Many of us often complain that mainstream media doesn't cover the issues that matter. But criticism only works to some extent. A good way to counter them is also to bring the issues that matter to the centre stage. Many journalists (e.g. Sayantan Bera from Mint) have published articles highlighting the plight of the farmers. Articles are linked in the description. For once, let's share their work in our WhatsApp groups. If there are any videos/Instagram posts that are talking about the farmers, share those too. Criticising the coverage of the media, only fuels their agenda further. Edit: Came across a very detailed analysis of the bills. Read here if you are interested: www.theindiaforum.in/article/three-farm-bills
@@jeet4134 i accept in the the past jio did great job but now they are creating monopoly....... Agr aisa chlta rha toh wo din door nhi jab 1gb net 400 me milega.
My grandmother was listening to this and she said "Isse accha zee news laga lo vo batainge reah chatorborty ke bare mein" Then I realised the affect of godi media
@Keshav Try to write why he said it,else some ppl get manipulated. Babasaheb Ambedkar on 2nd September,1953 in Rajya sabha- It is by placating the sentiments of smaller communities and smaller people who are afraid that the majority may do wrong, that the British Parliament works. Sir, my friends tell me that I have made the Constitution. But I am quite prepared to say that I shall be the first person to burn it out. I do not want it. It does not suit anybody. But whatever that may be, if our people want to carry on, they must not forget that there are majorities and there are minorities, and they simply cannot ignore the minorities by saying, “Oh, no. To recognise you is to harm democracy.” I should say that the greatest harm will come by injuring the minorities.
@Keshav Exactly! Even I support the presidential form of govt, and we need a strict system of checks and balances like that of the USA, plus we really need to follow Baba Saheb's ideals🙏
Punjabi celebs are quick in acting in favour of thier people, this is really good considering the fact that bollywood doesn't even stress on these things
arre bhai bollywood kya kre .... lagta he tumhe pata nhi he kya ho rha he .... koi bhi agar muh kholega to uske pichhe CBI .. usko pakistnai usko druggy pata nhi kya kya bana denge ... anti natinal tak ... lagta he past se nhi sikhe ho ... jaake dekho jis jis celebs ne sarkar ke kisi bhi feske ko galat bola he uska kya haal hua he
@abin sebastian punjabi artist ache se kar paye Bollywood wale nahi Punjabi artist pro farmer zyada they anti government Kam par Bollywood pein Ulta tha
Good for whom and bad for whom? US/Europe economic and foreign policies have hypocritically benefitted them but have caused huge losses to under-developed countries. The supremacist mindsets in India is applying these on Indians. And will definitely lead to enslavement of poors, farmers. *If we apply same formulas in a similar way, we are going to get similar results*
@@Terminator60 yes, and "unplanned" policies targetting unorganised sectors reveals "planned" intentions for whom market is forcefully being made free.
Capitalism is great if institutions, social and political, are strong. We Indians will have to bring democracy in our households and minds and reduce bureaucratic corruption.
@@shajeedaahmed9527 i dont think ki esa hoga kyu ki abhi business bs start hi hua hai abhi competition ki vajah se price high ke chances kam hain but dikhega near future mein
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
@@Vibey21 Recent data & Situation of our Country 👇👇 ~PM's Care scam ~ Yes bank and PMC bank scam 1 - Jet Airways closed 2 - Air India in Rs 7600 crore loss 3 - BSNL 54,000 jobs in danger 4 - No money to pay salary for HAL employees 5 - Postal departent loss of Rs 15000 crores 6 - 1 million to be laid off in Auto Industry 7 - 12.76 lakhs houses unsold in 30 major cities 8 - Aircel is dead 9 - JP Group finished 10 - Most profitable company in India - ONGC is now making losses 11 - 36 largest debtors missing from country. 12 - Rs 2.4 lakh crores loan waive off to a few corporates 13 - PNB continous losses. 14 - All banks incurring huge losses 15 - External debt on country 500+ Billion Dollars 16 - Railways on sale 17 - Rent Heritages including Red Fort 18 - Largest car maker Maruti cuts production 19 - Rs 55000 crores car inventory lying at factories, with no buyers. 20 - Builders all over stressed. Some committing Suicide, no buyers Construction Stopped due Mat cost rise (GST at 18% to 28%) 21 - OFB under corporatization affecting over 1.5 lac employee & families. 22 - Millions unemployed due to Demonetization 23 - Highest unemployment in 45 years. 24 - 5 airports sold to A**ni. 25 - Highest domestic stagflation. 26 - Record HNI individuals leaving India 27 - Videocon bankrupt. 28 - Tata Docomo perished Nothing is shown in media. It's our duty to let all others know the real picture....
@@Vibey21 *7 वर्ष झाली हो, काय झाले खालील पैकी* - 1)ना शिवस्मारक तयार झाले 2) ना वाड्रा जेलमध्ये गेला 4) ना विश्वगुरु झालो 5) ना 15 लाख मिळाले 6) ना काळे धन परत आले 7) ना दाऊद व माल्यास फरफटत आणले 8) ना रोजगार मिळाले 9) ना गंगा स्वच्छ झाली 10) ना स्त्रियांवर अत्याचार थांबले 11) ना स्मार्ट सिटी झाल्या 12) ना बुलेट ट्रेन धावली 13) ना दहशतवाद थांबला 14) ना महागाई कमी झाली 15) ना पेट्रोल स्वस्त झालं 16) ना शेतकऱ्यांना दीडपट भाव मिळाला 17) ना काश्मिरी पंडित घरी परतले 18) ना स्टार्टअप इंडिया झाला 19) ना मेक इन इंडिया झाला 20) ना स्किल इंडिया झाला 21) ना डिजिटल इंडिया झाला 22) ना अच्छे दिन आले 23) ना चीन घाबरला 24) ना डॉलर घसरला 25) ना धनगर आरक्षण मिळाले 26)ना बाबासाहेब यांचे स्मारक तयार झाले *१८-२०-२४ तास काम करून स्वयंघोषित चौकीदार करत तरी काय होता नेमकं?* खरंच विचार करायला लावणारा मेसेज *अच्छेदिन वाले सरकारचे 5 वर्षातील कामे* ▪आधार कार्ड बनवा. ▪आधार क्रमांक बँक खात्याला जोडा ▪आधार क्रमांक मोबाईल ला लिंक करा. ▪आधार कार्ड पॅन कार्डला लिंक करा ▪एलपीजी गॅस क्रमांक आधार ला लिंक करा ▪जुलैच्या अगोदर रिटर्न भरा. ▪नोट बदलून घ्या. ▪बदलेल्या नोटांचा हिशोब दया. ▪गैस सब्सिडी सरेंडर करा. ▪एटीएम मधून जास्त वेळेस पैसे काढू नका. ▪एटीएम मधून जास्त वेळेस पैसे काढले तर दंड भरा ▪बँक खात्यात पैसे जमा करा.बँक खात्यात कमी पैसे ठेवले तर दंड भरा. ▪बँक खात्यात जास्त पैसे ठेवले तर एवढे पैसे कुठून आणले म्हणून हिशोब दया.बँकेत जास्त पैसे ठेवले तर टॅक्स भरा. ▪सामान(Goods) वर टॅक्स भरा ▪सर्विस वर टॅक्स भरा ▪कफन वर टैक्स भरा. ▪सर्व पैसे बँकेतच ठेवा खात्यात ठेवलेल्या पैश्याची बँक जबाबदारी घेणार नाही. ▪आधार क्रमांक असेल तरच मुलांना शाळेत प्रवेश ▪उत्तरप्रदेश ,मध्यप्रदेश मध्ये बीफ खाऊ नका गोव्यात मजेत खाऊ शकतात. ▪शाळेत योगा करा कारण योग वाला बाबा आता फॅक्टरी चालवतोय. ▪जनतेने घरात चिनी वस्तू वापरू नका. फक्त सरकारच चिनी कंपन्यांना ठेका देऊ शकते. ▪पेट्रोल/डिझेल सह सगळ्या अत्यावश्यक वस्तुंच्या किमतीत भरमसाठ वाढ. ▪कुठेही काहीही खरेदी करा. पण शासनाला जी.एस.टी. सह वेगवेगळे कर भरावेच लागतात. ▪आवश्यकता नसताना अब्जावधी रूपये खर्च करून मुंबई - अहमदाबाद बुलेट ट्रेनचा हट्ट पूर्ण केला..पण सर्वसामान्यांना भिकेला लावले.. ▪भारतात ८०० रेल्वे स्टेशन वर फ्री वाय फाय मिळेल यासाठी सरकार ने गूगल सोबत साडे चार लाख कोटीचा करार केला आहे. *शेतकरी कर्जमाफीसाठी ८६ हज़ार कोटी नाहीत. परंतु वायफाय साठी सरकार कडे साडेचार लाख कोटी आहेत.* तुम्हीच सांगा लोकांना जगण्यासाठी भाकरी पाहिजेत का वायफाय? ▪६९ लाख रुपये पेमेंट साठी ६३ गरीब बालकांचा बळी गेला. ७५ खासदार और ३३७ आमदार वाले मुख्यमंत्री योगी म्हणतात की हॉस्पिटलमध्ये बालकांचा मृत्यू ऑक्सिजनच्या तुटवाड्याने नाही तर अस्वच्छतेमूळे झाला *आता तुम्हीच सांगा यांचे "स्वच्छ भारत अभियान"भारतात नाही तर पाकिस्तानात चालू आहे का?* "अच्छेदिन वाले साहेब, जगण्यासाठी भाषण नाही तर राशन लागते. हे तुम्हाला माहीत नाही का?" 😌 खरे भारतीय नागरीक असेल तर सर्वाना शेयर करा
just sad how all these indian news youtubers do way more research and hardwork, to tell "actual" news while Arnab is busy yelling and spoon feeding "opinions" and "emotions" instead of cold hard facts. These people deserve way more fame and money.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
u don't need to change your brother...u just have to ask questions to center and state govt...... If u support cong and will not ask ques than what's the purpose... Than cong supporters will be new bhakt... U are making him cong bhakt which is again wrong... You are just changing gutters ... Nobody asking what state govt is doing nothing....i am in Rajasthan we change govt but we get nothing... So changing govt will never beneficial if u don't have a guts to ask...
