SHOOTOUT Hilleberg AKTO vs MLD Supermid! Small one man TENT vs big TARP tent BATTLE for wild camping

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @doodoodum10
    @doodoodum10 3 роки тому +1

    This is a bit of fun and madly bonkers but it is very well done because you are one of a few who takes time to explain details of the Akto tent so good for you. Thank you.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  3 роки тому

      Yeah nuts eh lol glad you saw funny side of it as intended lol a few don't get it lol 😆 their loss 😉 it was ridiculous fun to do and completely made up as I went along and I actually did intend to give a few marks to akto in my original thought process at home but once I started I changed that to make it ridiculous 😄

  • @TonyHobbs
    @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +9

    NB this is deliberately a silly comparison ;) please watch to end for final result and dont take this seriously! Cheers :)

  • @lincolndave1966able
    @lincolndave1966able 3 роки тому +1

    That was a great bit of fun. I have a sneaking suspicion that if one of the tests was to determine which shelter had the best hilleberg label sewn on it, the supermid may have won lol.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  3 роки тому

      Thank you great comment and good someone got it lol 😆
      It was amazing fun to make
      I'm sure there is another similar lol

  • @KevinSmith-wr1sy
    @KevinSmith-wr1sy 2 роки тому +1

    enjoyed this!

  • @andystaveley237
    @andystaveley237 2 роки тому +1

    Hello Tony 😄
    Revisiting this one as I've been spending some time in a budget mid lately and have really enjoyed it. Now I was considering a Trail Star originally but this has got me thinking about an MLD mid instead as I can only afford one at the moment. Which one though ? Space is the thing I like best about them and the way you can sit with the doors open but you are still back inside under cover. Duomid XL ?? Cheers 😁

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  2 роки тому +1

      That is probably a very good option Duomid XL as you suggest it's nice to be able to sit up and like you and you will have heard me say it's great to sit inside with feet outside inner but under cover and a view is great so the duomid xl sounds good choices for you. I'm sure it'll be strong too. Let me know how it goes just remember lead times are very long so patience needed

    • @andystaveley237
      @andystaveley237 2 роки тому +1

      @@TonyHobbs Thanks Tony.
      Yes, from watching your video on the standard duomid it looks a little tight regarding leg room when sitting with legs towards the door.
      Appreciate your advice. Cheers 😁

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  2 роки тому +1

      Just remember the XL is bigger behind pole ie where feet wet kit etc goes in front of pole is same as or very very similar to duomid. If you want a lot of room get supermid lol

  • @neilquinn
    @neilquinn 4 місяці тому +1

    Have you been to iceland Tony? I'm debating bringing my Slingfin 1p or investing in either the Akto (heavier) or MLD Duomid. Not sure which woudl survive wind the best without tons of weight.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 місяці тому

      Had to look it up looks similar to MSR shelters
      Hilleberg Enan lighter. But Duomid with inner if midges are around (?) Good option. Light and spacious. Never been to Iceland. I'd like to get to Sweden if a friend is able to meet me there for a few days next year.

    • @neilquinn
      @neilquinn 4 місяці тому +1

      @@TonyHobbs Basically i'm debating a mid/pyramid style tent vs. a "tunnel" type tent for high wind conditions.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 місяці тому

      How windy are you expecting and will sheltered spots be available
      Another option. MLD Trailstar with inner if midges or no inner just groundsheet unless snow falling....

    • @neilquinn
      @neilquinn 4 місяці тому +1

      @@TonyHobbs It's always a bit of a gamble, but the main problem with iceland is that there will be few sheltered type areas, very wide open, and can hit extremely high winds. Obviously at some point any tent will fail but want to find something decent. Example storm: ua-cam.com/video/O255e1-NgzI/v-deo.html - "In the highlands, wind speeds reach 18 m/s (40 mph) on 50 days a year."

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 місяці тому

      I'd be using MLD Trailstar
      Nothing better for those conditions

  • @pallenielsen2463
    @pallenielsen2463 4 роки тому +2

    Ha ha, best comparison ever ! The best score was no. 9, the exercise point ! Absolutely love it. Keep up the good work ! By the way, what kind of trousers do you wear in this video ?

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      Haha lol I was dreaming up wins lol
      Paramo cascada

  • @matthewburrell3800
    @matthewburrell3800 4 роки тому +1

    Hi Tony, great video the ground sheet did you get that from MLD as well? I've a duomid as well but need a ground sheet for it any ideas?

