Is “Shut Down” BLACKPINK’S Worst Edit? | Pro Editor Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2022
- Wondershare UniConverter (Video Converter Ultimate) AI-Powered: bit.ly/3wYzfT3
Simple Video Editor with AI tech: bit.ly/3KKu7rf
The complete video toolbox to convert, compress, edit videos, burn DVDs and much more.
Seek more FREE online tools: bit.ly/3AVrRsS
get free music video editing lessons taught by me → dl.acidbite.com/teffreek
get the best asset library Artlist with 2 extra months free → tinyurl.com/28yt99az
www.jordanorme.com/whyJesus
God bless :)
Here's a Simple Video Editor with AI tech: bit.ly/3KKu7rf
Now you should see NCT 127 New Video :)
The reason the song feels monotonous in relation to the editing(I think) is because of the time signature. This is the first time that I'm aware of that BLACKPINK has ever done a song that _wasn't_ in the typical "4 on the floor" time signature. For this song, it's actually in 6/8, not 4/4. That's why you can count it in groups of 6... "one two three four five six, one two three four five six." 6/8 is a type of waltz time. It has this rolling characteristic to it, like it's unending and eternal...like a locomotive chugging along.
please react to TXT's GOOD BOY GONE BAD JAPANESE VERSION. we really wanna understand the breakdown of the shots!!!!!!?????? please.. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I love your videos and during Jennie's rap on the table there's a reverence for another music video
can you react to Stray Kid Maxident trailer please pls
Jordan's channel is literally the total package; memes, jokes, editing masterclass, awesome reactions, crazy details that most of us have missed and ofc....DANCE THERAPY Y'ALL! (thanks to some people in the comments for reminding me :3) My man rocks!
Wow, thanks :)
@@JordanOrme heyyyy thanks for replying dude!
yes i always wait for his reaction to blackpink music video tbh
And whenever he reacted to a meaningful music video, he’ll tell us the moral stories
RIGHT? Give the man his flowers.
i love how Rose and Jisoo are getting a chance to rap. the combo of beats with the violin is amazing. they crushed it. i felt so nostalgic watching the music video with all the tributes to their previous ones. i really enjoyed how you walked us through a story. i didn't realize it was more than the shout outs to the other videos!
I love how Jisso is actually getting more lines in this new album not just shut it down but the whole album
Realmente fue una buena sorpresa que ella hiciera eso
Rosé was really shining in this album.
Their raps were amazing, like when they sing they slay, but the rap was perfect too
@@Yo-_2 absolutely. she even got her own solo song!
I think the message of the song is that they’re closing this era coz they’re preparing for something new. Something not common to a KPOP. They’re compiling their MVs like they are telling us to “move on, relax, we’ll give you something new”
So just another bts tactic ? Boring
@@miyawakisakura8536 bts became boring.. not something w blackpink x
@@sourfelixyt6251 both are boring. No improvement. Just same lame songs.
@@sourfelixyt6251 a blink saying this while bp copied the "new era" topic for their comeback from BTS. They don't even have 30 songs in their "old era" what new era ? bro you haven't even reached the end of a chapter yet 🤨
Excuse me it's a video related to BLACKPINK so don't add BTS here
Jordan is so kind for not criticizing much about this MV editing. He is not as excited as for other MVs he reacted to before.
I love everything and all the lines in the song/mv but Jennie's "This is not a comeback cause we never left" at the beginning.... I don't think I'll ever get over it-
They just lurk, ig 🤣
it's a white lie but it sounds cool
For me it is Rosé's "Stay in your own lane because I'm about to swerve"
@@mayalejandra fr sounds so smooth
@@someone-re7sq It wasn't tho. While they may not have been promoting they never left in terms of relevance on social media, on the charts, and in people's minds.
I think it's cool that Pink Venom was released first, as if they knew what a lot of the reaction would be. A lot of the hate or criticism of Pink Venom was in comparison to their old stuff, either that it was too much like D4, KTL, and HYLT, or oppositely, because the chorus was an anti-drop it actually wasn't enough like the banger chorus' of D4, KTL, or HYLT. The hate went both ways, funnily enough. And this, almost in direct answer to that, is saying like it's lame to hate on us just by comparing us to our older stuff. They shut that down.
