I’m in no way rooting for Bonnet but you have to admit, he makes a FANTASTIC villain. He has that crazy vibe and just enough humanity to make him interesting.
I totally agree with that for both Bonnet and black jack Randall. And I have to say that in most of the cases all of the actors seem to have incredible facial expressions that can betray an emotion or what they're thinking without saying a word.
He's no Black Jack Randall but he's a good villain. If u read the books (or see the scene where he asks her to teach him to be a gentleman) then u'll know that this lunatic doesn't even know how to be a person. He doesn't even know what he did to Brianna was rape. He even tells her how to better perform the next time they're together. That's wen she realizes that he doesn't even know what he took from her. He doesn't know it's rape. He actually tells her to take whatever she wants from his valuables becoz he thinks that's how it works: u take your pleasure, she takes your treasure. And he actually likes her so much he wants her to have whatever she wants. It's so disturbing. Red-headed Frasers have the incredible misfortune of being the objects of the twisted affections of murdering rapists. Another thing I hate abt the TV writers is that they don't explain y Brianna feels the need to be sympathetic towards Bonnet. Wen she talks to Jamie abt it, she does ask if it wud help to kill him. What they don't show is that Jamie told her that what helped him get past wat Randall did was finding sympathy for that beast.
Maybe it's becoz I read the book that I understand his total lack of understanding. He didn't recognize Brianna, he didn't know what he did was wrong. To me, he's just a rabid dog that needs to be put down. And I feel like, in a way, Bree unerstood it too. And I'm not agreeing with the series that made her appease him. I'm just saying that she realized he was not worth her time or her guilt. She rook the high road and she was free
That look he gave her when she said I’ll raise my child to be a good person. Wooooweeee now he’s a good actor. The regret and hurt on his face on cue yeesh.
I think the reason people like Bonnet so much is because, well first, he is a great actor and fun to watch. Second, the show has gotten a bit stale. All of the conflict seems superficial and silly. Jamie or Claire get in trouble because they are always wanting to play savior and acting foolishly. Bree and Rogers conflicts seem childish and make their characters unlikable. Example: Bree and Roger just get “married”, he has risk his life and throws away the world he knows to find her in another time and she tells him to get lost over what should have been a small fight. Having a big baddie again, like Bonnet, gives us something to care about. We will be wondering when he will pop up again and what mayhem he will cause just like we did with Black Jack. Its not that we want Bree and Bonnet together, we just want SOMETHNG to happen other than the silly conflicts they have given us. Bonnet gives us something to fear and something to look forward to again.
ive seen a lot of acting in so many movies, briannas characters is such a powerful one, the gave her a lot of weight as a character and is sad that the rape is one of those reasons, the actress is charming, knows how to show her feelings, doesnt feel over reacted, and i love how she takes so much strenght like jaimey, her develpment as a character is so well done. There is no doubt about it, i mean, why brought characters like roger and bree to simply be extra characters? It was an inteligent decision to make the plot around them
@@truefrost1385 brianna's actress in season4 didn't show any realistic feelings nor reactions, she didn't play the character in a good way, she was just so terrible in her acting, but now in season5 i can say she's better than before, but still not playing brianna in a complete way. While stephen bonnet's actor has a lot of facial expressions and he moves a lot after everysinglecreepyword just like psycho and fun to watch and just very perfect for his role.
Lavi AWw that’s exactly how I felt. I felt like I was rolling my eyes every time Brianna did anything and I couldn’t tell if I didn’t like the character the show had turned her into or how the actress was playing her. I totally agree with how Ed played Bonnet! He actually made me scared a few times and then sick to my stomach when I felt an ounce of sympathy for him, but that’s all because of his great acting!
Great acting. You can see the scared the actor change Bonnets deameanor when his face morphs to a guilty child. Sophie Skelton acted with passion without over doing it. Fantastic!!
I could hear her real accent a bit when she said "anything". Either way, I really liked both of them in the scene. I hope he gets his butt kicked next season though, lol.
I love how Brianna came and saw him. And stood up to him saying that the child is her’s and that she will love it no matter who the father is. When I think about it this baby is the only good thing that came out of a horrible situation. And the baby will be so lucky to be with a family like the Fraser’s.
If Bonnet not the father then this mean the baby( can't think of his name) can never kill grow up and kill William son(whoever that is) since this son would be his ancestor. At the same time his ancestor would also be Brainna 2nd cousin. I wonder what would happen if if thier child did meet his 5th great grandfather who would probably be around his age and tried to kill him. Yeah i know it's crazy having an ancestor your age. Anyway would he disappear every time he try to kill him. William probably already had the son that will be his ancestor meaning Roger can probably kill his ass with no problem.
bjr is not charming or charismatic at all , he's just a sadist monster and nothing more, bonnet is way better than him and truly charming and fun to watch.
The amount of ppl cheering for Bonnett or saying he's better than Brianna in the comments makes me weep for humanity... (We all know the Brianna hate comes from one place, internalized misogyny, the fandom hates her for all the things they love about Jamie)
I just feel that Brianna's character is poorly written. Lack of charisma, I miss a 'dept' about her acting. Does not mean that I would cheer on a rapist. Like to see him hanging. But I think that the actor has more dept/intensity. And I do applaud his acting job.
To the people that complain about her acting do you see that Catriona wasn't too great in the first few episodes of season 1. Her acting improved over time. I would give her a little time. Then there are some who only care about Jamie and Claire. They don't want to get into Bree and Roger's stories. I actually find Roger more mentally and physically attractive in the books more than Jamie.
