Amtrak Locomotive Tier List
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- You know me as the AmtrakGuy, but what Amtrak locomotives do I really like most? That's a question I've surprisingly not answered beyond the F40PH being my alltime favorite. So, I'm finally going to answer that using a somewhat definitive tier list while explaining why or why not I like a certain engine. Which ones do you like? Let me know in the comments below!
Music Used:
Sonic Jam - Digital Manual
OMORI - Let's Get Together Now!
Pizza Tower - hmmm look what u done did you found a secret
Super Mario 64 Beta - Bob-Omb Battlefield
Sonic Frontiers - Fishing Vibes
Deltarune - WELCOME TO THE CITY
Kirby Super Star - Mt. Dedede
Wii Shop Channel Main Theme
OMORI - Push & Shove
Team Fortress 2 - Playing With Danger
Toby Fox - Green Room
Deltarune - When I Get Happy I Dance Like This
Links:
Twitter: / amtrakguy365
Instagram: / amtrakguy365
RedBubble Shop: www.redbubble....
Channel Membership: / @amtrakguy365
Flickr: www.flickr.com...
My Site: amtrakguy365.we... - Розваги
Extra rankings since everyone is asking for them:
F/E Units: B Tier (classic design, but I still prefer the look of others)
GG1: B Tier (another classic design, Amtrak paint looks kinda meh on them)
FL9: A Tier (again, classic locomotive design but Amtrak paint actually looks really nice on them)
Thanks for watching the video! What do you think of my list and how would you rank all of these locomotives seen here? Also sorry if my commentary sounds a bit repetitive, I'm not the best with unscripted content, but I wanted to try it out here. Hopefully I'll get better with it in the future.
I agree
You said the S word
At 14:15 you said the S word
Did pretty good. Agreed with the decision to make a separate tier for the talgo.
this list is ass imagine rating rolling stock that's not in revenue service and a locomotive that was barely a year on the roster.... and the P30CH in A tier? your opinions are shit
Finally, the Amtrak guy makes an Amtrak tier list. Also, the reason the Avelia Liberty coaches don't align with the coaches is that when they tilt, they align with one of the two sides. They couldn't include the tilting tech in the power cars because it would make them too heavy. It grinds my gears too, but it's a design choice that even the acela 1s have if you look closely.
They don’t look the same because the power car is an off the shelf product, it’s the same power car they use on the TGVM’s
As the previous comment said. It’s because the power car is completely off the self. France has a smaller loading gauge than the US, so when the power cars are matched up with American sized cars, they don’t match up. Horrible design choices IMO.
I also want to tell you all the fact that the power cars are off the shelf. aaaahhhhh that felt goooof
His career is complete
7 months is a good length of time for another person who no one asked to let you know that they were off the shelf
Whether it's that or to line up on curves, it still ain't look right.
Man,
Amtrakguy went it all out on the Talgo 😂
No wonder 😂
Can't blame him, that set is Fugly.
This is where the fun begins
Very tru
14:09 made me laugh with what he said about the “Talgo series 8 cab car” and called it ugly
I totally agree with the SDP40F placement, I too love the little smiles they have.
I find it hilarious that you they still smiled regardless of how many times they derailed
I’d bump the Dash 8’s to S (I have a Railking model of one and we had a couple here in Orlando at one point) and the turbocharger to A/B, but that’s about it. All your S tier choices especially make perfect sense. They ARE the locomotives of Amtrak.
I think he doesnt like them i agree with you tho
I freaking love the F40PH, I've always liked '70s and '80s stuff to begin with, but the F40PH is literally the epitome of that. I even see the "NPCU Cabbage Car" in the Cascades too!
I agree. The NPCU Cabbage car is also used on the Downeaster route running from Boston North Station to Brunswick, Maine.
Right off the bat ranking a loco A-tier because it vaguely looks like it's smiling. This is why I love your stuff.
it's really interesting to see other railfan's opinions in this regard, my list would be completely different and yet I still enjoy seeing your list and hearing your reasons for your placements.
