Timestamps 3:04 The Faceless Ones 16:30 Evil of the Daleks 32:30 The Invasion of Time 41:35 The Mind of Evil + Terror of the Autons 47:42 The Keys of Marinus 53:24 Time-Flight 54:20 The King’s Demons + The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe 57:42 The Underwater Menace & The Stolen Earth/Journey's End 59:57 The Wheel in Space 1:06:07 The Sontaran Experiment 1:10:16 The Daleks 1:16:10 Time and the Rani (Best one) 1:20:31 The Silence Arc (ngl, I got really confused here) 1:23:48 Resurrection of the Daleks 1:31:45 Conclusion
I have a bit of a defense for Evil of The Daleks. A couple days ago, before this came out, I read the novelization for Evil of The Daleks by John Peel (via PDF). In the novel, there's references to the Great War (from Mission to The Unknown and The Daleks' Master Plan), and Evil marks the end of that conflict (according to the TARDIS wiki). So, is it possible that the Daleks wanted the Doctor to spread the Dalek factor through Earth's history so that they would be able to prevent the Great War from starting? I know it causes a bit of a paradox, given that the Great War is what caused the Daleks to want to do that, but It's the only explanation I have for that.
I don't think a retroactive change to the plot in a book written 20 years after the fact is a particularly good defence. It's fine for headcanon though.
its true that im not that hot on The Doctor's Daughter, but there are parts of it I really like. however what i FUCKING DESPISE, is when Jenny comes back to life. Way to completely undermine the climax of the story. and to add insult to injury she never even comes back on TV. It felt like something out of the Moffat era.
@@LordSlarr to be fair it is credited as written by Stephen Greenhorn, but i know that Russell had a big role in editing every story. So its fair to put some blame on him.
but that moment is just so pointless. And its a shame because having yet another opportunity for this Doctor to potentially settle down with a family and then having it snatched away was really fitting. Having that death sink in would've been the right move imo, having her resurrect was completely unnecessary, and you could honestly edit it out of the episode and it would be better for it.
I loved doing this, my lord gastropod
Cheers for coming on Mr Maddox. And extra double plus cheers for doing the intro which I idiotically forgot to shout you out for!
Timestamps
3:04 The Faceless Ones
16:30 Evil of the Daleks
32:30 The Invasion of Time
41:35 The Mind of Evil + Terror of the Autons
47:42 The Keys of Marinus
53:24 Time-Flight
54:20 The King’s Demons + The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe
57:42 The Underwater Menace & The Stolen Earth/Journey's End
59:57 The Wheel in Space
1:06:07 The Sontaran Experiment
1:10:16 The Daleks
1:16:10 Time and the Rani (Best one)
1:20:31 The Silence Arc (ngl, I got really confused here)
1:23:48 Resurrection of the Daleks
1:31:45 Conclusion
What a banger! The best plan is clearly the one from the Keys of Marinus!
Demons of the Punjab probably takes the cake...
I have a bit of a defense for Evil of The Daleks.
A couple days ago, before this came out, I read the novelization for Evil of The Daleks by John Peel (via PDF). In the novel, there's references to the Great War (from Mission to The Unknown and The Daleks' Master Plan), and Evil marks the end of that conflict (according to the TARDIS wiki). So, is it possible that the Daleks wanted the Doctor to spread the Dalek factor through Earth's history so that they would be able to prevent the Great War from starting? I know it causes a bit of a paradox, given that the Great War is what caused the Daleks to want to do that, but It's the only explanation I have for that.
I don't think a retroactive change to the plot in a book written 20 years after the fact is a particularly good defence. It's fine for headcanon though.
Attack of the Cybermen is a doozy.....!
its true that im not that hot on The Doctor's Daughter, but there are parts of it I really like.
however what i FUCKING DESPISE, is when Jenny comes back to life. Way to completely undermine the climax of the story. and to add insult to injury she never even comes back on TV. It felt like something out of the Moffat era.
It does man, very out of character for RTD who usually likes consequences. He did go a bit haywire on that front from series 4 onwards.
@@LordSlarr to be fair it is credited as written by Stephen Greenhorn, but i know that Russell had a big role in editing every story. So its fair to put some blame on him.
but that moment is just so pointless. And its a shame because having yet another opportunity for this Doctor to potentially settle down with a family and then having it snatched away was really fitting. Having that death sink in would've been the right move imo, having her resurrect was completely unnecessary, and you could honestly edit it out of the episode and it would be better for it.
Are you still here? You haven't uploaded anything in a while
Yh. Those plans are a bit shit, aren't they?
Hell yh
Evil of the daleks is a lower average story with a worse plan.
*Evil creates a convoluted plan that is then flipped because the writer wants to seem clever*
-
-
Who wrote that? Steven Moffat?
I don't think the intention of that was to make the writer feel clever. I just think he was unsure of how to develop the idea.
@@LordSlarr I was referencing the fact that, that was what you all said.