🔥BSP Rock Bites: Jethro Tulls Martin Barre, On His Audition to the Ian Anderson Fallout! 🌟
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- "Dive into the captivating saga of Jethro Tull's Martin Barre, from his audition triumph to the bitter split with Ian Anderson. Uncover the untold stories and rock history as Barre shares the highs and lows of his legendary journey. 🎸✨ #JethroTull #MartinBarre #rockhistory
PLEASE HIT THAT LIKE BUTTON AND SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ROCK-RELATED CONTENT
Make Sure to Check Out Our New Partners Channel 'VRP ROCKS':
/ @vrprocks
‘LIVE LIFE LOUD’
BSP
Buymeacoffee: www.buymeacoff...
Agreed; without booth Ian and Martin, there cannot be a Jethro Tull.
I once heard Ian say that if, for some reason, Martin were not playing in Jethro Tull, Ian would not want to perform under the name "Jethro Tull." Ian explained: Martin's contributions to Tull were such that without Martin it would not seem to Ian to be Jethro Tull any longer. But something changed and we now see Ian and other minstrels performing as Jethro Tull without Martin Lancelot Barre.
Ian is the greatest entertainer I've ever seen, and I've in-person seen Tull or Ian perform about 18 times. Ian is not the amazing whirling dervish he was for decades, and that is not essential to the music (though it was great), but the decay of his voice has been hugely significant.
Martin.......an incredible guy and guitarist........No Martin? No Tull!
To this day the guitar solo in the song Aqualung, is one of my top 10 favorite. Thank you for the inspiration.
Unfortunately, Jethro Tull was never the same after Barriemore, John Evan, and David Palmer were fired. I did like Broadsword and Crest of the Knave, but never as much as the classic band.
Agreed.
It wasn't just one guy. Barrie got along great with Jeffrey Hammond and I thought the band of John Evan, Jeffrey, Martin Barre and Barlow was stellar. But when John Glascock came in, that core of Tull became a Phenom. There was no tighter or finer foursome in music from '75 to '78. Plus lets not forget David (now Dee) Palmer was involved in the orchestrations from way back, I think from Aqualung, so the music was far superior than what came after these folks departed.
LOL ... Jethro Tull was "never the same" period, exclamation point, full stop.
Never the same. Look at the albums and every one of them is vastly different.
You can say that Songs From The Wood and Heavy Horses were very alike, but the musicians you mention go back to the Aqualung.
The point is that Jethro Tull's music - all basically from Ian Anderson - was always different.
There are different points you can make about all the albums but in terms of liking the music or not, but it is all just subjective.
For me, I guess my favorites are across all the albums, and the Tull incarnations - with the one costant being Ian's talent and drive to make incredible music. The last two albums Zealot & RokFlote are amazing. I seriously think you folks are emotionally attached to some fantasy of Tull that keeps you from appreciating a lot of really great music. Your loss.
Martin is a very modest, and humble man, and one incredible guitar player. I don't supposed there's any point raking over old ground, but I have my own views of who came out of the 'parting of the ways' the better person.
I don't think there is any need to be judgemental or competitive. There's no law that says anyone has to play with anyone else if they don't want to. One thing is that the guitar parts in subsequent Tull releases have been great, as good as anything from before, but very different music.
Martin is a great, creative musician, and he was, next to Ian, the most important member of Jethro Tull.
I think that really insults John Evan and David Palmer who were both massive contributors to the style and history of JT.
Martin is such a great guitarist. It is a shame he is so shy because he shouldn't be.
Martin and Ian. Need to play Together again. What a team. 😂
Only if Ian is barred from singing.
It's a safety thing. Nobody wants the audience's ears and hearts to bleed.
Every fine guitarist I know loves Martin's tonal quality and excellent musicianship. He plays one of THEE BEST waa was solos, ever on We Used To Know!!!!
I watched "Jethro Tull" last month in Birmingham. Yet another guitarist who was very good but it isn't Tull anymore, despite what Ian might say or think. Musically they are very good, as always and I will go whenever they play locally as it's a good show but it just isn't the same without Martin!