In Germany we have a joke within the railfan community. The company name is the abbreviation for "Sicher ist eins, man erhält nur Schrott" (English: One for sure - all you get is scrap). Seems it applies to their US products as well.
Pretty good tier list of all of these Amtrak locomotives. I think all of them are beautiful. On going. Pretty good engines out there even though it’s a shame some of them are scrapped, mainly the GE P30CH. Happy St. Patrick’s Day, AmtrakGuy365.
14:10 yep, looks like those Talgo's got hit by the ugly stick a few thousand times.
Not arguing with you there, I see those Talgo's every other day where currently I live (Tacoma, WA).
AEM7: *retires
The Railfan community: “A sad anime death”
The Talgo part made me laugh so hard 😂
Edit: Guys, stop arguing about words! So what if he used swear words? And so what if someone dislikes the use of swear words? I will say that I did not expect the word 'shit' to be used many times in this video, but that doesn't mean you have to feel entitled to mock those who dislike them!
Edit 2: Are you seriously going to stop watching someone's videos just because of a word..
Edit 3: OH MY GOD THEY'RE JUST WORDS STOP FIGHTING
Same it made me laugh soooooooo hard I almost Choked lmao
@@TWF1003 boo hoo go tell the teacher
It's so accurate
It looks like a car.
@@TWF1003 fuck
@@TWF1003 Shiver Me Timbers
I actually really like SC44 chargers, especially with that dark-blue livery. Maybe it's just that so many of my trips behind Genesis engines have been on the Texas Eagle, which is naturally prone to breakdowns, so I've always been eager to see what comes next in efficiency and reliability. Since my region- upper midwest- isn't likely to get high-speeders any decade soon, the charger is basically the only game in town for us other than the genesis. Fingers crossed for the Northern Lights Express.
.........
*Are you okay?*
@@LongIslandRailfanner Yes. Why?
@@LongIslandRailfanner the sc44 is better than the alc42 though
@@TrainStreet it's still kinda ugly and has the same reliability problems as the ALC 42s
@@LongIslandRailfanner The Genesis units are far uglier and the ALC-42s and SC-44s don't have as many issues now as teething issues are being resolved
As someone who has been a railfan for 50+ years and who has ridden Amtrak for all but one of those years (didn't ride in 1972 or 2020), I enjoyed viewing your video. I agree with most of your ratings, particularly for the Talgo which looks like a toy inspired by a child's cartoon. At first, I did not like the looks of Amtrak's Genesis locomotives, but I eventually warmed up to them and really like the chug-chug sound and enjoy seeing them on the Amtrak's Pennsylvanian train. I evenpurchased an HO-scale model of the 156 in the Phase 1 paint scheme and have ordered the 100 in the Midnight Blue scheme. Thanks for sharing. This was a fun video to watch.
9 months late, but what happened in 1972!?
@@ahdog8 maybe he wasn't born yet
@@LongIslandRailfanner true
Nah, Turbotrain is legit my favorite, I love how doofy it looks, it's so cute
You made sure to point out at the beginning that this list would be more subjective, which is great. That being said, I think a follow up video using technical specifications, service history, etc. would be appropriate
I’m a train 364/365 Michigander, but last summer I spent some time on the east coast. The Acela train sets are showing age, they really rattle and don’t ride as nice as they should for the cost. Still worth “at least once” status. I also came to respect the ALC-42, they’re solid workhorses and they’re underrated here.
Also gotta say I do miss the Genesis on the blue water😢
Have you ever considered working for amtrak? I just started a few months ago and as a mechanically minded, diet foamer, and Im having a great time.
regarding the chargers sucking in snow. I previously interviewed with siemens and we discussed that. The person interviewing me figured out that issue and the solution. the specifics is there is an air duct running through the rear of the locomotive, from the ground up to the resister arrays. usually it pushes air up and away. however if it detects that there is snow or ice blocking the entrance down at the bottom it should reverse the fan direction so it blows hot air on the ice and snow, melting them. however the computer still warns you if you are operating it in conditions below 50f, which frankly is a ridiculous minimum temperature.
