Deconstructing I Want You (She's So Heavy) - The Beatles (Isolated Tracks)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 168

  • @sebastianmaharg
    @sebastianmaharg 2 місяці тому +39

    0:30 "It's no use being working class these days." That's what McCartney says.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +8

      Ahh that makes sense. I just couldn't understand the last part.

    • @earling22
      @earling22 Місяць тому +1

      He’s really funny. Says that’s what the guy gets for buying a house in a crummy neighborhood.

  • @rbstems
    @rbstems 2 місяці тому +56

    It'll be hard for anyone to make a better deconstruction than this, amazing job!

  • @BigSky1
    @BigSky1 2 місяці тому +53

    Ringo is just phenomenal.

  • @mysterymac38
    @mysterymac38 Місяць тому +22

    People have waited over 50 years for this!!

  • @hw343434
    @hw343434 Місяць тому +10

    John & George, the greatest and most influential guitar duo ever in my book

  • @sambakery2006
    @sambakery2006 2 місяці тому +38

    The video I'm sure we have all been excited and waiting for. And wow, it is a million times better than we could have imagined. Thank you so much for all the hard and amazing work Isolated Sterms

  • @RebelBourke
    @RebelBourke Місяць тому +14

    My all time favourite beatles song. and now I get to listen to an hours worth of everything I've already heard before! thanks for this

  • @gconyers
    @gconyers 2 місяці тому +47

    Paul’s bass playing is stellar as usual.

  • @jameskelly2559
    @jameskelly2559 Місяць тому +17

    That bass playing is incredible. What a tone he has, too.

  • @jaradwilson1251
    @jaradwilson1251 Місяць тому +6

    Why is this so meditative to listen to this all the way through!?.All the space in each track is so calming. This is a revelation

  • @JoaoGabriel-lk9cv
    @JoaoGabriel-lk9cv 2 місяці тому +15

    That’s fantastic. John’s voice… wow!

    • @ili626
      @ili626 Місяць тому +2

      we should be protesting AI exploitation

  • @joaquinsandoval5370
    @joaquinsandoval5370 Місяць тому +18

    I love Billy's parts so much. The harmonies, the improvs, the eerie sounds. Exactly what the song needed.

  • @richeymeister
    @richeymeister Місяць тому +13

    I was so happy to hear Billy Preston's contribution. It is so far down in most mixes as to practically vanish. It is astounding.

    • @pooman784
      @pooman784 Місяць тому

      Nobody talks about Preston's contribution to this song. He's a God

  • @philboyer9076
    @philboyer9076 Місяць тому +15

    Billy's organ part in the coda is vewry eerie. Sounds like a soundtrack to those old time horror movies.

  • @1rwjwith
    @1rwjwith 2 місяці тому +23

    Great to finally here clearly George’s guitar..it is an essential part if the song. Wow, there is always this talk of “guitar weaving” in the Stones but George and John did a lot of that too here. Very much a live in the studio band track.

  • @sackrafix
    @sackrafix Місяць тому +1

    whou, whou, whou and WOUH !!!!!!! Not more words need this amazing deconstruction. I can feel your love for this group of musicans that changed the world!!
    WOUH!

  •  15 днів тому +1

    A masterpiece. The four of them at the peak of their powers. Everything is amazing. We´ve all aknowlwedge Ringo´s drums, Paull bass, George Guitar. Even Preston skills. But above all, finally, the prove that John is an amazing lead guitarist. As well a singer, writer, composer, arranger and producer, of course.

  • @rockyraccoon2817
    @rockyraccoon2817 2 місяці тому +5

    Massive work on deconstructing them and the breakdown and full history in the description! I think you’re the only person to do this haha

  • @TheGabeNewellGamingChannel
    @TheGabeNewellGamingChannel 2 місяці тому +8

    This is the most impressive isolation job I've seen. This is awesome man!

  • @2145791
    @2145791 2 місяці тому +15

    Having known this album nearly all of my life and I’m only 63 I always wondered where the bass run came from in the outro and thought it must be Billy but now realise it’s Paul on his Hofner. Thanks x

    • @doctorpatient519
      @doctorpatient519 2 місяці тому +1

      another video I recently viewed stated that Paul ditched the Hofner for a Rickenbacker 4001 ... which is correct?

    • @2145791
      @2145791 2 місяці тому

      @@doctorpatient519 sounds like the Hofner to me.