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
@@AnmolTheRationalist himmat kaise hui is tarah ki behudi sawaal karne ki of course Kapil Mishra aur Amit Shah ka hi haath hoga, Sweden aur Norway jalane me bhi BJp Aur RSS ka hi haath hoga. Tumne socha bhi kaise ki koi musalmaan apna hi desh jalane ka sochega. HO HI NAHI SAKTA.
I spotted you While you clearly can’t see who are protesting half of the farmer unions are made by congress Or are funded by Punjab government I am not saying that they are wrong or whatever but here the opposition is clearly interfering and manipulating the farmers
It’s sad that just to prove not being a andhbakt people would oppose anything by the government For eg 370 which was a good idea as we can clearly see development in JnK and Ladakh Ladakh was kept underdeveloped just cause of Kashmir And now today we can see MNC opening their branches in Kashmir
People never see their opinion and a lot people thinking they are educated and intellectual don’t even have their own opinion they will just repeat what their favorite celebrities say No one remains centric The Left is too busy opposing everything even if it is good , that’s why they are anti national Right is too busy praising everything even if it is bad , that’s why they are called andh bhakt
@@prashantaryan3477 Kashmir is the most militarised region in the world. MNC will never setup their headquarters there. MNC shops were there before 370 also, it was never banned there. Don't spread ignorance 🙏
Deepak Joshi okay hold on a second not spreading ignorance there were no MNC , kfc has opened recently apart from that if u don’t know millatry is reducing there presence there .... 10 divisions or something have been called back ..... and if u understand geopolitics then you would understand it is required to have large numbers of troops in JnK And the thing about Ladakh is absolutely true the problem was in Srinagar... the why Ladakh suffered for 70 year
Hey.. I just started a UA-cam channel covering these social topics... Please check it out...If any suggestions then don't hesitate to comment... I would be happy to read that
@@abhinavsharma3819 yes you right but phele 2,3 sal corporate companies asha Rate dege aur log unko becenge aur APMC me koi nhi jaega aur fr APMC collapse ho jaega then chalu hoge corporate ki Monopoly
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Modiji is thinking that everybody is very intellectual and will get the use of this new bill after failing in gst modi should have realised the fact. Indians are not ready to accept these things without education
@@madhavanand756 the main focus should be education first if a guy is educated he himself will demand for these things Other wise it will look like modi imposed laws and only educated person took the benefits and poor remains poor
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
@@adilsayyed3617 you might get these comments from bhakth because you're a muslim but always remember that there are millions of hindus in india who love muslims as brithers n sisters
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
The reason why I love to watch your videos No personal views Only honest, neutral, knowledgeable information This is what a Journalism called Today's media need to learn this
@G K bruh I don't know I just write for some people who is interested in learning rather than emotional thing (if they are dispised toh kya karo and nahi hai toh mei kya karu) .
Akal dal is no more a Sikh party. they gave it up since 90's. Now they have national aspirations and plan to expand to other states . First ,they were Sikh party ,then they became a Punjabi party , Then North indian party....a wannabe National party .....they r Nothing but a Joke now bcz they are FENCESITTERS
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
You are wrong bro, I am a Punjab farmer and I can sell crops either in APMC or to any one in private . It is choice of farmers at present and from past decades.
Modi is a showman. He wants everything to be big and bold so he can come off as a revolutionary leader but he doesn't really think beyond the first step. Corporatisation isn't bad if your institutions are strong. Modi has weakened institutions, exactly the opposite of what he had to do.
exactly modi is showman,i feel he wants to do right and big for big appreciation but his party isn't really capable of doing what he says ,also as Mohan said modi govt should consultant more before applying these bills
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Congress ne jitna 70 saal me ny loota utna ka BJP ne 7 saal me hi loot lia. Avi to 3 saal baki h ptany ab or kya dekhna baki h😒 Waah Modiji Waah ab mat bolna isme b Nehru ka hath hai😑😑
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
1:47 (to my best knowledge) farmers can (before the rule) sell their crops to anyone and anywhere, however the merchants or middle man can only purchase from the mandi. (correct me if I'm wrong)
भगतसिंह-" क्रांति से हमारा मतलब है किसानों और मजदूरों के हाथ में सत्ता" मोदी: "क्रांति से हमारा मतलब है अडानी और अंबानी के हाथ मे सत्ता" यह है महान क्रांतिकारी और नकली राष्ट्रभक्त के बीच का अंतर #शहीद_ए_आजम #भगतसिंह के #जन्मदिवस पर सभी को #क्रांतिकारी सलाम #इंकलाब_जिंदाबाद.✊✊🇮🇳
To mudda ye nahi hai ki sarkaar sahi baat nahi kar rahi. Par mudda ye hai ki vo puri baat nahi kar rahi. Addha sach, jhoot se jyada khatarnak hota hai.
from the past few months agriculture sector is the only sector where we can see a positive growth despite all negatives due to the huge loss of economy.. GDP.. and what not.. kind off I feel like this bill was desperately passed to consume or to privatize all the positive sectors where ever they (gov.) can earn in favour of their gods or their own hands .. if only anyone can enlighten me about this will their books of "we want"
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
I seriously like the research and efforts behind each and every video of this channel. The data and the proof these guys collect is drastically much than any other channel on the you tube. KUDOS!!
Also MSP is for 22 crops..... Price discovery system too had flaws.... present regime should have extended the ambit of MSP..... even if it wanted to privitise the Mandis..... boht jaldi vedio daal diya.... shayad isiliye
Msp beneficiaries is just 6% because they are unaware of their rights and secondly msp is not implemented everywhere and on every product. This bills isn't perfect, regulating private companies and introducing an msp which is applicable to everyone will make a huge difference.
