Hey everybody, I just wanted to let you know that a patch has been released this morning and fixed the bug issues that I mentioned. It seems now that all characters are recruitable without any bugs or issues whatsoever. I just wanted to let you know. Hope you enjoy the game!
@@ChristianEzequiel-v6r I don't remember if it's for PC or not because I was interested in the Switch version, but if it is then that's an inevitability via mods (although the usual hosts won't allow such mods, so there will be a bit of searching involved).
I just realized after beating the game, during all the war battles the soldiers that fall are all named after people that donated off kickstarter. I noticed some of the names from watching the ending. They truly went all in on this wonderful game.
@@Gdg195 Oh because YOU don't like it then it's just nostalgia? Someone doesn't know how opinions and taste work. Sorry but your taste isn't "better" than anyone else's, no one is the supreme judge on what is "good" and what isn't, but fact is Suikoden II is widely considered to be one of the best RPG's ever made. If you didn't like it, fine, but to suggest anyone who likes it are blind to nostalgia is laughable. There are some old games that I don't like that others do but I don't just say they must just like them for nostalgic reasons, they have their own reasons for enjoying what they enjoy, I'm not narcissistic enough to think I know exactly how their mind works and the reasons they enjoy it. Get over yourself.
Suikoden II is one of the greatest JRPGs of all time, in my opinion, and you couldn't keep me away from this game by saying "it's so old school it doesn't have modern quality of life improvements" because neither does Suikoden II and I've found it kinda silly seeing some reviews where people complain about that. That's not a bug, to me, that's a feature.
Honestly, I would gladly take the old school feel wothout the "modern QoL improvements" if it meant seeing an actually diverse and likable roster of characters. I feel like that is a dead art form these days.
This is so well said, exactly how I feel! Some modern gamers don't have the experience of truly old school RPGs while living in real time in the era of old school RPGs, and I accept that it changes their perception. But dayam, it sucks to be them!! Well, except for those more vigorous younger folks who immediately feel at home getting their arse whooped. ❤
I'm 6hrs into it and what a game so far it's so beautiful and well done it's definitely just like playing a Suikoden game straight up. Im so proud and happy how well this game has turned out and can't wait to spend over 100+ hrs on it 😁.
Over 100 hours... it's not that long is it? That's concerning because games that are that long always suck because they're quantity over quality. Suikoden II is 33 and a half hours for just the main story, 52 hours for 100% completion and that game had A LOT to do and a perfectly good length for a story which doesn't drag. 100 hours would either mean the story drags on with poor pacing or there's a bunch of tedious copy paste quests to fill up time... NO THANKS. There's no reason for this game to be twice the length of suikoden II. Edit: Thank goodness, I found it is 40/45 hours story length and 55 to 60 hours for 100%. That's MUCH better than another one of those 100 hour chores (like Persona 5)
I backed this thing up, real early on, $100 in. The most I've ever spent on a video game. I'm so glad I did. I didn't know it was going to be Yoshitaka Murayama's last (though he did leave a story outline for a sequel to this, apparently). It makes me happy to see this game is doing so well and getting so much attention. That bug is a HUGE letdown. Though, I will play it before they patch it simply because I know I won't get everyone on my first playthrough. I always played suikoden games blind, and didn't do character recruitment guides until a second playthrough. But if they still haven't fixed that bug by then, that would truly sour the experience.
Come on, Erick. You should be used to random encounters interrupting the puzzles🙂Thank you for this great review. It is more informative than many others. As a Suikoden fan I can easily look past this game's problems, but I wish more people could do that. This game is so precious. Stay strong Rabbit and Bear. Murayama Yoshitaka and his games will live forever in our hearts
@@rupeeslang5121have you played the game? Bcs if you did, you will not said something like "there is not much left of the original Japanese writing" It has little bit of issue and cringe joke, but it is really not that bad.
It's a fantastic game. I will say that the two weakest aspects of it are war scenarios and localization. War combat is very bare bones. They could have taken inspiration from existing tactical RPGs. Maybe that's just me? And the localization is causing controversy because of recent issues with translators (inserting their own views rather than attempt to translate it faithfully) and companies like "Sweet Baby, Inc." Those who can read and speak Japanese will have no issues. RIP, Murayama-san.
@@zaciroth There are lines where it's pretty obvious the localizers did what they wanted. For example, there is one line where a character just says "Heeh..." but the localizers inputted dialogue. Mind you, that is one of several examples I found, and I'm 5 hours into the game. I'm the type of gamer who is okay with translations IF they stay true to the original's vision, by the way. If they take too many liberties, that's where it becomes a problem. Lian, in Japanese, is your typical upbeat female character. She's very similar to Nanami from Suikoden II. However, the localizers cranked her annoyance up to 20/10. I recommend keeping it on Japanese dub. If you can read Japanese, I recommend keeping it on both. That way, it's as true to Murayama's vision as it gets. Perhaps that's just me, though.
thats a good comment unlike the paladins saying the game localization dont matter and anyone complaining about it is not a suikoden fan , people are so adamant on defending clearly bad localization on some aspects of the game just because they dont care about the real vision of the author as long as they can play the game in english, and those are the ones that call themselves "true fans" lmao.
@@Durinson1 If you understand Japanese, it will make a huge difference. It will be even better if you can read Japanese, so you can get the full context.
The game look good. And I enjoyed the old school games. I see alot of people here talking about the localization and how bad it is. I've seen some of the comparisons from the true translation to the localized version and it honestly doesn't seem that bad. However I would push back on a couple of things. The guy that worked on this game's localization said something to the effect of they need to change certain things specifically because certain Japanese sensibilities would be considered offensive in the West. First, I'm in the West and have been playing Japanese games pretty much my entire life and would prefer that if they have something offensive to say, that I get to know what it is for myself. Second these people do not actually care at all about being offensive, they do it all the time. Many of them actually seem to revel in the idea of making people feel as offended as possible. They just like being able to decide who it is ok to offend and who it is not ok to offend. They smear people and call them names all the time. They are very selective see. But for them to say that they want to shield people from offensive content is a bad joke. They don't care about that at all. If they meant what they say, then it would be universally applied. And that is definitely not what is happening. Sometimes though, these things do get a little blown out of proportion. And I still want to pick this game up. I am a sucker for old school Japanese style games.
