Hey What If, i've been following your channel since 3 years and I've never been disappointed by the quality of your videos. Keep making your content as I always want more. +I have an idea, What If, we were a Type V Civilization.
"the biggest thing in the solar system isn't the sun or Jupiter but Jupiter's magnetic field" umm what about the suns magnetic field, its about 3000 times larger than Jupiter's lol
Its called the heliosphere (not sure) Its pretty much not fighting the suns rays , but its fighting interstellar space The size of it is 75-100 AU (AU= astronomical unit , or the distance from the sun to earth) So yea its big , goes way beyond Pluto's orbit
If Earth had Jupiter's magnetic field, it would have a number of significant effects. Jupiter's magnetic field is about 20,000 times stronger than Earth's, so life on Earth would be exposed to much higher levels of radiation. This could have negative effects on living organisms, including increasing the incidence of cancer and other diseases. Additionally, the stronger magnetic field would lead to more intense auroras, which could disrupt radio communications and damage satellites. The stronger magnetic field would also deflect more solar wind particles, which would reduce the amount of erosion on the Earth's atmosphere. In addition to these effects, the stronger magnetic field would also protect the Earth from more cosmic rays, which would make it more difficult for high-energy particles to reach the surface. This would have implications for the study of geology and the atmosphere, as well as for the study of the origins of life on Earth. Overall, having Jupiter's magnetic field would have both positive and negative effects on Earth, and it is difficult to say whether or not it would be beneficial overall.
"With such a big magnetic field, it will act as a particle accelerator and will no longer be able to protect us from solar radiation...." I somehow really doubt this, but I don't really have the knowledge to confirm or deny this. Can someone say if this is true?
yeh i dont agree, with an even larger magnetic field it will redirect charged particles at an even larger range hence probably provide even greater protection
That much greater and stronger magnetic field will intercept over 1 000 000 times more charged particles from the Solar wind. This will make the Van Allen belts MUCH more intense and bigger. For those particles, the gravitational field effect would be less than negligible. Like much less than 10^10 times less important than it is now, and now, the magnetic field already affect nearly 1000 000 times more than the gravity. The particle flow making the polar lights will be 100's of times more intense than currently, and also, the polar lights will extend to a wider area. Our polar lights are mostly fluorescence. With the stronger magnetic field, they would be plasma based. The will also dig much deeper in the atmosphere. Possibly even low enough to force airplanes to fly lower to avoid getting melted by the plasma. Plasma polar light illumination is rich in UV light, UV A, UV B and UV C, plus a good dose of X-rays. How do you like the prospect of getting a Sun burn, at midnight, in only a few second ? Also, you are in South Carolina.
@@nicolejohnson4786 The Moon only have weak residual magnetic field. Jupiter's magnetic field would barely make any difference at all. Take a random rock. How that rock react to a magnetic field ? The Moon would react pretty much the same way. We are talking about Jupiter like magnetic fields, not Jupiter like mass.
There’s another factor to consider. The primary factor for the magnetosphere’s size is its interaction with Io (there are some good papers on it, though an overview of the Jupiter-Io System would explain it just as well.) Io’s connection to Jupiter is in the form of a magnetic flux tube which strips material from the moon, inflating the magnetosphere’s size to over twice what we would expect and creates the Io Plasma Torus. In other words, in this What If scenario we should be dealing with a similar relationship between the Earth and Moon, otherwise, the field is just as powerful, just roughly half the size.
For clarification (and this is something that’s important when considering the content of the video), Jupiter is not 1,300 times larger than Earth. It is only 11 times larger than Earth. Instead, 1,300 Earths could fit inside Jupiter. I believe that the video creator is confusing volume with relative scale. If Jupiter was 1,300 times larger than than Earth, it would be truly monstrous in size, something as large as (or even larger than) some of the largest hyper giant stars discovered so far in the universe. To put this in perspective, the Sun is only 109 times larger than the Earth. Here is the information that I found at CalTech’s website about the relative sizes of Earth and Jupiter: “Jupiter has a diameter of about 88,695 miles (142,800 kilometers) which is more than 11 times the diameter of Earth. It's volume is over 1,300 times the volume of Earth. This means that Jupiter is so big that over 1,300 Earths could fit inside of it.”
