State of Nation: Xenophobic violence in South Africa

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 157

  • @adammohamedkasai8675
    @adammohamedkasai8675 2 роки тому +22

    The hate on black to black is unbearable.. What a shame

  • @ShaunyKnuckles
    @ShaunyKnuckles 3 роки тому +31

    It's simply jealousy.
    I'm South African

  • @aomine6817
    @aomine6817 4 роки тому +31

    poor people fight each other while the rich whites sit in their villas in gated neighborhoods. top 10% takes home 65% of country's total income while the bottom 50% only gets less than 7%! this is what extreme inequality leads to.

    • @ltenclavesoldier9280
      @ltenclavesoldier9280 4 роки тому +3

      Capitalism for the win

    • @nonhlanhlanunsy9179
      @nonhlanhlanunsy9179 2 роки тому +1

      Neh😭😭 very sad

    • @noulafrantz8589
      @noulafrantz8589 Рік тому +1

      😢😢true and sad that's happened in the motherland

    • @gysgijsbers4202
      @gysgijsbers4202 Рік тому

      The rich in South Africa are not just white, there are now people of ALL RACES in the RICH category and people of ALL RACES in the POOR category, including whites. Most whites in South Africa are middle or below middle class.

  • @inyeekaribi4913
    @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому +10

    This is so weird to me. A few years ago, as an African person I was defending and fighting for the people in South Africa in front of UN panels and the World Bank who wanted to reduce/re-evaluate development funding. Countless calls, interviews, disturbing my supervisors day and night because “there must be another way” as given that I KNOW that Africans in my position are very few, I see myself and an African first, and I have to fight for Africa AS A WHOLE, because when I tell you these people don’t care, believe me, these people could NOT care less about what happens on the African continent. Strange to think that I could enter South Africa and they will still see me as a foreigner and call for my head because of it. Very interesting.

    • @gysgijsbers4202
      @gysgijsbers4202 Рік тому +4

      Simple reason is there are MORE PEOPLE than OPPORTUNITIES in South Africa. Why can other countries in Africa not fix themselves, why do people have to go to over-crowded South Africa, it's a lie that SA is rich, it has no more resources than the DRC or other African countries, it simply has a more "Western"-approach (Parliament & Administration based on UK system with Republican elements, education & formal business model is UK based/Capitalist), in its management, and has more different races, that is the only difference, but it has just as much poverty, a bigger middle-class & slightly more elites...the middle-class of all races makes SA better, but the rest of Africa can get fixed or can fix itself.

    • @inyeekaribi4913
      @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому +1

      @@gysgijsbers4202 I mean, most large countries in Africa are overcrowded though. The entirety of Africa is resource rich, it is true that with better management no one in Africa would experience such extreme poverty, I also don't know if I agree that having a "Western" approach is a good thing (you would have to explain that one to me) I live and work in this West, and their approach is waaaay too problematic for African countries to succeed by copying it.

    • @inyeekaribi4913
      @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому +1

      @@gysgijsbers4202 The truth is, I empathise with South Africans and I can understand where they are coming from, but I don't think blaming foreigners is going to solve anything, because that is only a symptom of a much wider issue. Good conversation though.

    • @gysgijsbers4202
      @gysgijsbers4202 Рік тому +2

      @@inyeekaribi4913 tx for response, I added Western approach in brackets...remember we were a Dutch colony for +-150 years (Cape Colony), then under British rule for another +-150 years...that is the foundation of our economic & administrative model...never Communist or Socialist, allthough we are leaning towards the latter over the past 30 years under the ANC, with high unemployment & social grant system.

    • @inyeekaribi4913
      @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому +1

      @@gysgijsbers4202 Yes, you are very correct. I know a lot of African governments/ Freedom Fighters tried to adopt more Socialist models (SA included as you have just mentioned), but if they are just copying Socialism as it developed in Europe how would that work? Isn't still a "Western" approach? I haven't seen African countries trying to develop their own economic models (some may argue that it has all already been done)?

  • @alfredwongalethu5509
    @alfredwongalethu5509 5 років тому +22

    Actually we don't have a shortage of teachers and accountants in South Africa. There are plenty of them but the government don't want to employ them... ayikho le uyithethayo sister.

    • @waylinstevens6817
      @waylinstevens6817 5 років тому

      she said we not using the skills that is in the country

  • @matthewcragg3607
    @matthewcragg3607 2 роки тому +22

    Even if every foreigner left that country and the jobs and shops they had were all left behind for the natives to take I guarantee you most would still go unfilled or unused.

