Hamas actually intended to take hostages in order to exchange them with their people held hostage in Izraeli prison. However Izrael aware of the operation activated their Hannibal Directive which resulted in the casualties and then inflated the numbers. Footage broadcast by Izraeli Channel 12 shows an Izraeli tank firing a shell within Kibbutz Be'eri on 7 October. This corresponds with the testimony of Erez Tidhar, an Izraeli military veteran, who recalled a bewildering incident at Kibbutz Be'eri, where an Izraeli Apache helicopter was seen firing missiles into the kibbutz. His account details the chaos and confusion among residents, with sightings of tanks driving through and firing into houses. A report on Haaretz mentioned that an Izraeli helicopter was in that area on that specific day. And then the testimony of Yasmin Porat, an Izraeli settler who complained that IDF was shooting indiscriminately at anything that was moving and in the process klled their own people. An Izraeli Colonel named Nof Erez termed the Izraeli army's response to the events of October 7 as a mass Hannibal.
Meanwhile israel kills women and children, america and uk support them by sending bombs and troops... the western world keeps quiet and the story continues. As long as Israel exists in this Nazi ideology about the Palestinians there will be no peace in the WORLD
Please don't cover up for Hamas with wild story. A doctor wrote what happened in kibbut on istagram when she personally went to Kibbut and saw the inhumane atrocities by Hamas and straightaway pro- Hamas commentators denied such things ever happened as if they were there.
SLOWLY BUT SURELY THE TRUTH IS COMING TO LIGHT, IT HAS NOW BEEN REPORTED THAT 20% OF THEIR CASUALTIES WAS CAUSED BY "FRIENDLY FIRE" AND THIS GUY IS SMILING AS HE TELLS HIS VERSION OF THIS TRAGEDY 👎👎👎👎 PRO PA GANDA KEEPS ON FALLING
He can still smile despite of his orders to killed civilians?? He ordered the tank to shoot the blocks!!!! He said he found 8 kids tied together, killed cold blood... Who killed them?? The tank.... Not the HAMAS... His order killed them. He is such a coward... He was so scared, and he asked the tank to shoot everywhere... He never negotiated... He just said... SHOOT...
The IDF are the biggest cowards in the region because they hide behind artillery, sniper attacks, tanks and the airiel bombing of innocent women, children and men.
They lie just about everything. The hostage called Lipshitz who was thanking hamas for the kind treatment at her realease now released a video contradicting her first testimony. She now blames hamas for the unbearable treatment. They say she was drugged and intimidated to say good things about their captors. The truth is she was very well aware at her senses you could see it on the footage and she had nothing to fear of when the footage was made since she was already at home surrounded by her family . I hope people will get a glimpse of how the tribal hivemind is working in action.
@@mickeyoshea2035 Ach man , nobody believes iof /idf whatever their name is , they are known liars from incipience . The all of msm in on zion/ imperialists hands all the more reason never to trust US and their allies . F all of them 😡
You noticed it too? I saw the interview of a woman who survived the tank incident, and she gave some horrific details, it was the 2 tanks shells that killed everyone inside along with the HAMAS fighters and the tank was using a type of shell that burnt everything, a type of munition provided by US few days before Oct 7th. She went quiet, I hope she is safe. It feels like US is connected with the incident of Oct 7th. A Israeli official had a slip of tongue and said IDF is fighting on behalf of US, why?
Yes. Many of us here understand, but this clip will be used and interpreted as if it's not one big lie even while he smiles with duper's delight. He is amused by his lies.
"From 2008 until 6 October 2023, 1,434 Palestinian children were reportedly killed, with an additional 32,175 sustaining injuries, primarily at the hands of Israeli occupation forces. Of these, 1,025 children were killed in Gaza alone, since the unlawful blockade began in 2007." - UN Human Rights, ‘Unchilded’ from birth: UN expert calls for decisive protection of Palestinian children under Israeli rule, 24 October 2023
OOOOHHHH terrible, how about Yemen, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan, or any of the countries where those number are a joke. The UN should do something about them.
@@jackodknight Firstly, thats JUST kids 17 and younger. Secondly, it's a lot when 🇮🇱 keeps lying that they've been out of Gaza since 2005- it shows how much they don't respect the two-state solution of sovereignty (not to mention the air, land, and sea besiegement).
Since there leaders n terrorist are cowards who cannot defend their citizens why are they always d first to provoke those who are in every way more powerful than them,isn't dz the case of an arrogant wild dog biting a sleeping lion expecting d lion to spare it bcos it is a noisy cowardly dog😅
@@WanderingExistence if they hadn't left then Hamas and others wouldn't have been shooting rockets at Israel since 2005. They go back every time to stop being shot at. Not only did they leave they took all the Israelis with them. You claim it's lies, but there is documentation they left, recordings and very pissed off people that were forced to leave. What you dont have is any evidence they didn't leave, just that they keep going back to stop being attacked.
Israeli news is not showing to it population about the Killings in Gaza, they are showing them how they are avoiding bombing kids in a football field. There is not much left of Gaza, and they are still lying to their own population. This is beyond evil.
*_Under international law Gaza is still considered occupied since 2005, and has been since 1967, since Israel still has not transferred sovereign powers, and instead maintains control over the Palestinian Authority’s ability to function effectively. Examples: water and electricity, airspace, supply of civilian infrastructure, etc..._*
Gaza needs the Israeli people there to feed, water, clothe, and protect the palestinians from themselves. The palestinians are incapable of doing much for themselves, so they need caretakers.