    • @doctorpatient519
      @doctorpatient519 2 місяці тому +1

      @@2145791 thnx for the courtesy of your reply ... if you're better able to differentiate between the two guitars by the audio, good for you ... what I hear is that characteristic "thud" quality of flat wounds ... in subsequent video watching, it was a bass iso vid had only one picture for the video and Paul's playing the Rick

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +5

      @@doctorpatient519 Since this was recorded in February 1969 Paul most likely used the Hofner as he started to regain his liking for it after the January Get Back sessions. He used it again for Something, but I think the rest of the songs recorded for Abbey Road used other basses. We don't know 100% though as there aren't any actual images from the sessions but this does have the Hofner sound heard in the same period.

    • @doctorpatient519
      @doctorpatient519 2 місяці тому +2

      @@isolatedstems great info!
      thnx for the follow-up
      I still love his playing, regardless of the instrument model

  • @pez.emikazoo
    @pez.emikazoo 2 місяці тому +3

    Thank you, it's such a thrill to hear with such quality that piano. It's so evil and buried so deep down in the mix♪

  • @ChrisM-ve6qc
    @ChrisM-ve6qc Місяць тому +4

    I remember hearing this for the first time at age 13 in ‘70 or ‘71. The end was such a jolt. The song sounded spooky to me. Listening to the Billy Preston part makes it spooky all over again.

  • @thebordenasylum7726
    @thebordenasylum7726 Місяць тому +75

    That person who complained about The Beatles being too loud, lived out the rest of their life with nobody remembering their name- meanwhile, the noise they complained about turned into a song that will be remembered another 100 years from now

    • @evertvdb000
      @evertvdb000 Місяць тому +11

      I Want You is my favorite song.
      But people have the right to a good night's sleep. Even a 'nobody' (according to you).
      That person who complained had the right to complain. Trident studio was located in the middle of Soho London. Not an ideal place to have a recording studio.

    • @thebordenasylum7726
      @thebordenasylum7726 Місяць тому

      @@evertvdb000 You're correct, but it's The Beatles, what can you do

    • @evertvdb000
      @evertvdb000 Місяць тому +3

      @@thebordenasylum7726 Just do what he did: call the police, and the police called Trident, and the Trident manager asked the Beatles to tone it down. And they did. after 1 more take.
      But Abbey Road is/was a much better location to record music, during the night, like Beatles did after 1965.

    • @Steve-d8s
      @Steve-d8s Місяць тому +1

      ​@@evertvdb000poor Bastard

    • @Steve-d8s
      @Steve-d8s Місяць тому +1

      Poor Bastard

  • @robinfoster7597
    @robinfoster7597 Місяць тому +2

    This is The Beatles greates track, their Magnum Opus. Love it. :)

  • @glentorn5362
    @glentorn5362 Місяць тому +4

    There was genius amidst this crucible of creativity! 💙💜❤🧡

  • @jimmyv1301
    @jimmyv1301 Місяць тому +1

    Thank you for your time and effort in producing this!!!

  • @alexisperez5589
    @alexisperez5589 2 місяці тому +4

    That´s Cool! Great deconstruction! Congratulations! I like your work in separate instruments!

  • @stitchgrimly6167
    @stitchgrimly6167 2 місяці тому +5

    Even the photos are awesome. Right down to the effect at the end

  • @LautaroHourcade
    @LautaroHourcade 2 місяці тому +4

    No! This can't be so good! Please! Thank you thank you thank you!

  • @xIceyx115
    @xIceyx115 Місяць тому +5

    28:57 is the part your looking for…

  • @Arganthonio
    @Arganthonio 2 місяці тому +3

    Yo creo que con esta canción de John, dieron lo mejor de si mismos en sus instrumentos. Tocaron la perfección.

  • @GregoryKeithe
    @GregoryKeithe 2 місяці тому +5

    💯 one of your best ever!!
    Great bass work by Paul! Very unconventional
    I play a Hofner bass. I would bet large amounts of money I don't have that this is NOT a Hofner on this recording. It has a scooped sound, lots of lows and bright clear highs. A Hofner has a fuller rounder sound in the mids and lows.
    I do not own a Rickenbacker or Fender so I can't speak to the tendencies of those two basses, I don't have a hunch one way or another.. But Paul is most likely playing his Ric or Fender here.
    And Billy's organ! 🔥

    • @WithoutTheBeatles
      @WithoutTheBeatles Місяць тому

      I agree. I have a Hofner and Ricky bass and tgis is way too solid for the violin bass.

    • @drvee1983
      @drvee1983 Місяць тому

      Paul used his Rick on this.