    • @thabangtladi8057
      @thabangtladi8057 2 роки тому +1

      its fine as long as foreigners are out of our country

    • @bennym5244
      @bennym5244 10 місяців тому

      Precisely. They want to just get fat and rich from corruption and doing nothing.

    • @phillipngejane8874
      @phillipngejane8874 6 місяців тому +1

      That's all in your mind.

    • @matthewcragg3607
      @matthewcragg3607 6 місяців тому

      @@phillipngejane8874Read “Blood River” by Tim Butcher. It chronicles his travels down the Congo River and how all the advances left behind after European Colonialism are being neglected and allowed to crumble away. Sub-Saharan Africans never developed any advanced civilization (despite what they think) and have yet to maintain one without constant foreign aid.

  • @shumbagaro9547
    @shumbagaro9547 4 роки тому +19

    Every year this happens in SA its like a yearly ritual . Black on black why ??????

    • @chrisolagrim3597
      @chrisolagrim3597 2 роки тому +1

      Because the leaders have fucked up the country then use foreigners as scapegoats.

    • @petromhlanga6369
      @petromhlanga6369 2 роки тому +2

      The killing of Africans in RSA must be stopped now, I seriously call upon those who participate in such activities to have mercy and reconsider their strategy for whatever mission that they are pursuing.
      As South africans we know nothing about war, I'm also worried about the amount of crime which happens almost every single day. However let's not compare that crime statistics to war, I simply mean that by killing innocent Africans is like we are asking for war of which I know that we know nothing about. Unlike most African countries, our struggle heroes avoided to lead us to a war.
      Please stop killing innocent Africans because our constitution says a person is innocent until until proven guilty within a court of law.

    • @Bantuisrael
      @Bantuisrael 2 роки тому +2

      @@petromhlanga6369 I agree. I’m from KONGO and always saw South Africans as my BANTU brothers.
      But after watching this it make me kind of hate South Africans to see they don’t do this to the whites who had dogs eating them but instead they do it to us fellow BANTU???
      Makes me think maybe these people in South Africa are not part of BANTU family maybe some other grand tribe
      But this is not BANTU BEHAVIOR
      And these things can lead to war and maybe this time KONGO will join ANGOLA this for double payback.
      If we are all bantu this must stop if we are not all bantu then the bantu of Africa will be forced to clean that land for our brethren

    • @rmanne7703
      @rmanne7703 Місяць тому

      Because some are not following the laws of our country

  • @afrikaazanialuti
    @afrikaazanialuti 5 років тому +12

    Crime in South Africa does not discriminate. *Racism, Sexism, Xenophobia/Afrophobia/Nigeriaphobia* are all deep-seated traits that are difficult to transform, the only measure we have is the law, & unfortunately, the law is failing everyone. If you are running away from violence, you will only find more of it here, I suggest people run to *Europe* or *America,* maybe you will find peace there...

    • @lightarrow1684
      @lightarrow1684 4 роки тому +2

      The problem is that so many people think of running away all the times. Some of the migrants are legit, they really wish to integrate and to call home and respect the new country. However, other play the role as refugees of their own problems and only beg and demand from the host country an easy solution for their very complicated problems.
      I usually say: America fought their own civil war to change their law, France, England, Russia, China, all had civil wars. The outcome of such brutal civil wars was a committement from all sides to come along and deal with their differences. I think this is going to be next stage in some African nations, maybe South Africa is one of those countries. The frustration is building up, it's a matter of time... Either DNC changes or a new government comes into place, otherwise this will continue its escalation...

    • @bennym5244
      @bennym5244 10 місяців тому

      No!!!!! We've had enough!!!!

  • @Professor_Ntu
    @Professor_Ntu 2 місяці тому +3

    One day South Africans will learn a good lesson, one day

  • @manqobanqobzi8219
    @manqobanqobzi8219 5 років тому +12

    Our problem is weak borders yet it is also stupid to attack people who are contributing to the economy

  • @shanghaichica
    @shanghaichica 11 місяців тому +5

    You do all of that to foreigners and it won’t change your situation. There are still no jobs, people a still living in poverty and crime is sky high. Hold your government responsible instead of bullying others.