@GCKLXIX, Gee, tiny bit of Zionist racism at work... I have seen photos and videos of the time before Zionist OCC began in the '30s, and there was industrial growth, train lines, theatres, university, and bustling harbors. And, for hundreds of years before the Zionist terrorists came, Jews Christians and Muslims got along, even without a bunch of self-righteous Zionists showed up. Fact is, Izrael* limits the food, water electricity and fuel to Gaza.
Israel only provides for 10% of their water and power, they have their owns means. They also have this sovereign power.... What are they called, Oh ya HAMAS. Which was voted into power by the citizens of the state made independent. If independence was so important to them, they would have used the millions in aid to make something and not tunnels. When someone digs themselves a hole and then it is sad they are in a hole it sucks to be them, but they dug the hole. I do not know about you, but most people stop sinking money into a losing team. As far as international law? It seems to only apply when it suits those who are anti Israel.
Yeah. Such a shame that palestine voted in a terrorist group to govern them. None of this would have happened if they hadn't decided to murder innocent civilians.
What’s up with the smirk, so weird. No one who’s actually been in horrid combat situations smirks when they talk about it. It’s usually a blank stare coupled with indirect eye contact.
Everyone who died at Be'eri did so by this monster's order. In the complex that Yasmin Porat escaped from, she gave detailed information about the positions of everyone still inside - Palestinian and Israhelli. Her captor, who negotiated his surrender gave the same information. The army sat on the information for hours, then fired tank shells to destroy every living thing. There was no commando operation in that complex. Where there were commando operations in the kibbutzim, we have testimony from an airforce commander that many of these special forces were "tragically" killed by helicopter gunners who weren't notified and took it upon themselves to lay waste to the buildings.
He laughs like an idiot in the beginning while proudly saying I authorized the tank to shell the buildings, then he was asked did u expect to find any hostages alive? He stuttered and said there weren20 and we saved 4. The rest murdered by Hgroup. .... WHAT????? HE JUST SAID HE AUTHORIZED TANK SHELLING INTO BUILDINGS FULL OF HOSTAGES AMD HGROUP THEN BLAMED ALL THE DEAD ON HGROUP??? IS THIS HOW THEY REALLY MENTALLY IGNORE THEIR ACTIONS??
Aha. And had the terrorists not tied them up and put them in the building, using them as human shields, would they have used any form of force at all? Hamas wanted a war. Now they have it. F around and find out. All of you supporters are bleating like little lambs but are, in fact, wolves in disguise. You have and are being exposed for who and what you are.
@mansman2167 you my friend have it the wrong way around. Hamas is the cancer, Israel the highly skilled surgeon. You will find this is true, not only as a metaphor, but in real life too.
@@GCKLXIX By your analogy, Israel is a lousy surgeon. Decades of disproportionate killing and Hamas is still here. Boy, you guys suck. Israel has been oppressing Palestinians long before Hamas existed. It still does so in places where Hamas does not exist: West Bank. Your own analogy works against you. Try again. Hamas is the response to that oppression. Time to stop drinking the kool-aid, son.
@@GCKLXIX Your highly skilled surgeon seems to do surgery by completely destroying the host and using power tools not surgical instruments. Genocide simp identified.
Nope. He uses an expression "clearing" - which is the term that military and police shout when the area is secured and free from danger. Lost in Translation.
And awfully large amount of IOF - and before it existed zionist militias - like to name their operations around the concept of purity, sifting chaff, etc. All codewords for ethnic cleansing.
@plurabelle5 The flags and anthems rotate....the flat Earth knuckledragging territorial bestial resistance to planetary humanity and its rights remain constant behind the shifting masks.
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein @plurabelle5
this piece must be re edited with a narration of the actual events. too many people need to see this that don’t know the story. there are people in the US who need the truth so we can save ourselves and others in the world who suffer the ramifications of what our name is on. help us. FBA1
@@spaceman9599 And there is one main culprit who gives them this "Power" AKA a free pass and billions worth of peoples tax money worth of weapons and Turns a blind eye.. U.S. and its minion.
I hope people will understand and not jump on me when I say that for some it may be a coping mechanism. I recently watched a documentary on YT- I think it was called, Women In The IDF; it centred mostly on the experiences of 3 female soldiers. I was irritated and shocked by one who was recounting her killing an 8 year old Palestinian boy. She said that she would call friends and say, “I still can’t wash the blood off” well after the event, but the whole time, from beginning to end, she laughed and smiled incessantly. She was clearly traumatised and not functioning mentally. I think the smirk, smile and laughter was her just trying to get by. The more uncomfortable she was with direction of the interview, the more apparent her inappropriate responses and behaviour was. She was child like, not unlike this man in part. I can’t say the same for this man but it’s a possibility that he too is coping in his own way or he may just be revolting. Either way, it’s worth searching for the documentary.
@@sho-na The plan operates on two essential premises. To survive, Israel must 1) become an imperial regional power, and 2) must effect the division of the whole area into small states by the dissolution of all existing Arab states. Small here will depend on the ethnic or sectarian composition of each state. Consequently, the Zionist hope is that sectarian-based states become Israel's satellites and, ironically, its source of moral legitimation. 3 This is not a new idea, nor does it surface for the first time in Zionist strategic thinking. Indeed, fragmenting all Arab states into smaller units has been a recurrent theme. This theme has been documented on a very modest scale in the AAUG publication, Israel's Sacred Terrorism (1980), by Livia Rokach. Based on the memoirs of Moshe Sharett, former Prime Minister of Israel, Rokach's study documents, in convincing detail, the Zionist plan as it applies to Lebanon and as it was prepared in the mid-fifties. 4 The first massive Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1978 bore this plan out to the minutest detail. The second and more barbaric and encompassing Israeli invasion of Lebanon on June 6, 1982, aims to effect certain parts of this plan which hopes to see not only Lebanon, but Syria and Jordan as well, in fragments. This ought to make mockery of Israeli public claims regarding their desire for a strong and independent Lebanese central government. More accurately, they want a Lebanese central government that sanctions their regional imperialist designs by signing a peace treaty with them. They also seek acquiescence in their designs by the Syrian, Iraqi, Jordanian and other Arab governments as well as by the Palestinian people. What they want and what they are planning for is not an Arab world, but a world of Arab fragments that is ready to succumb to Israeli hegemony. Hence, Oded Yinon in his essay, "A Strategy for Israel in the 1980's," talks about "farreaching opportunities for the first time since 1967" that are created by the "very stormy situation [that] surrounds Israel."