  • @DeKevers
    @DeKevers 2 місяці тому +14

    I go crazy for John Lennon's voice

  • @zvigoshen5848
    @zvigoshen5848 2 місяці тому +4

    Одна из моих любимых песен. Результат впечатляющей, коллективной работы четверки+ Билли Престона.

  • @gaizkasalazarrodriguez5054
    @gaizkasalazarrodriguez5054 2 місяці тому +4

    Wonderful!!!👌👌👌THANKS A LOT!!!!!

  • @bullcrap9409
    @bullcrap9409 Місяць тому +5

    The thing about the Beatles (one of thousands) is their arrangements were insanely good.
    For example? Look at Dear Prudence. Starts off as a lovely light Travis picked folk song. Later swells into heavy drone stoner bit with fuzz guitar…and then? Ends as a sweet little folk song.

  • @stellapolanco6860
    @stellapolanco6860 Місяць тому +6

    The Moog synth part is insane !

  • @williswet
    @williswet Місяць тому

    FANTASTIC! Thanks so very much. I love hearing this stuff. 👍

  • @oskarmac14
    @oskarmac14 24 дні тому

    The moment you hear the arpeggios, you realize they started it all. Way back in Hamburg, they began their unique style. OMG. Just spell binding.

  • @thebeatlesarchive57-70
    @thebeatlesarchive57-70 Місяць тому

    Excellent work! These details are so useful and interesting✌️🙌

  • @parabenstv
    @parabenstv Місяць тому

    Genius at work. Incredible.

  • @IsmaëlMOUBACHIR
    @IsmaëlMOUBACHIR 2 місяці тому +3

    Excellent ! Je ne savais même pas qu’il y avait un piano !

  • @maop1959
    @maop1959 2 місяці тому +4

    GENIAL, GOOD JOB, THANKS

  • @MarceloMarqués-b1l
    @MarceloMarqués-b1l 2 місяці тому +3

    Gracias gracias Muchas gracias!!

  • @handlessbeggar11
    @handlessbeggar11 2 місяці тому +7

    Of interest the photo of the band taken from behind Ringo is at Apple studio. Paul has shaven off his beard and John is now starting to grow his. This is February 69 but its not Trident studios. Here is a great link featuring Peter Jackson discussing what happened during February
    ua-cam.com/video/uI03kB34sZ0/v-deo.html

  • @sbrave2
    @sbrave2 Місяць тому

    OMG, those vocal harmonies!!!

  • @trashbolt8437
    @trashbolt8437 2 місяці тому +4

    THANK YOU SO MUCH

  • @MrTafyism
    @MrTafyism 2 місяці тому +14

    That wind machine is the stuff nightmares are made of

  • @cookiemanlives
    @cookiemanlives 2 місяці тому +12

    Ok, this is historic. Almost scary. How the hell did you do this? AI??

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +13

      Yeah the 7.1 mix, the rockband stems, ai separation software like lalalai and msvep, and a lot of trial and error.

  • @michaelcolarossi5062
    @michaelcolarossi5062 2 місяці тому +1

    really awesome!

  • @RoidoFoja
    @RoidoFoja 2 місяці тому +11

    Hi, I was wondering if you're going to do a deconstruction of I'm only sleeping I love your work, you separate the tracks very well.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +3

      Check this video out here: ua-cam.com/video/xkiL0KLc-hQ/v-deo.htmlsi=YAUIm_nqVEGttTZG. I probably can't get much better than it.

  • @gelandres
    @gelandres 25 днів тому +1

    I never knew there were congas in this song. This is probably Ringo’s best drumming. As well as McCartney’s best bass performance.

  • @michelefrogan7150
    @michelefrogan7150 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks a lot! A true class!

  • @jamescooper6842
    @jamescooper6842 Місяць тому

    Great work‼️👍

  • @ili626
    @ili626 Місяць тому +1

    their time feel is so good

  • @DAODEA
    @DAODEA Місяць тому

    This is incredible! All 5 of them mind-blowing. One of many favourite Beatles tracks. The interplay between George’s and John’s guitars is so good. John’s vocals!!! Billy and Ringo - so good. And Paul’s screaming and bass.
    In the 80’s, Bass Player did an issue on the ten best rock/pop bass lines of all time. I'm going off my memory here, but I recall they limited Maca to one or two spots; otherwise, he’d have dominated many of the ten spots. I think they ranked this the number 1 spot for Paul’s daring, inventiveness and tone. It's so out of tune and off-the-cuff, and perfect!!!
    I didn't realise this was at Apple. I knew they tried it at Apple for Let It Be sessions. I'd assumed it was abandoned and then started again at EMI for the Abbey Road LP. But that’s definitely Glynn on the talkback, and the photos are mostly taken at Apple.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  Місяць тому +1

