It’s heartbreaking when there’s really no “bad guy” in situations like these. Just messed up people trying to figure things out and end up hurting each other along the way. It’s easier when there’s one clear person to place the blame on.
Liv didn't trust her from the jump. But she didn't want to stop Noah from meeting his actual family. Her guard is always up and she knows she's right most of the time, due to her occupation of being in law enforcement. But damn, she didn't expect the Grandmother to stoop so low.
Exactly. Why wait til now to gain custody of Noah. Noah doesn’t know this lady( Grandma Sheila) now she wants to fight custody of him she waited all these years because it’s a reason that Ellie lied about her parents being dead. Glad that Judge Linden didn’t granted the adoption to Sheila. Olivia almost had Noah taken from her when he was in the hospital with lung infection ( he was a baby), she was investigated for child abuse( Olivia was saving her kid from getting hit by a taxi) & now this.
@@AngelicMistyStorm Okay.. but its your fault for clicking on it. In case you didn't notice I'm not the only person who said that. But I actually gave a warning.
LegitAllyson oh weird cuz I don’t see it unless I click on Read More. I purposely inserted multiple ticks so people couldn’t see it unless you click on it.
dolphinsflirty yea but on some people’s devices it’s different... I just finished the episode where liv got Noah home safe.. I really hope liv adopts another baby
If only Shelia could have held on to this. It would have taken time, all good things do, but if she just held on to the small progress than she could have been an amazing grandmother to Noah...I get the pain she felt, her husband made her turn her back on her daughter and than they both died. She was alone, the only family she had was adopted out probably before she even knew about him (I only got to see this episode from youtube clips, so not sure if she knew before her daughters death or before the adoption). She never got over it, what parent could? She needed help, proper help for her mental state and further support that she didn't get or try to...In the end, her own actions cost her the only family she had left. She had no one to blame for the but herself. She put her grandson in danger, she was just lucky with how Olivia handled it.
This doesn't make sense. Ellie said she was bounced from foster home to foster home. That was the main reason my Olivia took Noah in the first place. Who changed this story up?
Jessy Grover I think when she said her husband said they needed to let her go is when she started foster care, and than got bumped around in it? But idk for sure xP
I know thie r doing this for the drama but if this lady tries to take Noah from luv she would be taking him from all he had ever known and that would be wrong
@@sarahreese6156 before he was kidnapped that was when Sheila & Noah went coat shopping at the mall & the SVU team finally found the cabin & brought him home. Sheila was arrested for kidnapping
Is the actress who plays Sheila related to Mariska in any way? Their resemblance is honestly uncanny, from the facial features to the tone of their voice, even their mannerisms and line delivery are incredibly similar.
No they are not related. They are a year apart. the actress who played Sheila is Brooke Shields. Mariska is older . Mariska was born in 1964 & Brooke was born in 1965
I hated the fact that they made Sheila character kidnap Noah but in real life i think any grandmother would. If your husband u listened to and maybe had to cause never knew if he was controlling and then u found out your daughter died and your only blood was adopted when u was never notified and u was a good person u think any human would unless yes u got close to that person and they became family and she like liv did let u be the true grandma u was but liv did make her feel like she was the enemy which maybe if it was under certain circumstances it would of been different. Liv never had a family bond or closeness except elliot which he left but she just didn't know how to identify with it. They should of kept her in and never had her kidnap him cause it would of been good for liv to have someone to lean on as family. I know I went everywhere with this comment it was more as to if u was Sheila and seen your grandson and could of had him if the courts knew would u of been okay with not having him after all your blood and family died. I just wouldn't know unless in that situation.
I like the line of "I Don't Wanna Be Your Enemy". This episode is similar related to my family. One of my older bros Stacey & his girlfriend Amy. Both have problems with partying of alcohol & drugs. But they had a on & off relationship..there were times thought that my parents & me. They would change. Then when they told us, that their gonna be parents. It brought us joy, then later 2 months after my nephew "Noble" was born. Before Christmas Stacey & Amy were happy to see their son in their arms. But now, let's say Amy has some trouble with law. Stacy has issues as well. Social services took Noble away, due suspensions of neglect. On which weren't true & facts got mistakenly. Now my nephew is now 2 yrs old. Living with amy gma. Amy is doin 8 months in jail & Stacy is tryin to stay straight & sober. Now both families are in a process same as Olivia. Letting both families visitation & bein part of Noble life. In hope & pray we have a bright future of being part of my nephew future as well his parents do the same. Only we can hope & move forward.
i hated the fact that they made her kidnap him. i wanted liv to have a family, and i also really love brooke shields so it was sad to see her gone so soon lol
I don't like how most special star pop up on the show is the bad person or how on one show the special guest star is good one minute and bad the next episode just crazy
Yes. Because Sheila was the one who kidnapped him along with her gardener Juan. Olivia eventually found Sheila & Noah in a cabin. Amanda & Sonny Carisi confronted Juan daughter Maria first then him. Olivia would never hurt Noah.