Oh, that could be it yeah. I was just thinking the opposite. I thought this would have been a great pre-release because it creates anticipation for that new sound they are talking about, but you're right. Pink venom is different compared to what blinks were used to and thats what the ‘‘keep talking, we shut you down'' is referring to. Now I realise, it was like a pre-emptative strike before delivering the ‘‘we are back/we've grown and we're better than ever'' message. It's a good marketing strategy too, now that I think about it. Blackpink basically rebranded themselves and their sound lmao 😂
oooooh that makes sense, mainly because when you listen to the album, all the songs that come after shut down doesn't sound like any other song of theirs. like, the only one that i think that has a vibe that is slightly similar to their older songs is ready to love, but that one also sounds completely different. i feel like shut down is them making a change of genre/music because even that song sounds NOTHING like what they've done before. this album is so well done, i love it
That makes sense
Lol I love Blackpink and made some of the criticisms cited above. It's not hate. Every work can be praised or criticized. Just because we thought it could be better doesn't mean we're hating on Blackpink. Shut Down joined my Spotify playlist as soon as I heard the violins, not a big fan of the MV though. Pink Venom does sound a lot like the other stuff mentioned, not the chorus, more like the bg sounds used, I'm kinda tired of hearing them. Shut down is refreshing to the ears.
@@elvillivle Sure, obviously it's fine to criticize -- I also said after my first few listens that I wasn't a fan of Pink Venom's chorus mostly due to the cadence/voice they use (it has since grown on me). But if your complaints are mostly in comparison to D4, KTL, or HYLT, that's less solid criticism and more about unfair personal wishes. Especially if as my original post stated, the complaints go both ways -- complain that Pink Venom is too much like D/K/H, but then also complain that the chorus isn't enough like them. When it gets into that territory, it starts to sound more like hate because...
... Comparisons are fine when it comes to personal taste -- everyone has their own fave songs and styles from BP and other artists. But it's far less fair to use as criticism. Just imagine a critic going "This song is bad because I wanted this part to sound exactly like D4 and this chorus to sound like HYLT, but I didn't want this verse to sound like KTL, and not for this bridge to sound like Pretty Savage, and this pre-chorus sounds new but I wanted it to be like Playing With Fire..." and so on and so on. For personal tastes that's fine, but that's not a decent criticism of music at all. Imagine you're the artist and that's the kinda stuff you hear after a new song, you'd 100% think of it as whiny/lame/silly hate because it's not actual criticism.
When you were talking about Jisoo (7:51) IDKY but I legit started to cry. I'm literally so proud of her. Jisoo was always the "least favorite member", people called her a visual hole, and etc. I'm literally so happy, on what she overcame. She's the queen Jisoo. She has such a pretty voice, her visuals no no joke, she's an incredible actress, she's honest, she's funny, and so much more. I'm so glad she's at the top now.
Also I really like pink venom and this whole album! All songs are incredible. But guys, don't be disrespectful just because someone likes/dislikes a song you don't/do like. That's just stupid. Everyone as a different taste in music. If you don't want people to tell you your taste in music is bad, that you're lying when a song you like is good, or whatever. Then don't do it to other people. People can dislike/like songs. So let people do that. Stop thinking you have to have it your way.
"people called her a visual hole" i- uh- when you ask a jisoo stan why they luv the first THING they mention is visuals before vocals
Jisoo is literaly the VISUAL
Nobody called her a visual hole
Who calls her visual hole?
@@winniejung it wasn't Jisoo stans, it was all solo stans of Rosie, Jennie, and Lisa, it was antis, and "fans" of other groups they said she was ugly and needed to leave Blackpink, because she was ruining them so-
@@KandyKayne a lot of people did. I've been a fan of BP since pre-debut and people called her ugly and talentless, said she was gonna ruin BP, it was all solo stans of Rosie, Jennie, and Lisa, it as antis, and "fans" of other groups
Im so proud of blackpick to what they have achieved and for making us happy in every song! they are the best girls ive ever seen.