    • @Lukholo-ph8jy
      @Lukholo-ph8jy 7 місяців тому +1

      If u were from here then you wouldn't call it bullying

  • @ericmachoka6001
    @ericmachoka6001 2 роки тому +5

    Africa is a dark continent, poverty, economic downturn, dishonesty, xenophobia, violence, corruption discrimination, drug abuse, violence in efficiency, collapse infrastructure etc we have a long way to go.

    • @tendaix100
      @tendaix100 9 місяців тому

      Sounds like every “top” nation😂😂

  • @taylortee8474
    @taylortee8474 4 роки тому +20

    Can you imagine some South Africans tried to join in the Black Lives Matter movement 😂 like sit down somewhere please.

    • @ngalahansel6066
      @ngalahansel6066 8 місяців тому

      😂😂😂indeed

    • @Lukholo-ph8jy
      @Lukholo-ph8jy 7 місяців тому +1

      What does the BLM movement have to do with this topic. Both of you guys have probably no clue about our struggles or even SA. Your comments have no relevance whatsoever.

    • @haloteddy5059
      @haloteddy5059 4 місяці тому

      ⁠@@Lukholo-ph8jy I think its the fact that these are black ppl attacking other black people and instigating the conflict, so what OP is trying to say is that some south Africans are hypocritical bc all black lives don't matter there

  • @SAsFinest-bt9zc
    @SAsFinest-bt9zc 4 роки тому +16

    These news are misrepresenting the facts. The truth is that there are
    too many iIIegal foreigners in South Africa who sell drugs and engage in human trafficking. Illegal foreigners are free to take lives since they are not registered in the country and are untraceable.They are responsible for the farmer jenocide. They have dilapidated the biggest city in Africa, Johannesburg,

    • @taylortee8474
      @taylortee8474 4 роки тому

      So does that justify their actions 🙄

    • @SAsFinest-bt9zc
      @SAsFinest-bt9zc 4 роки тому +5

      @@taylortee8474 If we are being killed in our own country any reaction is justified

    • @akasidina1708
      @akasidina1708 10 місяців тому

      I won't pay a dime to live in South Africa mtcheeew

    • @yummydishes2279
      @yummydishes2279 3 місяці тому

      You guys will fight a real war some day and those African countries might just be the only one to have your back.

    • @INNO_THE_TRAVELER
      @INNO_THE_TRAVELER 2 місяці тому +2

      @@SAsFinest-bt9zcSo South Africa is the only place in the world where drugs is being sold right?.. Why tf do you guys have police if you take law into your own hands

  • @musamilton6420
    @musamilton6420 2 роки тому +21

    Most foreigners don't behave, people are fed up

    • @Kuttas23x
      @Kuttas23x 6 місяців тому

      You’re just jealous you’re poor

    • @INNO_THE_TRAVELER
      @INNO_THE_TRAVELER 2 місяці тому

      Why did you guys destroy other peoples businesses that are innocent? SHAME ON YOU
      Poor people fight each other while the rich whites sit in their villas in gated neighborhoods. top 10% takes home 65% of country's total income while the bottom 50% only gets less than 7%! this is what extreme inequality leads to.

  • @raylancaster4605
    @raylancaster4605 5 років тому +9

    The sad thing about this is that as we ZA are trying to decolonise, we have to face issues like this it's actually sad. Trust me fellow ZA I know how the government has failed us especially our police. Now it doesn't give you an excuse for kangaroo courts, just like foreigners you have no rights to be disrespectful towards the people of the land.

    • @knockhello2604
      @knockhello2604 3 роки тому

      Go to hell lmao

    • @bennym5244
      @bennym5244 10 місяців тому

      Zimbabwe decolonise? You did that decades ago. Excuses excuses excuses.

  • @shanghaichica
    @shanghaichica 11 місяців тому +5

    Majority of criminals in SA and South African.

  • @southafrican1010
    @southafrican1010 4 роки тому +16

    I love my country, S.A.

    • @metrodrillz8903
      @metrodrillz8903 4 роки тому

      Jabez Urgo me and you both .

    • @isthatso9490
      @isthatso9490 4 роки тому +1

      @@szethvallano904 hmph

    • @ladifmefire2943
      @ladifmefire2943 2 роки тому

      Blllllzyp

    • @INNO_THE_TRAVELER
      @INNO_THE_TRAVELER 2 місяці тому +4

      Shame on you !.. But your country brothers and sisters are all over the world too running businesses, what if this kinda of thing happened to them

  • @zanellatutu6735
    @zanellatutu6735 2 роки тому +8

    All these businesses employ Zimbabweans no South Africans

    • @yummydishes2279
      @yummydishes2279 3 місяці тому +3

      Are you insane, don't you have a government to regulate that?