A Hebrew-language Haaretz article published on 20 October paints a very different story of what went down in Be’eri that day. A Kibbutz resident who had been away from his home - whose partner was killed in the melee - reveals stunning new details: “His voice trembles when his partner, who was besieged in her home shelter at the time, comes to mind. According to him, only on Monday night (9 October) and only after the commanders in the field made difficult decisions - including shelling houses with all their occupants inside in order to eliminate the terrorists along with the hostages - did the IDF complete the takeover of the kibbutz. The price was terrible: at least 112 Be’eri people were killed. Others were kidnapped. Yesterday, 11 days after the massacre, the bodies of a mother and her son were discovered in one of the destroyed houses. It is believed that more bodies are still lying in the rubble.”
What happened was that one of the fighters came out with a woman and surrendered. They told the IDF there were about 40 fighters and 20 civilians inside. The fighter tried to get his comrades to surrender as well. The fighters refused and instead tried to negotiate a return to Gaza. Rather than save the hostages Israel opened fire with tanks and machine guns for hours and killed almost everyone inside. The few survivors say there were no executions everyone was killed in the crossfire with the IDF troops.
I still find the idea of Hamas operatives surrendering or negotiating for surrender, instead of withdrawing, where elsewhere they came in, defeated the military, took hostages, and left far before this point in the day, before there was any coordinated IOF response. I suspect that the Palestinians here were not Hamas, but smaller/less well-trained militias, or other actors, possibly even those shocked by the lack of defence and keen on inflicting some revenge for their own 18 years+ of trauma, lost family members etc.
@@spaceman9599 I didn't think of that. But that particular group as described by the survivors seems to have not been as well trained as the al-Qasam fighters from other videos. She was like one of them just up and surrendered. The others had plenty of time to walk back into Gaza but froze up and stayed in the Kibbutz. The fighters out numbered the IDF but didn't try to fight their way out.
I heard one of the hostage survivors interviewed.... here acount was somewhat different. She says the battle went on for several hours and many hostages were in the crossfire - no way to tell who was hit by IDF or HAmas fire. She said the tank was finally used to fire two shots at close range which killed all remaing Hamas.
It's Hannibal Protocol which leads to killing everyone especially the hostages to avoid being under pressure for negotiation. Shalit spent 5 years in Gaza and they tried many times to kill him to avoid negotiations and prisoner trade. The fact that in 79 days they put 4000 new Prisoners on the Jails from the West Bank shows why Hamas is taking hostages. If U take every day tens of their people to the Jail just because he shared his country flag and considering it as an act of terrorism with 5 or 10 years condemnation it doesn't mean U will not have a reaction. Sure people will react and revolt.
He laughs like an idiot in the beginning while proudly saying I authorized the tank to shell the buildings, then he was asked did u expect to find any hostages alive? He stuttered and said there weren20 and we saved 4. The rest murdered by Hgroup. .... WHAT????? HE JUST SAID HE AUTHORIZED TANK SHELLING INTO BUILDINGS FULL OF HOSTAGES AMD HGROUP THEN BLAMED ALL THE DEAD ON HGROUP??? IS THIS HOW THEY REALLY MENTALLY IGNORE THEIR ACTIONS??
/df had the fire power that burns bodies and it makes a certain part above your shoulders explode H@mas didn’t have that kind of military equipment that had those capabilities so stop being in denial about the truth regardless of how ugly the reality is.
I wonder if the IDF has a simple count of rounds fired? Is there any report on what of type of rounds that killed who? Is there any explanation of why the IDF waited for hours, even after a delayed response?
his life does depend on it if the israelis find out that all 1200 killed on the 7th oct were killed by the idf...him and bibi would have nowhere to hide
After many hours of IDF related footage I can confidently state that I’ve found the inconsistencies; Pay close attention to his mouth, when he speaks the lies start.
@@ЗухраЧанышева-у4о No. I figured it out after reading comments this morning -- I was on a 24h comment-ban for saying "STFU, Z***ist" to a Hasbarazzo, so I couldn't reply -- but it's actually the soldat in shock at the acting OF THE REPORTER! He knows his job is to go lie his ass off, and he does a typically lazy job, but the "journalist" gives a Daytime Emmy-winning performance in response to this loser's unenthusiastic delivery of his script. It's like he's a porn star giving an interview to Barbara Walters, and she's hanging on his every word...
WHERE ARE THE HOSTAGES! IDF have failed to care about their safety and rescuing them. This war is about land grabbing and Netanyahu’s political career and civilians are the target! Netanyahu never cared about the hostages and cease fire is not In the best interest of Netanyahu career and he wants the Genocide to continue.
It was strange to me at first to see him smile while talking about the incident, then I realised, he smiled after seeing the interviewees acceptance of his narrative. This makes me think if what he conveyed is really true?
Duper's delight is very commonly seen when interviewing a sociopath -- like this guy. On a completely unrelated note 🙄, I'll add that this guy seems pretty young and green to be a Brigadier General in the IDF. I'm guessing he got his quick promotions by following the company line scrupulously -- and having some idea of the IDF company line, I'd say that confirms my suspicion that he's a sociopath.
but Israel say that they are a democracy so they have to be believed becase democracies dont lie. democracy is the perfect religeon that purifies people from doing any wrong and never lie. they only get vitimized.