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Yes groundsheet from MLD

  • @claudeback3890
    @claudeback3890 3 роки тому +1

    after seeing your video, I was quite distessed. Mostly because I just bought an Akto before I saw this. Now I have to face the question, do I bite the chalk and go on with a coffin or spend many times more for a supermid?

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  3 роки тому

      Haha well that depends 😅 price they similar are they not
      The akto is nice tent for sure and I enjoy using occasionally but prefer space lol

  • @tob74ias
    @tob74ias 4 роки тому +3

    Love the totally unbiased review Hobsy...😂 Have you got the losing shelter for sale cheap now....🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Lol yes totally unbiased and I kept it very fair and obvious about such lol ;)
      Given its fame I'll sell for double lol

    • @tob74ias
      @tob74ias 4 роки тому +1

      Tony Hobbs hahaha 😂 nice wrist check too mate still loving the hulk I see

  • @clausfrlund6092
    @clausfrlund6092 4 роки тому +3

    I don't understand your videos recently. Why are you doing this Supermid praise in almost every video? The Akto is a super tent. I have it together with a Nallo 3 GT and those two fits my needs. The Akto is too low but it is the only negative ting you can say about that tent, period. You should see it as a light and rugged tent. The Supermid is only a light and triangular shaped tarp, sorry to say ;-)

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      Comfort in winter
      Spring on the way...

    • @Super.Quasar
      @Super.Quasar 4 роки тому +2

      Claus Frølund . Claus, in the end Tony gave the edge to the SuperMid, 10 vs 0 to the Akto. Clearly, the Akto is not in the Rolex Class. I only wish he had recognised the importance of installing the inner in the SuperShilter. His Dad told him, do it right and do it once.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      @@Super.Quasar then I'd have found some way to give the edge to the SMid lol
      Rolex class of shilter lol ;)
      Well its all livened up the comments lol

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      I checked back... supermid started November and I didnt camp December so only three ;) for sub videos its ideal inside too :)

  • @pootlingalong8928
    @pootlingalong8928 2 роки тому +1

    The Akto will look after you I good weather and bad; the crinkly plastic tent looks like it would be very cold and I couldn’t live with the colour. Each to his own … 🙂

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  2 роки тому

      oh indeed and when you watch more from here you'll see that crinkly plastic wrapper in many a video camp lol its amazing. indeed the akto is great nice tent as is all Hilli stuff. But I am an MLD light weight cuben fan boy lol thank you for watching and hopefully you enjoyed the lighthearted video and unusual style here, we a bit odd for sure., See you around again....

  • @HDvroom10
    @HDvroom10 3 роки тому +1

    Nice watch⛺️⏱ Love your review😅

  • @dorkcork579
    @dorkcork579 4 роки тому +2

    God knows I know that cramped Akto feeling but you are comparing a single skin tent experience with the double walled Akto .
    You will have redo the entire filming again.... but this time in the Akto single skin mode.
    I have both the Akto & Soulo and tend to use the Akto between the Spring & Autumn equinox but rarely mid summer when I go bivy bag mode .
    With the Soulo as my go to Winter tent.
    I have used the Soulo single skin with bivy bag in the Pyrenees for months at a time and it was a palace.
    I cannot see why the Akto would be much different in that configuration.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Hello
      I think you misunderstood the preposterous idea in the first place lol it was deliberately done this way ;)

    • @dorkcork579
      @dorkcork579 4 роки тому +1

      @@TonyHobbs
      Fair enough
      In your defence the supermid looks great and would be the perfect tent for a up and down coastal walk in my opinion .
      However when at least a couple of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse are on the mountain I would prefer a vampiric nights rest in the Akto although breaking camp is always miserable in the Akto.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      @@dorkcork579 if five horsemen are around I'll take trailstar lol
      Hopefully folks will watch video in its entirety lol and its pretty clear it's a daft fin competition lol
      Two horsemen I'll take supermid ;)

  • @robertarquilla7970
    @robertarquilla7970 4 роки тому +3

    I just assumed this "shoot out" was either a jester on your part, or maybe the "drugs" kicked in...

  • @Super.Quasar
    @Super.Quasar 4 роки тому +4

    Tony, thank you for this very interesting, but completely invalid comparison ! My eagle-eyes spotted that one tent had an inner tent, and the other didn’t. For a fair comparison, you could have removed the inner of the Akto, providing a much more spacious accommodation. I’m confident that nobody on God’s earth would do that as nobody wants the wind whistling around their bag, although you promote this with your MLDs. So, you need to re-run the second half of this video with an inner inside the Super-Mid to avoid it being disqualified. Akto 10-0 Super-Mid.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      Of course it's totally nuts comparison that is the point ;) which of cause you know...