Nikhil Mhatre guess what apmc theme selves are not paying msp. In a free market when u get benefit of charging high, then why not vice a versa. Why the fucking hell are we so concerned abt farmers that we forget other sectors. Where there is no msp and are still surviving. And if private player don’t offer good compensation go back to apmc, who is stopping you. Bsnl even after Jio is functioning na. And why the hell we need to spend on msp. When we have other issues like education, health, infrastructure instead of giving msp we should focus on these areas. Why don’t u raise msp thing for msmse
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Bro... Our president act like proppet ..any bill i.e CAA NRC FARM BILL issued by BJP ...he gives consent without any delay .coz president belongs to RSS
Farmers have been ignored from a long time. We eat the food grown by them and still we don't pay our respects when necessary! We need to be together now and stay together for a long time. Listen to speeches/media interviews given by so many people from yesterday's protest and you'll know how important this is! Let's support our farmer brothers and sisters digitally. Social media has that power and we need to show that!! #kisaanmajdoorektazindabaad🙏
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
I really wanna thank you Mohak. I don't care about your political inclination.. But because I receive well articulated research material sans chaod and shouting. Gives me crystal clear clarity. Thanks man!
Hey.. I just started a UA-cam channel covering these social topics... Please check it out...If any suggestions then don't hesitate to comment... I would be happy to read that
The more we give power to this party , there is no days far when slavery will be legalised by them ! Cooperation monopoly will destroy the economy of this country.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Yes and farmers make the economy by sucking government budget they take 100 billion dollars and government budget is just 380 billion dollars they are leeches and destroying the climate like farming paddy in bihar where there is shortage of water and punjab's ground water supply will run out in next 10 years
1. Firstly, the statement "one monopoly to other monopoly" can not be further from the truth. The APMCs are still going to be present and MSP is still guaranteed to the farmers. 2. Second about the uncontrolled price inflation by the private sector, the acts clearly talks about what percent increases in the prices of the perishable and durable farm produce respectively are allowed before government intervention to stop the hoarding (which is what traders do to to drive the prices to go high). And yeah, thanks to the new acts, farmers ko iski bhoj uthane ki 1% bhi jaroori nahin hain, because the farming contracts are drawn based on a legal frame work (stay in your chairs as it is work in progress and will soon be released) that will ensure that the corporates can't transfer their losses caused by the market conditions directly to the farmers like how APMC traders played with the farmers 3. If corporates aren't picking farmers calls, they are more than welcome to go to APMCs where there will still be an MSP guarantee 4. What if some farmers don't have the wherewithal to transport their produce to the other states? Hmm, what if person ABC can't be enterprising enough to confidently take a calculated risk on a new venture? Hmm, what if a student can't perform as much as the average performance of his peers despite equal training? Do you have any intentions of seeing a formalized agri sector in our nation? if yes, these will be some of the initial hick ups any person has to face in the initial days of any new thing. Please be resourceful, apply yourselves and get by. Otherwise, there is always the good old APMCs which I can't stress this enough, will not be closed down. 5. These acts are very much needed to transform India's agriculture filed to consolidate and formalize the agri sector effectively. There is a lot of hidden unemployment currently prevalent in the farm industry and these people can find a lot of new jobs in food storage, transportation and processing industry and move them up economically. 6. Why are we calling these historic? if it suits you to not call them historic, knock yourself out mate! 7. Let's see, "Oh my god! corporates are going to suck the life out of the farmers with their negotiating upper hand" and "okay, let's not let the corporates do that instead let's let the APMC and state governments do that and also charge commissions and taxes for facilitating this". Can't be any more communistic and anti-capitalism than this! 8. If NDA is doing good politics then god be with them. Political party ka wahin hain kaam. Have you come late to the party? 9. State vs Center. if it is really unconstitutional for the center to do this, the opposition can nicely go to supreme court and appeal to the constitutional bench. Why are they going to the streets instead? Oh wait! ah, are there some precedents like this? why don't you talk about that? Please don't play the center vs states card when convenient. Let someone do the job. 10. The first solution you proposed is more amenable to a private sector. Come on, don't kid yourself, no APMC or government sector body is going to give anything electronically or for that matter do anything that makes peoples' lives easy. Try paying at a post office for a speed post using a credit card. Situation will be self explanatory. Bureaucracy thrives on making things complex and complicated where as the private sector thrives by doing anything but those things. 11. Your second proposed solution is very much the concern of the legal framework that facilitates the upholding of farmer rights and will provide specific guidance to farmers on how they can leverage this to better organize themselves. 12. Why do you really think that somehow Bihar did everything humanly possible to make this work? Why should the Bihar's model be heeded? and for that matter why should Bihar's model on anything be the deciding factor of not doing or doing something? (those who read this far, please don't be silly and think that I am somehow being disrespectful to Bihar, only think that if you believe Bihar is entirely defined by just its politics and politicians) Can you prove without leaving scope for even a modicum of doubt that everything that is being proposed by the Center is in strict accordance with the Bihar's model and subsequently is doomed to fail? Thought for another actually factual video if you like! 13. Last, if it is the case that all this is going to be completely ineffectual because center can control the prices just as it pleases by controlling import and export duties then what is all the fuss about? Something that can't be positively effective can also not be negatively effective by that very logic. Unless, you think that the center is this evil frat house with all the boogie men present and making plans to simply make everyone's life miserable. You don't need to explain on that, I have a fair idea on your perspective! 14. Yes, moti moti taur pe har cheej mein kamiya milenge bhai, ye bolkar bajan karte bhait nahin sakte. Jarah positive mind set aur optimism ke sat dekho sab theek dikenge. Jai Hind!
Earlier 1. Farmer could sell crop in a particular MANDI / APMC only. 2. License was required to trade inside APMCs 3. Auction method was followed in apmc trade where MSP was floor price The PROBLEM - Now due to point 3 License raj was being done, cartels or groups were formed who mutually agreed to not buy anything at MSP or above... since the licenses were with very few ppl and farmers could only sell to them there is a monopoly created ! Nobody would buy at the MSP and farmer used to sell below MSP. There were many middlemen who Carrie's out the auction process ,farmer is not given any transparency on what's happening at the auction or so, hence middlemen used to loot up the profits in case someone buys above/at MSP! After all this farmer had to pay market fee too! In this bill, there is a mention of Price intelligence and Market information system (PIMIS) where a framework is created to inform farmers about the worth and price of their crops, so that they are informed and not exploited There is also mention of digital transactions, an app is being made to track off mandi transactions! By this we can ensure transparency and assure farmers of their payment and reduce the risk of them getting cheated is also mention of digital transactions, an app is being made to track off mandi transactions! By this we can ensure transparency and assure farmers of their payment and reduce the risk of them getting cheated
"Is video me hum Data aur Evidence ko jaanch kar in questions ko answer karne ki koshish karenge" This video is not for Bhakts they should get out of it as Data & Evidence is not their cup of tea !!
See agriculture is a state subject hence some APMC mandis used to pay taxes like in Punjab and some don't like Haryana.... Now Every APMC mandi will have to pay tax whereas private mandis will be introduced where no tax will be levied...... Moreover in APMC 22 crops had MSP system and others had Price discovery for crops perishable goods where Auctioning happens on the basis of quality of produce. But now MSP & price discovery is also abolished..... that's the bone of contention...... plus other is contract farming..... where grievance redressal is in hands of District collector rather in hands of judiciary where they can file a PIL in SC against the corporate company in case of wrongdoings......
Correction: Farmers could sell their produce to private players even before the Farm Bills were passed. This is touted as a benefit of the Farm Bills; it isn't.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !! Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️ ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Aap legend ho bro The way u explain, nobody does it even close I have watched many videos on youtube regarding the same topic but the most brief and to the point "with solutions to the problem and the causes of the problem" has been done only by you Big fan...:-)
Actually Bro I Accept all your facts but Jalandhar Me Kisan Protests ke bich Khalistan Supporter Nare Lagte hi mann me doubt Aa Jata hai Same CAA ke time pe bhi Mumbai me "FREE Kashmir " " Go India GO Back " And Sharjeel Imam " Assam ko Kat Denge " & Ye sab Media ka Propaganda nahi hai Ye sab Mujhe nazar aata hai Me Kisi ko kuch nahi bol sakta But Ye galat hai Isse Indian Establishment ke log BJP ko Aur zada Support karenge Zadatar log centre me rehte the but Agar Protest Karna hai to India Ki Sovereignty ke khilaf thodi na bologe Ek baar hota mann leta but itni baar Agar me Khud Congress Supporter hoke bhi dekhunga To Mujhe khud Insecurity Mehsus hogi and Gradually Me bhi Right ward shift Ho jaunga
The problem with the policy making with the government is that they make a sudden immediate change, they do not give time and space to understand and gradually adapt the changing policies. They immediately bring big changes.