@@micshazam842 Totally different cases. The localization is using modern western left political insults like chud, that's an objective issue. Stellar Blade is just DEI advocates melting down.
I refused to watch any other reviews of this game until you did yours. I knew your love for the suikoden series would give credibility to your opinion. Great video, worth the wait.
Me in here hoping these guys revisit the Vandal Hearts concept again too, the unique structure of that TRPG always has me coming back and I want more, though its sequels never captured my heart like the first one did.
glad this game came out finally, i'm playing the ao no kiseki sub series, so i will give it a try much later, but by your review... i can't wait to play it, thanks for the video, have a good one.
Erick thank you so much for your review! I had seen a headline about "bugginess," and I'm glad I checked out your review to get the context! I will likely buy it soon if only to be able to track the bugfix as the green light to start playing!
For all those that worry about spoilers so kind of skip around in reviews he actually recommends NOT BUYING THIS GAME UNTIL IT GETS PATCHED. Right now there are bugs that prevent you from being able to recruit all characters, which can have adverse effects on other characters and the endings.
People are even compiling the bad localization like with Mio gendering a Golem. internet slang like "Chud" and the lines of Francesca is way over the top compare to the JP version.
Francesca's lines make me laugh 🤷♀Most people don't know Japanese and won't realize that there are differences so who cares really... This "issue" is completely overblown and doesn't impact your enjoyment.
Actually do recruit that one character you need the old spirit guy character in your party and if you talk to him at the end at the castle, he would tell you about her if she actually very old
Honestly, the thumbnail had me worried that this would be yet another thing I look forward to that ends up being garbage. I'm glad to see people like it, though. I plan on getting this one day.
This game gets a lot better mid-late game, but I really wish the re-balanced magic & hero combos to be more useful. Only a hamdful of hero combos are more useful than just having the 2+ characters separately basic attack, and most magic spells are powerful than basic attacking too. Magic finally started getting a bit stronger when I was about 30 hours in, and even then it was limited to a small number of spells on an even smaller number of heroes.
I have some doubts! Could you talk a little about the mini card game in this game? I'm super curious and I haven't seen anyone talk about it! When can I play the mini card game? Last question, this is the first turn-based game I've played that doesn't show the enemies' life bar at the time of the fight, I'm completely lost without knowing if that enemy is dying or not! How do you plan your fight without knowing the enemy's life?
what I love is there isn't any bloat, pacing issues or "devs not respecting the player's time" feeling that you find a lot in JRPGs nowadays : FF7R games, Octopath, the Trails, etc etc. Eiyuden grabs you and doesn't let go, like good JRPGs of old!
Only the official Chinese translation is faithful to the Japanese dialogue, every other language uses the English mangling. We'll have to wait for a fan patch kind of like how the PS1 Suikodens had fan patches for the localisation many years later.
@@armorvil depends on how adamant you are personally to what does and does not make a localization good/bad. Some take it VERY seriously (obviously). Some will likely play this and not even notice the difference or care that there is a difference. And that is totally fine. Most people are saying it is pretty shit though, not just bad.
yeah, no way these guys are getting my money, i am very serious and strict about these things since i'm not a brainless consumer, i can play something else. they blew it, next time find non woke translators.
Suikoden 1 is relatively short, I'd start there just to see if you like the style of the franchise, it's a lower time investment and still worth playing even if later entries may be better.
I just bought this today and haven't played it yet because I had to work 😢. I'm really glad I saw your review- I was starting to get discouraged after watching a few other reviews- all of which were primarily negative. Looking forward to playing once again!
So that "Do I now...?" line looked like a bug to me. Maybe the wrong string. But hey, it's a Suikoden 2 spiritual successor! Gotta have some baffling localization issues right?
Love the game absolutely a masterpiece when it comes to jrpgs. But man do i hate the inventory limit. That would be my biggest grip with the gm so far.
Im 10 hours in and i love the game, except Lian. That character is single handedly ruining this games story for me. Im tired of stupid, annoying characters in these types of games and Lian is by far the worse. I'm praying i can take her out of my party soon. I have a better grapple damager already who does more damage. If Lian stays a big part of the games story i will quite playing. Or just skip the story altogether. She single handedly deflates all the drama and escalation of every scene in the game.
Ok a couple more hours into the game and the war has officially kicked off and I got control of my first unit. Lian has become much more serious as well once it becomes apperant how bad things are. This is much better. I thought she was gonna act like an idiot airhead throughout the entire game but it looks like these events have knocked some sense into her. I kinda like that for her character so...well played Eiyudan Chronicles.
The Suikoden series is my favorite video game series ever, period. I owned and beat I-V numerous times, going back and recruiting all 108 stars of Destiny, and even tried my best to get through the DS game 😂 I downloaded this last night but I’m so excited to play a game like Suikoden again!
1:33 : Some people have posted side by side videos and PS5 and Steam both look roughly the same, amazing, PS4 looks like a step down from PS5/Steam but still good, Switch looks like a big step down. No major surprises with any of that, but its worth noting that if your looking for the optimal visual experience, PS5 and Steam are a noticeable step ahead of the other choices.
Turning on or off random encounters should be an option in any modern jrpg. As you said it annoys you during puzzles and also you can do challenge runs without leveling up...
the game is to sadly be avoided til they fix this terrible localization the answer "just learn a different language" shouldn't be the answer yet here it really is, its depressing but there's no point forcing yourself through a terrible localization by egotistical localizers thinking they're writers when they aren't
Localization always hate "grunts". Or a lot of "non worded" voice lines. At least if they are gonna put dialogue over these grunts, they should make appear as "inner monologues" if they insist of localizing a grunt into sentences if they think the english speaking people won't understand the nuance of a "grunt" or a Hrmmm...
tbh if only grunts that show disappointment they just can write, "ah cmon" or "Really", or "Oh" "ahh" an empty reaction that didnt have any meaning what so ever. why game this day always like this. did i need push my self to get N3 exam just for reading JP text.
Saw the localization quality and the person responsible for it... cancelled. Sorry, not giving these nutjobs my money, sorry to the Devs, as im sure it's 505's fault and not yours.