The SDP40F better be god tier
As a Charger person, Yea......
Other than it dying like every damn winter storm, it looks nice.
The saddest day in railroad history: Amtrak retires the P40s
3:28, “so um, *moves to S tier*, this engine is pretty cool and…” got me cracking up!
I’m not gonna get offended, I’m just a train.
how are you typing if your a train (sarcasm)
I remember seeing the genesis on there goes a train and I absolutely loved the design.
When ever i hear Amtrak, i think of the P42, the F40PH and and the F59PHI.
Same
14:14 “it’s an ugly piece of shit” bro had enough with the Taglo Cab car
No offense taken on this at all because i TOTALLY AGREE!! You did the Talgo locomotive so bad lol!! You had me laughing at that part! 🤣 100% agree with you!
I hope Amtrak keeps the Genesis engines on service until the Chargers work properly
They are starting to work properly
NGL the new Charger train set looks cleaner than the actual engine. I particularly like the F59PHi and Avelia since they look like straight aerodynamic BEASTS
I respect the F59 placements. I grew up riding behind them on NCDOT so my bias would have put them in S tier. Great video as always
When I think of Amtrak, the Genesis is exactly what pops up in my mind.
Have the same thoughts for the F40. There goes a train was a major but also living in Chicago was a plus. I got to see them a few times a month and i always loved them.
I had no idea how long they'd been around or that Amtrak had been phasing them out, same with Santa Fe and plenty of other lines I thought we're still around and thier engines.
Along with the Big Boy, those powerful long lasting beasts will always be my favorite. Anytime i take a drive into the city or near a line and see them still powering on i smile, knowing they're still here always makes me happy
Also had no idea we're the same age. Pretty cool
14:14 🤣🤣 bro the way you said it was pretty funny
0:53 yep, I always pictured that, especially on steam locomotives when they have the hand rail on their smokebox foot
14:55 this part cracked me up
@@TWF1003 Leave Then.
@Trimetwes Fan1003 Yes, he did. Don't ever bash my opinions
alright I must admit I'm excited to see what Amtrak does with the new Charger stuff.
F40HP is one of my favorite Amtrak trains to :)
The talgo and turbo look very awesome imo.
Then again I have a thing for unique and odd designs
Amtrakguy on the talgos: im about to end this engines whole career
I honestly feel the same way for the VIA rail f40ph's, lots of nostalgia related to them being a kid in the 2000's.
Also, HARD disagree on the D-tier placements. The turbotrain is by far one of my favorite trainsets, though CN's was a lot better looking when compared to gen 1 amtrak paint. The genset is nice because it's unique, and it looks like a proper shunting and utility loco, making it look well suited for its position.
Can’t wait for the Urbanists to rage about how the Chargers aren’t number one
"BuT wHY iS iTT nOT ToP TEAr!!¿?!?!?!?? ÆÆÆÆÆÆĄÆÆ"
Based comment. Gotta love those types of “Railfans” that refuse to acknowledge anything older than their Iphones.
Interesting on how Amtrak Chargers break down during the winter or now fall while Via Rail Chargers are working fine this winter season, two train sets running every Tuesday since November.
I remember when Amtrak had F40PH as there primary power
I mostly agree with your opinions but I think the dash 8 should be in a tier but also I saw a alc-42 charger for the first time not to long ago
Personally, I just really respect the Budd Metroliner. It's a brick, but it's a fast AF brick. Got to love something that gives the law of physics the middle finger.
