Wtf with these comments! A lot of toxic comments. Personally I'm a fan of both Evanescence and Nightwish. They are two very good singers. And this video shows that Amy and Floor are so great. Don't put fandoms against each other because a lot of evanescence's fans are also Nightwish fans, so this is really ridiculous.
Agree both are fantastic! I stumbled across this video because, on a whim, I wanted to see if they'd by any chance collaborated. There is plenty of room for two great power sopranos. Singing is not a zero-sum game!
Floor is better in high notes but Amy sings more emotional and her voice is suited better for rock. I think she's also better musician because even if Floor is better singer for someome, Amy is co-writer of all Evanescence songs and she is the best rock pianist.
@@sergeiivanovich6827 for which project she write songs? Nightwish is basically Tuomas, for After Forever whole band wrote. Evanescence have some songs written only by Amy, on first two albums it was mostly her and guitarist (Ben, then Terry). She also plays piano and other keyboards, harp and does some production things. Vocals are completely other style so they can't be compared. But Amy has a little wider vocal range.
Although Amy obviously is a good singer, I definitely prefer Floor always. She has a beautiful, full tone and a beautiful colour in her voice, while Amy's voice sounds somewhat thinner and shriekier to me and even without this comparison here, I never wanted to listen to more Evanescence songs in a row because of the colour of Amy's voice which my ear simply doesn't like so much. And since I've scrolled through a lot of other replies here, just on a general note... Not every comment that someone makes, which takes a side or states an opinion that a part of the people here don't like or agree with, is therefore "toxic". If I say that I prefer A or B and think A or B the best singer ever, then I'm not "toxic". Even if I say that imo A or B is a lot better than the other singer, it's still only an opinion that people can voice. Even if I say that A or B just hurts my poor ears,I'm STILL not toxic. The word toxic is overly used for just about ANYTHING you or you or you may not like to hear.
Both Amy and Floor are incredible performers with georgous voices, and Nightwish and Evanescence are two of the best bands in rock/metal history. I wish the fans would stop making everything a competition and just enjoy listening to these women side by side!💕🎶
Neither is better than the other. It is a matter of personal taste and opinion. Some prefer Floor, others prefer Amy and that is fine either way. Both are in my top 5 singers (with Sharon den Adel, Yuko Suzuhana and Ann Wilson). In my opinion Floor has a more powerful and controlled voice and Amy wins on emotion and tone. If I had to choose who I prefer overall I would go for Amy, but I think both are great.
Personally I prefer Floor's voice, I think she's stunning. But that takes nothing away from Amy's voice or talent. Both women are great in similar and very different ways.
Can we all agree that both are amazingly talented kweens each with pros and cons 💕? Having said that, I would SO love for Amy to have Floor's breath support as Amy would be my personal pick on this battle. Do a full range vocal battle between the two!
@@thebabbler8867 Amylee is an inspiration for all female rock singers our there everyone nightwish and other came after evanescence.. she is voice of our generation like Chester bennington
@@Saugaat_Sings Nightwish did not come after Evanescence. But it doesn't matter because Evanescence didn't even know about Nightwish. They're both great in different ways.
If we go by ease, technique, consistency and accuracy, then Floor wins this battle. She's near perfect technically speaking. Amy barely had any vocal training. However, I must say that I prefer Amy's tone over Floor's. I find Amy's singing to be more emotive (not that Floor's isn't). But you can tell Amy has to push in order to get some of these notes out, whereas Floor can hit them back to back without any problems. Amy simply lacks Floor's technical prowess. However, she is lucky to be blessed with such a pleasant, beautiful and angelic sound, and this kind of makes up for her technical flaws.
@@mrallsundayy understands what ? another attempt at futility ? unless the person above and yourself has spent an extensive amount of time listening to Floor like I have for 20 yrs as well as Amy,then your frame of reference is vague to say the least
Floor has the most beautiful voice I have ever heard. The colours of her voice are just indescribably beautiful and touch my soul like no other. It´s as if she has direct control over my emotions as I constantly get goosebumps or tears.
@@Bman2024 You asked me what I think of Amy´s voice but honestly I would prefer not to as you are clearly a fan of Amy and I´m only happy for you that you like her. For myself, Floor is the discovery of a lifetime. I endured 10 years of chronic illness after having menengitis and I was feeling sad and burn´t out. The first time I heard Floor sing I literally cried for 10 minutes. The first time i had cried for 10 years. She was the key that unlocked my emotion. I have never heard or witnessed any singer able to transmit emotion the way Floor does.. It´s mindblowing. Listening to Floor daily in the past 6 months has transformed me into a very positive and appreciative person despite ongoing struggles. I´m shocked that I get goosebumps and tears 5-10 times a day,everyday... It´s the best medicine for my soul and I will forever be grateful for Floor´s voice. She is one of a kind :)
@@laudatosiadastra1218 wow I really appreciate that. I am really sad that happened to you but really happy for you that you feel that way about Floor. She does have an amazing voice but I feel the exact same way about Amy. I was also in a dark time in my life and then I heard My Immortal and that really got to me. I have never been really into music until I heard Amy's voice and now I am obsessed with her. I have also lost a sister at a very young age like she did and that is what I think got me to connect with her so much and connect to her music and songs. Especially the ones that is about her sister. Again I am so happy for you that things are going alot better and I just know that things will only get better for the future. ❤❤
@@Bman2024 Wow Brendan, thanks for that nice message. It´s pretty special when coming across a vocalist/performer that can have such a profound impact in your life. I am likewise very happy for you and appreciate that you opened up and shared your story.
@@laudatosiadastra1218 anytime my friend. It is so special and especially when we both share the same personal experiences like losing a sister. That really connects us. Yeah thank you for sharing your story first. It gave me the courage to share mine. So again thanks. 🙏🙏🙏
I love Floor's voice I think she's great. She really knows how to sing, she is a professional,a vocal coach. But something tells my heart when I hear Amy's voice, she's not as good live as it is on studio sometimes. I'm sure if she had a good technique it would be amazing as a live performer. I love them both ❤
well Amy can get lower and higher as well. The video is just about "belted" notes (although there are a couple examples which are more head voice imo), which for them both seem to happen in that part of their range.
@@davemason4055 or Phantom of The Opera - Beste Zangers 2019 ? ah this guy picked what he needed to obviously try to make a comparison favoring what ever point he's trying to make,I bet he has heard very little of Floor's best vocals,anyways there are about 100 vocal pro reactors whom I can count on including 1 in my family that know the difference
Both impressive, most people can't do what they can. Also, just to be clear, Amy Lee is always very animated on stage by moving a lot and even running on stage while singing these songs that require a lot of vocal/breath control which she does well and has been getting better at it over time. And also plays piano on stage. Floor is extremely technical and is only focused on that, which leads to her standing still a lot. Not a bad thing, just saying that this has a lot to do which the sound. I love both, just prefer Amy's emotion when you combine all she does and not just focused on sounding "perfect"... it just comes to personal connections we have to different sounds :)
@@inessantos6899 oh yeah for sure! But that's pretty much it and only when she is not singing. Amy literally head bangs and runs while singing lol, probably not the best choice for singing technique, but still cool lol 😝
Exactly and the show she puts on is one of the best out there... Not many artist are that good of a performer like Amy. She makes you move and feel the songs she is constantly dancing moving flipping and jumping twirling around, doing headbangs and hand fist and running side to side of the stage, not using a mic pedestal at all or at least not even for a full song at times... and she play keyboards synths and piano while still doing all of these movements AND singing those hell of difficult notes she have in Evanescence music. Her long clean notes doesn't have to rely or do much vibrato... And definitely the notes she delivers are not an easy thing to do with the power she puts on so yet she sings em a lot. Her stage performance is an eyecandy the way she connects with the crowd is better than the other female fronted singers for sure. And that itself makes up for when she doesnt do it perfect a couple times. But she has proven to be perfecting it more as years go by. She entertains me way more than any other singer
Let me be the contrarian here. Floor has so much more stage presence. Her expressions and gestures are much more refined. If jumping and flipping on stage are your thing fine, but floor can do that too. Just see "I want my tears back" in buenos aires.