      Oh the photos don't completely represent the session since I Want You (She's So Heavy) was recorded at trident. These were the only photos from February so that's why they were chosen. In actuality these photos are a sorta mysterious session that took place at Apple and was the last time they did something at Apple as a group. I Want You was recorded in a period before Abbey Road where they were still trying to record songs to fatten up Get Back/Let It Be. So Glyn was probably the main producer with George Martin helping like during the January Get Back sessions.

    • @DAODEA
      @DAODEA Місяць тому +1

      Wow. That's amazing. Thank you. Trident! I had no idea. I love this video. I wonder, do you know if Paul did the white noise on the Moog, or was it John? I only ask because you have John’s photo up at the end. I always assumed it was Paul because he seemed to understand/ take to the Moog more readily than John or George. Even though - I’m pretty sure it was George’s Moog.
      I’m so amazed. I’m an old guy, and I’ve been following this stuff my entire life. I love that there is always new information coming out. And videos like this are such a revelation.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  Місяць тому +2

      @@DAODEA George was really keen on the Moog he even made his Electronic Sound album using the Moog, so he was probably the Beatle most intrigued by it. John dubbed the moog white noise with Ringo also doing a wind machine at the same time

    • @DAODEA
      @DAODEA Місяць тому

      @@isolatedstems thank you!

  • @scottamichie
    @scottamichie Місяць тому +1

    Imagine. But for Yoko’s part in John’s life we wouldn’t have this song today.

  • @robertocolman
    @robertocolman 2 місяці тому +13

    Billy preston parts are like bass, you take out that and songs feel incomplete

    • @stellapolanco6860
      @stellapolanco6860 Місяць тому

      You are ridiculous, you remove any instrument, not just the organ or the bass and the song will also be incomplete. No one can imagine this song without the guitars, the drums or the Moog synthesizer. You don't act like a child.

  • @rensdguitar
    @rensdguitar Місяць тому +3

    47:00 is a cursed image

  • @osbezouros1
    @osbezouros1 2 місяці тому

    Excellent Man !

  • @earling22
    @earling22 Місяць тому

    1) imagine asking the Beatles to turn it down, and 2) imagine the biggest band in the world actually being nice about it (after one final take)

  • @saladandballad3709
    @saladandballad3709 2 місяці тому

    all time favorite song LETS GO YKNOW

  • @jwjeffrey
    @jwjeffrey 2 місяці тому +1

    The Conga part sounds like the beginning of Clutch Cargo if you can remember that.

  • @NickT1023
    @NickT1023 25 днів тому

    I’m thinking that one of the additional guitar codas was actually a Fender Bass VI. That actually gives the final mix that bowed cello and bowed bass sounds.

  • @justiceforall6412
    @justiceforall6412 Місяць тому +8

    Great drum work by Ringo!

  • @NigelWelch-x3h
    @NigelWelch-x3h 2 місяці тому +1

    Nigel in Canada 🇨🇦
    the first rock song tuned down to C#
    before Black Sabbath

  • @PamelaMcIntyre-d1j
    @PamelaMcIntyre-d1j Місяць тому

    the vocals!!!

  • @peterobrien1499
    @peterobrien1499 Місяць тому +1

    Who said they were average guitar/bass players? They are way beyond comparison.

  • @jeff11030
    @jeff11030 2 місяці тому +2

    Has anyone ever heard the actual ending of the recording, as they finally stop playing? John had the engineer cut the tape when he wanted to end, but that is not when they stopped playing. The song could have gone on for another minute or more. Would love to hear how they actually stopped playing.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +5

      You can kind of hear it in this mix released in the boxset: ua-cam.com/video/BvT4BUFauqc/v-deo.htmlsi=1QGsiw9ZCMcf2K5Y but it does feature some instruments that weren't used in the final mix. But the bass and drums are from the version we're used to. Also think it might include the overdubbed coda guitars 3 heard in this video as well.

  • @NigelWelch-x3h
    @NigelWelch-x3h 2 місяці тому

    Nigel in Canada 🇨🇦
    love 💘 it

  • @fernandodeleon7466
    @fernandodeleon7466 Місяць тому +2

    Lennon was right about Preston ... "he could be the fifth Beatle".
    Now, speaking in general, since you have all this material, you SHOULD do a new remix, more powerful, with drums more on front, keyboards less buried, etc .
    If I was you, I'll do it !!