Oh, yes, if Electronic Intifada says the officer lies then no need to demand any proof he actually lies. The Electronic Intifada always says truth and never lies, right? )))
There was no misrake. They knew there were Israelis back there. They seized the chance to get rid of Palestinians in Gaza and expand settlements in Gaza faster.
Ok, but what are the evidence we have that what he's claiming here is false? They do admit they used tanks, but if Hamas fighters fired at them, then they didn't have a choice but to fire back even at the expense of civilian deaths.
If you think about it, something doesn't add up. They say hamas wants to kill all jew, but they're taking hostages. My theory is, those who stay with the hostages tries to force negotiations right then and there. And IDF didn't care about their civilian. Secondly, they didn't respond to the attack for hours. Even from the reports at the Nova music fest, Hamas were burnt together with Israeli which i presumed to be taken as hostage. They revised the death from 1400 to 1200. If you add the math, a ratio of 1:1 means 200 hamas killed along with 200 Israeli. Even half of that isn't comprehensible, 100 Israeli death for 200 hamas. And thirdly, it is evident they will kill on sight. We have 3 Israeli killed, unarmed and and with white flag, asking for help in hebrew and still were shot. It is obvious they have a different objectives. Instead of negotiating for hostages, they kill on sight. Why? Because it is an easier strategy to carry out.
This soldier smiling throughout the entire interview. Same reaction when the Israeli veterans were interviewed in Tantura. A documentary by Alon Schwarz. 2022 ua-cam.com/video/sWka3LDmsIk/v-deo.htmlsi=WfGHaVyDQVVkQ777
Hamas actually intended to take hostages in order to exchange them with their people held hostage in Izraeli prison. However Izrael aware of the operation activated their Hannibal Directive which resulted in the casualties and then inflated the numbers.
Footage broadcast by Izraeli Channel 12 shows an Izraeli tank firing a shell within Kibbutz Be'eri on 7 October. This corresponds with the testimony of Erez Tidhar, an Izraeli military veteran, who recalled a bewildering incident at Kibbutz Be'eri, where an Izraeli Apache helicopter was seen firing missiles into the kibbutz. His account details the chaos and confusion among residents, with sightings of tanks driving through and firing into houses. A report on Haaretz mentioned that an Izraeli helicopter was in that area on that specific day.
And then the testimony of Yasmin Porat, an Izraeli settler who complained that IDF was shooting indiscriminately at anything that was moving and in the process klled their own people.
An Izraeli Colonel named Nof Erez termed the Izraeli army's response to the events of October 7 as a mass Hannibal.
Meanwhile israel kills women and children, america and uk support them by sending bombs and troops... the western world keeps quiet and the story continues. As long as Israel exists in this Nazi ideology about the Palestinians there will be no peace in the WORLD
Please don't cover up for Hamas with wild story. A doctor wrote what happened in kibbut on istagram when she personally went to Kibbut and saw the inhumane atrocities by Hamas and straightaway pro- Hamas commentators denied such things ever happened as if they were there.
This smacks of , Total Fkn Fake..."
Fuc Yoo & Hamas BS. .... narrative.....
🧤🕳️🌑🪰IT. HAS ALWAYS SOUNDED FAKE🧤❕📞🪰
100% spot on
SLOWLY BUT SURELY THE TRUTH IS COMING TO LIGHT, IT HAS NOW BEEN REPORTED THAT 20% OF THEIR CASUALTIES WAS CAUSED BY "FRIENDLY FIRE" AND THIS GUY IS SMILING AS HE TELLS HIS VERSION OF THIS TRAGEDY 👎👎👎👎 PRO PA GANDA KEEPS ON FALLING
Wait....an IDF terrorist is lying?? Are you sure? I'm shocked!
Why are you shocked, c'mon
@@Kittyparcel Sarcasm.
@@squatch545 👍why is it so difficult to differentiate between sarcasm and the truth nowadays🤦this is my second time,i'm sorry
@@Kittyparcelno is not difficult at all 😂😂😂
ITF not IDF
Israeli Terrorists Forces .. that’s what they been doing since its establishment.
" At this point we have to always assume Israel is lying until proven otherwise." Caitlin Johnstone.
He can still smile despite of his orders to killed civilians?? He ordered the tank to shoot the blocks!!!! He said he found 8 kids tied together, killed cold blood... Who killed them?? The tank.... Not the HAMAS... His order killed them.
He is such a coward... He was so scared, and he asked the tank to shoot everywhere... He never negotiated... He just said... SHOOT...
The IDF are the biggest cowards in the region because they hide behind artillery, sniper attacks, tanks and the airiel bombing of innocent women, children and men.
They lie just about everything. The hostage called Lipshitz who was thanking hamas for the kind treatment at her realease now released a video contradicting her first testimony. She now blames hamas for the unbearable treatment.
They say she was drugged and intimidated to say good things about their captors. The truth is she was very well aware at her senses you could see it on the footage and she had nothing to fear of when the footage was made since she was already at home surrounded by her family . I hope people will get a glimpse of how the tribal hivemind is working in action.
Lying Muslim
There are 3 replies. They don’t show. Where did they go?
@@_filifjonkan4290censored or removed by youtube
2:26 _"Unbelievable"_ indeed. I've never seen a soldier smile so much while describing atrocities.
He's a psycopathic lyer on par with world famous serial killers.
Look at his face, exactly like a child who knows he’s lying.
Exactly! That face is called "duper's delight". He is delighted by his lies and amused that his lies are believed.
