These ladies are all GORGEOUS, especially the two at each end. I especially love the girl on the far left!!! 💘💘 Can anyone tell me all their names, left to right please? 🥰😊
Can everyone please look from 2:48 to 2:55 noone is singing because there is a little bit of backing track. HOWEVER Frankie is helping with the chorus in the song if you watch this song live Frankie and Vanessa are singing together so please dont hate on Frankie. She done a good job tbh. :)
i think Vanessa was singing backtrack on a few parts, maybe??? idk, haha. but at 2:52, during vanessa's part, she's not even holding the mic up to her mouth.
I think Frankie and Rochelle were signed to the same agency after S Club Juniors that made sure they joined an act as a duo as they were friends. Frankie and Molly are just pretty faces tbh.
listentothis It's Mollie, not Molly. Frankie can do high notes (hardly even for Vanessa and she says that on 24/7), she's the best dancer and she's beautiful for the pics, so Frankie is the complete package for what this band proposed to do.
Totally agree. I've always rated Vanessa as the best singer, then Rochelle, Una, Frankie then Mollie. You can totally tell the backing track is playing on the chorus because notice at 2:51 the girls aren't singing but the backing track is making it sound like they are. Frankie is suppose to be singing then and she realises, so joins in with the backing track. Someone's voice keeps breaking on the really high notes too and it sounds really bad :S I still think they are brilliant though! :)
at 2:50 + you can hear the filipino girls voice belting but u dont see anyone singing and then frankie starts 'singing' alone i bet she doesnt belt forever is over part
Overall best singer is Una! She has power, intonation & control too! Vanessa hasn't any control over her voice but she can be great especialy in high notes! Rochelle is quite good too! Frankie and Mollie are mess! Love that song! :)
she went for the xfactor twice, the 1st time she got no the second time she went with a band and it was yes no haha :L now she is in one of the bestest girl bands around, something has gone wrong there...
Everyone in the band has their strengths and weaknesses. This band would be pretty boring if they all sounded alike. You need the different tones to express the song fully. I think everyone is needed.
OK, I absolutely love The Saturdays but this is one of there only songs where I feel that Vanessa is the lead singer and the others are used as backups (sorry)
How on EARTH did Frankie and Mollie even get into the band? You guys might hate me for saying this and you may say theyve improved but at the end of the day think of ALL the talented and gifted singers out there on their grind trying to get recognized and instead theyre struggling and girls like these who are nice on the eye get instant and undeserved success. Vanessa is outstanding, Rochelle is great and I love Una's unique voice, but Mollie and Frankie? Maybe its just me that doesnt understand
Callum Hughes In my opinion, all the girls is good singers, some of them are better or not according to the song in the case. But the band is not only about the voices. The girls need to be beautiful and good dancers, so in this case, Frankie and Mollie are "the best members". You can't deny that Frankie can do high notes (hardly even for Vanessa and she says that on 24/7) on harmony. Frankie is the best dancer so far. And Frankie is always in center in almost of pictures and coreographys. And to be honest, you won't be here if they weren't beautiful. But, if you really want AMAZING singers, forget the girlbands at the first place!
This song doesn't work in a live setting like this - it comes across as too shouty. I mean when the chorus startsed after verse 1, I jumped cos it was like they were shouting. And I've always thought Rochelle's harmonies sound off-key. I don't think are but it just throws the chorus off even more.
Gaahh.. Mollie's aweful... Frankie should def. sing more than Mollie does. Not sure who was off key in the harmonies, but somebody did. o_O Not sure if they should totally get rid of the backing track, coz the off key sound is definitely NOT from the backing track.
![The Saturdays - Forever Is Over [Headlines Tour DVD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XFg64SnyPdo/mqdefault.jpg)
14 years ago ? Christ where does the time go ?
I miss the Saturdays. I ❤️ Una and Vanessa
Me too,wish they come back for a reunião tour
Vanessa and Una ❤️
that was AMAZING, LOVE THIS SONG!!! Love The Saturdasy
Vanessa does lead the chorus but unas solo at the start and near the end is amazing she has a strong husky voice
I LOVE THE SATURDAYS!