Jupiter's magnetic field is generated by its possibly metallic Hydrogen Inner Mantle, NOT its Core. We don't even know if Jupiter has a core to begin with.
@@macwelch8599 mainly because of the x parasites, those freaking form and memory copying abominations definitely sound like the stuff of nightmares, and humans there would be stupid enough to let themselves get infected, killed and copied by one
Amazing video as usual, the bright white screen transitions hurt while watching in bed during the night tho, somehow seemed like there were alot of them :')
Jupiter's magnetosphere is huge indeed but actually it;s not the largest structure in the solar system the sun's heliosphere is much much bigger it extends to at least 100 AU and easily encompasses all the planets and most if not the entire Kuiper Belt.
Albert Einstein was doubly right about the origins of geomagnetism. And these visions inspired me to study what was missing to complete the understanding of the mechanism for generating the Earth's magnetic field. Einstein expressed that the origins of geomagnetism were still one of the great mysteries of Physics and that the explanations should be related to the separation of electrical charges. In truth. The mystery has been solved. So forget the self-excited geodynamo conjecture to justify the origin of the magnetic field of the Earth, the Moon, and the celestial bodies. Magnetic fields can be generated not only by electrical currents but also by the movement of electrical charges. Earth's magnetic field originates from the solid inner core, not the turbulent liquid core. The foundations of electromagnetism mathematically proved this hypothesis. Learn more by accessing recently published manuscripts. What about magnetic reversals, why does this occur? Reversals occur due to the large impacts of large asteroids on our Planet. The mystery was solved.
Now what if Earth were to have Uranus's magnetic field? Uranus's magnetic field is a bit weaker than Earth's, but it's magnetic axis isn't aligned with its poles. It's more aligned with it's equator. How would this effect Earth?
Hey crazy thought. Energy and matter are interchangeable, right? Could gravity and the electromagnetic forse be the same? Meaning could the electromagnetic force be to enegy what gravity is to matter? Or is that comparison dumb?
The inner, solid, and incandescent cores of the planets Jupiter and Saturn possess rotation axes with inclinations of 9.6 degrees and zero degrees, respectively, and, surprisingly, exhibit opposite directions to the rotation of their respective planets. What is the basis for the evidence? These planets have reversed their magnetism, which is caused by their core rotating.
What if Earth had a surface mass of Jupiter and a core proportional to its size that would still be condusive to human life. AKA What if everything went perfectly normal in a What If video.
Sir , I think it would be very useful if you What would make a what if video regarding. What if the Zaporizhzhia plant exploded ? Seeing the current global unstability it would be very greatful if people get to know the mass destruction of nucliar plants and weapons .
You should do a what if earth exploded and what would happen to us, it's atmosphere, and it's magnetic field. Edit: I know of course we would die if earth exploded but what if we were strong enough to survive that?
Get 20% off Grammarly Premium by signing up at grammarly.com/WHATIF
nice
ok
Ok
ok
Like me
Hey What If, i've been following your channel since 3 years and I've never been disappointed by the quality of your videos. Keep making your content as I always want more. +I have an idea, What If, we were a Type V Civilization.
Thank you for sharing your idea with us. We are lucky to have you!
@@WhatIfScienceShow ITS WHAT IF!
@@WhatIfScienceShow Hi what If, im a big fan
How is the quality bad
4 to 4❤ggd him unofficial o03qd@@Deerfield5
I never knew Jupiter had such a big magnetic field! I swear I learn something new ever upload even if they’re just hypotheticals 😅
no sh
Welcome to the University of UA-cam!