This scene....is powerful beyond words. I always, ALWAYS, love confrontation scenes between a victim and their attacker. When the victim can finally say their piece and be done with them, and move on. What the hell is up with people being so critical?? Sophie did amazing in this scene. Maybe she’s not so impressive in EVERY scene. But this scene, she was phenomenal. As was Ed. His facial changes, on cue and incredible. But why would anyone criticize Brianna for what she said?? Any rape victim could react this way. She was attempting to be calm at first; but the second he was smug, as if he was trying to overpower her psychologically again, the claws came out. I’m proud of Brianna for standing up to him like that. Showing that she will not allow him to live in her head, he will not hover forever like some black cloud over her or her child. Plus her words emerged vulnerability from Bonnet, for a second. Proving monster he is, but he was once human. And she will raise her child to be that, a good human being. Something he no longer is. Those words had to be said. Hell, what she said could be considered civil compared to what other girls I know would say. Go Bri!
I love Sophie as Brianna. She is incredible. There is something about Ed Speleers that makes me like Stephen Bonnet, there is something about the way he plays the character.
He knows he is an evil person - and Brianna makes him aware of his own evilness and that evilness will never taint her child - she will love that child because it is hers - not his - she is a better person then most - is it a revelation to him that her child will have a better life then he did because of her compassion not for Bonner but for her child. I think he sees in that child a life he never had -
I hate Stephen Bonnet's SIN, but there is something about his character that's mysterious. For an actor to stir hate on the evil character he portrays is already a job well done. But to still make audience love and root for a supposedly hated character, that is pure talent. I'm his fan now. And oh, btw, HE IS 🔥
Ed Speleer does a fantastic job as a villain. I just don't want to see him anywhere near the Frasers again. You know he's going to show up again though...for the ruby, Bree or the baby...
You may recognize actor Ed Speleers from Downton Abbey, as footman "Jimmy" Kent. As well as the starring role of "Eragon", in the Eragon movies. In case you were wondering where you'd seen him before. Also, many, many other roles over the years.
Great performance for Steven and Brianna. Not sure from this clip if this is his end or not but great job. You are a bad man Steven Bonnet but a heart does beat in your chest. We will see soon what happens with you. Will it be as the book tells the story??
Karen Nallo I think he is still alive . They drop the keys in the jail next to his door when they rescued murtaugh . The last thing they show is the jail house being blown up . But I’m pretty sure he escaped before the gunpowder blew up the place
In the book it was much different as I know, he clearly escapes the building before explosion and saves Gray, because Brianna asks him to and when they leave the building he offers her to go with him, but she declines and THAN, not in the prison, he gives her the stone...
Ana Jgenti am I completely horrible for wanting him to become a changed man so he can be a good father come back for Brianna and they can be a happy family and all his sins forgiven 😫😫😫 I really don’t like roger for Brianna ! He seems the farthest from a man 😤
@@NaFariaSalazar I understand your feelings so well... 😓 I don't see the chemistey between Roger and Brienna and of course it can't even be compared to the connection Claire and Jamie had from the very first moment... and since show creators are trying to make Brienna somewhat important (if not the main) character, there should be strong attraction between her and the man she is with, I think 🤷 her chemistry with lord John is also satisfying for me, because even after the fact that I like Bonnet (and it makes me feel horrible also), I can't come up with a happy ending for the man who raped her and herself... :(
Such a great scene by both Sophie and Ed. I'm glad Brianna got her closure but I wish she didn't tell him about the baby, he's probably going to try and find them. But maybe it's a good thing, maybe then Jamie can finally kill him..
Anyone who read the actual novels would NOT feel any affection for Steven Bonnett. The rape scene in particular was horrifying ( I actually think Diana Gabaldon went too far there).
If you listen to Bonnet he describes what made him into the monster that he became..He also shows tiny bits of caring and humanity at times..Of course you would be a fool to trust him but still its all there for anyone to understand if you just listen and read between the lines..
What she did was so brave, very few people could have stood in-front of their attacker like that. Not only did she have the courage to confront him but she also showed him a unique kindness in forgiving him and giving him the comfort in knowing that he will have something left on this earth after he’s gone. However I do believe that she shouldn’t have said anything about the child, Bonnet is a monster and now that he knows that baby is his or at least he thinks....he’s coming for him.
Many say that she did this only because he was tied, but she was going to face him whether he was tied or not because when she made her decision to see him, she didn't even think that he will be tied and that's very brave.
Most "monsters" are human. That doesn't make them good people. Remember also that bonnet does everything with a self-serving purpose. Even psychopaths can appear to be loving, caring or remorseful if it's in their interest. They view their children as possessions, and people as tools, useful or not useful. Bonnet knew he was going to escape, this wasn't an act of kindness.
Victoria VanDam Its because he is a deranged mental case. A 1760s jekyll and hyde. He has his good points and they are over taken by his "bad" mental case self
THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST SERIES I HAVE EVER WATCHED. SAM AND CAT REALLY MAKE YOU FEEL LIKE THEY TRULING LOVE EACH OTHER. I DON'T THINK THE SHOW WOULDMEVER BE THE SAME IF THEY LEFT THE SHOW. I WOULD LOVE TO SEE JAMIE BE ABLE TO KEEP HIS FAMILY TOGETHER WITH HIS DAUGHTER AND GRANDSON, SO HE WOULD HAVE THE CHANCE TO BE A FATHER AND GRANDFATHER. SINCE HE MISSED OUT ON RAISING HIS DAUGHTER.
Why does my heart hurts for Stephen Bonnet? I have always hated him since what he did at Episode 1 but at 2:35, my heart just breaks 💔💔💔 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 very good acting indeed
I hated it when she slapped her father, Jamie. I may sound weird but it took me a while to come out of that scene. I mean, Jamie is a gem of a person. If he hadn't sent Claire back and took the pain of separation, Brianna wouldn't have lived to see the days. It's so sad to see Jamie being slapped by his own daughter. That scene broke my heart.