I already love the MVs but I always love them more after watching Jordan's reactions.
G DRAGON KING
Same!
saaaammmmee!!! he made us understand the videos more
sameeee
This song is PERFECTION like the MV the vocals the rapping the styling the beat its amazing ,blackpink came back with such a hit to shutup all the haters who are always saying that they're sticking to the same boring concept
But very low views how
@@omrasal7945 because at the same time b side song is released that’s why people stream a lot other songs too
@@omrasal7945 Actually some blinks said that they are not going to stream hard the mv this time.They are going to enjoy the song.
Views has nothing to do with enjoying the song
@@omrasal7945 happens witg lsg as well coz u know some people are also streaming the other songs in the album thats why
The dog standing next to Lisa (2:30) is Lisa's real dog, love❤️
5:41 *I think this step was homage to kill this love's last dancing part where they do a salute pose or some.*
The M/V is literally out of the world. The amount of references to the old M/Vs bringing back all the old eras. The lyrics, the music, vocals, the rap, the choreo, the sets just everything. This whole album is insane. This is what we wanted! This is perfection!
G DRAGON KING
So they just copy Bts 😂😂😂 couldn't they be original ?
@@selenaurquiaga3026 why BLACKPINK have to copy bts? ugh you’re not okay
@@shinhyunah7776 I'm definitely fine. Bts did it first 😂😂
@@selenaurquiaga3026 hahaha you’re just jealous don’t worry BLACKPINK already shut you down
Something extra I want to add is I find it very interesting how they chose to sample from Paganini’s la Campanella, now I normally dislike when modern producers use classical pieces for their music but I feel like this adds to the story of the MV even more. Paganini surpassed many great violinist in his time and even changed classical music due to his untraditional way of playing and performing, they said he even sold his soul to the devil due to his immense talent, so I feel like the producer knew that and most likely got inspiration from Paganini to make this song for black pink cause they to broke many records and in a way changed Modern pop music
This comment needs to be pinned to bring more attention to the poetry of Shut Down through the references, including Paganini.
I'm a classical violinist. I personally find the sample a bit repetitive because they essentially only use like 4 bars or sth. I can understand using a sample, but hey, at least it's getting represented?
@@codexone2194 true it was very repetitive and did get a bit annoying but so far It’s not too bad, I use to play the violin in my high schools orchestra I loved every minute of it !!
@@codexone2194 agree with this one. I'm a classical violinist too and the only thing i thought was "use the ending bar of that phrase PLEASE" which they ever only used twice. I quite liked the song, but I think they didn't use the piece and the many effects and variations they could've done with it just musically speaking. Not bad tho, the devil's violinist getting recognition like he deserves xd
@@carolrada991 they really missed out on the trill bit of the Milstein variations. That would have been an awesome oppurtunity for a bridge.
You also missed another hint i found in scene where rosé is on the globe 4:36 we can see that in th music video whistle it was a normal world, now its black and pink and it means that they are now ruling the worls
Love this!
8:12 here is As if it's you last
Damn! You definitely point out the message of their M/V. Iloveyou!
Thanks for hanging!
I think you r the most honest reactor I have ever seen on UA-cam and I'm not lying you r the first reactor whom I have subscribed to
ngl
Ikr
9:11 I don't know if I am wrong, but that scene reminds me AIIYL. In the scenes where they are in a pink car inside a tunnel with many lights
hahha. I also noticed the slight editing things. There really aren't any rules, but I agree that it could have been more satisfying. I think it's because they were trying to match the scenes that felt satisfying in their original videos exactly, but it's out of sequence and more referential. Those medium shots are more satisfying when aligned with the choreography.
This is so YG style. They are literally reviving their old and iconic rythm and style. I love it! Jennie with the red flapper hat reminds me so much of Gdragon!!! And Lisa with the cover up mask to TOP
SAMEEEEE
Red flapper hat?????
uh i think it's rhythm
Let's not talk about how insensitiv it was to release a music video with a tank and a russian hat in 2022
They did an amazing job this a masterpiece. Love how they included all of there mvs. Love y'all so much
G DRAGON KING
7:29 idk about yall, but I just noticed that the picture in the background is a picture of that scene, but the og in DDU-DU DDU-DU
in my opinion, BP's new MV is indirectly saying that they want to have new concept by closing the door which there's the old stuff from BP's previous MV.
