Panasonic Lumix G9 II Video IBIS Test vs OM1/GH6/S5II/XH2/R7/G9
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
- Remember to checkout my Panasonic Lumix G9II full review :)
• A New Phase of Micro F...
Instagram: / photo_by_richard
My Miniature Photography Instagram: / toycapturer
Facebook: / photobyrichard
#lumixg9ii #ibis #panasonicg9II
Thanks for taking the time to do such an extensive test. I was very impressed with the G9II, particularly at the longer focal lengths 👏🏻 OM-1, S5II and R7 were all very good too, but all beaten by the G9II IMHO. The Fuji was left behind by the others in this IBIS competition.
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed the video
The S5II at 24mm looked like it was gliding and it was smoother than the G9II 😍
Dude, are you blindfolded? Look at the corners on the S5II
Not one word said, yet a better test then all those reviewers who talk constantly in a cozy studio👍
Surprised by the good Canon stabilization!
Thanks for doing these tests.
No need to surprise canon has the best ibis in the business 8 stops
but not in longer focal length. g9 ii has the edge in all focal length
@@dmgfilmproductionandphotog1567 actually depends on the lens... canon rf 135mm f1.8 has IS on the lens... it is super stabil when combined with the excellent ibis
Much appreciated extensive test!
Thank you too!
longer focal lens stabilization is superb in g9 ii
Awesome Refreshing video 😁 Thanks for letting the images speak for themselves 😁
Yes, I let you decide which camera is the best yourself :)
Thank you Richard, really good job, for me only the OM-1 can compare with the G9ii
I hope the EIS algorithm of the G9II could be added to the S5II via firmware
@shariqahmed336 EIS, no IBIS. The EIS in G9II can correct the corner problems of IBIS when using wide angle lenses.
@shariqahmed336 no! Compute power required have nothing to do with the sensor size, only with pixel count, export resolution, way of get the resolution (line skipping, all I or IPB, binning, noise treatment, etc) and códec. A M4/3 sensor with 26mp requires more computation power than a FF sensor with 24mp if all other things are the same
@shariqahmed336 it's true, please don't be moronic. For the price no way oc. Obviously a full frame it's pricier because the sensor is a lot pricier. We are talking about compute power, not about price. There are several cameras with a lot more power than the G9II and a lot better video specs in the full frame realm. Just don't expect to be cheap...
@shariqahmed336 nooooo! Oh man. The GH5II have less pixels, so it need less compute power. The faster readout is linked to that too, and with the physical size. But the most important thing is that smaller the sensor then less heat is produced. But you have cameras like the Nikon Z8, with a FF sensor, with less rolling shutter and faster readout than any M4/3, with far better video specs. But obviously is pricier. One thing is clear: compute power have nothing to do with physical size, only with pixel count and data treatment, there are things more demanding and other that are easier (like line skipping IPB video vs down sampled all intra video; or 8bit 4-2-0 vs 10bit 4-2-2)
@shariqahmed336 no! I'm not confused. Please, man. GH5, 20mp; S5 24mp.
👍🙏🏾 G9 II is a Winner 🍷
I was pleasantly surprised how good the R7 was and shocked how terrible the X-H2 was. G9 ii and OM1 are the kings. G9 ii being just a hair better. Not really noticeable.
Great test thank you.!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and watching the video
The author of the video did not use O.I.S. for X-H2 (plays a crucial role in stabilization). But in comparison, O.I.S. was in the test for some reason at Canon R7 11:30
Why the author didn't use OIS for X-H2?
Is this done on purpose?
@@Sky-ne5gn I didn’t know that. It explains to an extent why. Regardless the stabilization shouldn’t be that terrible. It looked as though there was none.
@@Sky-ne5gnthe 33mm Fujinon doesn't have OIS. How would he 'activate' it? The 25mm on the G9II also doesn't have OIS. The xh2 IBIS is simply trash.
@@elzafir All Fujifilm KIT lenses have stabilization (OIS) -
Fujinon XF 18-55mm f/2.8-4 R LM OIS
Fujinon XC 15-45mm F3.5-5.6 OIS PZ
Fujinon XF 16-80mm F4 R OIS WR
The EIS in G9II really makes a difference. I have GH6, I just could not find any benefit of turn on EIS.