How did Eragon get here? But on a serious note, Ed Speelers and Sophie Skelton both did an amazing job with this scene, it remains one of my favorites from the show!
Now, that was a really stupid thing to do. She didn't have to go there to forgive him and she didn't have to tell him the baby is his when she has no idea if it is or not? She made a target of herself and her baby.
Any book readers out there who don't spoil anything but could tell me if he really meant it when he gave that gem to her and kinda wants his child to not become like him or was he just pretending like when jamie helped him escape
Stupid of Bree to tell Bonnet about the baby. You KNOW he makes it out of there and at some point in the future will seek out his child! Can’t help but like him though!
@@cataliapavlo well i just looked at outlander bonnet on Google check that out and it basically showed me what it says in the books cause i dont have time either but it says thorbs sells her to bonnet to be sent to England to get her family out of the way then it says he kidnapped her i think the thorbs sounds more true
I haven't watched the new series but can anyone answer this question for me? Claire her mom was known in the earlier seasons for using a specific herb as birth control. They mentioned it several times during the earlier seasons and I'm sure they also had herbs that would cause no implantation to occur (like a plan B) if time and duration of taking the herb was a factor. Why didn't Brianna tell Claire about what happened and ask for that type of herb?
Stephen Bonnett was hung here in my hometown (Charleston,SC) He met his maker in a park called White Gardens.. He was hung there back on December 10, 1718 with I believe 25 other pirates ..I hope that they at least admit that he did not die when Fergus and the Regulators blew up the jail..I have not read the books so I have no clue which way it will be told in the series..However it might be a totally different scenario since the writer's tend to change some of the scenes that was in the books to make the series more interesting ..
In the past, the maturity(?) level was higher at a much younger age . Bonnet was a well known/established pirate w his own ship, his own crew, his own $ ...despite how he acquired it being ruthless. He was still in his 20-30s. He accepted death as a gotta pay to play & manipulated his way out of it until the very end. He never cried or whined about it. Brie showed a bravery most 40-50 yr olds today couldn’t handle by choosing to visit bonnet. Asking LJG to marry her, not to mention having the child despite not knowing if she’d see Roger ever again...& that it was most probably bonnets. Jamie.... sh*t Everyone, was willing to fight , protect and work their fingers to the bone just to survive. Honor is a huge thing. Too bad we’ve lost it.
And I read the books and I know what will happen. Bree didn't need to reveal her pregnancy to him. She just gave him an incentive to escape and keep tabs on her.
She made it about her to the point she ignored her own safety. She knew Bonnet was a crafty psycho and assumed 18th Century security would hold him. She would have heard by this point of Bonnet's notoriety in the community. I'm a survivor of sexual assault as well by someone devoid of a moral compass but I won't try to heal my anger by physically approaching him and blessing him with my forgiveness, not even with modern security measures in place.
@@harleyquinn5774 I think that not everyone react and heal the same way, and maybe she didn't think this through but i can't blame her for the way she choose to "end" this even with the whole problem of the lack of security in that century.
I rooted for him. I wanted more of his character. Bree is so stupid. Had she not confronted him and told his everything. She would have never encountered him ever. Bree makes a ton of mistakes. So does Roger. I loved Bree to meet her dad than go back home.
If Brianna been a boy she probably would have beaten Steven up pretty easy but then again Steven might have not even given her a chance to fight back in the first place.
Cela promet une scène très forte et c'est un moment portant de la série! Bonnet va se montrer sous un autre jour...mais il n'en reste passions un "horrible "personnage!
Forgiveness is easy when the person who wronged you is going to die. She forgave him in order to move on. She cannot love her child unless she forgives her rapist. When she finds out Bonnet is alive, she will not be so forgiving in season 5.
The actor for Stephen Bonnet is so good that I think I have come to hate the character as much as I hated Black Jack Randall. In this scene he totaly made me believe that he is some misguided dude, spoiled due to hardships and I really wanted to pity him. But then I had to remind myself that nothing gives anyone the right to violate any other. Its just sheer psychopathy that manipulates you into believing they are good people, while actually they are not.
Yes Bonnet is a complete psychopath and even in this scene, he doesn't feel any remorse towards Brianna (he is incapable or such sentiments), he is just excited to have a baby - a continuation of himself after his death. But yes, he is a product of his terrible life experiences early in life, other people made him what he is, so I can't help but feel sorry for him at the same time.
She didn't do it to make him care. She did it to herself to get some kind of closure. She couldn't murder her but by knowing that he is gonna die, it gives herself some kind of comfort.
What is one to do when you just finished watching Wilmington and you don't have several more hours to watch the rest because of work in the morning? You go to UA-cam to see what became of that fucking piece of shit. I can sleep well tonight ;)
brooklynbuglet In a previous episode when she tells her mom she’s pregnant she says that Roger withdrew when they did it (but they did it more than once that night) but when Bonnet raped her he didn’t withdraw. so that’s why she thinks it’s his baby but in reality it’s 50/50
Judge me all you want but I ship them!!! I think way way down the road there could be redemption and even romance maybe a possible love triangle, that could be great tv! Hey Luke and Lara did it. Luke raped Lara, fast forward several years later and they have two kids and are married and one of the most beloved soap opera couples of all time. Now listen if this was real life I wouldn’t even entertain the thought or if it was a different actor but the way Ed Speleers plays Bonnet I can’t help but find myself wanting to see so much more of this character, so many layers to peel back if they are smart he will be on the show for a long time.
hate to burst your bubble but in the books he is tied to a post to be swallowed up by the ocean tide and Brianna ends up shooting him the head to end his worst fear.
Please, please rethink this. You say "I wouldn't even entertain the thought if this was real life," but storylines like Luke and Laura are a big factor why many people in real life think, "ah, women may say no, but they mean yes." We HAVE to stop romanticizing rape as a culture, in fiction and everywhere else.