South african here 9/10 for me as fan of suikoden 2, too wholesome,happy,power of friendhip ish, a pinch of dark and edginess would be great for the next installment cant wait
...I just saw this post after writing my own comment lol. Guess I'll need to look into what the translators did once some people compile stuff (which given how people have been compiling stuff lately due to Sweet Baby's BS may not be hard to find out nowadays). Granted some people also embellish how much the translators screw things over (Unicorn Overlord for instance hasn't really had anything in it that pushes woke BS and at worst expands on the Japanese lines for the sake of sounding more old Medieval English speech patterns you'd see in the Noble's court which is livable given the rest of the game is great...if it's like that I can give Eiyden a pass...if it's Dragonmaid anime levels of bad though ya I'd be out). As long as it's no worse than the localizations done from the PS2 era to around just before when woke shit was being hamfisted into our faces (last 5 years or so) it'll be tolerable at the very least if it's to play and at least understand the story of the game (basically as long as it's no worse than Pokemon's donuts translation of rice balls...ya wrong word but both are food and barely have relevance on the main plot...was it stupid though ya won't deny that but not gonna say no to a game I'm excited for (granted Eiyden would be more of a random pickup for me than full on excitement...a must have pickup would be Trails/Ys/Tales) just for some minor translation issues).
@@robsonazevedoferreira3119the community managers are banning people who complain about this in discord, both sides are annoying to some extent but only one has power
What did you think about Eiyuden Chronicle: Rising? I never saw you talk about it and am considering picking it up, seeing as it's only $4.49 for the next 3 days.
There is game breaking bug that wont let me continue the story. Late in game after i talk to seign on top of the castle . Then u have to talk to euma. It says on current goal you cant get to sleep. Try taking a walk. But in game its day light and nothing progresses the story. At all. I have no backup saves.
So I've encountered a couple of problems on Switch (I don't know if they're exclusive) that are annoying enough for me to not play it. 1. You cannot use Auto-Advance, it works in voiced cutscenes but if you try to talk to NPC's with it, then it closes the dialogue box before it's typed out, meaning you constantly have to toggle it between cutscenes and exploration making you have to try and guess where cutscenes are triggered. 2. It takes a good 10 seconds to load random battles which REALLY breaks the flow of the game. I know it's an indie title but they've had some good funding and it's 2024. These are minor grievances for most, I know. But they personally annoyed me enough within the first half an hour that I had to put it down. I hope they patch it up because I've been excited for this for years.
I forgot to ask: I saw in your video battle footage several kind of silly enemies. Are there a lot of teddy bears and silly looking enemies in this game? That's one thing that could be a negative imo...
Oh no... damn Deluxe Version and me not wanting to use a guide on the first time... I already spoke with that bugged character. Well, let's cross fingers I manage to get her anyway...
@@Kwisatz-Chaderach Maybe no more worries are needed. Today was a patch and they announced they wanted to fix that issue (and some other things) with it. I am crossing my fingers
I’ve never played a game like this and the suikoden series. Everyone is mentioning that. But I wanted to try it because of the artwork. Now I can’t wait to get home just to play it. 😅
I'm 9 hours into the PC version, and what I would say about the save system is that the autosaves are too far apart. The save points don't seem too bad, but there are times when you look at the time of the autosave and it was 30 minutes or more ago. In the event of a crash (or power failure) this would prove annoying. No stability issues on the PC version for me so far, but I hear the Switch version definitely suffers from crashes.
Having been playing the crap out of Star Ocean: First Departer R and Star Ocean: Second Story R. and playing the OG Suikoden 1 and 2 games through emulation along with FF1-6, the random encounter aspect doesn't bother me at all.
Load times before and after battles, bad translations, and the auto scroll skips dialogue which also makes that damn chirp noise after every press of the confirm button. A bunch of awkward small issues that can be patched for sure. Other than that this game is pure suikoden goodness, 9/10 baby
Is it required to play and beat Eiyuden Chronicle: Rising prior to this in order to understand the whole plot or unlock something important? I heard you unlock something in Rising and it carries over to Hundred Heroes.
It's not required. Rising is more an introduction to the world, lore, and some of the characters (and will probably get you to like its main 3 chars; it certainly did for me). What you get from transferring save is a rune that is from early mid game (honestly I didn't even use it, it wasn't that preferrable). Also the names that you give the weapons of the main 3 characters get transferred over, as well as the name you give the town specialty. You also get the tower in the town transferred over, but I have not yet made it to the town from Rising in this game, so I dont know what it does.
i feel bad to set my expectation to has same as Suikoden 2, its not that high bar, BUT, its something like Suikoden 1 but better. maybe as same as Suikoden 5 too. the inventory system should be bigger too, but im glad they didnt share slot with accessory. also maybe some in deepth for the Rune lore? i mean what hook me with Suikoden is How powerfull true rune is. and MC usually held that 1 true rune from 27 True rune. and if you play Suikoden IV or V you know how scary True rune power is. tho, i still waiting for the clue to recruit people, i hope they made secret / true ending if we get all the recruitable character like how Suikoden game always
I'm actually sort of glad runes were more of a McGuffin in this game than in Suikoden. The 27 true runes created a sort of narrative limitation because they were just sort of there, in a way. Rune Barrows and the primal lenses seem to have an entire ancient civilization tied to them, which might be put to use in a story further down the line (even if Murayama won't be the one to write it; I think Eiyuden as a franchise will live or die by how the sequel does). They already have in-world limits on who can use rune lenses and how well they can be used, so you don't really need to attach a character to a primal lens, either.
Good to know the loading isn't just on xbox which I'm currently playing on but will replay on ps5 down the line. I'll continue to play this on gamepass until the little issues are fixed. But having a lot of fun so far!
Hate it when people who've never played the original suikoden, make these dumbass reviews man. watched a reviewer (not you) complain that u can only change runes at the rune shop. duh! Ofc u can only change runes on the rune shop because that's how it is in suikoden 1 and 2. grew up playing the series during the 90's
@@craig581 Erick said that it's not needed. Why I hate that? Because it's basically impossible to get all of them without a guide during first playthrough. Playing with a guide is not fun.
Not really. You get a couple bonuses for having a save file for the game when you start a new game in Hundred Heroes. You get a Clock Tower in your eventual base, a rune, and can carry over names of weapons for a few characters. It's safe to say you probably won't notice these bonuses if you didn't have them. Although it's a fun game and fairly short. You'll probably go mad trying to 100% it though.... Seriously almost all the extra side quests are collection and grinding in old areas, and there's like 5+ that pop up damn near anytime you do something. It's a fun romp in the world with some extra lore thrown in.