What Ian says of thinks is exactly what Tull is, and I see little difference in the excellence of the studio music, and the live music problem is with Ian's voice, not any specific guitarist or musician. You screwball critics sound like a kookie Beatles fan saying the band was never the same since Pete Best left it. Get a grip.
As Martin said, he and Ian had a connection. You could really see it on stage.
Martin NOT a blues guitarist?? So much blues influence on Stand Up!! One of the very best JT albums, ever!!
I've never seen, heard martin talk so much. Ha missing the real tull.😢
Its sometimes hard to understand the motivations of the very creative band leaders. Frank Zappa abruptly dumped the players in the Mothers of Invention when he decided it was time to move in a different musical direction. Same could be said of David Bowie.
You’re stretching that - Tull’s music from 1969 to 2011 was great because they had their own style and sound which was a blend of the instrumentals of the flute and electric guitar plus bass,keyboards, drums. And for 43 years Tull was essentially Ian and Martin and the sound of the music was Martin’s guitar and Ian’s guitar,flute, vocals accompanied by the other musicians in the band throughout. While some of us Tull fans don’t consider Ian’s present band as Jethro Tull ( because Martin is not a member) we have to realize that for the last 25 years Ian has had another group of musicians who have played on his solo albums and and live performances as Ian Anderson plays Jethro Tull and they have been officially are a part of Jethro Tull. I have seen them about 7times and always a great show. They are still producing and performing as Jethro Tull and last October’s show was a great show from a long diehard fan. I am so pleased that Martin is doing what he does and I saw his show in 2016 in a small venue (20 feet from the stage) and it was great! I hope to see him again. Things change and in this case it’s allowed both Ian and Martin to be happy in their musical pursuits
Martin is a weak person. In his mind and his music he is a genius, incredibly skilled, but he is so introverted and shy it's been a real tough road forced on him by Ian. Who knows, maybe he deserved it or has benefited from it, but there is not law that rock groups have to maintain a teenage teen idol fantasy. Ian seems like an obsessive loner - I'm just glad he continues to write and play music at all - it's fantastic.
Someone needs to slap some sense into Ian. Im sure the members of his new band are great, but thers is nothing like vintage. If they are still competent in their skills, Ian,Martin,Barrie or Doane,John Evan and Jeffrey should be putting the band together and give it a proper sendoff. Lets go Ian
It's the music that has changed, and if you don't like it, don't listen, and don't insult it. Ian is the powerhouse behind the music, and one can see that by looking at the last albums that are very different and have popular support, but sound very different from anything before. The classic lineup put out some albums I don't care much for, like Warchild and Too Old To Rock and Roll. Ian is Jethro Tull.
You seem to be getting a little offended by opinions and views on Tull which don't align with yours; which you appear to set down as a truth one must never question. For me, Tull's final studio album was Dot Com, and even the two before were struggles for the ears as far as vocals were concerned. @justgivemethetruth
@@Broxin7
You're trying to make me seem overly emotional or unreasonable ... "offeneded", or I am forcing my "opinions" on others.
I don't see any evidence of that at all in my words.
I am not the one who says that Ian should be slapped for not aligning with my opinions of Tull.
And where do I intimate that no one can question my opinion? If someone says something, only the truth value and facts that it is based on count - to which you and the original poster ( 3 months ago in 2024 ) trying to push your own definitions of what Jethro Tull is onto everyone else - based on nothing.
You even say it plain - "For me Tull's final studio album was .."
I just think that is stupid, uncalled for, and egotistical. To get offended by something like that would be to get offended by an infant throwing food or acting out.
As I said, there is a simple solution to both your problems, don't listen to or buy music you don't like. To do that you do not have to tell everyone else to ignore released music that has the Jethro Tull name on it like it doesn't exist. You two don't have to behave like whiny babies.
@@Broxin7
Also, Ian's vocal problems are pretty much exclusively live issues.