No bubble bursted, I have read the books so I already knew this. I hated him in the books but like I said above there is just something about the way this actor plays him that makes me feel differently than I did reading the books. There is a chemistry there.
Lol relax no need to get all upset and think I find rape at all ok or romantic. I have clearly stated that it’s the way the actor is playing the role that made me feel differently. I hated him in the books. Again it’s just the way the actor has played him that is drawing me in. It’s how I feel and I’m not going to apologize to anyone for it. If you don’t like my opinion that’s ok you’re just someone on UA-cam we never have to meet lol cheers
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m in no way rooting for Bonnet but you have to admit, he makes a FANTASTIC villain. He has that crazy vibe and just enough humanity to make him interesting.
I totally agree with that for both Bonnet and black jack Randall. And I have to say that in most of the cases all of the actors seem to have incredible facial expressions that can betray an emotion or what they're thinking without saying a word.
We can appreciate three-dimensional, well-acted villains and still KNOW that we'd NEVER want to know such people in real life.
He was so charming...that was unexpected.
He's no Black Jack Randall but he's a good villain. If u read the books (or see the scene where he asks her to teach him to be a gentleman) then u'll know that this lunatic doesn't even know how to be a person.
He doesn't even know what he did to Brianna was rape. He even tells her how to better perform the next time they're together. That's wen she realizes that he doesn't even know what he took from her. He doesn't know it's rape. He actually tells her to take whatever she wants from his valuables becoz he thinks that's how it works: u take your pleasure, she takes your treasure. And he actually likes her so much he wants her to have whatever she wants. It's so disturbing.
Red-headed Frasers have the incredible misfortune of being the objects of the twisted affections of murdering rapists.
Another thing I hate abt the TV writers is that they don't explain y Brianna feels the need to be sympathetic towards Bonnet. Wen she talks to Jamie abt it, she does ask if it wud help to kill him. What they don't show is that Jamie told her that what helped him get past wat Randall did was finding sympathy for that beast.
Maybe it's becoz I read the book that I understand his total lack of understanding.
He didn't recognize Brianna, he didn't know what he did was wrong. To me, he's just a rabid dog that needs to be put down.
And I feel like, in a way, Bree unerstood it too. And I'm not agreeing with the series that made her appease him.
I'm just saying that she realized he was not worth her time or her guilt.
She rook the high road and she was free
Took her alot of courage to do this,dont know of many women that would confront her assailant. Powerful scene I think.
When I watched it I said to myself that if I was Bree I could never face him
It was a foolish and unnecessary thing to do. It served no purpose other than to make more trouble. He didn’t even remember her.
@@mokachyna22 excuse me?! who the FUCK are you to say ANYTHING?
Oh it can be done sugar! 😉 But you are right it takes a ton of courage!
Brianna made a mistake telling him about that baby. I suspect it won’t be the last time she sees him.
I agree, maybe thats why the author did that
Anyone watch the newest episode?
@@shelly3658 Yup... it furthers the plot.
That look he gave her when she said I’ll raise my child to be a good person. Wooooweeee now he’s a good actor. The regret and hurt on his face on cue yeesh.
I think the reason people like Bonnet so much is because, well first, he is a great actor and fun to watch. Second, the show has gotten a bit stale. All of the conflict seems superficial and silly. Jamie or Claire get in trouble because they are always wanting to play savior and acting foolishly. Bree and Rogers conflicts seem childish and make their characters unlikable. Example: Bree and Roger just get “married”, he has risk his life and throws away the world he knows to find her in another time and she tells him to get lost over what should have been a small fight.
Having a big baddie again, like Bonnet, gives us something to care about. We will be wondering when he will pop up again and what mayhem he will cause just like we did with Black Jack. Its not that we want Bree and Bonnet together, we just want SOMETHNG to happen other than the silly conflicts they have given us. Bonnet gives us something to fear and something to look forward to again.
ive seen a lot of acting in so many movies, briannas characters is such a powerful one, the gave her a lot of weight as a character and is sad that the rape is one of those reasons, the actress is charming, knows how to show her feelings, doesnt feel over reacted, and i love how she takes so much strenght like jaimey, her develpment as a character is so well done. There is no doubt about it, i mean, why brought characters like roger and bree to simply be extra characters? It was an inteligent decision to make the plot around them
@@truefrost1385 brianna's actress in season4 didn't show any realistic feelings nor reactions, she didn't play the character in a good way, she was just so terrible in her acting, but now in season5 i can say she's better than before, but still not playing brianna in a complete way. While stephen bonnet's actor has a lot of facial expressions and he moves a lot after everysinglecreepyword just like psycho and fun to watch and just very perfect for his role.
Yeah, I was waiting on a villian since Jack Randall. That dude was awesome. Not as a person, but you know.
Lavi AWw that’s exactly how I felt. I felt like I was rolling my eyes every time Brianna did anything and I couldn’t tell if I didn’t like the character the show had turned her into or how the actress was playing her. I totally agree with how Ed played Bonnet! He actually made me scared a few times and then sick to my stomach when I felt an ounce of sympathy for him, but that’s all because of his great acting!
gluten free bleach I totally know lol. Gone too soon!
Great acting. You can see the scared the actor change Bonnets deameanor when his face morphs to a guilty child. Sophie Skelton acted with passion without over doing it. Fantastic!!
Chad Lamoureux Also the first time she didn't slap or punch somebody out of anger ..I was half expecting that .
@@joannaarmstrong4720 The slapping is true to the books when she does it, so.
She struggles with the accent a little.
Shocked he posess a soft spot like other humans!😕
I could hear her real accent a bit when she said "anything". Either way, I really liked both of them in the scene. I hope he gets his butt kicked next season though, lol.
