the ULTIMATE red velvet tier list
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лип 2022
- Now, this is a video I've been wanting to make.
In a way, this video has been 5 years in the making. Red Velvet is the only group I've stanned for this long and this tier list acts like a tribute to them. I always thought they had something special about their music, which is exactly why I wanted to do this video. And now that it's here, I hope y'all enjoyed it as much as I did. :)
Try it out here: tiermaker.com/create/red-velv...
-----
abt vid -
intro • day 1 by red velvet
outro • feel my rhythm by red velvet
thumbnail • red velvet
abt me -
i’m 18, he/him
ults • rv, svt, stayc, izone, fromis, loona
ult bias • kim chaewon of le sserafim
faqs -
where do u edit vids? • kinemaster 5, final cut pro x
where do u edit photos? • picsart
how do u get the voice? • text to speech (iphone app)
credits -
all official videos/audios from SM Ent.
KKyunwoo and Jingnyeo | Folktales | Stories for Kids | Bedtime Stories • • Kyunwoo and Jingnyeo ...
day 1 inst • • Video
happiness inst • • RED VELVET - 'Happines...
be natural inst • • Red Velvet - Be Natura...
icc inst • • Red Velvet - Ice Cream...
automatic inst • • Red Velvet - Automatic...
dd inst • • RED VELVET - DUMB DUMB...
ootn inst • • [INST.] Red Velvet (레드...
rr inst • • Red Velvet - 러시안 룰렛 (R...
rookie inst • • [Clean Inst.] Red Velv...
red flavor inst • • [Clean Inst.] Red Velv...
pab inst • • Red Velvet(레드벨벳) - Pee...
bad boy inst • • Red Velvet(레드벨벳) - Bad...
power up inst • • RED VELVET - POWER UP ...
rbb inst • • Video
zimzalabim inst • • [Clean Inst.] Red Velv...
umpah umpah inst • • Red Velvet - Umpah Ump...
psycho inst • • Red Velvet - Psycho (O...
monster inst • • Red Velvet - IRENE & S...
like water inst • • Video
hello inst • • Video
queendom inst • • Video
fmr inst • • Red Velvet - Feel My R...
happiness fc • • [Fancam/직캠]150516 레드벨벳...
ice cream cake fc • • [4k Fancam/직캠]160604 R...
dumb dumb fc • • [4k Fancam/직캠]151014 레...
russian roulette fc • • [4k Fancam/직캠] 160921 ...
rookie fc • • 레드벨벳(Red Velvet) - 루키(...
power up fc • • 레드벨벳 - Power Up(슬기 포커스...
really bad boy fc • • 181210 아이린 IRENE 레드벨벳 ...
tags -
kpop korean kdrama music comeback review reaction impression album release showcase live ep mini discussion commentary reddit twitter youtube facebook documentary essay tea shade brutal bad good hate love opinion fact overrated underrated irene seulgi wendy joy yeri
![[After School Dinner] KISSY, Is it okay for you to know this?👀 l [Chatter from Behind] KISS OF LIFE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OCEQlUppY-U/mqdefault.jpg)
thank you to everyone who watched the video
💝💛💙💚💜
❤️
hey winterosy you dropped this 🤲👑
Hi, amazing video, you can tell the editing has so much love put into it! Thank you!
I'm only in the beginning (just after one of these nights) but couldn't go on to the cheery Russian roulette, without mentioning that one of these nights is actually about the Seoul fairy disaster. Please please research about it and give honour to those poor souls.
Edit 1: idk if anyone already mentioned this and I'm just being an idiot, but the different versions of psycho are because yt and streaming services actually mix differently any audio that goes through them, causing the violins to still be present, but much quieter, in the streaming services one. It's nothing to do with the actual song.
