MILGRAM / Es - Undercover [Music Video]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2020
- “Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?”
Vocal: Es (CV: Yurina Amami)
CD "Undercover" Release Confirmed!
Release date: May 27,2020
■CD Information
www.universal-music.co.jp/mil...
■Special
www.universal-music.co.jp/mil...
"Undercover" DL & Subscription
umj.lnk.to/MILGRAM
Lyrics: DECO*27
Music: DECO*27
Arrangement: DECO*27 & Rockwell
Movie by OTOIRO
Director / Character Designer / Main Animator: akka
Animator: roduki, RL & peatmos
Concept Artist: No.734
Composite / VFX / CG: Yuma Saito
Typography / Prop Designer: DMYM
Story / Author: Takuya Yamanaka
"Undercover" Instrumental
www.dropbox.com/s/jpt2nauu3ac...
■Offisial Site
milgram.jp
■Twitter
/ milgram_info
Lyrics:
“UNDER” If you say INNOCENT, you’re complicit and weak
I’m so lonesome, please love me
“UNDER” My cord’s being pulled but nothing’s ever enough
Contractual desires, oh what to do, FUTURE
“UNDER” Hiding and seeking from sin
Bring it, submit, and also shut your trap
“UNDER” Clutching a broken heart
The pain’s still there, after all this time
Take, grab, steal, dissect the thoughts of “Why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
To know someone, to bind them in their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The fine line between “Hate” and “OK”
Shouldn’t you look beyond your EGO, before it all ends?
After knowing all, I wonder
Can you really say INNOCENT?
“UNDER” Which way will you throw down your weight
To be the deceived, or the deceiver
“UNDER” I don’t wanna just give
Giving and taking, this is how to be in love
“UNDER” I just keep on dreaming
half in, half out, I’m doomed
“UNDER” The magic is in believing
There is no righteousness in broken promises
Take, grab, steal, dissect the thoughts of “Why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
To know someone, to bind them in their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The fine line between “Hate” and “OK”
Shouldn’t you look beyond your EGO, before it all ends?
After knowing all, I wonder
Can you really say INNOCENT?
“UNDER” Don’t you lie about Me
Me, I’ve done nothing wrong
“UNDER” Dedicating my life
Harrowing, burying the thing I want erased
Ravaging, brawling, losers please exit left
Even with accusations full of faults and mistakes
You will for sure, with a smile for sure
Be pleased and satisfied
Take, grab, steal, dissect the thoughts of “Why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
To know someone, to bind them in their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The fine line between “Hate” and “OK”
Shouldn’t you look beyond your EGO, before it all ends?
After knowing all, I wonder
Can you really say INNOCENT?
Deceivings, “UNDER”, inerasable
©MILGRAM
![MILGRAM / Haruka - Weakness [The First Trial Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/h7PJ__3OVDI/mqdefault.jpg)
![MILGRAM / Haruka - Weakness [The First Trial Music Video]](/img/tr.png)
![MILGRAM / Kotoko - HARROW [The First Trial Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_gTTtS0Fvxk/mqdefault.jpg)
I see a lot of comments about the last prisoner being Es, but I don't think that's all there is to it. I say they're representing a much larger group, like how the prisoners each represent wider issues-teen pregnancy and abortion, bullying, growing up in a cult, etc. So yes, Es is a prisoner, but the prisoner they're representing?
It's us. The audience.
The power of public opinion is a double-edged blade. On one hand, people can be really supportive. They can raise cash for charities, they can volunteer for relief after major disasters, or even help an old lady cross the street. On the other hand, people are absolute monsters. Take every single bullying situation where an entire class gangs up on a single person, a bunch of people canceling someone online, or maybe an entire city marginalizing social minorities.
In this case, Milgram is harnessing the power of social opinion to judge whether the prisoners should be condemned or forgiven, but is it really our place to? Frankly, we're not the ones they killed. We're not even related to the ones they killed. But we have a say in whether or not they should be forgiven. Us, as total strangers? To put in perspective, imagine if your mother was murdered. You love her, she loves you, you have a happy and healthy relationship, and then all of a sudden, she's gone. Her murderer is put on trial. The circumstances regarding the murder are unclear enough that it's a fifty-fifty on whether the murderer is declared guilty or walks free from self defense.
Somehow, the case blows up and now the whole nation knows and has their opinions on it. You listen to their comments everyday, speculating. Maybe your mother deserved to be murdered. Maybe the fault lies elsewhere. Maybe the murderer should be forgiven. Maybe the murderer isn't bad, but another victim. Whatever the case, it all boils down to this: you have a bunch of strangers butting in on something that's not their business and trying to influence the outcome of the case. Similarly, we're doing the same thing as the audience. We're breaching the privacy of the prisoners by looking into their thoughts via the mv's and we're the ones judging their crimes despite not being related to them. So again, is it really our place to judge them?
I really like how you write this. This is an interesting perspective. I always wonder about this myself too. Before I judge someone, I always asks myself: "Am I even better?" I still make sins. Sure, not to the extent of murder like the prisoners, but that still doesn't mean I should feel righteous.
That's why I like the lines sung by Es from this song. "Is it really okay to be done deciding with just your Ego?" It's true. We judge mostly from our Ego.
I can't wait to see how this project will go from here. If it actually inspired from the real Milgram experiment, then it's likely we're the subjects here.
THIS. milgram's whole point isn't about guilty or not, but forgive or not. they constantly talk about forgiveness and even the voting system is based on condoning.
I'm not the best at making theories but here's my attempt. If there's anything you'd like to add, please let me know.
Everything in this MILGRAM project represents something.
000-ES: The audience. Are we in the right to judge?
001-HARUKA: Maturity. People laugh when you're acting immature.
002-YUNO: Teenage pregnancy. Is it pro-life or anti-choice?
003-FUTA: Cancelling. At what point does justice become a criminal offense?
004-MU: Bullying.
005-SHIDOU: Hopelessness.
006-MAHIRU: Stalking. Doxxing has taken this one even further.
007-KAZUI: Neglect.
008-AMANE: Religion.
009-MIKOTO: Identity. Are you really the same person you claim to be in the eyes of others?
010-KOTOKO: Justice. And I only need four letters to tell you exactly what this has to do with the real world: ACAB.
JACKALOPE: Society itself. Always watching, always silently judging.
Except we're pretty much a whole bunch of these characters combined in some way or another.
this is such a good take on the whole milgram situation
You've summed it up so well. There's a child in my life who has such strong opinions on subjects she doesn't even understand. Everything is black and white to her and it scares me whenever she talks to me about, say, how someone deserves to lose their job, their life, everything, after bullying someone.
But that's the thing. What if the "bully" was never even a bully at all? We're not the "bully". We're not the "victim", either. So why do you think it is your place to judge so matter-of-factly? And it isn't just her, either. There are millions of other children, just like her, banding together to blindly play God with other peoples' business.
In Es's voice drama, it's revealed that there's an eleventh prison cell that's left unoccupied. Combining this with Es's lost memories leads me to think that there's a link between the two. If you look at the commonalities between the prisoners, each one has a song of their own, a cover of another one of Deco*27's songs, as well as a voice drama, which for some reason applies to Es but doesn't apply to Jackalope. From some of the other prisoners' voice dramas, we find out that Es gets violent with some of the other prisoners. It's quite likely that Es is the last prisoner.
Yes and they also hold like a cube in the beginning with 00 written on it and there were like other cubes too from 01 to 10 so maybe Es is like the 0th prisoner or like an other theory in this comment section the one that has been killed through different dimensions
@@raijin8049 bit late to the party but if you look at 0:18 you can clearly see 11 of those cubes, one for every prisoner and that with the fact that Es opens 000
where do you find the voice dramas? and are there translations for them yet?
@@cityyliights_ there are fan translations, you just gotta do some searching online and will probably find them
@@kevinli8000 thanks so much !
(Edited again after Kotoko 2nd Trial)
Another theory, this time overarching the prisoners.
As previously mentioned, the prisoners seem to come in pairs, even in release dates. Jackalope explicitly stated the numbers are important somehow. We have yet to learn why, but here’s my thoughts on that.
The prisoner’s rooms are arranged in a clock formation, from 000 to 010, and a hallway at the end for the common rooms.
Now divide the clock into 6 parts, 2 prisoners in each part (except 000 and the hallway) Each part represents a ‘theme’ of murder:
001-002 = *Family/Attention* (Haruka the Starved Child, Yuno the Tired Parent)
003-004 = *Manipulation* (Futa the Scapegoated Follower, Mu the Arrogant Initiator)
005-006 = *Timeless Love/Passion* (Shidou, trapped in Love Left Behind, Mahiru stuck in Love That Could've Been)
007-008 = *Promises/Commitment* (Kazui the Self-Denying Breaker, Amane the Stubbornly Committed)
009-010 = *Fight or Flight* (Mikoto the Self in Constant Flight, Kotoko the Self-Serving Fighter)
As for 000 & the hallway, the theme for them is not direct murder.
I think the theme is Bystander.
000 the Deciding Audience/Judge, and the common areas the Helpless Participant/Verdict.
I will explain the additional descriptions in a reply.
This comment will update after each trial.
MAJOR EDITS over the years:
- 004's label
- 005/006's THEME and labels
- 007/008's labels
- 009/010's labels
That is a frickin good obervation, wow!
Good catch! I knew something was up with the pairings, but I couldn't figure out what until this comment. It also made me consider something odd that I had noticed, but had dismissed until now.