My favourite is Una - she is one of the hottest and has consistently good vocals plus her personality is really cool
Mine is Mollie
These ladies are all GORGEOUS, especially the two at each end. I especially love the girl on the far left!!! 💘💘 Can anyone tell me all their names, left to right please? 🥰😊
Una Rochelle Vanessa Mollie Frankie
una is clearly the best singer...now that management are giving her a chance to sing
Vanessa, Una and Rochelle can sing very good live, especially Vanessa.
Can everyone please look from 2:48 to 2:55 noone is singing because there is a little bit of backing track. HOWEVER Frankie is helping with the chorus in the song if you watch this song live Frankie and Vanessa are singing together so please dont hate on Frankie. She done a good job tbh. :)
Frankie sounds good in this !! :) (Y)
And all of 'em look amazing , as always! :)
LOVE IT.. Defoo can tell its live !
some songs just dont need a dance routine and this is one of them
I look like Frankie.... Vanesaa and Rochelle and Frankie are amazing
UNA WAS AMAZING HERE!!!
such a great performance! :D
at 2:51 nobody sing....but we can listen vanessa voice (!!!). I love these girls
so did i lol i was like wow that was good and i looked at the comments and no one really liked it
Tone deaf springs to mind
Yay! Frankie is back to her short hair!!!!
Oh lord, it is worrying to see everyone helping out on that chorus. Poor Vanessa!
FRANKIE IS AWESOME! X
always vanessa sing and the others just a little frankie's voice is amazing she must sing more
great song Amazing !!!!!!!!!!!!!
UNAAAA!! She's amazing!
The drummer looks like the one Busted (and later Matt Willis) used to have, David I think his name is. Am I right?
shout for Mollie is so cute and she is also very gorgeous
best vocal on this song by vanessa expecially at the end!
i think Vanessa was singing backtrack on a few parts, maybe??? idk, haha. but at 2:52, during vanessa's part, she's not even holding the mic up to her mouth.
I think Frankie and Rochelle were signed to the same agency after S Club Juniors that made sure they joined an act as a duo as they were friends. Frankie and Molly are just pretty faces tbh.
listentothis It's Mollie, not Molly. Frankie can do high notes (hardly even for Vanessa and she says that on 24/7), she's the best dancer and she's beautiful for the pics, so Frankie is the complete package for what this band proposed to do.
mollie is my fave but she looks like heidi montag here btw love mollies hair
mollie is amazing
LOVE FRANKIE!!!!!!!!!!
Shocking vocals
great song , great legs !!
2:52 they forgot to sing, didn't they? hahaha well done frankie, at least you tried
frankie is great live
great Frankie has short hair again :) great performance
oh and i think frankie screwed up at 2:50? or Vanessa? somebody didnt sing their line and the backup track was heard
oh well
Frankie rocks :D
@BitorS Uh. no I mean live at any time in the world ever when they sing not remastered.
@xJanaRoxDaWorldx its not it just sounds like theres loads of voices all going at once cos of the backing track.
İ love Mollies !!!!!!
I hear cracks everywhere....
@thenook61 haha. nail the lot them? haha. they were good live and they are the prettiest of the girl bands as well.
My Ears!!! XS
Rip Paul
Una sounds brill at the end :)
Everyone is saying it is crap... I enjoyed it! Lol!
Sometimes Una remember me of Jennifer Love Hewit, but of course Una is Hotter ;)
@vidasineditas i know i saw it too
Totally agree. I've always rated Vanessa as the best singer, then Rochelle, Una, Frankie then Mollie. You can totally tell the backing track is playing on the chorus because notice at 2:51 the girls aren't singing but the backing track is making it sound like they are. Frankie is suppose to be singing then and she realises, so joins in with the backing track. Someone's voice keeps breaking on the really high notes too and it sounds really bad :S I still think they are brilliant though! :)
No Una is the best singer along with Vanessa the other 3 are equal.
Not exactly the best live performance, but at least they sang live.
Haha, it looks funny is Ness is next to Rochelle :D
@tsrstar I agree with you 100%
@ExMaster godesses??? ahahahahahahaha where??? on their tour dvd? ofc they do cos the sound was all remastered with a pre recorded track.
omg what a shocking performance
at 2:50 + you can hear the filipino girls voice belting but u dont see anyone singing and then frankie starts 'singing' alone
i bet she doesnt belt forever is over part
They don't have a backing track. They're singing with a live band.