    • @Super.Quasar
      @Super.Quasar 4 роки тому +1

      Tony Hobbs I am nuts, I bought one of those DCF shelters for pot-holers on your repeated recommendation, ya know the MLD Trailstar. Sold it after a month. Feckin’ thing !

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      @@Super.Quasar oh I love the ts its heading out with me again soon :)

    • @Super.Quasar
      @Super.Quasar 4 роки тому

      Tony Hobbs Maybe my prejudice comes from the years before built-groundsheets and £1,000 sleeping bags were common. Nights of shivering, wet feet, mice nibbled food, black beetles and slugs on my face. Oh, how I miss those days. :-)
      I understand the TS is useful on cross-America trails, but you only go on Dartmoor, 20 minutes from your car. You could drag a trailer-tent out there ! :-)

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      @@Super.Quasar I dont wish to drag anything and distance is immaterial (it's a bit more than 20) I could use TS anywhere almost and I have used it in a storm (check back many years please)
      The ts is unmatched imo and if I had one and only one shifter for anywhere it would be ts. Other than spin drift snow btw.
      For other uses the smid gives space lol lots of it.

  • @johnhorner769
    @johnhorner769 4 роки тому +2

    I'm with you on the Supermid Tony 👍

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +2

      The only one in the game lol but it is good end of story ;)

  • @wisenber
    @wisenber 4 роки тому +1

    Should have set the Akto up inside the MLD for effect. :)

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      Mmmmm probably not fit lol quite

  • @bobbymcdonald4365
    @bobbymcdonald4365 4 роки тому

    Hi Tony, that was a bit of fun.
    But I have a question for you about the pole in the mid,what is the weight of it, and where did you get it from.
    Also, love the dogs attention to you, listening to every word and being rewarded with a rub on the head. Classic.
    Anyway thanks...

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Ruta locura pole
      It's the 600 or 750
      200g
      Thanks :)

  • @ruairidhalexander7631
    @ruairidhalexander7631 4 місяці тому

    15 minutes to pitch an Akto?!
    Easy to pitch it in 5 minutes.

  • @yesterdaysfire
    @yesterdaysfire 4 роки тому

    How tall are you out of curiosity Tony?

  • @quen7770
    @quen7770 4 роки тому +4

    I think the acto won

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  3 роки тому

      They different of course, but the MLD easily wins even if not comparable. As always many thanks for watching and posting a comment

  • @WorldSurvivalist
    @WorldSurvivalist 3 роки тому

    Lol liked the video, but I really hate that super mid. Its a shelter made for toothbrush snappers not serious outdoorsman

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  3 роки тому

      Thank you, but you probably don't know how good it is. It has been used in very harsh conditions. I'd recommend it every anything, due to space and weight. Especially height. There are limitations but all can be overcome. I hope you will hang around for other videos...

  • @nahumshmushko6616
    @nahumshmushko6616 4 роки тому

    Can you get the Alto mahogany?
    It's not for me. It's for Grandma's bones.

  • @gavrielhamlin6917
    @gavrielhamlin6917 4 роки тому

    So not biased

  • @Yorkshiremadmick
    @Yorkshiremadmick 4 роки тому +1

    Nice to see you wearing your sub naturally as Indeed I do.
    They’re tool watches not safe queens
    Nice review, just wish I watched this before, as I’ve acquired a. coffin ⚰️

  • @Snake.coyote666
    @Snake.coyote666 4 роки тому +2

    Invalid comparaison !!! Hilleberg win !!!

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Whilst you've a point you may have missed the point lol 😆 actually the supermid wins hands down too ;)
      Check out my poncho vs nammatj video ;)

  • @actplastering
    @actplastering 4 роки тому +3

    Please stop with the innuendo.jokes

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +6

      Lmao no lol that is my style lol lol

  • @thewildonions
    @thewildonions 4 роки тому

    So hard to watch

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      Please elaborate. Thanks

  • @onthefly4711
    @onthefly4711 4 роки тому

    Sorry, but this is a totally useless comparison. Whhat about bugs, snow, strong wind... This video is like comparing a tank with a bicycle where the bike wins because of its weight.

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому +1

      You missed the fun and point of video then....

    • @TonyHobbs
      @TonyHobbs  4 роки тому

      I did another. Poncho vs tent. You might enjoy ;)