Edit 2: I am now subscribed to you.
thank you so much for making this video!!
u genuinely have such good opinions and I don't say that often. 10/10 reveluv fr
Gonna talk about automatic. Call me whatever y'all want, but that song, that harmonization, that vocals, the girls, the near the fire rock and reading a book vibes, the dance it's classy, it's etheral. They were just rookies, and they were so 🤲 i love that rnb song, so smooth, so velvety.
It just comes so naturallll it just comess automatic
Absolutely insanely well made song. All the layers of it are amazing and it tickles my ears everytime I listen to it!
You got a fantastic taste ;)
After reading this i might check it out, if its really good, ill feel sorry for myself for not knowing it😭
Frrr!!! Automatic is my fav song from themmm
feel my rhythm was IT
everything from the concept it was just perfect,,,,, so dreamy and ethereal yet somewhat packs a punch
For anyone that doesn’t appreciate Feel My Rhythm, I feel bad for you. In this KPOP climate of “girl crush,” and overly produced songs, Red Velvet broke the mold (as they do) releasing a classical masterpiece. Feel My Rhythm as winterosy said gives us the best of performance, costuming, concept, production, vocals, and IMO it is the embodiment of ART at it’s finest. As someone that has studied art and appreciates classical music, this song and MV blew me away. Red Velvet set the standard once again.
@@nikegrrl5105 PREACH!!!!!!!11!!!1
@@nikegrrl5105 Oh yeah you're so right
ikr!!
am i the only one who LOVES zimzalabim. like that beat drop is so hot and the cult stuff always makes me get UP! my girls said let’s have some fun and i did.
I absolutely adore this concept a lot. It’s very unique and fun, and I can bop to this song.
honestly, one of my favorite title tracks from them xD, but no one agrees with me lol
Zimzalabim is not for everyone. Some people take a few listens for them to grasp it’s power, but for me it’s truly magnetic! When they sing Zimzalabim over and over, I feel like like I’m being hypnotized, it just draws you in.
you're not alone.
The bass in the drop is so amazing 💅🏼
Finally someone who appreciates One of These Nights 😭 i feel so upset when someone doesn't like this song, it's one of my favorite Red Velvet's songs
I know, such a classic Red Velvet piece. The melody and vocals are so haunting and the somber tone of the MV and the tragedy it depicts blend together effortlessly.
Musically OOTN is amazingly arranged and performed.
It IS my favorite Red Velvet song to this day!
Not going it’s in my top three favs songs of my cake girls too next to feel my rhythm, and kingdom come
so nostalgic,i love it
i genuinely think peek a boo was red velvet’s best title track because i have never heard a song with vibes that peek a boo has. it’s creepy, fun and unique and the instrumental is very good! it almost has odd eye cricle’s loonatic vibes😩
i can’t tell whether it’s my favorite bc it has my favorite Red Velvet rap (Yeri went hard fr), or whether i just love how the concept and red murder mystery aesthetic 🍕
Peek a boo is literally one of my favorite kpop songs ITS SO GOOD!!
THIS
now i know why i love peek a boo bcs it has a same vibe with oec loona😃
One of their best!!
When I first hear "Feel My Rythm" it was so strange but so magical and beautiful at the moment, the whole mini-album is so amazing for me and really one of my favs. of 2022, btw dont put me "In My Dreams" bc that shit hurts my mental health
in my dreams,,, that song does smth to me
I love the whole album whew chef’s kiss (‘good bad and ugly’ didnt need to be there but its a solid 7/10 bc its the cake girls and their vocals are just honey)
In My Dreams will have me sobbing and journaling my feelings out after one listen I stg. What do they put in that song. It's like a goddamn emotion destabilizer.
I'm so glad someone else has a deep appreciation for art and in result has a deep appreciation for "Feel My Rhythm". People around me just didn't appreciate it much and some even think that it's not "good" because it's not fast or up beat enough. (Same thing happened when "Feel Special" by TWICE was released and it's disappointing because it's one of my favorites.) As much as I wanna argue with them, it's not like they can understand my perspective of how I saw it in its entirety without the proper knowledge I acquired as an art-lover. Or- as much as I wanna say that they're "tasteless", it's not as if they can like the same things that I do. Either way, "Feel My Rhythm" is a masterpiece that is truly like nothing else and I will die on that hill :).
