Roland FP10 vs Yamaha P45 Digital Piano Comparison - Which One Would You Prefer?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 тра 2019
- Roland's latest addition to their FP line of pianos, the FP-10, offers a tremendous amount of features at an affordable price point. But how does it stand up against Yamaha's venerable P-45? Both fall under the $500.00 price range, offer weighted keys, multiple sounds, varying levels of touch sensitivity, and so much more. We're curious as to what you think and would love to hear your feedback in the comment below. Play A Note, Change Your Life!
#digitalpiano #yamaha #roland #p45 #fp10 #pianocomparison
8: 42 Roland FP-10 → www.alamomusic.com/roland-fp-...
18:33 Yamaha P45 → www.alamomusic.com/yamaha-p-4...
Download our free piano buyers guide here → www.alamomusic.com/discover-m...
____________________________________________________________________
? Talk to an expert here → www.alamomusic.com/find-your-...
♪ Contact us: www.alamomusic.com/contact
♩ Call toll-free: (844)251-1922
♬ Connect:
Twitter → / alamomusic
Instagram → / alamomusic
Facebook → / alamomusiccenter
SOUND COMPARISON:
Roland FP10: 8:42
Yamaha P45: 18:33
thx
@@makotoozawa6018 shame the recording is only in MONO so there's little chance of actually hearing what these instruments actually sound like!
You can't do a sound comparison through your phone's / tablets speakers....
@@smokey6455 I bought the FP10 and it is a very nice sounding piano. I also have an RD2000 and while the FP-10 is not quite in that league it is just as pleasant to sit and play.
God bless you
Is that Yamaha P45 has ear trainning function ?
Cause saw FP10 has in the IOs/Android app..
Very helpful. Thank you.
I'm currently comparing these two digital pianos,so this video helps me decide thank you.
Great!
Great in depth review I’m still a beginner and I currently am playing a Casio but when I get better I’m looking to get a full 88 key Yamaha
Fantastic instruments!
Yamaha would be my preference ... But for the price range ... at this time , it seems to me that the Roland fp10 has some features that would appeal to me over the Yamaha p45 (which has been my preferred one for beginners fir the longest , until Roland came out with the FP10 )
But Yamaha has more of the sounds that I prefer .
Pros- The Roland fo10 has triple sensor triggering .... The Yamaha doesn’t ..... The Roland has 92 (or something polyphony ..) . The Yam’ p45 has 64 notes polyphony ... Thr Roland fp10 can trigger midi wirelessly / Bluetooth ...
Cons - The Roland fp10 has headphone jack out (1/8th inch). The Yam p45 had standard 1/4 out (more professional... )
So far , the Roland fp10 seems to be the over all midi controller for a compact inexpensive Midi’s controller for a professional pianist who wishes to trigger software sounds from MacBook Pro , any computer ... iPad , iPhones .... and have not only piano like feel in action & response (including fast repeats in one key with one hand or finger .... ).
I tend to prefer Yamaha piano sounds over Roland ... but the Yamaha p45 is so dated in comparison to the Roland since the recent issue of the Ro’ fp10.
For a professional seeking an inexpensive piano like trigger ,,, (to trigger softwares like Keyscape by Spectrasoic .... ravenscroft piano software ... native instruments ... or any other great sounding acoustic piano sounding commuter software sounds sourced , or iPad / iphone sound sources ... etc ... ) I think thus far , Roland is the preferred ins between the two .
I still prefer Yamaha keys over Roland in general ..
But fir the inexpensive route .. at the price level ... for me professionally .. since Roland has come out with this fp10 .. it seems to appeal to me more for the objectives I’ve mentored above .
But other than the Roland Fp10 Yamaha would be my preference
good review :)
I love the P-45! It's the most beaultiful sound beginners friendly digital you can start with. I might be talking bs but I felt the Roland FP 10 keys were too heavy. Heavier than the acoustic piano I played.
You can really hear the difference here
ROLAND 9:13
YAMAHA 19:06
Roland has the feel
I have always preferred the feel of Roland keyboards.
Yamaha realistic
I’ve never really liked the sound of Yamaha keyboards, even their acoustic pianos just don’t seem to sing enough for me.
@@elthpiano I guess it is a personal thing, for me it is 100% the Yamaha.
Roland FP10, Yamaha P45 or Casi Cdp s100?
Roland fp10 Bluetooth is perfect for learning
I'm a Roland A49 player but looking for an 88 keyboard with weighted keys that feel like a real piano.. but I'm stuck in choosing between the Roland fP10 - Roland GO:PIANO 88
CkBahadir i think go piano is not weighted keys
@@vincentlouieong oh really? Well then i'm going for the fp10 hahaha..
My next question is do the fp10 keys make sound? Like annoying sounds when you press them? My cheap old 80$ casio keyboard did that and it annoyed the hell out of me.. now I'm using a Roland a49 which is really fun but it does not have weighted keys and it's a 49 key midi keyboard..
CkBahadir not really but I guess if you press too hard or with real force. I have an fp10. Its really a good weighted keyboard. Go test first before buying but I am quite sure youll be happy with it
@@vincentlouieong yeah I will test it in the coming days. :D
My last question: is it like a midi keyboard ?can you connect it to a computer to use it with a program like ableton live?
@@SianCKB yes it has a fairly good MIDI spec and will work through USB, the FP-10 key bed is quiet and feels well. Glad you did not buy the Go piano, as it is terrible and not worth touching.... the FP-10 will serve you well. It has a good velocity curve and for MIDI performance and VSTi use on a DAW it is a good option and very inexpensive for a 88-note weighted piano keyboard.