I love Amy Lee's voice, for years I thought no other singer can make me feel the music more and put that emotion into me more, because most vocalists even really famous and good ones can't tickle my insides, Amy can. Then I heard a reaction to Ghost Love Score, and was struck by lightning. I had to hear more of this woman and band. One year later, sorry Amy, your voice is still beautiful and touches me, for a human woman, none other currently compares. Valkyrie Goddess Floor, my Queen, is not human, and her voice pushes emotion into me like none I have ever heard. Is Amy Lee talented and have a beautiful tone? Yes, absolutely! Does her technical abilities or ability to push emotions into anyone at will come close to Floor, absolutely not. All hail Queen Floor, Goddess of Music!
Yeah I watched that too and to be honest I think Amy could throw in alot more emotion. Don't get me wrong, Floor has alot of talent and I ain't taking anything away from that but nobody can throw enough emotions into a performance like Amy does. She is far and superior above everybody else. It's a fact.
@@Bman2024 That is all subjective. I knew Amy's work a lot earlier than Nightwish but I have to respectfully disagree with that. Emotion wise floor is at the top of her game. I've not seen anything top The Poet and The Pendulem (live - wembley arena version). And I'm a 50 year old male tearing up when she sings the sad parts. Nothing to take away from amy (I really like my immortal), but it is not at the same level for me.
Ev and Nightwish are two different hard rock styles and comparate them seems me absurde. Both sang n sing so fucking perfectly and both are a good singers.
I love Amy. However, to be honest she is much better in the studio. After about B4 her voice color is so much more strained and thin sounding. She has to work so hard even to hold those notes for any length of time. Above that she only goes for effect. As she gets older she won't even be able to do some of her own songs justice. Amy needs to work on her breath control. She is always falling flat and running out of breath in live performances. I actually love what she does on her studio recording. So emotional and beautiful. Floor blows her doors off. Sorry Amy. The great thing is it is not a competition. Amy does her thing and she does is wonderfully. Floor is the quintessential professional. Respect for Amy, Praise for Floor.
Yeah floor is amazing and I adore her 🤗❤️ but o think Amy's breath control is getting better I recomend you to check 2021 live version of weight of the world I thought she may not be able to hit that high note but she did it even better 🤗
So have you not heard her Bring Me To Life performance with the Wagakiki Band? She was absolutely amazing and totally did justice for that song. And that was only a few years ago. And yes she is getting way better with her breath control. So please stop disrespecting our goddess.
Floor is one of a hell versatile and professional trained singer for 25 years. SHE CAN DO WHATEVER SHE WANTS, remember that. Amy Lee is just a twangy singer. Period.
Floor can definitely do many things, yet she sounds flat and void of emotions. It's like listening to a robot. Which is understandable. At least she's not faking. She can't relate to the lyrics others have written in a way the writer can. Which is why Amy is superior in her delivery of emotional aspect of all of her songs. She genuinely connects to the crowd in a way Floor just isn't capable of. And Amy's timber is the most beautiful female vocal color recognized immediately, while Floor doesn't have that uniqueness. Different things move us in music... if you can't grasp the greatness of Amy Lee - don't be a jerk about it. Listen to Floor and let others enjoy who they find more appealing. Why the need to talk nonsense?
@@AmyLeeForever On one hand your saying let everybody enjoy there own favorite But how in the hell can you say Floor is incapable of singing with Amy’s emotion since the songs weren’t written for her Besides this video have you heard Floor sing one of the most common reactions to Floor singing is how emotional Grown Men get when there listening to Floor sing I could care less who anyone enjoys more But you can’t make a ridiculous statement like that
Hi! Fan of Amy Lee and Evanescence as well as a fan of Floor Jansen and Nightwish, ReVamp and After Forever. Can I just say that I love both singers equally and I have nothing against the other. I've always adored each singer and I love the emotions they give off live and studio. I've been reading some of these comments and I just want to say that the Nightwish Army (not all of the people in the Nightwish Army) are toxic. As goes to the EvHeads, there are toxic people (not all EvHeads) in that Fandom as well. I just want to say that both Fandoms may prefer one over the other, but can we please just be respectful about how we say who we like? That like literally something I'm sure Nightwish and Evanescence would agree with. I'm even sure that both bands would not like toxic people in each Fandom popping off on each other about who's the best live and whatever. Both Amy and Floor have their own way of approaching their vocals. People may clay it works, people may say it doesn't work. All I'm saying is that please do not come after each other because if Floor and or Amy sees people who are toxic in the Nightwish Army and the EvHead Fandom, they would not like it and would possibly resent individual fans that are toxic. So be nice or don't say anything at all. P.S. I hope everyone is aware that when you insult an Evanescence fan, you maybe insulting a Nightwish fan and vice versa. There are people who love both bands just as equal, but being respectful of who we prefer is much better than arguing. Yeah some bad things in the past were said and done, but if you want to live in that past, feel free to do so, because there are fans that just want to move on and be happy with each other. So with that said, there are Nightwish fans that love Evanescence. Don't disrespect people in your own Fandom because of who they like. Simple as that and that goes to Evanescence fans also.
Floor has a great Range and Belting Register . But she fails to Deliver me any Emotions . Amy Lee has maybe Not the perfect technique but she Delivers alot of Emotions and i enjoy her music and songs much More.
@@feridedogan7653 there's a difference in not preferring something in her voice and saying she doesn't do something that she does well above the average
Ich liebe Amy seid über 18 Jahren und finde sie ist die BESTE. Ihre Stimme ist einzigartig, bitte seht eich das Video von Lost in Paradies bei den AMP sessions an da hört man ihre Stimme am allerbesten. Floor ist auch gut aber nicht mein Geschmack ich finde es zu sehr wie Operngesang und das mag ich persönlich halt nicht (no hate) aber ich finde auch nicht dass man die 2 miteinander vergleichen sollte weil sie doch sehr unterschiedliche Richtungen haben 🤷♀️ schöne Grüße aus Österreich
Amy Lee can sing sure, but Floor's voice is just much more spacious and musical, amy lee is more limited, thinner in sound, and she has to force it more, it is never as free and spacious as that of Floor Jansen, sorry
Their belts are different. Passd Eb5, Floor is exclusively in a mix with headvoice. Amy is still belting in chest passed that note (not all the time, depending on the performances shown).