I feel the same as you about both feel my rhythm and feel special!!
Easily their best song. Visually and sonically it completely surpasses the others. I really loved the way SM was able to take RV’s energy and mature it to fit the member’s ages and point they’re at in their career. I feel like with Queendom the sound and visuals were a bit more mature/grown but they lost the RV quirk and that made it boring. FMR has so many layers to it as a song that make it interesting. I also really liked the way the producers were able to bring in the scraping and clanging metallic hyperpop sounds that are becoming part of SM’s house code and have it completely work within the song. They Kwangya-fied RV but not in a way that was Too Much. Just so well done in all aspects.
You are so right, about both this *and* Feel Special. I wish people appreciated it a little more.
Totally agree. That song have been carry my sanity throughout 2022. When in down I say to myself "someday your life could be like Feel my Rhythm" And I cheer up. I love that song for all that It represents. It deserves more recognition.
Feel My Rhythm saves 2022💫
Here is dumb dumb appreciation squad. You know, i love the manufacture doll thing and i love that it's quirky and cute. Now zimzalabim, it just so good. It has the upbeat music then the quite pre chorus with adding the cult upbeat. So amazing. Next is ice cream cake, it has that creepy la la la which is just standing out, but the cute upbeatness covers it up.
Yass
PRAISE!
When I was first beggining to explore RV, I downloaded the whole discography on spotify for a flight. The 3rs song that came up was Dumb Dumb and I 😲😲😲😲 hard, put it on repeat, next thing I knew the plane landed and it was still there. Amazing song
Dumb dumb is one of those songs that I always feel embarrassed about bc people will judge me for it, like it's on my "don't play out loud in front of people" list for sure, but that doesn't mean I don't love it so much. The concept goes so hard and they lean so far into it which I appreciate. I think if they shied away from the "annoying" of it then it wouldn't actually be as good. The repetition works along with the factory sounds and the robotic singing tones to create something really creepy sounding and it by all means shouldn't work, but in actuality it works flawlessly, at least in my opinion.
I'm gonna need you to apologize for the peek a boo SLANDER, I may be biased because it was the first comeback I was a part from but DAMN the song is so good even today. The playfulness and the creepiness all together matches RV's concept so perfectly and the MV is so iconic. Also, we got rainbow dress joy, what's more iconic than that. Altough I agree with the fact that bad boy is much better, and in fact the peak of their career, PERIOD.
I nearly cried when you were talking about feel my rhythm. great video as always
omg im so glad someone said this, i felt the same exact way! red velvet is almost like wine, or basically IS wine if we're talking musically: they age perfectly and not a single cb was the worst song someone could ever hear, or at least that's imo. this whole video made me happy and sad, but of course all positive ways. FMR was destined to be released under the group name red velvet and it holds so much emotion to it like any other sad toned velvet cb, such as ICC or OOTN. becoming a luvie was the best decision i've ever made music wise and maybe even in general almost lmao, and this is only coming from a 2018 luvie too!
I shed a few tears, yes.
Same...
I will not take this power up slander I love that song so much. It holds a special place in my heart as one of the first cuter songs I liked
It definitely isn’t one of their best song quality wise, but for some reason it sticks around as one of if not my favorites just cuz it always brings a smile to my face. I guess I’ll call it my guilty pleasure along with Queendom, which also gets way more hate than it deserves.