Ed Speleer does a fantastic job in every scene he is a part of. 👏👏
I love how Brianna came and saw him. And stood up to him saying that the child is her’s and that she will love it no matter who the father is. When I think about it this baby is the only good thing that came out of a horrible situation. And the baby will be so lucky to be with a family like the Fraser’s.
And I believe it's not the scum's baby right?
It's Rogers!
@@carolinesalv not sure they make the baby looks like bonnet in the tv show
If Bonnet not the father then this mean the baby( can't think of his name) can never kill grow up and kill William son(whoever that is) since this son would be his ancestor. At the same time his ancestor would also be Brainna 2nd cousin. I wonder what would happen if if thier child did meet his 5th great grandfather who would probably be around his age and tried to kill him. Yeah i know it's crazy having an ancestor your age. Anyway would he disappear every time he try to kill him. William probably already had the son that will be his ancestor meaning Roger can probably kill his ass with no problem.
His facial expressions are amazing
He did an amazing job. Just like Randall's character there is something charming and charismatic yet frighteningly evil about Bonnet
bjr is not charming or charismatic at all , he's just a sadist monster and nothing more, bonnet is way better than him and truly charming and fun to watch.
Lavi AWw well, i liked both of them because im into psychopaths and im a dumb bitch lmao
@@laviaww2256 I though Randall was charming in a weird British way. Both of them were sadist monsters and great villians.
@@queerlibtardhippie9357 stephen is not sadist, but yup he was a great villian.
@@laviaww2256 It wasn't sexual sadism; it was a power sadism; if that makes sense.
The amount of ppl cheering for Bonnett or saying he's better than Brianna in the comments makes me weep for humanity...
(We all know the Brianna hate comes from one place, internalized misogyny, the fandom hates her for all the things they love about Jamie)
You hit the nail right on the head.
Facts!
I just don't think she's a good actress, so...
I just feel that Brianna's character is poorly written. Lack of charisma, I miss a 'dept' about her acting.
Does not mean that I would cheer on a rapist. Like to see him hanging.
But I think that the actor has more dept/intensity. And I do applaud his acting job.
To the people that complain about her acting do you see that Catriona wasn't too great in the first few episodes of season 1. Her acting improved over time. I would give her a little time. Then there are some who only care about Jamie and Claire. They don't want to get into Bree and Roger's stories. I actually find Roger more mentally and physically attractive in the books more than Jamie.
God I’m in love with the way the actor plays him
He's just so f*cking lovely, dammit. 😘
love this. Brianna actually made Stephen seem to care that he completely scarred her.
This scene....is powerful beyond words. I always, ALWAYS, love confrontation scenes between a victim and their attacker. When the victim can finally say their piece and be done with them, and move on.
What the hell is up with people being so critical??
Sophie did amazing in this scene. Maybe she’s not so impressive in EVERY scene. But this scene, she was phenomenal. As was Ed. His facial changes, on cue and incredible.
But why would anyone criticize Brianna for what she said??
Any rape victim could react this way. She was attempting to be calm at first; but the second he was smug, as if he was trying to overpower her psychologically again, the claws came out. I’m proud of Brianna for standing up to him like that. Showing that she will not allow him to live in her head, he will not hover forever like some black cloud over her or her child.
Plus her words emerged vulnerability from Bonnet, for a second. Proving monster he is, but he was once human.
And she will raise her child to be that, a good human being. Something he no longer is. Those words had to be said. Hell, what she said could be considered civil compared to what other girls I know would say.
Go Bri!
Finally someone who doesn't romanticize rapists based on looks.
Isabella.Moon. Rose The fact that there are people who actually do that is disturbing.
Back in the first episode of season 4 I knew this actor is someone important to rest of the show because he has this kind of charming appearance.
I love Sophie as Brianna. She is incredible. There is something about Ed Speleers that makes me like Stephen Bonnet, there is something about the way he plays the character.
To me he feels very diffrent from his book character
@@EstherHulst-Artist Yea it think he's supposed to be taller and scarier
Yes. Me too. He’s like black jack Randal you love to hate him.
I still see Jimmy Kent, only he's gone psychopath.
@@ceeceediamond323 stephen bonnet is way better than Black jack randall, just saying .. (i'm talking about the acting)
This scene was amazingly done by both actors.
Ed speelers.. one word.. outstanding
He knows he is an evil person - and Brianna makes him aware of his own evilness and that evilness will never taint her child - she will love that child because it is hers - not his - she is a better person then most - is it a revelation to him that her child will have a better life then he did because of her compassion not for Bonner but for her child. I think he sees in that child a life he never had -
Brilliant acting by Sophie and Ed Speerler. I’d love to see more of them which hopefully will happen.
Even though his charachter is a son of a bitch , That bonnet guy is really good actor ;)
deadoralive cowboy he’s a good actor he was good in downton abbey as well
He was also the kid from eragon
@@annythekettle7031 he looks and sounds unrecognizable hes so thin in the face deeper voice good acting
To think this man played Eragon...
OH MY GOD!!!! You're right!!! I didn't even recognize him!! Now that you say that though i totally see it now!!
I'm sorry... what. Did. You. Just say?!?! *furiously googles*
We do not speak of "that film".
THAT’S where I know him from! It’s been bugging me for ages!
Thats why he looks familiar!
I hate Stephen Bonnet's SIN, but there is something about his character that's mysterious. For an actor to stir hate on the evil character he portrays is already a job well done. But to still make audience love and root for a supposedly hated character, that is pure talent. I'm his fan now. And oh, btw, HE IS 🔥
I hope he doesn't get killed off the show too quickly, I want to see more from him. Ed Speleers is amazing as Stephen Bonnet. ❤️
@Lucky You will sure see more of him. 😉
This was one of the best scenes ever in outlander
Ed Speleer does a fantastic job as a villain. I just don't want to see him anywhere near the Frasers again. You know he's going to show up again though...for the ruby, Bree or the baby...
susanne chakan he doesn’t truly care about the ruby though
you're right...Eeeek
He will if it follows the books and it has so far I’ll not say no more than that
Leah vapes86 what happens in the books?
