When i was younger i always voted modern bc i thought it was cool and should be the main theory instead of rtanic but now i appreciate rtanic sinking cause it was the first sinking in roblox titanic
In modern form, you can see the ship going sideways, the light turning orange, the ship turning, the split in half being delayed, the music changing, and the ships final plunge is starting halfway down.
Rtanic had a very interesting break-up. Instead of breaking in front or aft of the third funnel like most theories do, it instead breaks below the third funnel.
Everyone loves the modern one, and so do I, but I prefer to vote for classic/rtanic because it’s more stable and easier to navigate since it doesn’t have the port list modern sinking holds.
When ever I play roblox titanic, I allways vote for modern. Also I notice that nobody really votes for Rtanic, its just that nobody votes at all so thats the default
Modern is ironically still inaccurate, as Funnel #4 never collapsed when the ship broke. Plus, the breakup is in the Rtanic location (between Funnel #3 and #4) instead of between Funnel #2 and #3.
The modern Roblox titanic theory is inaccurate but not just on the break but with alot more: #1:In this modern animation the two forward funnels fell forward. But According to inquiries/testimonies they actually fell to starboard(left). #2:In the modern animation, Titanic's forward funnels collapses when water just reached them but according to accounts like from Lighttoller, Titanic's funnels actually fell when water surrounded its base. #3:The break depicted in the modern theory is the banana peel based which kinda has a lot of problem with it. As an example, the double bottom could never be able to pull the stern in the air. Remember that putting the double bottom in an intense bending stresses could remove all strength from it meaning it would be nearly impossible for this theory to occur. #4:Another breakup inaccuracy in the modern theory is that the forward tower didn't form at the surface. According to survivor accounts, the forward tower (middle section) might have likely formed during the break up at the surface and eventually dislodged from the stern during the implosion including other sections to like the aft tower, the galley decks, boiler room number five, a chunk of the titanics engine cylinders ect. #5:Another inaccuracy is that in the modern animation, Titanic keeps its port (right side) list till the very end but according to accounts, Titanic eventually even out its port list to the starboard (left side) list mentioned by survivors like Jack Thayer. But after the break, Titanic rolled to a port list because of a starboard cylinder engine sliding off causing imbalance in the ship. The port side became heavier later causing the pivoting motion. #6:The last major inacurracy is that in this modern animation the fourth funnel falls when the break happens. However, survivors reported that the fourth funnel was standing still after the break. A survivor by the name of Patrick Dillon testified the funnel collapsing aft(backwards) when water reached its base a minute or so after the break up.
@@xm9g Incorrect, the coal was shifted to the port side while the initial starboard lean after the collision early in the sinking was caused solely by the water coming into the hull from the damages being on the starboard side until later in the mid-sinking when the water level equalized and then the ship began heavily listing to port
I definitely rather the Classic it feels more accurate to me but I also like the modern but I feel like they do that sinking all the time and I get it it’s a good sinking but sometimes I like to switch it up.
@@alissaclifton8334No disrespect to you, but we know the hull couldn't have taken more than 23 degrees of stress when full of water. So, modern is more accurate.
And The Modern Roblox Titanic Theory Is Also Fairly Inaccurate Just So ya Know The Recent And Up To Date Theories Are Honor And Glory 2024 On A Sea Of Glass 2021 And More
Yeah I Guess The Classic Sinking Is pretty Cool And Dramatic But Unfortunately It's Pretty Inaccurate Like High Angle No Listing Inaccurate Breaking Funnels Falling To The Wrong Side Ect...
how is this so popular?
Classic
When i was younger i always voted modern bc i thought it was cool and should be the main theory instead of rtanic but now i appreciate rtanic sinking cause it was the first sinking in roblox titanic
RTanic didn’t make that sinking it was the 1997 movie which is inaccurate.
@@juanleon3875 ok????
@@juanleon3875 the classic sinking in Rtanic is kind of different to the 1997 movie
@@DrCury448 How
@@juanleon3875 the base of the 2nd funnel is still half out of the water when lights go out
Bro forgot to change water textures before recording
mad
Terrain
Water textures is a thing in the game?
@@dude_uncool_6969yea I think
In the old roblox titanic the water used to just be dark blue and not see threw
1:05 perfect timing
1:15 too
@@shelty3178 oh yes that one aswell
0:57 the lifeboat is just spinning while titanic is sinking
In modern form, you can see the ship going sideways, the light turning orange, the ship turning, the split in half being delayed, the music changing, and the ships final plunge is starting halfway down.