It's not their best song but it reminds me of the time I started to actually get into kpop so I associate a lot of positive things with it, the slander is not deserved
@@davidkonevky7372 same here, especially since it was my first comeback after my friend showed me Peek a Boo and I got hooked. Power Up and Cookie Jar just hold special places in my heart
This was my exact reaction 😂 I love power up
@@NotoriouslyNoah I was literally spamming “Ba-banana” to my friends the whole month after it came out 😭😭
Omg that explanation of One of these nights made me realize that it’s based on the same story of dreamcatcher’s July 7th. I love seeing connections between two songs I love 😫 ALSO Omg fmr is what convinced me to get into red velvet. I LOVE classically driven pieces of music, and I had always felt like Kpop should incorporate more classical music themes into its music. So fmr was like literally a gift from heaven. I lOVE the way the Bach sample is used, and it’s just such a beautiful and lovely song for the spring
literally my exact thoughts
finally some proper 'one of these nights' appreciation, that song made me look into red velvet in the first place and for a good year it was my favorite of them, it's beautiful
red velvet is my ult group among girl groups, their concepts, songs, that group is a masterpiece
I totally disagree with Peek-a-boo, i think is one of RV best, maybe it's really simple but the atmosphere that it have is the best, is creepy but fun at the same time, i can say this is not boring and every part of the song is good imo, but i love this video, one of the best talk about RV discography, thanks for this video!
THE STORYLINES of red velvet MVs are enough to beat every other competitor out there. I can stay up all night watching UA-cam theories of who’s the psycho, the hidden concept of them killing eachother, and oh my lord FEEL MY FUCKING RHYTHM had sooo much genius symbolism and the classic pieces of art and music is just … setting the bar too high. NOBODY does it like red velvet.
Joy was the Psycho but then Irene convinced them all with dance but she is the next Psycho.
I'll die believing this
i normally don't comment but like, this video was so well done. it really made me look at their songs from a different perspective. your hatred for power up is hilarious lol.
honestly rookie and rbb are probably my favorite title tracks from them. i don't why i love rookie so much, but the pre chorus is beautiful.
random thoughts throughout the video:
-rookie basically forced me to become a reveluv. it's the catchiest song i've ever heard plus it's actually good. literally the only thing i could listen to for like a week. but it's kinda outshined by all their other good songs now
-peekaboo is somehow watered down and good at the same time, the watered downess just affected it's longevity
-how you feel about power up is how i feel about queendom i can't shake the feeling of disappointment i got after waiting for so long. the mini album is one of my faves tho so forgive and forget?
-i want another reve festival so bad we were so spoiled
-i want an aseul comeback so bad i still have the bsides on loop too
Agree with you, Queendom got me scared for the future of RV. But the FMR came out :DDDD
i was queendom's biggest defender when it came out but i quickly realized it does not fit with the rest of their songs at all.... the album is great tho. pose, knock on wood and better be are fire
Feel My Rhythm is THE SONG. Everytime I hear this song, i feel this special feeling, like if it was what we really needed. RV 4ever
one of these nights finally getting the appreciation it deserves, it truly is one of rv's best songs
I tried to make a list of Red Velvet's best songs, but gave up after about 10 minutes.
They're discography is way too deep and way too good.
I'm in awe with your editing ! Ngl, the introduction for Psycho and Feel me rythme made me a little emotional.
Edit : I'm going to be blasphemous and says the I found Bad Boy quite boring and absolutely love Power Up (maybe even more than Red Flavor). Also love RBB and Zimzalabim.
Omg we have the same opinions
Same!
sameee I love love love power up, zimzalabim and rbb !!
100% agree
Power up is so so good! Idk why people still shit on it tbh
Idk but i love peekaboo with all my heart, i even have the album. It wasn't my first kpop song i listened to ( it was Russian roulette) but it introduced me to a whole new concept and made me start to dance and explore new groups. Maybe because it's so special to me that's why I love it. But people can have opinions so
"there's really no other group like Red Velvet. because no one else can do Red Velvet other than Red Velvet themselves." FACT. i see another group trying to be "red velvet" but yeah red velvet is unbeatable.
No way i sat and watched a 44 min video, that proves how good this video is. Amazing stuff!!! Kept my attention the whole time♥️
One Of These Nights was the first comeback I’ve experienced with RV and it’s still my favorite kpop song to ever exist, it’s crazy how it moves me 6 years later, it doesn’t get enough credits. I’m literally the president of the OOTN squad istg.