Before she kidnapped Noah. Sheila never knew about Noah when Olivia adopted him. When the squad tried to find Noah living relatives they couldn’t find anyone so Judge Linden ask Olivia did she want to adopt Noah as her son. There wasn’t a background check. There was a home inspection which the caseworker approved
I don't wanna be your or her enemy 😢😮 says the person who kidnapped him the boy and put a gun to her face 👀😈 lmaoo 🤣😅😁🤗 I know I'm being sarcastic but it's really not funny in the long run in reality I guess.
I'm just talking sht. . I'm Godly sure. you would be a good Mother. . Please enjoy my seed. it let it enrich uour life and your family. . . Blessings... ...
If i fostered or adopted a child id let the parents see him because its the right thing to do if you stop parents or a parent from seeing a child the parent or child would become worried or distressed
Tereas Downes ik I’m late but if u adopt a kid, that’s your kid, and sometimes some children especially rlly small ones will get confused and aren’t fully capable of grasping the situation and it’ll be too much.
Okay first avole if u haven’t seen the part where Sheila tried to kidnapped Noah u would get why now olivia isn’t going to let the grandma see Noah idiot
@Lanaforeva technically Olivia can because Noah is Olivia child. She raised him as her own. Sheila never knew about having a grandson because Ellie told the team that both of her parents were dead. As a mother Olivia make the decisions who will be in her & her son life . Sheila waited 5 years to come to New York to see if she can overturn the adoption & Judge Linden dismissed it . That’s why when Sheila asked Olivia could she take Noah to the mall to try on coats. Sheila gardener Took Noah & The team discovered the Sheila was behind the whole thing. Sheila was caught & arrested. Noah & his mother was reunited.
It’s heartbreaking when there’s really no “bad guy” in situations like these. Just messed up people trying to figure things out and end up hurting each other along the way. It’s easier when there’s one clear person to place the blame on.
Please dont take Noah away from Olivia. She is the only mother he has known his life. I love watching the benoah scenes.
Brooke Shields looks amazing for her age! She sounds a lot like Liv and her pauses and speech are a lot like Liv's too!
Richard Hutchison law order svu
Are they the same age
Mariska is a year and bit older than Brooke.
The two ladies are good friends off screen so it makes sense they have great chemistry. They are both talented actresses as well.
Which episode and season
this is so sad watching back because they could have been such a great family 😥
Liv didn't trust her from the jump. But she didn't want to stop Noah from meeting his actual family. Her guard is always up and she knows she's right most of the time, due to her occupation of being in law enforcement. But damn, she didn't expect the Grandmother to stoop so low.
Exactly. Why wait til now to gain custody of Noah. Noah doesn’t know this lady( Grandma Sheila) now she wants to fight custody of him she waited all these years because it’s a reason that Ellie lied about her parents being dead. Glad that Judge Linden didn’t granted the adoption to Sheila. Olivia almost had Noah taken from her when he was in the hospital with lung infection ( he was a baby), she was investigated for child abuse( Olivia was saving her kid from getting hit by a taxi) & now this.
It said in the episode that Sheila didn’t know about Noah until cps investigation that said, I didn’t trust her from the beginning
Olivia benson, I cried during this video because it warmed my heart into what love truly is! It’s not fake, it’s real
SPOILER ALERT:
-
-
-
-
-
-
She kidnaps him
dolphinsflirty Gee Thanks. 😡
@@AngelicMistyStorm Okay.. but its your fault for clicking on it. In case you didn't notice I'm not the only person who said that. But I actually gave a warning.
dolphinsflirty yea but mine showed the whole thing on some people devices in shows the whole text...
LegitAllyson oh weird cuz I don’t see it unless I click on Read More. I purposely inserted multiple ticks so people couldn’t see it unless you click on it.
dolphinsflirty yea but on some people’s devices it’s different... I just finished the episode where liv got Noah home safe.. I really hope liv adopts another baby
Mariska, great performance! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Ugh! I understand a grandmother's pain of not knowing her grandson & understand the pain of a mother whose adopted a child.