I have been waiting for this! I would call myself a blink and I knew I saw resemblance from old videos. I was jumping saying they’ve been here before and seeing Lisa with record sliced really brought it home. Shattering records. Just ahhhh much love for them and thank you for helping me understand it
I loved all the references and the album itself, it gave us twerking material, it gave us tears hahah! I'm so happy the girls are back (even tho "they never left" ;) ) Thank you Jordan for analyzing everything so meticulously and for always giving us a fresh perspective and interpretation!! You're the best :)💚💚 Hope you'll also react to 2 BADDIES by NCT 127, it's truly one of if not THE best video they've ever released!!! I may have accidentally watched it like 30 times HAHAHA it's just THAT good! What a comeback. I don't know what kind of performance demons possessed them on set LOL
yo, no hate, but like get a life...
G DRAGON THE KING ,
Fr yes!!
"Twerking material"LMAO😂😂😂
Additional notes for Jordan orme's editor :
7:36 As if it your last
10:20 we really need that dance therapy as of this moment, thank you 🤣🤣
this bro deserve more viewers, love that he's just don't react to the editing but also trying to understand and point out the message and meaning of the music/mv itself.
exactly! And I really learned stuff as well.
This mv is really good to remind blinks blackpinks old music videos it's really amazing and important to remember stuff that blackpink did for us💞🖤😊💗 we love you jordan and blackpink
I love the way you have broken down all the scenes and all your comments were on point. Always looking forward to your reactions!❤
I love the references to Bombayah. I think its very cool how they reference their debut in 2016. So thrilled.
the mv is all about going on another level with their artistry it is an end of an era but it is just all the way up from here and they will be together for the journey
I actually like that it´s more minimal than their other MVs and all the references, my god!! Love the song too, more than Pink Venom.
It makes me sad and worried that it might be their last comeback because of the fan-service and it feels like it pays homage to past MVs like a goodbye :(
hopefully not though, but in the last scene, after they have taken the elevator up, there were new garage doors there instead of nothing, so maybe it's a hint that they will continue as BLACKPINK and have more MVs and so tracks coming soon?
pretty sure the point of the mv is that their shutting down their old era and entering a new one… dont think they will disband this year but maybe in 2023 if they dont resign their contract
It's not a goodbye
Ita a goodbye
To their previous selves
As they are going to be reborn
Hence the name born pink
I don't think this'll be their last MV bc they'll probably make a sad Disband song like ikon and 2ne1
Did anyone notice that the globe Rose was sitting on was black and pink which means that they final got the attention and finally spread their music to the whole world. Compared to the globe in whistle. They are in a whole new era. They are changing, so their shutting down what happened before.
2:04 istg that part of closing the garage's door is so satisfying to me ahhhhhh
So I have listened to their "Born Pink" album a few times and I must say that their English tracks just blew me away. Especially, "Typa Girl," "Hard to Love," and "The Happiest Girl". The lyrics are so much more personal and relatable, rather than fillers like Ra-ta-ta-ta. Maybe due to their global success, the group seems a bit more distant to me, but with this album I am in love with BP all over again.
when I say that your reactions are always top-tier, I mean it. it’s so rare to see someone you can actually learn a lot of things from but at the same time, you’re being entertained. thanks for this bro! 🙌🏻
This is mindblowing your explanations!!!!! Especially the part of the different gates of their music sets, seriously did not even think of it after watching it so many times, thank you so much for your detailed analysis. Their other songs in the album is on point too, I am just so happy they are back with new musics 😭
9:42 I like the point you made here. I think more people should notice this.
Having a classical violin sample in hip hop doesnt always work but in this case its brilliant! Different meters and rhythms come together seamlessly... It just works. And jordan nails the essential message here -- 'shut down on the past'. Blackpink moves on from so many great moments in the past to even greater future heights!!! 🖤❤️🖤❤️🖤💘💘💘💘💘💘💖🖤❤️
love you jordan ! thank you for bringing joy in our lives :)
In 9:19 references As If It's Your Last.