PS : I’m only half way through the video but it’s so good, it makes me appreciate RV even more, they’re my fav group for a reason but it’s so great to see their evolution like that
when you look into the subtle ties to the sewol ferry disaster in the OOTN mv, you appreciate it even more. the artistry of the song and the emotion in the girls' voices are perfect as a tribute to the lives lost.
you got all my respect for the OOTN appreciation. it's nice to finally see someone else who respects that song and sees it as one of red velvet's best.
💖[Timestamps]💖
👑 0:00 Intro 👑
1:25 ♥️ Happiness
3:28 🖤 Be Natural
5:38 ♥️ Icecream Cake
7:33 🖤 Automatic
9:44 ♥️ Dumb Dumb
12:01 🖤 One of these nights
15:00 ♥️ Russian Roulette
16:52 🖤 Rookie
18:15 ♥️ Red Flavor
20:26 🖤 Peek a boo
22:07 ♥️ Bad Boy
24:19 🖤 Power Up
25:45 ♥️ Really Bad Boy
27:26 🖤 Zimzalabim
29:07 ♥️ Umpah Umpah
31:06 🖤 Psycho
34:20 ♥️ Monster
36:04 🖤 Like Water
37:25 ♥️ Hello
38:45 🖤 Queendom
40:59 A recap of all the rv songs
41:24 ♥️ Feel my Rhythm
✨ ENDING ✨
Top 12:
1.Russian Roulette
2.Peek a boo
3.RBB
4.Psycho
5.Feel my rhythm
6.Zimzalabim
7.Red Flavor
8.Dumb Dumb
9.Bad Boy
10.Happiness
11.Queendom
12.ICC
ALL MASTERPIECES!
Where is One of These Nights?
@@kikanemu7736 I didn't include the ones that I didn't like so.... yeah
Not the velvet side and rookie slander 😭😭
@@bad_revecula I forgot about rookie. I love it, it should be 6th
it should be a crime for queendom to be so low
Feel My Rhythm is a masterpiece that could be done only by red velvet because there’s no artist who makes music (REAL MUSIC) like red velvet, and as a musician that bach sample makes me cry from time to time when i listen to this song
Red Velvet’s disc. Is perfection. Not a single bad song, and will forever be iconic
Putting Zimzalabim in it’s own tier is low key the best decision in this video 🤩 No one’s ready for this?!1!1!😪😩
Ugh I love their discography so much. I think my God Velvet songs would be Dumb Dumb, Bad Boy, and Feel My Rhythm. RV really has something special
Red Velvet will be my ults in KPOP. The reason why I love them is because they are so different! New concepts, new trends, unexplainable theories in their music video, their talents and their discography alone? PERFECTION! It is really difficult for me to rank them since I do enjoy performing them, appreciating the meaning and the background of each track and even appreciating their vocals to be honest! I give you the respect the hardwork especially the ranking! Awesome editing by the way!
P.S: Along with Red Velvet, f(x), LOONA and BILLLIE are the groups that I am fully invested as well!
I see a Billlie mention, I like.
When I saw the video and thumbnail first, I thought "44mins? That's a lot he/she must have ranked all the Red Velvet Albums with b-sides" but then when I watch the video, it's just title tracks. So, I was pretty disappointed at first but this 44mins passed so fast LOL. Thank you for the amazing video! I really enjoyed it.
Looking forward to the Ultimate Red Velvet B-sides Tier list next time!!
Feel My Rhythm blew my mind in everyway. With so many classics in their discography like Automatic, Dumb Dumb, Russian Roulette, Bad Boy and Psycho it seemed impossible to be even better, but they managed to do it with FMR, what group is making classic songs almost 8 years into their career? Only Red Velvet!
Not to mention it was a commercial success, it’s so promising that we’ll continue to get more RV comebacks for years to come.