It bothers me when singers don't have vibrato in the belts. It kind of hurts my ears, the vibrato is cushioning, the straight belt notes are irritating. I know floor does some straight notes like in the song Devil and Deep Dark Ocean but her voice at those times is still not irritating.
Actually a mezzo is a soprano but there are different ranges of soprano. That being said I like both vocalists but cant stand how some fanboys act in comments so I usually don't comment
Amy Lee's voice may not be technically the best but it is so smooth and has so much emotion in it. Not many singers have that quality. So imho Amy is better than Flo.
Si bien Flor muestra más tecnica y menos aire me quedo con Amy; tiene mejor timbre y mucho mas rango que sólo belting... Por algo es Amy Lee señores... en los 2 mil todas la imitaban, todas quisieron ser Amy: Kelly, Xtina, Avril, Tarja y Sharon lo han dicho, evanescence les abrió las puertas a ellas como front womans también... de ahí para adelante.
@@cavernadigitalpro estás muy mal Amy Lee es considerada vos única y te digo mas me gusta mucho más Sharon den adel que Floor ,Sharon en vivo es mágica
@@eddiehesselman3904 they said musician. Amy is a multi-instrumentist as she plays piano, harp, guitar bass and ukalele besides singing. She also writes every song in Ev's catalog from Fallen onward
Floor is and will always be the superior singer. Floor can take ANY song from ANY artist and make it her own. She has an uncanny ability to make every note count. Amy Lee is a one trick pony singing her own songs that have the backing from being an American. I just don't see Amy Lee giving Ghost Love Score or Pan or Shoemaker any justice. But I am 100% positive that Floor could take Evanescence song and make it her own. If you would watch any of the hundreds of Nightwish concerts on UA-cam you would clearly see that Floor connects with her audience and is a true professional and acts accordingly. She doesn't need to jump around like a baffoon to make a point or put on a show.
If Floor was to sing ANY Evanescence song it would show how flat her delivery is. And calling Amy a buffoon just shows how envious you are... Shame on you.
Bruh your comment sounds like you really hate Amy lol. She isn't vocally trained unlike Floor (she is also a vocal coach) and their music genre is different. Both are great in their own ways, they have both pros and cons. I love them both. But I'm not sure if Floor can do justice if she sings any of Evanescence's songs, she needs to show her emotions when singing it since Amy always put her emotions to her songs. Amy could sing GLS in her own style though like what Annette's did.
Yeah, everyone knows floor but no one knows Amy. Amy sings bad, doesn't know how to play instruments live and also wrote no successful songs. She is such a failure of an artist when compared to floor.
I don't think this is a reasonable comparison, most people tend to forget that Amy Lee has always been more of a musician and composer than just some band's singer. Floor has definitely the strongest technique out of the two. And Amy could definitely find a vocal coach to help her improve her singing skills, but she does a lot more to just sing for her band and I don't think she has the time and the desire to do so.
Both amazing singers, and two of my favorites but totally different ranges and styles. I believe Floor is an objectively better singer, but I prefer Amy. Would be interesting to see them covering each other’s song.
Una más del montón? JAJA será al revés para escuchar un intento de opera tenemos a tarja, simone parece que otra es una más del montón. UPS se tenia que decir y se dijo.
Sera al revés Floor Jansen no tiene mi la mitad de los premios de evanescence además Amy tiene una vos única flor tiene un tiemble y un color de vos muy común a diferencia de Amy y Sharon y Amy domina y toca más instrumentos además es la líder de su banda mientras que floor es lame botas del odioso de Thomas
Creer que floor y tarja son el mismo tipo de cantante demuestra el poco conocimiento en el mundo del metal que tienen algunos por favor a escuchar más metal
@@raulcalderon2579 habla de Amy Lee no se Tarja Amy Lee es mágica igual que a Sharon den adel sin mágicas floor solo canta bien no es mágica no desprende magia en el escenario sabiondo
In singing maybe. In all the other aspects of an artist she is waaaay behind. Amy sings, play the instruments live while singing and sings very successful songs she wrote herself. Floor is a magnificent singer but that is it. Pretty mediocre in every other aspect.
Nice video. Long snippets from Amy, partly much shorter ones from Floor. And the audio quality is partly really good selected for a comparison. Here you can see where the preferences lie. 😉 For example 3:06 12 sec Amy and best quality 5 sec Floor shitty quality
I tried to choose similar videos and believe me ıt was really hard to find all of the notes so thats why 🤗 at 2:00 floor hits 2 long d5's and Amy's one is shorter. do u really think that im trying to throw trash at floor 🤗
At the time stamp u wrote compares Floor's E5 and Amy's Eb5? And she even only hits Eb5 for 2 seconds 🤗 and ıf u take a little look at my videos u can clearly see I adore floor 🤗❤️
@@Harolddespui omg 😭😭 FLOOR MENTION it several time that she isn’t an opera singer. You clearly don’t know what an opera singer is. floor is a classical singer
This is a beautiful video. I love how shape of endless note's: audio-action at noting notes, forming endless action are felt; visual sight and emotional sense joyful love of musical singing well-animated clear are mentality and physicality saturated sensed: resonating-ponder, musical-intricacies of action are outlet felt-learned to learnt feeling, and absorb in the magical moment singing are monumental for the video here. For inspire clear note singing are felt in the tone: tonal awakening of the phenomenal Evanescence Lead Singer inspired and inspires, inspiring delighting my own singing talent which is an endless, variety: fun blend of The Oneness of all-Things Musical for progression of musical training at the refine of in the moment noting note's. Thanks for the video here.
Amy wins for me, her voice is way more likeable and fine to listen to, her tone is way richer, whereas Floor feels like a more perfeted singer but doesn't release emotion in her voice, more power but less intimate unlike Amy who has power and also way of emoting with each note she sings. Floor could have a better technique but as far as performance level, Amy is an excelent performer, her stamina, her energy on stage, the way she puts on a great show and knowing she is a full on musican and not just a singer, makes her better. Floor is praised by songs she doesn't write in Nightwish, and Amy is singing her own words and lyrics and songs she composed from 0, that's the difference between a good singer and a full on musician like Amy.
Amy lee has a really lovely tone right!!!! 🤗 I actually think that Floor is a gorgeous stage presence too and I also like her but I don't think you know about her previous projects 🤗 She composes her own songs too 🤗
@@mrallsundayy yeah I know she has written her songs but those songs aren't as good as the ones on Nightwish where people are loving her for. Tuomas is better writter than her, floor is not singing while playing instruments neither. I rarely see her move around the stage she uses mic stand all the time. So her performance is more all about her vocals and Amy is about everything bc shes doing her songs her vocals moving all over the stage headbanging twirling and rocking out each song, whenever she did Synthesis she proved how well she does in thay standing pose but as far as Ev rock shows she is way more entertaining to watch her do a concert
@@xPaLmaaHx the who is the better composer thing is so subjective I think Playing enstrument thing is up to singer 🤗 Floor moves around a lot too and she has awesome headbangs I like Amy's stage presence a lot too 🤗❤️ they both are really good
Not to be rude but comparing two different singers in different genres makes no sense. Floor is a metal singer, Amy lee isn't. In my opinion Floor is technically a better singer just for the fact that she can growl which makes her so versatile singer than Amy Lee. Not saying Amy Lee is bad it's just I heard Amy Lee struggles live performances mid way.