I am a medical student at Safdarjung hospital, Delhi....Today i saw private lab in our hospital for carrying out diagnostic tests... I was very shocked that govt. can't even pay for their people's health... Is privatizing everything that good...
I belong to an agricultural family in Punjab. all the family members are going to strikes from many days even they are worried about our education after the monopoly of MNC's this bill would have a really drastic impact on the life of farmers and even the workers that work in the fields.
Well I must say, saw a lot of informative videos abt the "historic" Farm-Bill... This was the best one and was well explained.... P. S. The soch guy says moong dal to masoor dal... Just correct it if u can😝 else gr8 work!
Still most of the people don't know about this act please share as possible as , because being Indian we have to know what is going on in our country, we must take stand for our farmers
Wow! ur video compiles really admirable aspects nd constantly adds more to the quest of learning and creates well-awareness in this phase of rampant dissemination of misleading nd biased informations! Indeed it's an unmatched work, Mohak nd team :)
Thank You Brother for making a video explaining both sides in a simple way. Agree on the point that making decisions look like historic , or like no one has done this before , for fake publicity is causing more damage.
Brother Amazingly put👌👌 Journalism of India is dead except NDTV and few newspapers. But hats off to you, what a balanced critique! Keep it up! It always feels good to see people with good sense and Logic taking about ISSUES THAT TRULY NEED ATTENTION.
Many of us often complain that mainstream media doesn't cover the issues that matter. But criticism only works to some extent. A good way to counter them is also to bring the issues that matter to the centre stage. Many journalists (e.g. Sayantan Bera from Mint) have published articles highlighting the plight of the farmers. Articles are linked in the description. For once, let's share their work in our WhatsApp groups. If there are any videos/Instagram posts that are talking about the farmers, share those too. Criticising the coverage of the media, only fuels their agenda further.
Edit: Came across a very detailed analysis of the bills. Read here if you are interested: www.theindiaforum.in/article/three-farm-bills
देश चलाने वालों का मूल मंत्र ये है कि एक्टिंग करते हुए पकड़े जाओ तो ओवर एक्टिंग करने लगो।
Nice work bro. Give me some tips for my chnl too.
I support these bills. Unnnecesary protest just like NEP2020.
Please provide subtitles sir, it helps, please
Congressi Bhakt UA-camr Spotted
Bro If you Don't know anything about the bill Please don't spread Rumors about it😂😂
Let's see the growth of JioMart after these bills. I bet it will become the biggest buyer and hoarder of the farm produce!
Good to see ur comment from jio sim and Chinese phone.
U r free to say that u r not using it.
Right brother
@@jeet4134 i accept in the the past jio did great job but now they are creating monopoly....... Agr aisa chlta rha toh wo din door nhi jab 1gb net 400 me milega.
Previously it was done by the Mandis.
My grandmother was listening to this and she said
"Isse accha zee news laga lo vo batainge reah chatorborty ke bare mein"
Then I realised the affect of godi media
🤔🤣😂😁🙏
What you said is very real, tragic and dangerous. This is the story of almost every household.
@@ishaansrivastava2008 yup
For a change my nani is addicted to china and Pakistan.
That's why we don't have a Television for past 4 years. 😂
No TV no Nuisance!!😅
Salute to our Punjabi Celebrities unlike our Bollywood celebs.
Yes they are celebrities only bcs of Punjabis ,and they know this very well
I love punjabis nd mallus
Love from North East
Atleast they are true to their people.
@Keshav Try to write why he said it,else some ppl get manipulated.
Babasaheb Ambedkar on 2nd September,1953 in Rajya sabha-
It is by placating the sentiments of smaller communities and smaller people who are afraid that the majority may do wrong, that the British Parliament works. Sir, my friends tell me that I have made the Constitution. But I am quite prepared to say that I shall be the first person to burn it out. I do not want it. It does not suit anybody. But whatever that may be, if our people want to carry on, they must not forget that there are majorities and there are minorities, and they simply cannot ignore the minorities by saying, “Oh, no. To recognise you is to harm democracy.” I should say that the greatest harm will come by injuring the minorities.
@Keshav Exactly! Even I support the presidential form of govt, and we need a strict system of checks and balances like that of the USA, plus we really need to follow Baba Saheb's ideals🙏
Punjabi celebs are quick in acting in favour of thier people, this is really good considering the fact that bollywood doesn't even stress on these things
Yes very quick
arre bhai bollywood kya kre .... lagta he tumhe pata nhi he kya ho rha he .... koi bhi agar muh kholega to uske pichhe CBI .. usko pakistnai usko druggy pata nhi kya kya bana denge ... anti natinal tak ... lagta he past se nhi sikhe ho ... jaake dekho jis jis celebs ne sarkar ke kisi bhi feske ko galat bola he uska kya haal hua he
Bollywood ki toh L lag gyi hai . Abb bolne layak nahi bacha woh
For people or for APMCs and middlemen.
Even if anyone act. People will troll them badly. Honestly the level of trolling is out of this world in case of Bollywood. So it's on them.
Punjabi Singers really have a spine, they have my respect for life
They have always held their grounds firmly.
agreed, kudos to daljeet dosanjh and the singers
@abin sebastian punjabi artist ache se kar paye Bollywood wale nahi Punjabi artist pro farmer zyada they anti government Kam par Bollywood pein Ulta tha
@@ayanbandyopadhyay8302 why are people even against this bill
@abin sebastian this a good bells for the farmers just watch an open letter
After Labour laws, Farmers bills, GST
Long shot Question remains " *Is India ready for Capitalism ?* "
Capitalism is not bad ,but question is that capital is under control of whom?
Yes. I welcome liberalism!
Good for whom and bad for whom?
US/Europe economic and foreign policies have hypocritically benefitted them but have caused huge losses to under-developed countries.
The supremacist mindsets in India is applying these on Indians. And will definitely lead to enslavement of poors, farmers.
*If we apply same formulas in a similar way, we are going to get similar results*
@@Terminator60 yes, and "unplanned" policies targetting unorganised sectors reveals "planned" intentions for whom market is forcefully being made free.
Capitalism is great if institutions, social and political, are strong. We Indians will have to bring democracy in our households and minds and reduce bureaucratic corruption.
When a gutter cleaner's son is forced to follow his father's job then why does Kangana not cry against this nepotism??!!??
😂😂😂savage bhai
Because like you said, he's "forced"
@@A-VirajGaidhani He's forced by the system not by his father so it's systems nepotism so voice should be raised against this nepotism
@@helloyoutube728 Exactly, the nepotism in bollywood at least benefits the people involved in nepotism, but over here, it isn't benefiting anyone
Then go and clean gutters no one will stop
some people can't think beyond politics or political parties.
this farmer bill will impact the nation not some MLA or MP.
Exactly...... Black marketing, hoarding aur price rise toh ab honge...... Rajya sabha mein pass hote hi hamare yahan Onion rates have already increased....... Sabki baari aayegi..... lekin thoda sabr karna padega
@@shajeedaahmed9527 i dont think ki esa hoga kyu ki abhi business bs start hi hua hai abhi competition ki vajah se price high ke chances kam hain but dikhega near future mein
This farm bill will revolutionize farming in India to greater heights.
Modi hai to mumkin he 😄
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
I'm afraid that they might also bring One nation, One party.
Thinking of this makes me claustrophobic
Civil war it is then 🙂
BJP is obsessed with "One"..
@@nitishamehta9337 same when i think of china 😂
@@hehhehe7194 yes it is for sure
"मैं देश नहीं मिटने दूंगा।
मैं देश नहीं बिकने दूंगा।
.