Gurl youre everywhere
Thank you for your support! Stay tuned for more fun and educational hypotheticals to come. 🙂
"the biggest thing in the solar system isn't the sun or Jupiter but Jupiter's magnetic field"
umm what about the suns magnetic field, its about 3000 times larger than Jupiter's lol
I was wondering that as well seeing how the Sun is natural bigger than Jupiter.
Its called the heliosphere (not sure)
Its pretty much not fighting the suns rays , but its fighting interstellar space
The size of it is 75-100 AU
(AU= astronomical unit , or the distance from the sun to earth)
So yea its big , goes way beyond Pluto's orbit
If Earth had Jupiter's magnetic field, it would have a number of significant effects. Jupiter's magnetic field is about 20,000 times stronger than Earth's, so life on Earth would be exposed to much higher levels of radiation. This could have negative effects on living organisms, including increasing the incidence of cancer and other diseases. Additionally, the stronger magnetic field would lead to more intense auroras, which could disrupt radio communications and damage satellites. The stronger magnetic field would also deflect more solar wind particles, which would reduce the amount of erosion on the Earth's atmosphere.
In addition to these effects, the stronger magnetic field would also protect the Earth from more cosmic rays, which would make it more difficult for high-energy particles to reach the surface. This would have implications for the study of geology and the atmosphere, as well as for the study of the origins of life on Earth.
Overall, having Jupiter's magnetic field would have both positive and negative effects on Earth, and it is difficult to say whether or not it would be beneficial overall.
Short answer: We're all gonna die
Long answer: We're all gonna die
Ayo
"With such a big magnetic field, it will act as a particle accelerator and will no longer be able to protect us from solar radiation...." I somehow really doubt this, but I don't really have the knowledge to confirm or deny this. Can someone say if this is true?
Well it also depends on Earth's gravitational pull as well meaning the size but absolutely
yeh i dont agree, with an even larger magnetic field it will redirect charged particles at an even larger range hence probably provide even greater protection
That much greater and stronger magnetic field will intercept over 1 000 000 times more charged particles from the Solar wind. This will make the Van Allen belts MUCH more intense and bigger.
For those particles, the gravitational field effect would be less than negligible. Like much less than 10^10 times less important than it is now, and now, the magnetic field already affect nearly 1000 000 times more than the gravity.
The particle flow making the polar lights will be 100's of times more intense than currently, and also, the polar lights will extend to a wider area.
Our polar lights are mostly fluorescence. With the stronger magnetic field, they would be plasma based. The will also dig much deeper in the atmosphere. Possibly even low enough to force airplanes to fly lower to avoid getting melted by the plasma. Plasma polar light illumination is rich in UV light, UV A, UV B and UV C, plus a good dose of X-rays. How do you like the prospect of getting a Sun burn, at midnight, in only a few second ? Also, you are in South Carolina.
Jupiter pull would pull the moon into earth
@@nicolejohnson4786 The Moon only have weak residual magnetic field. Jupiter's magnetic field would barely make any difference at all.
Take a random rock. How that rock react to a magnetic field ? The Moon would react pretty much the same way.
We are talking about Jupiter like magnetic fields, not Jupiter like mass.
Ive been watching this channel since it first came out..
Great video..👍👌💞💞
I am damn sure this channel has a huge number of what if ideas to be uploaded in future. ❤️❤️❤️
Thank you for your support! Stay tuned for more fun content to come. 🙂
@@WhatIfScienceShow omg I cant beleive i got a like and comment from you team. Never fail to entertain us with your stuffs. 🔥
Thank you What If, it's always fun and interesting to watch these videos!!😃
Thanks for watching, stay tuned for more! 🙂
@@WhatIfScienceShow I sure will!😁
@@WhatIfScienceShowhello
We would die from the sun's radiation when the earth doesn't have a magnetic field. (And a good video like always, WHAT IF. 👍)
This channel will NEVER ran out of content ..and you know why
What if this channel ran out of content?,
What if he ran out of content?