Yeah Floor definitely has better technique and education Amy uses little growls in her songs too not as much as floor but still does It's not about comparing it's more like having a beautiful music experience
Floor is a 10 in vocal technique. Amy is maybe an 8 at best? However as full artists Amy is faaaar ahead of floor. Better composer, live pianist, band leader. Just a complete and successful artist. We are comparing a magnificent professional singer to a complete artist. For example, My immortal which was written by Amy when she was 15 is more successful than any song floor has ever dreamed to write.
Making these videos is inviting arguing in the comments anyway, it breeds contention to compare like this. People like what they like aurally and it's vastly variable. Why even keep.making these.
Idk but i think Floor have better Quality tone in LIVE performances.. Could be the fact that Amy moves too much around the stage and lost her breath.. But either way they are great.. And Floor it's just something else that Singing.. Floor it's a 11/10 and Amy it's a 9/10 For sure.
both artists have great and famous voices.. for me, ŞEBNEM FERAH .. has a better voice in both.. The disadvantage of ŞEBNEM FERAH is that it does not have an international reputation.. if it could be international like floor and amy, it has millions of fans and audiences in the world today. she would be an artist... but ŞEBNEM FERAH is a rock queen.
Hard to tell, but considering she's a mezzo soprano you're probably right. The same could he said about floor's talent for composition. 15 year old Amy lee was able to write My immortal. You could combine every single song floor has ever composed and the total won't reach the success of a single song a teenager Amy lee reached. Not to mention that Amy plays the piano for half of their songs. Her brain is basically divided into two different instruments, while floor is always 100% focused in her single instrument.
I really like floor she is a super singer the best technically but the voice of Amy Lee and Sharon den Adel is something sweet that relaxes the soul in addition to having unique tones the tone of floor is very common, not like Amy and Sharon's is only my criteria and my tastes
Amy is fantastic, but Floor is on a higher level and vocal capabilities, she can sing anything. I love them, I'm a musician and I'm telling you how things really are.
Wtf with these comments! A lot of toxic comments. Personally I'm a fan of both Evanescence and Nightwish. They are two very good singers. And this video shows that Amy and Floor are so great. Don't put fandoms against each other because a lot of evanescence's fans are also Nightwish fans, so this is really ridiculous.
Thanks 🥰
Agreed. I love both Nightwish and Evanescence.
Agreed!
Agree both are fantastic! I stumbled across this video because, on a whim, I wanted to see if they'd by any chance collaborated. There is plenty of room for two great power sopranos. Singing is not a zero-sum game!
Floor is better in high notes but Amy sings more emotional and her voice is suited better for rock. I think she's also better musician because even if Floor is better singer for someome, Amy is co-writer of all Evanescence songs and she is the best rock pianist.
bullshit
Floor is more higher level than Amy, and she writes own songs...
@@sergeiivanovich6827 for which project she write songs? Nightwish is basically Tuomas, for After Forever whole band wrote. Evanescence have some songs written only by Amy, on first two albums it was mostly her and guitarist (Ben, then Terry). She also plays piano and other keyboards, harp and does some production things.
Vocals are completely other style so they can't be compared. But Amy has a little wider vocal range.
Floor is the best female singer in the world. She can sing anything she likes
Floor's the Queen
Amy is The Goddess!
@@AmyLeeForever goddess in what? Tell me specifically.
@@AmyLeeForever amy sing 1 styl , floor many styls , metal rock opera pop
@@fredverkerk838 So? Amy is true to her style as she creates her songs, while Floor sings what others create. Your point?
@@AmyLeeForever so dit floor in her bands , wat is your point
Although Amy obviously is a good singer, I definitely prefer Floor always. She has a beautiful, full tone and a beautiful colour in her voice, while Amy's voice sounds somewhat thinner and shriekier to me and even without this comparison here, I never wanted to listen to more Evanescence songs in a row because of the colour of Amy's voice which my ear simply doesn't like so much.
And since I've scrolled through a lot of other replies here, just on a general note... Not every comment that someone makes, which takes a side or states an opinion that a part of the people here don't like or agree with, is therefore "toxic". If I say that I prefer A or B and think A or B the best singer ever, then I'm not "toxic". Even if I say that imo A or B is a lot better than the other singer, it's still only an opinion that people can voice. Even if I say that A or B just hurts my poor ears,I'm STILL not toxic.
The word toxic is overly used for just about ANYTHING you or you or you may not like to hear.
I love Amy Lee's raw emotion expressions when she's singing 🥺🥺🥺
Raw as a trash
@@taurusguy9305 you are trash.
@@taurusguy9305 payaso 🤡🤡
@@taurusguy9305 You're kinda being trash lol
Both are good but Amy Lee is my style, everybody got preferences
Both Amy and Floor are incredible performers with georgous voices, and Nightwish and Evanescence are two of the best bands in rock/metal history. I wish the fans would stop making everything a competition and just enjoy listening to these women side by side!💕🎶
Neither is better than the other. It is a matter of personal taste and opinion. Some prefer Floor, others prefer Amy and that is fine either way. Both are in my top 5 singers (with Sharon den Adel, Yuko Suzuhana and Ann Wilson). In my opinion Floor has a more powerful and controlled voice and Amy wins on emotion and tone. If I had to choose who I prefer overall I would go for Amy, but I think both are great.
Techniques do matter, sorry! ...otherwise there will be no such a thing as vocal training
Personally I prefer Floor's voice, I think she's stunning. But that takes nothing away from Amy's voice or talent. Both women are great in similar and very different ways.
I can't agree more !!! Nuff said . NWSU
Cualquiera de las dos...te hacen volar la cabeza. Son muy buenas, y espero algún día, verlas en un escenario cantar juntas.
I wish that too
Can we all agree that both are amazingly talented kweens each with pros and cons 💕? Having said that, I would SO love for Amy to have Floor's breath support as Amy would be my personal pick on this battle. Do a full range vocal battle between the two!
No. Only Floor is the real deal. Amy Lee's voice is just a joke.
@@taurusguy9305 your life is a joke. 🖕🏼🖕🏼
@@Bman2024 Keep on crying
@@taurusguy9305 Cringe.
From B4 to E5 amy has better sound... from E5 to G5 floor :)
Thats true
Yeah that's absolutely right 👏👏👏
Love them both... Amy Lee will always be my number 1
Amy Lee is washed. Floor Jansen is far superior in every category.
That's my guy! Always and forever Amy Lee will be #1. She is a beast.
@@thebabbler8867 also f off person. You don't talk about our goddess like that. 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼
@@thebabbler8867 Amylee is an inspiration for all female rock singers our there everyone nightwish and other came after evanescence.. she is voice of our generation like Chester bennington
@@Saugaat_Sings Nightwish did not come after Evanescence. But it doesn't matter because Evanescence didn't even know about Nightwish. They're both great in different ways.
If we go by ease, technique, consistency and accuracy, then Floor wins this battle. She's near perfect technically speaking. Amy barely had any vocal training.
However, I must say that I prefer Amy's tone over Floor's. I find Amy's singing to be more emotive (not that Floor's isn't). But you can tell Amy has to push in order to get some of these notes out, whereas Floor can hit them back to back without any problems. Amy simply lacks Floor's technical prowess. However, she is lucky to be blessed with such a pleasant, beautiful and angelic sound, and this kind of makes up for her technical flaws.