Under studio control Ian's voice may be limited in range and power, but he makes the best use of it he can, and it never has the problems he has live on stage. Struggle for the ears is just silly. Try listening to Leon Russell or Tom Waits - both very popular artists with horrible voices - so what?
@justgivemethetruth
"So what?"
And I'm the whiney baby?
While Ian's vocal issues are unfortunate, they are no less a reality that many - myself included - find as the deal breaker. This is why I neither buy nor listen to anything Ian's released in the new millennium. Some are fine with it, while some are not. That's why I said "for me" as I speak for myself only. I never advocated for anyone to not listen to it at all. Just like you when you said you didn't much care for Warchild or the fish-out-of-water album (the yellow one). You were speaking for yourself, yet the underlying tone of your words was one of umbrage, painting a picture of a little boy in a sandpit defending his best friend's broken toys.
Tull should have held on to Glenn Cornick through Aqualung: would have been a much better album, and easier to produce. I've read that Cornick was in on all the demos anyway.
Could have moved on to the more Proggy-sound for TAAB, with Hammond on bass & Barlow on drums.
'69-'79 were Tulls Crown Jewell' LPs.After Electric Folk music
Ian made a couple of mistakes- first and foremost he sacked the best lineup Tull ever had- Barrie Barlow, John Evans, and David Palmer. It is pretty much a foregone conclusion that Tull’s best work was from Aqualung to Stormwatch ( with a few forgettable albums here and there) Second mistake letting go of Martin in 2012 and lying that he encouraged him to go out on his own. Martin says he was just outed from the band like others before-Andrew Giddings, Diane Perry. It paints Ian as a kind of ruthless task master. BTW I like his latest album Rock Flute , but with yet another group of musicians.
Ian seems to do what he thinks he needs to to maintain the economic and artistic success of JT/IA bands. The music and lyrics and ideas are fantastic. Someone so talented and productive - no other member or former member of Tull has ever gotten a song or album as successful as Ian and Tull. You can see there was really a problem with Martin. He was pathologically shy, and even when he got his own band, at first he would stand off to the side of the stage and play his guitar brilliantly, but there was nothing to back it up, and few good ideas. I's probably been a very good thing for Martin to have to get out there on his own and realize how much Ian had to deal with all these years, writing, composing, managing, booking, all the work he did for Tull - yet every Tull video that shows up on UA-cam has some BS yammering about how Ian is such a mean guy. There is nothing stopping Martin from doing whatever he wants, there never has been. Martin's band is like a teen-age garage band of old men, and the vocalist is awful, and all he does is to try to imitate Ian.
Martin was a special personality and look in the Tull band. Not to mention, one of the best guitarist in history. But Ian Anderson is Jethro Tull and that will never change !
Jethro Tull defeated bingo Jed in a no holds barred cage match.
Ian croaked
I just wish u would get your lighting setup up properly’ im not trying to be mean but fck dude’ this whole moonface thing is getting abit hard to deal with 😂 I like your videos a lot and u do fantastic job’ but aswell as your interview starts and it’s the bright white light on your face it kind of takes away from the professional style of your interviews’ I’m sure your more than capable of putting your light up higher and direct it in a different way’ anyway bro’ keep up the rad interviews 💪💙✌️🍻👀
Ian is a pompous ass too often. He is sick talented, but needs to chill!
Martin was the guitarist for Tull - the first album -all blues was great but not what they became .
The band that became jethro Tull was with Martin on guitar . First concert I saw with my dad I was 10 and took my moms place - she was gone . It was 77 Boston garden .
Just an opinion .. we can’t do a fucking thing other than that . That’s mine .. I’m o.k with yours .. reading people get mad about it makes me laugh .
Tough guys on the keyboard getting pissed about music . Get out much ??
Jethro Tull = Ian Anderson
Totally wrong . The prof currently Ian Anderson band is a disaster. As Martin said : Jethro Tull only had two guitarists, M Barre and Mick Abram’s
Jethro Tull - Marin Barre = 0.