“This felt more like a pre-debut release rather than an actual and fully fledged out debut”
Well that kinda makes sense because it kinda is, without Yeri red velvet isn’t complete ❤️
nah cause red velvets discography is a whole other tier of amazingness
the way you described "feel my rythm" made me so emotional for some reason, i've always regarded red velvet as my muse to all my art works and heck the russian roulette comeback even saved me from art school college. and feel my rythm is just this culmination and celebration of art and their career in general. the girls have worked so hard throughout the years and i'll forever be grateful for the talent and artistry they gave to the world.
Oh, I love the editing in this video. It is very minimalist, nothing really fancy. But the transitions are so smooth and it gives me chills. I’m a sucker for great transitions. And as someone who studied multimedia myself, this is heaven to my ears and eyes. Keep up the good work! 👍👍
Your intro to FMR gave me chills dude! NGL! It made me realize that FMR is a culmination of RVs releases throughout the years.
💖💖💖💖💖
The Feel My Rhythm section made me so emotional 😭😭😭
Loved the video! U did such a great job :) 💖💛💚💙💜
I'm not a philosopher to write huge reviews, but this video is what I needed.
I became a ReVeLuv in the peek-a-abo era. My love for girls in december 2017 began with fangirling but now every previous release (even which I can't stand) seems to me as good as wine over the years. the main idea that I took out for myself is that you don't need to make each of your releases ***IDEAL*** to please the public (or even your fandom). The thing is that you grow, develop yourself musically as a single organism(as an artist(in this context reve)) and only with time listener understand what really was a bop and what was a flop.
In some places I didn't agree with you (and somewhere I agreed down to every letter but with a different song haha), but from the bottom of my heart I'm thankful to you that you spent your time to put your thoughts in this video and absolutely conveyed to the viewer exactly what you meant. as a twt citizen, I can't write anything except woof woof or sksjskhjs, and here is a whole essay for 44 minutes about all of my feelings.
p.s. 41:53 - 42:02 PLS THIS IS THE BEST JOKE OF THE WHOLE VIDEO
p.p.s. I wanted to find similar videos on UA-cam with other bands of interest to me, but no one did it better than you
I haven't seen a lot of kpop tier ranking videos that actually catch my attention but this one hits the spot. This video is so well done and all your points were amazing. I can't get over the fact that Zimzalabim is so complicated that it needed its own tier ranking I had to pause and laugh 💀
Surprisingly this is what I listen to whenever I do complicated projects. It's informative and feels like a podcast dedicated to Red Velvet's discography. It may be opinionated but it's well researched. I love it.
I love the eloquence on how you express your thoughts and feelings. And as a fellow Luvie I admire your keen ears and eyes for recognizing Red Velvet's masterpieces. Your attention and perception to details is exquisite. We may have different opinions on the rankings but my respect and admiration for you should be manifested.
I think red velvets discography is just perfect i dont think i ever disliked ANY of their songs. AND THEIR CONCEPTS TOO? Just Immaculate.
Btw winterosy i love your vids ❤️
Gurl, are u a writer?! U made this video like it was the last day of your life! The format, style, editing, it was gorgeous. I felt more gooood in the feel my rhythm part, it was amazing i love your tier ranking vids.
Ps. The evolution of our girlies, fromis 9, back then made me love u moreee.
So sad to hear the disrespect for Power Up and Peek-a-boo! I agreed with most everything else though, thank you for taking so much time to make this thoughtful list!
If I had to, I would put Zimzalabim at my bottom of the list, but I still appreciate it for the amazing production. TBH I would hate to think of any of the RV songs not existing because I will take as much content as I can get! 💖💛💚💙💜Reveluvs fighting!
the introduction to feel my rhythm made me emotional lol.. but FMR was a cultural reset, everything kpop needed. i am so mad that people don't appreciate it the way they do to psycho but feel i am soooo satisfied with the ep. and this has so good bside. this is honestly one of their non-skipable ep. and the concept of combining classical music to new music, their costume in this era, their voice. everything was perfect. just one thing i wasn't satisfied with was that sm didn't promote it more but expecting anything from sm is just hurting my own feelings
Day 1 sounds so nostalgic. Reminds me of the opening themes of retro animes for children. Love it so much.