Im so happy to see that someone really understands me 🤗
@@mrallsundayy understands what ? another attempt at futility ? unless the person above and yourself has spent an extensive amount of time listening to Floor like I have for 20 yrs as well as Amy,then your frame of reference is vague to say the least
@@nicod1361
You don't know anything about me. Stop assuming. I said what I said and I have a good reason for that.
@@nicod1361 yeah u win biggest floor fan awards goes to nico d everyone 🥳🥳🥳
@@theseeker2586 which is what exactly ?
Two beautiful ladies, with beautiful voices and have a lot of talent using there voice in their own way.
Floor
Floor has the most beautiful voice I have ever heard. The colours of her voice are just indescribably beautiful and touch my soul like no other. It´s as if she has direct control over my emotions as I constantly get goosebumps or tears.
And what about Amy's voice? To me she is way better.
@@Bman2024 You asked me what I think of Amy´s voice but honestly I would prefer not to as you are clearly a fan of Amy and I´m only happy for you that you like her. For myself, Floor is the discovery of a lifetime. I endured 10 years of chronic illness after having menengitis and I was feeling sad and burn´t out. The first time I heard Floor sing I literally cried for 10 minutes. The first time i had cried for 10 years. She was the key that unlocked my emotion. I have never heard or witnessed any singer able to transmit emotion the way Floor does.. It´s mindblowing. Listening to Floor daily in the past 6 months has transformed me into a very positive and appreciative person despite ongoing struggles. I´m shocked that I get goosebumps and tears 5-10 times a day,everyday... It´s the best medicine for my soul and I will forever be grateful for Floor´s voice. She is one of a kind :)
@@laudatosiadastra1218 wow I really appreciate that. I am really sad that happened to you but really happy for you that you feel that way about Floor. She does have an amazing voice but I feel the exact same way about Amy. I was also in a dark time in my life and then I heard My Immortal and that really got to me. I have never been really into music until I heard Amy's voice and now I am obsessed with her. I have also lost a sister at a very young age like she did and that is what I think got me to connect with her so much and connect to her music and songs. Especially the ones that is about her sister. Again I am so happy for you that things are going alot better and I just know that things will only get better for the future. ❤❤
@@Bman2024 Wow Brendan, thanks for that nice message. It´s pretty special when coming across a vocalist/performer that can have such a profound impact in your life. I am likewise very happy for you and appreciate that you opened up and shared your story.
@@laudatosiadastra1218 anytime my friend. It is so special and especially when we both share the same personal experiences like losing a sister. That really connects us. Yeah thank you for sharing your story first. It gave me the courage to share mine. So again thanks. 🙏🙏🙏
Amy is a very accomplished pianist and she writes the songs for Evanescence.
Much more complete as an artist. Floor is a bit better singing and that is it.
I love Floor's voice I think she's great. She really knows how to sing, she is a professional,a vocal coach. But something tells my heart when I hear Amy's voice, she's not as good live as it is on studio sometimes. I'm sure if she had a good technique it would be amazing as a live performer. I love them both ❤
I like them both, but this video makes no sense, Floor can start lower and go higher than shown, so they can equalize everyone.
well Amy can get lower and higher as well. The video is just about "belted" notes (although there are a couple examples which are more head voice imo), which for them both seem to happen in that part of their range.
@@tinker4261 yeah exactly thank you 🤗 ıt was hard to find all of these Belts so there might be some mistakes thank you so much again 🤗❤️
@@tinker4261 If it's just the belting where is Floor's D6 from Romanticide?
@@davemason4055 the D6 at the end of the slide? That's head voice *shrugs*
@@davemason4055 or Phantom of The Opera - Beste Zangers 2019 ? ah this guy picked what he needed to obviously try to make a comparison favoring what ever point he's trying to make,I bet he has heard very little of Floor's best vocals,anyways there are about 100 vocal pro reactors whom I can count on including 1 in my family that know the difference
Floor’s C5 on Ghost River at Wacken may be my favorite note live ever... that trailing vibrato at the end also (*chef’s kiss*)
It's an amazing one 🥰
It's a G#5
@@xX_N_E_O_Xx 1:18 is a C5 ...”Ghost River” not “Ghost Love Score”
My bad
@@xX_N_E_O_Xx all good my friend ✌️
Both impressive, most people can't do what they can. Also, just to be clear, Amy Lee is always very animated on stage by moving a lot and even running on stage while singing these songs that require a lot of vocal/breath control which she does well and has been getting better at it over time. And also plays piano on stage.
Floor is extremely technical and is only focused on that, which leads to her standing still a lot. Not a bad thing, just saying that this has a lot to do which the sound.
I love both, just prefer Amy's emotion when you combine all she does and not just focused on sounding "perfect"... it just comes to personal connections we have to different sounds :)
So you've never watch Floor doing the windmills?? She could power an entire city with them! :P
@@inessantos6899 oh yeah for sure! But that's pretty much it and only when she is not singing. Amy literally head bangs and runs while singing lol, probably not the best choice for singing technique, but still cool lol 😝
Exactly and the show she puts on is one of the best out there... Not many artist are that good of a performer like Amy. She makes you move and feel the songs she is constantly dancing moving flipping and jumping twirling around, doing headbangs and hand fist and running side to side of the stage, not using a mic pedestal at all or at least not even for a full song at times... and she play keyboards synths and piano while still doing all of these movements AND singing those hell of difficult notes she have in Evanescence music. Her long clean notes doesn't have to rely or do much vibrato... And definitely the notes she delivers are not an easy thing to do with the power she puts on so yet she sings em a lot. Her stage performance is an eyecandy the way she connects with the crowd is better than the other female fronted singers for sure. And that itself makes up for when she doesnt do it perfect a couple times. But she has proven to be perfecting it more as years go by. She entertains me way more than any other singer
Let me be the contrarian here. Floor has so much more stage presence. Her expressions and gestures are much more refined. If jumping and flipping on stage are your thing fine, but floor can do that too. Just see "I want my tears back" in buenos aires.
I love Amy Lee's voice, for years I thought no other singer can make me feel the music more and put that emotion into me more, because most vocalists even really famous and good ones can't tickle my insides, Amy can. Then I heard a reaction to Ghost Love Score, and was struck by lightning. I had to hear more of this woman and band. One year later, sorry Amy, your voice is still beautiful and touches me, for a human woman, none other currently compares. Valkyrie Goddess Floor, my Queen, is not human, and her voice pushes emotion into me like none I have ever heard. Is Amy Lee talented and have a beautiful tone? Yes, absolutely! Does her technical abilities or ability to push emotions into anyone at will come close to Floor, absolutely not. All hail Queen Floor, Goddess of Music!
Provided by:
NATIONAL INVENTGRAPHIC.
A new magazine that compiles things that happened only in your mind.
Yeah I watched that too and to be honest I think Amy could throw in alot more emotion. Don't get me wrong, Floor has alot of talent and I ain't taking anything away from that but nobody can throw enough emotions into a performance like Amy does. She is far and superior above everybody else. It's a fact.