.
.
.
.
(मैं खुद देश मिटाऊंगा!!
मैं खुद देश बेचूंगा!!! )"
😂😂
-By Ek Madhrc****
Ye likhna bhol gye bro
@@Vibey21 Recent data & Situation of our Country 👇👇
~PM's Care scam
~ Yes bank and PMC bank scam
1 - Jet Airways closed
2 - Air India in Rs 7600 crore loss
3 - BSNL 54,000 jobs in danger
4 - No money to pay salary for HAL employees
5 - Postal departent loss of Rs 15000 crores
6 - 1 million to be laid off in Auto Industry
7 - 12.76 lakhs houses unsold in 30 major cities
8 - Aircel is dead
9 - JP Group finished
10 - Most profitable company in India - ONGC is now making losses
11 - 36 largest debtors missing from country.
12 - Rs 2.4 lakh crores loan waive off to a few corporates
13 - PNB continous losses.
14 - All banks incurring huge losses
15 - External debt on country 500+ Billion Dollars
16 - Railways on sale
17 - Rent Heritages including Red Fort
18 - Largest car maker Maruti cuts production
19 - Rs 55000 crores car inventory lying at factories, with no buyers.
20 - Builders all over stressed. Some committing Suicide, no buyers Construction Stopped due Mat cost rise (GST at 18% to 28%)
21 - OFB under corporatization affecting over 1.5 lac employee & families.
22 - Millions unemployed due to Demonetization
23 - Highest unemployment in 45 years.
24 - 5 airports sold to A**ni.
25 - Highest domestic stagflation.
26 - Record HNI individuals leaving India
27 - Videocon bankrupt.
28 - Tata Docomo perished
Nothing is shown in media. It's our duty to let all others know the real picture....
@@Vibey21 *7 वर्ष झाली हो, काय झाले खालील पैकी* -
1)ना शिवस्मारक तयार झाले
2) ना वाड्रा जेलमध्ये गेला
4) ना विश्वगुरु झालो
5) ना 15 लाख मिळाले
6) ना काळे धन परत आले
7) ना दाऊद व माल्यास फरफटत आणले
8) ना रोजगार मिळाले
9) ना गंगा स्वच्छ झाली
10) ना स्त्रियांवर अत्याचार थांबले
11) ना स्मार्ट सिटी झाल्या
12) ना बुलेट ट्रेन धावली
13) ना दहशतवाद थांबला
14) ना महागाई कमी झाली
15) ना पेट्रोल स्वस्त झालं
16) ना शेतकऱ्यांना दीडपट भाव मिळाला
17) ना काश्मिरी पंडित घरी परतले
18) ना स्टार्टअप इंडिया झाला
19) ना मेक इन इंडिया झाला
20) ना स्किल इंडिया झाला
21) ना डिजिटल इंडिया झाला
22) ना अच्छे दिन आले
23) ना चीन घाबरला
24) ना डॉलर घसरला
25) ना धनगर आरक्षण मिळाले
26)ना बाबासाहेब यांचे स्मारक तयार झाले
*१८-२०-२४ तास काम करून स्वयंघोषित चौकीदार करत तरी काय होता नेमकं?*
खरंच विचार करायला लावणारा मेसेज
*अच्छेदिन वाले सरकारचे 5 वर्षातील कामे*
▪आधार कार्ड बनवा.
▪आधार क्रमांक बँक खात्याला जोडा
▪आधार क्रमांक मोबाईल ला लिंक करा.
▪आधार कार्ड पॅन कार्डला लिंक करा
▪एलपीजी गॅस क्रमांक आधार ला लिंक करा
▪जुलैच्या अगोदर रिटर्न भरा.
▪नोट बदलून घ्या.
▪बदलेल्या नोटांचा हिशोब दया.
▪गैस सब्सिडी सरेंडर करा.
▪एटीएम मधून जास्त वेळेस पैसे काढू नका.
▪एटीएम मधून जास्त वेळेस पैसे काढले तर दंड भरा
▪बँक खात्यात पैसे जमा करा.बँक खात्यात कमी पैसे ठेवले तर दंड भरा.
▪बँक खात्यात जास्त पैसे ठेवले तर एवढे पैसे कुठून आणले म्हणून हिशोब दया.बँकेत जास्त पैसे ठेवले तर टॅक्स भरा.
▪सामान(Goods) वर टॅक्स भरा
▪सर्विस वर टॅक्स भरा
▪कफन वर टैक्स भरा.
▪सर्व पैसे बँकेतच ठेवा
खात्यात ठेवलेल्या पैश्याची बँक जबाबदारी घेणार नाही.
▪आधार क्रमांक असेल तरच मुलांना शाळेत प्रवेश
▪उत्तरप्रदेश ,मध्यप्रदेश मध्ये बीफ खाऊ नका
गोव्यात मजेत खाऊ शकतात.
▪शाळेत योगा करा कारण योग वाला बाबा आता फॅक्टरी चालवतोय.
▪जनतेने घरात चिनी वस्तू वापरू नका.
फक्त सरकारच चिनी कंपन्यांना ठेका देऊ शकते.
▪पेट्रोल/डिझेल सह सगळ्या अत्यावश्यक वस्तुंच्या किमतीत भरमसाठ वाढ.
▪कुठेही काहीही खरेदी करा. पण शासनाला जी.एस.टी. सह वेगवेगळे कर भरावेच लागतात.
▪आवश्यकता नसताना अब्जावधी रूपये खर्च करून मुंबई - अहमदाबाद बुलेट ट्रेनचा हट्ट पूर्ण केला..पण सर्वसामान्यांना भिकेला लावले..
▪भारतात ८०० रेल्वे स्टेशन वर फ्री वाय फाय मिळेल यासाठी सरकार ने गूगल सोबत साडे चार लाख कोटीचा करार केला आहे. *शेतकरी कर्जमाफीसाठी ८६ हज़ार कोटी नाहीत. परंतु वायफाय साठी सरकार कडे साडेचार लाख कोटी आहेत.*
तुम्हीच सांगा लोकांना जगण्यासाठी भाकरी पाहिजेत का वायफाय?
▪६९ लाख रुपये पेमेंट साठी ६३ गरीब बालकांचा बळी गेला.
७५ खासदार और ३३७ आमदार वाले मुख्यमंत्री योगी म्हणतात की हॉस्पिटलमध्ये बालकांचा मृत्यू ऑक्सिजनच्या तुटवाड्याने नाही तर अस्वच्छतेमूळे झाला
*आता तुम्हीच सांगा यांचे "स्वच्छ भारत अभियान"भारतात नाही तर पाकिस्तानात चालू आहे का?*
"अच्छेदिन वाले साहेब, जगण्यासाठी भाषण नाही तर राशन लागते.
हे तुम्हाला माहीत नाही का?"
😌 खरे भारतीय नागरीक असेल तर सर्वाना शेयर करा
@@Vibey21 right
I support Farmers Protest 🙏🙏
just sad how all these indian news youtubers do way more research and hardwork, to tell "actual" news while Arnab is busy yelling and spoon feeding "opinions" and "emotions" instead of cold hard facts.
These people deserve way more fame and money.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Is it only me or you are posting more regularly without actually hurting the quality ?
ikr
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
अगर किसान टेररिस्ट है
तो क्या अभी तक बम खाते थे
Who said that they're terrorists?
Bhai kaun sa maal khate ho....desi ya videsi
@@parvadhami980 kangana said
@@parvadhami980 Kangana Ranaut said.
@@jiwankanwar7216 can you give me the link of her tweet?
Today my elder bhakt brother change to a normal person...
I spent 5 months to do this...
Now i want only one thing that is....nobel prize 😤😤😤
You deserve a nobel prize 👍
U got the satisfaction nd happiness best prize
Well done💙
Bhai tumne kaisa jela usko wow bhai u deserve bharat ratna for that. 😂😂👍
u don't need to change your brother...u just have to ask questions to center and state govt...... If u support cong and will not ask ques than what's the purpose... Than cong supporters will be new bhakt... U are making him cong bhakt which is again wrong... You are just changing gutters ... Nobody asking what state govt is doing nothing....i am in Rajasthan we change govt but we get nothing... So changing govt will never beneficial if u don't have a guts to ask...