Thank you so much four posting this Video! ! Can't wait to watch the episode. ...
Mama I’m in love with a criminal
Ikr
Love the song...
There is more chemistry between Bonnet and Brianna than between her and Roger...
I hate Roger so much, he is an asshole😌😅
Hahaha I hate how true that is
Omg yes
............are you for real?
Ed is handsome
You may recognize actor Ed Speleers from Downton Abbey, as footman "Jimmy" Kent.
As well as the starring role of "Eragon", in the Eragon movies.
In case you were wondering where you'd seen him before.
Also, many, many other roles over the years.
Best scene of this episode! ❤️
1.29 that childish look on his face.... made me feel some mercy for him.
Great performance for Steven and Brianna. Not sure from this clip if this is his end or not but great job. You are a bad man Steven Bonnet but a heart does beat in your chest. We will see soon what happens with you. Will it be as the book tells the story??
Karen Nallo I think he is still alive . They drop the keys in the jail next to his door when they rescued murtaugh . The last thing they show is the jail house being blown up . But I’m pretty sure he escaped before the gunpowder blew up the place
Well he won't die for a while intill its his time just like what jamie said all men like that will get whats coming to em
In the book it was much different as I know, he clearly escapes the building before explosion and saves Gray, because Brianna asks him to and when they leave the building he offers her to go with him, but she declines and THAN, not in the prison, he gives her the stone...
Ana Jgenti am I completely horrible for wanting him to become a changed man so he can be a good father come back for Brianna and they can be a happy family and all his sins forgiven 😫😫😫 I really don’t like roger for Brianna ! He seems the farthest from a man 😤
@@NaFariaSalazar I understand your feelings so well... 😓 I don't see the chemistey between Roger and Brienna and of course it can't even be compared to the connection Claire and Jamie had from the very first moment... and since show creators are trying to make Brienna somewhat important (if not the main) character, there should be strong attraction between her and the man she is with, I think 🤷 her chemistry with lord John is also satisfying for me, because even after the fact that I like Bonnet (and it makes me feel horrible also), I can't come up with a happy ending for the man who raped her and herself... :(
Two amazing actors. Love that Brianna took her power back!
I think he has survived during explosion in 4th season. Because somewhen he said to Clair he is afraid of water und is sure he will die by drowning.
Such a great scene by both Sophie and Ed. I'm glad Brianna got her closure but I wish she didn't tell him about the baby, he's probably going to try and find them. But maybe it's a good thing, maybe then Jamie can finally kill him..
The only thing is I don't think he is dead. People like Bonnett always manage to have one more surprise left to them.
Anyone who read the actual novels would NOT feel any affection for Steven Bonnett.
The rape scene in particular was horrifying ( I actually think Diana Gabaldon went too far there).
That’s true. Since the first time he attacked Claire on the ship I just couldn’t like him.
If you listen to Bonnet he describes what made him into the monster that he became..He also shows tiny bits of caring and humanity at times..Of course you would be a fool to trust him but still its all there for anyone to understand if you just listen and read between the lines..
I think that a lot of people like Steven Bonnet is because the actor has so much charisma.
Something I'm lacking in Brianna's character.
True
She is bland
She needed closure but I don’t think she should’ve told him about the baby
What she did was so brave, very few people could have stood in-front of their attacker like that. Not only did she have the courage to confront him but she also showed him a unique kindness in forgiving him and giving him the comfort in knowing that he will have something left on this earth after he’s gone. However I do believe that she shouldn’t have said anything about the child, Bonnet is a monster and now that he knows that baby is his or at least he thinks....he’s coming for him.
Many say that she did this only because he was tied, but she was going to face him whether he was tied or not because when she made her decision to see him, she didn't even think that he will be tied and that's very brave.
I laughed so hard when I saw the keys in Bonnet's cell later in the episode
I can never get it out of my head that he played the main character in Eragon my favourite childhood movie.
Ed is really good actor ! Please Hollywood take him for another serie/movie 🙏🙏
Why did you need this!? I was fine seeing him as a monster and you had to go make him human.
Most "monsters" are human. That doesn't make them good people. Remember also that bonnet does everything with a self-serving purpose. Even psychopaths can appear to be loving, caring or remorseful if it's in their interest. They view their children as possessions, and people as tools, useful or not useful. Bonnet knew he was going to escape, this wasn't an act of kindness.
Victoria VanDam he’s another blackjack and he’ll be back to claim what’s his..should be outstanding!
Victoria VanDam
Its because he is a deranged mental case. A 1760s jekyll and hyde. He has his good points and they are over taken by his "bad" mental case self
Humans can be monsters.
THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST SERIES I HAVE EVER WATCHED. SAM AND CAT REALLY MAKE YOU FEEL LIKE THEY TRULING LOVE EACH OTHER. I DON'T THINK THE SHOW WOULDMEVER BE THE SAME IF THEY LEFT THE SHOW. I WOULD LOVE TO SEE JAMIE BE ABLE TO KEEP HIS FAMILY TOGETHER WITH HIS DAUGHTER AND GRANDSON, SO HE WOULD HAVE THE CHANCE TO BE A FATHER AND GRANDFATHER. SINCE HE MISSED OUT ON RAISING HIS DAUGHTER.
Oh dear god that look he is a great actor really one of the best 1:30 just look at him 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Ed Speleers was so different in Downton Abbey. What an actor!
And after all that, the child ended up not being Bonnets afterall.