Once there is a mod to fix the translation I will buy it. I don't want to read stuff like "Rub-adub-dub, don't be a flub" or use Urban dictionary to understand Zoomer jokes.
@@sharebear421 As far as I know, the original Japanese text is very different from the English text. Just compare the English subtitles with the translation from the Japanese.
Yeah this game is a 9/10 so far. I was worried after all the reviewers I follow and said they were fans all had different pros and cons. I have to say there are no load times on steam and it's super fast. So when I see people complaining about quality of life improvements I think they have been overblown. Switch Verizon does sound like it needs a patch. Otherwise any complaint I've seen about this game really comes off as whining. I think people have just become too used to newer crappier rpgs that just give you everything off the bat in menus. I loved the star ocean remake but the "qol" changes really killed my interest in replying as well. Felt like the game was playing itself and just checking off accomplishments and I didn't earn anything. I have seen people complaining about your inventory only holding 30 items, but they literally give you your vault from the very start to full up to your hearts content. First couple Suikodens were all about planning. I personally love some of the dungeons in this game (haven't said that in a few suikodens) and with the low encounter rate I haven't found it frustrating at all. This is old school gamer and suikoden delight so far.
Noriyuke Iwadare, Michiro Naruke and Motoi Sakuraba on music duty is incredible news and would make me pick up the game even if the rest of the game was awful. Fortunately, it sounds like that is not the case. Cannot wait to play this!
Hey everybody, I just wanted to let you know that a patch has been released this morning and fixed the bug issues that I mentioned. It seems now that all characters are recruitable without any bugs or issues whatsoever. I just wanted to let you know. Hope you enjoy the game!
What about a non woke retranslation patch? did they release one of those?
@@ChristianEzequiel-v6r I don't remember if it's for PC or not because I was interested in the Switch version, but if it is then that's an inevitability via mods (although the usual hosts won't allow such mods, so there will be a bit of searching involved).
I just realized after beating the game, during all the war battles the soldiers that fall are all named after people that donated off kickstarter. I noticed some of the names from watching the ending. They truly went all in on this wonderful game.
Suikoden II is one of the all-time greats and this definitely looks promising. Thanks for the review!
You know, for as much love as 2 gets, it is criminal that few ever mention 1 in the same sentence which is honestly equally as good.
@@mattbrown9631Yo, 1 is dope af. That duel with Pan and your Dad is classic.
No its not stop projecting nostalgia syndrome
@@Gdg195 Oh because YOU don't like it then it's just nostalgia? Someone doesn't know how opinions and taste work. Sorry but your taste isn't "better" than anyone else's, no one is the supreme judge on what is "good" and what isn't, but fact is Suikoden II is widely considered to be one of the best RPG's ever made. If you didn't like it, fine, but to suggest anyone who likes it are blind to nostalgia is laughable.
There are some old games that I don't like that others do but I don't just say they must just like them for nostalgic reasons, they have their own reasons for enjoying what they enjoy, I'm not narcissistic enough to think I know exactly how their mind works and the reasons they enjoy it. Get over yourself.
@@Vaquix000 dont care nostalgla syndrome ls really crlnge
I hope the Devs fix all the problems.Not playing until everything is ok.Great review!
I've had not a single issue with it. Started playing 2 weeks ago. It's absolutely worth the price. Plus it's on sale.
Suikoden II is one of the greatest JRPGs of all time, in my opinion, and you couldn't keep me away from this game by saying "it's so old school it doesn't have modern quality of life improvements" because neither does Suikoden II and I've found it kinda silly seeing some reviews where people complain about that. That's not a bug, to me, that's a feature.
Honestly, I would gladly take the old school feel wothout the "modern QoL improvements" if it meant seeing an actually diverse and likable roster of characters. I feel like that is a dead art form these days.
@@baalfgames5318 Absolutely agree.
I like that it went more traditional. I miss world maps and random battles.
Suikiden 2 IS the greatest jrpg of all time in my opinion and I still treasure my copy of the game. Gonna get this physically if reviews are good.
This is so well said, exactly how I feel!
Some modern gamers don't have the experience of truly old school RPGs while living in real time in the era of old school RPGs, and I accept that it changes their perception.
But dayam, it sucks to be them!! Well, except for those more vigorous younger folks who immediately feel at home getting their arse whooped. ❤
never clicked on a video so fast. great work Erick.
I'm 6hrs into it and what a game so far it's so beautiful and well done it's definitely just like playing a Suikoden game straight up. Im so proud and happy how well this game has turned out and can't wait to spend over 100+ hrs on it 😁.
Over 100 hours... it's not that long is it? That's concerning because games that are that long always suck because they're quantity over quality.
Suikoden II is 33 and a half hours for just the main story, 52 hours for 100% completion and that game had A LOT to do and a perfectly good length for a story which doesn't drag. 100 hours would either mean the story drags on with poor pacing or there's a bunch of tedious copy paste quests to fill up time... NO THANKS. There's no reason for this game to be twice the length of suikoden II.
Edit: Thank goodness, I found it is 40/45 hours story length and 55 to 60 hours for 100%. That's MUCH better than another one of those 100 hour chores (like Persona 5)
So it's been 4 months since ur comment. What's ur final view? I'm 11 hours in and loving it so far.
long live jrpg fans and thanks for the review dude
I started playing this recently. You’re right. This is the Suikoden successor fans have been hoping for! ❤
I backed this thing up, real early on, $100 in. The most I've ever spent on a video game. I'm so glad I did. I didn't know it was going to be Yoshitaka Murayama's last (though he did leave a story outline for a sequel to this, apparently). It makes me happy to see this game is doing so well and getting so much attention. That bug is a HUGE letdown. Though, I will play it before they patch it simply because I know I won't get everyone on my first playthrough. I always played suikoden games blind, and didn't do character recruitment guides until a second playthrough. But if they still haven't fixed that bug by then, that would truly sour the experience.
Come on, Erick. You should be used to random encounters interrupting the puzzles🙂Thank you for this great review. It is more informative than many others. As a Suikoden fan I can easily look past this game's problems, but I wish more people could do that. This game is so precious. Stay strong Rabbit and Bear. Murayama Yoshitaka and his games will live forever in our hearts
I'm afraid Eiyuden 2 won't have a writing this good because of Murayama's absence but it might reveal new talents...