  • @090nj2
    @090nj2 Місяць тому

    Billy really added tht flavour🫶🏿

  • @EFE_sopita
    @EFE_sopita 2 місяці тому +2

    Ohohohooooooooooo yeah🎉

  • @michaelwirth6843
    @michaelwirth6843 Місяць тому +2

    I have never heard a piano in this recording.😗

  • @noseloquedigo92514
    @noseloquedigo92514 2 місяці тому +20

    its his own fault for gettin a hous e in such a lousy district hahahahahah

    • @davidlauter1622
      @davidlauter1622 Місяць тому +1

      McCartneys arrogants Strutting itself again as usual !

    • @noseloquedigo92514
      @noseloquedigo92514 Місяць тому +1

      @@davidlauter1622 man, the boys had a great sense of humor, relax. They were funny guys.

    • @davidlauter1622
      @davidlauter1622 Місяць тому

      @@noseloquedigo92514 He was being sarcastic not funny - McCartney was an egomaniac back then, that's what really broke up The Beatles ! ( And don't tell me what to do ! )

  • @sigi_hipolito
    @sigi_hipolito Місяць тому +1

    Las guitarras se escuchan brutales, muy pesadas, es evidente que estos tipos hicieron metal antes que black sabbath. 🤘

  • @Pharoset
    @Pharoset Місяць тому +4

    Why is the get-together in February "mysterious?"

    • @GBOAC
      @GBOAC 29 днів тому +1

      Hardly documented, if it wasn’t for the photos it perhaps never had been established

  • @robertavery7891
    @robertavery7891 Місяць тому

    Tell me this isn’t grunge before grunge…😂 I always loved Ringo’s fills during the epic ending

  • @drvee1983
    @drvee1983 Місяць тому

    Since " Revolver " it was often that McCartney would do his bass track last in recording. He would do scratch tracks, then finals last.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  Місяць тому

      It was song dependent a lot of the time he would still do bass on the basic track that would be used in the final mix. Especially the later 68/69 period the bass wasn't overdubbed often.

    • @drvee1983
      @drvee1983 Місяць тому

      Ok. If you say so. Thanks for posting!

  • @FiremanSam60
    @FiremanSam60 Місяць тому

    I never noticed the congas until now

  • @PeteZolli
    @PeteZolli 2 місяці тому +1

    In the Overdubbed Coda Guitars 3, it's a guitar and a bass.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +5

      Could be a fuzz bass not sure though.

    • @PeteZolli
      @PeteZolli 2 місяці тому

      @@isolatedstems Just sounds like a clean bass to me. Maybe John on his Epiphone and George on his Jazz Bass.

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +3

      @@PeteZolli I don't hear any clean bass it's all just very fuzzy to my ears. It may also be isolation bleed, but I don't think there's a bass on that track.

  • @moonriver3552
    @moonriver3552 Місяць тому

    I'd be willing to bet Glyn Johns was trying to get them to turn down so he could get more overall control of the sound and mix. Maybe there was someone complaining, maybe not., Anyway, obviously it all worked out okay.😃

  • @koji6297
    @koji6297 Місяць тому

    この9thみたいなコード感はジョージですか?やはりビートルズは天才だー

  • @pooman784
    @pooman784 Місяць тому

    Feels like 28 Days Later, even though it doesn't sound like it

  • @kevink973
    @kevink973 28 днів тому +1

    That piano coda is pretty spooky. George Martin perhaps?

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  28 днів тому

      Could be, but I don't really even know when in the process it would've been recorded. Most likely it was one of the Beatles except Ringo.

  • @strothermartin5368
    @strothermartin5368 Місяць тому +1

    I wonder why Billy Preston didn't get credit on the album sleeve

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  Місяць тому +3

      I think that was a pretty normal thing for guests not to be credited. Like Eric Clapton didn't get credit for WMGGW. Billy did get credit for Get Back though.

  • @m1eztr0s44
    @m1eztr0s44 Місяць тому

    What neural network processed this?😮

  • @DennisTedder-wj5ln
    @DennisTedder-wj5ln Місяць тому

    Without the voices...they are the music makers.

  • @alainraux5075
    @alainraux5075 Місяць тому

    👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @rmarlon3061
    @rmarlon3061 Місяць тому

    Obra prima do Beatles. O Pink Floyd plagiou essa musica em In The Flash.