"They are not Farmers, They are terrorists"
- Great Queen Kangana Modi
🤣😂🙏
😂😂
😂😂
Jo tumhara pate bhar rhe hain.
Wo terrorist hain, toh acche kaun hain?
@Jahanvi Negi lmao
One nation, one propaganda!
That's right
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Farmer's never have any kinda barrier to sell their products to another state
Soo true.... If you want to know further about this topic please visit my channel... I have recently started it... Need support from you guyzz
@@AnmolTheRationalist tahir hussain aur umar khalid ka haat hi hai.
No doubt
@@AnmolTheRationalist himmat kaise hui is tarah ki behudi sawaal karne ki of course Kapil Mishra aur Amit Shah ka hi haath hoga, Sweden aur Norway jalane me bhi BJp Aur RSS ka hi haath hoga. Tumne socha bhi kaise ki koi musalmaan apna hi desh jalane ka sochega. HO HI NAHI SAKTA.
For your kind info Farmers never had barrier because they had these so called Middle Man to help them and this bill has now cut them off well done!!
@@nhovinroy5624 now these middle man will be corporate
Much needed video. Hope andhbhakts will understand what's going on
I spotted you
While you clearly can’t see who are protesting half of the farmer unions are made by congress
Or are funded by Punjab government
I am not saying that they are wrong or whatever but here the opposition is clearly interfering and manipulating the farmers
It’s sad that just to prove not being a andhbakt people would oppose anything by the government
For eg 370 which was a good idea as we can clearly see development in JnK and Ladakh
Ladakh was kept underdeveloped just cause of Kashmir
And now today we can see MNC opening their branches in Kashmir
People never see their opinion and a lot people thinking they are educated and intellectual don’t even have their own opinion they will just repeat what their favorite celebrities say
No one remains centric
The
Left is too busy opposing everything even if it is good , that’s why they are anti national
Right is too busy praising everything even if it is bad , that’s why they are called andh bhakt
@@prashantaryan3477 Kashmir is the most militarised region in the world. MNC will never setup their headquarters there. MNC shops were there before 370 also, it was never banned there. Don't spread ignorance 🙏
Deepak Joshi okay hold on a second not spreading ignorance there were no MNC , kfc has opened recently apart from that if u don’t know millatry is reducing there presence there .... 10 divisions or something have been called back ..... and if u understand geopolitics then you would understand it is required to have large numbers of troops in JnK
And the thing about Ladakh is absolutely true the problem was in Srinagar... the why Ladakh suffered for 70 year
MSP assurance is not written any where in bill
also it was passed in really undemocratic way
Hey.. I just started a UA-cam channel covering these social topics... Please check it out...If any suggestions then don't hesitate to comment... I would be happy to read that
@@shambhavibhardwaj9264 yeah sure
good channel i subscribed to you
But APMC is not gone
If one needs MSP
Can go to APMC
Who is forcing you to go to private players?
@@abhinavsharma3819 yes you right but phele 2,3 sal corporate companies asha Rate dege aur log unko becenge aur APMC me koi nhi jaega aur fr APMC collapse ho jaega then chalu hoge corporate ki Monopoly
@@sekhonhome9473 sahi kaha
isi liye msp gurantee likhna chahiye tha government ko
*We must stand for our farmers same as we did for our jawans*
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Game of thrones ho gayi hai modi sarkaar.
S1 mein danayers Targaryen saviour of the people thi
Aur s8 to yaad hi hoga 😂😂
Jon snow kon hey
@@dragonborn3283 Ambani 😂😂😂
Wo kneel nahi karega , lekin sarkaar uske saath hai
🤣🤣🤣🤣
lmao it this government was never a saviour of anyone except fascists
Modi Ji is a theoritical politician rather than practical.
True
Modiji is thinking that everybody is very intellectual and will get the use of this new bill after failing in gst modi should have realised the fact. Indians are not ready to accept these things without education
@@Extensive_deeck Very True dude, infact at ground level things are worst
@@madhavanand756 the main focus should be education first if a guy is educated he himself will demand for these things
Other wise it will look like modi imposed laws and only educated person took the benefits and poor remains poor
@@holyturtle1132 it takes time if nep is implemented that doesn't mean that india is educated.
India is heading to be a
Reliance- Republic PVT India Ltd.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
mukesh ambani told he doesn`t want to join agricultural sector
@@bromegh4323 bro keep believing in the words of politicians and industrialist
Kangana' be like : This is bcoz of Nepotism😂😂
Ask her to speak on jay shah 😂😂
@@IndianBoy77 Saab log bura maan jayege
@@IndianBoy77 forget jay Shah.
Ask her about her sister and brother...
😂😂😂
@@shahwayne4302 why what happened? Abb kya kardiya?
@@yrashid6108 uski behen aur Bhai hi Uske manger aur financial advisor something Hain...😂😂
She is just the biggest hypocrite
Nicely Pointed the 2 issue of Present Government :-
1) Non-Consultation Attitude
2) Use of Distraught Manipulating Words like "Biggest Reforms".
✔️👍
Government should really help the farmers
@@apurvabhide2860 Why? I'm an Indian
@@apurvabhide2860 And you should go to China . Deshdrohi.
@@adilsayyed3617 don't mind him bhai he's a bhakth dheshdrohi
@@apurvabhide2860 go to china bhakth dheshdrohi
@@adilsayyed3617 you might get these comments from bhakth because you're a muslim but always remember that there are millions of hindus in india who love muslims as brithers n sisters
I think kuch bandar video pe ate hi dislike dene k liye hai.
Aise andhbhakt apni zindagi me kya karenge, rab hi jane 🤦🏼♂️🙏
Now they r not andhbhakt they are lundbhakts
Bomb fodenge😂
@@AdityaSingh-cr8ed yeah just like peacefully people
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
In both languages , hindi nd eng as well
The reason why I love to watch your videos
No personal views
Only honest, neutral, knowledgeable information
This is what a Journalism called Today's media need to learn this
0:55 akali dal is older than BJP 1920 for sikh protection and farming
@G K bruh I don't know I just write for some people who is interested in learning rather than emotional thing (if they are dispised toh kya karo and nahi hai toh mei kya karu) .
Akal dal is no more a Sikh party. they gave it up since 90's. Now they have national aspirations and plan to expand to other states . First ,they were Sikh party ,then they became a Punjabi party , Then North indian party....a wannabe National party .....they r Nothing but a Joke now bcz they are FENCESITTERS
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
You are wrong bro, I am a Punjab farmer and I can sell crops either in APMC or to any one in private . It is choice of farmers at present and from past decades.
Modi is a showman. He wants everything to be big and bold so he can come off as a revolutionary leader but he doesn't really think beyond the first step. Corporatisation isn't bad if your institutions are strong. Modi has weakened institutions, exactly the opposite of what he had to do.
This comment is underrated
Yes this comment is really underrated
You have my vote
Best comment ever
exactly modi is showman,i feel he wants to do right and big for big appreciation but his party isn't really capable of doing what he says ,also as Mohan said modi govt should consultant more before applying these bills
Rightwing government never consults. This is basis of rightwing governance to impose own judgment.
