My Top 10 Game Recommendations If You Love Scythe

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 жов 2024
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @DrayvinAximov
    @DrayvinAximov 3 роки тому +3

    Played Scythe for the first time this past Saturday. Came home and bought all expansions, metal coins, realistic resources and legendary box. Loved it

  • @kentofu08
    @kentofu08 3 роки тому +23

    Scythe is the first game I purchased when I was introduced to this hobby 2 years ago and it is still my favorite!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +5

      I'm honored to hear that Scythe was your first hobby game purchase!

    • @cartergreen2309
      @cartergreen2309 3 роки тому +3

      It was my first purchase too! 4 years ago. Still in my top 10!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      @@cartergreen2309 That's awesome--thanks Carter!

  • @ewa_ce
    @ewa_ce 3 роки тому +11

    I love Scythe! We have all the expansions, we are right now starting last episode of Fenris.. so great timing for this video 😂 Scythe is amazing and so diverse, gives so much possibilities of changing the game completely, never ending replayability. And so beautiful! And rules are so easy to remember, I don't have to go back to the rulebook during the game, actually I don't go back at all, it is so clear. We have played as 2 players until now, can't wait to try 4 players. And will try 2p + Automa. And modular board awaits its turn. I have never got so much into the game before - we are playing it for 5 weeks straight. Thank you Jamey for this experience!!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +2

      Thank you so much, Ewa! I'm always excited to hear when people dive deep into one of our games. :)

  • @mrp4242
    @mrp4242 3 роки тому +3

    Well, I do like Scythe, and I have found Root, Orleans, Architects of the West Kingdom and Terra Mystica to be quite fun as well, so Jamey’s on to something here.

  • @tbahr123
    @tbahr123 3 роки тому +5

    Would love to see one of these for Viticulture too!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +5

      Thanks! That's actually next on my list. :)

  • @rossjaax
    @rossjaax 2 роки тому

    Scythe is at the top of my list of favorites because of the satisfying accomplishments throughout the game with those BRA, and the tension of maintaining control of hexes and resources, and it’s high replay ability because of its asymmetry. Love this game. Thanks so much for bringing this into our lives.

  • @BillyIndiana
    @BillyIndiana 3 роки тому +3

    Scythe is terrific & I also really enjoy Architects, Tapestry & Kemet! I own Near and Far as well as Rurik, but haven't played them yet. I really want to try Dune Imperium, but I'm not allowing myself to buy more games until I get some of my other recent acquisitions played first 😉

  • @joelxenoulis-malafouri6043
    @joelxenoulis-malafouri6043 Рік тому

    I think that you have accomplished something unique with Scythe. You brought a whole world and era into life. Seriously. When i play the game i have a full feeling of the theme. Amazing job!👍

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  Рік тому +1

      Thank you so much, Joel! I give full credit to the artist and worldbuilder, Jakub Rozalski.

  • @yardene3426
    @yardene3426 2 роки тому

    All of these games are either on my Favorite Board Games list or are on top games to play. Great video! I've been wanting to play Scythe since it first came out and final got a chance to play it for the first time this year, instant Top #5 game.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому +1

      That's great! Thanks for trying Scythe. :)

  • @djbobilicious4730
    @djbobilicious4730 2 роки тому

    Scythe is my favourite game! I’m so glad you mentioned Orléans. I agree about the engine building, it’s really satisfying and efficient.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  2 роки тому

      I'm flattered to hear that! And yes, I really enjoy Orleans too. :)

  • @carlwadley1175
    @carlwadley1175 3 роки тому

    Scythe was also my first ‘modern’ board game purchase back in 2017 and it sparked a new obsession and hobby. Thanks Jamie 😃

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thanks for making Scythe your first modern board game--I'm glad it welcomed you into the hobby!

  • @Tanks.With.Teeth.Malloy
    @Tanks.With.Teeth.Malloy 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for this list. The first time I went to my FLGS, the very first game I saw on a table was Scythe and my jaw hit the floor. It was then I realized how awesome board games coule be.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thanks for sharing, Justin! It's neat that Scythe was the first game you saw at your FLGS. :)

  • @Louiismontreal
    @Louiismontreal 3 роки тому +1

    Awesome video! Scythe is my favorite boardgame! Now I want to try Clank and Tidal blades.