@@Bman2024 That is all subjective. I knew Amy's work a lot earlier than Nightwish but I have to respectfully disagree with that. Emotion wise floor is at the top of her game. I've not seen anything top The Poet and The Pendulem (live - wembley arena version). And I'm a 50 year old male tearing up when she sings the sad parts.
Nothing to take away from amy (I really like my immortal), but it is not at the same level for me.
Nice try, but, objectively, Amy is nowhere near Floor.
Agree
@The Scalla Can you make up your mind? A few days ago you called floor a metal/rock singer. Trolling again ?
@The Scalla So why are you saying a pop singer? The fact is that you're contradicting yourself all the time in your trolling.
S Muziek because of amy lee that floor jansen happened, otherwise we wouldn't even know it was the same. Get the right view!!! 😉
@@franciscoewerton6614 Haha, really? Ever heard of Anneke van Giersbergen and Tarja Turunen?
I respect Amy, but I prefer Floor, she has more power, versatility and I like her voice color
FLOOR!
Indeed
@@taurusguy9305 🤡
Ev and Nightwish are two different hard rock styles and comparate them seems me absurde. Both sang n sing so fucking perfectly and both are a good singers.
BOTH ARE VERY GOOD SINGERS AND FOR MY FLOOR JANSEN IS THE BEST
They both sound great but a lot of these simply aren’t belts. A lot of mixed register and even some strong falsetto notes.
Yeah i was so ignorant when i did the video
I love Amy. However, to be honest she is much better in the studio. After about B4 her voice color is so much more strained and thin sounding. She has to work so hard even to hold those notes for any length of time. Above that she only goes for effect. As she gets older she won't even be able to do some of her own songs justice. Amy needs to work on her breath control. She is always falling flat and running out of breath in live performances. I actually love what she does on her studio recording. So emotional and beautiful. Floor blows her doors off. Sorry Amy. The great thing is it is not a competition. Amy does her thing and she does is wonderfully. Floor is the quintessential professional. Respect for Amy, Praise for Floor.
Yeah floor is amazing and I adore her 🤗❤️ but o think Amy's breath control is getting better I recomend you to check 2021 live version of weight of the world I thought she may not be able to hit that high note but she did it even better 🤗
So have you not heard her Bring Me To Life performance with the Wagakiki Band? She was absolutely amazing and totally did justice for that song. And that was only a few years ago. And yes she is getting way better with her breath control. So please stop disrespecting our goddess.
Both amazing. Amy's voice is not as powerful, but it is PERFECT for rock (and still obviously very powerful, but I shouldn't even need to say that).
wow! #Floorgarsm #Evgarsm mi dos cantantes favoritas, siempre he querido escucharlas juntas, gracias por este video! muy bueno
de nada mi amigo ❤️
They both put on awesome shows
Love and respect them both for what they do. But Floor is the far superior singer, always consistent in her live performances; whether sick or not.
Floor is one of a hell versatile and professional trained singer for 25 years. SHE CAN DO WHATEVER SHE WANTS, remember that. Amy Lee is just a twangy singer. Period.
Floor can definitely do many things, yet she sounds flat and void of emotions. It's like listening to a robot. Which is understandable. At least she's not faking. She can't relate to the lyrics others have written in a way the writer can. Which is why Amy is superior in her delivery of emotional aspect of all of her songs. She genuinely connects to the crowd in a way Floor just isn't capable of. And Amy's timber is the most beautiful female vocal color recognized immediately, while Floor doesn't have that uniqueness. Different things move us in music... if you can't grasp the greatness of Amy Lee - don't be a jerk about it. Listen to Floor and let others enjoy who they find more appealing. Why the need to talk nonsense?
@@AmyLeeForever you're so wrong in so many levels about Floor.
@@taurusguy9305 Just like you are about Amy Lee.
@@AmyLeeForever On one hand your saying let everybody enjoy there own favorite But how in the hell can you say Floor is incapable of singing with Amy’s emotion since the songs weren’t written for her Besides this video have you heard Floor sing one of the most common reactions to Floor singing is how emotional Grown Men get when there listening to Floor sing I could care less who anyone enjoys more But you can’t make a ridiculous statement like that
@@jerrypapadatos1210 It's simply a fact. What song evokes which emotions for you. Do tell.
it might be a joke. u can not compare with goddes and a singer.
Both beautiful, talented ladies. If I had to choose it would be Floor every time, over everyone male or female from any genre or era. 👌😊👍
Floor is technically better, Amy has a more beautiful timber. Love both
Hi! Fan of Amy Lee and Evanescence as well as a fan of Floor Jansen and Nightwish, ReVamp and After Forever. Can I just say that I love both singers equally and I have nothing against the other. I've always adored each singer and I love the emotions they give off live and studio.
I've been reading some of these comments and I just want to say that the Nightwish Army (not all of the people in the Nightwish Army) are toxic. As goes to the EvHeads, there are toxic people (not all EvHeads) in that Fandom as well. I just want to say that both Fandoms may prefer one over the other, but can we please just be respectful about how we say who we like? That like literally something I'm sure Nightwish and Evanescence would agree with. I'm even sure that both bands would not like toxic people in each Fandom popping off on each other about who's the best live and whatever. Both Amy and Floor have their own way of approaching their vocals. People may clay it works, people may say it doesn't work. All I'm saying is that please do not come after each other because if Floor and or Amy sees people who are toxic in the Nightwish Army and the EvHead Fandom, they would not like it and would possibly resent individual fans that are toxic. So be nice or don't say anything at all.
P.S. I hope everyone is aware that when you insult an Evanescence fan, you maybe insulting a Nightwish fan and vice versa. There are people who love both bands just as equal, but being respectful of who we prefer is much better than arguing. Yeah some bad things in the past were said and done, but if you want to live in that past, feel free to do so, because there are fans that just want to move on and be happy with each other. So with that said, there are Nightwish fans that love Evanescence. Don't disrespect people in your own Fandom because of who they like. Simple as that and that goes to Evanescence fans also.
Floor has a great Range and Belting Register . But she fails to Deliver me any Emotions . Amy Lee has maybe Not the perfect technique but she Delivers alot of Emotions and i enjoy her music and songs much More.
Floor fails to deliver emotions???😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
@@jackskellington9570 ever heard of an opinion or preference? It ain't that deep
@@arisboba That's nice Roger. Hey how are the kids Roger?
@@jackskellington9570 yes her Timbre is not very warm . I m not into her voice Timbre .
@@feridedogan7653 there's a difference in not preferring something in her voice and saying she doesn't do something that she does well above the average
Ich liebe Amy seid über 18 Jahren und finde sie ist die BESTE. Ihre Stimme ist einzigartig, bitte seht eich das Video von Lost in Paradies bei den AMP sessions an da hört man ihre Stimme am allerbesten. Floor ist auch gut aber nicht mein Geschmack ich finde es zu sehr wie Operngesang und das mag ich persönlich halt nicht (no hate) aber ich finde auch nicht dass man die 2 miteinander vergleichen sollte weil sie doch sehr unterschiedliche Richtungen haben 🤷♀️ schöne Grüße aus Österreich
Amy Lee can sing sure, but Floor's voice is just much more spacious and musical, amy lee is more limited, thinner in sound, and she has to force it more, it is never as free and spacious as that of Floor Jansen, sorry
Their belts are different. Passd Eb5, Floor is exclusively in a mix with headvoice. Amy is still belting in chest passed that note (not all the time, depending on the performances shown).