The explanation at the end gave me goosebumps
I love how you explain every single detail that a normal human like me whose got no idea about video editing would somehow miss. So cool Jordan! Well yeah! New Era for Blackpink. Haters gonna hate...
This my favorite comeback of theirs. The whole album has no skips!
Jordan!!! This review is sooo cerebral and sooo satisying!!! What an amazing review you did. Thank you 🖤💓
Are we even surprised? Blackpink never disappoints! YG Queens!
한국인입니다 한국에는 이렇게 장면마다의 숨은 의미나 카메라 전환에 관해 자세히 알려주는 채널이 없었는데.. 이렇게 정보가 빨리 올라오는 채널이 있다는게 너무 좋습니당 부족한 영어 실력으로 잘 보고 갑니다 셧다운 많관부🖤💕
I m also not that much fluent in English but still watching it to get to know the details
Amaaazing! Every details were explained very weeeellll!!! Nice one, Jordan!
ily for this video..Love the reactions. Thankyou so much
I’m honestly so happy I found your channel this past year! I love your content! Always fun to watch you in your element
you collected the references is just absolute gift to us.. thankyou
This is the only reaction video channel I enjoyed, and also I'm learning something about editing! Thank you Jordan!
I feel like with every video you post I learn something new! The way you explain how each transition and use of cinematography blows my mind. Especially since I am trying to learn as much as I can right now for going into film. Keep being awesome :)
OMG they effort you put into this video amazed me. thank you for making this video :)
on 6:21 in Jennie's right side there is a table on which there is two things are kept, first is a diamond heart from kill this love, second is a wings show piece which refers to the wing which Jennie had wear in kill this love MV
always love how you discover the meaning of every scene that i cant see just by my eyes!
I like the fact that they went to the new floor at the end cuz the new floor's garage doors were all shut so I'm SO excited to open those doors to see what's next for them in this new era!!
I always wait for your reaction for every famous k-pop music video because you really help crack the codes in the mvs even the smallest part that I didnt even notice. You really help open up the minds 😂😂 thanks
I always wait for your reaction videos. You notice every detail and it helps me to understand more the MV!
I love how you analyze musics vids so well and it helps people understand what the meaning is of the song love your vids ❤
That’s why I like your videos! I notice those little things, but I know absolutely nothing about editing. Then I see your videos, and it all makes sense to me, and you really make it fun to watch.
This has to be the best breakdown of this MV on UA-cam. You always have great insights and commentary on your videos
Since the release of "Shut Down", I was waiting for your reaction. We learn something new every time, we see your video. I love your reactions the most.
Also, your Dance therapy is therapeutic to the ones who are watching you as well! Great moves!!!
i always always wait for your detailed reactions for our queens thank you 🥰😘
Thank you so much for sharing the real message of this video with us!!
I love how they included multiple reference of their other music video , and the way they changed the vue point of them . Truly amazing as alway's !
Not even a Blink but looked forward to your analysis.
From The Force Awakens crit to the funny awkward sign-off, and of course all the entertaining, educational content in b/t...just one of the best channels on this here Tube of You.
I hope you land that Kpop vid gig, cuz you deserve.
Always good to watch your reaction. it's like your uncovering the secrets of every scene.
This reaction is really cool and fun to watch. Keep it up 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
2:37 she also has money in the bags referencing money 😮
the car scene with rose and jisoo is also acutally a call back to as if it's your last. u guys always leave that one out! lmao
the earlier scene when jisoo if in the front with lisa is also a call back to whistle.
I love how you put in the reference to their previous videos when my head tries to put them all together but failed. Thanks man.
Omg so cool to see a break down of the video!! Thanks!!
I knew you would react to thisssss! I'm actually excited for your mv reaction 💯💙
I've been waiting for this reaction!!
Love watching your reaction videos. Learning a lot from you👍👍
I was waiting for this reaction vid from you.❤
I love the all MV sets in this Video and them shutting them down it’s ICONIC, wishing you react to the full BORN PINK Album it’s 🔥🖤💗
Great to see you react "shut down".
