4 DEEP Messages In 'The Whale' You Might've Missed | Film Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 29

  • @jadenterrell2604
    @jadenterrell2604 Рік тому +6

    I’ve been wanting to see this movie because I love Brendan Frazier in everything he does. This analysis makes me want to see it even more.

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому

      Thank you Jaden for stopping by. He nails it in this role and he deserved the Oscar 100% :)

  • @CallumDT
    @CallumDT Рік тому +3

    3:00 these responses from the students were what moved me the most in the film. Flawed but yet an incredible and important film.

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому

      I loved that part as well Callum. Just goes to show we hide so much of who we are from people. And like Charlie says--that's the stuff that actually matters.

  • @CynthiaWylie
    @CynthiaWylie Рік тому +1

    Thank you for your thoughtful and well-spoken observations.

  • @danielnorville
    @danielnorville Рік тому

    This movie is so multi complex with it's themes genuinely perfection

  • @smoothcritical1
    @smoothcritical1 26 днів тому

    The fundamental meaning of the film:
    ua-cam.com/video/CQQUTQ_f4Is/v-deo.html&ab_channel=WyattStagg

  • @YevgenyLibov
    @YevgenyLibov Рік тому +2

    Great analysis.
    I would like to propose to you to review Melancholia.

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому +1

      Hello! Wow, thank you for watching. I'll take a look at that movie. :)

  • @michaeljohns8817
    @michaeljohns8817 Рік тому

    GREAT ANALYSIS , THANKS !!!!!!

  • @CallumDT
    @CallumDT Рік тому +1

    I am interested to know your thoughts on silence of the lambs a film I did not get around to seeing till recently. I think it is incredible. peak horror

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому

      Callum I've never seen it and I'm scared to see it but for you I might just go see it 😄

  • @urvanamenon6170
    @urvanamenon6170 Рік тому +1

    Such fine analysis

  • @worldpeace1969
    @worldpeace1969 6 місяців тому

    hi Tom! Guilt is the worst feeling...michelle from Substack Peace yes feels disgusting only one answer for me prayer peace will watch and write some essays especially this one and religious abuse

  • @j.knight2250
    @j.knight2250 3 місяці тому +1

    Wow! Such great commentary, pulling out the deeper meanings. Thank you for a very thoughtful review.
    As i watched the movie, I found it kind of irritating that Charlie kept calling people, especially Ellie who was an angry brat, amazing. Were they really amazing? I also found it heart breaking, that when pressed, the missionary, who came to bring the love of God, confessed he found Charlie disgusting. The truth is we all have a disgusting side but God loves us anyway. Then I thought how Jesus might see us. He created us out of love and called us good. I believe he thinks we are amazing. So maybe Charlie wasn't religious but he was the one who was closest to the heart of God in regards to what he believed about people.

  • @emesar5233
    @emesar5233 Рік тому +2

    Nice review. Left out the condescending & negative wife though. She highlighted Brendons optimism & empathy for how others feel & what they are capable of.
    Beautiful movie. Did cry - too close to home. Will sub... thanks for the video

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому +1

      Thank you! Yeah, there's a lot to talk about with any movie worth it's salt for sure.

  • @richardcruz8130
    @richardcruz8130 7 місяців тому

    Do you know !!! The Asian girl who is taking care of him is the sister of his boy friend !!!!

    • @socialmediaaccount4206
      @socialmediaaccount4206 6 днів тому

      Yes. Late reply but her family were the founders of the new life church the missionary boy went to as well.

  • @CHABIEPORTNOY
    @CHABIEPORTNOY Рік тому +1

    He won best actor

  • @rameshdevasi6720
    @rameshdevasi6720 Рік тому

    if you look at the etymology of character name u will find this movie is actually very "religious" spiritual...and at last charles rise up just like jesus toward elie the light.

    • @filmalysis
      @filmalysis  Рік тому

      Really good catch there Ramesh you are right

  • @smoothcritical1
    @smoothcritical1 26 днів тому

    The problem isn't traditional religion, which is very much subordinate in Charlie's culture; it's the suicidal and nihilistic "liberal" culture which destroys him. Had he lived among the Amish the story would have been impossible.
    The film is essentially identical to Aronofsky's "The Wrestler", just more degenerate and made for a later period of frog boiling. Both have the same ending: the suicidal protagonist consumed by white light. Aside from making money, the goal of this film is to degrade the audience.