Its not a great review. He did not mention a lot of issues this game have
@@claudiegarnier4560 Like what?
@@armorvil They butchered the translation anyway, there is not much left of the original Japanese writing.
@@rupeeslang5121have you played the game? Bcs if you did, you will not said something like "there is not much left of the original Japanese writing"
It has little bit of issue and cringe joke, but it is really not that bad.
It's a fantastic game.
I will say that the two weakest aspects of it are war scenarios and localization.
War combat is very bare bones. They could have taken inspiration from existing tactical RPGs. Maybe that's just me?
And the localization is causing controversy because of recent issues with translators (inserting their own views rather than attempt to translate it faithfully) and companies like "Sweet Baby, Inc." Those who can read and speak Japanese will have no issues.
RIP, Murayama-san.
I speak decent and read ok, so I should be fine...what was injected?
@@zaciroth There are lines where it's pretty obvious the localizers did what they wanted.
For example, there is one line where a character just says "Heeh..." but the localizers inputted dialogue. Mind you, that is one of several examples I found, and I'm 5 hours into the game. I'm the type of gamer who is okay with translations IF they stay true to the original's vision, by the way. If they take too many liberties, that's where it becomes a problem. Lian, in Japanese, is your typical upbeat female character. She's very similar to Nanami from Suikoden II. However, the localizers cranked her annoyance up to 20/10.
I recommend keeping it on Japanese dub. If you can read Japanese, I recommend keeping it on both. That way, it's as true to Murayama's vision as it gets. Perhaps that's just me, though.
thats a good comment unlike the paladins saying the game localization dont matter and anyone complaining about it is not a suikoden fan , people are so adamant on defending clearly bad localization on some aspects of the game just because they dont care about the real vision of the author as long as they can play the game in english, and those are the ones that call themselves "true fans" lmao.
@@TheSpectacledOwl to avoid bad localisation,can we put the game on japanese dub with english subtitles?
Will it be different?
@@Durinson1 If you understand Japanese, it will make a huge difference. It will be even better if you can read Japanese, so you can get the full context.
For some reason I see Garr as Viktor turned into a werewolf lol.
I've reserve this game for a while on PS5... but man, those loading screens on every random battle it´s just wild and make me very anxious.
Imagine playing it on the switch, with 30 secs loading time on EVERY. RANDOM. BATTLE.
you get used to them, especially since there aren't many random battles
@@mnopinionit's 6 seconds on the switch
3 second loading screens are a problem now?
Are you new to gaming?
Glad I got it on Steam because I saw the graphics are slightly worse on PS5 and I didn't want longer load times
The game look good. And I enjoyed the old school games. I see alot of people here talking about the localization and how bad it is. I've seen some of the comparisons from the true translation to the localized version and it honestly doesn't seem that bad. However I would push back on a couple of things. The guy that worked on this game's localization said something to the effect of they need to change certain things specifically because certain Japanese sensibilities would be considered offensive in the West. First, I'm in the West and have been playing Japanese games pretty much my entire life and would prefer that if they have something offensive to say, that I get to know what it is for myself. Second these people do not actually care at all about being offensive, they do it all the time. Many of them actually seem to revel in the idea of making people feel as offended as possible. They just like being able to decide who it is ok to offend and who it is not ok to offend. They smear people and call them names all the time. They are very selective see. But for them to say that they want to shield people from offensive content is a bad joke. They don't care about that at all. If they meant what they say, then it would be universally applied. And that is definitely not what is happening. Sometimes though, these things do get a little blown out of proportion. And I still want to pick this game up. I am a sucker for old school Japanese style games.
Nah Americans are definitely more easily offended than most other cultures.
@@prisonerofwar8375 Only half of us. Look who's crying about Stellar Blade to know which half.
@@micshazam842 Totally different cases. The localization is using modern western left political insults like chud, that's an objective issue. Stellar Blade is just DEI advocates melting down.
@@Vulpaslol right? They not bout to paint us all as a buncha weenies based off of social media posts.
I also like the idea of different "defend" commands for different characters.
I find the shield one for squishy mages very interesting!
I like it too, except the "Provoke" and "Dodge" ones, because these rely on RNG, which also translate into nearly non-existent dodges/provokes
Francesca is truly best girl! Right from her first cutscene I knew that I would probably be keeping her in my part as often as I was able!
I refused to watch any other reviews of this game until you did yours. I knew your love for the suikoden series would give credibility to your opinion. Great video, worth the wait.
Me in here hoping these guys revisit the Vandal Hearts concept again too, the unique structure of that TRPG always has me coming back and I want more, though its sequels never captured my heart like the first one did.
I love the energy you put into voicing this review
We urgent need a new translation for this game.
Not really...
@@AngryCosmonaut rub a dub dub, dont be a flub.
YES, THEY DO.
@@AngryCosmonaut Chud detected
@@Shirolicious Dude, its a game for kids. Don't go in expecting all characters to be super edgy, mature, or ones you like.
@@AngryCosmonaut What? This is a game for everyone, it isn't Kirby 😂😂
glad this game came out finally, i'm playing the ao no kiseki sub series, so i will give it a try much later, but by your review... i can't wait to play it, thanks for the video, have a good one.
I have been looking forward to this game for a long time. Eric.. thanks for the review
Erick thank you so much for your review! I had seen a headline about "bugginess," and I'm glad I checked out your review to get the context! I will likely buy it soon if only to be able to track the bugfix as the green light to start playing!
For all those that worry about spoilers so kind of skip around in reviews he actually recommends NOT BUYING THIS GAME UNTIL IT GETS PATCHED. Right now there are bugs that prevent you from being able to recruit all characters, which can have adverse effects on other characters and the endings.
Still own suikoden 1&2 physical copies for the ps1. Love the second one. Looking forward to this when it goes on sale. The backlog is real!!!!
I think ima pick this up for sure
I'm glad it lived up to the hype (bugs aside). Can't wait to one day play it myself!
A review from an actual fan of the suikoden series. Gracias hermano 🙏
Random encounters puts hair on your chest.
I wish it would put hair on my head.
People are even compiling the bad localization like with Mio gendering a Golem. internet slang like "Chud" and the lines of Francesca is way over the top compare to the JP version.