Your reaction so professional, you can find any detail in each MV.
I don’t think it’s about them shutting down everything else in the room, when they come in 2:14 . Its about shutting down the old area because they are starting the new one now.
oh my god, thank you for this. I knew there was a message, I saw all the throw back scenes, but I assumed it was JUST an homage . love this.
I haven’t watched all your videos for awhile but coming back and seeing your amazing reaction and the dance therapy which helped me whilst I have a bad cough I laughed without coughing in a good way thank you!
So many ppl are out their opinions up on this music video, bad opinions thinking “SHUT DOWN” sucked!
To me I LOVED IT!!!! Especially Rose’s black and green outfit which they are hating on but it’s making you pay attention to her more! It made her POP!
People have to understand it’s a new era they ain’t ever gonna make the same song!
Their Music Is Changing because they are growing up, they are going through things that we can’t seem to know but we can see it in their music!
So those haters not liking their music is because they aren’t old enough to understand the meanings in their songs or even understand that music Changes every day.
Nobody can ever beat BLACKPINK OR EVEN BE LIKE THEM!
So stop comparing them!
This music video opened a new window!
They brought all the members together and everyone had their fair share in their parts.
As a person who is 23 years old! I definitely say THEY CAN MAKE WHATEVER MUSIC THEY WANT! I’ll make sure they see my support!
If they are going to be Gone soon why the hate and not ACCEPTANCE!
Look how much they grown!!!!
WOULDNT YOU BE PROUD?!
So those negative opinions just to get Views? They don’t MATTER! Say what you want! BLACKPINK won’t ever see your hate cos they don’t care! LEAST THEY ARE SUCCESSFUL! Meanwhile you are in your room miserable and wishing you were them!
I LOVE BLACKPINK!!!! LETS GROW WITH THEM GUYS!!!
THIS🙌🏻like fr people need to know that THIS IS A FREAKIN NEW ERA!!!😂i understand opinions but people be going " I'VE NEVER BEEN THIS DISAPPOINTED" or "THIS IS NOT THE BP IK" tbh i loved this mv alott 💗🖤
@@Jimin_yOu_Got_nO_jams_. IT MADE ME FEEL EMPOWERED WHEN LISTENING TO ITTTT
LIKE AHHHH
ppl need to be more nice 😭
I couldn't agree more!!!
I haven't seen anyone say this song sucked though. I personally think it's wayyy better than pink venom(not saying that was bad either, it just wasn't as good for me). This song knocked it out of the park and the references made it even better
@@murasakino101 people lit saying this song is shit and pv is better
I have to laugh
I think the meaning of the Music Video is they are close to "Shut Down" Blackpink, considering it's their last year of contract. And with all the controversies about YG, and maybe pursuing their solo careers.
Maybe it's the end of an era, a "Shut Down"
It makes sense. They have only 11 months left of their contract so I think YG would give Jisoo a solo comeback. And that's it.
Blackpink never disappoints us!
J.. I just want you to know that we appreciate the effort you put into your videos. As someone who’s interested in video making… your quick lessons are blessings! You are doing great!
I didn't know it's possible for Lisa to have even more confidence and charisma. Her vocals??? Shookt! Especially on the Happiest Girl and her rap in Typa Girl??? Girl is mad! LISA PROVES SHE'S AN ALL-ROUNDER, AN ACE JUST LIKE WHEN THEY'RE TRAINEES! I'M SO PROUD OF HER.
I look forward to your reactions and am never disappointed.
i was waiting for this reaction. thank you
Thank you for this Jordan!! The best reacts as always.
Thanks for watching!
I love how detail oriented Jordan is (part of the job description of course), but adding technicality, humour, insight and dance therapy is icing on the cake! Awesome review!
Thanks for the analysis. There’re many details I didn’t notice
I really love how you explain every shots in the video... im so amaze 😎
This reaction was fire and i think soon you'll be on a professional level of dancing thanks to your dance therapies!🔥🔥🔥
Yeah finally you drop it 😍
Oh my gosh new subscriber because I absolutely loooove how you break these videos down professionally ❤
Awesome Reaction! Technical n Storytelling, on point!! Great job!