The modern one has more action. The hard list especially after it breaks into 2 pieces is amazing. I prefer modern but ritanic is more classic
i extremely love the modern version! as a titanic historian, the double keel hang-on after it split was just amazing! 10/10 VVG Games!
If you think that's good, look at Titanic SOS!!!
I also extremely love modern version
@@theguyjawntoo laggy
@@geomaniac171 you must have a bad device then 🤷♂️
@@theguyjawn Titanic: Honor and Glory seems better
So we ain’t gonna talk about that life boat spinning on modern
I like the modern because the colors are beautiful
Rtanic had a very interesting break-up. Instead of breaking in front or aft of the third funnel like most theories do, it instead breaks below the third funnel.
Everyone loves the modern one, and so do I, but I prefer to vote for classic/rtanic because it’s more stable and easier to navigate since it doesn’t have the port list modern sinking holds.
Great the portlist looks great
Modern is just amazing Classic or Rtanic is just from the movie i think Modern is like from a night to remember
Modern is actually from the 2012 theory of James Cameron
@@Gustavo_81114 yup
No, it is not the 'Banana Peel' Theory from 2012. The BP theory has the ship list heavily to Port when the Ship splits and sinks@@Gustavo_81114
Put it on 2x speed the music sounds more catchy
I honestly wish they put more sinking theories or atleast improve the modern version in 3.0
0:17 this guy in the lifeboat was doing donuts by the titanic s hull lol
Is anyone gonna notice how boats were lowered before the iceberg hit
On the modern one you are true
I like how the implemented the list to port like in the real thing
Its not clear if the titanic implemented to the port side the other theory does straight
Its not clear if the titanic implemented to the port side the other theory does straight
When ever I play roblox titanic, I allways vote for modern. Also I notice that nobody really votes for Rtanic, its just that nobody votes at all so thats the default
2017 vibes when i play this
How you can do this also these the water so modern is please tutorial
yes please tutorial
Modern one it’s how the titanic sank because the ship tilted 9º
I love how the classic represents James Cameron titanic but if I had to pick one, it would be the modern sinking
0:54 bro thinks hes a propeller (the boat in the bow)
Whoa look at the modern the lifeboats hit by iceburg and THE LIFEBOATS SPINNING LIKE A HELICOPTER 🚁 💀
I mean, the sinking on modern is better but classic split is more better and modern sinking stern is still better
Why do the funnels on my game fall through the ship and not bounce of it?
Are you playing the older version?
can you do titanic sos next
That one lifeboat spinning:
Modern is ironically still inaccurate, as Funnel #4 never collapsed when the ship broke. Plus, the breakup is in the Rtanic location (between Funnel #3 and #4) instead of between Funnel #2 and #3.
How did you do that film ?
I used the film maker gamepass
What’s the music in the background?
ua-cam.com/video/CJQaoULGWEU/v-deo.htmlsi=Rccoe9XU3pYa7-vN
The modern one is great, one downside is the kinda innacurate split up, but we may never know how the ship split up.
The modern Roblox titanic theory is inaccurate but not just on the break but with alot more:
#1:In this modern animation the two forward funnels fell forward. But According to inquiries/testimonies they actually fell to starboard(left).
#2:In the modern animation, Titanic's forward funnels collapses when water just reached them but according to accounts like from Lighttoller, Titanic's funnels actually fell when water surrounded its base.
#3:The break depicted in the modern theory is the banana peel based which kinda has a lot of problem with it. As an example, the double bottom could never be able to pull the stern in the air. Remember that putting the double bottom in an intense bending stresses could remove all strength from it meaning it would be nearly impossible for this theory to occur.
#4:Another breakup inaccuracy in the modern theory is that the forward tower didn't form at the surface. According to survivor accounts, the forward tower (middle section) might have likely formed during the break up at the surface and eventually dislodged from the stern during the implosion including other sections to like the aft tower, the galley decks, boiler room number five, a chunk of the titanics engine cylinders ect.
#5:Another inaccuracy is that in the modern animation, Titanic keeps its port (right side) list till the very end but according to accounts, Titanic eventually even out its port list to the starboard (left side) list mentioned by survivors like Jack Thayer. But after the break, Titanic rolled to a port list because of a starboard cylinder engine sliding off causing imbalance in the ship. The port side became heavier later causing the pivoting motion.
#6:The last major inacurracy is that in this modern animation the fourth funnel falls when the break happens. However, survivors reported that the fourth funnel was standing still after the break. A survivor by the name of Patrick Dillon testified the funnel collapsing aft(backwards) when water reached its base a minute or so after the break up.