I only hope mods will save us.
@@TheRealCaptainLavender i really hope so. Like they just machine translate the Original JP lines. I don't even mind JP dub.
@@TheRealCaptainLavender Not the Discord mods, that's for sure!
Francesca's lines make me laugh 🤷♀Most people don't know Japanese and won't realize that there are differences so who cares really... This "issue" is completely overblown and doesn't impact your enjoyment.
@@armorvilmost reviewers criticism is this game is very over the top and localization is the one to blame.
Actually do recruit that one character you need the old spirit guy character in your party and if you talk to him at the end at the castle, he would tell you about her if she actually very old
I bought this game on ps5. I did everything wrong that you could do and was still able to recruit Lam with no issues. Maybe the bug isn't on ps5?
I been playing Octopath 2 since it cane out and still havent beat that grind fest. I will wait till I beat it and this goes on sale for now
Honestly, the thumbnail had me worried that this would be yet another thing I look forward to that ends up being garbage. I'm glad to see people like it, though. I plan on getting this one day.
This game gets a lot better mid-late game, but I really wish the re-balanced magic & hero combos to be more useful.
Only a hamdful of hero combos are more useful than just having the 2+ characters separately basic attack, and most magic spells are powerful than basic attacking too.
Magic finally started getting a bit stronger when I was about 30 hours in, and even then it was limited to a small number of spells on an even smaller number of heroes.
I have some doubts!
Could you talk a little about the mini card game in this game? I'm super curious and I haven't seen anyone talk about it!
When can I play the mini card game?
Last question, this is the first turn-based game I've played that doesn't show the enemies' life bar at the time of the fight, I'm completely lost without knowing if that enemy is dying or not!
How do you plan your fight without knowing the enemy's life?
There are a lot of RPGs that don't show the enemies' health bars. While it's annoying, I can tolerate it.
When the enemy's name is red, that means it's gonna die this turn. Usually it will take 1 or 2 attacks from this point.
Level 5 and loving it so far. It has the vibe of Suikoden 1 & 2
I'm loving this game ❤
what I love is there isn't any bloat, pacing issues or "devs not respecting the player's time" feeling that you find a lot in JRPGs nowadays : FF7R games, Octopath, the Trails, etc etc. Eiyuden grabs you and doesn't let go, like good JRPGs of old!
W0k3 translation 😢
Suikoden 2 is my favorite RPG of all time. I will definitely be getting this game the day it comes out for Switch.
Only the official Chinese translation is faithful to the Japanese dialogue, every other language uses the English mangling.
We'll have to wait for a fan patch kind of like how the PS1 Suikodens had fan patches for the localisation many years later.
Saving my Potch for now
this criticism is completely overblown.
Nah
@@armorvil depends on how adamant you are personally to what does and does not make a localization good/bad. Some take it VERY seriously (obviously). Some will likely play this and not even notice the difference or care that there is a difference. And that is totally fine. Most people are saying it is pretty shit though, not just bad.
yeah, no way these guys are getting my money, i am very serious and strict about these things since i'm not a brainless consumer, i can play something else.
they blew it, next time find non woke translators.
I’ve been meaning to play Suikoden 1 and 2 for a while now. Should I play this first or does it matter?
you can play as you want. It is just a spiritual sucesor
Suikoden 1 is relatively short, I'd start there just to see if you like the style of the franchise, it's a lower time investment and still worth playing even if later entries may be better.
I just bought this today and haven't played it yet because I had to work 😢. I'm really glad I saw your review- I was starting to get discouraged after watching a few other reviews- all of which were primarily negative. Looking forward to playing once again!
So that "Do I now...?" line looked like a bug to me. Maybe the wrong string.
But hey, it's a Suikoden 2 spiritual successor! Gotta have some baffling localization issues right?
Love the game absolutely a masterpiece when it comes to jrpgs. But man do i hate the inventory limit. That would be my biggest grip with the gm so far.
Im 10 hours in and i love the game, except Lian. That character is single handedly ruining this games story for me.
Im tired of stupid, annoying characters in these types of games and Lian is by far the worse. I'm praying i can take her out of my party soon. I have a better grapple damager already who does more damage.
If Lian stays a big part of the games story i will quite playing. Or just skip the story altogether. She single handedly deflates all the drama and escalation of every scene in the game.
Ok a couple more hours into the game and the war has officially kicked off and I got control of my first unit.
Lian has become much more serious as well once it becomes apperant how bad things are.
This is much better. I thought she was gonna act like an idiot airhead throughout the entire game but it looks like these events have knocked some sense into her. I kinda like that for her character so...well played Eiyudan Chronicles.
Thanks for the great review. I’ll be waiting until it’s all patched up before playing, I think.
The Suikoden series is my favorite video game series ever, period. I owned and beat I-V numerous times, going back and recruiting all 108 stars of Destiny, and even tried my best to get through the DS game 😂
I downloaded this last night but I’m so excited to play a game like Suikoden again!
1:33 : Some people have posted side by side videos and PS5 and Steam both look roughly the same, amazing, PS4 looks like a step down from PS5/Steam but still good, Switch looks like a big step down. No major surprises with any of that, but its worth noting that if your looking for the optimal visual experience, PS5 and Steam are a noticeable step ahead of the other choices.
Switch has very bad load times and the game chugs a bit when walking through towns and dungeons.
Will definitely buy this! thanks for the review!
Suikoden 2 is my Favorite JRPG of All Time so seeing this JRPG from the old Suikoden Team really makes me want to Play the Game
any idea when is SUikoden remastered coming ?
waiting for the bugged to be fixed before buying it.
This year, I think summer.
Turning on or off random encounters should be an option in any modern jrpg. As you said it annoys you during puzzles and also you can do challenge runs without leveling up...
I agree, it's a necessity.
the game is to sadly be avoided til they fix this terrible localization
the answer "just learn a different language" shouldn't be the answer yet here it really is, its depressing but there's no point forcing yourself through a terrible localization by egotistical localizers thinking they're writers when they aren't
Now i know why I dont like the games you like most and you dislike the games i really like. Random encounters. Bro. Embrace the grind.
I like sharks so I'm getting it, but I'm definitely playing it in a foreign language and just translating. Screw that localizer.
This bad localization is encouraging me to improve my Japanese knowledge.