You literally ATE with the transitions and script
Wait...this is such a beautiful video, why did I get emotional at some points?😭💘
The “I am still stuck in this era” for Bad Boy is very really like how did we move on after that majestic song
I love love LOVE the editing in this
the way you explain everything and the editing is so good
okay okay okay hear me out: power up may not be their best title track, but the b-sides on summer magic? IMMACULATE. mosquito goes SO hard, with you and blue lemonade have cute summery vibes, mr. e and hit that drum have great upbeat energies, and the english version of bad boy is such a treat!! (even if the lyrics are a bit awkward/questionable at times) all of red velvet's b-sides are absolute gems but i find myself returning to the summer magic b-sides more often than the b-sides on red summer or queendom, for example.
also i'm so so happy to find another reveluv who actually enjoys umpah umpah!! it's so upbeat and fun and it deserves so much more love!!
I swear i got chills at the end of the one of these nights section its so beautifully done and so as the all song transitions
this video was EVERYTHING i couldnt have agreed more with this tier list, thank you for this !!
You know the discography is perfect when I'm struggling to think of just ONE fav title track, and I don't even exclude the Japanese releases because UGH so good
This is such a cute and well made video omg
I enjoyed every minute of it (except for the power up and zimzalabim part :P)
no, but honestly I LOVE THIS
Red Velvet are my all time favourite group but listening to you talk about them made me like them even more lmao
Thank you for making this video! It's amazing, from the concept to the execution, it's a beautiful tribute to RV.
oml, i really really enjoy the video, ESPECIALLY TYE EDITING IS SO SO *CHEF KISS*
thank you for this list, and for explaning your views and not just ranking their songs without explanations !
The editing of this video is just.. Stunning I love it so much
That ending! I swear your video essays are sooo good
this video is so well done, i absolutely loved it!! the transitions are iconic, and the opinions are on point, and i agreed with a majority of your rankings (although red flavor is def god velvet for me!). i can just tell from how much effort went into producing this video that you really love red velvet and their music, so thank you for sharing!
feel my rhythm was actually why got me into red velvet (thanks to those teaser photos 🙏🙏) and i can say that it is truly a masterpiece. i actually hate classical music because of my older bro being a part of orchestras most of my life, a lot of my adolescent life was fed into classical music to the point where my heavy punk music would counter it. but when i heard this song, it made me realize just how beautiful and amazing classical can really be, and how it can be transformed into something way beyond just strings and horns. red velvet has done it again and if it can transform my boredom and hatred into new found appreciation, then they're truly artists
The editing is so good, I can't explain how much I love this editing. It must've took a long time to edit this, honestly one of the best editings I've seen on K-POP UA-cam.
Other then the fact that I agree with everything you said. This video is very well put. Your editing and commentary kept me so entertained! Definitely subbed.
I started stanning red velvet recently and... I WAS NOT READY. I was scrolling through my homepage when I saw this video, and I'm so glad you did it because it made me go and look up a lot of songs I didn't know, so tyyyyy. Btw i love ur videos, I'm always waiting for news and theyre just so well edited and everything... Thank you so much (I mean it)
i love the one of these nights and umpah umpah appreciation, also our opinions are REALLY similar like i agree with lots of your points in each song! loved this vid tbh
Here again to appreciate this masterpiece of a video, especially the feel my rhythm part. Just chefs kiss
the editing is immaculate omg this was such an enjoyable video to watch
your videos always make me so emotional idk why, but i really love them!!