Have fun in the Soviet Union my friend
@@hansbingolanda104 have fun in nazi Germany my friend
@@prince7444 wah! Kya comment hai😂😂😂😂😂
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Congress ne jitna 70 saal me ny loota utna ka BJP ne 7 saal me hi loot lia. Avi to 3 saal baki h ptany ab or kya dekhna baki h😒
Waah Modiji Waah ab mat bolna isme b Nehru ka hath hai😑😑
@@holyturtle1132 no 10% in manmohan govt check on google
@@holyturtle1132 abe manmohan singh got india to ,11%growth rate
@@holyturtle1132 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 u should make research from your own , not from whatsapp University 🤣🤣🤣🤣😊
Baii unho loote ke baad bhi desh ki GDP ki ma ni chode di yaad rakhna gaadiyaan bik rahi thi logo ko naukriyaan mill rahi thi
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Next; *"One Nation, One Party"*
1:47 (to my best knowledge) farmers can (before the rule) sell their crops to anyone and anywhere, however the merchants or middle man can only purchase from the mandi. (correct me if I'm wrong)
Yeah
भगतसिंह-" क्रांति से हमारा मतलब है किसानों और मजदूरों के हाथ में सत्ता"
मोदी: "क्रांति से हमारा मतलब है अडानी और अंबानी के हाथ मे सत्ता"
यह है महान क्रांतिकारी और नकली राष्ट्रभक्त के बीच का अंतर
#शहीद_ए_आजम #भगतसिंह के #जन्मदिवस पर सभी को #क्रांतिकारी सलाम
#इंकलाब_जिंदाबाद.✊✊🇮🇳
To mudda ye nahi hai ki sarkaar sahi baat nahi kar rahi. Par mudda ye hai ki vo puri baat nahi kar rahi.
Addha sach, jhoot se jyada khatarnak hota hai.
No video explained this whole fiasco any better and without being biased! Kudos!
from the past few months agriculture sector is the only sector where we can see a positive growth despite all negatives due to the huge loss of economy.. GDP.. and what not.. kind off I feel like this bill was desperately passed to consume or to privatize all the positive sectors where ever they (gov.) can earn in favour of their gods or their own hands ..
if only anyone can enlighten me about this will their books of "we want"
I rate your analysis as one of the best amongst youtubers .... Great work (Y)
First attacked at NorthEastern States
Now attacked at Western States
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
I seriously like the research and efforts behind each and every video of this channel. The data and the proof these guys collect is drastically much than any other channel on the you tube. KUDOS!!
Nicely explained as always, I don't know but I prefer your videos and amount of research over Dhruv
His approach is kinda milder
@@manishalobo5429 yup, that's too, and what is more fascinating about him is that his solutions are purely research based, rather than speculations.
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
.#we_stand_with_farmers
#we_stand_with_farmers
Farmers ❤️
Why haven’t u pointed that msp beneficiary is just 6 percent. Why are u bringing half baked facts. I’m really disappointed by ur research this time
Also MSP is for 22 crops..... Price discovery system too had flaws.... present regime should have extended the ambit of MSP..... even if it wanted to privitise the Mandis..... boht jaldi vedio daal diya.... shayad isiliye
Msp beneficiaries is just 6% because they are unaware of their rights and secondly msp is not implemented everywhere and on every product. This bills isn't perfect, regulating private companies and introducing an msp which is applicable to everyone will make a huge difference.
Nikhil Mhatre guess what apmc theme selves are not paying msp. In a free market when u get benefit of charging high, then why not vice a versa. Why the fucking hell are we so concerned abt farmers that we forget other sectors. Where there is no msp and are still surviving. And if private player don’t offer good compensation go back to apmc, who is stopping you. Bsnl even after Jio is functioning na. And why the hell we need to spend on msp. When we have other issues like education, health, infrastructure instead of giving msp we should focus on these areas. Why don’t u raise msp thing for msmse
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
i found your channel recently and kudos! very clear and well-researched.
Kisan basmati rice bechta hai rs. 20 me .... aur private companies aapko bechti hai 120,130 rs. Me ...... aur ab yeh aur mehnga hone wala hai ....
Not even paid half. Wtf
Bro yahi toh middle class ko samajh nahi aa raha..... jo lage pade hai MODI MODI karne
aalo kisan 2,3 rs. kg bechta hai aur aap khareedte ho 40,50rs. me
Sad Part is, Bhakts nahi manenge :'(
Bro... Our president act like proppet ..any bill i.e CAA NRC FARM BILL issued by BJP ...he gives consent without any delay .coz president belongs to RSS
He speaks facts.. if you don't like his 'views' basically you've got a problem with 'facts'.. as usual very well researched brother..!
Waiting for this nd finally 😊👍
I mean ur video on this topic
Farmers have been ignored from a long time. We eat the food grown by them and still we don't pay our respects when necessary!
We need to be together now and stay together for a long time. Listen to speeches/media interviews given by so many people from yesterday's protest and you'll know how important this is! Let's support our farmer brothers and sisters digitally. Social media has that power and we need to show that!!
#kisaanmajdoorektazindabaad🙏
Love his contents.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
I really wanna thank you Mohak. I don't care about your political inclination.. But because I receive well articulated research material sans chaod and shouting. Gives me crystal clear clarity. Thanks man!
Hey.. I just started a UA-cam channel covering these social topics... Please check it out...If any suggestions then don't hesitate to comment... I would be happy to read that
@@shambhavibhardwaj9264 provide some link bro.. Sirf popular channels dikha raha..
@Humza Jamal please click on the icon / profile... You'll be redirected to my channel.. I'll share the link also
The more we give power to this party , there is no days far when slavery will be legalised by them ! Cooperation monopoly will destroy the economy of this country.
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Yes and farmers make the economy by sucking government budget they take 100 billion dollars and government budget is just 380 billion dollars they are leeches and destroying the climate like farming paddy in bihar where there is shortage of water and punjab's ground water supply will run out in next 10 years
Please keep posting videos consistently.I like your videos so much
1. Firstly, the statement "one monopoly to other monopoly" can not be further from the truth. The APMCs are still going to be present and MSP is still guaranteed to the farmers.
2. Second about the uncontrolled price inflation by the private sector, the acts clearly talks about what percent increases in the prices of the perishable and durable farm produce respectively are allowed before government intervention to stop the hoarding (which is what traders do to to drive the prices to go high). And yeah, thanks to the new acts, farmers ko iski bhoj uthane ki 1% bhi jaroori nahin hain, because the farming contracts are drawn based on a legal frame work (stay in your chairs as it is work in progress and will soon be released) that will ensure that the corporates can't transfer their losses caused by the market conditions directly to the farmers like how APMC traders played with the farmers
3. If corporates aren't picking farmers calls, they are more than welcome to go to APMCs where there will still be an MSP guarantee
4. What if some farmers don't have the wherewithal to transport their produce to the other states? Hmm, what if person ABC can't be enterprising enough to confidently take a calculated risk on a new venture? Hmm, what if a student can't perform as much as the average performance of his peers despite equal training? Do you have any intentions of seeing a formalized agri sector in our nation? if yes, these will be some of the initial hick ups any person has to face in the initial days of any new thing. Please be resourceful, apply yourselves and get by. Otherwise, there is always the good old APMCs which I can't stress this enough, will not be closed down.
5. These acts are very much needed to transform India's agriculture filed to consolidate and formalize the agri sector effectively. There is a lot of hidden unemployment currently prevalent in the farm industry and these people can find a lot of new jobs in food storage, transportation and processing industry and move them up economically.
6. Why are we calling these historic? if it suits you to not call them historic, knock yourself out mate!
7. Let's see, "Oh my god! corporates are going to suck the life out of the farmers with their negotiating upper hand" and "okay, let's not let the corporates do that instead let's let the APMC and state governments do that and also charge commissions and taxes for facilitating this". Can't be any more communistic and anti-capitalism than this!
8. If NDA is doing good politics then god be with them. Political party ka wahin hain kaam. Have you come late to the party?
9. State vs Center. if it is really unconstitutional for the center to do this, the opposition can nicely go to supreme court and appeal to the constitutional bench. Why are they going to the streets instead? Oh wait! ah, are there some precedents like this? why don't you talk about that? Please don't play the center vs states card when convenient. Let someone do the job.
10. The first solution you proposed is more amenable to a private sector. Come on, don't kid yourself, no APMC or government sector body is going to give anything electronically or for that matter do anything that makes peoples' lives easy. Try paying at a post office for a speed post using a credit card. Situation will be self explanatory. Bureaucracy thrives on making things complex and complicated where as the private sector thrives by doing anything but those things.
11. Your second proposed solution is very much the concern of the legal framework that facilitates the upholding of farmer rights and will provide specific guidance to farmers on how they can leverage this to better organize themselves.