Localization always hate "grunts". Or a lot of "non worded" voice lines. At least if they are gonna put dialogue over these grunts, they should make appear as "inner monologues" if they insist of localizing a grunt into sentences if they think the english speaking people won't understand the nuance of a "grunt" or a Hrmmm...
The people in control can't process subtlety or nuance. Need character to say " I'm sad now" , indead of "sigh".
tbh if only grunts that show disappointment they just can write, "ah cmon" or "Really", or "Oh" "ahh" an empty reaction that didnt have any meaning what so ever. why game this day always like this. did i need push my self to get N3 exam just for reading JP text.
Saw the localization quality and the person responsible for it... cancelled. Sorry, not giving these nutjobs my money, sorry to the Devs, as im sure it's 505's fault and not yours.
Lol your loss
@@seapeajones you mean win
@@seapeajones Eiyuden stutter and the 100 bugs. POS.
@@seapeajones im good
@@seapeajones Losing wokeness is called a gain.
I will never be OCD enough to play a game like this. It is pretty tho.
ahahah francesca is my fav too!!!!! i just love her!
South african here 9/10 for me as fan of suikoden 2, too wholesome,happy,power of friendhip ish, a pinch of dark and edginess would be great for the next installment cant wait
Seems that Wokestar/translators have ruined the English translation, please provide an updated review. Thanks.
He doesn't read comments and he's certainly not going to update his review because you're not happy.
it's amazing that, even when the localization is bad, the anti-localization crowd still manages to be absolutely unbearable
...I just saw this post after writing my own comment lol.
Guess I'll need to look into what the translators did once some people compile stuff (which given how people have been compiling stuff lately due to Sweet Baby's BS may not be hard to find out nowadays).
Granted some people also embellish how much the translators screw things over (Unicorn Overlord for instance hasn't really had anything in it that pushes woke BS and at worst expands on the Japanese lines for the sake of sounding more old Medieval English speech patterns you'd see in the Noble's court which is livable given the rest of the game is great...if it's like that I can give Eiyden a pass...if it's Dragonmaid anime levels of bad though ya I'd be out). As long as it's no worse than the localizations done from the PS2 era to around just before when woke shit was being hamfisted into our faces (last 5 years or so) it'll be tolerable at the very least if it's to play and at least understand the story of the game (basically as long as it's no worse than Pokemon's donuts translation of rice balls...ya wrong word but both are food and barely have relevance on the main plot...was it stupid though ya won't deny that but not gonna say no to a game I'm excited for (granted Eiyden would be more of a random pickup for me than full on excitement...a must have pickup would be Trails/Ys/Tales) just for some minor translation issues).
If it’s anything like unicorn overlords translation. It will be way better than “source “ anyways
@@robsonazevedoferreira3119the community managers are banning people who complain about this in discord, both sides are annoying to some extent but only one has power
On PS5 it constantly overheats my system, it's a bug in the game, sent a bug report to 505
Looks good! Working through some backlog so I can wait for a bit. That will allow bug fixes and walkthroughs to come out haha.
I’ll wait for updated patches.
same, glad Erick mentioned some bad bugs to us, I would have been livid if a character recruitment didnt work
Will be playing very soon!
What did you think about Eiyuden Chronicle: Rising? I never saw you talk about it and am considering picking it up, seeing as it's only $4.49 for the next 3 days.
Thanks Erick, I almost forgot about this. Still disappointed they never ported Suikoden 5 to any of the newer playstations.
Honestly, your opinion/review of this game is the only one that matters. Sold.
*to you.
There is game breaking bug that wont let me continue the story. Late in game after i talk to seign on top of the castle . Then u have to talk to euma. It says on current goal you cant get to sleep. Try taking a walk. But in game its day light and nothing progresses the story. At all. I have no backup saves.
So I've encountered a couple of problems on Switch (I don't know if they're exclusive) that are annoying enough for me to not play it.
1. You cannot use Auto-Advance, it works in voiced cutscenes but if you try to talk to NPC's with it, then it closes the dialogue box before it's typed out, meaning you constantly have to toggle it between cutscenes and exploration making you have to try and guess where cutscenes are triggered.
2. It takes a good 10 seconds to load random battles which REALLY breaks the flow of the game. I know it's an indie title but they've had some good funding and it's 2024.
These are minor grievances for most, I know. But they personally annoyed me enough within the first half an hour that I had to put it down. I hope they patch it up because I've been excited for this for years.
I forgot to ask: I saw in your video battle footage several kind of silly enemies. Are there a lot of teddy bears and silly looking enemies in this game? That's one thing that could be a negative imo...
Nice to see that it made people happy.
It's amazing,also don't listen to reviews from people who have never played a suikoden game I'd seen one saying there was no fast travel 🤦
Can't wait to recruit all characters from this game, and collect them like pokemon!
Lots of different reviews out there that i avoided, bit i knew i was gonna watch Ericks take
Oh no... damn Deluxe Version and me not wanting to use a guide on the first time... I already spoke with that bugged character. Well, let's cross fingers I manage to get her anyway...
Just make sure you get riufan, yalk to him in your HQ, and have him in your party when you get to Daphan.
@@Kwisatz-Chaderach Maybe no more worries are needed. Today was a patch and they announced they wanted to fix that issue (and some other things) with it. I am crossing my fingers
@SheenaTigerspielt nice. Hopefully they fixed the encounter rate bug too 😆
I’ve never played a game like this and the suikoden series. Everyone is mentioning that. But I wanted to try it because of the artwork. Now I can’t wait to get home just to play it. 😅
Switch have a problem with this game.... even emulators are running it with slowdowns in the menus...
You did not talk about how save points are far from one another, the long loading in combats and many other technical issues.
It's old school
I'm 9 hours into the PC version, and what I would say about the save system is that the autosaves are too far apart. The save points don't seem too bad, but there are times when you look at the time of the autosave and it was 30 minutes or more ago. In the event of a crash (or power failure) this would prove annoying. No stability issues on the PC version for me so far, but I hear the Switch version definitely suffers from crashes.
That’s good stuff lol. The translation is the only bad thing.
Save points are extremely plentiful
@@beezusHrist Old school 2D rpgs didn't have loading times for battles...
Having been playing the crap out of Star Ocean: First Departer R and Star Ocean: Second Story R. and playing the OG Suikoden 1 and 2 games through emulation along with FF1-6, the random encounter aspect doesn't bother me at all.