I don't trust Shiela....Olivia ought not to trust her either
Jordan Cooper megeygyhejs
Jordan Cooper has been
2 years later and you were right!
Well it's because Noah is unhappy with Olivia.
@@shahidulkhan9566 lies!
If only Shelia could have held on to this. It would have taken time, all good things do, but if she just held on to the small progress than she could have been an amazing grandmother to Noah...I get the pain she felt, her husband made her turn her back on her daughter and than they both died. She was alone, the only family she had was adopted out probably before she even knew about him (I only got to see this episode from youtube clips, so not sure if she knew before her daughters death or before the adoption). She never got over it, what parent could? She needed help, proper help for her mental state and further support that she didn't get or try to...In the end, her own actions cost her the only family she had left. She had no one to blame for the but herself. She put her grandson in danger, she was just lucky with how Olivia handled it.
Noah really does bring the sweetness of benson...they're the perfect match
Agreed. I was happy when Judge Linden gave custody of Noah to Olivia. Despite Olivia job she’s trying to be there for her son
I’m still sad they made her crazy:/ They don’t do co-parenting well on this show 😆😅
But she'd experienced so much sadness & loss, it just pushed her too far. That happens when people lose loved ones.
I'm waiting for Noah's half brother's family to end up crazy, ha!
@@psymompahope that doesn’t happen.
The feels coming from this moment
That lady on the left changed my life and it will alway be better cause of her being a love. Thank you SVu
This doesn't make sense. Ellie said she was bounced from foster home to foster home. That was the main reason my Olivia took Noah in the first place. Who changed this story up?
Jessy Grover girl could have lied
Jessy Grover I think when she said her husband said they needed to let her go is when she started foster care, and than got bumped around in it? But idk for sure xP
I think Ellie lied.
I remember that. She could have lied or the writers can’t bother to be consistent.
Girl must of lied
I know thie r doing this for the drama but if this lady tries to take Noah from luv she would be taking him from all he had ever known and that would be wrong
Liv* yes it would be wrong because Noah knows Olivia his whole life
She’s scandalous my instinct tells me.
I really wish that They didn’t make her crazy and make her a main character that would have been awesome
This makes me nervous 😬
I never trusted Sheila at all and when she kidnapped Noah I was like I knew something was off with her.
Was this after she kidnapped Noah?
@@sarahreese6156 I'm not sure it's been so long I'm sorry
It was before
@@sarahreese6156 before he was kidnapped that was when Sheila & Noah went coat shopping at the mall & the SVU team finally found the cabin & brought him home. Sheila was arrested for kidnapping
Noah is so precious
He sure is. Even when he was a baby & toddler. I love Olivia with her son
Arse
Is the actress who plays Sheila related to Mariska in any way? Their resemblance is honestly uncanny, from the facial features to the tone of their voice, even their mannerisms and line delivery are incredibly similar.
No they are not related. They are a year apart. the actress who played Sheila is Brooke Shields. Mariska is older . Mariska was born in 1964 & Brooke was born in 1965
This is a good show
If Sheila had of did what she did to Olivia to me ,she will not be around me or my child , because I wouldn't trust her with nothing .
Sheila was eventually caught & arrested for kidnapping Noah. I hope that Olivia won’t let Sheila around Noah for a long time.
What if Noah was like, " I hate books." *whispers to Liv*
First of all the first meeting would be in a public place!!
Am so glad am black I love broke shield but damn she aged with make up on .. we age like fine wine. She good actor though.
I hated the fact that they made Sheila character kidnap Noah but in real life i think any grandmother would. If your husband u listened to and maybe had to cause never knew if he was controlling and then u found out your daughter died and your only blood was adopted when u was never notified and u was a good person u think any human would unless yes u got close to that person and they became family and she like liv did let u be the true grandma u was but liv did make her feel like she was the enemy which maybe if it was under certain circumstances it would of been different. Liv never had a family bond or closeness except elliot which he left but she just didn't know how to identify with it. They should of kept her in and never had her kidnap him cause it would of been good for liv to have someone to lean on as family. I know I went everywhere with this comment it was more as to if u was Sheila and seen your grandson and could of had him if the courts knew would u of been okay with not having him after all your blood and family died. I just wouldn't know unless in that situation.
I like the line of "I Don't Wanna Be Your Enemy". This episode is similar related to my family. One of my older bros Stacey & his girlfriend Amy. Both have problems with partying of alcohol & drugs. But they had a on & off relationship..there were times thought that my parents & me. They would change. Then when they told us, that their gonna be parents. It brought us joy, then later 2 months after my nephew "Noble" was born. Before Christmas Stacey & Amy were happy to see their son in their arms. But now, let's say Amy has some trouble with law. Stacy has issues as well. Social services took Noble away, due suspensions of neglect. On which weren't true & facts got mistakenly. Now my nephew is now 2 yrs old. Living with amy gma.