"There Goes a Train" is such a core memory - I watched that thing countless times on VHS as a kid and remember finding it on youtube one day to much delight. I came away from that smitten with Santa Fe and also the "new genesis" locomotives, specifically the phase III P40DC. I also spent my early childhood in SoCAL and so the Amtrak Surfliner F59PHIs were my favorites to watch
Good video
I agree with you about the p30ch and aem-7
Thanks for making this!
Lol no explanation needed for the f40ph
Because of Metra, The F40PH is a Coolio locomotive to me
I have a second Buick Terraza painted like SDP40F #644, the only one left, in Amtrak's phase III color scheme.
Love the metroliner and the pooch
The UA Turbos were great to ride in the dome car, they were loud and had issues but were fun to ride
Yay, somebody else who actually remembers _There Goes A Train!_ 😀 Me personally, it's nice to see the newer Charger locomotives against the well-aged Amtrak fleet, but I really only see them shuttling between Pontiac and Detroit. Between Detroit and Chicago still seems to be predominantly Genesis locos...?
HHP-8 is the Curséd dollar store Acela, deserves D-tier
Well done and nearly concur with just about them all! Great little fun video. BTW, not harsh enough on the Talgo and Liberties (those horns; uggh!).
Amtrakguy: Chargers aren't that bad.
Also AmtrakGuy: Cusses on camera because of a Talgo (It's the other way around for me)
11:33 Its a similar story with the Hitachi AT300s (Classes 800 to 803) here in the UK From Leaking Air Conditioning Units, Overheating Engines, Software Issues, Problematic Power Changeover Sequences to Cracks in the Lifting Brackets and now Fatigue and Cracks in the Body Shells, The list goes on...
Same Here with the EMD DM/DE30AC here on the Long Island Railroad hey mainly suffer from Electrical problems but thats about it
We, and the world, needed this.
More tier lists please, this was a great watch
14:14 I kinda agree there. I don't think it's the worst one ever but still ugly 14:28 14:58
ive been Trainmaxxing so hard recently and its all because i rewatched this guy's trainz 12 crashing video
My first mainline cabride was in SDP40F #603. Charleston to Huntington, WV October 1975.
I recall running over a tv antenna lying on the track.
Jesus...were you alright?
Atleast Amtrak won’t need to worry about their GE’s blowing turbochargers anymore they’re completely phased out. I do hope they work out the charger kinks. But your charger attitude makes me wander how they could have better luck with long range adapted EMD F125’s or MPI MP54AC’s.
The MP54AC would be so off for long-distance trains to me
Me personally, I love the F40PHs, P42DCs, the Geeps, & the Dash 8s, I love the sound they produce
I love the great Nintendo game songs You add in the background. You are ASS LOADS of awesome!
Me at the beginning of this video. If the Genesis isn't S class I'm rioting 😂
Maybe I haven’t been on your channel long enough, but I don’t think I’ve ever heard you swear until the Talgo rant. It makes your ranting natural and and genuine, and that says enough about how you feel about them 💀
4:30 couldn't agree w/ you more. they're my favorite loco of all time, *mainly Septa's for the extremely custom tuned horn* but also bc I saw em a good amount of times during my childhood ( i live a mile from the keystone corridor) so yeah, my favorite.
I fucking lost it at the Charger and Talgo parts. The Talgo does look like a car/truck hybrid. I absolutely hate both of those locomotives, and I couldn't agree more. The fact you created entire bad catagories for them is perfect, and you put the F40PH (my favorite locomotive) in S tier makes this even more awesome than it is. Thank you, AmtrakGuy!
The Talgo part is not a locomotive, it's a cab car
I can't 😂😂 that part got me so bad
liking for "friend-shaped diesel" now i need to find a P-30 and give it a hug
They've all been scraped
What about the GG1 or E and F units?
5-stars for using the word "lambasted"
I totally agree about everything F-45 looking
12:23
Yeah, have to agree on this one - the bit about the Power Car's Profile not matching up with the Coaches.
It feels like somebody got lazy during the design phase, and nobody noticed this error during the production phase.