@@mickeyoshea2035
Ach man , nobody believes iof /idf whatever their name is , they are known liars from incipience .
The all of msm in on zion/ imperialists hands all the more reason never to trust US and their allies . F all of them 😡
You noticed it too? I saw the interview of a woman who survived the tank incident, and she gave some horrific details, it was the 2 tanks shells that killed everyone inside along with the HAMAS fighters and the tank was using a type of shell that burnt everything, a type of munition provided by US few days before Oct 7th. She went quiet, I hope she is safe. It feels like US is connected with the incident of Oct 7th. A Israeli official had a slip of tongue and said IDF is fighting on behalf of US, why?
@@tanvirkabir4960
This is one thing I haven’t heard, although I do believe from things I’ve heard that the government knew beforehand.
@@mickeyoshea2035
Wow it has a name? That sounds more sinister.
They have to lie to themselves - otherwise they cannot uphold their state.
…. or sleep at night.
I hope EI can re-edit this interview to add the facts that the commander is contradicting.
Yes. Many of us here understand, but this clip will be used and interpreted as if it's not one big lie even while he smiles with duper's delight. He is amused by his lies.
Otherwise Im not sure what the point of this video is other than to literally be propaganda for the people it's supposedly exposing.
Yea, agreed. Some context needs to be added here.
Agreed...in the mean time can someone else add the facts here, so that others can see the contradiction by this terrorist idf
Agree. Because I need clarity at which part the soldier was lying.
"From 2008 until 6 October 2023, 1,434 Palestinian children were reportedly killed, with an additional 32,175 sustaining injuries, primarily at the hands of Israeli occupation forces. Of these, 1,025 children were killed in Gaza alone, since the unlawful blockade began in 2007." - UN Human Rights, ‘Unchilded’ from birth: UN expert calls for decisive protection of Palestinian children under Israeli rule, 24 October 2023
OOOOHHHH terrible, how about Yemen, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan, or any of the countries where those number are a joke. The UN should do something about them.
@@jackodknight Firstly, thats JUST kids 17 and younger. Secondly, it's a lot when 🇮🇱 keeps lying that they've been out of Gaza since 2005- it shows how much they don't respect the two-state solution of sovereignty (not to mention the air, land, and sea besiegement).
@@jackodknight nice try trying to discredit what's happening in palestine d1ckhead
Since there leaders n terrorist are cowards who cannot defend their citizens why are they always d first to provoke those who are in every way more powerful than them,isn't dz the case of an arrogant wild dog biting a sleeping lion expecting d lion to spare it bcos it is a noisy cowardly dog😅
@@WanderingExistence if they hadn't left then Hamas and others wouldn't have been shooting rockets at Israel since 2005. They go back every time to stop being shot at.
Not only did they leave they took all the Israelis with them. You claim it's lies, but there is documentation they left, recordings and very pissed off people that were forced to leave.
What you dont have is any evidence they didn't leave, just that they keep going back to stop being attacked.
Need an independent investigation of what happened on Oct 7th, clearly the suvivors story is at odds with the IDF.
Israel refuses
Independent Investigations never happen in Israel.
Thank you for reporting the facts to us Electronic Intifada!❤
Israeli news is not showing to it population about the Killings in Gaza, they are showing them how they are avoiding bombing kids in a football field. There is not much left of Gaza, and they are still lying to their own population. This is beyond evil.
*_Under international law Gaza is still considered occupied since 2005, and has been since 1967, since Israel still has not transferred sovereign powers, and instead maintains control over the Palestinian Authority’s ability to function effectively. Examples: water and electricity, airspace, supply of civilian infrastructure, etc..._*
Gaza needs the Israeli people there to feed, water, clothe, and protect the palestinians from themselves. The palestinians are incapable of doing much for themselves, so they need caretakers.
So are you going to call the police you rat? Snitch
@@GCKLXIX
Listen to yourself much ? What do you hear ? It’s not pretty.
@GCKLXIX,
Gee, tiny bit of Zionist racism at work... I have seen photos and videos of the time before Zionist OCC began in the '30s, and there was industrial growth, train lines, theatres, university, and bustling harbors.
And, for hundreds of years before the Zionist terrorists came, Jews Christians and Muslims got along, even without a bunch of self-righteous Zionists showed up.
Fact is, Izrael* limits the food, water electricity and fuel to Gaza.
Israel only provides for 10% of their water and power, they have their owns means. They also have this sovereign power.... What are they called, Oh ya HAMAS. Which was voted into power by the citizens of the state made independent.
If independence was so important to them, they would have used the millions in aid to make something and not tunnels. When someone digs themselves a hole and then it is sad they are in a hole it sucks to be them, but they dug the hole.
I do not know about you, but most people stop sinking money into a losing team.
As far as international law? It seems to only apply when it suits those who are anti Israel.
So now what we have is two months later with 1% of the Gaza population gone forever & 1.9 million displaced. 7,000 plus beautiful children destroyed.
Yeah. Such a shame that palestine voted in a terrorist group to govern them. None of this would have happened if they hadn't decided to murder innocent civilians.
@@GCKLXIX such a shame your parents gave birth to you
What’s up with the smirk, so weird. No one who’s actually been in horrid combat situations smirks when they talk about it. It’s usually a blank stare coupled with indirect eye contact.
thats his acting smirk...looks like he's auditionning for a part
It’s called Duper’s Delight !
@@supernova7848 Diaper delight
Please edit to put in contradicting facts for people who did not watch other interview to know which part was fabricated
Everyone who died at Be'eri did so by this monster's order.
In the complex that Yasmin Porat escaped from, she gave detailed information about the positions of everyone still inside - Palestinian and Israhelli. Her captor, who negotiated his surrender gave the same information. The army sat on the information for hours, then fired tank shells to destroy every living thing.