    • @QhayiyaCobo-ts9me
      @QhayiyaCobo-ts9me 2 місяці тому

      ​@@yummydishes2279 The government is useless.

  • @ZeeInterpretationz
    @ZeeInterpretationz Рік тому +9

    We fought for this democracy and are still fighting, also you my fellow Africans stay in your country and fight for your government.

    • @Storyteller3769
      @Storyteller3769 Рік тому +1

      Can you see you are like animals for this your comments

  • @owethulonwabomolefe7894
    @owethulonwabomolefe7894 Рік тому +2

    As a South african I feel as if this document is truly one sided....South Africans have a voice too .....let them talk let them Show their anger and why they are behaving like then that when you will realise

    • @yummydishes2279
      @yummydishes2279 3 місяці тому +2

      I think all the killings have done that for them

    • @INNO_THE_TRAVELER
      @INNO_THE_TRAVELER 2 місяці тому

      Why did you guys destroy other peoples businesses that are innocent? SHAME ON YOU - taking law into your hands
      Poor people fight each other while the rich whites sit in their villas in gated neighborhoods. top 10% takes home 65% of country's total income while the bottom 50% only gets less than 7%! this is what extreme inequality leads to.

  • @HamandisheMpofu
    @HamandisheMpofu 4 місяці тому

    The last person's testimony on this video is really heartbreaking. He's shattered and it seems he has to deal with it in his own way without help hence staying away from everything.
    Very sad 💔.
    I wish well and that he should be given some help to cope with the trauma he's going through.🙏🏿

  • @gysgijsbers4202
    @gysgijsbers4202 Рік тому +1

    The problem is our borders are too porous. The countries of origin need a fixing & held joint responsible for bad governance & no family planning policies. South Africa does not need desperate drug traffickers, pimps & other criminals in our country.

    • @inyeekaribi4913
      @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому

      Literally every country in Africa has porous borders. That’s a result of colonisation and the scramble.

    • @shanghaichica
      @shanghaichica 11 місяців тому +2

      You already have plenty of criminals in your own country.

    • @gysgijsbers4202
      @gysgijsbers4202 11 місяців тому

      @@inyeekaribi4913 Botswana police are very vigilant, Namibia is also not easy to get residency. Much stricter.

    • @INNO_THE_TRAVELER
      @INNO_THE_TRAVELER 2 місяці тому

      Why did you guys destroy other peoples businesses that are innocent? SHAME ON YOU - taking law into your hands , are you the only country that have criminals like wtf
      Poor people fight each other while the rich whites sit in their villas in gated neighborhoods. top 10% takes home 65% of country's total income while the bottom 50% only gets less than 7%! this is what extreme inequality leads to.

  • @ndongmojoseph238
    @ndongmojoseph238 Рік тому +1

    15:51 is exactly what I needed to hear. And it's pure golden facts...keep relying on grants and housing benefits

    • @QhayiyaCobo-ts9me
      @QhayiyaCobo-ts9me 2 місяці тому

      The grants are what makes the corrupt government stay afloat. They will never stop providing them.

  • @gysgijsbers4202
    @gysgijsbers4202 Рік тому +1

    More people than JOBS will always create crime & desperate actions, no matter where...in any country...the UN & AU needs to promote FAMILY PLANNING in Africa & other developing countries. South Africa has a HIGH UNEMPLOYMENT already.

    • @pauleypavillion6088
      @pauleypavillion6088 Рік тому

      South Africa was much better under Apartheid. It will get worse when millions more Africans migrate to South Africa and tribal wars will occur; hundreds of thousands killed.

  • @nontokwela1466
    @nontokwela1466 Рік тому +8

    You can't destroy your country and hope to hide in SA u are wrong

  • @steelem422
    @steelem422 5 років тому +3

    You guys do great coverage

  • @BillyDean-u9b
    @BillyDean-u9b Рік тому +1

    Same thing in Amerikkka Against Foundational Blacks by African People 🌚The Wedge Among Black People Globally...

  • @sheger8670
    @sheger8670 4 роки тому +4

    Now im understanding abour aphartide how can any body live with this people, and they say other africans take thier job.