Amy is doin 8 months in jail & Stacy is tryin to stay straight & sober. Now both families are in a process same as Olivia. Letting both families visitation & bein part of Noble life. In hope & pray we have a bright future of being part of my nephew future as well his parents do the same.
Only we can hope & move forward.
i hated the fact that they made her kidnap him. i wanted liv to have a family, and i also really love brooke shields so it was sad to see her gone so soon lol
I love Olivia Benson and Noah Hargitay they are both very beautiful ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Noah last name is Benson on the show. Hargitay is Mariska last name.
Omg, poor Liv😪
Will Serrano- No there is!😏
Omg, American sweetheart River Fields!!!!!!
What we finally find out is that Brooke tries to steal Noah.
If you're going to funerals for work I got nothing to say.
.
I don't like how most special star pop up on the show is the bad person or how on one show the special guest star is good one minute and bad the next episode just crazy
OLIVIA SHOULD PLAY THE ELLIOTT CARD SHEILA SKS BROOKE SHIELD HOME WRECKES
OLIVIA EILYL OWN IT N ROCK IT .
BROOKE SHILED IS AND GOOD ACTRESS '😊
Brooke Shields is one year younger than Mariska Hargitay, but is playing the grandmother. Seems odd.
Cuz Noah's biological mother was like 16.
wait.. seriously 😲
Boy, Brooke got old. She's come a long way from her Blue Lagoon days.
Olivia loves Noah Porter Benson
Definitely
What episode and season is this
Season 19 episode 3 "Contrapasso"
Babez!
Lana parrilla Love e fã 800 1 2018 de vocês e gay e paixão lana parrilla e mamãe de paixão amor 😭😭😭👭👭👭😍😍😍👑👑💋💋💋💖💖
Did this take place after Sheila tried to threaten Olivia with a gun?
Yes. Because Sheila was the one who kidnapped him along with her gardener Juan. Olivia eventually found Sheila & Noah in a cabin. Amanda & Sonny Carisi confronted Juan daughter Maria first then him. Olivia would never hurt Noah.
Can somebody please tell me what season and episode this is
Season 19 early in the season. Not sure of the exact episode, sorry.
@@mckayleem3098 Thank you
@@breezybriannarose7987 np
The episode is Contrapasso
Isn’t she Ryan really grandma
Not in real life. Brooke Shields isnt
#Oliviaisjealous
Brooke Shields, A grandmother!?
Yes.
Is this before or after she kidnapped Noah??
Before she kidnapped Noah. Sheila never knew about Noah when Olivia adopted him. When the squad tried to find Noah living relatives they couldn’t find anyone so Judge Linden ask Olivia did she want to adopt Noah as her son. There wasn’t a background check. There was a home inspection which the caseworker approved
Que episodio es
Season 19 episode Contrapasso
I don't wanna be your or her enemy 😢😮 says the person who kidnapped him the boy and put a gun to her face 👀😈 lmaoo 🤣😅😁🤗 I know I'm being sarcastic but it's really not funny in the long run in reality I guess.
I'm just talking sht.
.
I'm Godly sure.
you would be a good Mother.
.
Please enjoy my seed.
it let it enrich uour life and your family.
.
. Blessings... ...
Olivia shouldn't keep Noah from her.
If i fostered or adopted a child id let the parents see him because its the right thing to do if you stop parents or a parent from seeing a child the parent or child would become worried or distressed
Tereas Downes ik I’m late but if u adopt a kid, that’s your kid, and sometimes some children especially rlly small ones will get confused and aren’t fully capable of grasping the situation and it’ll be too much.
Okay first avole if u haven’t seen the part where Sheila tried to kidnapped Noah u would get why now olivia isn’t going to let the grandma see Noah idiot
@Lanaforeva technically Olivia can because Noah is Olivia child. She raised him as her own. Sheila never knew about having a grandson because Ellie told the team that both of her parents were dead. As a mother Olivia make the decisions who will be in her & her son life . Sheila waited 5 years to come to New York to see if she can overturn the adoption & Judge Linden dismissed it . That’s why when Sheila asked Olivia could she take Noah to the mall to try on coats. Sheila gardener Took Noah & The team discovered the Sheila was behind the whole thing. Sheila was caught & arrested. Noah & his mother was reunited.