Watching all of these What If videoes gives me a better understanding of certain things every day. Thanks, What If team! ❤
There’s another factor to consider. The primary factor for the magnetosphere’s size is its interaction with Io (there are some good papers on it, though an overview of the Jupiter-Io System would explain it just as well.) Io’s connection to Jupiter is in the form of a magnetic flux tube which strips material from the moon, inflating the magnetosphere’s size to over twice what we would expect and creates the Io Plasma Torus.
In other words, in this What If scenario we should be dealing with a similar relationship between the Earth and Moon, otherwise, the field is just as powerful, just roughly half the size.
For clarification (and this is something that’s important when considering the content of the video), Jupiter is not 1,300 times larger than Earth. It is only 11 times larger than Earth. Instead, 1,300 Earths could fit inside Jupiter. I believe that the video creator is confusing volume with relative scale. If Jupiter was 1,300 times larger than than Earth, it would be truly monstrous in size, something as large as (or even larger than) some of the largest hyper giant stars discovered so far in the universe. To put this in perspective, the Sun is only 109 times larger than the Earth. Here is the information that I found at CalTech’s website about the relative sizes of Earth and Jupiter:
“Jupiter has a diameter of about 88,695 miles (142,800 kilometers) which is more than 11 times the diameter of Earth. It's volume is over 1,300 times the volume of Earth. This means that Jupiter is so big that over 1,300 Earths could fit inside of it.”
I find mectric units VERY OFFENSIVE and offensive content notices at 1:18 and 3:04 and 3:13 and 3:18 and 5:33
Magnetars: Wow look at those ants trying to defend themselves
I love science and "what if " vids help me in science 🔭 ✨♥️♥️
jupiter magnetic field: nah i'de win
sun: im protecting yall from cosmic radiation LOL
Effective
Just loved it!
The sun's 20 million mile magnetosphere versus Jupiter's 3 million mile magnetosphere.
What is the name of the movie shown at 1:45 Where the meteors are falling at the gas station?
What If, there would be no 2 min pointless advertising???
This would be a better world
a
If we had Jupiter's magnetic field we would be ALMOST invincible but not completely we would not die though!
Jupiter's magnetic field is generated by its possibly metallic Hydrogen Inner Mantle, NOT its Core. We don't even know if Jupiter has a core to begin with.
What if Earth was in the Star Wars galaxy?
It would definitely be safer than being in the metroid Universe
@@asurashun9695 I’ve heard that’s some scary stuff
@@macwelch8599 mainly because of the x parasites, those freaking form and memory copying abominations definitely sound like the stuff of nightmares, and humans there would be stupid enough to let themselves get infected, killed and copied by one
Cool
Believe it or not, I was actually studying electromagnets as this video released. What a great addition!
Heyu
Amazing video as usual, the bright white screen transitions hurt while watching in bed during the night tho, somehow seemed like there were alot of them :')
Can you pls use calmer music
That would be good for us
Jupiter's magnetosphere is huge indeed but actually it;s not the largest structure in the solar system the sun's heliosphere is much much bigger it extends to at least 100 AU and easily encompasses all the planets and most if not the entire Kuiper Belt.
Now that's big
Love what if videos
Appreciate your videos
Good one bro
Everybody dies
Thanks
Nope
Albert Einstein was doubly right about the origins of geomagnetism. And these visions inspired me to study what was missing to complete the understanding of the mechanism for generating the Earth's magnetic field. Einstein expressed that the origins of geomagnetism were still one of the great mysteries of Physics and that the explanations should be related to the separation of electrical charges. In truth. The mystery has been solved.
So forget the self-excited geodynamo conjecture to justify the origin of the magnetic field of the Earth, the Moon, and the celestial bodies. Magnetic fields can be generated not only by electrical currents but also by the movement of electrical charges. Earth's magnetic field originates from the solid inner core, not the turbulent liquid core. The foundations of electromagnetism mathematically proved this hypothesis. Learn more by accessing recently published manuscripts.
What about magnetic reversals, why does this occur? Reversals occur due to the large impacts of large asteroids on our Planet. The mystery was solved.
Awesome Video!