Now, throughout the project, the prisoners have been presented in numerical order; Haruka comes first, then Yuno, then Futa, etc. This has been an invariable constant.
EXCEPT for 2:08-2:15, where the scenes for each prisoner are shown in an entirely new order:
Haruka, Kotoko, Yuno, Mikoto, Futa, Amane, Mu, Shidou, Kazui, Mahiru
This pattern is, as far as I can tell, never repeated elsewhere, and the fact that the scenes are shown again mere seconds later in the "proper" order suggests this was not just an oversite.
I had no idea what this new order could mean, but your comment did give me an idea: perhaps this new order is meant to indicate secret, hidden pairings between the cast. What those pairings mean, I'm not entirely sure, but it could be worth looking into.
big brain moment
Woah that’s a really cool theory
This makes so much sense thanks
「ミルグラム」2周目説ってあるかな?最初のジャッカロープの反応といい空いている11番目の牢といい、エスはもともとは囚人で、唯一赦されたから2周目では記憶を消して「看守」役についた…っていうのがあってもおかしくない気がしてきた。
ジャッカロープ、いつもこうなんだって言ってましたし、それありそうですよね。
許すなら共犯者って歌詞あるし、許したらエスが11人目になるって可能性もある気がする
誰かを死刑にしたら殺した罪でエスはやっぱり11人目になるとか
全く同じこと考えてる人おったわ(最近どっぷりハマってきた新参)
一番最初に開けてた０番目の箱、それと同じ形で用意されたほかの10個の箱、やっぱり同じ「裁かれる」側の人間なんじゃないかなって僕も思いました
ちなみにその11番目の牢の描写ってどこですか？
@@N_mirra13 エスのCDのボイスドラマで聴けます！
I'm new here and reading all these advance theories are giving me headaches for someone who just started at step 1, but all seriousness aside, this song is a bop tho and sure will the next ones
Same, I literally discovered all of this yesterday but I'm so invested already, can't wait to see more!
aaa I thought I discovered this late but I'm happy there are others like me! I'm so into this my head hurts
Welcome to Milgram!
This is my first video. Can someone tell me what this is?
@@shinycharizard97 It's about forgiving the prisoners or not, ur the one who who will judge them.
Here's a little thing about the lyrics, every time Es transition to one prisoner, after the line 'UNDER', the lyrics are as if sang by the prisoner. If you watch the cast introduction, it's similar.
You make a good point. I've been enlightened.
I noticed that too and,,, nice xiao prfp
@@katzwei_ now it’s ayaka
That's really cool
yea and his voice changes like for mu and haruka its soft and timid and for mahiru and amane its sweet and a bit girly and for futa its a bit angry
エスの声優さんの、男とも女ともつかない声質が、性別が分からないエスにあっててすごく好き。あと、歌い方もとても好き。
『痛いのはいつまで続くのかな』の音の切り方とか、『赦せるかなーｧｩｯｯ』(語彙力)みたいな切なそうな音の切り方がドツボすぎて。。
Anyone else notice how Kazui seems to be the only one (with the exception of Yuno who's just holding a knife over Es's body, we don't see her harming them directly) who isn't touching the Es body in any sort of harmful way in the final sequence? Haruka has his hands around Es's throat, Futa is roughing Es up, Mu appears to be stabbing Es (its hard to tell?), Shidou looks as if he's physically ripping out an organ?? Mahiru is supporting Es's fallen body, however she does have her arms around their neck, symbolizing how she strangled her partner in their relationship with her overattachment. Amane is beating Es with a bat, Mikoto is beating Es from behind with a bat, and Kotoko is kicking Es (presumably to death).
Kazui is on his knees, holding Es's body and seems to be in distress.
Kazui seems to be the most innocent if you solely watch Undercover alone. With Undercover and Half, I still firmly hold Kazui innocent.
Yuno is aborting a baby lol
Hey do you know where i can find these images because they go by too fast in the video and even when paused i cant make out all the details and cant see who's who (except kazui, that one was obvious)
@@dumbmonkey1313 you can slow down the video in settings
something intresting to add, I saw a theory on twitter about how Futa might not have been directly the murderer, but was most likely scapegoated aswell as gaslighted into being a murderer, till he believed it himself. While he was part of the group, he was not the main person who caused the death of the person. You note that they are "roughing" es up, which doesnt mean they killed them, but did cause some damage.
Haruka-well we saw the entire strangling his child self thing, whatever that means(murder,probably)
Yuno-Abortion, presumably with a knife.(Not murder, unless you're one of those people who believe abortion is murder, or you live in a place where abortion IS murder.)
Mu-well we saw that in the video.(murder)
Shidou-Organs!(murder,unless you believe the theory that it wasnt directly organs he was taking, but rather knowledge on how to save a life, or whatever else he could be taking from a terminally ill patient or person in need of surgery.)
Mahiru-Overattachment stuff(cause of death, but not murder)
Amane-Cult shit (murder)
Kazui-If we had to guess, Kazui did something that caused his wife stress to the point that they committed suicide. It might be cheating, or he might be working in a bar, or it might just be a normal lack of communication or Misunderstanding between them. (cause of death, but not murder)
Mikoto-We saw that they obviously beat the fuck out of a person with a bat in like the first 10 seconds of the MV(murder)
Kotoko-Well that video hasnt come out yet, but probably vigilante justice if i had to guess, probably killed.(murder)
@@matchari2712 Is it 100% abortion for Yuno. Because I don't remember exactly what's it called, but it's a type of manslaughter where a mother after giving birth because severely depressed and murder's her baby. It has a sentence of 5 years in Canada.
これを後々「ああ、こんなところに伏線が…あんなところにも…」とか思いながら聴くんだろうなあ
せやなぁ…
それも楽しみ…ww
そう考えると聴く回数倍ぐらいに増えそうですねw
てか考察と勉強のために10回か20回は絶対聞いてるんだよな
間違いない！
今後に期待したいですね！
もうこれOPに使ってミルグラムのアニメ作って欲しい
なにそれ超絶見たい
アニメ 映画化希望で!!✧︎
@@upashi- 実写は嫌かなぁ…
それ絶対作画崩壊するやつ(○○プロで学んだ)
山下真樹
映画化言うとるだけで実写と違うんやないかな...???
小説読んできた直後のクソデカ感情のままコメントしてるんだけど、
「赦すなら共犯者」
「全てを知った僕はちゃんと赦せるかな」
がもうほんと天才のそれすぎて
共感
第一審MV視聴前 「なんやこれみんなかっこいいやん！！こんなん無罪や！！」
第一審MV視聴後 「倫理観ぶっ飛んでる奴おるやんけ 赦さん」
decoさんより、エスの声優さんには各キャラのパートはそのキャラの歌い方を真似て歌ってもらったそうです。素晴らしいですね。「さぁしっぽ巻いて黙ってどうぞ」とかわかりやすいですね。好きです。
最高かよおおおおお！
フータからムウの変わり方がわかりやすいですよね
(荒い感じから弱くなった感じが)
@@mtm9603 マヒルさんとかカズイおじも分かりやすい
DECO*27が1番
「僕」と書いて「あなた」って読むのはエス（僕）が視聴者（あなた）の意思を反映しているからかな
I just thought about it when reading the theory comments..
Maybe we’re the ones being tested? The Milgram experiment is something about obeying orders I guess . And we’re doing exactly what jacklope told us to do in the earlier videos. Watch the prisoners’ MVs and judge them, and most are doing as he told us to...
it is heavily hinted that we are being the ones tested
I thought that too! I also thought that maybe the prisoners were actors like in the original experiment :OO Just a thought!
YeahOh Welp In real life, that’s the most likely answer~ But the votes aren’t asking “Guilty” or “Innocent” , in Japanese version , they’re asking if we would whether forgive them or not~ So I believe this is all to test peoples’ experience~ Most people tend to forgive the ones who went through similar to them so~ But I guess in real life they would have been given death penalty already as you said--
Edit- Typo
when you think about it, the rabbit told us to judge the prisoners without any explanation to why, or what would happen in the end. Es or any of the prisoners could get killed because of our votes for all we know yet we keep voting.
The original experiment had 'a teacher', who would be the rabbit, a test subject, and an actor.
If we're the ones being tested, then does that make the prisoners the actors..?
@@tvheadtrash_6936 the prisoners after the 3rd trial: you've been fooled! we were paid actors this whole time!
es who suffered so much controlling a bunch of 'murderers':
コトコちゃんのボイスドラマでエスの最初の赦すなら共犯者の意味を理解した…エスが囚人にたいして自分なりに10人分の罪を自分のもののように背負って最後まで裁いていく覚悟あるのほんとにかっこいい
I think Es is the personification of their sins. If you look closely around 2:50 the person being hurt/murdered is always them, and Es could not possibly be murdered by all of them. For example, one of the silhouettes (which I understand is Mu) is holding a cutter against the victim, and in Mu's PV she murders a girl the same way. This is a bit of a strech but in Psychology 'Es' is the abreviation of Estimulous, something that changes the behaviour or makes someone react in a certain way. Maybe Es is called that way because they are the reason why the others are being judged, the "turning point" that it's going to determine the rest of their lives.