  • @caroljohnson3686
    @caroljohnson3686 3 роки тому

    Great list! I think that is the most games I've played from one of your lists (8), and love them all. Really great job formatting the picks to 10 different aspects of the game!

  • @AWarner1690
    @AWarner1690 3 роки тому

    Tapestry, with a few more expansions, can be one of the greatest games ever made. Glad that you brought it up beforehand!

  • @FostertheMeeple
    @FostertheMeeple 3 роки тому

    So many great recommendations! We love Scythe so it's great to know other options that have similarities! Thanks :)

  • @dylangajewski
    @dylangajewski 3 роки тому +1

    "Terra Mystica was a great inspiration for Scythe" - I haven't played Terra Mystica or Scythe, but Gaiai Project is my favourite game so that's a massive reason for me to look closer at Scythe.

  • @Jomofroyo
    @Jomofroyo 3 роки тому

    Absolutely love Near and Far and I rarely hear it mentioned in videos! Happy to see it here.. Also love Architects, both great games!

  • @gowest7797
    @gowest7797 2 роки тому

    Scythe is in my top 5 games of all time. I absolutely love the depth and additions to this game. I've extremely excited to hear what games you think I might like based on my love of Scythe.

  • @kumanight
    @kumanight 3 роки тому

    I got Scythe for christmas and my first game took over 2 hours! Such an intriguing game, I definitely need to get it to the table again

  • @sirvliam
    @sirvliam 3 роки тому +1

    Great video! I never made that connection between Scythe and Villainous (both games I love) although it seems so obvious after the fact.

  • @ludwigmises
    @ludwigmises 3 роки тому +1

    I’ve been into the hobby less than 2 years and haven’t yet tried a Stonemeier game. (But that will soon change as I preordered Red Rising!) I’ve only played light and medium-weight games so far. The asymmetry in Scythe looks intriguing.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Welcome to the hobby! I think Red Rising is a good introduction into our games--I hope you enjoy it!

    • @ClockworkWyrm
      @ClockworkWyrm 3 роки тому

      Stonemaier Games makes some of the best games both in terms of gameplay and component quality. I can't recommend their games enough to friends and family. If you end up loving Red Rising definitely check out it's inspiration, Fantasy Realms which is fantastic. Fantasy Realms is a lighter game, that plays in about 10-20 minutes, so it's a great option to introduce to your non-gaming friends and family.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      @@ClockworkWyrm Thank you!

  • @5L04d3s
    @5L04d3s 3 роки тому

    Orleans' Development track also shares similarity with Scythe's Popularity track, in the multiplying factor in end game scoring.

  • @AccordingToPlandrew
    @AccordingToPlandrew 3 роки тому

    Agree that I love playing Anachrony in a way that feels a lot like Scythe (which i also love), but not how to describe why they're similar

  • @travis2144
    @travis2144 3 роки тому

    Really great video Jamie, I love how your cat just sat attentively in the background.
    A few games that I really haven't considered.

  • @Alithia451
    @Alithia451 3 роки тому

    I remember backing Scythe when it came out on KS. Mainly bc of the setting and artstyle.

  • @lenakimarctaedius3056
    @lenakimarctaedius3056 3 роки тому

    i really enjoy scythe. great game that i always enjoy playing. thanx for bringing it to the world. i also enjoy your videos very much. they have a really natural feel to them that i really like.

  • @Breyfunk
    @Breyfunk 3 роки тому +1

    Two things I love about Scythe that aren’t mentioned:
    1) Individually, the mechanics of Scythe are easy to understand. There are several wheels in motion which combine to make a great game. You get to choose which of these wheels to interact with to gain your victory. In this sense, that’s the reason I enjoy Dinosaur Island, as that feels similar, you choose which way you want to achieve victory, do you go for specific goal cards, do you try to build the most exciting dinosaurs, do you build roller coasters? The choice is yours
    2) Win or lose, after playing Scythe, I feel as if I have created a story. This is the same way I feel after playing Core Worlds. In Core Worlds, you can look at what planets you’ve conquered, the units under your command and the heroes you’ve recruited, all by looking at your final deck.
    While Scythe is my favorite game, I do love all of your games, and anxiously await Red Rising to arrive!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thanks for sharing these elements! Both are really important to me (the accessibility and the story/sense of satisfaction even if you don't win).

