me and most others.
@@marskavols1073dirty slav
Poland lost its opportunity to reclaim Silesia and Lusatia during this conflict. What a waste.
I think "what a waste" is more or less the official tagline of the _30 Years War._
How was it possible for Ottomans to be involved in a catholic versus protestant christian conflict :)
Because it was politically expedient for them. The wars would weaken the Empire
They surely benefited from religious conflict in Europe but they didn't. The Europeans would be grateful to the Ottomans by always meddling in Ottoman internal affairs in 19th-20th century(Muhammad Ali's rebellion, Crimean war, Arab uprising etc).
They actually had been allies of the French against the Habsburgs since the middle of the 16th century. The french kings, who styled themselves as "The Most Christian Kings", were not all to keen to make that alliance public, though.
@Lukas Wilhelm True, but we see that in hindsight. In the 16th and 17th centuries, it was a wise policy for any Sultan to play one European power against another, and the French were always willing if it meant weakening the Hapsburgs.
Catholiesm aint Christian
Can someone translate that into English?
@@eldorados_lost_searcher "Catholicism isn't Christian"
@@gergelylaszlo5463
Thanks.
Now I'd like to get a second opinion on whether or not Catholicism is or is not Christian, and an explanation of what actually qualifies as Christianity if it doesn't.
Indeed, Orthodoxy is the only correct Christian faith ☦️☦️☦️
/s
Everything in Catholicism is biblical.
Neither holy, nor roman, nor an empire
True 😂
@@JulesXu
No, don't listen to this shit talking French expat.
Especially because its nonsense in English
jew