JETHRO TULL,WAR EINE MIXTUR VON IAN ANDERSON UND MARTIN BARRE,JOHN EVAN UND BARRIE BARLOW UND JOHN GLASCOCK❤ RIP..ALS JOHN STARB, ENDETE DIE ALTE TULL-ÄRA UND ES KAM NIE WIEDER SO.😢 DOCH NACH DEM WEGGANG VON MARTIN 2011,GIBT ES JETHRO TULL NICHT MEHR,😢 SORRY,ES IST EINE IAN ANDERSON- TRIBUTE-BAND,IST SO!!😢😢😢😢
Martin has no right to say that without him it isn't Jethro Tull. Jethro Tull was a band BEFORE he joined, does he not consider THAT Jethro Tull? Yet, he was a HUGE part of Tull when he was there, but to say that it's not Jethro Tull just because he isn't in the band is kind of arrogant on his part.
Ian himself used to say that about Martin. The whole thing would be easier to accept if Ian didn't give a different explanation for Martin's departure every time it comes up in an interview.
But it was Martin on all of Jethro Tull's greatest albums
He's right. It isn't.......Love Ian but he has a history of not treating members of the band very well........Martin is not arrogant.......How would you feel if you got dumped like you didn't matter after 40 years?
True, I am so sick of the regular bunch of goofball misfits showing up and telling all the rest of us Tull fans what is Tull and what isn't or that they like Martin or think he is more or equally talented as Ian. It's nonsense. Ian is an amazing guy, and it is him I buy music from, and who comes up with the great ideas and lyrics and puts the whole thing together.
Tull was over after Heavy Horses IMO..
I'm still salty about them winning over Metallica! There's no flute in heavy metal man! 😂
Get over it.
😂
“The flute is a heavy, metal instrument” 😁
If he has, i haven’t heard it….just simply say what the basic issue(s) were, between him and Ian.
I don’t think Ian has said what the problem was.
Yes, respect people’s privacy…but i mean how bad could it have been?..but had to bad enough because Martin says the friendship totally dissolved.
HI MARTIN, incredible guitarist.
"The brand is now so diluted" ?? WTF is Martin talking about?
He's referring to the constant firing of people and the revolving door of personnel over the last 15 years or so, especially guitarists.
@@DavidGainesVeganComposer
"Constant firing of people?"?
That's silly. And it is dishonest of you to pretend you know what Barre is talking about.
I don't think the music has suffered, and probably very likely is the fact that Martin's salary was too much to carry with the way the live shows are going these days. I look at the last 2 new albums and the guitar work has not suffered ... the sound of the music is what determines the brand, and to me I think Ian is still great, and the rest of the band is as good as they ever were. It's mostly an emotional response to Martin being gone that is the problem with fans. The reality is that, sad to say, and I love Martin since I started paying attention to the band members - but Martin and his band have had many years to come up with some good songs, and they do not have one that can hold up next to the least popular Tull song.
I don't know if it was right, or fair that Martin is gone, I just know it's Ian's call. Ian evolved the whole thing over many decades of very hard work and has the right to run things the way he wants. If he keeps at it. maybe Ian can find a way to use AI to recreate his great voice of the past.
Right! The brand doesn’t exist anymore. Hate to use this fast food analogy, but if Burger King stopped making flame broiled burgers and did what McDonald’s is doing, the BK brand is gone. The “brand “of JT was over when Ian made a monstrous mistake in cutting ties with Martin.
@@clsieczka
Not legally or in reality. Ian is Jethro Tull, from the beginning.
You people are whiners.
Its so unfortunate that Ian killed a great band with the album "A", and by giving the band a one year notice after Stormwatch (gotta rack in them bucks with a tour first! Right?) Ian tried to save things with Broadsword but was not totally successful. I attended that concert, and it was good, but I didn't know about the band changes at the time. Crest of a Knave was the only album I bought after Stormwatch. Barre had a few good moments after Stormwatch but the band direction seemed to be intent on going 80's radio pop, much like Plant did after Pictures at Eleven. Many other bands did the same, none of those albums being classics. Unfortunate indeed.