I think that scene is just the prisoners committing their crimes but their victim is replaced with es. Also, might be a stretch but es is the German way to say id which might be a nod to the id ego and superego theory with how much the word ego is mentioned
I also noted that Yuno 'Es' is well...lying between her legs. Knowing her trial theme is "Abortion" and the people she killed is "Her Childrens". It's as if 'Es' become the representation of her babies
"Es" means "id". To be a literal translation, "Es" means "it" or "the thing"
赦すの定義は「共犯を認める事」という文を読んだ事があります。共犯者が、罪を責める事は出来ないですからね。
へぇやるやん。
ふと思ったのですが
2:44で各キャラ達が殺した人物がエスに成り代わってるんですよね。そしてエスは『僕(あなた)』である。このことから……
もしもあなたが被害者だったとしたら、自分の人生を強制的に終わらせた人物を赦せるのですか？
という問いかけが入っている気がするのは私だけですか？？？
まぁミルグラムのアプリで自分達が赦すか赦さないかを投票するからってのもあると思うけどね
中性的な声だけど女性キャラの時はちょっと女性っぽく、男性キャラの時はちょっと男性っぽく聞こえる…すご…
this singer went from thomas the train to this. this is absolutely incredible
HOL UP WHAT
@@GE-0530RN yeah she was the seiyuu of thomas the train (idk if she is still the seiyuu of him tho) !!
@@kuri. oh my goodness es the train es the train
es the train
WHAAAAAAT es the train???
嫌い対OKの境界線を
我儘のまま終わっていいの？
ってとこって私たちが見た目や声の好き嫌いで、赦す赦さないを決めていいの？ってことだと思う。
既に推しを決めている人への皮肉？
そうなんですかね...それだったらエス本人は基準はなんでもいい(性癖とかもw)と言っているので矛盾しちゃわないすかね...？
@@user-nh3li7uv4h
確かに矛盾しちゃいますね💦
それを踏まえて的な…？無理矢理ですけど笑
りょっきー明太子
矛盾というか、性癖でもいいけど本当にそれでいいの？っていう感じの問いかけかなぁと思います。
@@ufer1575 めっちゃ納得！
@@ufer1575 確かに納得致しました天才ですか
0:33の「フュー↑チャー↑」がすき
てか、マジ尊い
激しく同意
クリームアイス
分かる。最初聞いた時はびっくりしたけど、何回も聞いていくと癖になる
分かる（笑）えぇ……高っ！って最初なったけど癖になるw
@@user-sr8hg5uv2x それなですそれなすぎてそれなです
確かに。
ただカラオケで歌うとき地獄w
回想シーン
2:09 ハルカ 部屋
2:10 コトコ 路地裏、右上にサイレンぽい光
2:11 ユノ 学校の屋上？腹抑えてる？
2:12 ミコト 仕事？
2:13 フータ 葬式、スマホで撮影
2:13 アマネ シャワー？雨？
2:14 ムウ 教室
2:14 シドウ 病院
2:15 カズイ 車道
2:15 マヒル 手を重ね合わせてる
タイムテーブル上手く行かなかったので目安です
殺害シーンっぽいシルエット
2:44 ハルカ
エスの首に痕跡。絞殺？ハルカがエスに股がってる。ハルカの隣に小さくて丸い影があってそれが小さい子供に見える（曲げてるエスの足かも）。画面右下の破片に血痕。
2:45 ユノ
エスの腹部に痕跡。右側にナイフが刺さってるようにも見える。刺殺？ユノの体制が足を付いて踏ん張っているように見えるから流産？手がどこにあるかは見えないのでわからない。
2:46 フータ
エスの首~上半身に痕跡。撲殺？胸ぐらを掴んで無理矢理立たせようとしているように見える。フータもかなりの返り血を浴びてる。
2:55 ムウ
エスの腹部に痕跡。ムウの手にカッターらしきもの。刺殺（MVに描写あり）。エスに股がってるムウ。
2:56 シドウ
エスの胸あたりに痕跡。刺殺？赤い塊が出てるように見える（臓器？）。エスの足が地面についてなさそう、吊るされてる？
2:57 マヒル
エスの首に痕跡。首を絞めているように見える。絞殺？（MVから考察すると自殺っぽいから首吊りかも）。エスの左足の靴が脱げてる。2:17でマヒルは手を握ってたけど、相手は握り返していない（手が開いた状態）から死体と手を合わせてた？
3:01 カズイ
エスの顔~腹に痕跡。エスをカズイが抱き上げてるように見える。自殺？（MVから考察すると飛び降りだけど轢死もありえる）。エスの左足の靴が脱げてる。
3:02 アマネ
エスの腹に痕跡。正面から棒状のもので殴ってる。撲殺（2:13が風呂場だとするとシャワーヘッドが兇器？）。アマネの背後にアマネの帽子と何かがあるけどよく見えない。
3:04 ミコト
エスの背中に痕跡。形状、MVからしてバットで背後から殴ってる。撲殺。
3:06 コトコ
エス自体には痕跡が見当たらない。コトコの足には飛び散ってる。殺害方法、不明。エスの腕らへんを蹴ってる。
gracias por hablar de las siluetas.
la silueta perteneciente a Fuuta me confunde. al ser el pecado de Fuuta algo más indirecto resulta difícil de interpretar la silueta
アマネちゃんのシーンはシャワーだよ
もし彼らの殺害シーンの対象をesにして見せているのではないかと思いますね?🤔
@@l_lanran そうですよ
わざわざありがとうございます(´▽｀)
OK so I'm a psychology student and i noticed a lot of references to popular psychological theories in this series. Of course the Prison or the whole project is called "MILGRAM", a study about authority. BUT that is not what i want to focus about in my little theory here. The prison guards name or "the audience" is called ES, which is the german word for Id in the outdated but still popular structural model of personality by Freud. He argues our psychological apparatus is made up of three parts, ID (Desires, repressed memories, etc.), the EGO (the mediator between Id and super-ego and the only aspect which has a connection to the outside world) and the super-ego (morals, oftentims restricting a lot of desires of the Id). In this song we are asked "You get to know them, tie them with THEIR Ego" and later on "Is it really okay to be done with deciding with just YOUR EGO?". This stood out for me, the EGO is the part that mediates, the part that lets through some desires, represses some cause of the super-ego etc. We - so our ego - decide upon the fates/who is forgiven or not. So maybe it is also a Test for the protagonist ES to decide which cases the super-ego finds okay or which cases don't. A Test of the EGO you might say, which tests ES desires to forgive/not forgive and their super-egos alignment. Because remember, the EGO is the one mediating between the Id/EGO and the super-ego. Because we still dont really know much about the prison guard ES itself. Maybe ES is tested upon their own morals using Freuds psychoanalytic understanding of our psychological structure. But these are just my ramblings i thought about watching this video. Sorry if this might sound confusing at times, English is my second language. :)
And another thing, why do I notice this just now? Everytime a prisoner is shown there, Es says "UNDER", which would normally be something the Ego would do, the ego suppresses desires, not the ES. So its really intriguing why the so called ES here is seeing all these sins and is saying "under" (suppression). It doesn't Really fit in to the role of an ES and more of an ego. Oh im so interested into this whole project and how es relates to the characters or maybe - symbolizations of some type of sins? Archetypes of something the Es wants but is suppressed by something higher? Ah so many interesting possibilities. Maybe I'm reading too much into this but it's a really interesting project.
Hi, i'm a psicology student too. Thank u, you are the only who talk about Freud's structural model of personalities and reading this i feel less alone lol, I thought i was the one who noticed that. I know i'm very late for this game but i found about it 3 days ago rip.
This is so coolllllll
Guess I'll read this two years later
It did not need two years, we read about these concepts last week and now I understand your point
2:36 でみんなニヤッてするとこ好き
イントロでDECO*27を確信し
歌い始めでDECO*27を確信し
サビでDECO*27を確信し
ラスサビの転調でDECO*27を確信した
圧倒的DECO*27
フータが好きです(ﾎﾞｿｯ)
ほんとDECO*27さんパネェってなりますよね...
ハルカとアマネ好きです()
DECO*27さんの楽曲って神曲しかないから本当に凄いですよね…
コトコが好きです(ﾎﾞｿｯ)
beco27さんの曲全部中毒性半端ない(アマネが好きです(
Decoさんの曲はどれも全部神やから皆聞いてくれよ…
(シドウさんとハルカくんとカズイおじ コトコしゃまが推しですこすこ)
全てが一緒で親近感を勝手に感じる
i just realized they changed the translations a bit for the prisoners part? they made it have a connection to their trial 1 song titles
0:25 [haruka] "if you say innocent, you're complicit and *weak* "
0:29 [yuno] "my *cord's* (umbilical cords) being pulled but nothing's ever enough"
0:47 [fuuta] " *bring it* , submit, and also shut your trap "
0:52 [muu] "the *pain's* still there, *after* all this time"
1:27 [shidou] "which way will you *throw down* your weight"
1:34 [mahiru] "giving and taking, *this is how to be in love* "
1:39 [kazui] " *half* in, *half* out, i'm doomed "
1:43 [amane] "the *magic* is in believing"
2:19 [mikoto] "don't you lie about *Me* . *Me* , i've done nothing wrong."