Great video!! Do you think the G9ii will eliminate ultra wide angle wobble on the normal EIS mode or do you have to use the high setting with 25% crop for that? I shoot with Tokina 11-20 on Metabones XL and the wobble on G9 v1 is unbearable but I can't stand the thought of a 25% crop.
The g9ii's stability is crazy good
LET'S RUN! Love it! Amazing change of atmosphere too... Wow super impressed with your commitment Richard! G9II rocks! esp. at those longer focal lengths... Would have love to have seen it against S5II at 50mm... Any ideas? Thanks Rich!
hey Ben! thank you! Re vs S5II at 50mm, "i think" i did some quick test and the results were very similar. But overall, the wide angle is quite similar between the two camera, but once you get to telephoto end, then the G9II becomes noticeably better
Ah! That's Good to know @@TheRealRichardWong !!! It would be great to shoot wide up to 50mm, maybe even 85mm with awesome stabilisation for narrative work: LOVE The G9II! But also would love the S5II
GREAT Comparrison! Pity that you did not manage to test OM-1 Sync-IS vs G9II dualIS but still great.
Thanks. yes there are quite a few things i want to test.. Sync-IS vs Dual-IS at short and long focal length, Sony A6700 vs G9II, Canon R7 with IBIS only vs G9II IBIS only...etc.
Unfortunately it's not easy to organise all the camera/lenses I want within a short period of time
@@TheRealRichardWong I imagine. This was not a criticism, nor even request. However Comparison of OM-1 + 12-100mm PRO vs G9II + Leica 12-60mm would end this discussion of who has the best IS system once and for all. And the cross test (with lenses mixed) would be also helpfull. If that would be within your reach this could be beneficial to many potential m43 users.
Yes i understand that and i do really appreciate all the feedbacks/comments and even criticisms as they all help me to improve. For the comparison you suggest... are you (or people) more interested in photo IBIS comparison or video IBIS comparison? Not saying I can do that, but I would like to know what people are interested in the most if i got a chance to test and compare them. Ideally i would test both, but in reality i may only have to focus on one.
@@TheRealRichardWong video. Photo IS reaches impractical territories already
the canon r7 stabilization looks better than the g9ii. at the wide angle.
Which camera has the best video IBIS performance?
*** CORRECTION: The Canon R7 15mm video at 11:12 was actually shot at 18mm ***
OLYMPUS
G9II is the best (OM1 looks like may be equal), Second is GH6 and S5İİ is the third.
G9II by far. At 9mm and 12mm OM-1 was equal but at longer focal lengths G9II was better. Unfortunately there was no comparison between OM-1 Sync-IS (12-100mm PRO) vs G9II Dual-IS (Leica 12-60mm). That would be the ultimate comparison @12mm, 25mm and 60mm.
G9II. The R7 is surprising.
Walking at wide angle. I see s5II, OM1 and R7 slightly ahead of G9II. But once focal length goes longer. G9II is the best among them.
G9ii seems to be on par or only slightly better than the S5ii, GH6 and OM1 at the wider focal lengths, but the EIS gets rid of the wobble, which makes it much more usable. However at the longer focal lengths, there is quite a difference.
Look at 8:31 lumix g9ii is clearly better
Hi Richart.. if you had the oppertunity. Please test the ibis G9ii vs Nikon Zf 🙏
I have been trying to get hold of a Zf to do a review, unfortunately there isn't even one in New Zealand yet. If i managed to get one and still haven't return the G9II, i would do a test!
Great work!
Thank you! Cheers!
Incorrect test. FUJIFILM should be with optical stabilization O.I.S. X-H2 is used in conjunction with IBIS +OIS+DIS (for maximum stabilization) and it is O.I.S. that plays a crucial role. But it was not in comparison, however, O.I.S. was in the test for some reason at Canon R7 11:30
Why didn't you use OIS for X-H2?
Great comparison, very useful. Two things: G9II is unbeatable with longer lenses and R7 is very very good (surprisingly good)
yes , i also said the same thing in my G9II review, i was very surprised by R7's performance.
Amazing work!!
Hello Richard, thank you for putting this comparison video together!! Great insight into how different cameras+lens+IBIS working together. Lovely music too. Like that classical piece starting around 5:00. Just curious about what platform do you source your music from? Would you mind sharing? Thanks. Mark.