  • @namelessfire
    @namelessfire 3 роки тому

    Scythe is right behind Magic: The Gathering for my favorite game of all-time. Scythe and Viticulture are two games that will always have me interested in every new Stonemaier release.

  • @cwieq665
    @cwieq665 3 роки тому

    I think Scythe has one more feature wich appeals to me greatly, namely near compleat information on the state of the game. I don't mean a total score of each player during the game, thoug it's also trackable, but you alwas know how many stars each of your opponents gained, how many combat cards do they have, what is their military power etc. This allows for formulating a long term strategy, not mearly react to the current state of the game.

  • @noddstudios
    @noddstudios 3 роки тому

    Hi Jamey...Really like Scythe and bought my copy in Essen in 2017...and man what a game it is.... Even got it on app too😁
    The elements described in your video plays a huge part for for me deciding what games I/we buy for our collection...
    Eclipse is nice but the random element of dice is just a bit too much... But we really enjoyed the workings of Kemet and the cards way of doing battle and resolving conflict. You are spot-on about asymmetry and replayability of games and that is what we LOVE about Scythe...
    Engine building and like the one in Scythe always plays a nice part in feeling that you have accomplished something in the game even if you haven't won in the end...and THAT to me/us is a huge part of us loving to play Scythe.
    Some of the games that you mentioned in your review served us with some good inspiration as we set out the create our own game that encompasses some of these great concepts that that you have mentioned in your video... And tells us that we are on the right path ito of the elements we tried to include in our game.... Thx so much sharing this video and hearing your thoughts on this topic... This was a real blessing today😁

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      That's awesome--I'm glad you're inspired by some of these games, and I look forward to seeing what you create! Have you announced the name of your game?

    • @noddstudios
      @noddstudios 3 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier Yes our project/game's name is TradeWarz and we are really proud of what we've created so far given the 10 aspects you covered in your video.

  • @adamblessing8528
    @adamblessing8528 3 роки тому

    Hands down, Scythe is my favorite game of all time! I have all the expansions, a wooden organizer, the board expander, metal money, and realistic resources. The box weighs 11 pounds at this point. Worth it!

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thanks for going deep into Scythe, Adam--that's a heavy box!

  • @TheLobbyOfHobbies
    @TheLobbyOfHobbies 3 роки тому

    Great list Jamey, it reminded me why I love both Orleans and Architects so much. I still need to try Terra Mystica.

    • @cartergreen2309
      @cartergreen2309 3 роки тому +1

      Don't do it. Its a trap

    • @TheLobbyOfHobbies
      @TheLobbyOfHobbies 3 роки тому

      @@cartergreen2309 haha

    • @cartergreen2309
      @cartergreen2309 3 роки тому +1

      @@TheLobbyOfHobbies in all seriousness though I may hate it but a lot of people really like it so it's worth giving it a go just to see if it's your thing haha

    • @TheLobbyOfHobbies
      @TheLobbyOfHobbies 3 роки тому

      @@cartergreen2309 I’ve been deciding between that one and Gaia Project to try and see which one I prefer.

    • @cartergreen2309
      @cartergreen2309 3 роки тому +1

      @@TheLobbyOfHobbies gaia project seems to be the one people like more. I know most tm fans say its just an upgrade so I'd say go for that. I'm not a good person to recommend here because I don't like the first one and know I won't like the second but it seems evident in the community that gaia project is thr better version

  • @marcosseven8872
    @marcosseven8872 3 роки тому +1

    Isn't that Terra Mystica was improved and reimplemented by Gaia Project? I see many people talking about Terra Mystica but not much about Gaia Project. Why is that?
    Great Video ! Cheers

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +1

      Gaia Project is indeed a spiritual successor to Terra Mystica. Gaia Project is higher rated on BGG, but it's also more complex.

