Forclaz Trek 900 Best Budget Ultralight Tent?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- Could this be the best value ultralight tent?
Is it worth €130/£100?
You want to read this review?
www.theonegood...
After a 3 weeks of ownership and a few nights of wild camping, I wanted to share my overall review on this ultralight tent from Decathlon. (Hopefully after 2-3 months we can share a more long term review.)
In this review, I do compare this tent to my old trusty 4 year old R.E.I Passage 1 tent. Which hopefully gives a better impression of the Forclaz Trek 900 materials, and it's overall design.
I want to note that even though this is rated as a 3 season tent, it did a good job of trapping heat inside the room of the tent.
Thanks for the overview, I've got the 2 man version, it's worth the extra money and bit more weight, it's like a palace in there - 2 doors, 2 vestibules, one for my kit the other for my Brompton. I have been waiting over a year for someone to actually do a review of one of these tents 'in the field', not just a Decathlon video. If you buy the extra footprint, you can set it up freestanding outer-first, then clip the inner in afterwards thats why they call it semi-freestanding, you need the NOT included footprint (more money, more weight). The pegs are OK, you just need to angle them better - 45 - 60 degrees for security (the hole in the top is for you to add small cord to, to help in removal). A couple of Delta pegs in your kit will always help, it would seem almost everyone swaps their pegs out for their preferred style and material anyway. Its always sold out here in the UK, so it would seem popular, but strangely there aren't any reviews for it anywhere on UA-cam... (as of March 2021). Looks like a beautiful place to live and camp, thanks again.
I wanted to buy that one, but I ended up buying the lower end trek 100, because it was sold out. It's only 400grams havier tho and the material is much thicker and it is freestanding, so I am pretty happy with my decision.
@Montañero Paisa I do. I have now used it for a total of 50 days and it's still in fairly good shape. The fact you can pitch it in the rain without anything getting wet is great. I might still buy the tent in the video to save 800 grams on my next trip. They both have their pros and cons.
@Montañero Paisa If I was backpacking I'd definitely take the tent in the video. I usually go bike packing tho, so I can afford to carry some extra weight. Have fun in Pakistan!
I will midify my 1p version with another Y section. Like this the tent will be free standing and I will be able to set it up rainfly first easier. And it will only need 2 more stakes for the vestibules.
for a guy with bulging discs and lower back issues this tent made camping possible again for me, 1.3 kg is the best part of it
The tent is decent, I used it during a Storm Francis about 35mph winds, it held up
That being said, I had to get some deeper more heavy duty pegs from Cotswold
I have this tent, I used it during the last summer here in Sweden and I like it. It's light but wouldn't say it's ultralight. Found the interior a bit small for me (I'm 1,79m) but not too bad. I'll use it again during this summer.
Dude this tent's thin coating can be a life saver under extreme hot over 37°... I can not stand the hot weather and can not sleep at night so this tent could be what I look for. For ppl who have no problem with hot weather I will definitely recommend Ferrino Solo. That s the best I have seen so far...
thanks for the detailed reviews.
It appears to be a clone of the MSR Freelite 1p, at practically one third of the price. The material is similar to that used by MSR. Knowing Decathlon, it is a very good buy.
A niggling problem I find with the tent, is when it comes to attach the flysheet to the horizontal pole, where there are two attachment points. I really need to tug at the loop to clip it on. Not sure if you came across this problem or not?
Most tents are a clone of another tent. Most tent designs haven't changed much in decades. Just materials. Many people don't realise this. The design of This particular tent in this video has been around for at least 20 years. Almost identical to the old Phoenix Phreeranger
Many thanks for this review! I resigned buying 3P version because of this thin materials! You helped me a lot :)
Please, do a review of your older tent :)
waiting for Decathlon to get these back in stock, seem like a solid option.
I juts bought this tent, to use during my hike of the South Downs Way. So far, only spent one night in it (to test it out).
Weight is competitive. Don't know that I would call it ultralight, but at this price point, and for those of us in a pinch, it works (I shaved almost 500 grams compared to the tent I used last year on the SDW).
Price is incredible if you ask me. Agree that the durability of the materials might be a constant doubt, and also the finish in some of the seams isn't great, but if you want to try a smaller tent, or can't stretch that far with your budget, it's great.
Space is so-so, leaning towards small, definitely an acquired taste, and helps if you're willing to leave the pack outside (you will have to).