There should be no consequences to choices made just like in real life.
Load times before and after battles, bad translations, and the auto scroll skips dialogue which also makes that damn chirp noise after every press of the confirm button. A bunch of awkward small issues that can be patched for sure. Other than that this game is pure suikoden goodness, 9/10 baby
Is it required to play and beat Eiyuden Chronicle: Rising prior to this in order to understand the whole plot or unlock something important? I heard you unlock something in Rising and it carries over to Hundred Heroes.
It's not required. Rising is more an introduction to the world, lore, and some of the characters (and will probably get you to like its main 3 chars; it certainly did for me).
What you get from transferring save is a rune that is from early mid game (honestly I didn't even use it, it wasn't that preferrable). Also the names that you give the weapons of the main 3 characters get transferred over, as well as the name you give the town specialty. You also get the tower in the town transferred over, but I have not yet made it to the town from Rising in this game, so I dont know what it does.
@@jmporkbob Thank you
Is there a voice over or English dubbing? Or is it just text?
There's plenty of voice acting in Japanese and English, when just out and about chatting up random villagers, it's just text.
i feel bad to set my expectation to has same as Suikoden 2, its not that high bar, BUT, its something like Suikoden 1 but better. maybe as same as Suikoden 5 too. the inventory system should be bigger too, but im glad they didnt share slot with accessory. also maybe some in deepth for the Rune lore? i mean what hook me with Suikoden is How powerfull true rune is. and MC usually held that 1 true rune from 27 True rune. and if you play Suikoden IV or V you know how scary True rune power is.
tho, i still waiting for the clue to recruit people, i hope they made secret / true ending if we get all the recruitable character like how Suikoden game always
I'm actually sort of glad runes were more of a McGuffin in this game than in Suikoden. The 27 true runes created a sort of narrative limitation because they were just sort of there, in a way. Rune Barrows and the primal lenses seem to have an entire ancient civilization tied to them, which might be put to use in a story further down the line (even if Murayama won't be the one to write it; I think Eiyuden as a franchise will live or die by how the sequel does). They already have in-world limits on who can use rune lenses and how well they can be used, so you don't really need to attach a character to a primal lens, either.
I love some parts of what this game is, but have had reservations pop up over the past 48 hours to the point that Ill probably wait for a sale.
Localizers are the worst scum of the industry.
Anime is effected too, so disappointing
Good to know the loading isn't just on xbox which I'm currently playing on but will replay on ps5 down the line. I'll continue to play this on gamepass until the little issues are fixed. But having a lot of fun so far!
Aight bro ive never played suikoden but when you said motoi sakuraba composed this i was already sold
i have played the first hour of the game and of that first hour 50 minutes are dialogue and cutscenes i dont know if want to continue playing it.
Hate it when people who've never played the original suikoden, make these dumbass reviews man. watched a reviewer (not you) complain that u can only change runes at the rune shop. duh! Ofc u can only change runes on the rune shop because that's how it is in suikoden 1 and 2. grew up playing the series during the 90's
it's being judged on its own merits, nobody needs to play a separate franchise just to evaluate what's in this game, that's ridiculous
Do I need to gather all heroes (stars of destiny) to get true good ending? I really hated that in Suikoden games.
Why play suikoden then?? The recruiment of stars of destiniy is the core of suikoden.
you usually have to do extra stuff to get true ends, nothing new
Yeah. You have to put in extra time and effort if you want the true ending.
@@gunturbayu6779 For the story, characters and setting.
@@craig581 Erick said that it's not needed. Why I hate that? Because it's basically impossible to get all of them without a guide during first playthrough. Playing with a guide is not fun.
I couldn’t find Rising’s review on Erick’s channel, is it worth playing it first ?
Not really. You get a couple bonuses for having a save file for the game when you start a new game in Hundred Heroes. You get a Clock Tower in your eventual base, a rune, and can carry over names of weapons for a few characters. It's safe to say you probably won't notice these bonuses if you didn't have them.
Although it's a fun game and fairly short. You'll probably go mad trying to 100% it though.... Seriously almost all the extra side quests are collection and grinding in old areas, and there's like 5+ that pop up damn near anytime you do something. It's a fun romp in the world with some extra lore thrown in.
@@zedgathegreat9122 eh that doesn’t sound like my Jam. Thanks for the reply, I’ll just focus on the main game
Once there is a mod to fix the translation I will buy it. I don't want to read stuff like "Rub-adub-dub, don't be a flub" or use Urban dictionary to understand Zoomer jokes.
And it is even worse for non American's. Most of what is written make no sense to me.
@@mattestethat’s not particularly American lol it’s English translated from Japanese in general
If those very rare lines are enough for you to not try this gem, I’d reckon you weren’t really in to begin with
@@sharebear421 As far as I know, the original Japanese text is very different from the English text. Just compare the English subtitles with the translation from the Japanese.
She is supposed to be bubbly and goofy.
they have to tox this bug ASAP. I cant recruit the last character because of this 🙄
Yeah this game is a 9/10 so far. I was worried after all the reviewers I follow and said they were fans all had different pros and cons. I have to say there are no load times on steam and it's super fast. So when I see people complaining about quality of life improvements I think they have been overblown. Switch Verizon does sound like it needs a patch.
Otherwise any complaint I've seen about this game really comes off as whining. I think people have just become too used to newer crappier rpgs that just give you everything off the bat in menus. I loved the star ocean remake but the "qol" changes really killed my interest in replying as well. Felt like the game was playing itself and just checking off accomplishments and I didn't earn anything. I have seen people complaining about your inventory only holding 30 items, but they literally give you your vault from the very start to full up to your hearts content. First couple Suikodens were all about planning. I personally love some of the dungeons in this game (haven't said that in a few suikodens) and with the low encounter rate I haven't found it frustrating at all. This is old school gamer and suikoden delight so far.
3hrs in on Steam Deck and runs like a charm, seems like SD can handle it pretty well
Noriyuke Iwadare, Michiro Naruke and Motoi Sakuraba on music duty is incredible news and would make me pick up the game even if the rest of the game was awful. Fortunately, it sounds like that is not the case. Cannot wait to play this!
Why no one mentioned this game is on Game Pass...... there is a lot of JRPG bangers on game pass.