appreciation you for doing this whole ass doc, im enjoying it
okay so, you're in for a huge ramble. i know i'm pretty late with watching this video considering you posted it like 9 months ago, but i'm glad i finally clicked on it after seeing it so many times in my recommendations. i just love the way you edit, describe and even rank things, although i don't always agree with your opinions (which is totally fine btw), + i love red velvet a bunch as well, so i enjoyed this so, so much. especially the last part where you talk about feel my rhythm because you put it in a light i've never seen it in and it made me like the song even more. i even got teary eyed with the things you had to say about it and this is not the first time happening to me while watching your videos. maybe it's me being too emotional and over dramatic since i am currently sick while writing this, but i just wanted to say thank you for making videos and for making them the way you make them, if that makes sense. i could honestly only wish getting on your level of quality content (let's ignore that i haven't posted videos so far during this entire year). so again, thank you for this video and have a nice day!
this might be one of the best youtube videos ever made. especially about rv. nobody does it like them. also the editing!??!! for the most part I agree with your ranking
i love how the god velvet tier is the one with most songs + this video is edited really really beautifully u ate that
Great Video! Didn’t even realize it was 40 min long ! I watched it all through in one sitting. Red Velvet is something special ✨Love how you explain each MV + the editing.
💖💛💙💚💜
I just really wanted to compliment on your editing of the video! I imagine it took you quite a bit of time and it’s obvious that you probably put a bunch of effort into it. The music in the background, the cool title shots, the subtitles, and the transitions between the songs made the video all the more fun to watch! I didn’t agree with EVERY single opinion you have on the songs but I generally appreciated your opinions and I can really tell that you really love Red Velvet :)
bro your editing is something i've never seen before, IT'S STUNNING! YOU DESERVE LIKE OVER 1M SUBS MAN! 😭💕
omg i really love your tier list and i WHOLEHEARTEDLY agree on what u all said about this tier list. The vid was also well done
This was such a great video about red velvet songs. And I loved every part of this video and enjoyed it thoroughly. Maybe the reason why I really like this particular review of yours about RV is because your reviews and thoughts on their songs are same as mine and you described everything perfectly. Your editing was amazing and even I was getting emotional as I was watching this video till the end. I'm not even a reveluv, just a casual listener but this video also made me realize that despite me not being their fan, red velvet will always manage to capture people with their diversity in music and artistry that they never fail to deliver.
All in all, I really enjoyed this video and am not really the type to write long essays in comments, your editing was so worth it to praise about so I couldn't resist the chance.
The editing in this video is so so so good. That's all. Thank you.
THE AUDIO FADING EDIT IS SO MAGICAL IM CRYING OF HOW WELL MADE AND TIMED EACH AUDIO FADE WAS
thanks for this video winterosy. i can tell this probably took a lot of hard work to make and us viewers appreciate it! i agreed with pretty much everything in this video and i hope to see more like this 🙏 also i totally agree with what you said about one of these night. idk why people dont appreciate that song more it is literally a masterpiece
Can I just take a moment to praise your editing. Because I just loved it all the way through!
truly beautiful video, loved it !
oh my goodness... this is the most creative love letter to rv's legendary discography. The way you edited this is amazing! I enjoyed watching this so much 🥺
Wow the editing of this video is top-notch! I had major goosebumps at the end when you were talking about Feel My Rhythm. They were definitely robbed during Psycho era but I know their best is yet to come! Can't wait 🤞
the editing,, the ranking,, everything. this was so good and only 8.5k views?? this deserves 1 million idc what other people say this is literally so good 🫶😍
man i love your editing skills, it gives me chills
Your taste is IMMACULATE, one of these nights doesn’t get enough love man 😭 I’m so glad you recognised the beauty in it 😭
the editing on here is phenomenal like woah..... literal chills
Such a well made video, thank you!
this video is so well made i really loved it and the final conclusion made me tear up. i felt your emotions about not only about the music but about what the girls mean to you
wow your reflexions on red flavor got me on tears, what a beautiful way to express your thoughts in a song. 💟