Thank you Monseigneur for this clear and very well structured response to the “co-redemptrix” role of our Lady! This topic is very important. God bless you🙏
Monseigneur with all do respect this subject is not a dogma in the holy Catholic church, as you know there's more than one opinion or perspective to look into this subject, therefore we cannot say explicitly if our lady is a co-redeemer or not , and in this case of multiple opinions on subjects that are not yet dogmas the faithful are free to embrace or to reject.
I think his explanation was nuanced enough and represented the complexity of the « co-redemptrix » debate. He started by ruling out that Mary could be considered as equal to Jesus (the confusion that the « co » term might imply) and went on to define how Mary can work « with » the Lord to help him in his salvific works. If everyone is invited to cooperate with God’s grace to bring about the salvation of the world by living an authentic faith, our Lady who is the mother of God will undoubtedly have a unique way of cooperating with him in the redemption of the world. At the end you are right, this is not a dogma, many popes decided to distance themselves especially because not everyone will take time to deep dive into that theological reasoning hence the possibility of confusing the believers. God bless🙏
@@joannaabiallam hello sister First to be clear I am in favor of co-redemptrix as a dogma. But what I am clarifying here that in this case and any other similar case of a belief that is not yet confirmed as a dogma we cannot assume or decide or tell the faithful nor to accept or to reject , cause our holy mother the church leaves the freedom to her children to accept or to reject. For this the title of this video can we call Mary the co-redemptrix without affirming what I was saying leads to ambiguity.
Thank you Monseigneur for this clear and very well structured response to the “co-redemptrix” role of our Lady! This topic is very important. God bless you🙏
ابونا هناك جدل آخر ان امكن ان توضح حقيقته: هل مريم هي "وسيطة كل النعم" بحسب تعليم الكنيسة الرسمي اليوم؟؟
Monseigneur with all do respect this subject is not a dogma in the holy Catholic church, as you know there's more than one opinion or perspective to look into this subject, therefore we cannot say explicitly if our lady is a co-redeemer or not , and in this case of multiple opinions on subjects that are not yet dogmas the faithful are free to embrace or to reject.
I think his explanation was nuanced enough and represented the complexity of the « co-redemptrix » debate. He started by ruling out that Mary could be considered as equal to Jesus (the confusion that the « co » term might imply) and went on to define how Mary can work « with » the Lord to help him in his salvific works. If everyone is invited to cooperate with God’s grace to bring about the salvation of the world by living an authentic faith, our Lady who is the mother of God will undoubtedly have a unique way of cooperating with him in the redemption of the world. At the end you are right, this is not a dogma, many popes decided to distance themselves especially because not everyone will take time to deep dive into that theological reasoning hence the possibility of confusing the believers. God bless🙏
@@joannaabiallam hello sister
First to be clear I am in favor of co-redemptrix as a dogma.
But what I am clarifying here that in this case and any other similar case of a belief that is not yet confirmed as a dogma we cannot assume or decide or tell the faithful nor to accept or to reject , cause our holy mother the church leaves the freedom to her children to accept or to reject.
For this the title of this video can we call Mary the co-redemptrix without affirming what I was saying leads to ambiguity.