There was no commando operation in that complex. Where there were commando operations in the kibbutzim, we have testimony from an airforce commander that many of these special forces were "tragically" killed by helicopter gunners who weren't notified and took it upon themselves to lay waste to the buildings.
He is the pure definition of what it means to lie through your teeth.
His teeth tried to bite is tongue, his teeth evidence that he knows the truth. His teeth feared the Almighty, and the man failed his teeth.
He need a personal coaching from Mark Regev
another one in the club of the totally criminally insane
Liar are believing what they are saying, but not the rest of the world
He laughs like an idiot in the beginning while proudly saying I authorized the tank to shell the buildings, then he was asked did u expect to find any hostages alive? He stuttered and said there weren20 and we saved 4. The rest murdered by Hgroup. .... WHAT????? HE JUST SAID HE AUTHORIZED TANK SHELLING INTO BUILDINGS FULL OF HOSTAGES AMD HGROUP THEN BLAMED ALL THE DEAD ON HGROUP??? IS THIS HOW THEY REALLY MENTALLY IGNORE THEIR ACTIONS??
Aha. And had the terrorists not tied them up and put them in the building, using them as human shields, would they have used any form of force at all?
Hamas wanted a war. Now they have it. F around and find out. All of you supporters are bleating like little lambs but are, in fact, wolves in disguise. You have and are being exposed for who and what you are.
@@GCKLXIX Those terrorists are only reacting to the oppression. You blame the symptom called Hamas instead of blaming the disease called Israel.
@mansman2167 you my friend have it the wrong way around. Hamas is the cancer, Israel the highly skilled surgeon.
You will find this is true, not only as a metaphor, but in real life too.
@@GCKLXIX By your analogy, Israel is a lousy surgeon. Decades of disproportionate killing and Hamas is still here. Boy, you guys suck. Israel has been oppressing Palestinians long before Hamas existed. It still does so in places where Hamas does not exist: West Bank.
Your own analogy works against you. Try again.
Hamas is the response to that oppression.
Time to stop drinking the kool-aid, son.
@@GCKLXIX Your highly skilled surgeon seems to do surgery by completely destroying the host and using power tools not surgical instruments. Genocide simp identified.
He said hostages were found tied up & shot.. does this make sense to anyone? If they were found in that state for real, then it was by friendly fire
The expression he uses, "purifying the neighborhood", could have been said by an SS officer
Nope. He uses an expression "clearing" - which is the term that military and police shout when the area is secured and free from danger. Lost in Translation.
And awfully large amount of IOF - and before it existed zionist militias - like to name their operations around the concept of purity, sifting chaff, etc. All codewords for ethnic cleansing.
The "2000 years" thing.
Nice touch.
Like he believes the narrative.
With his pale complexion. 😂
Definitely embarrassing to watch.
😂😂
"...purifying the area..".
Says it all.
@plurabelle5 The flags and anthems rotate....the flat Earth knuckledragging territorial bestial resistance to planetary humanity and its rights remain constant behind the shifting masks.
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people." - Norman Finkelstein
@plurabelle5
The smirk - smile he has is called "duper's delight". He is pleased and amused about his lies being believed.
this piece must be re edited with a narration of the actual events. too many people need to see this that don’t know the story. there are people in the US who need the truth so we can save ourselves and others in the world who suffer the ramifications of what our name is on. help us. FBA1
This man is smirking! Despicable !
Look in that guy's eyes.
You can tell he enjoys his work.
Ever see a deer in your headlights ? He is in the spotlight now
Guilty eyes
A psychopath from a nation of psychopaths, in a psychopathic organisation of systemic unaccountability and ultimate power.
@@spaceman9599 And there is one main culprit who gives them this "Power" AKA a free pass and billions worth of peoples tax money worth of weapons and Turns a blind eye.. U.S. and its minion.
He is having to think about what he is saying, which is a bad sign.
are these people psychopaths? why is he SMILING when talking about this ? mental health issues?
Yes
Definitely
"Dupers delight " smiling while getting away with lying/ manipulating, thinking they have an upper hand
I hope people will understand and not jump on me when I say that for some it may be a coping mechanism.
I recently watched a documentary on YT- I think it was called, Women In The IDF; it centred mostly on the experiences of 3 female soldiers.
I was irritated and shocked by one who was recounting her killing an 8 year old Palestinian boy. She said that she would call friends and say, “I still can’t wash the blood off” well after the event, but the whole time, from beginning to end, she laughed and smiled incessantly. She was clearly traumatised and not functioning mentally. I think the smirk, smile and laughter was her just trying to get by. The more uncomfortable she was with direction of the interview, the more apparent her inappropriate responses and behaviour was. She was child like, not unlike this man in part.
I can’t say the same for this man but it’s a possibility that he too is coping in his own way or he may just be revolting. Either way, it’s worth searching for the documentary.
@@sho-na The plan operates on two essential premises. To survive, Israel must 1)
become an imperial regional power, and 2) must effect the division of the
whole area into small states by the dissolution of all existing Arab states.
Small here will depend on the ethnic or sectarian composition of each state.
Consequently, the Zionist hope is that sectarian-based states become Israel's
satellites and, ironically, its source of moral legitimation.
3
This is not a new idea, nor does it surface for the first time in Zionist
strategic thinking. Indeed, fragmenting all Arab states into smaller units has
been a recurrent theme. This theme has been documented on a very modest
scale in the AAUG publication, Israel's Sacred Terrorism (1980), by Livia
Rokach. Based on the memoirs of Moshe Sharett, former Prime Minister of
Israel, Rokach's study documents, in convincing detail, the Zionist plan as it
applies to Lebanon and as it was prepared in the mid-fifties.