  • @marianhlavacek714
    @marianhlavacek714 3 роки тому

    Wow. Cool. Thank you for this video very much! I like Scythe so much. Our childern found My little scythe under christmas tree.. I don't have many games at home, because I started with board games about a year ago. And it's unbelievable that you mention just the games I have. My first game was Mage Knight, then Scythe and then Terra Mystica, Architects, Clank and Near and Far. You have my great respect. What about Eclipse second dawn?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks Marian! I need to finally try Mage Knight someday. :)

    • @marianhlavacek714
      @marianhlavacek714 3 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier I forget to mention Through the Ages. I am from Czech and you know Vlaada Chvaatil is one of our favourite game designers ;)

    • @marianhlavacek714
      @marianhlavacek714 3 роки тому

      @@jameystegmaier And Dune Imperium I have just ordered yestarday 😉

  • @AleksandarDaGr8
    @AleksandarDaGr8 Рік тому +1

    My turns are so long in Dune sometimes😂😂

  • @stefanopaolini6117
    @stefanopaolini6117 3 роки тому +1

    I have always seen Scythe as a Concordia with war implemented

  • @Uniqo.7
    @Uniqo.7 2 роки тому

    I was looking for video games with scythes(the weapon) and found this lol. Good video tho

  • @tonycork2pa469
    @tonycork2pa469 3 роки тому

    Another good video, Jamey - I look forward to these each Sunday. I've still to play a Stonemaier game and am intrigued by recent Red Rising videos/reviews (game looks beautiful too ! - well done).
    With Red Rising inspired by (and of course better than :) Fantasy Realms; and Incan Gold having similarities to Deep Sea Adventure (IMO) - I wonder if you would consider doing a future video on your favorite/Top 10 'game twins' - games that you deem to have such similarities. I suggest you mention your preferred choice for each pair first (triplets and more welcome as well).

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thanks for the idea, Tony! I'll think about that. :)

  • @thomasoswald4626
    @thomasoswald4626 3 роки тому

    I think Inis is certainly a contender for your #7 slot (combat). Don’t get me wrong, Inis is far more combat-heavy than Scythe, but the two games have similar philosophies of war. There’s the idea that anyone could have an ace up their sleeve, the “little guy” is not always at a clear disadvantage, all players involved in combat are burning through resources (therefore, you have to be more selective about picking fights) - and most importantly, you don’t need to fight at all to win the whole game! In fact, the peaceful players in both games tend to sneak past the finish line. Unfortunately for Inis, Scythe came out in the same year. 2016 was a phenomenal year in board game history, and Inis just got buried under all the craziness.

  • @cartergreen2309
    @cartergreen2309 3 роки тому +1

    Well I unfortunately didn't get a lot of use out of this since I own 9 of the 10 and the other one I have played and HAAAAAAAATE it (Terra Mystica) haha. Pretty sure I rated it a 4. (Scythe is a 10 for me btw). But you know sometimes games that people feel are similar to a game you love still won't work for you. It happens. Still great list. I agree with all but number 1 haha

  • @thediceodyssey4690
    @thediceodyssey4690 3 роки тому +1

    Great list Jamey. Don’t worry about blanking on it that rule. We all do things like that....
    Also, I gotta try Clank, I keep hearing wonderful things.
    Also, dune imperium is on my list to try, how’d you feel about the components, I’ve heard mixed thoughts from some people.

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks! I'm perfectly happy with the Dune Imperium components. It's such a thematic Euro that I'm not bothered by the cubes at all.

  • @buddha1062
    @buddha1062 3 роки тому

    Unfortunately I've never played Scythe but would love to one day. Just doesn't fit in the affordable budget when you're in nz.

  • @Odaddy89
    @Odaddy89 3 роки тому

    Scythe is my favorite because of the gameplay and artwork!

  • @select_startgaming1295
    @select_startgaming1295 3 роки тому

    Hi! Got Scythe for Xmas and can't get enough of it. I've since grabbed Wingspan and preordered Red Rising!
    I was wondering whether the hardcover rulebook you held up at the beginning of the video is planned to return to the store at any point?

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому

      Thank you! Yes, we're reprinting it now--if you sign up for a back-in-stock notification on our webstore, I'll contact you when it's ready in a few months.