12. Why do you really think that somehow Bihar did everything humanly possible to make this work? Why should the Bihar's model be heeded? and for that matter why should Bihar's model on anything be the deciding factor of not doing or doing something? (those who read this far, please don't be silly and think that I am somehow being disrespectful to Bihar, only think that if you believe Bihar is entirely defined by just its politics and politicians) Can you prove without leaving scope for even a modicum of doubt that everything that is being proposed by the Center is in strict accordance with the Bihar's model and subsequently is doomed to fail? Thought for another actually factual video if you like!
13. Last, if it is the case that all this is going to be completely ineffectual because center can control the prices just as it pleases by controlling import and export duties then what is all the fuss about? Something that can't be positively effective can also not be negatively effective by that very logic. Unless, you think that the center is this evil frat house with all the boogie men present and making plans to simply make everyone's life miserable. You don't need to explain on that, I have a fair idea on your perspective!
14. Yes, moti moti taur pe har cheej mein kamiya milenge bhai, ye bolkar bajan karte bhait nahin sakte. Jarah positive mind set aur optimism ke sat dekho sab theek dikenge. Jai Hind!
Mohak and dhruv both are best explainer
Please...Make a video on corporal punishment in Indian schools
Great! Very beautifully explained in detailed information
Earlier
1. Farmer could sell crop in a particular MANDI / APMC only.
2. License was required to trade inside APMCs
3. Auction method was followed in apmc trade where MSP was floor price
The PROBLEM -
Now due to point 3 License raj was being done, cartels or groups were formed who mutually agreed to not buy anything at MSP or above... since the licenses were with very few ppl and farmers could only sell to them there is a monopoly created ! Nobody would buy at the MSP and farmer used to sell below MSP.
There were many middlemen who Carrie's out the auction process ,farmer is not given any transparency on what's happening at the auction or so, hence middlemen used to loot up the profits in case someone buys above/at MSP!
After all this farmer had to pay market fee too!
In this bill, there is a mention of Price intelligence and Market information system (PIMIS) where a framework is created to inform farmers about the worth and price of their crops, so that they are informed and not exploited
There is also mention of digital transactions, an app is being made to track off mandi transactions! By this we can ensure transparency and assure farmers of their payment and reduce the risk of them getting cheated is also mention of digital transactions, an app is being made to track off mandi transactions! By this we can ensure transparency and assure farmers of their payment and reduce the risk of them getting cheated
Please provide subtitles for this video. This is best 360 degree analysis of the farm bills I have seen till now and should reach a wider audience.
"Is video me hum Data aur Evidence ko jaanch kar in questions ko answer karne ki koshish karenge"
This video is not for Bhakts they should get out of it as Data & Evidence is not their cup of tea !!
True...every decision is declared as "Historic" that leaves no room for further discussion..
Sir, i want to know that law which was stopping farmers earlier to sell his farm produce outside apmc mandis.
No such law , I m not saying so heard this from a credible you tube video
See agriculture is a state subject hence some APMC mandis used to pay taxes like in Punjab and some don't like Haryana.... Now Every APMC mandi will have to pay tax whereas private mandis will be introduced where no tax will be levied...... Moreover in APMC 22 crops had MSP system and others had Price discovery for crops perishable goods where Auctioning happens on the basis of quality of produce. But now MSP & price discovery is also abolished..... that's the bone of contention...... plus other is contract farming..... where grievance redressal is in hands of District collector rather in hands of judiciary where they can file a PIL in SC against the corporate company in case of wrongdoings......
@@shajeedaahmed9527 that does not give answer to my question.
Great content. Beautifully explained.
Correction: Farmers could sell their produce to private players even before the Farm Bills were passed. This is touted as a benefit of the Farm Bills; it isn't.
Waiting for this video, Thankyou so much ♥️♥️
5:48 same picture in two different cases? waah 😑
Superb research and well summarized with minimum personal opinions and maximum facts. Sharing this video with all my like minded friends.
All dislikes by Andbhakts sale. A sale Andbhakt BJP k liye apni izzat Tak bech dega
My friend made a wonderful nd very understandable video on this !!
Check out nd make sure to like , share nd subscribe ❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/9t2INKGjWWc/v-deo.html
both languages , hindi nd eng as well
Aap legend ho bro
The way u explain, nobody does it even close
I have watched many videos on youtube regarding the same topic but the most brief and to the point "with solutions to the problem and the causes of the problem" has been done only by you
Big fan...:-)
Actually Bro I Accept all your facts but
Jalandhar Me Kisan Protests ke bich
Khalistan Supporter Nare Lagte hi mann me doubt Aa Jata hai
Same CAA ke time pe bhi
Mumbai me
"FREE Kashmir "
" Go India GO Back "
And
Sharjeel Imam
" Assam ko Kat Denge "
& Ye sab Media ka Propaganda nahi hai
Ye sab Mujhe nazar aata hai
Me Kisi ko kuch nahi bol sakta
But
Ye galat hai
Isse Indian Establishment ke log
BJP ko Aur zada Support karenge
Zadatar log centre me rehte the but
Agar Protest Karna hai to
India Ki Sovereignty ke khilaf thodi na bologe
Ek baar hota mann leta but itni baar
Agar me Khud Congress Supporter hoke bhi dekhunga
To
Mujhe khud Insecurity Mehsus hogi and
Gradually Me bhi Right ward shift Ho jaunga
The problem with the policy making with the government is that they make a sudden immediate change, they do not give time and space to understand and gradually adapt the changing policies. They immediately bring big changes.
#we_stand_with_farmers
Farmers know what is beat for them..that's why they are protesting throughout the country! ❤️
I am a medical student at Safdarjung hospital, Delhi....Today i saw private lab in our hospital for carrying out diagnostic tests... I was very shocked that govt. can't even pay for their people's health... Is privatizing everything that good...
You r doing well . All the best mohak !!
I belong to an agricultural family in Punjab. all the family members are going to strikes from many days even they are worried about our education after the monopoly of MNC's this bill would have a really drastic impact on the life of farmers and even the workers that work in the fields.
GST was also historic and see now how devasted it was!!...BJP:-A completely failed government(employment,GST,note bandi and now farmers bill)
Thanks for making, you were very very articulated , keep up the good work, we need individuals like you.
Best explainer videos.. love you brother..!!
Loved your way of explaining things... Sounds good 👍
Well excepted I have seen many analysis videos and Interviews on new Farm bill but your expansion is so simple and in point
mohak mangal research is toughest job as i read all news article seen many video but no one cleared so well hats off
Yeah Bande ne Jo Knowledge Liya hai 😎Itna Saare Neta Logo ke bhi Paas nahi!!
Well I must say, saw a lot of informative videos abt the "historic" Farm-Bill... This was the best one and was well explained....
P. S. The soch guy says moong dal to masoor dal... Just correct it if u can😝 else gr8 work!
you are better than most media.. my friend
Still most of the people don't know about this act please share as possible as , because being Indian we have to know what is going on in our country, we must take stand for our farmers
Very informative. Your research is much appreciated. Thanks for providing such wonderful analysis.
Your content is top notch bro ...
Kudos for always keeping an unbiased opinion😃
Fantastic explainer.. the best of watched on this topic.. good collection of data.. please do more videos on more topic..
Wow! ur video compiles really admirable aspects nd constantly adds more to the quest of learning and creates well-awareness in this phase of rampant dissemination of misleading nd biased informations! Indeed it's an unmatched work, Mohak nd team :)
Thank You Brother for making a video explaining both sides in a simple way.
Agree on the point that making decisions look like historic , or like no one has done this before , for fake publicity is causing more damage.
Brother Amazingly put👌👌
Journalism of India is dead except NDTV and few newspapers.
But hats off to you, what a balanced critique! Keep it up! It always feels good to see people with good sense and Logic taking about ISSUES THAT TRULY NEED ATTENTION.
Love you brother.. tumhare video se hamesha hmko kuch naya sikhne ko milta hai ..thanks..
The quality of your content is top notch
Even govt didn't consulted Kisan Unions. Govt is privatising and liberalising everything what else can we expect Now !!