2:26 [kotoko] " *harrowing* , burying the thing i want erased"
thought this was a fun detail!! though it's probably not as accurate to the og translation now
Yess!! I noticed that to!! and it sounds like the prisoners talking to es, like es is quoting them somehow
エスって黒い手袋をしてるけど、黒い手袋って「私の穢れを見せたくない」っていう意味があるらしい…。
やっぱエスなんかあるわぁ…
キリスト教の聖書によると
羊→善
ヤギ→悪だそうです。
2つのマークがでてくるので参考にしてみてください。
おー！いい情報ゲットー！
え、てことはシルエットからイラストに切り替わる間奏の部分(語彙力)のマークって羊とヤギですよね…??脳に近いところに羊(善)がある場合、なんらかの事情があって殺さざるを得なかった(?)のか…????アマネとか虐待っぽいし楽になるために殺した…的な(語彙力皆無)
@@user-ct1dc5fy9w 確認してきたら全員羊の方が脳に近かったです…！
その人が善か悪かあなたが判断しろ、的なやつですかね…？
ジャカロープさんツノがヤギしてる
@@user-xn3eu1mm3l ジャッカロープってのはこのために作られたキャラじゃなくて、アメリカのワイオミング州あたりの未確認生物なんですけど、あれはシカの角ですよ！
最後の、エスっぽい子が囚人にめっちゃ襲われてる所、皆が人を殺した時の殺し方？なんじゃねって思ったら鳥肌(伝われ)
違ったらごめんだけど、フータ殺してるってより襲ってる感あった気がしたから、やっぱいじめてた子が自殺したとかかな...
天才ですか……？
最初の青い子(名前忘れた)は家庭の事情だったら赦せる？
ムウちゃんは正当防衛で殺すのは赦せる？
小学生の子(名前忘れた)は幼かったら赦せる？
フータは間接的な殺人だったら赦せる？
多重人格説出てる子(名前忘れた)は別人格だったら赦せる？
みたいな、こう言う理由だったら赦せるんだねってことだと思ってる
2:08
Boy sitting on a bed in a children bedroom = Haruka
Girl walking through an alley = Kotoko
Girl standing idk what to write = Yuno
Boy sleeping in front of a screen = Mikoto
Someone taking a pic of a home = Futa
Person lying on the ground = Amane
Girl lying on the school floor = Muu
Idk how to describe the this = Shidou
Person kneeing outside = Kazui
Holding hands idk = Mahiru
To be honest, I’m very interested in the past of Es, maybe more than any other prisoners’. Why is he given the opportunity to decide whether others are guilty, they could have chosen any other people, but why a person who forgot his past. Is his past somehow related to the prisoners? Did he commit any ‘crime’?
One more thing, I tried searching ‘milgram’ and found out that it’s a psychology experiment. Let us not spend time going through the details, if this project is an imitation of the experience. Then probably, the person with power and authority is Jacklope. And Es will be the person obeying authority/subject. There are 2 possible roles for other prisoners, I think. Either they are just normal prisoners waiting for the judgement from Es. Or they are prisoners controlled by jacklope to encourage Es act in a certain way. In any cases, I feel like what we (Es) choose to do will affect not only the prisoners future, but also Es’ future.
Moving out of the settings, this project may be an experiment itself, where we (listeners), are the subject. As till now, there is no exact conclusion from ‘milgram experiment’. Maybe they would like to find out how many people follow the society’s moral standard (a kind of authority that we usually perceive it as truth) in deciding whether others ore guilty.
I’m just trying to organise my thoughts so that I could use it as a reference when the story goes on. But feel free to point out anything that you find it unacceptable. It would be good for me to listen to more analysis to make decisions
Yes, i think so. Its still a mystery why they choose Milgram as their name. Also, Jackalope didnt reveal what will they do to the Guilty ones, maybe it can be that the guilty will be punished by Es? Or something like that. Its kinda freaks me out that this total music project is a mystery. I love it though
Also i think the same as you, that this music project test us as a human, ruler, jury, and civilan. I mean, we can choose whether they are guilty or not from whatever point of view right? It can be from the laws (which is different among countries), tradition, moral issue, value issue (which is different among people), from psychological (in Haruka), maybe medical (like in Umbilical), and from their future if they had judged as guilty or not guilty
Yeah, but how are they extracting memories and converting them to songs? like i know every single one of them is a bop but HOW? seems fake to me (i'm talking about the plot of course)
is this a movie series or a novel or something cause I'm very interested in this story
Phát Nguyễn I hope I ain’t explaining it wrongly.
It’s actually a music project which the music is produced by DECO*27 and the story plot is written by Takuya Yamanaka. Songs are just part of the project, there are voice dramas as well which we could listen on Spotify I think. These provide us information related to the prisoners (those songs and dramas are actually a way for them to introduce what they have done,and clues could be found from both listening and watching the video)
For us,we will be standing at Es’ point of view and our job is to decide whether the prisoners are guilty or not. By voting (using the official app of MILGRAM), we could make a change in the development of the story plot and affect the future of the prisoners. There are 3 rounds for us to vote, which means each prisoners will have 3 songs.
There are actually even more details but I am afraid I would make mistake. That’s why it will be better for you to maybe check out the video in the channel that introduces the whole settings. I hope what I’ve said could give you a bit basic understanding of this whole project at least :)
0:33
最初は違和感の塊だった
「フュー↑チャー↑」が好き、癖になる
囚人によってエスの歌い方が違うのかっこいいな
与えるだけじゃやーよのエスの歌い方がすごく好き
もしかして、0番であるエスは“まだ”罪を犯していないのかも知れない。しかしエスが間違ったジャッジを下すこと、つまり誤審は十分罪と呼べる。十人の囚人の罪について歌っているのは、今から自分が犯すかもしれない罪(誤審)に彼らの罪が関わっていて、エスの罪は自分自身の因縁ではなく一方的な審判の結果であるからと推測できる。
2:38から（恐らく）エスに対して囚人たちが暴力を振るう様な描写があるのですが…
これを見て何となく思ったのが、
実はエスも囚人たちと同じく罪を犯した事のある人で、
囚人たちが最終的に赦されるか赦されないかが決定した後、
エスの罪に関する曲が公開されて、
囚人たち若しくは視聴者たちによって赦すか赦さないかを決められるんじゃないかな…と。
もし、囚人たちによって裁かれるのであれば、
エスが囚人たちに対してどのような判断を下していたか、
それによって彼らがどのような経験をして、どのような心境の変化があったのか、
そんな要素から囚人たちが下す判断が変わってきて、
最終的にエスが赦されるか否かが決まりそうだなーって。
ただ、エスの罪が彼らを自分勝手に裁いていたことだったりしたら、
エスを通して判決を下していた私たちもまた、囚人たちによって裁かれることになるから…
それもそれで面白そうだなと何となく妄想を…してしまいました…。
もしエスが赦されたらまた記憶を消してミルグラムが行われたりするのかな…
0:15〜床に落ちてる箱は10個…それぞれ囚人の(罪の)箱？
エスの横にも1個箱がある。最初エスが手に持ってた箱は000。エスにもナニかある…？
アンダーカバーがエスの心象なのかもね…
それぞれのキャラの心情を現す歌を出すオルゴールじゃない？
Sは彼女ではなく、彼らです
シドウのパートの｢騙される方か騙す方か｣って歌詞がすごく気になる
ドラマトラックで尋問が行われる前に｢嘘はつかないつもり｣と言っているし終始冷静で誠実そうに見えるのにDECO*27さんの楽曲から彼がカバーしているのはライアーダンスだし、普段の様子とはかけ離れたかなりはっちゃけた歌い方をする
どうして彼に嘘や騙す等といったキーワードがまとわりついているのか考えると、今まで出た情報のどこからどこまでに｢嘘｣の要素が含まれるのか本当に分からないのが怖くてたまらない…。
ミクちゃんカバー聴いて帰ってきた民おるやろ？？おるやろ(圧)
ミクちゃんカバー聴いてミルグラム沼にハマった人間おるやろ？？おるよな()
( ´ ▽ ` )ﾉｶｴｯﾃｷﾀﾖ
@@user-rr4cu7ys6x おかえり( ´∀｀(((
ハマってしまった...
しかし後悔なんてする訳ない
後者ですはい( ￣▽￣)
ハーイここにいまーす！
I JUST REALIZED kazui (the oldest) is paired with the youngest member omggg also based on how it's shown, i feel like the last two are contrasting in ways where mikoto who takes 0 responsibility for his actions and kotoko who fully admits them
Yupp, we can even go further because Futa is a cyber bully and Mu got bullied
@@Naynin Haruka was neglected by his mother, while Yuno was a neglecting mother
In that case, Haruka pleads to receive love, Yuno gets paid to give love. Futa, the bully, and Muu, the bullied. Shidou, the one who does everything to make sure his lover/family/whoever stays alive, while Mahiru (unknowingly) slowly kills her lover. I’m not sure about the other two pairs…
Kazui is the one that breaks promises whilst amane stays true to them
from the future. Mikoto is confirmed to have DID and is *protected* by his alter, and kotoko is *protecting* "weak people" and es.
皆考察してる中の私
( ᐛ)「フューチャー」
不意打ちすぎて笑ったw
笑ったwww
待ってそれ私もですwww
ちょうど見てたから吹いたw
全く同じですwww
Notice how Es has all the little boxes around them. Notice how there are ELEVEN, not ten.
I wonder if one is for them.
The box Es opens at the beginning is labeled with "000." In the Welcome to MILGRAM video, we can see Es is also referred to as "000" there. Pretty interesting!
At the end, we’ll vote whether Es is guilty for sentencing everyone else and causing their deaths
@@chantolove That's probably the case
Kotokos 2nd trial vid finally came out and she mentions a number 11 prisoner as inept guard, most likely referring to Es. So maybe Es is seen as a prisoner as well?
