Why I switched to Capture One (comparision to Adobe Lightroom)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 гру 2022
- Lightroom or Capture One? Where do I see the advantages and disadvantages of each RAW converter? And what would I choose today?
I also use Topaz Software for improving my images (Affiliate link): www.topazlabs.com/image-quali...
Good discussion of the pros and cons. I think you should have managed that LR has (now) better mask management, i.e., one can add masks or subtract them from each other. C1 also used to be way better regarding colour editing tools, but LR caught up. Sadly, C1 lost its way recently with many features not implemented well (panorama, HDR), some worse than they were before (export dialogue
Thanks for your input. I totally agree with you. I will pin the comment so that hopefully many other see it as well
I liked your honest reflection/discussion on both.
Thanks
Same reason I still are looking for alternatives. The management features in LRc are just above everybody else. I need to have a proper catalogue.
I continue to use LR for its asset management capabilities, I used to export TIFFs from DPP4 to get a much better raw conversion and resentful switched to using DxO PL6 for raw conversion, optical corrections and noise reduction. All other edits and masking is done in LR, the new AI-assisted masking is like magic. For photo’s that don’t need superior sharpness or noise reduction, I just import the raws straight into LR.
I’m also using custom camera profiles from ColorFidelity since the Adobe profiles for the M6II and R7 turn my skin into zombie grey.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I was always curious to try DXO Photolab 😊
im on LR 5.71. my daughter and wife have the 2 licenses in my LR 6. i just bought C1 23 (before it goes to subscription) because if im going to have software for any length of time, its more cost effective to have the old style.
ill be trying the C1 here in the near future...
Have fun
Very nice video! I tried Capture one for a few days and although I didn't use it for a long period of time I found lightroom's still better for me. In addition, Capture One perpetual license doesn't include new software only bug fixes and stuff like that and we are talking about 1.631 US dollars.
Thanks! Yes, I’m also not happy about that change. But how do you end up with 1631 USD for Capture One?
@@FabianFoppNaturephotography Not at all. I'm on currently Adobe. While in the long run I end up paying more, at least I get all the latest updates from Adobe. Adobe's current AI is bloody awesome right now. :)
Capture One's push towards subscription recently and their upcoming changes to perpetual licenses, pushed me to look for an alternative from C1. I'm now using DxO PhotoLab 6 and couldn't be happier.
Yeah, let’s see how the prices will look like in the future
Can you organize your images and add keywords in DxO PhotoLab 6?
@@bioliv1 Since you don't actually upload any folders or files into PhotoLab, like you would in Capture One or Lightroom, I'm guessing any image organization you want to do is done outside of PhotoLab. But I could be wrong. Yes you can add keywords in PhotoLab 6.
Here's a UA-cam video that might help answer your questions better. it's version 4 but still applicable to version 6. At about the 32:06 time he goes into keyboarding. ua-cam.com/video/LEu94iG5KYY/v-deo.html DxO offers a 30 day fully functional trial version if you want to try it out first.
I'll have a look at that. As I wrote above, I'm looking for something better than DPP4 and not as complicated as Lr.
Do you buy DxO PhotoLab 6 or have to subscribe to it?
@@fgb3126 Lr Cloud is extremely easy, and the best for removing chromatic aberrations.
Same as you, I don't like the subscriptions, mostly because I am out of internet most of the time, at least any good internet as I use satellite internet. Anyway, now my LT 6 is not working with windows 11, I think this is the reason. It starts and close down after a few seconds. So I really appreciate this review and I think I will go for the Capture 1
Thanks!
Smart Previews in LRC?... I think COP always works in a similar fashion: we can perform some functions and edits offline, thats why COP seems to take longer importing and building a catalog, what it does is what LRc do when you turn on the option to build Smart Previews. If we make that comparison, making LrC work in a similar way as COP does, we can see that the import time and the size of the two catalogs+previews is roughly equivalent. If i'm not correct, I apologise. Have a nice 2023. Cheers.
Hi!
Thanks for your comment and happy new year as well. Yes, many things work similar but AFAIK you can’t export pictures that are offline with Capture One
Hi Fabian, not ever having heard of Capture 1 I was hoping that it was the kind of post-processing program I have been seeking: that is, a program between my current Canon Digital Photo Professional 4 and Lightroom 6. I've never been able to get into Lightroom, it's just too complicated. So I've stayed with my trusty DPP 4. But obviously there is more that I'd like to be able to do with my photos. Surely someone will develope a process like what I'm after: more sophisticated that DPP but not as damned complicated as Lightroom. (By the way I bought Lightroom 6 which I still own; I saw that subscription rip-off coming and did something about it. Not having ever used Lr I certainly did not need anything more "up-to-date" than 6!)
Hi! I can‘t stand DPP as I find it very hard to use. But I also have not found the perfect program yet
@@FabianFoppNaturephotography at first glance I thought you were being sarcastic! DPP too hard to use?! I'm a technological idiot and I can use it no problem. Maybe if a fella can use Lr easily then he can't use something simple! LOL
Ok, different opinion apparently. Some tasks I find really time consuming
Lr Cloud with 1TB storage is extremely easy to learn!
But unfortunately also very limited for my taste
@@FabianFoppNaturephotography Yes, of course, Capture One is much more fun. But Lr Cloud you can learn in a couple of days, if you want to concentrate on photography only. Note that AOWS only uses Lr Cloud.
Does C1 replace LR + PS? As LR+PS always come togerther.
No, C1 is comparable to Lightroom (a bit more powerful in editing). But I have never used photoshop to edit my images anyway, so I don’t miss that
I’ve used most of the commercial and freeware converters. They all have advantages and disadvantages. I still prefer C1 for portrait work for clients. The workflow of C1, especially if you use multiple computers, is hard to beat. That said, I think LR is a better overall converter that works well in most situations. The $10/mo (in the US) is a great deal.
Thanks for your input!
It's a great deal if you want to be Adobe's serf.
Does Topaz software work (as a plug-in) with C1?
yes it does
Yes, i use it like that all the time 😊
Don’t pay subscription model.
Then I guess Capture One is your only option