How do u have clear water when I bought the hax it didn’t work
It’s the graphics settings and in the lobby you can turn on realistic water
@@Averagebloxy I have max graphics and realistic water
@@Boeing.aviation63 that’s weird it should work
Make sure your roblox graphics setting is high
How do you change the water texture to modern?
Go to settings and turn on realistic water
Why the Rtanic sinking has no modern water?
I forgot to change the setting
@@xm9g lol
How do we put the modern version ?
You can vote for it in the menu
The breakup happened in the front of funnel 3 and someone explain where did the Port list go? This is why i like Titanic SOS than Roblox titanic
By the way they forgot tower 1 and 2 breaking up in the ship
@@jamesmaverick9553 port list started to equalize by the time the bridge was flooding from what i know
They would have to likely redo the ship to reposition the break. Also the port list stabilized when port side of the bridge started flooding.
EVERY COMMENT WAS LOVED BY THE CREATOR???
Yes
Bro for the classic you just chose the classic gameode and turned down your graphics 💀💀💀
yes thats the point
What is that swimming past the titanic
the iceburg
The modern beatiful
I love modern but my roblox quality is classic
i like modern
more
Modern should be starboard side cuz the ship is loosing water in starboard side of ship
i edited this 1
yes i did again 2
Actually due to a fire, coal was moved to the starboard which caused there to be more weight which caused the ship to sink to the starboard
@@xm9g oh okay
@@xm9g Incorrect, the coal was shifted to the port side while the initial starboard lean after the collision early in the sinking was caused solely by the water coming into the hull from the damages being on the starboard side until later in the mid-sinking when the water level equalized and then the ship began heavily listing to port
@@xm9gcoal was moved to the port side actually
my bad I meant port
music name?
Cirrus by xm9g
I do not like this game, but the modern sinking is much more better than the classic because it actually happened
Modern❤❤❤❤
How do i get modern
You vote for it
Oh yea just voted for it while i was playing im stupid 😅😅😅😅 (and i never got a person to reply to my comment)😮
I definitely rather the Classic it feels more accurate to me but I also like the modern but I feel like they do that sinking all the time and I get it it’s a good sinking but sometimes I like to switch it up.
Ship going 45 degrees in air is realistic to you?
The bow going deeper under which pulled the ship up so ya and it’s just my opinion respectfully
blud thinks that it going like 70 degrees up and not listing is accurate 💀💀
Even with that, the ship would not have been able to reach that angle in the air. Do you really think it's realistic?@@alissaclifton8334
@@alissaclifton8334No disrespect to you, but we know the hull couldn't have taken more than 23 degrees of stress when full of water. So, modern is more accurate.
THE LIFEBOATS😭😭😭😭
One is spinning
Here lemme show ya 1:11
It looks like the modern sinking had sped up
Both have been
I dont Think modern one used to see through water only classic can't see water
The water is based on your setting not on what sinking
Oh ok
Classic Is The Best
Modern is a more accurate sinking, Classic is 1997 movie but differencies
1:15 👌
I like them both
I find the Classic Version alot better
cool i like this video and roblox titanic game
Blud didint even hit the iceberg
Rtanic 💀💀
i cant see the vote for modern sinking
why
the only difference i see is the lists
The classic is just a part and a outdated sink theory
The modern is actual water terrain and updated to a more accurate theory
The Modern one is the real theory, The Classic one is Titanic 1997.
I think the modern one is James Cameron 2012
@@BuynLargeCorpUnfortunately The 2012 James Cameron Theory Of Titanic's Sinking Is Fairly Outdated In A lot Of Areas :/
And The Modern Roblox Titanic Theory Is Also Fairly Inaccurate Just So ya Know The Recent And Up To Date Theories Are Honor And Glory 2024 On A Sea Of Glass 2021 And More
Modern is 85% accurate
Its sinking fast
It's a timelase
in my opinion i like classic better
Yeah I Guess The Classic Sinking Is pretty Cool And Dramatic But Unfortunately It's Pretty Inaccurate Like High Angle No Listing Inaccurate Breaking Funnels Falling To The Wrong Side Ect...
I like modern better ngl
Roblox?
To me, they’re both the same
S.O.S better fr fr
old better
Its the same
no
I hate morden rtanic is ogrinal
NO I LOVE BOTH
Rtanic is just the 1996 theory change my mind
Bro is tryna act cool and say that the innacurate version is better
@@Epic_carpet tbh modern is pretty inaccurate in that game.
only the split@@Acorn11982