Pretty much the Main Gripe I have with it ever since setting my eyes on it the first time.
Then again, everybody is entitled to their own opinion.
It annoyed me too but it’s like that for a reason. The coaches tilt, the power cars don’t. Because they tilt if the side profile WAS straight up and down like we think we want the top of the coaches would breach the loading gauge at the top when in tilt. Which you don’t want.. hence they’re tapered so they stay within gauge
Genesis will always be my favorite. They were amtraks first "modern" locomotives packed with all the latest electronics. I also like their cab interior the best too since they use the IFD screens instead of old school guages.gages. Really wished GE would've stepped up with a "next gen" version of the Genesis instead of just letting Siemens take over take over as amtraks main locomotive manufacturer.
The should have made it and called it "Exodus"
Ngl the Talgo 8 cab car really does look like a road vehicle on rails😂 LMAO
Nahh AmtrakGuy365 Defied the laws of physics or computer gravity to make Talgo tier and it makes it even funnier...
The F40ph knows nothing of retirement.
I love the via charger/venture when I went to quebec city I made sure that I was exclusively on them (mostly because the interiors are nicer)
Fun Fact: some locomotives look similar to the SDP40Fs which are the F40Cs and they were more successful than the SDP40Fs
I would've thrown the E60 into the S Teir cause that Big Bulky strong look is what caught your eye
While the E-60s had shorter Noses, the Profiles were very close to the P30-CHs.
I'm proud to have personally worked with the F40PH locomotives in the GCRY fleet, especially No. 237
Can I just say how you incorporated welcome to the city from dr is just genius? Like as an underground railfan, when I saw the playthru of deltarune in cyber city, I thought oh yeah this is some nice music when trains basically or... when that one npc said "public transit" i connected it all together!
He roasted the talgo 😂😅
the talgo looks like a scania 146l or 124h
I have been waiting for this one.
damn.. took that f59ph rating to heart. they did amazing for go transit for years, i understand this is an amtrak perspective, but they used to push and pull 10 bi levels no problem, with beautiful k5LA’s.
The proper video we needed:
U ACS-64 #637????
3:57 WELCOME TO CHICAGO!
The Acela Express was a very comfortable ride, coming from a german tourist
Chargers look great you're insane!
Funny that the Chargers are having issues with snow in the air intakes. The Pennsy had the same issues with the GG1s sucking in snow and having issues. Not sure how they addressed that…
It was called teething issues, All locos from the earliest steamers had them, and just like Pennsy Amtrak has worked out the charger issues
But that crazy tho bro did the chargers dirty
In my opinion is the SC-44 alright looking. I warmed up to it a long time ago since railfan in California and there's lots of them but I think you will warm up to the ALC-42 since they have the same style cab as the ACS-64
Well that was certainly interesting. Family friendly channel that talks about trains in a very meme-like fashion- “this train looks like an ugly piece of shit.” I’m not disagreeing, I was just surprised.
The only changes I would make on my tier list would be to bump the Dash 8 up to A (always had a weird love for them, not sure why), and to put the Acela in S. I know it’s childhood bias from growing up on the east coast in the late 90s and early 2000s, but that is the first train I ever remember vividly, and I’m glad I got to take a ride on one as a kid from DC up the NEC
What about those experimental European trains (like the RC4 and German ICE)?
The talgo cab car is definitely something straight out of Ohio 💀
The ALC-42 didn’t even REACH the MMBSI goal! That shows how bad it is!
But the display board on the charger is nice. They should add it on the ALC-42E.
I know that’s not you
You’re absolutely entitled to your opinions, but boy are your aesthetic tastes are eccentric.
So what are your aesthetic tastes?
Amtrakguy365, Amtrak Cascades is still running their f40ph fleet and a few of the other f40s that Amtrak had. P42 Genesis locomotives should be able to get in to a few preservation museums I hope because they are very iconic to Amtrak. I also agree about the Talgo 8 series. They designed a car/truck/train