👍👍👍👍👍👍
Love the vid... Would also want to know how sun magnetic field works as well but that's a story for another what if😂
The Earth’s is not too weak or not too strong
Video idea:"What if all the planets in the Solar System was spinning at the speed of light?"
Nice video.
Great content as always!
Now what if Earth were to have Uranus's magnetic field? Uranus's magnetic field is a bit weaker than Earth's, but it's magnetic axis isn't aligned with its poles. It's more aligned with it's equator. How would this effect Earth?
Hey crazy thought. Energy and matter are interchangeable, right? Could gravity and the electromagnetic forse be the same? Meaning could the electromagnetic force be to enegy what gravity is to matter? Or is that comparison dumb?
0:30 mangetis sphere 💀
I can't go away from grammarly
What if ....all of sudden .....all smartphones androids and IOS phones disappear from EARTH
Hes just casually talking while his shirt says "EVERYBODY DIES"
What if we had Jupiter’s magnetosphere? We’d die.
this channel never runs out of ideas
I don’t know about the intro, the sun’s heliosphere seems pretty big to me… so does the Oort Cloud…
The inner, solid, and incandescent cores of the planets Jupiter and Saturn possess rotation axes with inclinations of 9.6 degrees and zero degrees, respectively, and, surprisingly, exhibit opposite directions to the rotation of their respective planets. What is the basis for the evidence? These planets have reversed their magnetism, which is caused by their core rotating.
I Love this Video🥰❤️💯 because I learned a lot about this🥰❤️💯
My a big fan, make a video of "what if space exploded?"
Well it will fall to the biggest black hole (i think)
@@Ilovecapybarasomuch ty for letting me know :D
What if earth 🌎 had suns magetic field damn its big
What if earth had a magnetar's magnetic field?
Do you know the occasional extremely bright transition you use b/n the scenes is making it hard for most of us to watch your videos.
Thank you magnetosphere. 🥰
How about we put our atmhospere in jupiter
Zero views but 20 more likes
Well
At least USA won't be affected but,
R.I.P Greenland,Iceland,Cantada,Alaska,North Russia,Nordics
the feelds
Jupiter: The strongest magnet known to science
I love your t-shirt❤
I like your videos like science
Harvey!
3:23 What movie is it?
Sun has a hilosphere
What if Earth had a surface mass of Jupiter and a core proportional to its size that would still be condusive to human life.
AKA
What if everything went perfectly normal in a What If video.
can you do
" what if all of earth was land "
now that would be interesting 🧐
Then you have to dig to access (limited) water
You are smart bro!
What if team 😊 ❤
The suns heiloshpere protecting the systym from cosmic radiation seeing this:
Sir , I think it would be very useful if you What would make a what if video regarding. What if the Zaporizhzhia plant exploded ?
Seeing the current global unstability it would be very greatful if people get to know the mass destruction of nucliar plants and weapons .
Ok now Jupiter with earth’s magnetic field
Idk what would happen
Love these videos thx what if. 🤣😁😁😁😁
Im 30 seconds late 🤩🤩
What If Earth Had Jupiter's Magnetic Field?
short answer: we die.
long answer: we all die.
I just have a question the sun's magnet field is bigger than Jupiter's it protects from a comic radiation
Interesting video
What if we can digest fiber
What would happen if we took all the magnets on earth and put them on one single side of the globe?
Gauss' Law = magnetic fields 😮.
The Question " What If ?" Never Ends....
You should do a what if earth exploded and what would happen to us, it's atmosphere, and it's magnetic field.
Edit: I know of course we would die if earth exploded but what if we were strong enough to survive that?
What if Jupiter would replace Mars?
Sun isn't the biggest how??
A
The answer is on his t shirt 🤣🤣🤣
Love your videos!
What is how fast do gravity train would go on the sun
Does radiation causes mutants as in movies
bro forgot about magnetar or blazors
💀💀👺👻
Hey can you make a what if humans could absorb solar energy to our cells 🙏
What If Earth had a magnetic field like a magnetar?