Pegs are good, comparable to MSR Needle. Personally I will use four of them (on the corners), and add 6 v-pegs (for guy lines, vestibule and rear)
I do wish the webbing straps that attach the top of the fly (head end) were the same as the bottom ones (foot end), or viceversa; that way you just have to 'learn' one way, and not have to remind yourself about clipping the G hook or whatnot.
One nifty trick it has (and should be easy to replicate as a hack on other tents) is the bottom corner of the door is attached with some cord to the zip puller, so that when you pull the zip upwards to open the door, it 'travels' up, like a curtain, instead of dangling down on the floor.
Hope it'll do me proud on the SDW in 10 days time...
PS: I also think I will end up buying the footprint...
The foot print is usefull and u can keepit in the sack.
Thank you for the review, I was considering this tent due to it's availability and budget price. Could be a bit tight for my height (182cm) .
Cheers, I appreciate the feedback. Honestly 175cm is the maximum, maybe if they do a larger size if it's possible definitely go with the bigger size, perhaps the 2 person might be better? 👍
@@TheOneGoodRoad i dont understand, on the website and bag it say bedroom lenght 210cm, why is it tight for 175??
@@matteo-cu8uv i have a friend who use this tent, he is 190cm and the tent isn't small for him.
@@dobocsillag7007 Hali, a haverod mióta használja? Mi a véleménye róla?
Thanks for this video! Might get this when I need a one person tent for myself.
Good honest review....and a nice guitalele at the end! 😁 Thanks👍
Thanks for honest and detailed review. It seems to be really good for moderate conditions. Looks like better option than MSR regarding price and than my Fjord Nansen ultralight tent (Tromvik) that I'm not satisfied with. Anyway great thanks once again!
Your opinion and experience are a little different from what I've experienced with this tent. If you think this material is not durable, please don't ever buy a Nemo 😂 The trade off of weight vs durability applies to every tent on the market. I prioritise weight every time, so this tent suits me more than the REI version. I agree with you - this is a fantastic budget offering, allowing people to get into lightweight tents at an affordable price. Compare it to a Big Agnes Copper Spur (freestanding vs semi freestanding) and it's half the price at the same weight and durability.
Thank you, I just bought the fly, poles, bedroom and ground sheet for £87, I have spare ultrAlight pegs anyway.
I saw you could do that on the Decathlon website, seems crazy you can buy it as 'parts replacement' for cheaper than the whole package
@@IgnacioGlezCllo you don’t get the pegs or bag but yes, a significant saving!
@@stickyprickle Can I ask where on the website you got the single parts?
@@InsaneShape Hi, I simply put in the search term “p1 900” , “ forclaz 1 person” and “900 tent” on the decathlon website and scrolled through the results to find what I wanted. However I have just had a look and they currently have no stock of either the spares or the full tent. I guess if you want something light, cheap and this month have a look at a flame creed on AliExpress, it’s a trekking pole tent but at 700g and £70 it’s remarkably good except for condensation and no warranty. Good luck.
Wish I'd seen this FFS tent just cost me 159£ still need a ground sheet and better peggs too 😮
I'd love this guitar :D
It's amazing 😁 #guitarlele 🤟
@@TheOneGoodRoad Holy F***! This is the day when something changed in my life. U'r great. Thanks Mate! That's the stuff I'm lookin' for
@@LPlata happy to help! :)
I've used mine now for a year on a few overnight fastpacking trips. I'm 180 cm and I have room at the head and by my feet when I use my decathlon or Nemo mat. Not sure how at 173 you have no room.
Now i use camp minima superlight 1p for bikepacking - tent is really light and super small when packed. But it is like bivi, I cant even sit in it. So probably will buy decathlon. 300gr havier and a lot bigger when packed but should be worth it.
This tent is awesome. Just needs pitching properly and it’s really solid in the wind.
Yeah with different stakes or tying it down securely it would be an improvement for next time.
Hey, thank you for your video. I've been following you for years. I'm a bike tourer also and I live in France (though I'm American). Also, I love Decathlon. Most of my bike touring and hiking gear is from there. If you don't mind my asking, what are you doing in France?