Based on the comments on this video I can't help but feel how toxic Floor's fanbase has become.
And yet evanescence fan base isn’t toxic?
@@marie882 not at that level, no
my heart belongs to Floor!
Floor is good in her own right but Amy is in a league of her own
no comparison: Floor = more power, more room more music, sorry. Amy Lee can sing, but not very special
Two of my favorite singers ♥️♥️ BOTH
It bothers me when singers don't have vibrato in the belts. It kind of hurts my ears, the vibrato is cushioning, the straight belt notes are irritating. I know floor does some straight notes like in the song Devil and Deep Dark Ocean but her voice at those times is still not irritating.
Yeah Amy sings very staight notes most of the time but floor has a beautiful vibrato. I guess it's about preferences
Also after a certain point its objectively not fair to compare belts past a certain range as floor is a soprano and Amy is not.
Actually a mezzo is a soprano but there are different ranges of soprano. That being said I like both vocalists but cant stand how some fanboys act in comments so I usually don't comment
@@gzin33 A mezzo soprano is not a soprano. Its the middle of the three main female vocal ranges
Amy Lee's voice may not be technically the best but it is so smooth and has so much emotion in it. Not many singers have that quality. So imho Amy is better than Flo.
I prefer Amy. Her voice feels more melodic, sweet, and emotional. Floor's voice is too deep and flat for my liking, her voice feels boring to me.
i am lucky i see both them live
You're absolutely super lucky
Amy lee
Si bien Flor muestra más tecnica y menos aire me quedo con Amy; tiene mejor timbre y mucho mas rango que sólo belting... Por algo es Amy Lee señores... en los 2 mil todas la imitaban, todas quisieron ser Amy: Kelly, Xtina, Avril, Tarja y Sharon lo han dicho, evanescence les abrió las puertas a ellas como front womans también... de ahí para adelante.
Mejor técnica, mejor manejo de aire, más potencia, versatilidad.. Floor es mejor cantante, el q grupo gusta más ya es subjetivo y personal
@@cavernadigitalpro estás muy mal Amy Lee es considerada vos única y te digo mas me gusta mucho más Sharon den adel que Floor ,Sharon en vivo es mágica
@@van3638 Es mi punto de vista, todo bien con que no estés de acuerdo.
name of the all musics please
Floor has an amazing voice and control, but in my opinion, Amy is the better musician in general.
No,no,no Floor is the most complete and versitile singer
@@eddiehesselman3904 Notice I said musician, not singer.
@@eddiehesselman3904 they said musician. Amy is a multi-instrumentist as she plays piano, harp, guitar bass and ukalele besides singing. She also writes every song in Ev's catalog from Fallen onward
@@mimi8808 this video is about singing and not about musicianship so where's the problem.
Floor is and will always be the superior singer. Floor can take ANY song from ANY artist and make it her own. She has an uncanny ability to make every note count. Amy Lee is a one trick pony singing her own songs that have the backing from being an American. I just don't see Amy Lee giving Ghost Love Score or Pan or Shoemaker any justice. But I am 100% positive that Floor could take Evanescence song and make it her own. If you would watch any of the hundreds of Nightwish concerts on UA-cam you would clearly see that Floor connects with her audience and is a true professional and acts accordingly. She doesn't need to jump around like a baffoon to make a point or put on a show.
If Floor was to sing ANY Evanescence song it would show how flat her delivery is. And calling Amy a buffoon just shows how envious you are... Shame on you.
Bruh your comment sounds like you really hate Amy lol. She isn't vocally trained unlike Floor (she is also a vocal coach) and their music genre is different. Both are great in their own ways, they have both pros and cons. I love them both. But I'm not sure if Floor can do justice if she sings any of Evanescence's songs, she needs to show her emotions when singing it since Amy always put her emotions to her songs. Amy could sing GLS in her own style though like what Annette's did.
I like them both, but live Amy is no competition to floor
Yeah, everyone knows floor but no one knows Amy. Amy sings bad, doesn't know how to play instruments live and also wrote no successful songs.
She is such a failure of an artist when compared to floor.
@@leoni7649 I don't say Amy is no good, I like her. but floor is the better singer. she doesn't play any instruments so those points go to Amy.
I have a lot of respect for Amy, but Floor is better...
I don't think this is a reasonable comparison, most people tend to forget that Amy Lee has always been more of a musician and composer than just some band's singer. Floor has definitely the strongest technique out of the two. And Amy could definitely find a vocal coach to help her improve her singing skills, but she does a lot more to just sing for her band and I don't think she has the time and the desire to do so.
Both💖💖
Oh no. I love Amy. Don't do this to her!! She doesn't hold a candle towards Floor. But she is so amazing and I love her
Both amazing singers, and two of my favorites but totally different ranges and styles. I believe Floor is an objectively better singer, but I prefer Amy. Would be interesting to see them covering each other’s song.
Amy lee queen ❤⚡
I prefer Amy's voice, Floor sounds flat to me.
I love them both so friggin much
Both are great singer and I like Floor Jansen, but Amy lee is my life 🧬
No se puede comparar a la gran floor jansen con Amy l una mas del montón floor es una de las más grandes en la historia del metal
Una más del montón? JAJA será al revés para escuchar un intento de opera tenemos a tarja, simone parece que otra es una más del montón. UPS se tenia que decir y se dijo.
Sera al revés Floor Jansen no tiene mi la mitad de los premios de evanescence además Amy tiene una vos única flor tiene un tiemble y un color de vos muy común a diferencia de Amy y Sharon y Amy domina y toca más instrumentos además es la líder de su banda mientras que floor es lame botas del odioso de Thomas
Eres un loco no ves que floor no tiene ningún logro de nada solo es una más de muchas si quiero oír ópera oigo a Tarja o a Sahara Brightman
Creer que floor y tarja son el mismo tipo de cantante demuestra el poco conocimiento en el mundo del metal que tienen algunos por favor a escuchar más metal
@@raulcalderon2579 habla de Amy Lee no se Tarja Amy Lee es mágica igual que a Sharon den adel sin mágicas floor solo canta bien no es mágica no desprende magia en el escenario sabiondo
Amy is way better.Amy is way better.
Floor is at least 3 levels above Amy Lee
In singing maybe. In all the other aspects of an artist she is waaaay behind. Amy sings, play the instruments live while singing and sings very successful songs she wrote herself.
Floor is a magnificent singer but that is it. Pretty mediocre in every other aspect.
Nice video. Long snippets from Amy, partly much shorter ones from Floor. And the audio quality is partly really good selected for a comparison. Here you can see where the preferences lie. 😉
For example 3:06
12 sec Amy and best quality
5 sec Floor shitty quality
I tried to choose similar videos and believe me ıt was really hard to find all of the notes so thats why 🤗 at 2:00 floor hits 2 long d5's and Amy's one is shorter. do u really think that im trying to throw trash at floor 🤗
At the time stamp u wrote compares Floor's E5 and Amy's Eb5? And she even only hits Eb5 for 2 seconds 🤗 and ıf u take a little look at my videos u can clearly see I adore floor 🤗❤️
Floor seems better trained, Amy seems more versatile and has great tonal quality
More versatile, you are aware that Floor does everything from growling to opera right?