How about the clicking noise of the keys? For some reason, none of the reviewers dont mentions this misunderstanding. After a week of using the FP-10, the keys start to click. This is due to the mechanics of the keyboard and the using of grease under the keys. The problem is very common, there are many discussions on Reddit about this. Owned FP10, the key click problem was confirmed. Loved this instrument, but this clicking issue is really disappointing. Roland needs fp10 quality control.
You're posting this on every fp10 video. Not everyone is having this issue. Every keyboard have their own issues.
I am using the p45 it's been almost 2 year still works like new. The sound is not bad to my ears.
@@eyesofvenus If there is a good chance I will run into this problem, I want to know. Tell me what's wrong with that? Maybe they decided a better keyboard raises the price too much. That's fine, Roland just be honest about it.
Thanks for telling that
I’ve just bought a P45 and I really don’t like the piano sound. It’s so opaque! I wonder if I can adjust that in any possible form. Thanks if you know how.
Yes,you can play it with another sound by connecting It to a computer via midi and using a vst. You won't change the sound of the piano,you will transmit to the PC midi files (what key you pressed,how long,how hard you pressed,sustain...) and you will Play a virtual instrument.
I own a p45 myself and I recomend you using some good headphones! At the beginning I used to play with my everyday headphones and the sound looked so cunfused and digital,then I bought the "superlux hd861" on Amazon,they cost around 30€ and they're great headphones!
I'm telling you that because the p45's speakers aren't very good so the sound doesn't look great,but if you use good headphones (they don't have to be very expensive,I highily recomend you the superlux,they're often compared to 100€ headphones) then the sound will get much better!
About the superlux hd861...they're semi-open headphones so they don't isolate you from external sounds,it depends by your needing,I needed semi-open so they're perfect. If you need isolating headphones the superlux hd662 are close but they cost a bit more! (40/50€)
I hope I've helped you
If you don't want to use headphones you can change the sound with midi connection and play a vst,I'm not used to midi but there should be tutorials on the web
You must have tried and listened to the piano to be able to buy it, if you didn't like it, you didn't have to buy it
I just read de question... If you press function and the B flat under the C4, you'll get a birghter sound.
I like more Roland FP-10, because it sounds better and are more polyphony than Yamaha P-45. Thanks for comparison!!
Не ожидал увидеть РД-шника в комментариях под ТАКИМ видео.Это круто!)))
It kinda disappoints me that the keys start to click after 1 week.
Love the comments everyone thinking they are some sort of musical hearing expert :)) like TVs everyone is different. For a beginner both pianos are perfect. NO beginner has ever even heard of half the crap people are going on about so chill out. Its all about learning and playing later comes the the know how and the experience.
Don't you hear the difference? For me the Yamaha has a tone I reallly like, I wish the Roland would have that samples.
It's clear the Roland FP-10 is superior, which says no, means that his hearing is damaged 😀
I prefer the Yamaha
Can someone explain which is better and what is the difference between NUX NPK 10 and Roland FP 10?
It depends on the style you like. But I like Roland fp -10 better. Roland sounds softer and sweeter.
@@arunee9209 I went to the store and checked Nux is much better, brighter louder more functional, so you are wrong!!!
Under $500. FP10 is $750 🇨🇦 p45 is $660 🇨🇦
Really? The FP10 can be purchased for less than $750 AUSTRALIAN dollars, so that's crazy.
Super compact, super sleeek (mic dead) 1:10
Super slEEEEK
I hate that there is a sound when you play the key and I do not mean the sound of the piano strings.
?
The random occasional sound blaring from your microphone is weird and distracting. 18:24 just one example. "especially if you're *SITTING"*
apocalypseap I think it may have been his beard scraping against the lav mic, or the mic clip catching on his body as his shirt moved? It probably needed to be clipped further down on his shirt, as the levels were too low when he “talked away” from his body, too...
@@onshisan Yeah I kinda expect a channel focused around music to better handle sound in general. I haven't checked out many of his videos so hopefully it's fixed.
I bought the fp10 and got it home only to find out it has no outputs and no midi ports. Only USB and a 3.5mm headphone jack on the back. Unbelievable.
@@concert_band Yes it does, but what if you for example want to play your roland boutique synth with it, you can't, its either route it through a computer or buy an expensive box that converts the usb to midi. Even cheap toys have midi ports.
@@chris_nielsen the FP30 has what you need I believe
Same with the Yamaha.. most digital pianos in this range all lack midi ports. If you're tech savvy build a midi host using an old raspberry pi to play your synths. Good luck
I don’t understand your comment as at 6:15 we can clearly see that there’s a midi port output 🤔
Let's see, let's clarify the matter, the roland FP10 and the Yamaha P45 are cheap digital pianos, for that reason they are very limited and lack more connections.
Another detail is that traditional 5-pin MIDI ports are already obsolete today, for that reason is that old keyboards have those MIDI connections, so does the Yamaha P35, which is the one before the P45.
Piano companies are putting more connections like traditional MIDI in more expensive keyboards like the Yamaha P515, because what is usually used now is a USB host that connects it to the PC with a printer cable, it is something more modern, it What you need is to buy an 88-key MIDI controller since that keyboard is good for that
its a joke even to compare.. roland fp10 sounds and feels better than any yamaha instrument even flagmans. you can compare it to avantgrand series and still roland fp10 sounds better. comparing to p45 is a joke :D yamaha 125 actually is quite okay instrument to compare to fp10 because of its price.. but not p45. in the end even CP88 sounds plastic crap comparing to this cheapest roland.
Those are your tastes, there is nothing more to say
Yea the Cp88 sounds patches sucks and its too boomy
@@ayrtoninchejanampa6874 I like the Yamaha sound more
"really, really." "really? "patch?" "really, really:)?
Roland FP 10 has the best key action