Yup decathlon had gotten a lot better over the years. I appreciate the support! 👍 What am I doing in France? Well... I love mountains and the pyrenees has a few of them? France is gerenally cheaper than the UK? Hard question to answer. Long story short I live in France but due to the brexit changes, I'm unsure if can start much longer and can only visit on standard tourist visas. So yeah...
@@TheOneGoodRoad You can apply for a visa. My British friends all got theirs pretty easily. If you've lived in France since before Brexit you should be fine. Let me know if you need info.
Kinda odd that you say its not durable when youve only used it a couple of days. Apart from that very informative review, thanks.
This was more of a comparison video. Since then I have purchased the tent my self I think it's fantastic for the price.
1.300g for a 1 person tent would hardly be classified as ultralight. Still a good value for money.
On most tents I twist the peg once or twice it helps stop it coming out of the loop, (as in once it’s in the loop twist clockwise) attach a little paracord to the thick ribbon peg out points. How did this hold up over time? It’s £160 now my only other options are Alpkit soloist mostly good but badly designed door, or Naturehike.
To my surprise its done well for my use case. Thx for the tip. I'd still recommend the tent.
Hey
Thanks for video.
Please tell me the name of your old tent and where did you buy?
I am also camper and will be glad if you check some of videos
R.E.I but no sure if they still make that model.
@@TheOneGoodRoad thanks
Привет с Израиля. Вчера мы с женой спали в этой палатке вдвоём. Было экстримально, но мы выжили lol
I am a Japanese who cannot speak English, but I would like to ask a question using automatic translation.
When I read the official website, it says "This tent can withstand some snow, but it is not constructed to withstand loads." How much snow can it actually withstand?
I don't intend to use it for mountaineering when it snows a lot, but I would like to know because I intend to go to a mountain with less snow in November and December.
As a side note, there are no actual Decathlon stores in Japan, and few products are available on the Internet. Therefore, we are unable to purchase a dedicated groundsheet. Since we are on the other side of the world, it is difficult for us to deal with any malfunctions. We have to accept it, but it is sad.
Not sure I fully understand the question because it says on the website it's a 3 season tent not 4 season. If you use it in winter remember it's not designed for that season. You can use it in the snow but it's not designed for it. Remember you can take a short visit to South Korea there they have Decathlon at Seoul.
@@TheOneGoodRoad
Sorry
I am a beginner who has only been mountaineering for about a year, and I heard from a senior student at my university that "I went to a mountain where it snows thickly with a summer tent, so I think it will be fine even if it is not a winter tent. I thought this tent would be good for three seasons, but I still couldn't shake off my uneasiness and asked him about it.
Now that I think about it, there are tents in the world that can be used for both summer and winter simply by changing the flysheet, so perhaps that was the tent that the senior had used. I guess he was using such a tent, instead of a 3-season tent like mine.
Anyway, there is such an event in Korea. I did not know that. I would like to visit there when I can afford it. Thank you very much.
If you compare sawaj 3 ultralight? Which you prefer?
nice location
Can you place stuff on the other side of the vestibule that doesn’t have door on the inner mesh and outer fly? Was thinking if the stake could be removed from the outer and stuff could be placed there before staking down again. Thank you!
Well yes in theory but you would reduce the size of the other side.
Thank you for this review ! I was thinking about buying this tent but you kind of convinced me about your older one. The REI ("Passenger One "? ). Is there any possibility to get one of those or maybe an updatet version ? I'm from Europe, but in times of globalisation there must be a way right ? If you have other recommendations for lightweight single person tents (due to your experience) I'm listening =) Looking forward for new videos ! Thanks again keep up the great work.
Well they are possible to import from R.E.I website you can simply order them but you will encounter high import fees. Maybe %20 or less? Depends on the country. I can recommend the 2 man quickhiker tent from decathlon still worth money. Good luck and thanks for the feedback, it's rare people agree with my opinion 😉
I still can’t decide tarp+bivy or tent for winter in Scotland
For warmth? Definitely tent 👌🏻
It's great but it's NOT ultralight. The Naturehike Tagar 2 beats it in weight and size when packed into a backpack. Also Tagar is WAY easier to pitch up, which is super imporant in rain and wind.
Is that the yamaha guitalele??
Yup it's the GL1 I mention it in one of my gear list videos.
Year later, they didn’t improve anything
10:05 - See what you did there...
I don't think it's proper to write "1 people". I guess it should be "1 person". The word people means more than one person.