4
The first massive Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1978 bore this plan out to
the minutest detail. The second and more barbaric and encompassing Israeli
invasion of Lebanon on June 6, 1982, aims to effect certain parts of this
plan which hopes to see not only Lebanon, but Syria and Jordan as well, in
fragments. This ought to make mockery of Israeli public claims regarding
their desire for a strong and independent Lebanese central government.
More accurately, they want a Lebanese central government that sanctions
their regional imperialist designs by signing a peace treaty with them. They
also seek acquiescence in their designs by the Syrian, Iraqi, Jordanian and
other Arab governments as well as by the Palestinian people. What they
want and what they are planning for is not an Arab world, but a world of
Arab fragments that is ready to succumb to Israeli hegemony. Hence, Oded
Yinon in his essay, "A Strategy for Israel in the 1980's," talks about "farreaching opportunities for the first time since 1967"
that are created by the "very stormy situation [that] surrounds Israel."
Cooked story. They too well to write the scripts... how about hannibal order?
'Purifying the neighbourhood' .... has a familiar ring to it.
A Hebrew-language Haaretz article published on 20 October paints a very different story of what went down in Be’eri that day. A Kibbutz resident who had been away from his home - whose partner was killed in the melee - reveals stunning new details:
“His voice trembles when his partner, who was besieged in her home shelter at the time, comes to mind. According to him, only on Monday night (9 October) and only after the commanders in the field made difficult decisions - including shelling houses with all their occupants inside in order to eliminate the terrorists along with the hostages - did the IDF complete the takeover of the kibbutz. The price was terrible: at least 112 Be’eri people were killed. Others were kidnapped. Yesterday, 11 days after the massacre, the bodies of a mother and her son were discovered in one of the destroyed houses. It is believed that more bodies are still lying in the rubble.”
Massacred by idf tanks?
The truth will come out eventually at some point. 😊
@@jamiah_alias1651yes
That smirk that says I know I'm lying, you know I'm lying, does not leave this wicked beasts gob
Tell it to the war crimes commission...
What happened was that one of the fighters came out with a woman and surrendered. They told the IDF there were about 40 fighters and 20 civilians inside. The fighter tried to get his comrades to surrender as well. The fighters refused and instead tried to negotiate a return to Gaza. Rather than save the hostages Israel opened fire with tanks and machine guns for hours and killed almost everyone inside. The few survivors say there were no executions everyone was killed in the crossfire with the IDF troops.
I still find the idea of Hamas operatives surrendering or negotiating for surrender, instead of withdrawing, where elsewhere they came in, defeated the military, took hostages, and left far before this point in the day, before there was any coordinated IOF response.
I suspect that the Palestinians here were not Hamas, but smaller/less well-trained militias, or other actors, possibly even those shocked by the lack of defence and keen on inflicting some revenge for their own 18 years+ of trauma, lost family members etc.
@@spaceman9599 I didn't think of that. But that particular group as described by the survivors seems to have not been as well trained as the al-Qasam fighters from other videos.
She was like one of them just up and surrendered. The others had plenty of time to walk back into Gaza but froze up and stayed in the Kibbutz. The fighters out numbered the IDF but didn't try to fight their way out.
@spaceman9599 you're spot on. That's exactly what happened.
@@grinningchickenyes that group were not fighters and many early videos show civilians from Gaza going through the border fence.
See the enterview with dr lerpong sayed from thailand he understands what really happen on October 7.
I heard one of the hostage survivors interviewed.... here acount was somewhat different. She says the battle went on for several hours and many hostages were in the crossfire - no way to tell who was hit by IDF or HAmas fire. She said the tank was finally used to fire two shots at close range which killed all remaing Hamas.
It's Hannibal Protocol which leads to killing everyone especially the hostages to avoid being under pressure for negotiation. Shalit spent 5 years in Gaza and they tried many times to kill him to avoid negotiations and prisoner trade. The fact that in 79 days they put 4000 new Prisoners on the Jails from the West Bank shows why Hamas is taking hostages. If U take every day tens of their people to the Jail just because he shared his country flag and considering it as an act of terrorism with 5 or 10 years condemnation it doesn't mean U will not have a reaction. Sure people will react and revolt.
He laughs like an idiot in the beginning while proudly saying I authorized the tank to shell the buildings, then he was asked did u expect to find any hostages alive? He stuttered and said there weren20 and we saved 4. The rest murdered by Hgroup. .... WHAT????? HE JUST SAID HE AUTHORIZED TANK SHELLING INTO BUILDINGS FULL OF HOSTAGES AMD HGROUP THEN BLAMED ALL THE DEAD ON HGROUP??? IS THIS HOW THEY REALLY MENTALLY IGNORE THEIR ACTIONS??
/df had the fire power that burns bodies and it makes a certain part above your shoulders explode H@mas didn’t have that kind of military equipment that had those capabilities so stop being in denial about the truth regardless of how ugly the reality is.
The smug smile of duper's delight is nauseating
Well done. Just well done for your work. The truth have no legs.
All this sadness has to Stop
He knows this interview wont go to western media
There were a total of 8 children between 12 and 16 killed at Be’eri. And in the one house seems odd
The smirk on his face speaks louder then his words 😮
truth always comes out soon or later
Him smiling the whole time seems odd to me.
I wonder if the IDF has a simple count of rounds fired?
Is there any report on what of type of rounds that killed who?
Is there any explanation of why the IDF waited for hours, even after a delayed response?
After a preliminary investigation, investigators decided that Israel killed so many Israelis that they couldn't continue investigating
That 'smile' of this soldier commander bothers me.
It bothers everyone....