「喜ぶでしょう」のとこで皆がほくそ笑んでる？みたいなところの皆が写った最後、一瞬だけエスみたいな人がうつってるんだよなあ
囚人服を着たエスが。
追記 2:39
今さらだけどラスサビを見ていつか囚人メンバー達がエスに対して手を出してきそうじゃないかと思ってしまった。
確かに…殺してるのエスだもんね、手を出しそうだな…とくにミコトとかミコトとかミコトとか((
@@user-ss5ty6uo5e ミコトくんばっかじゃねーか！w
ボイスドラマのネタバレ含みます
ボイスドラマですでに手出されてましたね…ぶん殴られるエス君とてもよかったです墓に帰ります
@@user-zy9fv1lb7j
※ほんのちょっぴりネタバレ
私も初見聞いた時ビックリしたし殴られた後苦しそうにするエスくんにリョナ心が芽生えたし
私の中でミコエスというカップリングに目覚めてしまったきっかけでもあるんですよねホントにありがとう((((
@@helloex-6767 絶対趣味あうじゃないですかあ…
For whatever reason the lyrics were updated after nearly 3 years....
They aren't more accurate they just seem to have awkardly tried to fit the season 1 MV titles into the lyrics (which the Japanese lyrics didn't do?)
Anyway, if anyone still wants to read the old lyrics they're up on the wiki
I'll try copy pasting them here but youtube is funny about what it marks as spam:
“UNDER” If you forgive this sin you’re as good as an accomplice
I’m alone and lonely, please give me some love
“UNDER” I feel the emptiness inside me
We agreed to seek each other, I wish we could do something about it,
FUTURE
“UNDER” I am playing hide and seek from the sin I committed
You should all give up and shut up
“UNDER” I always have a broken heart
When will it stop aching?
“Scramble for life”, Dissecting our thoughts while asking “why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
“UNDER” Which will you choose
To deceive or to be deceived
”UNDER” I don’t just want to give
Both giving and receiving are good things
“UNDER” I keep on seeing dreams
I am always indecisive, I can’t be saved
NEW LYRICS
“UNDER” If you say INNOCENT, you’re complicit and weak
I’m so lonesome, please love me
“UNDER” My cord’s being pulled but nothing’s ever enough
Contractual desires, oh what to do, FUTURE
“UNDER” Hiding and seeking from sin
Bring it, submit, and also shut your trap
“UNDER” Clutching a broken heart
The pain’s still there, after all this time
Take, grab, steal, dissect the thoughts of “Why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
To know someone, to bind them in their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The fine line between “Hate” and “OK”
Shouldn’t you look beyond your EGO, before it all ends?
After knowing all, I wonder
Can you really say INNOCENT?
“UNDER” Which way will you throw down your weight
To be the deceived, or the deceiver
“UNDER” I don’t wanna just give
Giving and taking, this is how to be in love
“UNDER” I just keep on dreaming
half in, half out, I’m doomed
“UNDER” Just need to believe
There is no reason to break a promise
“Scramble for life”, Dissecting our thoughts while asking “why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
“UNDER” Don’t lie about me,
What did I do?
“UNDER” Dedicating my life
There is something I want to remove
“Strife” Losers go on first
A false accusation full of mistakes
You would probably smile
And be pleased
“Scramble for life”, Dissecting our thoughts while asking “why”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with their EGO
Can you really judge them?
The border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
Deceit, “UNDER” That cannot be removed
The subs on most of these vids suck so bad I honestly don't know what's going on. They either just take subs from anyone who comes forward with them or have the world's okay-est machine translator working for them
@@rosen_venus I want to give the translator some credit, these lyrics are uh 'interesting' in ways that indicate a human touch instead of the incomprehensible mess of machine translation
like even when it's confusing it's still a Choice
That said I have no idea what they're going for
考察に何となく役立ちそうな歌詞&セリフまとめ(一部他の動画のコメントをコピペさせて貰っています)
激長いので注意
○ハルカ/櫻井 遥
「じゃ、じゃあどうすればよかったんだよ！どうすればさ…教えてよ、馬鹿な僕にもわかるようにさあ！」
アンダー 赦すなら共犯者
ひとりぼっち 愛を頂戴
○ユノ/樫木 優乃
「はあ…めんどくさ。」
アンダー 何かが足りないんだ
求め合う決まり なんとかしたいフューチャー
○フータ/梶山 風汰
「なんでだよ(?)、俺だけじゃねえだろ、みんな面白がってただろうがよ！なんで、俺だけ…俺だけ責められなきゃいけねえんだよ！」
アンダー 罪からのかくれんぼ
さあ尻尾巻いて黙ってどうぞ
○ムウ/楠 夢羽
「ふふふ…あなたが悪いんだよ…私に、酷いことするから…」
アンダー 壊れたハート持って
痛いのはいつまで続くのかな
○シドウ/桐崎 獅童
「ッハハハハ…ッハハハハ…確かに(?)死んでない…まだ、死んでないよ…今更わかったよ…俺が奪ったものの価値を」
アンダー どちらを選ぶんだ
騙されるほうか 騙すほうか
○マヒル/椎奈 真昼
「これが…恋…？これが…！恋…！」
アンダー 与えるだけじゃやーよ
するのもされるのも いいもの
○カズイ/椋原 一威
「夢見ちまって…くだらねえっ！」
アンダー 夢ばかり見ているんだ
もう半端ばっか 救えないな
○アマネ/桃瀬 遍
「アア！ごめんなさい！ごめんなさい！決まりを破ってごめんなさいっ！」
アンダー 信じるだけでいいの
約束を破る道理などない
○ミコト/榧野 尊
「僕の人生…こんなはずじゃなかったんだけどな…」
アンダー 嘘をつかないで
僕は何もないだろう？
○コトコ/杠 琴子
「…フッ…気持ちいい…」
アンダー 命を使って
消したいものがあるから
ありがとうございます参考になります！！
並べてみたら結構台詞と歌詞がリンクしてますね！！！
ありがとうございます！
コトコよく見たら殺すときに笑ってますね，，，
@生田海輝 それな
全く確定じゃないので分かんないんですけど
ハルカで精神患者(考察から)だったら赦せる？
ユノで堕胎なら赦せる？
フータで間接的(追い詰めるみたいな)だったら赦せる？
ムウで正当防衛(?)だったら赦せる？
後は幼かったら赦せる？とか別人格だったら赦せる？とか愛してたら赦せる？
みたいな、どういう人殺しなら赦せますか、どちらも人殺しなのに状況が違うだけで赦せるんですねっていうことだと思う(伝われ)
看守が許せる立場なのかどうかって誰かが言ってたからそう言うことだと思う
みんなの殺し方っていうか動機が違いすぎて
Here is my theory that Es is one of the prisoners
• At 2:39 we can see Es with a prisoner suit
• The box that Es' holding have a number "000"
• the room for prisoners have 11 rooms, 000 to 010
• while Es is sitting in these MV, there are 11 box around them. the other one is next near to them
• in this music video, you can see that there no door iron bars for the prisoners, that means. Those full iron bars can be open by sliding it to the side or opening it to the top. Im not sure about this iron bars part because when I listened the Voice Drama of Es, before the prisoner's exit their rooms, there is this mechanical sound that can guess that these iron bars can be open by going it to top or sliding it by side
- plus, Es mentioned that the room of 000 has no iron bars/lock that's what makes me think
• And at the end of the MV, Es disappears and then Jackalope is the only one left, when the "000" box closed
- probably mean that the box "000" is belong to a prisoner, and that is Es. I mean if its belong to Prison Guard, Jackalope should be disappear too
I also have a theory that Es probably have connection with Mu
• Because at Es' voice drama, while Jackalope introducing the prisoners to them. Es only remember Mu's name
• Also before this MV ends, when Es' eyes get near, you can see Mu's reflection on
Wait btw which vid is the one with muu and es being connected
@@timorysimon586 8 months late but i think they meant this one where muu is the last person to appear before the final scene with jackalope
音楽も歌詞も凄いし、コメント欄の考察も凄いんだけど、
毎回サビ×人数分の１枚絵とアニメーションと伏線背景を描いてる絵師さんに尊敬しかない。
わかりみ
わかりみ
わかりみ深し尊臣秀吉
わかりみ不可思議
I can't thank the official staff enough for adding the English subtitle
グルミクとのコラボで知り、この動画に辿り着きました
もうイントロからビリビリ来ちゃいまして完全にこの曲に惚れてしまいミルグラムという作品への興味が止まりません
知れてよかった...