Glad it was helpful Mark! I have been using "Epidemic Sound" for my UA-cam background music for a few years now. It's not free, actually it's one of the more expensive music library around. But i tried a few free/cheaper one and keep having issues so just keep using Epidemic Sound.
Thanks for this hard Test.👍
Thanks for watching @essiturbo!
how was it not obvious how much better the s5ii wqas to the g9ii??? (just IBIS)
with wider lenses that is, clearly
how much stabilization has become better on G9 compared to g9 ii? Can I use g9 ii without gimbal by walking?
How much is quite hard to define, but as you can see from this video, there is quite a bit of improvements with the mark II. Whether you can use without gimbal is completely up to your expectation and how steady you can hold the camera. It is almost gimbal like with a wide angle lens, but it is still not a gimbal as there is only so much the IBIS can adjust to compensate movement/shaking.
@@TheRealRichardWong thank you.
Hello Richard, new subscriber here, thank you so much for the great videos covering the Lumix G9 II :)
If it's not too much to ask, would you make a similar test in a low light environment? I'd love to see if the G9 II + Leica 9mm combo with standard E.I.S would suffer the "jitters" present in electronic stabilization with friendly shutter speeds, where motion blur is present. Thank you!
Hi MB! I think that would be an interesting test especially if i do a side by side comparison with a camera like the Sony A6700 which uses gyro for electronic stabilisation. Unfortunately I have returned the 9mm and other UWA lenses. But i'll see if i got a chance to do that in the future!
oh and thanks for the sub!
@@TheRealRichardWong Thank you very much! Keep up the great work
Great video. Please take int considaration that the focal length also affect the IBIS. Have seen video of other sites when the tested both Sony a7IV and Panasonic S5II that the Sny was better in some focal length and at other focal lenght is was the opposite.
Very usefull comparison. Do you know if the opengate mode (5,8K) is improved as well ? On the GH6, the opengate IBIS is really not as good as 4K (more jumps) ?
sorry I haven't done much IBIS test in 5.8k mode so i can't answer that.
❤❤❤
Ричард привет! Благодарю за обзор!!! 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Thank you for watching!
will somebody please put an Olympus 4/300, and/or 150-400, on the blasted thing and tell us if the G9II's IBIS can do itself justice. re: 60 fps; how many frames are actually captured in 1 second and how many are in focus?
OM-1 and G9ii almost identical
Thank you
g9ll手ぶれ少ないですね！
a7cllやa6700とどっちが良いですかね？
検証お願いします🙇
Hello , i have not got a chance to compare with A6700 and A7CII yet. ごめんなさい
Didn't you mismatch the result of S5II vs G9II IBIS?
I just double checked, the labels for S5II and G9II are correct
People, UA-cam, please stop bolting two cameras together for stability comparisons. In real life, you arent holding that much mass. Its not realistic.
🔥🔥🔥
just going to go ahead and assume that no news is in fact BAD news then for potential G9II and Olympus 4/300 and 150-400 shooters.
Excellent video!
Incredibly annoying music.
thanks for the feedback. Music is a tricky one. I need background music , but no matter what music i choose there are always some people that love it and some people hate it
I know, you can't please everyone, but it was so repetitive...
that Canon crop 🤣
he zoomed in in both cameras. there was no crop that i saw. the canon stabilization was better at the wide angle.
@@truthseeker6804 you should try both cameras and then make your assumptions
@@DePrimal you can see in the video the Canon stabilization is better. Unless you're suggesting he's lying.
@@truthseeker6804 i was referring to the crop, on stabilization both are pretty good. Also don’t be such a fanboy ->
@@DePrimal yh both are good. Was surprised the canon was better. I dont have the r7 but definitely a Canon fan, coz where I live that's the camera 90% of people use and it's easy to get canon stuff. But I like panasonic over sony.
The Fujifilm X-H2 IBIS is worthless.
G9 II is insane, the Fuji sucks.
1. G9II
2. OM-1, G9, GH6
3. R7
4. S5II
5. XT-5
Om1 is winning over g9ii but only by little
I thought G9 II was only slightly better. Almost equally good.
🤡