  • @Spandau-Filet
    @Spandau-Filet 3 роки тому

    Are you excited for Kemet 2nd edition? I backed it but oddly apprehensive. I love Kemet so much...
    Getting My Little Scythe this week. My little ones are growing up 🙂

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +1

      I am excited about it! And thanks for trying My Little Scythe. :)

    • @ClockworkWyrm
      @ClockworkWyrm 3 роки тому +1

      My Little Scythe is a lot of fun...even if you're not a little one anymore. :P
      My kids are reaching the age when they are getting ready to move out and they still enjoy it.

    • @Spandau-Filet
      @Spandau-Filet 3 роки тому

      @@ClockworkWyrm wonderful to know 👍🏼

  • @peacenite
    @peacenite 6 місяців тому

    I enjoyed played scythe it is really awesome board game till now but I just wish it have more expansion or more sequel game

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  6 місяців тому +1

      It now has a sequel: Expeditions! :)

    • @peacenite
      @peacenite 6 місяців тому

      @@jameystegmaier yes i check it and its so good not gonna lie your board game so magnificent for me

  • @StevenStJohn-kj9eb
    @StevenStJohn-kj9eb 3 роки тому

    Prior to watching your video, I decided that Scythe is characterized by 3 core elements: 1) it's an engine-builder, 2) it has a map, 3) it has asymmetric factions. (I think the map is especially important to Scythe's magic formula, as there a many engine builders out there with the world abstracted. In Scythe, it's concrete, and its integral to your engine building.) So brainstorming games with those 3 characteristics:
    1. Terraforming Mars (although the map here is used differently, more as bonuses than conflict or engine building)
    2. Marco Polo II (although engine building is minor in this game but the cities do offer new ways to generate resources)
    3. Yokohama (although the asymmetric powers are acquired during the game, not granted at the beginning, and are minor)
    4. Terra Mystica (the most obvious selection)
    5. Crusaders: Thy Will Be Done (have you played this? You should try it!)
    6. Risk: Europe (a very Euro Risk, not just literally!)
    7. Tapestry
    8. Clans of Caledonia
    As an Honorable Mention I'd list Concordia and Navegador. Neither has asymmetric powers (very weakly in Concordia, I suppose, as you might buy a card no one else has at some point), but both do the Scythe map-engine building integration so strongly.

    • @StevenStJohn-kj9eb
      @StevenStJohn-kj9eb 3 роки тому

      Now halfway through your video I would add the theme as a 4th core element. Shows my bias as a gamer to think mechanisms first. Scythe's art and theme though were both definitely part of why I love the game so much. Of all the games I put on my list, Terraforming Mars is the clear winner for carrying through a theme embedded into the game and also being really interesting. Most of the other games on my list are pretty by the book "obtain economic dominance somewhere in Eurasia."

    • @jameystegmaier
      @jameystegmaier  3 роки тому +1

      @@StevenStJohn-kj9eb Thanks for sharing this list, Steven! I have played Crusaders, and I agree that it fits really well onto this list.

  • @leecurkeet7654
    @leecurkeet7654 3 роки тому +2

    Concordia

  • @johnbrown6230
    @johnbrown6230 3 роки тому

    I love Scythe but can't somehow get into Terra Mystica.

  • @albertolopes829
    @albertolopes829 3 роки тому

    Theme, art, and gameplay

  • @denkautomat8921
    @denkautomat8921 3 роки тому +2

    scythe is great. but gaia project is the better terra mystica.

    • @kevinverbergt6222
      @kevinverbergt6222 3 роки тому

      I love Gaia Project but I guess I'm one of the few people who prefers Terra Mystica just a tad more.
      Reason is the cutthroat nature of TM which makes it more tight and intense. There can be serious competition for certain hexes and Gaia Project is just way more forgiving since you will almost always find a way to form a federation. Gaia Project has deeper gameplay and is a more advanced puzzle to solve, so I get why people often prefer it over TM.

    • @denkautomat8921
      @denkautomat8921 3 роки тому

      Right. the map is better in tm. but gaia map can be built up differently.
      in my opinion the cult tableau is only an additive in tm. in gaia, research is more integrative and allows even more possibilities.
      and the factions are nice ... mad androids, year!
      let's see what the fan factions bring to tm
      but scythe is still the best. in general, i'm a big stonemaier fan. it's a shame that feuerland decided against red rising :(

  • @Frickenchies
    @Frickenchies 3 роки тому

    Iron Harvest!