リリリリとミルグラムと全然違って逆にギャップあるし性癖に刺さる…っ！
赦さないを”嫌い”って表現するの、見てるだけのやつらの傲慢の極みで好き
歌詞の“僕“の読み方は全部”あなた”でしたね
エスって心理学で無意識だから、何かしらの私たちの“本能”が反映されてるのかな。
本能が人を裁くのか…
最後のサビの絵が、初めて裏側が見えた気がしていろんな意味で鳥肌たったよ…
エスは主人公でありながら、我々視聴者の依代となる存在っていう設定ですよ！
最後の絵エスが色んな囚人？に殺されてましたよね なんか考察が深まります
｢アンダー｣から続く歌詞がキャラ一人一人のことを指していて、しかもエス目線ではなく恐らくキャラ目線での心情？みたいに聴こえるんだなぁ
もう何回も再生してる
エスの中の人である天海さんの歌唱力と演技力にも注目してぇ( ; ; )
元の声けっこう高い方なのに中性的な声＋囚人一人一人に合わせた歌い方ってすごくないですか。
なんでですか
that was actually such a banger oh my god 😭 UNDERR🗣️🗣️
考察は後々頑張るので歌詞書きます。
アンダー
赦すなら共犯者
ひとりぼっち 愛を頂戴
アンダー
何かが足りないんだ
求め合う決まり なんとかしたいフューチャー
アンダー
罪からのかくれんぼ
さぁ尻尾巻いて黙ってどうぞ
アンダー
壊れたハート持って
痛いのはいつまで続くのかな
奪い合い"どうして"の精神解剖
間違い探しの延長線を
誰かを知って 愛で縛って
裁けるかな？
"嫌い"対"OK"の境界線を
我儘のまま終わっていいの？
すべてを知った 僕（あなた）はちゃんと赦せるかな？
アンダー
どちらを選ぶんだ
騙されるほうか 騙すほうか
アンダー
与えるだけじゃやーよ
するのもされるのも いいもの
アンダー
夢ばかりみてるんだ
もう半端ばっか 救えないな
アンダー
信じるだけでいいの
約束を破る道理などない
奪い合い"どうして"の精神解剖
間違い探しの延長線を
誰かを知って 愛で縛って
裁けるかな？
"嫌い"対"OK"の境界線を
我儘のまま終わっていいの？
すべてを知った 僕（あなた）はちゃんと赦せるかな？
アンダー
嘘をつかないで
僕は何もないだろう？
アンダー
命を使って
消したいものがあるから
喰らい合い 敗者は先にどうぞ
間違いだらけの冤罪だって
僕（あなた）はきっと 笑顔できっと
喜ぶでしょう
奪い合い"どうして"の精神解剖
間違い探しの延長線を
誰かを知って 愛で縛って
裁けるかな？
"嫌い"対"OK"の境界線を
我儘のまま終わっていいの？
すべてを知った 僕（あなた）はちゃんと赦せるかな？
騙し合い消せないアンダー
Ok so between the 2:08 and 2:16 we can see some scenes from each one of the prisoners, I went over them and I think i know who each one represents. Not much info can be extracted from each scene though, probably the foreshadowing will make more sense in future songs. We still can deduce some things if we connect the frames with the lyrics that appear with each one of them:
2:08 - Haruka (blue haired guy) "I'm alone and lonely, please give me some love" - Probably abused by someone in his household?
2:09 - Kotoko (girl w/ the piercings) "Dedicating my life, there is something i want to remove" - can't deduce much on this one
2:10 - Yuno (long-haired girl) "We agreed to seek each other, I wish we could do something about it" - Bad relationship? Heartbreak?
2:11 - Mikoto (guy w/ dyed hair) "Don't lie about me, what did I do?" - not much can be deduced from the lyrics, but he was probably overworked as hell in school
2:12 - Futa (delinquent guy) "I am playing hide and seek from the sin I committed. You should all give up and shut up" - Now this one's interesting, maybe the phone suggest he was stalking his victim?
2:12 - Amane (child) - "Just need to believe, there is no reason to break a promise" - literally no idea, but her dialogue in the voice PV is very cryptic and is always talking about "breaking the law".... what did this child even DO
2:13 - Mu (shy girl) - "I always have a broken heart, when will it stop aching?" - pairing it with her dialogue on the voice pv ("you have no idea what i've gone through") I think it's obvious she was bullied at school, maybe heartbreak too?
2:14 - Shidou (white haired guy) - "Which will you choose, to deceive or be deceived" - no idea what he did, but its obvious he deceived/was deceived by someone. Maybe he was a surgeon?
2:14 - Kazui (older guy) - "I keep on seeing dreams. I am always indecisive, I can't be saved" - We can't deduce what he did from this, but definitely how he felt
2:15 - Mahiru (happy blonde girl) - "I don't just want to give, both giving and receiving are good things" - Maybe she was in an abusive relationship where she felt she wasn't being loved back??
That's all i can deduce for now, but im really excited!! I can't wait to see how the next songs will play out!!
Their was also scene that showed how they killed their victims but it was stencil so i could really tell but you could see some weapons and some of the environment at 2:39
Ahh I like your theories, my personal theory about Amane is that she was in a cult (specifically, her parents are in a cult and she was born into it). A few of her voice previews mention god, as well as breaking rules so I think that theory may be correct?? The poor kid probably was trying to protect herself without realising what she was doing. I also have a theory about Futa, my guess is that he's some rich kid who wants attention (there's honestly no basis for this besides his voice trailer mentioning that he'll sue Es for human rights violations, which seemed like a spoiled rich-kid thing to me), and that he committed his crime because he was trying to impress people (once again, no actual basis for this, but in his voice trailer he makes it very clear that whatever he did, it wasn't his fault). That's much more a stretch than my Amane theory, but it's all up for speculation at this point.
@@stuffystuff24 I found the stencil part interesting like some of the shadow figure things had more gaps in them than others so I'm guessing the more gaps there are, the more broken the person
im addicted to this song
Ah yes I found the english comment
見事にDECO*27さんの策略にハマった人です。
今出ている楽曲全て聞いて戻ってきました。
新参者ですが、これからどうぞよろしくお願いします。
I think this is the case of "bad person repents by punishing other bad people". That's why Es is undercover, they deserve to be in the same place, but because they took a deal they are now the one to punish others.
SO EXCITED EEEE
「僕(あなた)はちゃんと赦せるかな」
私たちは赦したい前提なの？
まあ、多分最後の曲が出るまで赦すことになるだろうけど(少なくとも私は)
これからどうなるんだろうほんとうに楽しみ
各人物の姓名 1櫻井 遥（さくらい はるか） 2樫木 優乃（かしき ゆの） 3梶山 風汰（かじやま ふうた） 4楠 夢羽（くすのき むう） 5桐崎 獅童（きりさき しどう） 6椎名 真昼（しいな まひる） 7椋原 一威（むくはら かずい） 8桃瀬 遍（ももせ あまね） 9榧野 尊（かやの みこと） 10杠 琴子（ゆずりは ことこ） 部首がきへんなのは伏線だったりするのかな?
え、ホントだ
え、これ偶然じゃないよね…！？
よく見つけましたね…
あの…間違ってたら申し訳無いのですが「むわ」じゃなくて「むう」だと思います。
@@user-pd3ld1dh3u むうでした。修正しておきます
気になったので木へんの意味を調べてみようとしました。そしたら出てきたのが「欺騙(きへん)」。
欺き騙すという意味でした。
「私たちは欺き騙している」とエス(リスナー)に伝えてるのかなと思いました
(私考察伸びないのであとは誰かに託す)
You know, I've always wondered what it meant when they said "to decieve or to be decieved" for shidou's part
Shidou decieved the patients family while he was decieved by his family that he has to save his wife/whatever. Its shown in the mv that he is not sure in wanting neither: deciving the patients family and being decived by his family. (I think he said something like that in a questions that he no longer has a family since that person died, but it may have been Kazui idk)
These lines are probably the aspects of the characters that Es relates to. I can explain all of that if someone wants to see it written down.
Es is decived by us. Who knows what he really thinks, since he does as we say so. Without memories he can only build his morals on our opinions. Even if he developed some sense of justice along the way (probably didnt) he still has to think what we think. I dont think its good for him being here. And he decives the prisoners. If he sais that this person's sin is unforgivable/forgivable they will mostly belive it. None of the characters really disagreed yet. Fuuta mentioned that this is unfair, but from the side we voted Kotoko as innocent. He thinks agrees in that he is guilty.
This answear was probably more than enough information lol.
Shidou has a cover of Liar Dance, it probably has to do something with this line. I will look up the lyrics now.
Edit: (only spelling corrections since i cant write)
i wish Milgram was a visual novel/rhythm game i could play, have Es be the player character and play thru all the music levels so i wouldnt have to wait for them all to come out! tho id still like to see what other players voted for concerning each character ofc
actually, the songs are in the rhythm game D4DJ!
MILGRAM songs was added in the Japanese version of D4DJ! Would recommend to play D4DJ eventhough the rate-up sucks
they don’t have a visual novel but a novel has been released
I'd pay for us to play as es
ミクcoverから来た人へ
ようこそ沼という名の監獄へ
看守デビューおめでとう
…て……けて……_(:3｣∠)_
看守デビューって言葉選びすこ
マヒルさんまで聞いてなんとなくこうなのかなって感じるのは、ハルカとユノ、フータとムウ、シドウとマヒルそれぞれが対になっているというか、共通するテーマか何かがあるのかなと感じた。個人的に、
ハルカとユノ→「母と子」親子間で何か問題があったり、事情があれば殺人は赦されるのか？
フータとムウ→「報い、報復」悪いことをしてる人は殺していいのか？
シドウとマヒルは→「愛」愛する人のため、自分の愛のためなら殺人は赦されるのか？
というようなかんじ。
ともあれ早く全員の曲聴きたい。
頼む。全囚人で合唱してくれ
最近ハマった者だけど提案が素晴らしすぎる
今まで公表されている曲を聴いてからそれぞれの囚人たちが1人ずつ登場する部分の歌詞を見ると「囚人たちのそれぞれの罪に関わるヒントかな」って最近思うようになった
1:46 ここの真顔に戻る瞬間やべぇ
かわいい( ´ཫ`)👍(ワイは変態じゃないからな)
Imagine someone just stumbling onto this series with no context then they saw the comments--
That's me. I spent like half an hour figuring out what the hell this is.