Why does my heart hurts for Stephen Bonnet? I have always hated him since what he did at Episode 1 but at 2:35, my heart just breaks 💔💔💔
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 very good acting indeed
I hated it when she slapped her father, Jamie. I may sound weird but it took me a while to come out of that scene. I mean, Jamie is a gem of a person. If he hadn't sent Claire back and took the pain of separation, Brianna wouldn't have lived to see the days. It's so sad to see Jamie being slapped by his own daughter. That scene broke my heart.
Who tf slaps their own father .. that was so… not right
I love this scene, such great acting from both of them!
How did Eragon get here? But on a serious note, Ed Speelers and Sophie Skelton both did an amazing job with this scene, it remains one of my favorites from the show!
For real! That was my introduction to him and he was this cute hero and now look at him! So crazy
Now, that was a really stupid thing to do. She didn't have to go there to forgive him and she didn't have to tell him the baby is his when she has no idea if it is or not? She made a target of herself and her baby.
I thought he was going to say he cant have kids
Wouldn't that of been nice .
It’s Rogers anyway ...
@@m.b.1111 Rogers baby?
frenxasca1
Yes,it’s Roger’s child.
@@Wlf5953 How do you know that ?
Any book readers out there who don't spoil anything but could tell me if he really meant it when he gave that gem to her and kinda wants his child to not become like him or was he just pretending like when jamie helped him escape
MissPenguin He actually meant it. He didn’t really care about the gem
Stupid of Bree to tell Bonnet about the baby. You KNOW he makes it out of there and at some point in the future will seek out his child! Can’t help but like him though!
Deborah Streb
Brianna does a lot of stupid things through out the books but this one tops the list .
You like a character who is a rapist? Seriously?
@@alishamacaulay1710 Why he kidnapped her? Whats the point of kidnapping here? Please tell me! I dont have the time to read the books!
Gina Dexter The ACTOR!
@@cataliapavlo well i just looked at outlander bonnet on Google check that out and it basically showed me what it says in the books cause i dont have time either but it says thorbs sells her to bonnet to be sent to England to get her family out of the way then it says he kidnapped her i think the thorbs sounds more true
So this is what happens when Eragon goes to the dark side
Am i the only one who gets chills watching scene...
I haven't watched the new series but can anyone answer this question for me? Claire her mom was known in the earlier seasons for using a specific herb as birth control. They mentioned it several times during the earlier seasons and I'm sure they also had herbs that would cause no implantation to occur (like a plan B) if time and duration of taking the herb was a factor. Why didn't Brianna tell Claire about what happened and ask for that type of herb?
Duszka I think at that time, Brianna didn’t know about the herb... just Claire.
Stephen Bonnett was hung here in my hometown (Charleston,SC) He met his maker in a park called White Gardens.. He was hung there back on December 10, 1718 with I believe 25 other pirates ..I hope that they at least admit that he did not die when Fergus and the Regulators blew up the jail..I have not read the books so I have no clue which way it will be told in the series..However it might be a totally different scenario since the writer's tend to change some of the scenes that was in the books to make the series more interesting ..
Stephen Bonnet's death was one of the most dramatic scenes in the books, so I doubt they will change it. But in the books, he wasn't hanged.
@@aumelb How does he die in the books?
@@annythekettle7031 sorry I don't want to spoil it for other people here who haven't read the books.
@@aumelb I don't mind
@@annythekettle7031 the comments are public. My responses can be read by anyone, not only you.
1:32 OMG NOOOO tis the puppy eyes
Even though bonnet did that to her, he does seem to have some compassion
I think a lot more could have been done with this character and I wish it would have
Extraordinary acting!
In the past, the maturity(?) level was higher at a much younger age . Bonnet was a well known/established pirate w his own ship, his own crew, his own $ ...despite how he acquired it being ruthless. He was still in his 20-30s. He accepted death as a gotta pay to play & manipulated his way out of it until the very end. He never cried or whined about it. Brie showed a bravery most 40-50 yr olds today couldn’t handle by choosing to visit bonnet. Asking LJG to marry her, not to mention having the child despite not knowing if she’d see Roger ever again...& that it was most probably bonnets. Jamie.... sh*t Everyone, was willing to fight , protect and work their fingers to the bone just to survive. Honor is a huge thing. Too bad we’ve lost it.
Holy sh*t, I didn't recognise Ed Speleers there..🙈
Does this mean Brianna thinks bonnet is the actual dad?
No, Bree. Nooooo! Don’t tell the bastard that. You didn’t even mention Roger!
It's not about Bonnet or Roger, she needed a close to what he did to her, it was about her and what she wanted.
And I read the books and I know what will happen. Bree didn't need to reveal her pregnancy to him. She just gave him an incentive to escape and keep tabs on her.
@@harleyquinn5774 but how could she know that? Bree thought he was going to die. Anyway it still was about her, not Roger or Bonnet.
She made it about her to the point she ignored her own safety. She knew Bonnet was a crafty psycho and assumed 18th Century security would hold him. She would have heard by this point of Bonnet's notoriety in the community. I'm a survivor of sexual assault as well by someone devoid of a moral compass but I won't try to heal my anger by physically approaching him and blessing him with my forgiveness, not even with modern security measures in place.
@@harleyquinn5774 I think that not everyone react and heal the same way, and maybe she didn't think this through but i can't blame her for the way she choose to "end" this even with the whole problem of the lack of security in that century.
2:23 Ignore the bribing and protect yourself.
I rooted for him. I wanted more of his character. Bree is so stupid. Had she not confronted him and told his everything. She would have never encountered him ever. Bree makes a ton of mistakes. So does Roger. I loved Bree to meet her dad than go back home.
lmao I will never understand woman like you who sympathize with rapist
Amazing great job
If Brianna been a boy she probably would have beaten Steven up pretty easy but then again Steven might have not even given her a chance to fight back in the first place.