Great way to live your life, in a police state with martial law. Real safe 🤪
The Israeli officer lied like his life depended on it.
his life does depend on it
if the israelis find out that all 1200 killed on the 7th oct were killed by the idf...him and bibi would have nowhere to hide
It probably does
He is a liar
comments are being deleted
After many hours of IDF related footage I can confidently state that I’ve found the inconsistencies; Pay close attention to his mouth, when he speaks the lies start.
you don't tie them up if your intension is just to delete them.
Israel was born on May .14 .1948 , died on 0ctober . 07 .2023
Rest in Peace Israel , because you couldn't live in peace .
‘Things just happen’ and the hostages were victims of who knows what. Being a hero must be a real burden for this soldier.
From the river to the sea Palestine will be free
Why does he keep smiling that idiotic toothy grin throughout the conversation?
It's when you lie and you know you won't be punished
@@ЗухраЧанышева-у4о No. I figured it out after reading comments this morning -- I was on a 24h comment-ban for saying "STFU, Z***ist" to a Hasbarazzo, so I couldn't reply -- but it's actually the soldat in shock at the acting OF THE REPORTER! He knows his job is to go lie his ass off, and he does a typically lazy job, but the "journalist" gives a Daytime Emmy-winning performance in response to this loser's unenthusiastic delivery of his script. It's like he's a porn star giving an interview to Barbara Walters, and she's hanging on his every word...
"Israeli officer lies about 7 October events in Kibbutz Be'eri." Figures. Totally figure. They tell you grass is green? Get a 2nd and 3rd opinion...
אך הם יושנים אחרי כלהשקרים האלו? אך? רובם יש להם משפחות אך היה אפשר ליבצעה כזה קישלון?
Greetings from Ireland. Having an issue when trying to subscribe, the sign in Isn't accepting my email. Is there a block internationally?
Pure evil and Psycho..
Like the holocaust witness old lady who said she indeed could see “fire flames” rising high from the concentration camps
WHERE ARE THE HOSTAGES! IDF have failed to care about their safety and rescuing them. This war is about land grabbing and Netanyahu’s political career and civilians are the target! Netanyahu never cared about the hostages and cease fire is not In the best interest of Netanyahu career and he wants the Genocide to continue.
Desperate lies as the truth is coming out
It was strange to me at first to see him smile while talking about the incident, then I realised, he smiled after seeing the interviewees acceptance of his narrative. This makes me think if what he conveyed is really true?
Wow ! Lies so fluently and shamelessly.
Activate automatic subtitles please
Smiling the whole time...
Duper's delight is very commonly seen when interviewing a sociopath -- like this guy.
On a completely unrelated note 🙄, I'll add that this guy seems pretty young and green to be a Brigadier General in the IDF. I'm guessing he got his quick promotions by following the company line scrupulously -- and having some idea of the IDF company line, I'd say that confirms my suspicion that he's a sociopath.
pampers army
He laughs when telling a horrific stories of his people? this is how you know they are compulsive liars.
Why is he smiling?
"Yes, for 2000 years we see this" 😂
They smile when they talk...as if this is a joke.
STATE OF ISLIAR
but Israel say that they are a democracy so they have to be believed becase democracies dont lie. democracy is the perfect religeon that purifies people from doing any wrong and never lie. they only get vitimized.
He,s a liar.and smiling while he lies
Israel has the right to defend itself against Israel
Israeli soldier lied? And water is wet.
Merchant of death
Is he smiling??? What's wrong with these people???
Why and where does he lie exactly?
full of shit
Oh, yes, if Electronic Intifada says the officer lies then no need to demand any proof he actually lies. The Electronic Intifada always says truth and never lies, right? )))
Can’t even listen to the tone of evil.
Well..well.well. What a ridiculous habit
There was no misrake. They knew there were Israelis back there. They seized the chance to get rid of Palestinians in Gaza and expand settlements in Gaza faster.
That smirk 😏
Ok, but what are the evidence we have that what he's claiming here is false? They do admit they used tanks, but if Hamas fighters fired at them, then they didn't have a choice but to fire back even at the expense of civilian deaths.
If you think about it, something doesn't add up. They say hamas wants to kill all jew, but they're taking hostages.
My theory is, those who stay with the hostages tries to force negotiations right then and there. And IDF didn't care about their civilian.
Secondly, they didn't respond to the attack for hours. Even from the reports at the Nova music fest, Hamas were burnt together with Israeli which i presumed to be taken as hostage. They revised the death from 1400 to 1200. If you add the math, a ratio of 1:1 means 200 hamas killed along with 200 Israeli. Even half of that isn't comprehensible, 100 Israeli death for 200 hamas.
And thirdly, it is evident they will kill on sight. We have 3 Israeli killed, unarmed and and with white flag, asking for help in hebrew and still were shot.
It is obvious they have a different objectives. Instead of negotiating for hostages, they kill on sight. Why? Because it is an easier strategy to carry out.
Where did he lie? You are not bringing any proof to contradict his testimony.
That smirk 🤢
His stories has lack of convincing effect. His eyes shows it.
"when we were purifying the neighborhood" ......... genocidal language seems so natural to them...
So you accuse him of lying but this video provides literally no evidence one way or the other.
"Unbelievable," she says. Yes, I agree. I don't believe him.
Where's the evidence of lies? A grin doesn't prove anything.
His cynical grin says it all. His prepared speech of lies was a drama act for him.
This soldier smiling throughout the entire interview. Same reaction when the Israeli veterans were interviewed in Tantura. A documentary by Alon Schwarz. 2022
ua-cam.com/video/sWka3LDmsIk/v-deo.htmlsi=WfGHaVyDQVVkQ777
...and feeling sorry for themselves, sick