Have to say it was worth it. This is a super cool idea/series. I'm excited to learn all their stories.
@@toast_cooked_bread oh gods-- HAHAHAHA
Glad you found it and are interested then cuz you can join the rest of us in this adventure of a series
I was the same too lol. I just stumbled into Mu's video and thought it was simply a video about the bad effects of bullying. I was confused by the really long comments talking about stuff that I didn't even knew existed.
im really confused at this point, I just came across one of the songs in my reccomended and ended up here.
I guess I'll continue searching as it seems interesting
@@lee-anne3045 Yeah, the whole story is confusing out of context if you just happened to be exposed to one the later videos. They can be easily be confused as one of those one-off Japanese songs.
If you want more info on the series you can start off by watching the "Jackalope" video on this channel. It explains the gist of the whole premise.
I'm not sure if this is mentioned but from 2:38, the red section, all the characters kill Es in some way (haruka strangling es, yuno... posing over es, Futa yelling at Es/holding Es' collar, Muu stabbing Es' stomach, etc.).
These shots are basically showing us how each character executed their murdering. Haruka was strangling (as partially confirmed at the end of Second Mv), Yuno is abortion (showed by how the blood was on her leg), Futa was online insults (symbolic yelling through internet?), Muu was stabbing the stomach (again, confirmed through both 1st and 2nd MV), Shidou was organs stealing, Mahiru was hanging, Kazui is... idk..., Amane was beating with a stick, Kokoro was hitting with a bat.
I'm not sure if this is helpful, but that's what I noticed. Thank you :>
Mahiru did not kill the victim, she probably is grabbing es who was hanging or something, the same way she did when she found her boyfriend committing suicide(probably)
Kotoko is actually kicking Es
Its possible that Kazui is holding his dead wife that commited suicide, just like mahiru's boyfriend.
isn't the one with the bat obviously mikoto
2:29 there’s a picture in the light.
Also, does anyone find it interesting that the title is “Undercover”, meaning that at least one of the characters could just be pretending to be a criminal. If this is based on the Milgram experiment, Es or the other characters could pretend that they participating in this while in reality, they’re giving back info to whoever is in charge of this project.
Gotta say one of the coolest things coming back to this MV I've noticed after following along with this channel for years, is how all the mugshots show the locations of where the crimescene / murders took place.
Haruka - The mountain forest where he killed his childhood crush with a rock.
Yuno - The abortion clinic where she got rid of her child.
Futa - The tossed up bedroom of the person who committed suicide after he spread rumours about them.
Mu - The pathway by the river bridge where she stabbed Sotohane-chan.
Shidou - The hospital bed where he dissected / euthanised patients.
Mahiru - The forest where her boyfriend committed suicide.
Kazui - The bottom of a cliff / balcony that his wife threw herself off of.
Amane - The bathroom where the cult waterboarded/ tortured people.
Mikoto - The train where John went on his "rampage".
Kotoko - The alleyway where she killed the paedophiles.
Confirms a lot about which events are real and actually happened as it's not deluded by the perspective of the inmates.
i read the lyrics after everytime es says "UNDER" and i realized that the verses are referencing to every prisoners songs lol
「アンダー～～…」のところ、人によって歌い方というか、声というか、ちょっとずづ変えてる?!すごい…！！
I think I'm beginning to understand what the 11th cell is all about. We are going to judge Es last in the third trial. Kind of like a way of asking ourselves if we think we did a good job.
2:23のミコトの顔がなんか引っかかる。
二重人格or記憶喪失ならこの状況に疲れ切ってる顔ってことになるけど、もしも罪悪感感じない系のサイコパスなら、追求されてめんどくさいって感じがすごいする。
さすがに考察にサイコパスふってくんのはないとおもうから何かあるんやと思う
耳を触る時の心理は「他に関心がある」らしいです。（多分）
cv花江夏樹だしね…（花江さんとばっちり）
新曲が出る度に味が出てくる曲ですね
誰も三審目で「赦さない」になるれば「死刑」とは言ってないとこに注目してる
個人的に小説「6人の嘘つき」のような形でミルグラムも終結するのでは？と思ってたりする
ここから本題
やっぱり何度も繰り返すサビに大事なことが隠れてるんじゃないかと考えます
考察↓↓
看守=僕(エス)=私たち(視聴者、考察者)
『』←歌詞
――サビ――
『奪い合い “どうして”の精神解剖』
「殺した原因の責任」を被害者と囚人で擦り付け合う。原因〜事件〜裁判の囚人の記憶を曲や映像として落とし込み看守が「どうして」と考察する
『間違い探しの延長線を』
囚人サイドの主張の矛盾、粗を探す遊びみたいなもの。
『誰かを知って 愛で縛って 赦せるのかな？』
考察して知った気になって、囚人くん/ちゃんが好きとかそんなんで裁けるの？という嫌味皮肉。
『“嫌い”対“OK”の境界線を 我儘のまま終わっていいの？』
犯罪を「赦す」「赦さない」は個人の自己満や食わず嫌いの意見なのではないか。看守の意見は全て正義で間違ってないのか。
『すべてを知った 僕(あなた)はちゃんと 赦せるかな？』
判決が出た後に「すべて」がわかる曲を投下される可能性。
「ちゃんと赦せるかな？」より、「ちゃんと」というからには「赦す」というのが正しい道や正解、美徳とされている世界観？(子ども同士の喧嘩「ごめんね！！💢💢」「いいよ！！💢💢」みたいな)。
――cメロ――
『喰らい合い敗者は先にどうぞ』
囚人が囚人に対しての挑発文句？(この歌詞の意味よくわからなかった)
『間違いだらけの冤罪だって』
考察が行き届いていない可能性。間違った解釈がある。
もしくは、看守に全てを見せる(解かせる)気がない暗示
『僕らはきっと 笑顔できっと 喜ぶでしょう』
このミルグラムという「赦す」「赦さない」の三審制の投票が一つの心理実験だから、結果が出て看守やミルグラムの主催者が喜ぶ。
または、空想の世界だと知っているので結果が出て単に結末を知れて看守が喜ぶ 。
以上です
I just realized this but the lyrics after every "UNDER" is referencing the titles of each prisoners' first trial MVs
Haruka's part mentioned the word "weak" which is a reference to his MV: Weakness
Yuno's mentions a cord, which is a reference to the Umbilical Cord and Umbilical being her MV's title
For Futa, it's "Bring it" for his MV "Bring it On"
Mu's mentions "Pain" which is a direct reference to "After Pain"
Shidou's is "Throw Down" which is in the lyrics and is also his MV's title
And for Mahiru, it's "How to be in love" which is only missing the "with you" part in "How to be in love with you" her MV's title
Next is Kazui's part which says "half in, half out" and his MV's title being "Half"
Amane's is just "Magic" which is her MV's title as well
Mikoto's "Don't you lie about Me Me, I've done nothing wrong" is a clever word play for his MV "MeMe"
Kotoko's part says "Harrowing" which is in her MV's title "Harrow"
These were actually changed recently! Idk when but they were originally different
@@sunnysideoflucie^^ they were changed yesterday
i just realized their first trial song titles are hidden in the lyrics of when each prisoner appears,???
僕はきっと笑顔できっと喜ぶでしょう、のとこ視聴者に対しての皮肉っぽくて好き
I don’t know how I just found out about MILGRAM today, but I am so happy I got Mikoto’s song in my recommended. Es’s voice is really nice! I’ll definitely keep up with it from now on.
In "This is the MILGRAM" and the character voice trailer it's shown that Es doesn't remember anything before being assigned his role as prison guard, and in this video Es' eyes are hidden for most of it (either by shadow/his hat in the "Under" parts, or being blank in his silhouettes with each of the prisoners). Given Es' role as the Judge, could this be representative of the common phrase of "justice is blind"?
But isn't the point of milgram being to contrast it with the "justice is blind"?
I've seen a lot of theories about Es being the 11th prisonners, because at the beginning there are 11 boxes, representing the prisons, and he appears when Box 000 is opened.
And then I thought about something. Jackalope or whatever told us to find the sins amongst the MVs, because they'd be there.
That doesn't exclude Undercover, does it?
What if we're not actually judging the prisoners? What if we're judging Es, by making him vote innocent or guilty? If he's a murderer, it brings a whole bunch of shades to the voting. Especially since he lost his memory.
We're trying to save Es, not the prisoners.
As a lot of Milgram's experiments theories have pointed out, supported by the theory that Es might be a criminal himself, I'd say the best course of action is to not vote. But it's too late. Haruka and Yuno are already judged innocent. Then what can we do? I'm so confused my brain is overheating but the Rabbit is definitively testing Es, and us. Whether anyone is guilty or innocent doesn't matter.
The rules are "Watch the MVs and judge them". Es has an MV. Which would mean he's hiding his sins somewhere.
And maybe, just maybe, Es pictures himself as the victims of the murderers' crimes as he distances himself from the role of murderer.