    • @Lukholo-ph8jy
      @Lukholo-ph8jy 7 місяців тому +1

      If you are human or if you have anything about you then you shouldn't understand apartheid. You wrote this 3 years ago hopefully today you have a better understanding

    • @pegasus6100
      @pegasus6100 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Lukholo-ph8jyif you are human enough then you should stand against xenophobia towards your fellow blacks and human beings. Fix the boarders, not kill people in the sake of pushing them out. Would Madiba want things done like this??

  • @rmanne7703
    @rmanne7703 Місяць тому +1

    Why open it in your country? Your business.
    No no they can do that legally.
    Let me shut this podcast.
    You cant come without papers n force that country to give you ids.that bullshit.

  • @cd5516
    @cd5516 Місяць тому

    A lot of the hatred on the part of black South Africans toward their African brothers has to do with jealousy, laziness, a culture of dependency and a lack of skills within their community.

  • @geordie114
    @geordie114 2 роки тому +2

    Can we say the same about all of the Illegals coming into the UK.

    • @shanghaichica
      @shanghaichica 11 місяців тому +2

      They aren’t stealing jobs. The jobs they do are the ones we don’t want.

  • @ltenclavesoldier9280
    @ltenclavesoldier9280 4 роки тому +4

    South Africa looks like America in the 1910s

  • @mathiaspersson5273
    @mathiaspersson5273 4 роки тому +2

    let me pull up in south africa with black air force 1s

    • @Lukholo-ph8jy
      @Lukholo-ph8jy 7 місяців тому

      You welcome. We love niggas with style bro❤

  • @knockhello2604
    @knockhello2604 3 роки тому +3

    Just get a Glock.

  • @judynemaz3283
    @judynemaz3283 2 роки тому

    Keep working my brother

  • @judynemaz3283
    @judynemaz3283 2 роки тому +1

    U are not started South Africans u are going to suffer for this

  • @millicentlopez3592
    @millicentlopez3592 5 років тому +9

    *Afrophobia*

    • @brot6238
      @brot6238 5 років тому +6

      How does hostility towards Bangladeshis, Pakistanis, Sri Lankans, Indians count as Afriophobia? They are some of the most frequent targets.

    • @makeithappen4021
      @makeithappen4021 2 роки тому

      @@brot6238 you have melanin don’t you ??

    • @sunhythen
      @sunhythen Рік тому

      @@brot6238 Tell that to a Nigerian.

    • @chinomsoosuagwu9128
      @chinomsoosuagwu9128 Рік тому +1

      ​@@sunhythenfr we have it so bad,not all of us are criminals but they js generalize

    • @inyeekaribi4913
      @inyeekaribi4913 Рік тому

      The attacks on other Africans are more frequent because they are more accessible.

  • @lynnleigha580
    @lynnleigha580 2 роки тому +5

    Man, how I wish that we could do this to illegal immigrants, but NOOO Brandon wants "open borders"

  • @marcaurele7692
    @marcaurele7692 4 роки тому +4

    Same soon in Europa

  • @teketelmathee7280
    @teketelmathee7280 Рік тому

    Wow

  • @judynemaz3283
    @judynemaz3283 2 роки тому

    Don't talking nonscence it's Africa

  • @grahamfullagar5197
    @grahamfullagar5197 Рік тому

    African brothers and sisters take back your country

    • @bennym5244
      @bennym5244 10 місяців тому

      From who? The white man has left. Gone. It's only you now.

  • @ntombizanelejob
    @ntombizanelejob Місяць тому

    😭

  • @siphomagasane5218
    @siphomagasane5218 4 роки тому +5

    You are not our neighbor

    • @mukisaroland8127
      @mukisaroland8127 2 роки тому +4

      I don't blame how the white treated you! Africans of then were wrong about u, am sure those were crocodile tears!! If you can't love your fellow Africans I just guess all those who stood with you, they were wrong too

    • @tydronlee8214
      @tydronlee8214 2 роки тому

      @@mukisaroland8127 we are a rainbow nation now stay 8n poor

  • @kriskulczynski8957
    @kriskulczynski8957 Рік тому

    They’re all the same

  • @fathimamangubaneahmed4840
    @fathimamangubaneahmed4840 5 років тому +1

    😭😭😭😭😭I just don't know what to say.

  • @krishkrish-m7p
    @krishkrish-m7p Рік тому +2

    I think SA is animal

  • @janpretorius7379
    @janpretorius7379 4 роки тому +1

    Just look at these Bantu go... Go Bantu go, hahahaha...