Cela promet une scène très forte et c'est un moment portant de la série! Bonnet va se montrer sous un autre jour...mais il n'en reste passions un "horrible "personnage!
Non???
Season 5 will be very interesting . He seemed remorseful
Probably a stone he stole from her family anyhow.
Correct! It was one of the stones he stole from jaime and claire when he attacked them
Forgiveness is easy when the person who wronged you is going to die. She forgave him in order to move on. She cannot love her child unless she forgives her rapist. When she finds out Bonnet is alive, she will not be so forgiving in season 5.
I must wait till tomorrow... I’m so excited.
Mel Same in Australia the only two options for getting good quality are pay tv or iTunes season pass.
Ugh, Sophie and Ed had incredible chemistry.
Reminds me of Ramsey and Sansa last scene in game of thrones
Sophie was so great in this scene!
Love you Ed speleer, you are a handsome guy
Un hijo lo cambia todo creo yo que está arrepentido Bonnett Con su carita triste
The actor for Stephen Bonnet is so good that I think I have come to hate the character as much as I hated Black Jack Randall. In this scene he totaly made me believe that he is some misguided dude, spoiled due to hardships and I really wanted to pity him. But then I had to remind myself that nothing gives anyone the right to violate any other. Its just sheer psychopathy that manipulates you into believing they are good people, while actually they are not.
Yes Bonnet is a complete psychopath and even in this scene, he doesn't feel any remorse towards Brianna (he is incapable or such sentiments), he is just excited to have a baby - a continuation of himself after his death. But yes, he is a product of his terrible life experiences early in life, other people made him what he is, so I can't help but feel sorry for him at the same time.
He just wants his bloodline to continue. It was a huge thing back then. It's not like they can leave their "legacy" on the internet and be sastisfied.
Just goes to show bad/evil/digusting people are capable of doing good somehow.... also when faced with certain death makes one act differently.
Brianna is silly to tell him about her baby
She obviously didn't know he was gonna escape.
Why would he care that she's pregnant? She didn't need to see him
She didn't do it to make him care. She did it to herself to get some kind of closure. She couldn't murder her but by knowing that he is gonna die, it gives herself some kind of comfort.
@@Illumnia548 that makes sense, thanks!
Does anyone else still love him
In a way I would love to see them fall in love with each other, his acting is so good makes you want to give him another chance...
Rachel Eloise O'Neill ... h- he literally raped her I- 😶
Like. No. Just no.
He’s too evil tho :(
Cuarta temporada Netflix CR cuando la ponen para verla
seguro la suben antes q se estrene la quinta, como hicieron con la 3
Si eres de México y tienes Telmex puede verla en clarovideo 👍👍
@@GabrielaCordova93 soy de CR y la estoy esperando q la pongan en Nexfli gracias
j'ai bien aimé ce passage
Is he Jimmy from Downton Abbey?
You would be correct
What is one to do when you just finished watching Wilmington and you don't have several more hours to watch the rest because of work in the morning?
You go to UA-cam to see what became of that fucking piece of shit.
I can sleep well tonight ;)
So the fact that she doesn't know who the father is was thrown out the window I guess...
In the books, it is revealed that the father of her baby is Roger.
@@matth.7276 Good 👍
Can anyone tell me what the last line Roger says as he goes back to the hut with the Indians?
Karen Nallo "that's right lads, take me back to the idiot hut"
Karen Nallo I was wondering the same thing. I kept rewinding it and tried to read his lips even lol thank you for asking 😉
Rachael C.
That’s a very 19th century way of thinking but your a highlander at heart
Roger.
@Karen Nallo: "I want a lawyer."
He tossed in the F-word also right? t least that is what it sounded like to me..Lol
Less than three hours! Whew-- !
I'm confused. I thought there was a chance it could be either Steven or Roger's child? why has Roger been ruled out as the father?
brooklynbuglet In a previous episode when she tells her mom she’s pregnant she says that Roger withdrew when they did it (but they did it more than once that night) but when Bonnet raped her he didn’t withdraw. so that’s why she thinks it’s his baby but in reality it’s 50/50
In the books it is later revealed that Roger is in fact the father of the baby due to a birthmark.
@@matth.7276 Bonnet will be pissed
Judge me all you want but I ship them!!! I think way way down the road there could be redemption and even romance maybe a possible love triangle, that could be great tv! Hey Luke and Lara did it. Luke raped Lara, fast forward several years later and they have two kids and are married and one of the most beloved soap opera couples of all time. Now listen if this was real life I wouldn’t even entertain the thought or if it was a different actor but the way Ed Speleers plays Bonnet I can’t help but find myself wanting to see so much more of this character, so many layers to peel back if they are smart he will be on the show for a long time.
hate to burst your bubble but in the books he is tied to a post to be swallowed up by the ocean tide and Brianna ends up shooting him the head to end his worst fear.
Please, please rethink this.
You say "I wouldn't even entertain the thought if this was real life," but storylines like Luke and Laura are a big factor why many people in real life think, "ah, women may say no, but they mean yes."
We HAVE to stop romanticizing rape as a culture, in fiction and everywhere else.
No bubble bursted, I have read the books so I already knew this. I hated him in the books but like I said above there is just something about the way this actor plays him that makes me feel differently than I did reading the books. There is a chemistry there.
Lol relax no need to get all upset and think I find rape at all ok or romantic. I have clearly stated that it’s the way the actor is playing the role that made me feel differently. I hated him in the books. Again it’s just the way the actor has played him that is drawing me in. It’s how I feel and I’m not going to apologize to anyone for it. If you don’t like my opinion that’s ok you’re just someone on UA-cam we never have to meet lol cheers
Who are Luke and Lara? Are they from a book or TV series?
Very much reminds me of Sansa Stark and Ramsay Bolton