There's still a chance to try the "no vote" tactic in the second and third trials (assuming that the results of the first one are not going to be carried over).
well the songs says rhat if you vote them innocent you're as good as an acompalice
マジで…
DECOさん凄過ぎ…
いろんな人に楽曲提供して、さらに自分の方でも曲をあげる…
2:36あたりの「喜ぶでしょう」のとこでみんなが笑みを浮かべるの鳥肌たった
ココ最近気づきましたが順番通りに写ったあとアマネとカズイだけ何故か2回うつってるんですよね…アップで。そのあとフータらしき人物の拘束されたシルエット…気になります
y’all are here theorizing but all i have to say is WHO GAVE YALL THE RIGHT TO MAKE SUCH A BANGER?? LIKE WHATTTT
何度聴いてもこの中性すぎる歌声好きすぎて爆発しそう
力強さとか声質の雰囲気は女の子感全くないのに、でもかといって男の子ってわけもしなくて、あえて言うならショタ…
ほんとこの中性感どうなってるんだ毎日狂わされてる
DECO*27さんは"歪んだ愛"をテーマの曲が多いと思うんだけど、今回もそれぞれ、"歪んだ愛"が絡み合ってるのかな？
いづれにせよ楽しみです！
他の楽曲との関係性は否定されてます！
ですが、どの曲も、この曲もほんとにすごくいいですよね☺️
確かに、1.54のところで
「愛で縛って」
とあるので何か関連している可能性が大きいと思います。
マヒルさんやシドウさんとかカズイおじも愛と関係あるし
ユノもハルカくんもそうだしねムウもそうかも
それぞれの｢アンダー｣の後の歌詞が前のやつの砂嵐のところのセリフとあってる感じあるよね
なるほど！！！
ミコトだけは違う気がします。
h mgu 違うっていうよりかは、ミコトだけ他の囚人達と比べて砂嵐のところのセリフが誰(もしくは何)に対して言っているのかが分かりにくいだけなのでは？(他にもセリフだけでは分かりにくい囚人もいますが年齢や性格でなんとなく予想はつくと思いますし...)どちらにせよこれから分かっていくだろうし、今はそれを楽しみにしときましょ！☺️
何かが足りないんだ→ゆのっぽさ
だまってどーぞ→ふーたっぽさ
痛いのはいつまで続くのかな→ムウの被害者感っぽさ
いいものっ♡→まひるの可愛さ
約束を破る道理などないっ→アマネの子供っぽさ
上手すぎん？
They changed the en sub lyrics so in case anyone's interested in the old ones, here they are!
“UNDER”
If you forgive this sin you’re as good as an accomplice
I’m alone and lonely
Please give me some love
“UNDER”
I feel the emptiness inside me
We agreed to seek each other
I wish we could do something about it
Future
“UNDER”
I am playing hide and seek from the sin I committed
You should all give up and shut up
“UNDER”
I always have a broken heart
When will it stop aching?
“Scramble for life”
Dissecting our thoughts while asking, “why?”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with thеir- EGO
Can you really judge them?
Thе border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your- EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
“UNDER”
Which will you choose
To deceive or to be deceived
”UNDER”
I don’t just want to give
Both giving and receiving are good things
“UNDER”
I keep on seeing dreams
I am always indecisive, I can’t be saved
“UNDER”
Just need to believe
There is no reason to break a promise
“Scramble for life”
Dissecting our thoughts while asking, “why?”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with their- EGO
Can you really judge them?
The border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your- EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
“UNDER” Don’t lie about me
What did I do?
“UNDER”
Dedicating my life
There is something I want to remove
“Strife”
Losers go on first
A false accusation full of mistakes
You would probably smile
And be pleased
“Scramble for life”
Dissecting our thoughts while asking, “why?”
Looking for mistakes in overtime
You get to know them and then tie them with their- EGO
Can you really judge them?
The border between “Hate” vs “OK”
Is it really ok to be done with deciding with just your- EGO?
Will you be able to forgive them after listening to their sins?
Deceit
“UNDER”
That cannot be removed
Thank you!
Does anyone have a transcript of the new ones? :)
I prefer this one than the new one since the voting isn't really innocent or guilty, the JP meaning is forgive or not forgive which the old script shows lol
最初のエスの後ろを走ってついて来るジャッカロープがくそ可愛い
Random thought from rewatching this video. In the end, we see all of them "commiting their sins" (where we see the stencils stragling, kicking and so on) The person that is on the recieving end, the person getting hurt, has ES hairstyle and color. So maybe ES has a connection with all of them, maybe he was victim of their sins, or was bullied by them and now Jackalope is giving ES the chance for revenge in style of these trials., by showing ES what made his "bullies" do what they did, what made them the humans they are now. Maybe that's why the eleventh cell is empty. If ES chooses to get revenge, he will end up in that cell himself, as he has commited a sin himself. but that's just a though that came me just now. may be total bullshit
HONESTLY I LOVE THIS CCOMMENT
OH DANG
I like where you headed with this theory, but I took it as ES being sort of placed in the "victim's shoes" to probably get a better understanding of the 'sins' the cast committed. We'll just have to wait and see for the rest of the songs to be released!
@@Mika-de2jr that might be a reason as to why the title of the song is undercover, maybe.
@@nix__2164 haha you're probably right! I'm just spitballing here ^^
好きな曲を、聞いた曲っぽい歌い方で歌うのが好きだけど、エスくんは特に「騙し合い消せないアンダー」の落ち方が首絞められてるみたいな声で、この歌い方できる自信全然ない()
if you slomo from 2:37, you can see es in a prisoner costume.
which supports the theory of es either being a prisoner, has been a prisoner before or will become one soon.
idk if anyone has mention this but I just realized- Isnt all the victim that showed from 2:39 until the end are the same person? I have the feeling that all the victims there are Es. Either he's just projecting/replacing all the real victim, or maybe- just maybe -this is like an alternate universe where everyone that killed Es in their universe being gathered in one place?? That can explain why Es is the one who give the judgement bcs they r all his killer. Also There's a part in the lyric that say "Anata wa chanto yuruseru kana" means "Will you be able to forgive them?". If you see the lyric in Japanese (as in the kanji and you can see it in the video in 2:55) They use the kanji boku and the furigana (the way to read the kanji) is anata. Which means that lyric can be translated to "Will I be able to forgive them?". Maybe Im just reading to much into it but I can say this is another interesting detail to notice.
I was thinking the same thing, not that deep tho.
I just think it's to hide any indication of the people the Prisoners could have killed, so Es is possibly used to literally just hide the spoiler.
either that or it may imply that Es is trying to look at the perspective of the victim instead of himself
I thought it was kind of like a re-image of things the way the police do
OOOO WHAT
【2:39】
今までどんなイラストだ？って思ってたけどわかった!!
ここからってエスが被害者の代役で、各囚人の“罪“にあたる出来事が描かれてるんだ！
【2:45】ハルカ/絞殺
エス首元にハルカの手が重なっている。
(エスは対抗した形跡あり)
【2:46】ユノ/堕胎
出血箇所と二審までの考察も含めてこの可能性が一番高い。
(エスは脱力状態→赤子だから意思がない)
【2:47】フータ/糾弾
胸元を掴み責め立てている。
(弁解するようなエスの表情と持ち上げられている様子)
【2:55】ムウ/刺殺
手にカッターが握られている。
(エスが抵抗している)
【2:56】シドウ/？
腹部内に手を突っ込んでいるような描写。
二審までを踏まえると参考にする考察が多いけど、具体的な罪状は不明。
(エスは反動で腕が上がっているのか抵抗しているか曖昧。強く抵抗はしていない様子)
【2:58】マヒル/絞殺..?
首元に手をかけている描写はある。
※他の囚人と比較してマヒルだけ口元が映っていない→実質的にマヒルは手を下していない？
(エスが抵抗した様子がない。→相手は自死している？)
【3:01】カズイ/？
手をかけた描写では無い。
亡骸を抱えているようにも見える。
(エスが無抵抗で脱力している→既に死んでいる？)
【3:03】アマネ/撲殺
長い棒のようなものを振り上げている
(エスは抵抗していた姿勢になっている)
【3:04】ミコト/撲殺
バットで殴っている
(エスは抵抗するまもなく背後から不意をつかれた様子)
【3:06】コトコ/蹴殺
明らかに蹴ってる
(エスは蹴りの反動で仰け反っているが抵抗の跡がない→抵抗する間もなく蹴られた可能性がある)
一生懸命考えた素人の考察です🙇♀️
まだ参審もあるので間違いも多いでしょうが、自分なりのまとめとしてコメントしてみました。
既に似たコメントや考察が出ていたらすみません。😢😢
なるほど…ありがとう
It might have already been addressed before in some comments, but while listinening to the song, I noticed how Es' "Under" are slightly different to each other, as if the charecter appearing in the clip after said "Under" was the one zho said it :
0:24 is Haruka's , 0:29 is Yuno's , 0:44 is Futa's , 0:50 is Mu's , 1:26 is Shidou's , 1:31 is Mahiru's , 1:36 is Kazui's , 1:41 is Amane's , 2:18 is Mikoto's , 2:24 is Kotoko's.
In the beginning of Undercover Es holds a box and it opens thus starting the song and then after the song Jackalope is seen with the box but Es is nowhere to be found. There are 10 boxes and 10 prisoners so each box I'm assuming contains each prisoner's song. But here is where it gets complicated. In Es' voice drama it's revealed there is an 11th prison cell that's "unoccupied" and there is also an 11th box that is near Es during Undercover. Along with this Es has a song but Jackalope doesn't which is odd since apparently only the prisoners have songs. Along with this Jackalope didn't answer all of Es' questions in the first trial announcement. Which Jackalope is supposed to answer Es' questions. Basically what I'm trying to say here us that Es could possibly be the 11th prisoner.