Overall best singer is Una! She has power, intonation & control too! Vanessa hasn't any control over her voice but she can be great especialy in high notes! Rochelle is quite good too! Frankie and Mollie are mess! Love that song! :)
she went for the xfactor twice, the 1st time she got no the second time she went with a band and it was yes no haha :L now she is in one of the bestest girl bands around, something has gone wrong there...
Some pins on them too !!!!
wow they are so shakey singing this..
I love this song but why they gotta shout when they sing the chorus it’s like a screaming match lol 🤣
frabkie is beautiful mollie wondelful
they put the shortest next to the tallest... very smart
Vanessa at 3.20 👌🏻
@mjbod2010 Of course, everyone can be fans of anything they want (:
Everyone in the band has their strengths and weaknesses. This band would be pretty boring if they all sounded alike. You need the different tones to express the song fully. I think everyone is needed.
OK, I absolutely love The Saturdays but this is one of there only songs where I feel that Vanessa is the lead singer and the others are used as backups (sorry)
@Rebecca097 Yes. Goddesses. There's not doubt.
@ExMaster with me there is a little but if doubt.
UNA! *-*
vanessa and frankie are the only ones that can sing in tune still a good song though
@dld016 Within the 5 months of putting that comment and now. I'll agree with you. But I'm still a bigger fan of The Saturdays for my own reasons....
@mariahandchristina oh, haha. i guess you're right, =]]
UNAAA
Vanessa and Rochelle r the best!!!!!!!!!!!
Umm excuse me what about UNA!!!?
@missterrijean88 I agree 100% Girls Aloud is so much better. At least when all five of them sing, it sounds amazing.
@Spurs4Eva01633 shockingly good :)
una on that middle 8...:'D
Vanessa is the best!!!!!!!!!
@mjbod2010 You're right .. sang a few words .. but with style (of a cow).. =)
@BritneyDigitalLive don't forget Una! Almost as good as Rochelle!
Love the song 2 bits bt do think only una and molly can sing live
lmao :')
rochellee sounds gooood.
How on EARTH did Frankie and Mollie even get into the band? You guys might hate me for saying this and you may say theyve improved but at the end of the day think of ALL the talented and gifted singers out there on their grind trying to get recognized and instead theyre struggling and girls like these who are nice on the eye get instant and undeserved success. Vanessa is outstanding, Rochelle is great and I love Una's unique voice, but Mollie and Frankie? Maybe its just me that doesnt understand
Callum Hughes In my opinion, all the girls is good singers, some of them are better or not according to the song in the case.
But the band is not only about the voices. The girls need to be beautiful and good dancers, so in this case, Frankie and Mollie are "the best members".
You can't deny that Frankie can do high notes (hardly even for Vanessa and she says that on 24/7) on harmony. Frankie is the best dancer so far. And Frankie is always in center in almost of pictures and coreographys.
And to be honest, you won't be here if they weren't beautiful. But, if you really want AMAZING singers, forget the girlbands at the first place!
vanessa is the best =DD.
I heard way worse versions by them than this.
Tbh, Vanessas singing sounds really good and the rest aren't too bad.
legs up to their necks !!!!
This song doesn't work in a live setting like this - it comes across as too shouty. I mean when the chorus startsed after verse 1, I jumped cos it was like they were shouting. And I've always thought Rochelle's harmonies sound off-key. I don't think are but it just throws the chorus off even more.
@amsmart1 THE SATURDAYS FAILOL.
@Rebecca097 Uhhh. sure. Girls Aloud are goddesses. Yes.
Frankie is HOT in those leggings and heels x
@ExMaster goddesses you think so?? Can't agree with you there
there usually really good live but this sounds awful :( love frankie and mollie
Gaahh.. Mollie's aweful... Frankie should def. sing more than Mollie does. Not sure who was off key in the harmonies, but somebody did. o_O
Not sure if they should totally get rid of the backing track, coz the off key sound is definitely NOT from the backing track.
exactly what i was thinking! u lose the magic of the song with that shouted harmonzing...
Frankie is shouting throughout this performance in the chorus's and it doesn't sound good at all they can be better