  • @Henry3Studios
    @Henry3Studios 2 місяці тому +1

    How do you separate the 5.1 mixes?

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому +1

      Depends on what you mean. If you talking about being able to listen to the different tracks of the 5.1 mixes you just need to drop the right file type into a program like audacity. If your talking about further separation I use lalalai and msvep

    • @Henry3Studios
      @Henry3Studios 2 місяці тому

      @@isolatedstems do you have a link to the 5.1 mix?

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  2 місяці тому

      @@Henry3Studios Sure here's a 5.1 link: drive.google.com/file/d/1S4AECpZLgxdAkbOqNgXiu_xK_rXJRseH/view?usp=sharing

    • @Paranoidisagreatsong
      @Paranoidisagreatsong Місяць тому

      @@isolatedstemsu have the 7.1 mix?

  • @jayskeone
    @jayskeone Місяць тому +1

    dude 36:15 wow

  • @navasaband
    @navasaband Місяць тому

    Proof that perfect recordings don’t make great recordings.

  • @nutshell1127
    @nutshell1127 27 днів тому

    RINGO

  • @Henry3Studios
    @Henry3Studios 2 місяці тому +1

    Paul used the Hofner on this

  • @bullcrap9409
    @bullcrap9409 Місяць тому +1

    Is there a way to blot out Yoko innall these vids? I still haven’t watched the long docs because of her. (And because i grind my teeth thinking of how immature and narcissistic Lennon was making everyone else perform w her in the middle. )

  • @williamtynertyner1425
    @williamtynertyner1425 Місяць тому

    Do you mean to tell me that some idiot had the complete lack of character, soul. and intellect to tell THE BEATLES to turn down in the middle of the night (their normal working hours) at their fixed workspace while recording their final work of timeless genius and he wasn't kicked out of the U.K. forever? That's just wrong.

  • @thebordenasylum7726
    @thebordenasylum7726 Місяць тому +1

    Paul's bass work sounds like someone picked up a bass that said they knew how to play and then pretended lol. Great bass work indeed, but didn't realize how much random noodling he did

    • @gregchristopfel8106
      @gregchristopfel8106 Місяць тому

      Pretended to play??? I think you mean brilliant!

    • @thebordenasylum7726
      @thebordenasylum7726 Місяць тому

      @@gregchristopfel8106 Listening to the Coda bass part, there is a ton of random noodling going on and some of it doesn't sound super cohesive or great, but it's so drowned out in the mix and cacophony of the other instruments that you really can't hear it in the final mix. It doesn't mean that his playing was bad (assuming that was Paul), it was just a bit messy for his usual standard of work

    • @gregchristopfel8106
      @gregchristopfel8106 Місяць тому +1

      @@thebordenasylum7726 Thanks for you additional explanation! I know what you mean, but I think the goal of this part of the song was to actually create that cacophony of sound against the backdrop of the ever swelling and repetitive chord changes. Those bass runs, in context of the song, keep the listener listening. They are unusual and very creative. I've always loved hearing them in the context of the song and extremely cool to hear them so clearly on this isolation. I didn't hear any notes that sounded out of key or that they didn't belong. I don't think anyone who never picked up a bass would have haphazardly stumbled on these notes. I love the discussion and find the different takes on it fascinating, so thanks again!

  • @kingrobert1st
    @kingrobert1st Місяць тому

    What a fucking mess!

  • @BixLives32
    @BixLives32 Місяць тому

    Your noise-gating is bloody ANNOYING! Your new toy?

    • @isolatedstems
      @isolatedstems  Місяць тому

      My goal of isolating these parts is to get the individual parts isolated, so if that means noise-gating to get rid of an instrument I'll do it if it doesn't effect the sound too heavily. This video only has 3 tracks with a noise gate. One on the bass track that starts cuts off frequencies above 2.55 incrementally, one on the coda organ part to cut off any unwanted low and high frequencies, and one used on the "overdubbed coda guitar 3 track" to cut out any hi-hat frequencies which due to the isolation software was really harsh on the ear. I don't think noise-gating is a problem since I mostly use it to get rid of isolation bleed from the AI separation programs and most of the time it really doesn't effect the sound in any meaningful way. Anything else you might think is noise-gating it just AI artifacts from the separation. This is the best tech available publicly with only room to improve, so at this moment not all frequencies are going to survive the AI isolation. I hope you enjoyed the video, I think it speaks for itself about how far we've come and how far we can still go.