@@Harolddespuifloor doesn’t singer opera that’s not opera. It’s classical not opera
@@FluffyLaDooDooAfter 3 years of Rock academy, in 2002 Floor did one year of opera training at a Dutch conservatorium. Ofcourse she can sing opera! 😄
@@Harolddespui omg 😭😭 FLOOR MENTION it several time that she isn’t an opera singer. You clearly don’t know what an opera singer is. floor is a classical singer
@@FluffyLaDooDoo Here Floor doing opera: ua-cam.com/video/UeTyAZtV5wI/v-deo.htmlsi=t4WpGamjCOgS6z4-
Have a good night.
This is a beautiful video. I love how shape of endless note's: audio-action at noting notes, forming endless action are felt; visual sight and emotional sense joyful love of musical singing well-animated clear are mentality and physicality saturated sensed: resonating-ponder, musical-intricacies of action are outlet felt-learned to learnt feeling, and absorb in the magical moment singing are monumental for the video here. For inspire clear note singing are felt in the tone: tonal awakening of the phenomenal Evanescence Lead Singer inspired and inspires, inspiring delighting my own singing talent which is an endless, variety: fun blend of The Oneness of all-Things Musical for progression of musical training at the refine of in the moment noting note's. Thanks for the video here.
It's a pleasure for me bud 🥰 Im glad you liked it
Id like to hear a cover by you if its possible 🥰
@@mrallsundayy Thanks buddy..
@@mrallsundayy Fine can I send it in to the @Robbie Ren on an audio-file or something? I am honored for such an opportunity Robbie Ren.
@@melbourneleogibbsgibson...1653 of course bud 🥰 I am actually honored to be able to hear your art ❤️🤗
Floor Jansen ❤
Amy wins for me, her voice is way more likeable and fine to listen to, her tone is way richer, whereas Floor feels like a more perfeted singer but doesn't release emotion in her voice, more power but less intimate unlike Amy who has power and also way of emoting with each note she sings. Floor could have a better technique but as far as performance level, Amy is an excelent performer, her stamina, her energy on stage, the way she puts on a great show and knowing she is a full on musican and not just a singer, makes her better. Floor is praised by songs she doesn't write in Nightwish, and Amy is singing her own words and lyrics and songs she composed from 0, that's the difference between a good singer and a full on musician like Amy.
Agree to disagree
Amy lee has a really lovely tone right!!!! 🤗 I actually think that Floor is a gorgeous stage presence too and I also like her but I don't think you know about her previous projects 🤗 She composes her own songs too 🤗
@@mrallsundayy yeah I know she has written her songs but those songs aren't as good as the ones on Nightwish where people are loving her for. Tuomas is better writter than her, floor is not singing while playing instruments neither. I rarely see her move around the stage she uses mic stand all the time. So her performance is more all about her vocals and Amy is about everything bc shes doing her songs her vocals moving all over the stage headbanging twirling and rocking out each song, whenever she did Synthesis she proved how well she does in thay standing pose but as far as Ev rock shows she is way more entertaining to watch her do a concert
LOL you cant be serious.
@@xPaLmaaHx the who is the better composer thing is so subjective I think
Playing enstrument thing is up to singer 🤗
Floor moves around a lot too and she has awesome headbangs
I like Amy's stage presence a lot too 🤗❤️ they both are really good
Not to be rude but comparing two different singers in different genres makes no sense. Floor is a metal singer, Amy lee isn't. In my opinion Floor is technically a better singer just for the fact that she can growl which makes her so versatile singer than Amy Lee. Not saying Amy Lee is bad it's just I heard Amy Lee struggles live performances mid way.
Yeah Floor definitely has better technique and education
Amy uses little growls in her songs too not as much as floor but still does
It's not about comparing it's more like having a beautiful music experience
Nice to meet the voice of Amy Lee, Quite impressive i must say,
Amy can't even compare to Queen Floor.
Floor is a 10 in vocal technique. Amy is maybe an 8 at best? However as full artists Amy is faaaar ahead of floor. Better composer, live pianist, band leader. Just a complete and successful artist.
We are comparing a magnificent professional singer to a complete artist.
For example, My immortal which was written by Amy when she was 15 is more successful than any song floor has ever dreamed to write.
F5 E5 part killed me😂😂😂😂. Amy is the queen of emotional singing.
Right it was amazing 😜🤟🏻 thank you
Obviously you aren't familiar with Floor then because she puts emotion into every song.
@@floorfan7987 well I like them both but it's subjective 🤗❤️ I love floor emotions a lot
@@mrallsundayy I also like both.
Making these videos is inviting arguing in the comments anyway, it breeds contention to compare like this. People like what they like aurally and it's vastly variable. Why even keep.making these.
Amy ❤
Sin dudas Amy lee
Amy is amazing specially live in front of her Synthesis was out of this world
Idk but i think Floor have better Quality tone in LIVE performances.. Could be the fact that Amy moves too much around the stage and lost her breath.. But either way they are great.. And Floor it's just something else that Singing.. Floor it's a 11/10 and Amy it's a 9/10 For sure.
both artists have great and famous voices.. for me, ŞEBNEM FERAH .. has a better voice in both..
The disadvantage of ŞEBNEM FERAH is that it does not have an international reputation..
if it could be international like floor and amy, it has millions of fans and audiences in the world today. she would be an artist...
but ŞEBNEM FERAH is a rock queen.
🖤🤘Şebo Rock Queen kısmını anladım :D
I love them both equally!
05:03 If Amy Lee sings that note, she'll die of shortness of breath
??? 05:18
Hard to tell, but considering she's a mezzo soprano you're probably right.
The same could he said about floor's talent for composition. 15 year old Amy lee was able to write My immortal. You could combine every single song floor has ever composed and the total won't reach the success of a single song a teenager Amy lee reached.
Not to mention that Amy plays the piano for half of their songs. Her brain is basically divided into two different instruments, while floor is always 100% focused in her single instrument.
Amy Lee 💕
I really like floor she is a super singer the best technically but the voice of Amy Lee and Sharon den Adel is something sweet that relaxes the soul in addition to having unique tones the tone of floor is very common, not like Amy and Sharon's is only my criteria and my tastes
Amylee forever 🤘🤘 but love both
Floor ⚘💖
Amy ❤️❤️❤️
Give a Layne Staley song to them both and then , everyone of them who can sing it correctly, is better than the other one
FFFLLLOOORRRR
Nothing against Amy but she wasn't really belting those last 2 notes. Sounds more like a head voice to me
They sounded like mixy belted notes to me im not quite sure u might be right bud
FLOOR
Amy is fantastic, but Floor is on a higher level and vocal capabilities, she can sing anything. I love them, I'm a musician and I'm telling you how things really are.
Two of the greatest female vocalist. I would love to see/hear Amy do some deeper lyrics, to hear her coloring to express emotions and passion.
What do you mean deeper lyrics? Most of her songs has really deep lyrics. Especially the ones about her sister. Tf?
İkisi de çok iyi ama Amy alır
Mdlsmsls yia yine anında ldksldmdşd
@@mrallsundayy her zaman sfsdg
Deberis escuchar adimash kudaybergen